Comanagers Fantasy Football Show

The Comanagers are back after a week off, and we waste no time getting right back into playoff madness. Episode 87 opens with Justin discovering the rare joy of actually needing a jacket on vacation, before we dive headfirst into a full NFL Playoff Recap.

We break down every game from Wildcard Weekend through the Divisional Round. From the Rams and Bears surviving late-game insanity, to Buffalo riding Josh Allen until the wheels nea...

Episode 86 kicks off with John calling out one of the most painful truths of the 2025 fantasy season: the sophomore slump absolutely wrecked the 2024 wide receiver class. From overhyped breakouts to weekly lineup landmines, we break down how expectations crashed into reality.

From there, it’s full Playoff Week Preview mode as we dive into Fantasy Feast, highlighting the players we think will carry teams when it matters most. The Com...

In this episode, John opens with one of the cruelest truths of fantasy football: dominating the regular season meant absolutely nothing in 2025. We break down the wild stats showing just how unlikely it was for top regular-season teams to actually win a fantasy championship—and why the playoffs remain a beautiful, unpredictable mess.

From there, we hand out the highly anticipated 2025 Comanagers Fantasy Awards, celebrating the bigge...

Episode 84 opens with immediate chaos as Justin unloads on one of the softest ejections of the season—Alec Pierce getting tossed for barely brushing a referee. It’s a rant fueled by disbelief, slow-motion replays, and the age-old question: what are we even doing here?

From there, we take a victory lap through a week full of NFL history, including Myles Garrett breaking the single-season sack record, Caleb Williams rewriting the Bear...

Episode 83 starts exactly where it should: with completely unhinged NFL stats that make absolutely no sense. The Packers are somehow 0–3 when they don’t punt, the Eagles are 3–0 when they forget how to throw the ball for an entire half, and that pretty much sets the tone for the rest of the episode.

From there, we dive into another round of Fantasy Feast + Famine, including a tightly contested Comanagers Clash where Justin barely sq...

Episode 82 is a full-blown roller coaster of dominance, disappointment, and late-season weirdness.

We open with a quick reality check on the NFL landscape—highlighting just how few wins some teams have managed against opponents over .500—before diving headfirst into another jam-packed Winners and Sinners episode.

This week’s Winners feature video-game performances across the board. Drake Maye puts together one of the most efficient q...

Episode 81 is a celebration, a history lesson, and a warning label for Week 18 all rolled into one.

We start by congratulating all the fantasy champions, including Lon, who took down Dave in the home league, thanks to dominant performances from Christian McCaffrey and Dak Prescott. From there, the guys break down a week filled with record-setting performances, led by Josh Allen becoming the fastest and youngest quarterback in NFL hi...

Episode 80 starts exactly how you’d expect — completely off the rails.

Justin gets so fired up talking about cookies that he earns the first-ever Comanagers censor beep, setting the tone for a legendary Cookie Draft. The guys go head-to-head in selecting the best cookies on the board, from Chocolate Chip and Thin Mints to controversial picks like Frosting-Decorated Cookies. John confidently declares himself the winner, while Justin ...

Episode 79 is a full Winners and Sinners breakdown after one of the wildest fantasy weeks of the season.

The Comanagers dive straight into the Week Winners, highlighting massive performances across every position. Brock Purdy drops five touchdowns, Matthew Stafford continues his elite season with nearly 460 passing yards, and Trevor Lawrence keeps stacking top-tier weeks. At running back, Christian McCaffrey and Bijan Robinson remin...

Episode 78 starts with absolute NFL whiplash.

John opens the show reacting to the Jaguars and Patriots suddenly looking like legitimate AFC contenders, the Lions somehow scoring two game-winning touchdowns and still losing, and a brutal playoff exit thanks to Joe Burrow, Chris Olave, and Kenny Gainwell all choosing the same week to explode. The guys also take a look at the Jets’ season-long receiving leaders.

From there, it’s time fo...

Episode 77 is all about putting instincts to the test — and watching them fail in real time.

The Comanagers dive straight into Keep, Trade, Cut, debating quarterbacks, running backs, wide receivers, and tight ends. From elite names like Lamar Jackson, Jalen Hurts, Bijan Robinson, Justin Jefferson, and Brock Bowers to polarizing depth plays and prospects, every decision sparks disagreement and second-guessing.

Next up is Blind Resume,...

Episode 76 kicks off on a high note as the Comanagers take a moment to appreciate what this pod has become: two friends talking football, having fun, and realizing people are actually listening. From there, it’s straight back to business.

This week’s episode centers on the Fantasy Feast + Famine Week Preview, starting with another chapter of the Comanagers Clash. Justin continues his hot streak, securing a 6–3 victory by absolutely ...

Episode 75 opens with Producer Dakota stepping in early — literally handing Justin a note reminding him to be nice. Things somehow only escalate from there.

This week is all about Winners and Sinners, and the fantasy scoreboard was absolutely unhinged. Trevor Lawrence headlines the Week Winners after a six-TD eruption, prompting John to attempt — and immediately abandon — a “Lawrence of Arabia” joke. Bo Nix, Kirk Cousins (inevitably...

The fantasy playoffs wait for no one — and in Episode 74, the margins were brutal.

We open with a full breakdown of Justin’s playoff collapse, a perfect storm of underperformers headlined by Isaiah Likely and capped off by running headfirst into Trevor Lawrence’s nuclear performance. On the other side of the bracket, John looks ahead to a tough matchup against friend-of-the-show Dave, who’s rolling out James Cook and Amon-Ra St. Bro...

Monday Night Football is wrapping up as we hit record, and things are trending very differently for your Comanagers. John is cruising toward the 1-seed and a first-round bye, while Justin… well, Justin is fighting for his fantasy life. Emotions are high, confidence is… uneven.

We kick things off with a spicy round of Keep, Trade, Cut, including a special “Retirement Home Edition” featuring Philip Rivers, Tom Brady, and Derek Carr — ...

We’re recording during one of the wildest Monday Night Football games in recent memory — and Jalen Hurts is committing turnovers like he’s speed-running a bad Madden challenge. A -4 point play, five turnovers in an eleven-play span, and the first six-turnover first half since 1978. It’s chaos, it’s comedy, and it’s absolutely impacting fantasy leagues everywhere. 

This episode, we dive into our Week Preview: Fantasy Feast + Famine, ...

The fantasy playoffs are heating up, but the NFL injury carousel keeps spinning — and this week it might have cracked open the door for one of the craziest storylines imaginable: Philip Rivers possibly stepping in for Riley Leonard, who’s now week-to-week with a strained knee ligament. Yes, the same Philip Rivers whose oldest child is literally the same age as the quarterback he may replace. You can’t make this stuff up.

This week, ...

Fantasy playoffs are officially here, and Episode 70 opens with John celebrating a massive lead thanks to Gibbs and Brandon Aubrey (sorry, Sara). Both Comanagers have secured playoff spots in the home league, with the top two seeds to be determined on Monday Night Football. It was a weird fantasy week overall — low scoring, strange QB choices, and even stranger NFL playoff standings with teams like the Pats, Jags, Steelers, and Bea...

Welcome to Episode 69 (Nice!) of the Comanagers Podcast! John opens the show discussing Christmas decorations. Justin has begrudingly decorated a bit this year.

The guys dive into another chaotic round of Keep, Trade, Cut, debating everything from rookie QBs to Saquon, from Wandale hype to whether Brenton Strange is actually good (he might be).

Then it’s time for Blind Resume, featuring rushing leaders, efficiency traps, and John get...