December 9, 2024 • 60 mins
This episode is a real treat for all those who are interested in bowhunting, bowhunting culture and the ethics of bowhunting compared to rifle hunting. Everything sprinkled with a healthy dose of hunting stories.
It feels like I’m one of the only very few who talks about bowhunting with European listeners in mind. Indeed, I would like to see hunting with archery tackle being legalised and popularised on the old continent. In my view, the notions that it’s inhumane or somehow unethical are ill-advised and plain wrong. It is especially disturbing when such unwise opinions are expressed with confidence by hunters or veterinary practitioners who have no experience or previous exposure to bowhunting.
To talk about these matters I’m joined by expert bowhunter Jim Clark. In our conversation, Jim shares a wealth of knowledge about bowhunting as well as some of his personal stories. As always I didn’t shy away from asking him hard questions to tease out the potential downsides of using archery tackle over firearms.
It was a thoroughly enjoyable conversation and it only made me want to try my hand at bowhunting even more. I will keep talking about hunting with archery tackle to at least provoke a constructive discussion among European hunters and hunting organisations alike. If you would like to see bowhunting legalised, please leave a comment. What are your thoughts?
Subscribe to Tommy's Outdoors: Conservation and Science Newsletter
Support the Podcast and Buy Me a Coffee.
Recommended Books: tommysoutdoors.com/books
Merch: tommysoutdoors.com/shop
Follow Tommy's Outdoors on Bluesky, Twitter, Instagram, YouTube and Facebook
Mentioned in this episode:
This is the Conservation and Science podcast Replay series, a curated collection of best episodes from last year. If you are new to the show, this is an excellent opportunity to catch up with the most popular episodes from the back catalogue. And if you’re a regular listener, maybe you missed one of those or want to listen to one of them again. Don’t worry! The new episodes are being published on the regular fortnightly schedule, so keep tuning in for the new content every other Tuesday.
Mark as Played
Transcript
Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
(00:00):
This is the Conservation and Science Podcast Replay series,a curated collection of best episodes from last year.
If you are new to the show, this is an excellent opportunityto catch up with the most popular episodes from the back catalog.
And if you are a regular listener,maybe you miss one of those or want to listen to one of them again.
(00:20):
Don't worry, the new episodes are being published on their regularfortnightly schedule, so keep tuning in for the new content
every other Tuesday.
Is bow hunting inhumane?
Is killing an animal with an arrow and inhumane thing to do?
Well, there is a lot of folks who insist the answer is yes,and that is somehow reflected in the regulations.
(00:44):
As hunting with archery tackle is illegal in most of Europe,and I am not surprised if those opinions are expressed
by, let's say, a veterinary professionalwith particular interest in animal welfare,
who on top of that had very little,if none, experience and exposure to bow hunting.
(01:04):
But when those opinions are expressed by hunters and almost bothered
especially that those hunters had also no exposure,no real world exposure to bow hunting.
And in a second part of this podcast,you will hear a story about a hardcore old European hunter
(01:27):
who changed his mind about bow hunting oncehe took part and participated in a hunt with archery tackle.
So that's in the second part of this podcast,
but I think it is my role here in this podcastto be bringing you different opinions, different points of view.
And this is, probably third or fourth episode.
(01:49):
Where are we going to talk about bow hunting?
So today we are joined by an expert bow hunter, Jim Clark.
Jim Hunts with archery tackle close to four decades.
He hunts with a compound bow with a recurve bow.He hunted with a crossbow.
And obviously he handled with a rifle.
So his opinions and his views, I think that are very well thought out.
(02:14):
And he has a wealth of experience, and he's sharing that with us today.
And as usual in those episodes, I'll post him a little bit,asking him questions
about hunting with archery, tackle and bow huntingthat might be uncomfortable.
And, yeah, you're gonna hear his answers.
(02:35):
In the episode, we also discuss the development and progressin, technology of archery, tackle
and how this might or might not impact the humaneness of an endeavor.
And also, Jim will share some of his hunting stories.
So overall, that was a very enjoyable episode to record,
(02:59):
and I hope you will learn a thing or two about bowhunting and hunting with archery tackle.
And just to be clear, if you are against bow huntingor you think it is an inhumane thing to do,
I'm not expecting you to change your mindafter listening to this episode.
But maybe, just maybe, on the surface of your strong opinion,a little crack appears and if that happens, my job is done.
(03:28):
This is what we do.
In this podcast, we discuss issues related to environmentsand human wildlife interactions that are sometimes controversial,
maybe not clear cut, and the role of the podcastis to present different angles and different opinions on those aspects.
So this is one of those episodes.And as always, before I let you enjoy this episode of the podcast.
(03:49):
Just a reminderthat if you're interested in the subjects we're discussing here
and you want to dive deeper in those subjects, you should subscribeto my newsletter, the so-called Conservation and Science Newsletter.
The link is obviously in the description of the show,and that newsletter comes together
(04:09):
with podcast episodes,and it usually contains some other reading and other materials
that will allow you to dive deeper into the subjectswe discuss on the podcast.
And also you'll get notifications thereabout live events, weather, events.
When I'm speaking live. Or maybe I'm just attending participating.
(04:32):
So if it's something that interests you, you can join the event,you can go to the event.
And if you see me there, come up and say hello.
So, that's it for that introduction.
And so now,ladies and gentlemen, Jim Clark and hunting with archery tackle.
(05:04):
And. Jim, welcome to the show.
It's a pleasure to have you in the pleasure. Talk with you.
Thank you. Tammy,I really appreciate it. Been looking forward to our conversation. Yes.
And as, listeners of this podcast know,and as you already know as well, I,
I'm really keen, to talk about bow hunting any time I can,because bow hunting is just not a thing in Europe, and I.
(05:32):
I hope that maybeif there's going to be like 1 or 2 people who starts, you know,
pushing right buttons to get that bow hunting going in Europein, in the to the greater extent, because there are
some places in France, I think that in Spain there are some provinceswhere you can bow hunt, but in general you cannot bow hunting.
Where I am in Ireland, it's a no no in the UK as well,where the probably majority of the listeners are.
(05:57):
So, you know, I'm very keen to talk about it and we,we have a lot of talk.
So before we start, Jim, could you give us, like,a, like a brief introduction to,
who you are, what you do, and how you got started, in bow hunting?
