What the NFL Taught Carl Pickens About Pressure, Mindset & Accountability

Thinking about playing football at the next level?

In this episode of The Gametime Guru Podcast, we dive deep into the real-life journey of Carl Pickens, from high school standout to Freshman All-American at Tennessee, to NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year with the Cincinnati Bengals.

This conversation is essential listening for:

🚨 Aspiring college and pro athletes

🚨 High school football players looking to understand the process

🚨 Parents and coaches helping athletes navigate transitions

🚨 Fans of 1990s NFL football (Boomer Esiason, Jeff Blake, Deion Sanders, and more!)

🎯 Key Questions Answered in this Episode
➤ How can players handle the disappointment of draft day?
Carl shares how being passed over by the Denver Broncos fueled his fire and how he embraced the unexpected call from Cincinnati.

➤ What’s the hardest part about the transition from high school to college football?
It’s not just the playbook—Carl talks about culture shock, homesickness, and learning how to re-prove yourself at every level.

➤ Can you make it to the NFL if you’re not a 5-star recruit?
Carl explains how mindset, consistency, and accountability matter more than rankings.

➤ What’s it really like to go from college to the pros?
From catching passes from Boomer Esiason to learning the pro playbook—Carl explains what being a professional means beyond just talent.

🧠 Top Takeaways from Carl Pickens
Accountability defines professionalism: From showing up on time to running clean routes, accountability is the #1 trait that separates the pros.

Setbacks are setups: From being redshirted at Tennessee to switching positions early in college, Carl used every obstacle as fuel.

You don’t have to be open to make a play: Learn how Carl won contested catches vs. elite DBs like Deion Sanders and Aeneas Williams.

Support systems matter: Carl’s family and coaches helped him stay grounded during the hardest transitions of his career.

Your “why” drives your success: He didn’t want to let his parents down—and that kept him focused during the grind of NFL life.

🏆 Highlights from the Interview

Playing high school basketball as a 6'1" forward and high jumping 7'1"

Being the only freshman receiver at Tennessee and transitioning to free safety

Being passed on by Denver during the NFL Draft and picked by Cincinnati instead

How turf vs. grass impacted his favorite stadiums (Denver, Cleveland)

Stories from the locker room: relationships with Darnay Scott, Boomer Esiason, and Jeff Blake

📍 Follow Carl Pickens on Instagram:
🔗 https://www.instagram.com/thecarlpickens 

Want to see what Carl’s up to now? From motorcycles to horses to podcast appearances—he’s just getting started in his post-NFL journey.

🎙 About The Gametime Guru Podcast
Host: Shane Larson
Global reach: 182 countries
🔁 Weekly interviews with pro athletes, coaches, and sports visionaries

👉 Subscribe for more powerful conversations that reveal what it really takes to compete and succeed at the highest level of sports.