The Winner Effect: The Science Behind Clutch Performance

Send us a text

Winning changes everything—but not in the way most coaches think. Beyond the scoreboard and standings, victory triggers a fascinating biological transformation in the brain that makes future success more likely. Coach Ken Carpenter dives deep into "The Winner Effect," revealing how each hard-fought win releases testosterone and dopamine, rewiring neural pathways to create athletes who thrive under pressure rather than crumble.

The science is clear: players who experience meaningful victories develop increased confidence, better focus, and the ability to take calculated risks in clutch moments. But there's a crucial caveat—easy wins against weak competition or hollow praise don't create this effect. Instead, they breed complacency and entitlement that collapse at the first sign of adversity. Coaches who understand this distinction hold the key to building genuinely resilient teams.

Coach Carpenter shares practical strategies for implementing this knowledge, from creating small competitive scenarios in practice to shifting praise toward effort rather than talent. The middle infielders competing for the cleanest double-play turns. The "beat the coach" batting practice drill. These seemingly minor competitions stack up, creating the neurological foundation for clutch performance when the stakes are highest. "Confidence built on work sticks. Confidence built on compliments crumbles." It's not just a catchy phrase—it's backed by neuroscience. For coaches serious about developing players who rise to the occasion, this episode provides the blueprint for turning biology into championships. Subscribe and leave a review if you're ready to transform how your team approaches winning.

Join the Baseball Coaches Unplugged podcast where an experienced baseball coach delves into the world of high school and travel baseball, offering insights on high school baseball coaching, leadership skills, hitting skills, pitching strategy, defensive skills, and overall baseball strategy, while also covering high school and college baseball, recruiting tips, youth and travel baseball, and fostering a winning mentality and attitude in baseball players through strong baseball leadership and mentality.

Support the show

• Follow: Twitter | Instagram @Athlete1Podcast
• Website - https://www.athlete1.net
• Sponsor: The Netting Professionals
• https://www.nettingpros.com

Episode Transcript

Speaker 1 (00:01):
What if I told you winning isn't just about talent.
It actually rewires the brain.
In this episode of Baseball,Coaches Unplugged, I break down
how stacking small, hard-foughtwins can turn an average player
into a clutch performer.
If you're serious aboutdeveloping confident,
pressure-proof athletes, youdon't want to miss this one.

Speaker 2 (00:53):
Welcome to Baseball Coaches Unplugged with Coach Ken
Carpenter, presented byAthleteOne.
You don't want to miss this one.
We'll be right back.
Insights on recruiting,coaching leadership and crafting
a team culture that championsproductivity and success.
Join Coach every week as hebreaks down the game and shares
incredible behind-the-scenesstories.
Your competitive edge startshere, so check out the show
weekly and hear from the bestcoaches in the game.

(01:15):
On Baseball Coaches Unplugged.

Speaker 1 (01:18):
This episode of Baseball Coaches Unplugged is
powered by the nettingprofessionals, improving
programs one facility at a time.
The Netting Pros specialize inthe design, fabrication and
installation of custom nettingfor baseball and softball.
This includes backstops,batting cages, bp turtles,
screens, ball carts and more.
They also design and installdigital graphic wall padding,

(01:41):
windscreen, turf, turfprotectors, dugout benches and
cubbies.
They're not limited to justbaseball and softball.
They also work with football,soccer, lacrosse and golf
courses.
Contact them today at844-620-2707.
That's 844-620-2707.
Or visit them online atwwwnettingproscom.

(02:06):
Check out Netting Pros on X,instagram, facebook and LinkedIn
for all their latest productsand projects.
Hello everyone, and thanks forjoining me here at Baseball
Coaches Unplugged.
I'm your host, coach KenCarpenter.
If you enjoyed today's show,please be sure to hit that
subscribe button.
Leave us a review.
It helps us to grow the show.

(02:26):
Check us out every Wednesday,where I sit down with some of
the best high school, collegeand professional coaches around
the country.
You ever notice in baseball how,once a team starts winning, it
just keeps happening, almostlike momentum has a life of its
own.
It's not magic, it's not luck.
There's something deeper goingon, something you can actually

(02:50):
build inside your program if youunderstand it.
There's a fascinating bookcalled the Winner Effect by Ian
Robertson.
It's all about how winningactually changes the brain
chemically, biologically, makingfuture success more likely, and

(03:12):
it's something every highschool baseball coach needs to
understand if you're seriousabout not just a winning season
but building a winning culture.
Here's what Robertson foundEvery time someone in anything
wins, their brain releases aboost of testosterone and
dopamine.
That's not just a temporaryhigh Testosterone makes them

(03:36):
more assertive, more confidentand more willing to take
calculated risk.
Dopamine fires up motivationand locks in the focus.
Win enough times and the brainstarts rewiring itself for
future success.
It's why you see some playerswho just keep rising in big
moments.
Their brains have been trainedto expect success, not fear it.

(04:01):
That's why confident teams playso loose and tight games.
It's not fake swagger, it's notjust a mental toughness poster
hanging on the locker room wall.
It's biology.
But here's the catch If winningis too easy, if it's a blowout
win against cupcakes or fakepraise handed out like candy,

(04:25):
the brain doesn't get the samechemical hit.
You get the oppositeComplacency, entitlement.
Players start showing upexpecting success, not earning
it, and the second adversitypunches them in the mouth.
They fold.
So the real key is stackinghard-earned wins, not just in

(04:46):
games, in practices, in theweight room, even in the locker
room.
One thing you can start doing isbuild small competitions in
everything.
Middle infielders compete forthe cleanest double play turns.
Outfielders track down everyfly ball and make sure it

(05:07):
doesn't hit the ground.
Hitters play beat the coachduring BP.
If you barreled up a line drive, you won.
Every day had a six scoreboard,even if it was just in the
player's head.
Another thing you got to stoppraising talent.
Stop praising things likeyou're a great hitter.

(05:29):
Instead, it was all those extrareps on the tee and after
practice that's starting to showup in the game.
Confidence built on work sticks.
Confidence built on compliments, crumbles.
And here's the last piece Neverlet them feel like they've

(05:50):
arrived.
The last piece.
Never let them feel likethey've arrived.
The moment you win a big gameor tournament, you immediately
raise the bar.
New goals, new challenges, newways to sharpen the edge.
If you want your team to stackwins, don't just chase talent,
chase small wins.
Chase earned confidence.

(06:10):
Chase the kind of competitionand competitive fire that
rewires the brain day after dayuntil winning isn't a miracle.
It's just what your programdoes.
The Baseball Coaches Unpluggedpodcast is proud to be partnered
with the netting professionalsimproving programs one facility

(06:30):
at a time.
With the netting professionalsimproving programs, one facility
at a time.
Contact them today at844-620-2707, or visit them
online at wwwnettingproscom.
As always, I'm your host, coachKen Carpenter, and thanks for
joining me on Baseball CoachesUnplugged.