Which Murderer?

Which Murderer?

Which Murderer talks about the methods, motives and background to murderers and their victims, covering two crimes per episode and debating from the victim's perspective which murderer we would pick to kill us if we HAD to choose. Hosted by Holly (the Canadian) and Gemma (the Scot) from Edinburgh, Scotland. Instagram (https://www.instagram.com/whichmurderer/) Twitter (https://twitter.com/whichmurderer) Explicit content and subject matter.

Episodes

September 24, 2021 39 min
In Season 4 Episode 16 the girls talk about Melanies and Murder – our particular Melanie is excluded from this of course (for now). Mel kicks things off with the story of Melanie McGuire before Holly tells you the sad story of Melanie Ann Road.

Shoutout for Superfan Carrie and thanks so much for your amazing suggestions….keep 'em coming!

Mel contracts the Corona, Holly gives an update on the Murder Flat, Mel’s Melanie is a smart...
Share
Mark as Played
In Season 4 Episode 15 the girls talk about Murders that happened in Courtrooms – aka Courthouse Murders. Holly kicks it off with Tahir Naseem and Mel follows with Brian Nichols who we are not a fan of.

There is a very informative cereal knowledge session which includes singing, Holly finally writes down her sources, Mel is very encouraging of some crimes possibly, the girls are finally aware of how much they are talking and stick ...
Share
Mark as Played
September 10, 2021 35 min
In Season 4 Episode 14 the girls talk about Murderers Who Were Inspired by Music. Mel kicks it off with the Columbine High School Shooting before Holly covers the story of Jared Lee Loughner.

Mel tea shames Holly but also doesn’t know what year it is so maybe don’t listen to her too much, we find out that Holly doesn’t make her own tea ever, a recap of girls night reveals a severe difference in musical tastes, Mel tries hard to get ...
Share
Mark as Played
September 3, 2021 41 min
In Season 4 Episode 13 the girls cover a suggested topic from Season 1-3 Co-host Gemma – Incels Who Murder. AKA Involuntary Celibates. Holly starts things off with the poster boy for this group who was responsible for the 2014 Isla Vista murders before Mel chats through the case of Alek Minassian.

Shout-out to Carrie for her lovely comments about Mel who is doing much better at checking Facebook occasionally.

The girls are up agai...
Share
Mark as Played
August 27, 2021 40 min
In Season 4 Episode 12 the girls cover Olympic Murders with Mel starting things off with the Dave Shultz tragedy before Holly covers the Munich Massacre.

Shout-outs to lovely bestie Loulou and our Gemma. Also high fives to Melinda for suggesting this weeks theme.

Holly is all over the place with food and time, Mel tries to get the listeners arrested and fired, evil geese fight for their lives, Holly has an unreasonable dislike for ...
Share
Mark as Played
August 20, 2021 32 min
In Season 4 Episode 11 the girls cover tales of Murder and Revenge! Mels starts us off with the story of Connie Serbu before Holly tells the sad tale of the Ding family.

Things start off terribly with Holly drinking while recording, Mel is outed as a drink sniffer, Holly has a police connection and a burning body story, the girls have an actual fight over funding each other going on the run and we all learn what sport will kill you...
Share
Mark as Played
August 13, 2021 38 min
In Season 4 Episode 10 the girls talk about Clowns and Circus Murders…which are extra terrible because CLOWNS. Mel starts off with a true crime Goliath…..John Wayne Gacy before Holly leaves you with the slightly less horrific but still murdery tale of Eva Clark.

Shoutouts to Melinda (who superfanned a theme suggestion our way – which we are absolutely using) and Lindy who revealed there is a Which Murderer team member on Love Island...
Share
Mark as Played
August 6, 2021 31 min
In Season 4 Episode 9 the girls tackle the horrific topic of Genocide. While we figure if you are listening to a murder podcast you are pretty Teflon, we do include a bit of warning with this one due to the brutal level of violence spoken about. Holly kicks it off with the Killing Fields of Cambodia before Mel talks about the Armenian Genocide.

The girls discuss the Dead Body Window and Holly’s DNA, farming is hard, the Kardashians...
Share
Mark as Played
July 30, 2021 29 min
In Season 4 Episode 8 the girls talk about Athletes Who Murder. Mel starts off with Robert Rozier who was the Mr. Bean of Murder before Holly tells you about Mark Anthony with a truly tragic nickname.

Holly is hungry and leaking, Mel loves the sports theme but regrets it when she has to actually communicate with Holly about the sports, the girls judge cults pretty harshly, fences are the natural enemies of footballers and the girls...
Share
Mark as Played
July 23, 2021 34 min
In Season 4 Episode 7 the girls talk about Arsonists Who Commit Murder. Holly kicks things off with the very first namey Bruce George Peter Lee before Mel tells you all about John Leonard Orr.


Shoutouts for Facebook fans Sarah and Mel’s new friend Dave. You are both now legally required to suggest topics.


Mel’s singing talents are showcased, bouncy castles are a very important topic requiring actual research, Holly almost dies befor...
Share
Mark as Played
July 16, 2021 37 min
In Season 4 Episode 6 the girls talk about Fast Food Murders. Mel covers the story of Evan Ebel before Holly tells you how badly wrong Paul Dennis Reid turned out.

