#435 Pronouns, Puberty Blockers, and Parental Rights: Where Do We Draw the Line? 4 of 6

And Another Thing With Dave, by Dave Smith

Host: David Smith
Guest: Spirited Journey

In this compelling follow-up conversation, David Smith and Spirited Journey tackle the layered and controversial issues surrounding gender identity, medical ethics, and parental involvement. The episode explores the real-world implications of schools using and withholding students' preferred pronouns from parents, and how that might relate to a broader “slippery slope” involving medical decisions like puberty blockers.

The conversation draws parallels with long-standing debates, such as minors accessing birth control without parental consent. However, as David and Spirited Journey emphasize, the stakes are arguably higher when it comes to irreversible medical interventions. They critique the lack of long-term studies on puberty blockers and challenge the idea that these treatments are always “completely reversible.”

Listener messages add depth and nuance, offering perspectives on conversion therapy, parental roles, and the consequences of institutional overreach. One listener raises a poignant scenario involving interracial relationships and parental prejudice, asking where schools should draw the line in protecting or informing parents.

David and Spirited Journey also dive into the politics of academia, referencing research showing open discrimination against conservatives in psychology, and how ideological bias may shape the type of research that gets funded and published. The episode closes with case studies illustrating the real-world consequences of medical decisions made too early, too quickly, and possibly under pressure from societal norms.

Follow me and find More of My Content with link below

https://linktr.ee/andanotherthingwithdave

• [04:16] Slippery slope: From pronouns to medical decisions in schools

• [05:08] Puberty blockers, long-term effects, and medical reversibility

• [06:28] Criticism of priorities: Pronouns vs. real-life preparedness

• [07:20] Clarifying the difference between affirmation therapy and conversion therapy

• [08:21] Advocacy for equality while critiquing current practices

• [09:16] Discrimination in academic publishing based on political views

• [11:08] Bias in research and funding: Is ideology replacing science?

• [12:13] When did DSM definitions of transgender identity change—and why?

• [14:13] Listener scenario: Should schools tell parents about interracial relationships?

• [15:19] Government neutrality in personal identity matters

• [17:05] Call for better school funding and more school-based mental health services

• [18:22] Case studies: The consequences of early medical intervention in children

  
  

• Gender identity in schools

• Pronouns and parental rights

• Puberty blockers and informed consent

• Political bias in academic research

• School policies and transparency

• Case studies on medical ethics

• DSM and transgender diagnosis

• Conservative representation in psychology

• Mental health in schools

• Youth rights vs. parental rights

  
  

  
  

#PodcastWithDave #AndAnotherThing #ParentalRights #PubertyBlockers #SchoolTransparency #PronounDebate #AffirmativeCare #TransYouth #MedicalEthics #PoliticalBias #PsychologyResearch #DSM5 #Ge