Which Murderer?
Which Murderer brings together two hosts who talk about the methods, motives and background to murderers and their victims, covering two crimes per episode and debating from the victim's perspective which murderer they would pick to kill them if they HAD to choose. Hosted by Holly (the Canadian) and Garry (the Scot) from Scotland. Instagram (https://www.instagram.com/whichmurderer/) Twitter (https://twitter.com/whichmurderer) Explicit content and subject matter.
Episodes
April 18, 2025 • 24 mins
In Season 3 Episode 40 the girls talk about Chainsaw Murders – happens more than you’d think. Gemma starts you off with the gruesome murderer Jonathan Stasiuk before Holly tells you all about the sad story of Teri Lea Zenner and her brutal murder.
Shoutouts for the fabulous band @Battalionofflies who are dropping their EP TODAY so go check them out, Dave who recommended us (including a minor dig at the Canadian co-host – watching y...
Shoutouts for the fabulous band @Battalionofflies who are dropping their EP TODAY so go check them out, Dave who recommended us (including a minor dig at the Canadian co-host – watching y...
Mark as Played
April 11, 2025 • 33 mins
In Season 3 Episode 38 the girls talk about Ax Murders – can you believe it’s taken 3 seasons to get here? – with Gemma kicking it off by telling us the tale of the Ax Man of New Orleans and Holly then going on to chat us through the South African murderer Henri Van Breda.
Shoutout for Superfan Mel who is having a very busy apocalypse.
A translator is brought in for Holly’s case but she totally ignores it and changes the first name ...
Shoutout for Superfan Mel who is having a very busy apocalypse.
A translator is brought in for Holly’s case but she totally ignores it and changes the first name ...
Mark as Played
April 3, 2025 • 29 mins
In Season 3 Episode 11 – Solved Their Own Murders – Holly tells the story of Grace May Brown who helped convict her killer after her death before Gemma goes on to tell the sad story of Simon Ng who blogged his murderer into a conviction.
Shoutout to Natalie in Canada – thanks for recommending us! And thoughts go out to Holly’s Mom who is going through a hard time.
In this episode we learn that Producer Craig has planted clues alrea...
Shoutout to Natalie in Canada – thanks for recommending us! And thoughts go out to Holly’s Mom who is going through a hard time.
In this episode we learn that Producer Craig has planted clues alrea...
Mark as Played
February 27, 2025 • 26 mins
Which Murderer Flashback Episode!
In Which Murderer’s 36th episode of Season 6, the girls cover Paranormal Murders. Mel starts us off with a story about the Hammersmith Ghost, before Holly terrifies you with the Greenbrier Ghost story.
Emma Jo suggested this week's episode - thanks so much! It was a blast to research.
In this week’s episode you find out that Holly quote, ‘loves paranormal shit!’, Jesus is claimed, there are some exc...
In Which Murderer’s 36th episode of Season 6, the girls cover Paranormal Murders. Mel starts us off with a story about the Hammersmith Ghost, before Holly terrifies you with the Greenbrier Ghost story.
Emma Jo suggested this week's episode - thanks so much! It was a blast to research.
In this week’s episode you find out that Holly quote, ‘loves paranormal shit!’, Jesus is claimed, there are some exc...
Mark as Played
February 21, 2025 • 36 mins
Which Murderer Flashback Episode!
In Which Murderer’s Episode 41 Season 5 the girls cover chilling cases of Children Who Murder. Holly starts us off with the shocking case of Alyssa Bustamonte before Mel goes into the unbelievable murder by Amarjeet Sada.
Shoutout to Saraid for the suggestion! Blink twice if you are in danger.
In this episode you will go around the world with a tour of German foods (that actually aren’t German) and ...
In Which Murderer’s Episode 41 Season 5 the girls cover chilling cases of Children Who Murder. Holly starts us off with the shocking case of Alyssa Bustamonte before Mel goes into the unbelievable murder by Amarjeet Sada.
Shoutout to Saraid for the suggestion! Blink twice if you are in danger.
In this episode you will go around the world with a tour of German foods (that actually aren’t German) and ...
Mark as Played
February 14, 2025 • 41 mins
Which Murderer Flashback Episode!
In Season 4 Episode 36 the girls tackle another listener suggestion and tell you about Murders Solved by Psychics. What a great idea! Mel kicks it off with the sad story of Melanie Uribe before Holly tells you about a lovely man named Andre Daigle.