Yeah, absolutely. Tommy.
So my name is Jim Clark, and I grew up in Chicago, Illinois,so in a city, fairly good sized city. And,
(06:25):
since a young age, I always love the outdoors.
Just it was just one of those things where I was always taking myfishing rod and going out to the local pond and things of that nature.
And, and once a year,my dad would take us on a, on a pheasant hunting trip.
So I got exposed to hunting a little bitthrough my father and his business.
But he was not a passionate big game hunter, nor a bow hunter.
(06:46):
But I just fell in love with it.
With the with the whole lifestyle of of pursuing game
and the tremendous challenge and fulfillmentthat I got out of that, even even though I started small time.
And so as I got older,I started working in a sporting goods store and was introduced.
The sporting goods store sold bows and I was like, wow, that is cool.
(07:09):
And I'd shot the little bowswhen I was a kid, right? But never a real bow.
And so I started shooting at that store,and I fell in love with archery, and I got introduced
to the concept of bow hunting for deer,which was much easier to get a tag.
Right. So. So the reason I started bow hunting wasI had never gun hunted up to that point.
(07:31):
But there was a lot of areas that had public groundthat you could bow hunt.
Only where I grew up, outside of Chicago, Illinois,they didn't allow gun hunting, just buying.
So I'm like, well, this is perfect for me.
I can I can learn a new sport that's pursuing big game,which I thought was the sport of kings and still believe that.
And I started and I didn't really know what I was doing.
(07:51):
So I did a lot of readingand I didn't really have any mentors at the time.
So I just started figuring it out with another friend of mine.
So that's how I got started in bow planning, and I've pursued itmy whole life from from that kind of from that starting point.
So you're you're neveryou never started, like, with a rifle and then graduated to the bow.
You just started straight up.
(08:12):
Bow was the first type of hunting you started.
I did, and that's a little unusual mill based on all the friendsthat I now know, that bow and a lot of them started,
in different ways, mainly started gun hunting,and then wanted more of a challenge and bonding.
But I started bonding because it was theit was the only opportunity that I had.
And, and, and it was very accessible, right.
(08:33):
In many state, in many areas in the United States,both seasons starts way earlier than rifle season.
It's three and some cases four months long,whereas rifle season or even, primitive weapon season is very short.
So it opened up a lot of opportunity over with longer seasons
and created a great challenge.
(08:55):
Right. Because bow hunting is certainly very challenging,particularly with the, the,
the equipment that we had 35 years ago when I started up.
But I, but I, but I fell in love with itand since then I've done more gun hunting and so on.
But I've shot and harvested many more animals with a bow than a gun.
What is for youthe main difference between bow hunting and hunting with a rifle?
(09:18):
If I was to boil it down to 2 or 2 a word, it was it's intimacy,
meaning the ability to be very intimate with the animalbecause they're very close.
The requirement to get very intimate about your knowledgeof their movements, where they bed, where they feed.
You know, you have to really study the movements of the animals to putyourself in position between where they are and where they're going.
(09:44):
Whereas with a rifle, you can sit on an opposite hillside and knowa general area that's good for for deer or elk or whatever it may be.
And see animals in a distance and today shoot them at 600 yards.
So that has its own challenge and own fulfillment.
I'm not knocking that, but I love the intimacy of bow on.
It is there is there going like a, a little bit of a rivalry betweenthe bow hunters and and rifle hunters?
(10:11):
It's a it's an interesting question. I would say,
there is a bit, but,
rifle hunters know they have a tremendous advantage, right?
But their seasons are typically late in the season.
After the rut in most states is when you can gun hunt.
So the rifle hunters are sometimes they're a little bit,
(10:32):
miffed that the archery guys get to hunt during the peak of of themating season of the rut, which is when the animals are most vulnerable.
So there's a little bit of that,but bow hunters have the added challenge. So.
So in my years of exercise,I've never run into, like, a real rift between gun and bow.
The at least in the circles I travel,I know it exists, but I haven't haven't really run into that.
(10:56):
I respect rifle hunters.
And I feel like they they respect what what I do as a bow hunter.
But I have heard stories of of of friction there, for sure,but I don't really see a need for it.
We're all there to enjoy the same thing. We just do it in our own way.
Yeah.
And I and I think that also kind of like, is, separation of seasons is,
(11:18):
you know, helping that deer because I presume it wouldn't workif the season like, is it, maybe that's a question.
Is there situations that you can hunt the animalsboth with the rifle or with the bow?
There is in most in most states in the US,
you can legally hut deer during gun season with the bow.
(11:42):
Okay. Provided you're following all the regulations of a gun hunter.
So if they require blaze orange, you have to be wearing blaze orange.
If they require an extra tag, you have to have that extra tag.
But you can legally Beaumont during gun season.
Now that has has its obvious disadvantages however.
But if you're on private ground that you have exclusive rights to huntand there's guys gun hunting all around
(12:06):
and you want to have it harvest an animal with a bow,
that's actually not a bad time, because there are a lot of timesmoving those animals onto your property.
Hahaha. Not that's true, that's true.
So yeah, I've done, I've done,I've done some of that and it can be effective.
Okay, okay. Yeah.
I was just thinking about, you know, the safety measuresbecause you need to get so much closer to the animal.
(12:28):
And, you know, I can I can almost imagine you're just, you know, trying,to take a shot at the animal and then someone 200 yards, boom.
Just happens.
It's it's sits the other. Well, it can happen. And you mentioned safety.
That's paramount. Like when you're bow hunting during gun season,you have to, be very aware.
(12:48):
And yet in most states, you're.
I would always wear blaze orange during gun season. Full stop,whether it's required or not. Absolutely.
Because of that safety reason. Yeah, yeah.
Before we, jump into ita little bit further into the details of bow hunting,
I got to askyou also about crossbow so that it that counts as a archery equipment.
(13:10):
Yes. And yeah, the probably you can elaboratenow whether there's a separate season for
for, crossbow probably depends on the state.
Or is it, like archery equipment is all encompassing?
You know, so if youif you could give us a little bit of the, insight on this,
(13:32):
keeping in mind that, you know, most of the listeners of this podcastnever hunted with a bow and never hunted with a crossbow
and might not even be fully aware ofwhat are the differences, in effectiveness and so on.