Holly died 5 times from the heat during this episode, Mel tip-toes around the topic of football, there is some confusion about whether some people can play golf after death, Holly makes up facts yet again and the brain has been renamed as ‘doodads in the front of your he...
Share
Mark as Played
In Season 4 Episode 5 the girls talk about Con Artists Who Murder. Holly kicks it off with the case of Carol Waugh before Mel tells you about Sante and Kenny, a super healthy mother and son duo.

Shoutouts to Mark on Facebook, Superfan Caitriona (whose last name we will never say out loud), Dave on Insta and Cara who Holly annoyed with her sweeping incorrect generalisations – sorry Cara! And the country of South Africa. And the conti...
Share
Mark as Played
In Season 4 Episode 4 the girls talk about Lawyers Who Were Murdered. Mel kicks it off with the case of Sarah H. Quirt Sann before Holly tells you about Rashid Rehman in Pakistan.

Holly is stripping off in the corner of Mel’s recording loft, Mel is the only one who actually remembers to tell you who they are, gun laws are once again questioned in America, Holly’s voice is sad but she is not, there is a big debate at the end and Mel ...
Share
Mark as Played
June 25, 2021 36 min
In Season 4 Episode 3 the girls tell you all about Abductors Who Murder. Holly teaches you about Donald ‘Nappey’ Neilson who was not a fan of diapers or postal workers before Mel covers Anni Dewani’s murder right after Holly awkwardly snickers at the name.

Shoutouts to Facebook Sarah (are you still listening?) and a weird one to the wonderful Gemma and Consulting Producer Craig.

We find out Holly is finally back to work and sad tha...
Share
Mark as Played
In Season 4 Episode 2 (Part Two) the girls finish talking about Journalists Who Are Murdered. Holly covers the twisty tale of Jake Lingle then there is a detailed debate.

Mel kicks it all off by insulting an entire nation, Holly continues the mob theme from episode one despite hating mob murders, there is a big debate despite the method of murder being exactly the same in both cases, there is a discussion on all the mistakes in Ho...
Share
Mark as Played
In Season 4 Episode 2 (Part One) the girls talk about Journalists Who Are Murdered. Mel covers the sad story of Jill Dando in the first of this two part episode.

Mel emphasises the best way to keep Holly happy, the girls decide gynaecologists are undatable, Mel makes a royal comparison, and Holly has to badly sum up this episode post-recording due to her being an idiot. EVERYTHING IS FINE.

Production, recording and post production ...
Share
Mark as Played
June 4, 2021 29 min
Welcome to Season 4 of Which Murderer!


In Season 4 Episode 1 Mel and Holly cover Mob Murders - Mel's choice as Holly has terrible taste in TV shows. It all connects. Holly kicks off the episode with the story of Albert Anastasia before Mel tells you about Abe Reles.


The girls discuss Holly's terrible brain, some new possible career options, an overview of Mel's extensive criminal history, there are some absolutely fabulou...
Share
Mark as Played
May 28, 2021 4 min
Welcome to Season 4 of Which Murderer!

In the Season 4 Intro you finally get to meet this season’s new co-host – MEL!

You’ll hear how she started off on this journey hating true crime and podcasts….look how that turned out. Almost as well as Holly saying she would never date again. There are loads of great cases lined up for this season so stay tuned!

Production, recording and postproduction completed by Holly who is trying to convi...
Share
Mark as Played
In the Season 3 Final Episode the girls cover Diagnosed Psychopaths Who Murder for Gemma’s final podcast appearance. Gemma chats through Robert Black before Holly talks about Jane Toppin.

Holly has some nickname confusion, Gemma tells a horror story of note, Holly may be serving seconds when it comes to her murderer and the girls share a final tough choice at the end of this episode.

Much love to Gemma and Producer Craig ss they star...
Share
Mark as Played
In Season 3 Episode 51 the girls talk about Beauty Pageant Murders with Holly kicking off her story of Svetlana Kotova before Gemma dives into her tale about Michaela McAreavey.

Shoutouts for Sarah with a case suggestion and Woody over at Real Life Real Crime who helped solve a cold case murder recently. We are super impressed and proud and totally recommend you listen to him. And not just because of his melty voice.

Time travel brea...
Share
Mark as Played

Popular Podcasts

  • If you can never get enough true crime... Congratulations, you’ve found your people.

  • The Daily

    This is what the news should sound like. The biggest stories of our time, told by the best journalists in the world. Hosted by Michael Barbaro. Twenty minutes a day, five days a week, ready by 6 a.m.

  • Dateline NBC

    Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations.

  • Morbid: A True Crime Podcast

    It’s a lighthearted nightmare in here, weirdos! Morbid is a true crime, creepy history and all things spooky podcast hosted by an autopsy technician and a hairstylist. Join us for a heavy dose of research with a dash of comedy thrown in for flavor.

  • Fake Doctors, Real Friends with Zach and Donald

    You know what's long, tedious and boring? Surgery. You know what isn't? This new podcast! Join Scrubs co-stars and real-life best friends Zach Braff and Donald Faison for a weekly comedy podcast where they relive the hit TV show, one episode at a time. Each week, these BFFs will discuss an episode of Scrubs, sharing behind-the-scenes stories and reminiscing on some of their favorite memories from filming. They’ll also connect with Scrubs super fans and feature beloved show cast members for exclusive interviews.

Advertise With Us
Music, radio and podcasts, all free. Listen online or download the iHeartRadio App.

Connect

© 2021 iHeartMedia, Inc.