Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
NARRATOR (00:01):
This is Episode 250 of IDRA
Classnotes.
VIVEK (00:13):
You know, I'm amazed at the power
that people of color and advocates in
impacted communities always displayed at
the Capitol. But it often feels like
we're forced to be responsive to the
actions of policymakers or very much on
defense. And I think policymakers
themselves should be leaning into
communities of color and our experiences
and what we think of the ideas that
they're developing at the onset, and not
just, you know, in the middle of the
policy development stage or near the end
of the process, because, sometimes it
feels like they're checking off a box
rather than, really, truly incorporating
the opinions and input that we can
provide.
MIKAYLA (00:52):
Hello, and welcome to the
Classnotes podcast series featuring
reflections from our IDRA Education
Policy Fellows. My name is Mikayla
Arciaga, and I am the Georgia advocacy
director and education policy fellowship
coordinator at IDRA. I'm so excited to
host this series of four episodes. This
is episode two, highlighting our third
cohort of the Education Policy Fellows.
During this episode, you'll hear from
our fellows DeAndrea Byrd, Vivek Datla,
Kaci Wright, and Isabelle Philip. And
you can read about their bios and the
full breadth of their work in the link
shared in the podcast show notes. In
this episode, we’ll be inviting our
fellows to share their experiences,
advocates of color, fighting for
educational justice here in the South.
Let's go ahead and get started. First,
DeAndrea, we'll start with you. How has
your cultural and ethnic identity shaped
your advocacy experience? What benefits
and challenges did you recognize or
experience as an advocate of color in
the statewide policy advocacy space?
DEANDREA (01:51):
Well, this session, as a black
woman at the Capitol, I felt the weight
of both my identity and my purpose every
single day. I'm really from Atlanta. So,
my cultural and ethnic background it's
not something I carry; it's what I care
about. Like East Atlanta made me, but
DeKalb County raised me. I come from a
community that has been historically
silenced, overlooked, under-resourced,
but celebrated and duplicated in many
ways, culturally. So, when I show up in
spaces that are policy-filled, I'm not
just speaking for myself, I'm bringing
my grandmama's strength and my
children's future and my grandchildren's
future, and the voices of families who
don't always get to, you know, show up
and belong in these rooms. So, the truth
is, being a black woman at the Capitol
did have some real, um, challenges
because it was like microaggressions.
And sometimes, they happen so often that
I would like kind of ignore them or not
say anything. And when they happened to
somebody else, I didn't like to process
it right away. Even in the Treehouse
space that was meant for lobbyists,
sometimes, those microaggressions were
just like, "Okay, I'm going to deal with
it later." And I get home and overthink
it. It just started to feel like the air
there-- because you could kind of feel
like they may have been dismissive or
tolerating new faces, because they're
always there. It was important that I
saw that so that I can encourage other
people, like, "Hey, we got to show up in
these spaces, so it's not like you're
the outsider, or it's not like people
feel like that you don't belong." And I
also saw black women legislators at the
Capitol come up with really good bills,
research-backed bills, but they were
often dismissed, talked over, and
tolerated. And some of their bills were
thoughtful, research-backed, and
directly served the needs of their
community, but they were met with
resistance.
(03:36):
And they were women with degrees, livedexperience, professional expertise, who
had been there a while. Oh, they would
get interrupted. So that sent a clear
message, like even if they followed the
rules or spoke the language and did the
work, oftentimes, black women's voices
were considered optional. And I know a
lot of times it was said like, "Why do
you bring race into it?" But like by the
time somebody black brought race into
it, it was already in it, so that's why
we're speaking about it. So sometimes,
that was like, "Oh, okay." But also,
when you talk about black women
advocating for black children in the
system that was never built for them
anyway, it's like not optional. So,
you've got to be there anyway. Like it
or they're going to say, "Well, nobody
showed up. This is what they wanted."
And that's with any other ethnic
background. If you don't show up,
they'll say you wanted it, sign your
name, and then you just must deal with
it. So, I still see my identity as my
superpower. Being rooted in my culture
keeps me grounded. It makes me remember
where I come from and why I do this.