Shoutout to Cheryl for this week’s suggestion! Keep them coming…..you guys are doing a fantastic job.
Mel is on the running bandwagon while Holly remains...
In Season 4 Episode 36 the girls tackle another listener suggestion and tell you about Murders Solved by Psychics. What a great idea! Mel kicks it off with the sad story of Melanie Uribe before Holly tells you about a lovely man named Andre Daigle.
Shoutout to Cheryl for this week’s suggestion! Keep them coming…..you guys are doing a fantastic job.
Mel is on the running bandwagon while Holly remains...
Mark as Played
February 7, 2025 • 27 mins
Which Murderer Flashback Episode!
In Season 3 Episode 44 the girls talk about Murderers Haunted by Victim’s Ghosts. Gemma starts you off with the case of Adrian Daou before Holly goes over Jose Ferreira’s story.
Shoutout for Scott who is smitten with Producer Craig apparently. The girls are trying not to let Craig hear his praise or he will take over and kick them out of the team.
The girls are engrossing you all with endless storie...
In Season 3 Episode 44 the girls talk about Murderers Haunted by Victim’s Ghosts. Gemma starts you off with the case of Adrian Daou before Holly goes over Jose Ferreira’s story.
Shoutout for Scott who is smitten with Producer Craig apparently. The girls are trying not to let Craig hear his praise or he will take over and kick them out of the team.
The girls are engrossing you all with endless storie...
Mark as Played
January 28, 2025 • 30 mins
Which Murderer Flashback Episode!
In Episode 26 Season 2, Gemma and Holly talk about murderers who lost their heads!....while decapitating people. Gemma covers the murderer Mathew Borges who took 'troubled teens' a step or ten too far and Holly speaks about the Kingsbury Run murders from the 1930s.
The girls plug Gemma's guest appearance on the podcast 'Good Nurse Bad Nurse', Holly has another Reddit breakdown, the girls guess a mov...
In Episode 26 Season 2, Gemma and Holly talk about murderers who lost their heads!....while decapitating people. Gemma covers the murderer Mathew Borges who took 'troubled teens' a step or ten too far and Holly speaks about the Kingsbury Run murders from the 1930s.
The girls plug Gemma's guest appearance on the podcast 'Good Nurse Bad Nurse', Holly has another Reddit breakdown, the girls guess a mov...
Mark as Played
January 12, 2025 • 26 mins
Which Murderer Flashback Episode!
In Season 3 Episode 7 – Edinburgh Unsolved Murders, Holly kicks off the local tales of Murder with the sad story of the lovely Anne Ballantine. Gemma then goes on to cover the murder of Helen Kane – with some pretty big potential serial killer links.
Shoutout to a lovely Facebook follower who gave some feedback on our ‘Murders that Shocked the World’ episode – she spells her name very Irishy.
There ...
In Season 3 Episode 7 – Edinburgh Unsolved Murders, Holly kicks off the local tales of Murder with the sad story of the lovely Anne Ballantine. Gemma then goes on to cover the murder of Helen Kane – with some pretty big potential serial killer links.
Shoutout to a lovely Facebook follower who gave some feedback on our ‘Murders that Shocked the World’ episode – she spells her name very Irishy.
There ...
Mark as Played
January 5, 2025 • 37 mins
Which Murderer Flashback Episode!
In Season 3 Episode 14 –1970’s Murder – Gemma covers ‘Bad Man’ Randy Kraft while Holly tells you all about Robert John Maudsley who we might like a little?
Shoutouts for some lovely iTunes reviewers including ‘Canadian Danni and Super Husband Clive’
In this episode Gemma goes and ruins Holly’s favourite pasta, Holly gives some amazing Serial Killer pro tips, three entire adults fail to math, we concl...
In Season 3 Episode 14 –1970’s Murder – Gemma covers ‘Bad Man’ Randy Kraft while Holly tells you all about Robert John Maudsley who we might like a little?
Shoutouts for some lovely iTunes reviewers including ‘Canadian Danni and Super Husband Clive’
In this episode Gemma goes and ruins Holly’s favourite pasta, Holly gives some amazing Serial Killer pro tips, three entire adults fail to math, we concl...
Mark as Played
December 31, 2024 • 37 mins
Which Murderer Flashback Episode!
