WHY DIETS DON'T WORK EP 15

Break Free from Diet Culture and Embrace Body Autonomy

In today’s episode, Jennie Kramer and Nina Manolson talk about the pitfalls of diet culture, the emotional toll of restrictive eating, and the path to reclaiming your body autonomy. 

Both Jennie and Nina share personal experiences and insights from working with clients who have struggled for years with the allure of diets, promising a quick fix for deeper issues.

As they highlight, the dieting cycle is often rooted in societal pressures—especially around body image—and perpetuated by a multi-billion-dollar industry designed to exploit our insecurities. Nina notes that many of her clients have been on over 10 different diets, lured in by the promise of thinness, success, and acceptance. But as both women discuss, the real "win" never comes from external validation.

The Allure of Dieting

Dieting is sexy. Not because it’s healthy, but because it's marketed as the magic solution to all of life’s problems. Jennie underscores this point, noting that societal beliefs about thinner bodies being better accepted fuel our obsession with weight loss. She points out that this is especially prevalent in the medical field, where many physicians wrongly assume that weight loss will solve health issues like high cholesterol, perpetuating weight stigma.

The Emotional Toll of Restriction

Jennie prefers the term “deprivation” to describe what happens when we diet. While diets might promise physical transformation, they also lead to emotional and psychological deprivation. As Nina elaborates, this deprivation disconnects us from our natural hunger and satiety cues, creating a pattern of chronic dissatisfaction and body shame. "Eventually, our inner rebel shows up and says, ‘Don’t take that away from me!’” Nina explains. This often leads to overeating, followed by guilt and shame, trapping us in a vicious cycle.

The Path to Body Autonomy

Rather than focusing on what to restrict, Nina encourages listeners to add in elements of self-care: sleep, hydration, variety, and pleasure. The goal is not to deprive yourself but to listen deeply to your body’s needs. Whether it’s respecting personal dietary triggers (like Nina’s experience with gluten) or giving yourself permission to enjoy food without guilt, the journey to body peace begins with understanding that you deserve nourishment.

Breaking the Cycle

They wrap up by examining the diet cycle’s inevitable fail. As Jennie eloquently puts it, "Dieting and restricting create a cycle of failure and shame, and the industry knows it. Every time you ‘fail,’ there’s a new diet waiting for you." Nina adds that real body autonomy comes from making thoughtful, educated decisions about your body—whether that’s trying a new plan or simply slowing down to enjoy your meals.

In a world where diet culture is pervasive, Jennie and Nina’s conversation is a breath of fresh air, encouraging us to tune into our bodies and reject the notion that thinner is always better.

This episode is a must-listen for anyone trapped in the cycle of dieting or looking to reclaim their relationship with food and their body.

⁠Connect with Nina and Jennie⁠Learn more about your ad choices. Visit ⁠ads.spotify.com. ⁠