Even when I feel like I want to take a
break, I'm like, "No, you got to get
back out there, girl." It also allows me
to translate policy into something
that's like real and urgent, and tell
them like, "You need to be more involved
in just voting. Like, policy is really
what you're mad at. You're mad at the
principal. Or you're mad at the teacher.
Or you're mad at the disciplinary rate.
But if we don't change this policy, it's
only going to get worse." I also learned
that we can't wait for seats at the
table. Go where you think you don't
belong. Go where you've never been
before. As advocates of color, we must
build our own tables but also bring
people together and bridge those tables.
And work together with others. Change
the conversation. And it just let me
know that I must continue to challenge
myself and to continue to take up space.
MIKAYLA (05:20):
Awesome. Yeah. I think I told
you all when you first started, we
operate kind of via a closed-mouth
system. If you don't take what you need
and say what you need, we don't always
know. Vivek, I'd love to hear your
thoughts on this question. You had an
interesting experience too.
VIVEK (05:35):
Yeah. You know, I'll be honest, I
think it can be mentally and emotionally
challenging, daunting, and draining at
times to operate and be in a
policymaking space when you know that so
many of the bills that are being
proposed and are being discussed will,
very seriously and very negatively, harm
people of color. It's especially, I
think, frustrating to operate in that
space when, again, diversity, equity,
and inclusion initiatives are twisted
and reframed and attacked as somehow
these discriminatory policies and
initiatives, when the very purpose of
them is to make spaces more open to
people of color and communities of
color. I recall a lot of conversations
in legislative offices where I tried to
lean into my lived experience as a
person of color and received dismissive
or very uninterested responses in
return. There was a certain glazed look
in the eyes of some of the staff members
that we talked about when we would try
to bring up our experiences. And I
recall being in office and attempting to
advocate in favor of an ethnic studies
bill that would have allowed students to
count an African-American studies
course, for example, as a social studies
credit and not an elective credit, and
being told by a, a legislative staff
member that they were concerned that the
bill would be considered diversity,
equity, and inclusion, and therefore the
representative could not or likely would
not support it for that reason. And so
Those kinds of experiences are hard when
you feel, like no matter how many times
you or other individuals of color try
and offer up perspectives and
experiences, that countless people in
the building simply don't care or who
will continue to move in the direction
that they've chosen to move in despite
the heartfelt and, you know, emotional
concerns that are shared for how their
decisions might hurt us or our
communities.
(07:27):
On the flip side, I think the benefit ofbeing an advocate of color is that you
know that you're bringing a strong and
unique perspective to so many policy
discussions because so many of the
proposals directly affect our
communities in a profound and often
disproportionate way. And so, our
cultural and racial identities are
things to tap into always. And I think
DeAndrea said it best, they're a
strength, they're a superpower, and
they're a source of knowledge for us as
well.
MIKAYLA (07:55):
Yeah. Thank you so much for
that. Kaci, you, me, and Vivek all share
experience as educators. And I know that
was a big point of reflection for you on
some of the challenges that you
experienced, as well as your identity.
We'd love to hear what you experienced
in this.
KACI (08:10):
Yeah. Thank you for asking. I will
say coming into the Capitol as a young
woman of color came with those very
intersecting identities that came with
their own challenges throughout the
session that taught me who this space is
really made for and who it's not made
for. And I remember, just the first day,
walking in the building and looking
around and expecting there to be a
representation of our state. And that
was not seen in the people who were
working there in many ways. But it also
allowed the opportunity whenever I saw
other women of color, we just kind of
naturally, organically support each
other. And it was nice to have the
support system between the advocates
there that kind of knew the stakes that
were at risk whenever we're fighting
against these bad bills and fighting for
good bills. Especially coming from not
only these deeply personal issues, not
just to me and my community, but to the
students I taught. I mostly taught
students of color. And so, I think there
was something powerful testifying and
going to offices, being able to say, you
know, "I know how this affects me. I
know how this affects the students I
taught." And I'm not just saying that
because of my experience, which is
valuable, but I'm saying this because
research and data also back this up. You
know, "This policy's harmful for black
students, and I can show you the numbers
that support that." I think that it was
powerful coming from someone like me and
being strong in my stance on that, and
being able to say, "I've seen this, and
we know it's happening." So, there's
kind of really no denial of it. Like
DeAndrea said, the race is just
naturally a part of a lot of these
systems that are put in place, that have
been put in place for years, centuries.