Okay, great. Well, it's a really interesting question.And that is a hot button in many, in many circles.
But just to boil it down, when you're shooting a bow,whether it's your traditional recurve or long bow
(13:56):
where you don't have a sight on it and a release, or you're shootinga compound bow, which often has a sight and a release.
So it's a little bit easier to be accurate at a distance.
You still have limitations relative to theyou still have to draw the bow back, hold it back,
keep it on target, and make a clean release,with an on magnified, sight pin.
(14:18):
If you're cutting with a compound bow.
So there are limits to, you know, the range and accuracy and so on.
With a crossbow, the primary distinction is it's more like a rifle,in that once you pocket and put the bolt in, it stays cocked.
And the arrow, which is called a bolt,the bolt in a crossbow is much smaller.
(14:39):
It's shorter and heavy,so it travels extremely fast and flies extremely, flat.
So you can you're much more accurate out to 70, 80 yards with a crossbowthan you would ever be with a compound.
And when you get the animal in close,you don't have to draw back the crossbow.
It's already cocked like a rifle. So you just point and shoot.
(15:01):
Then you can put a scope on a crossbow.
So it's a crossbow.
Is has, I think, more similarities to a rifle than it does a bow,
relative to the advantagesyou obtain by always having it cocked and ready to shoot.
It has a safety on it, and you can put a scope on it.
The similarities are they both use a a banded,you know, abandoned bow limb to propel the arrow.
(15:26):
That's about the only similarities.
So I'll just stop there from a just the different standpoint.Does that make sense.
Yeah. Yeah, absolutely.
And and obviously because of thatalso the range you can shoot an animal is way
longer or higher or you can, you can should an animalfor the greater distance or the crossbow I presume
you, you can I mean, obviously there's people out there that can shoota compound bow very accurately, particularly out west where you're.
(15:52):
We're hunting big country longer distances.
They'll shoot maybe even out to 40, 50, even 60 yards,which is really long with a bow, but with a crossbow.
But that takes a high degree of skill. Yeah. Someone.Someone who has never shot a crossbow.
I've ever shot a crossbow in your life. You know I did not.
If you've picked if you picked up a crossbow today.
(16:14):
If I handed you, handed you one that was sighted
and you went to shoot it, you could shoot itvery accurately out to 70, 80 yards and your very first try.
So imagine that it takes away more practice and expertiseto accurately shoot a bow out to say, 60 yards than with a crossbow.
Who you could just pick it up and shoot it,which gives a lot of people confidence to take a lot longer shots.
(16:35):
Maybe then they're capable, different, different story.
But that's the that's the difference primarily, is it?
Then causing the again, tension between the like a classical,let's call them bow hunters and and crossbow
because it's like okay, we have this season for bow huntingand it requires skill and all those things and all that.
(16:56):
Then, you know, someone shows up, like I said, with a crossbow,first time in their hands, and they have all that,
you know, advantages, let's say, of the early archery seasonand so on, that, that you're absolutely right.
There is there is tension and friction there. And it really gets down to
(17:17):
the, the advantages of the equipment that you, that you reference.
In other words,
people who bohot at least speaking for myself, I chose to bow becauseI love the challenge and the intimacy of getting closer to the deer.
And part of the challenge is the requirement to really practiceshooting your bow and really get good at.
And I shot traditional.
I shot recurve for the first 25, 30 years of of my hunting.
(17:41):
So so so I really,
actually I started with a compound bowshot, a few deer with it, and I'm like, I want something else.
And then I went to recurve and hunted with a recurve traditional bowfor about 30 years.
I think. And, it was by choice.
But it's because I enjoyed the challenge and the intimacyand the the requirement to practice and so on.
(18:02):
And so most folks that bow hunt feel like bow hunting with the longerseasons should be limited to, more, you know, Archer traditional archery
equipment, because you're giving a lot, you know, a longer opportunityto hunt because you have a more a bigger challenge with the equipment.
Once you enter crossbows into that equation, right?
(18:22):
There is some friction because it's like, look,
we're having someone who's hunting with a crossbow has the advantageof a rifle hunting in a, a traditional equipment season.
And that's really where the friction is.
What I can say is in the United States and I don't know the exactnumbers, I haven't studied the numbers, but there are a lot of states
(18:42):
where archery in in archery season, you can only hunt with a compound,
or a traditional bow, like a longbow or recurvecrossbows are not allowed.
The only time they would be allowed is if you had a disabilityand you applied for a permit, and you got granted a permit
based on some kind of a doctor's, you know, disability note,and it has to be approved by the state.
(19:05):
So, so they're, they're they're not allowed in Boces.
They are allowed in what's called I think it's called,there's a primitive weapon season in a lot of states,
which is primarily, muzzle loaders and oftentimescrossbows are allowed in muzzleloader season.
Oh, because they're actually more akin to that if you thinkabout the effective range of a muzzleloader being, let's say,
(19:27):
I should say a traditional muzzleloader, out to about 100 yards.
Well, the, you know, that's kind of with a crossbow. You're,you're good out to nearly there.
So in other states, for example, Ohio or Kansas,crossbows are allowed in bow season as a traditional weapon.
And there is some friction there because of what I mentioned earlier.
(19:49):
It's like, hey, you're you're coming in and you're not having it.
You're not being held at the same standard of scoutingand getting close to the animal and practicing and so on and so forth.
You can come in and shoot a deer at 50, 60 yardswith a crossbow, fairly easily.
And so that's the distinction. And there is some friction there.
And it's state by state.
It's been a battle between the traditional archersand the guys that oftentimes the manufacturers that want it
(20:16):
legalized in the state, because they're going to sella lot more crossbows if it's legal during bow season.
You know, the economics of that.
So of course, that's where the tensionthat's where the tension is. Yeah.
Oh okay. Thanks for for laying that out for us, Jim.
And you mentioned like an interesting thing that I, that I want one moreand that is kind of like a equipment, front.
And this is something we mentioned briefly before we started recordingthis podcast, is that there is a traditional equipment,
(20:42):
scale required, traditional bow, compound bow.
But then when you look at the compoundbow, well, it's nothing but traditional.
You have, you know, space age materials and you have a proceed precisionmachining and 3D printing and all that technology.
