Third Parties: Spoilers or a Real Shot?

Is a third party a real alternative, or just the reason your least favorite candidate wins? In this episode of We Vote Too, we unpack the structural roadblocks, cultural skepticism, and political urgency surrounding third-party politics in the U.S.

Host Leise Winny sits down with political organizer Muhammad to discuss exploring third parties, exploring their historical role, whether third parties are viable, what role they’ve historically played in elections, and how they might better serve marginalized voters than the two-party system. Can a third party work—or is the system too rigged for real choice?

From the spoiler effect to single-issue voter traps, and from ballot access to the 2024 stakes, we’re asking: What would it take to build a third party that wins?

Because We the People? We Vote Too.

• 00:00 – Disclosure

• 00:32 – Intro music

• 00:33 – Can a third party work? Breakdown begins

• 03:48 – Interview with Farajii Muhammad

• 04:44 – Can a third party work in this system?

• 07:38 – Did third parties ruin past elections?

• 10:29 – The spoiler effect: myth or math?

• 13:36 – Should there be a third party for minorities?

• 19:55 – How to fix the single-issue voter problem in third parties

• 24:30 – Should we pause third-party pushes until Trump is out of office?

• 31:04 – What we should be doing to create third-party options

• 35:36 – Could a third-party candidate beat someone like Gavin Newsom?

• 39:57 – Will Democrats go too far left in 2024?

• 43:34 – How perfectionism hurts progressive movements

• 49:36 – Vote for who you want to vote for

• 52:54 – Outro