In Season 4 Episode 29 the girls wish you a very happy 2022 with MURDER. New Years Murders to be exact. Holly talks about murderer Scott Watson before Mel tells you all about John Allen Mohammad.
The girls continue with the Covid chat which annoys them both, they touch their microphones a lot in this episode so…. good luck listeners, the girls tell you how much they hate New Years Eve but also have a...
In Season 4 Episode 29 the girls wish you a very happy 2022 with MURDER. New Years Murders to be exact. Holly talks about murderer Scott Watson before Mel tells you all about John Allen Mohammad.
The girls continue with the Covid chat which annoys them both, they touch their microphones a lot in this episode so…. good luck listeners, the girls tell you how much they hate New Years Eve but also have a...
Mark as Played
December 23, 2024 • 26 mins
Which Murderer Flashback Episode!
Merry/Happy Christmas everybody! Our 30th episode focuses on Christmas murders....we discuss the tragic murder of Joanna Yeates and the Christmas Day massacre committed by Bruce Pardo. We realise that Holly is way too presumptuous to sit on a jury. Holly also completely traumatises Gemma and she will never look at Santa the same again. Then we propose a new mating ritual that is bound to be successf...
Merry/Happy Christmas everybody! Our 30th episode focuses on Christmas murders....we discuss the tragic murder of Joanna Yeates and the Christmas Day massacre committed by Bruce Pardo. We realise that Holly is way too presumptuous to sit on a jury. Holly also completely traumatises Gemma and she will never look at Santa the same again. Then we propose a new mating ritual that is bound to be successf...
Mark as Played
September 27, 2024 • 31 mins
In Season 7 Episode 2 Holly and Gary talk about Mistaken Identity Murders. Garry kicks things off with the story of Martin Trayton Smith before Holly talks about Rishmeet Singh.
Shoutout to Emma Jo for this week’s topic suggestion! Thanks so much.
The co-hosts are riddled with plague and are very poor babies who need their beds, Holly’s OCD carries over into the swimming pool, the metric system strikes again, and the dying prow...
Shoutout to Emma Jo for this week’s topic suggestion! Thanks so much.
The co-hosts are riddled with plague and are very poor babies who need their beds, Holly’s OCD carries over into the swimming pool, the metric system strikes again, and the dying prow...
Mark as Played
September 13, 2024 • 26 mins
In Which Murderer’s first official episode of Season 7, the gang covers TV Special Murders. Holly starts us off with the case of Jennifer Ann Mee, before Garry goes over the tale of Brynn Omdahl Hartman.
Listener Mel suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much!
This week there is TV series catchup with blatant spoilers, lovely listener messages which are butchered, hiccup cures are provided and there are too many N's.
Production, r...
Listener Mel suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much!
This week there is TV series catchup with blatant spoilers, lovely listener messages which are butchered, hiccup cures are provided and there are too many N's.
Production, r...
Mark as Played
September 6, 2024 • 29 mins
LISTENER ANNOUNCEMENT: It’s a boy! Welcome Garry for Season 7!
In Which Murderer’s opening episode of Season 7, the gang covers Murdered by Proxy. Garry starts us off with the case of John Bodkin Adams, before Holly goes over the tale of Mark Hopkinson.
Listener Saraid suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much!
This week Holly recounts her summer (most of which she can’t remember), Garry starts his podcasting journey and drugs ma...
In Which Murderer’s opening episode of Season 7, the gang covers Murdered by Proxy. Garry starts us off with the case of John Bodkin Adams, before Holly goes over the tale of Mark Hopkinson.
Listener Saraid suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much!
This week Holly recounts her summer (most of which she can’t remember), Garry starts his podcasting journey and drugs ma...
Mark as Played
July 22, 2024 • 31 mins
WHICH MURDERER FLASHBACK EPISODE!
In Which Murderer’s Episode 44 Season 5 the girls finally cover Witch Murders. Mel starts us off with Ama Hemmah from Ghana before Holly goes into the complicated case of Lawrence Harris.
Shoutout to Saraid for the suggestion!
In this episode the girls decide who the next James Bond will be and what TV Witches they want to drink some tea with, Mel is very clearly making up the name of her murderer en...
In Which Murderer’s Episode 44 Season 5 the girls finally cover Witch Murders. Mel starts us off with Ama Hemmah from Ghana before Holly goes into the complicated case of Lawrence Harris.
Shoutout to Saraid for the suggestion!