And so, I love to keep that dialogue and
keep that conversation happening at the
Capitol. And I think exactly what
everybody else said, you know, now
coming in, I feel like I had a little
bit of imposter syndrome questioning,
you know, my worth in this space. And
that completely just switched around
quickly when I really realized I do have
value in my experience and what I've
seen," and to take power in that and to
own that and to have that motivate my
passion moving forward.
MIKAYLA (10:07):
Thank you. Isabelle, certainly
not least, but if you would share last,
I'm interested in what you felt were
challenges or benefits from your
experiences in this.
ISABELLE (10:20):
Yeah. I mean, it can be very
frustrating to have to argue about an
issue that's so personal, or discuss an
issue that's so personal, with people
who just couldn't possibly relate to it
because they don't have the lived
experience, so. And I've seen that to be
true for me. I've seen that to be true
for the students that I've worked with
and colleagues. It can all sometimes be
very overwhelming because how are you
not supposed to get emotional, even if
you keep it deep down? And then the
person across from you can stay calm,
cool, and collected because it really is
just policy to them. And somehow that
makes you seem like the person who
shouldn't be taken seriously. So, I
think that's something that I've seen
and experienced a lot. But I've also
seen, from the legislators to even some
of the lobbyists, that I was always
shocked because I would learn, like,
"Oh, this person is related to this
person who's done this before." Like,
there are just so many familial ties
that I didn't expect, which is just much
harder to come by when you aren't white
or you're an immigrant. So, I think you
just see it so clearly. There's a lot
of-- a lot of nepotism going on, which
is just another reason that we must, you
know, do programs like this, get our
communities involved. And that's where,
I think, the superpower part comes in,
that y'all are talking about, because
now we've grown so much and we are so
passionate, in part due to our
experiences, and we know best how to
communicate with our communities and to
bring them in. So, it also presents
itself as a great opportunity to
advocate for us.
MIKAYLA (12:13):
Yeah. Absolutely. Um, and
staying with you, Isabelle, I'd love to
hear how you would like to see this
landscape change. What does that look
like as far as it relates to the
influence of communities of color? I
think you've hinted at it. I mean, what
keeps people like us out of the process?
What would you like to see change?
ISABELLE (12:30):
This one's a little hard for
me because I really have such distrust
of politicians and, you know, the
legislative process, which made this
whole fellowship an eye-opening
experience for me because we can only
control so much. Right? So, I want to
see more communication between the
progressive legislative space and
directly trying to bring people in. Like
this program is one of the only ones
that I know of in Georgia. And I think
that it should be a part of every
advocate's - or every progressive
lobbyist or whatever you all call
yourselves - job to bring more people
in. Because you can develop all the
relationships you want, but if you're
not bringing in the rest of us, then
that work stops with you. And when you
go, then what's left for everyone who
comes after you? The policies you push
for will only be there for so long, and
then someone will change them back. So,
we need a consistent push. And that
means bringing everyone to the table and
having that be the focus of the work.
MIKAYLA (13:39):
Absolutely. We felt very
strongly about the pipeline. Kaci, what
about you? What would you like to see
change to make our policy landscape have
more influence from communities of color
and directly impacted folks?
KACI (13:51):
Yeah. So much. I always go back to
where it starts is really
representation. And you need to have
people at the table who've experienced
diverse things to make policy for such a
diverse state. And I think that's where
Texas and a lot of other states in the
South are lacking. And walking in it
every day, you could just see it right
in front of your eyes. And that goes
from the politicians at the top to the
people that are coming in to testify.
And I would love to just see diversity
among all those different spaces. And
that really comes to opening that door
and allowing opportunities for those
people to come in these spaces, like
this fellowship that allows people to
have the chance to learn from somebody
and to be in the building every single
day and to gain confidence. That's going
to have me go out and tell people I
know, "Hey, come and do this." I mean,
it really takes that community uplifting
and empowering others to play a part in
the whole policymaking process. And just
those small little changes, I think it's
going to affect the long term. And, I
would love to see just acknowledgement
that, you know, communities of colors,
their input is still valuable today. I
think there's a lot of narrative that we
can shift away from making decisions
based on race. And I don't think we're
at a point in society where we can make
those decisions. And so just an
acknowledgement from people that, "Hey,
we need to look at these things. We need
to look at how this affects different
communities and prioritize that in the
policymaking process."
