Preacher Vs Preacher: A Comparison Companion

Preacher Vs Preacher: A Comparison Companion

Preacher Vs Preacher: A Comparison Companion is a podcast that not only recaps episodes of AMC's series Preacher, but also compares it directly to it's source material, the 1990's comic book series of the same name written by Garth Ennis and Steve Dillon published by Vertigo Comics.


June 7, 2020 50 mins

his week on the DC TV Report: The Legends of Tomorrow finale brings the usual madness, and Ed and Sara go deep on the Batwoman casting announcement, the history of the Thong Song, and Luke and Owen Wilson as dogs. Spoilers ahead, so jump over the ones you don’t wanna know about.

Episode recaps

Stargirl 6:05

DC’s Legends of Tomorrow 20:51

News updates

Batwoman 38:28

Green Lantern 42:13

As always, Ed and Sara close with the winner of...

Mark as Played

THIS IS THE END! The final episode! Our guest is Agent Palmer from The Palmer Files podcast! He's her to help us break down the episode recap and compare this finale to the comics! Jessie fights Saint Of Killers and makes a deal book readers saw coming, Tulip fights Cassidy and thinks he's funny, Jesus fights Hitler and breaks lots of furniture, Herr Starr fights a Fax machine and plays golf, Featherstone stops fighting and God get...

Mark as Played
September 23, 2019 71 mins

Steph Muniz is back! She joins Bill to recap and compare another episode or PREACHER to the comics! This time: God gets in everybody's way! Jesse calls out for help! Tulip gets antagonized! Cassidy pulls a double-cross! Jesus and Hitler wrestle! Herr Starr and Featherstone finally get busy! And Arseface hits the road! plus we try to guess the ending that's coming!

Mark as Played
September 16, 2019 50 mins

Ed from The DC TV Report returns to aid Bill in recapping Preacher season 4 episode 8 "Fear OF God" and compare it to the comic book! Jessie sees God! Tulip, Cassidy and Humperdoo form a family! Herr Starr met some new friends! Stuff from the book happens! We try to guess how they'll wrap it up!

Mark as Played
September 9, 2019 61 mins

Sara Netzly from The DC TV Report joins us this week to recap and compare Preacher season 4 episode 7 "Messiahs" to the comics! Jesse gets an offer he tries to refuse! Tulip and Cass hit the road with a plan to block God's plan! Humperdoo comes out of hiding! Herr Starr looses a valuable asset! And the Dog suit gets an origin? PLUS: We speculate where the show will go next! What stuff from the book can they still squeeze in before ...

Mark as Played
September 2, 2019 54 mins

This week Ed is back as we recap and compare this episode to the comics! Jesse and The Saint have a walk and talk, Tulip and Cassidy tun into 70's cops, Starr gets giddy, Arseface is locked up, Jesus and Hitler have a sit down, and God's plan comes to fruition! PLUS we try to guess how the show will wrap up!

Follow the show on Twitter @PreachVsPreach

Mark as Played
August 26, 2019 71 mins

This week Agent Palmer is the guest as Jesse Custer finally crosses paths with Arseface and The Saint Of Killers! Cassidy hangs out in a bar! Tulip and Jesus hit the road! Herr Starr might just pull off this big meeting! And Hitler gets a beating!

Follow us on Twitter: @AgentPalmer @PreachVsPreach and Bill @WickedTheory


Mark as Played
August 19, 2019 61 mins

This week Ed O'Hare is back! Jessie is lost at sea! Cassidy is still in Masada! Tulip is still trying to get him out! Herr Starr is dealing with a real big summit! Plus Jesus arrives! And Hitler too! Big question: What Is Jesus' Power Set?

Some links:
Find Ed on The DC TV Report:


Mark as Played
August 13, 2019 96 mins

Howdy Pilgrims, this time Bill is joined this time by Steph Muniz you should know her from The Gotham Lights podcast, which became The Orville Lights Podcast and she’s also on Moving The Needle podcast and has a blog at! They’re Covering PREACHER season 4 episode 3 “Deviant”! Besides the recap they also get into what is “morality” on a show filled with deviants like Je...

Mark as Played
August 5, 2019 85 mins

We're back for season 4! Bill is joined by Ed O'Hare from The DC TV Report to breakdown two episodes of PREACHER! "Masada" and " Last Supper"! Yes, two episodes in one, because that's how they aired! Jessie, Tulip and Cassidy are up to their usual madness, only this time we are heading for the end of this crazy road trip! We try to spot the changes from book to show, what did we miss? Let us know!