I would argue that even if I go and buy a new rifle, like a tick,or whatever, new rifle, decent rifle, it's actually technologically
(21:12):
very old and obsolete compared to when I go and buy a new compound bow,which is all the latest it is.
So I'm curious, like what's your what's your view? What's your comments?
Maybe on this because this is, this is one of the things that I oftenhear like, oh, this is like traditional, like, not traditional at all.
Yes. It's having shot both compounds and,
(21:37):
traditional recurve and shot animals with both.
I have mixed feelings on itwith respect to a, a traditional bow recurve longbow.
When you pull a 65 pound bow back, you're holding 65 pounds,so you can't hold it for long, right?
You got to pull back and shoot, and you're shooting instinctively,meaning no sights,
(21:58):
when you are with a compound. Of course.
We talked about the advantage of being youpull it back and there's a release.
So if you're pulling back 65,maybe you're only holding 3035 at full draw so you can hold for longer.
Let the animal get closeand then you have a oftentimes a trigger release so you can hold it.
And when you release you're not,you know, relying on your fingers doing the work.
You're just pulling a trigger.So you get a good clean release more frequently.
(22:21):
So those advances are normal and have, you know, evolved.
And yet on the one hand,
you know, I'm in favor of anything that helpspeople make a clean, humane kill shot.
Like, to me, that's the most important thing, respecting the animaland making a good, clean, humane shot.
And so things like sight pins and releases on a compound bow
(22:45):
enable the average hunter to more accurately placea shot on an animal and have a humane kill.
So there.
So having said that, when you start getting to advancements like,
both sites that have, magnification or bow sitesthat have lighted pins and magnify,
(23:05):
and the ability to turn a dial to adjust to, you know, 27 yardsor 36 yards or both sites that have integrated rangefinders in them.
Yeah, I heard that.
That's the that's the latest, right,with the bow bow site with the range finder. Okay.
So there you go.
So so then then you say, well wow,those really make it much easier for someone
(23:27):
to effectively range an animal, dial in their sightand make a clean shot at further distances.
Jim, how do you feel about that?
Well, again, I just said anything that helps an archermake a clean, humane shot more consistently is a good thing.
But and those elementsI just discuss those advancements certainly do that.
(23:49):
Right? Yeah.
But at what point does the advancement in technologystart to reduce the level of challenge that's required to Beaumont,
and bring in a lot of folks into the sport that just want to have it.
They just want to hunt deer more frequently and make it easy. You bet.
And by the way,you can make the same argument about the crossbow, right?
It's absolutely it makes you, you know, more more proficient,and it makes you, you know, more likely to have a quick
(24:17):
and humane kill in the animal. So it's a it's interesting.
Let me just a quick story on thatbecause I have some experience with that.
I had never shot a crossbow until last year.
And last spring I was involved in a, in a hunting accident where I got,I got, shot during Turkey season in my right side of my face,
and it put my right I am. Yeah. Oh, geez.
(24:39):
Yeah. Yeah.
Happens.
It's a really unfortunate, but but the point is,
they were able to restore some vision to my right eye,but not to the point where I had any level of acuity.
You know, out of. It'smore like looking through a bottom of a Coke bottle.
So, I'm coming up to both season,and I don't have the time to learn how to shoot left handed.
Right. And I don't want to miss both seasons.One of my greatest passions in life.
(25:02):
And I'm really conflicted.
I'm like lawmakers. And we were going to Kansas. I'm like,am I just going to go to Kansas?
And help with my brother in law?Just hang out with him? Or am I going to hunt? But I can't both.
I can't shoot righty.
But I can't learn the left handedand be accurate enough in the next six weeks.
So I'm in that conundrum.
How do I get accurate and make a good, humane, clean kill?
(25:24):
And so I ended up borrowing a crossbow.
Now, borrowing a weapon goes against my grain,but generally for hunting, right?
Like you got to get a, you know, you got to get a weapon,you got to get proficient at it.
But I felt like if I could be proficient at it and limit my range,I could still enjoy the, you know, enjoy my Beaumont.
(25:46):
Right.
So I went to Kansas, had had a had a barrel bow.
I shot it a couple of days beforehand.
And when I shot at righty, it was iffy because of my vision.
So I had to shoot it lefty because my left eye is was is better.
And I got to where I could just naila target at 30 yards with a crossbow.
Like I'm talking like this in two days.
(26:09):
I maybe shot 30 arrows, 30 bolts, and I am just absolutely knocking the,you know, the center out of the target.
So I'm like, I'm comfortable.
You know, Archer and I shot it out to 50.
I'm like, I'm comfortable out to 50.
But I'm I've never shot a deer with my bowin all the years over 25 yards
in all the deer I shot, probably 45, 50 deernever shot one over 25 years because I like to get them in close.
(26:32):
So the moral of the story is I go out hunting and, we're three daysinto the hunt and I have an opportunity to shoot a really nice buck,
and I can't get many closer than 50 yards,
and he's out in the middle of a field and it's in the wide open.
He's with a doe. He's very. He's distracted. It's the perfect situation.I can't get him any closer.
(26:53):
I've tried. I've rattled.
He's not getting any closer. He's going to move off.
And I ranged him and he was 50
and I shot him left handed offand at no rest. Just left handed, 50 yards.
Shot him right in the heart. He went 50 yards and died.
And and I was shot.
But I felt so confident making that shotbecause when I put that that weapon on him
(27:17):
and it was a scoped crossbow for I think it was a two power scope,maybe, I put it right on his breadbasket.
I pulled the trigger. I just knew I was going to make a clean shot.
So I didn't violate any any of my, you know, ethos,if you will, that way.
But after that hunt, I was reflecting on the fact that.
How easy was that for me to have never shot a crossbowand then just picked it up a few days before, and I went out
(27:42):
during both season, and I shot a deer that I would not have shot with mywith my normal equipment, and I shot him at 50 yards.
Yes, I made a good clean kill,
but it it what it did was it it actually emphasized the primary beefI have with allowing crossbows during both season.
And I did it and I did it legally and it enabled me to hunt.And because I had this disability. Right.
(28:04):
And I and I enjoyed it for all that it was,but it really highlights the advantage of a crossbow.
That's a great story, Jim. That's athat's a great story. Congratulations on the book.
Yeah, it was interesting.
I never in my life thought I'd shoot a deer with a crossbow ever.