MIKAYLA (15:13):
Absolutely. And, Vivek, what
about you? What thoughts do you have?
I'm sure you have several.
VIVEK (15:16):
I want to echo what Kaci already
said so well. I think that, in an ideal
world, for me, communities of color
would have influence on policy language
before it emerges in the form of a build
text. You know, I'm amazed at the power
that people of color and advocates in
impacted communities always displayed at
the Capitol. But it often feels like
we're forced to be responsive to the
actions of policymakers or very much on
defense. And I think policymakers
themselves should be leaning into
communities of color and our experiences
and what we think of the ideas that
they're developing at the onset, and not
just, you know, in the middle of the
policy development stage or near the end
of the process, because sometimes it
feels like they're checking off a box
rather than truly incorporating the
opinions and input that we can provide
to the table. And I think one way we can
change that is by continuing to build
our strength in numbers, like as a
program like this fellowship is meant to
do and, I think, does very well. Because
the more people we have in this space,
the more amplified our voices are and
the more welcoming those spaces become
to people from diverse backgrounds.
MIKAYLA (16:25):
Absolutely. I'm so glad you
said that. DeAndrea, what about you?
DEANDREA (16:29):
I just want to echo from
everything Isabelle, Kaci, and Vivek
said. I feel programs like these are
super important because this was the
bridge way of bringing people that
aren't normally in these spaces into
these spaces. And it's a ripple effect.
Once you bring those that are in here,
we can take it back, tell more people
about the program, or just basically
share what we learned. I would like to
see a truly equitable space where all
parties are included instead of pitting
parties against each other. Like
parents, teachers, students, community
members, and lawmakers should literally
be working together from the start, not
just when it gets complicated or it hits
the fan. And it shouldn't be so
transactional coming to the community
when you need us for something, but like
leading with that. And what keeps
regular people like us out is like lack
of access, complicated language, the
feeling that these spaces, like Isabelle
said, aren't built for us. People don't
show up when they feel ignored. If you
don't know somebody, you don't like
them, and you don't trust them, a lot of
times you throw your hands up, and
you're like, "Well, I just don't want to
deal with it." Politicians need to meet
communities where they are, use plain
language, and create real invitations
for them to lead, not performative.
MIKAYLA (17:41):
Thank you, guys, so much for
that. I think we've talked about some of
the challenges quite a bit and what
we've focused on. And we're going to
talk about the future of your work and
what you guys have planned for the
future. But for this question, I mostly
just want to talk about sustainability
and what you did or what tips you have
for keeping this work going. How did you
make this sustainable for yourself? How
did you protect your peace or manage the
emotional burden that comes with this
that all of you have talked about? I'd
love that to just be kind of like our
wrapping thought. What is it that you do
to make this work continue? DeAndrea, if
it's okay, I'd like to start with you.
DEANDREA (18:16):
What I would like to do to
make this work continue, number one,
continue to learn, keep showing up now
that I know how to show up in the
correct way. Doing legislative season,
how to track bills correctly, who's
responsible for what, that's information
I can go back and share with the people,
places, and community organizations that
I'm connected to. I really want to
create a PDF or maybe like an eBook for
parents that just want to get started on
understanding policy, how it works, that
they could just go to, download, where
they don't need me for it, or they don't
need the next person. Just in plain
English, just an advocacy toolkit. Like,
"This is where you look for this," maybe
like a resource. And I want to continue
to teach community classes, like policy,
continue to teach them on IEPs, 504s,
and just about how the school system
works, student discipline works. So just
continue. And what keeps me going is
knowing that real lives are on the line.
Like I do this because I've lived it as
a parent, I've lived it as a child of an
educator, and I see the impact of policy
every day, not just in theory, but in
schools, in homes. And I lean on other
advocates. I lean on people like
Mikayla. I lean on people like Isabelle.
I lean on other organizations, so we
just need to be able to lean on each
other to continue to do the work. In
every policy term and process, we got to
continue to show up until it's changed
and continue to be disruptive until the
change comes.