Mark as Played

THE END IS HERE! Well, of this season. But hey, look who came from The DCTV Report podcast - it's Sara Netzley! (And a dash of Ed too.) We all get together and breakdown the Preacher season 3 finale "The Light Above", and compare it to the books! How is it different! What are the changes? Who lives - who dies? What will happen to our heroes, Jesse, Tulip and Cassidy? Plus we give thoughts on the season overall and look to the futur...

Mark as Played

Bill and Dom recap and compare Preacher season 3 episode 4 "Schwanzkopf" to the books! Tulip, Arseface and Hitler are heading for hell! Cassidy is headed towards the light! Jesse is headed for Granma! How much of this is actually from the book?? Listen to find out!

Follow the show on Twitter: @PreachVsPreach

Follow your hosts: Dom @Dom_Torre Bill @WickedTheory

Mark as Played
August 14, 2018 63 mins

Howdy Pilgrims! Bill and Dom are here again! This time, they're recapping Preacher season 3 episode 8 "The Tom/Brady" and comparing it to the comics! What does that title mean? How many Humperdoo's is too many? How come cassidy can't fly? What phone company does grandma use? We answer none of those questions.

Follow the show on Twitter: @PreachVsPreach

Follow yo...

Mark as Played
August 7, 2018 64 mins

Bill and Dom are here again to recap and compare episode 7 of season 3 of AMC's Preacher to the graphic novels! Hitler makes sandwiches, Tulip wears Grail colors, TC hears Genesis, Jessie makes a deal, Herr Starr wears a beanie, Cassidy takes bromance to the next level, and Grandma gets her nails done.

Follow the show on Twitter: @PreachVsPreach

Follow your host...

Mark as Played

This week Bill and Dom recap and compare episode 6 of Preacher season 3 to the comics! This one's got a lot of Cassidy stuff that in the books was flashback, but here it's present day! Plus, Jessie and Tulip pull a soul heist to save Evil Old Grandma, and TC goes to the petting zoo! Awwwww.

Follow the show on Twitter: @PreachVsPreach

Follow your hosts: Dom @Dom_...

Mark as Played

This PVP episode might have the most rings of the "book bell" so far because episode 5 of season 3 of PREACHER has a LOT taken directly from the books! The Duke! The Coffin! All Father! Goofy hats! Even Billy-Bob! Good thing Bill and Dom are here to break it all down for you!

Mark as Played

We're back recapping Preacher season 3 episode 4, The Tombs and comparing it to the book! Jessie puts on an act, Tulip gets the scoop, and Cassidy catches the bus? How much of this episode is from the book? Where do we think this season is going? Listen to find out!

Follow the show on Twitter: @PreachVsPreach

Follow your hosts: Dom @Dom_Torre Bill @WickedTheory<...

Mark as Played

The infamous Agent Palmer is the guest this week as he and Bill recap and compare episode 3 of Preacher season 3 to the comic book source material! Jessie and Cassidy are on-again/off-again BFF's, Tulip has another chat with god-dog, Grandma reopens the Tombs, Jody & TC figure out Cassidy's secret, and some of that was actually in the books!

Thanks to @AgentPalmer for going us!

Read more

Mark as Played

We recap Preacher episode 2 "Sonsabitches" and compare and contrast it directly to the books - well, as much as we can. As we do that, we also theorize on where the show is going in season three and beyond, including the shifting dynamic between Jesse, Tulip and Cassidy. We breakdown the changes as we see them, tell us what you think in an email! Or tell us about Your Crazy Grandma Stories!

Mark as Played
June 26, 2018 82 mins

PREACHER is back and so is PVP! And boy have things changed on this podcast for season 3! Is it a reboot? New music, new graphic, new approach. Wait, what!? Well, yeah, kinda, but not really. You'll see. Anywaaay, all you book readers should be happy as Jessie, Tulip and Cassidy finally meet up with Jody, T.C. and Grandma and things get spicy while setting up the season ahead! We give our thoughts on how it compares to the books! I...

Mark as Played

Popular Podcasts

    Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations.

    Crime Junkie

    If you can never get enough true crime... Congratulations, you’ve found your people.

    Around the NFL's "Around the NFL" crew (Gregg Rosenthal, Dan Hanzus and Marc Sessler) break down the latest football news, with a dash of mirth.

    Stuff You Should Know

    If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.

    The Bobby Bones Show

    Listen to 'The Bobby Bones Show' by downloading the daily full replay.

Advertise With Us

For You

    Music, radio and podcasts, all free. Listen online or download the iHeart App.


    © 2023 iHeartMedia, Inc.