Yeah, and I did, and I, I took nothing away from the animal.
(28:26):
I love the experience. I enjoyed it,but it really gave me a lot to reflect on, honestly.
Yeah, yeah, yeah for sure, for sure. And that's a, that's athat's a great story.
And you know, like sometimes things are happening in lifethat made you try things that you would,
you will never try and then you enjoy it or at least have it like a,you know, some thoughts about it, like you did.
(28:51):
Jim. So I think you it's a great moment now to kind of like a transitionto another part of this conversation.
You mentioned the word humane there quite a few times.
Yes. And obviously, well, obvious to me, maybe to other people as well.
This is one of the biggest,
arguments of the opponents of bow hunting.
(29:14):
And, you know, even on this podcast,I spoke with, few bow hunters, but I also spoke with veterinarians and,
even accomplished hunters, rifle hunters who were expressing their,
you know, various level of disapproval for bow hunting based on the,
(29:36):
how humane that their shot is.
And it seems to me like the the most common argument is that the,
arrow is lacking the concussive power that they can concussive,affect on the, on the animal where you have the, the,
effect where the water in the eye,it says a name that is eluding me right now, which, which has a,
(30:01):
the basically is the all the water in the body ofthe animal is disturbed and creates like a wave.
It's, it's it's called hydro electric shock or something like that.
So it doesn't have a concussive barrier. Therefore it is less humane.
And I, you know, I think and thisthat was also confirmed by many people who said like, well, why?
(30:23):
Why, you know, why is
causing that concussion to the animal.
How can you come to the conclusion that this is somehow more humane?
If you can shoot an animal that and we know those stars.
You shoot an animal, an animal.
Just look what happenedand then comes back to grazing and then falls over.
(30:44):
They didn't even know what hit him.
But then the argument is like, yeah,but how many shots like that really happens?
It's one every now and thenand then again, fundamentally it's an issue, mate. So
once again, I would ask you to once again on this podcast,unpack this argument and how, how you feel about it.
(31:08):
How does that, said in your opinion, it's a great question.
It has some complexities and nuance to it,but it's a great question. And so
I'm no,
doctor or surgeon. Right.
But what I do know is that, having studied it is that,
(31:28):
an arrow kills through hemorrhage,
right?
Like blood loss or lungs, you know, for blood,
you know, it's just killed by hammered, whereas a bullet kills by shock,concussive power and damage to the material.
Whatever it hits, right.
And so I can only speak through that.
I'll only speak through experience here.
And that is to say, I've shot, you know, quite a few deer with my bow,
(31:50):
and I've shot a fair number of deerwith both a rifle and black powder and a shotgun slug.
And I will say that,
during all the years of bow hunting,I may have lost 2 or 3 deer that I hit, that I didn't recover
in all the years of bow hunting.
Right? 35 years.
(32:11):
So. Well, why?
Hey, wait a minute.
That seems like.
Well, it is low, but it's because,
of the commitment to practice and be proficient
and make sure the animal is close enough to make a clean shot.
And having the discipline to pass up anything that doesn't pass thatlitmus test of, I'm going to make a clean shot on this animal, right?
(32:34):
So I've had to pass upsome really nice animals at 35, 40 yards with my recurve.
I just not going to shoot them. Right.
Because I thought I probably would have voted themand I probably would have at that distance with a recurve.
So the animals that I've shot with my bow,I would say ballpark 80% of them after I hit them in some cases.
(32:56):
Well, they died within a hundred yardsthere. Went through them all the way, all the way through them.
And then they ran off. And I typically would see them fallor hear them fall within 100 yards, in some cases less,
because when you double lung
an animal with a arrow and it goes all the way through them like yousaid, they just they flinch,
especially if you don't hit a rib.
(33:18):
And I've had them go back to grazing and tip over in eight seconds.
If you hit a rib with your arrowand they feel that, you know, they'll they'll run for a while,
but they'll often stop after 30 or 40 yardsand then that blood flow to their brain ceases
because you let the air out of their lungsand they die in less than 10s, like literally 7 or 8 seconds.
(33:39):
And if you look at them on film, that's about how long it takes
with a rifle, unless you shoot them right in the head or in the,you know, or in the, you know, even in the spine.
Right?
The animals I've shot with a rifle have,some of them that have tipped over right where I shot them.
But oftentimes you hit them and they run even if they're hit.
Well, because what kills them is that shockand ultimately that blood loss. But,
(34:04):
I would say that
I don't have any evidence, personal evidencethat would suggest that that killing with a rifle
is more humane than taking an animal with a bow,because that just hasn't been my experience.
And when an animal is shot with a bow, oftentimesit's not that concussive bang,
you know, that hits themand that bullet expands and explodes inside them.
(34:28):
It just goes throughit must it feels like a, you know, fly prick sometimes, right?
Because they don't get spooked and all wild eyed and run off.
They'll run off 30, 40, 50 yards and stop and then fall over. So
any I know that it's a big topic out there,but in my experience that just hasn't been the case.
If you apply the discipline to make a clean shotand don't take those marginal shots.
(34:50):
And that's where the problem is, guys pushing that envelopeand they wound a lot more deer and that is a problem.
I'm just calling that out.
Yeah.
No. And and the and you're right because this is like athe next argument that follows closely by right.
And just to finish off on the on the concussive power versus versusjust, just, you know, sharp arrows cutting through the animal eye,
(35:14):
you know, like, I feel like if I, if I were a deer and I had to choose,I would, I would always choose to be shot by the bow
and by the arrow because they, I don't I justI don't see the argument of the concussive power making it more humane.
If the time it takes is roughlythe same, you're actually saving the animal
(35:35):
this extra concussive power and the, you know, sound of the gunshotand all these things.
So but that's that's just my my comment on it.
So let's talk about the difficulty because like you said,this is another argument that comes next that,
oh the guys are pushing the envelope.
They're they're taking the shots that they have no business taking.
(35:59):
My view on this is that, well, there are people who are taking shotswith the rifle that they have no business taking.
Yes. So,
that argument actually doesn't cut to me too much about,you know, who am I?
I live in a country that prohibits bow hunting. I never bow hunt.
So that's whatI have you on the podcast to talk about these, these things.
(36:20):
But the argument then is that because of such a high degree of skillrequired,
bow hunters are putting a lot of effort into training,into honing their skill, into shooting arrows.