MIKAYLA (19:42):
Kaci, what about you? How did
you maintain this work? What tips might
you have for somebody else who might
feel that anxiety coming into your--?
KACI (19:51):
Yeah. That's a good question. And
this work can be extremely frustrating
and draining at times. And there were
moments throughout session where I
experienced burnout. And I think
something I learned early on, and our
team really learned early on, is that
you really can't do it all. Especially
in education, there are just so many
issues that, you know, I wanted to go
testify on so many bills and, you know,
talk to offices about so many different
positions that we had on different ones,
but it really came down to prioritizing
what we wanted to work on and kind of
just going in on it and, making that the
priority in session. So, I just think
it's important to focus and, and narrow
down the scope of the work that you want
to do is important. And then really
leaning on the people around you to lift
you up when things are hard. We had an
amazing team that were always there to
lift us up and support us. When we
couldn't do something, there was always
somebody next to you that was willing to
support you. So having a support system
around you is extremely important. And
then just whenever things get hard, go
back to your why, go back to your
motivation. Whenever I was tired at the
Capitol at 2:00 AM in the morning and I
wanted to go home, I thought about the
students that I taught and how this
would affect them. And that just kind of
kept me on the prize and, you know, on
the goal at hand.
MIKAYLA (21:00):
Isabelle, how about you?
ISABELLE (21:02):
During session, what kept me
going was mostly the students that we
got to take to the Capitol. We ran a
program in Georgia to support students
in advocating for public education at
the Capitol by speaking with their
legislators, giving testimony, reading
bills. They would spend a whole day with
us to learn more about the process. And
it just kind of plays into what I was
talking about earlier with passing on
knowledge and making sure that there are
other people who have access to and are
equipped to keep the work going. Because
another thing that has helped me a lot,
that I finally realized, is that this is
such a long-term battle. Every fight is
very important, and it feels very
intense. But if you fully feel that
every single moment of the day, during
session and afterwards, it's very hard
to be effective, um, and it's very hard
to keep your mind straight. So just like
thinking to yourself and knowing that,
"Okay, we lost this one, but there's so
much more to do, and there's such a long
fight ahead," is really, really valuable
to think about. And, knowing that this
isn't the only avenue for change. Policy
is one way, but there's people out there
who are organizing, there's people out
there who are working within the
communities outside of the system. So
just knowing that there's so many people
out there that are on your side, even if
it feels very lonely at the Capitol.
MIKAYLA (22:37):
Vivek, certainly not the least,
but if you'll wrap us up.
VIVEK (22:42):
So, the work is emotionally
draining, especially in environments
like Texas and Georgia, where the
victories can be few and far between,
and the losses tend to feel like they
kind of stack up on top of one another.
And, you know, I've worked, very
emotionally tough jobs before, but this
one is a different kind of emotionally
tough. Just knowing that it's,
oftentimes, it feels like it's not just
your voice that maybe isn't being heard,
but it's the voice of so many
individuals from impacted communities
that aren't being heard. And that's very
tough. But I think what sustained my
work was just kind of inspiration and
comfort that I took from being in
community with other people from IDRA,
and also just other advocates from
partner organizations that we worked
closely with on issues. And knowing that
the person next to me was, was fighting
until the last possible moments,
sometimes at 4:00 in the morning, or
whatever odd hour of the night, to
achieve any small victory for
communities, it made me want to keep up
with them. So, I think there are a lot
of inspiring and extremely hardworking
advocates and community members that
work tirelessly throughout each
legislative session to support good
policies and push back against the bad.
And you can feel their presence in a
very meaningful way. And that's what
kept me going.
MIKAYLA (23:52):
Thank you so much. And thank
you to anyone who's here listening. We
hope you'll join us for the other
episodes of our series. If you haven't
gone back to listening to episode one, I
highly recommend it. And join us for our
episodes three and four, which provide
an overview of the fellowship and our
hopes for the future.
NARRATOR (24:11):
Thank you for listening to
IDRA Classnotes. For more information on
IDRA and other Classnotes topics, go to
www.idra.org. You can also send us your
thoughts by email to podcast@idra.org.