In this episode the girls decide who the next James Bond will be and what TV Witches they want to drink some tea with, Mel is very clearly making up the name of her murderer en...
Mark as Played
July 15, 2024 • 41 mins
IT'S A WHICH MURDERER FLASHBACK!
In Season 4 Episode 36 the girls tackle another listener suggestion and tell you about Murders Solved by Psychics. What a great idea! Mel kicks it off with the sad story of Melanie Uribe before Holly tells you about a lovely man named Andre Daigle.
Shoutout to Cheryl for this week’s suggestion! Keep them coming…..you guys are doing a fantastic job.
Mel is on the running bandwagon while Holly remains ...
In Season 4 Episode 36 the girls tackle another listener suggestion and tell you about Murders Solved by Psychics. What a great idea! Mel kicks it off with the sad story of Melanie Uribe before Holly tells you about a lovely man named Andre Daigle.
Shoutout to Cheryl for this week’s suggestion! Keep them coming…..you guys are doing a fantastic job.
Mel is on the running bandwagon while Holly remains ...
Mark as Played
June 21, 2024 • 29 mins
LISTENER ANNOUNCEMENT: THIS WILL BE THE FINAL EPISODE OF SEASON 6 AS WE ARE NOW ON OUR SUMMER BREAK. WE WILL BE BACK IN SEPTEMBER! Stay safe and keep those episode suggestions coming in!
In Which Murderer’s 51st episode of Season 6, the girls cover Vengence Murders. Holly starts us off with the gangland murder of Bailey Atkinson, before Mel goes over the tale of poor Keith Philpott.
Listener Emma Jo suggested this week’s topic - tha...
In Which Murderer’s 51st episode of Season 6, the girls cover Vengence Murders. Holly starts us off with the gangland murder of Bailey Atkinson, before Mel goes over the tale of poor Keith Philpott.
Listener Emma Jo suggested this week’s topic - tha...
Mark as Played
June 14, 2024 • 32 mins
In Which Murderer’s 50th episode of Season 6, the girls cover Body Snatcher Murders. Mel starts us off with the world famous Burke and Hare Murders, before Holly goes over the closely related tale of the London Burkers.
Listener Ricky suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much!
The weather girls (sorry, women) are covering ground breaking issues like murderous highland cows, resting livers, dead body shortages and how alcohol and ...
Listener Ricky suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much!
The weather girls (sorry, women) are covering ground breaking issues like murderous highland cows, resting livers, dead body shortages and how alcohol and ...
Mark as Played
June 7, 2024 • 34 mins
In Which Murderer’s 49th episode of Season 6, the girls cover Care Home Murders. Holly starts us off with the drug fueled case involving Rachel Baker, before Mel goes over the ‘angel of death’ story of Heather Pressdee.
Listener Kirsty suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much!
This week's episode begins with memory failure, involves Eurovision, some very good advice regarding drugs (don’t do them kids!) and Holly is a time trav...
Listener Kirsty suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much!
This week's episode begins with memory failure, involves Eurovision, some very good advice regarding drugs (don’t do them kids!) and Holly is a time trav...
Mark as Played
Popular Podcasts
Does hearing about a true crime case always leave you scouring the internet for the truth behind the story? Dive into your next mystery with Crime Junkie. Every Monday, join your host Ashley Flowers as she unravels all the details of infamous and underreported true crime cases with her best friend Brit Prawat. From cold cases to missing persons and heroes in our community who seek justice, Crime Junkie is your destination for theories and stories you won’t hear anywhere else. Whether you're a seasoned true crime enthusiast or new to the genre, you'll find yourself on the edge of your seat awaiting a new episode every Monday. If you can never get enough true crime... Congratulations, you’ve found your people. Follow to join a community of Crime Junkies! Crime Junkie is presented by audiochuck Media Company.
The latest news in 4 minutes updated every hour, every day.
If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.
Listen to 'The Bobby Bones Show' by downloading the daily full replay.
Latino USA is the longest-running news and culture radio program in the U.S. centering Latino stories, hosted by Pulitzer Prize winning journalist Maria Hinojosa Every week, the Peabody winning team brings you revealing, in-depth stories about what’s in the hearts and minds of Latinos and their impact on the world. Want to support our independent journalism? Join Futuro+ for exclusive episodes, sneak peaks and behind-the-scenes chisme on Latino USA and all our podcasts. www.futuromediagroup.org/joinplus