Then, compared to the rifle hunterswho I know, people who are just, you know,
(36:41):
they they they never own the range, they just shooting on the animalsbecause it's so easy, you just putting in a crosshair and bang.
And then when they miss they go on the range, do zero of the skullbecause, oh, I'm just I just missed just missed this dog.
And so then the level of training, you know, there's so inmy head is like,
(37:03):
you are equally likely to take a shot that you shouldn't be able toyou shouldn't be taking if you're, you know, this kind of person.
But the bow hunter, by definition, at least,should be way more skilled and trained because of a difficulty of it.
Now, this is my, you know, borrowed opinions and what I think.
(37:26):
I want to hear your opinion is, is there any truth to that?
Is there are there any caveats to that?
What I said, I think it's a it's a fair
it's a fair observation from, from your perspective in that,
knowing, you know, over the years, hundreds of bowhunters and many, many gun hunters,
(37:48):
most of the bow hunters I know, Tommy,are, are very committed to the sport, right?
Because, you know, they enjoy archery, they shoot 3D shoots,you know, that that they,
around the area that they live in, the three dimensional targetswhere they're set up at different ranges to test their skill,
you know, estimate ranges and shoot and score.
(38:09):
And they're out here out west where I live in Oregon.
Now, there's they they train physically cardiobecause there's big hills, right? Big mountains out here.
And so they know they're going to have to be physically fitand to be able to execute a shot.
So they're very committed, to the sport.
And therefore they really work on their proficiency with their weapon.
(38:31):
I know many gun hunters that are also very committed to shooting
accurately and go to the range and would never go hunting with a riflewithout shooting in before setting in beforehand.
But I know probably an equal or greater numberthat fall into the category you describe, which is like, oh, it's,
you know, you've been to the range this year.Oh no, my, my, my rifle was cited in last year.
(38:53):
I killed a nice bike with it. I'm good to go.
Well, really, you know what I mean. Yeah. You've pointed that out.
And so they go out in a mess and I've had guys go, oh go to the range.
And it's, you know, up, up a foot offand they miss or worse wound an animal
because they didn't feelthey needed to take the time because of the proficiency of a firearm.
So I think what you characterized is reasonably true.
(39:15):
But but with any sport, especially blood sportsthat we're talking about here, just to be, you know, candid,
there are folks that
that endeavor to do it correctlyand are really respectful about the animal and the sport and so on.
And there are some smaller proportion that want to take the easyroute, are willing to chance a long shot at an animal
(39:35):
even if they wounded in the event that they might take it,you know, doing things that they shouldn't do.
And I think that that exists in any sport.
But when you're talking about shooting animals,I think it's, it's really unfortunate that that can be the case.
And the easier you make it, the in my opinion,the more it invites casual, less committed folks.
(39:58):
And that gets right back to the conversation we had on crossbows.
And anything that makes it easy
invites more people not willing to necessarilyput the time in to say, oh, if it's that easy, I'll give it a try.
And that to me is is it?
That rubs me the wrong way.
Yeah. They're more focus on the outcomerather than on the process. Nailed it.
You just nailed it. That's right.What about the wounding rates? Wounding rates are higher with a bolt.
(40:22):
I think there is no no questions about it. Or are they.
Well, it's all about shot placement right. And so
the opportunity to wound an animal with a bow is definitely therebecause just the angle of the animal.
Right.
Like if it's dead broadside and you shoot it right in the,you know, right behind the front, like you'll take out both lungs.
(40:45):
But if that animal's quartering to you even slightly 15 degrees,same shot, you might hit one lung and miss the second one, right?
That animal or one lung hit animal can run hundreds of yards. Right.
And so you can run them
and but but most are fatally wounded, right.
(41:08):
Like most are fatally wounded.
So that's where skills of tracking, understanding animal behavior,where they where they typically go
and their behavior after they're mortally wounded is really important.
And, you know, I take tremendous pride on my ability to track animals.
And I don't give up. I've tracked them for days,
(41:28):
and hours on my hands and kneesand have a very, very high recovery rate.
As a consequence, I don't give up if I don't see specks of bloodlike I'm following tracks turned over leaves.
I'm following directionally where I believe they're going to go.I understand my property.
I know where they would likely to goif they were one London. They were hit and they're going to go downhill.
They're going to go toward waterand they're going to go and take cover. And I look there.
(41:50):
So if you really work at it, youyou can recover a high, high percentage of any wounded animals.
And when they're not fatally wounded with a bow.
Right. It's just like a clean slice. They often recover
like they often do.
I've killed many, not many.
I've killed a handful of of deer that had a broad head in their hip,and they were fine, right.
(42:14):
Or they had a scar, but they were fine. So,
there is a, an opportunity to own an animalno matter the weapon you use.
But as a bow hunter, I'mvery committed to because they die by hemorrhage.
You follow blood, right?
And, you can recover most animals if they're fatally hit, without doubt.
(42:38):
So I'll just. I'll just leave it there.
That's one of the reasons we talked about advancements in technologyearlier,
you know, where do they make sense and wherewhere do they maybe go against the rules of fair chase, lighted knocks,
you know that as it's lighted, knock on the back of an arrow,it lights up when you shoot it.
Yeah, I know, but you can explain to to the listeners.
But yeah, the knock is the is the end of the arrowthat attaches to your string, and it's made out of plastic.
(43:01):
And today they offer those that that light up when you shoot them.
They light up like with a little LED light,like light green or light pink.
So when you release the arrow you can see it fly and see it hit.
And and I
believe that's a good advancement in technologybecause the greater knowledge you have on where the arrow hit
hit the animal, the better odds are you're going to recover itbecause you're going to know where you hit.
(43:26):
That's a good thing.
When you have I for years shot broad headsthat were traditional broad heads, like the old bear broadhead
where you were, you actually,it was like a razor, but you had to sharpen it yourself.
So I'd sit there in front of the TV and sharpen it myself for hoursso I could cut air off.
My whole arm would be bald because I use that as a test.My left arm would be just completely bald.
(43:48):
Get it?
Going into Boston because I was testing it, right? And like, yeah,if I can shave hair off my arm, it's it's good.
It's it's it's right.
But what I found
is I tried one year the new mechanical broadhead,which fundamentally I was against.
