EXPOSED: Rivals Caught RED-HANDED Downgrading Big 12 Commits | BYU's FIVE-STAR QB the Latest Victim?

A storm is brewing in the college football recruiting world, with scouting website Rivals.com facing significant backlash over what many perceive as a blatant act of "duplicity" in their latest prospect rankings. This podcast dives into the controversial plummet of five-star quarterback Ryder Lyons after his commitment to BYU, juxtaposed with the curious rise of an Oregon commit, and explores the wider implications of alleged bias against Big 12 schools.

The core of the controversy centers on Ryder Lyons, who was widely considered a consensus five-star prospect and a top-tier quarterback in the 2026 class. However, immediately following his high-profile commitment to the BYU Cougars over the Oregon Ducks, Lyons' ranking on Rivals reportedly plummeted, dropping him from five-star status and significantly down the overall national list. This sudden downgrade, occurring without any on-field performance to justify it, has ignited outrage among BYU fans and recruiting analysts alike.

Adding fuel to the fire is the simultaneous, seemingly inexplicable, surge of Oregon commit Bryson Beaver. Until recently, Beaver was a three-star prospect, unranked in the Top 100. Yet, after committing to the Ducks, he reportedly vaulted ahead of Lyons in the Rivals rankings, gaining a fourth star. This stark contrast in trajectory, directly tied to their respective commitments, has led to accusations of bias and a lack of transparency from the scouting service.

This episode will dissect the alleged "duplicity" at play. Is this a calculated move to influence recruiting narratives, or a genuine (albeit poorly timed) re-evaluation? We'll discuss the implications of such actions on the credibility of recruiting services and the fairness of the recruiting process. If rankings are perceived as being swayed by conference affiliation or institutional preference rather than pure talent evaluation, it undermines the entire system.

For BYU and other Big 12 schools, this alleged bias is a significant concern. If prospects are being downgraded simply for choosing a Big 12 program over a traditional "blue blood" or a perceived "bigger" conference, it creates an uneven playing field. We'll explore how this could impact recruiting efforts for programs like BYU, who are actively building top-25 classes and competing for elite talent.

Join us as we unravel the Rivals' ranking riddle, discuss the perceived bias against Big 12 commits, and examine the far-reaching implications of this alleged duplicity for the future of college football recruiting.

The college football world is buzzing with controversy as Big 12 commits experience a sudden drop in recruiting rankings. This unexpected shift has sparked debates about potential conference bias and its influence on the sport's future. Drake Toll and Jake Hatch, seasoned analysts, dive deep into this recruiting scandal, examining its far-reaching implications for BYU COUGARS and the entire Big 12 conference.

SEC Media Days: Unveiling Conference Tensions

The podcast explores the recent SEC media days, uncovering simmering tensions between conferences. Toll and Hatch dissect the changing dynamics of college football, offering listeners insider perspectives on the evolving landscape. Their analysis sheds light on the power struggles and shifting alliances that are reshaping the sport.

BYU and Provo: Challenging Misconceptions

Drake Toll's recent visit to Provo, Utah, serves as a focal point for challenging common misconceptions about BYU's home. Listeners are treated to an eye-opening account of the city's vibrant culture and the unique atmosphere surrounding BYU football. This segment offers valuable insights for fans and recruits alike, painting a vivid picture of what makes Provo and BYU special.

Utah Valley: An Adventure Destination

Contrary to popular belief, Utah Valley emerges as an unexpected adventure hub. From trout fishing in pristine mountain streams to heart-pounding zip lining experiences, the podcast reveals the diverse range of activities available in the region. This exploration of Utah Valley's hidden gems adds depth to the discussion about BYU's appeal to recruits and fans.

Big 12: The Next College Football Powerhouse?

Toll and Hatch present a compelling case for why the Big 12 might be poised to become the next powerhouse in college football. They analyze the conference's strengths, recent developments, and potential for growth, offering listeners a fresh perspective on the changing hierarchy of college football conferences.

BYU's Unique Gameday Atmosphere

The podcast delves into what sets BYU's gameday experience apart from other programs. From traditions to fan engagement, listeners gain insight into the electric atmosphere that makes BYU football games a must-see event. This discussion highlights the intangible factors that contribute to a program's appeal beyond just rankings and statis