Right. It's like, you know, it's another technological gimmick. Right.
(44:09):
But I tried and tested the mechanical broadhead,
with a 1.5in cutting radius.
And the very first year I shot with one,I shot him, you know, through both lungs.
And the blood trail was amazing.I mean it because of the cutting radius.
If you kill by hemorrhage, the more cutting, the better.
So my point is I'm in, I believe mechanical broadhead
(44:33):
are beneficial to the animal because of the larger cut radius.
Quicker kills, easier recovery because the blood trailis much more substantial for people who are listening to this.
The mechanical broadhead is the brow side.
Like thethe blades of the broadhead opens on the contact with the animal. Yes.
So that that improves the flight of the arrow,I guess because it's, it's it doesn't have the broadhead
(44:58):
with the, with the blades on it cracked open.
And then because of that it can open too much, like I said,larger extend larger blades basically, which makes a bigger cuts.
So so exactly.
You explain it perfectly.
So the arrow is much more likely to hit where you're aiming it,meaning a good clean kill.
And when it hits and those blades open up, it makes a very largecutting radius, which then leads to a very, very good blood trail.
(45:26):
And that's what you want.You want to recover the animals you you hit, right. That's the key.
So those advancements in technology help recovery of animals,which I'm in favor of absolutely makes sense to me.
Makes sense.
And and look, we, we people who are more interested in their, you know,details of technical leaders of all the elements of the bow and arrow.
(45:49):
We have an episode,
on the podcast also, it's called,
I think, Sizzling Arrows, where we go into greatdepth on all the types of arrows and things like that.
So I'm just not one.
I don't want to go into technicals on it.
Because we have way more interesting things here to cover.
Oh, one other things that you mentioned that I also heard earlieris that the wounded animals, the animals wounded with a with a
(46:16):
as a result of the, of a inaccurate bow shot are more likely to recoverwhile the animals that are, that are, wounded by a gunshot
that's usually dead animal only it can take weeks or,you know, long time.
So that's that's you're you kind of confirmed that, as Mark.
(46:39):
Okay.
So I just want to switch gearshere, a little bit and talking about how long
in, on average, how long it
takes a person to practice with a bow before they get proficient.
In enough to be able to go and execute a shot at the animal,having in mind that
(47:07):
executing shot at the animal is quite a different dealthan executing, show that the range,
because of the emotions and the buck fever and all those things.
So I'm going with this thing here, you know, likeif anyone wants to try and, you know, maybe even the question is like,
if people like myself or other who live in Ireland, in the UK,they want to go hunting, they want to go bow hunting,
(47:36):
and they, they can go to Spain or to France or to Hungary,whatever that place in Europe, or maybe even fly to the US
to do this, you know, bow hunting experience.
But they need to prepare.
They cannot just, you know, how long it takes to become proficient.
(47:56):
And what would be your advice to person,
you know, like, again, who lives in Europeand wants to prepare themselves for that sort of experience?
It starts with what equipment we're using.
So I'm going to start with the most common, which is a compound bow.
And when I say a compound bow, I'm going to assume that there's aa sight,
(48:17):
a set of sight pins on the, on the bow bow side and a release,because that's the most common setup you see today.
Okay.
So my son is a good example because he just took up archery this year.
We got him a bow,
set up the way I just described.
And he became
(48:37):
pretty proficient at the range in a matter of, let's say four weeks,
five weeks. Now he's going three, four times a week.
You know, he goes to the range, he's shooting a 20 yardsand he's extending out to 30.
But he's really focused on just focus on your form.
You know meaning you release nice and smooth, no jerky.
(48:58):
You know, just nice and smooth. Focus on the fundamentals.
And, you know, in in 4 to 6 weeks.
And when he last he came up here,he was shooting a very tight group at 30 yards.
Meaning I take when I see a tiger,I'm talking about less than three inches. Okay. Like that bit.
So that's good. That's pretty impressive.
And now the question is becomes, well, is he proficient enough to hunt?
(49:19):
And at that point, no.
And however he's proficient enough to shoot accurately at a range then.
So that's let's call that six weeks. I think that's reasonable.
You know, a couple days a week, three days a week for six weeks.
You can be pretty proficient with it,should be expressive with the hours on the range. Right.
Because like six weeks ago.Yeah. About three times a week for six weeks.
(49:42):
Yeah.
I mean literally I mean if you shoot 2 or 3 times a week,but you're shooting about, you know, 75 arrows at a time, right.
And you do that over a period of six weeks. The equipment is so goodthese days.
You can get proficient at the range. Okay.
So in terms of elapsed time, I don't know how many hours that is,but it's not an inordinate amount of hours.
Right. It's reasonable.
(50:04):
The next step before you would ever go
hunting is you need to go out and shoot3D targets, different angles at unknown distances.
That's the next step.
So. Right.
Because when you know I'm shooting
20 yards, 30 yards, 40 yards, even if you're shooting deer targetsat an archery range, everything is controlled.
Everything.
You know, the distance,the next step is to go shoot a 3D range where you're shooting
(50:27):
at three dimensional targets of of deer or wild boar or elk or whateverthey have as the targets.
And you're shooting at different distances.
So you might be shooting at 18 yards, 27 yards, 36 yards,whatever it is. And,
you have to determine, do you want to use a rangefinderor do you want to estimate sight without a range fighter?
(50:48):
For all my years of hunting, I justI was able to estimate yardages without that.
But, but I would recommend having a range finder to knowif there's nothing wrong with that, because, again, good clean kill.
So if you spend another, let's say 4 to 6 weeks elapsed timeor whatever time you can spend,
shooting three
dimensional targets, unknown ranges at more realistic angleslike you would in the field.
(51:13):
That's the next step.
So let's call that another four weeks or so.
Transferhow much time you can at most of us work, so you can't do it every day.
And then the last step
would be to make sure that those last few practice sessions, shootingthree dimensional targets, either in your yard or at a range,
you're wearing the clothes you're going to hunt with, you'rewearing gloves, everything, face mask or whatever you're going to wear
(51:40):
hunting you're wearing on the range and you're shootingyour actual broadhead, and you do that for a couple of weeks.
Those are the phases.So if you think about that, you say, you know what?
In, you know, in 4 or 5 months over the period of a spring summer,could you be starting from zero?
Could you pre-prepared and equipped, if you put that time in
(52:02):
to go hunting confidently and make a humane kill on a big gameanimal with a bow, I would say that's reasonable.
Oh, and then might I might say that that was,
that was shorter period of time that I thought.
But again, it's very compressed effortbecause it's like a concert stunt going, going, going.
(52:22):
But so in other words, like if you're if someone would like to go,
for, you know, bow hunting experience trip, next yearif they start today,
then by that time next year, they should be more than able to goand execute humane shot at the animal.
That's correct.
(52:43):
And, and, you know, as a nonresident,I believe you can apply for, deer permits in the United States.
Yeah. I mean, like,you know, it's it's one of those things if you want, you can do it.
It's it's just, I think very unfortunate that that we can't do itwhere we live.
You know, like,I came into hunt and regular listeners of this podcast know this story.
(53:05):
I said it many times that, you know,I came to hunting very late in my life.
I was in that early 40s, late, late 30s, for sure, less than a decade.
And I was an angler.
And I wanted bow hunting,you know, obviously American church shows and the TV's like, oh, I gonna
I feel like I'm ready to graduate to hunting from fishing.
(53:25):
And I want to go bow hunting because it was like,so natural and like, more like a fishing rod.
You know, you have a good bendy and, element and then you have a lineand all these things and they're like, no illegal.
And I didn't even want to go into the whole effort of getting, like,a firearm permit and all those things.
(53:46):
And it turns out like, no, I have no choice. I had to do this.
But this bow hunting thing other than, you know, talking about itand educating people through the podcast,
it is in the back of my head.
I would definitely like to, like to try it,
to wrap this up, Jim,what would be like a foolproof advice for you, arguments
(54:10):
for people who are looking favorably at bow huntingand they find themselves,
any in the, companion of other hunters, rifle hunterswho are, you know, usually don't have any experience with bow hunting.
And discussion starts about like, oh, you know, this is inhumane.
(54:33):
And should they what would be your like, a foolproof advice
how to conduct that conversation and,and give the give the fair representation of bow hunting.
It's an interesting question. I've never been asked that question.
And I would say that
Isabel Hunter, if I was in the company of, ofof of a lot of gun hunters and they were, they were,
(54:55):
you know, challenging the humaneness of my sport.
Right. Is that what you're suggesting? Right. Yeah.
My response would be that no matter the weapon you choose to use,there are certain standards
that that you have to and certain level of of skills and commitmentyou have to put forth to ensure a humane kill,
(55:17):
whether it's a rifle or a bow or a crossbow or a muzzleloader,there is a certain level of of of commitment
you have to make to become proficient and then discipline,you have to apply on what shot you will and will take.
And what I can say for myself and other bow hunters that I knowthat are as committed as I am, is that we make quick, humane kills
(55:42):
at a high, high rate 95 plus percent of the time.
Right?
And another state I would say isI've only missed 2 or 3 deer in my entire life.
Missed it completely because I just don't take long shots.
It's only 25 yards. I'm not going to miss a deer at 25 yards.
The ones that I did miss went down a hill and went shot over the back.
(56:05):
So I don't miss many.I know a lot of rifle hunters that have missed a lot of deer. Why?
Because they're taking shots that they shouldn'ttake, running animals, distances that they shouldn't.
They're just taking a pot shot. Right.
So my sport is any not any more, more or less humane than your method.
If we apply the same level of commitment to knowing our weapon andunderstanding its limits and being disciplined about what shot we take.
(56:31):
So let's let's go grab a beer.
That would be my response.
It's a great response.
And, you know, like this is like so many things that for example,some hunters in Europe, like in Germany and France,
they they think like, oh, bow hunting is inhumane.But then they, they should go running animals.
It's like a how that is humane.
Like if bow running is inhumaneand you're just shooting like a running deer and they're running right.
(56:54):
But that's, that's a, completely separate, conversation.
And I just want to, end up with, with a story this yearin, in, in May was
it was in an AprilI was on the, on the symposium and the like a CIC event
and I was talking with the, with the old hunter from Liechtensteinand we started and there was also people from the US and the and the,
(57:20):
not a hunter, but the guy who
is, really involved in conservation from the US was sitting at the tablewith us and the topic, got into the bow hunting.
And, you know, we started talk about hunting, and I look at the guyfrom the Liechtenstein and I said, oh, there we go.
Right. And then finally I goes like,so tell me what you think about bow hunting.
(57:41):
You're you're against this. You don't like it.
And this is like a hardcore old school European hunter.
And he goes like, you know what? I was somewhereI don't remember a square.
And there was a bow hunter, and he shook the deer,and I was shocked, in shock how quickly that animal went down.
(58:01):
So I am not against bow hunting. I'm I'm fine with bow hunting.
And I was like, yes, this probably the first time I hear likean old school European rifle hunter who actually says like it's great.
Like the animal.
Like because he saw that, you know, animals hit by an arrow,it'll be running with you. Whatever happens.
And he was he was shocked.
He couldn't believe how quickly that animal just just expired.And that was it.
(58:25):
So that's, kind of like a confirmation.
And maybe that is that once you see something and once you try it, onceyou experience that firsthand, then you are in a much better position
to, you know, offer opinions rather than just borrow an opinionand just repeat it without even, you know, experiencing,
(58:46):
editing yourself.
Jim, it's been great pleasure talking with you.
Just wondering, do you have any any words of wisdom to all the huntersand otherwise who are listening to this podcast?
I do, I do as I was thinking about where you started in your listeners,most of them don't have an opportunity
to hunt because of where they live in the restrictions.
And, I was thinking that what I wish and hope for all of your listeners
(59:12):
who truly love the sport of hunting, I wish and hope that they allhave an opportunity to bow out in their in their hunting lifetimes.
And and they make the commitment to do sobecause the level of intimacy and adrenaline
and the feeling that you getwhen you get that close to an animal and harvest it on its terms,
and you had to fool it and make a good, cleanshot, is a level of adrenaline and intimacy that I've never got in
(59:39):
all the years that I've gone, had, and I've certainly had, you know,I've certainly taken many animals with my rifle, which I enjoy as well.
It's just a completely different feel.
And I hope you and your listeners who are have the interest,have that make that opportunity for themselves happen.
Absolutely.Thanks very much, Jim. Okay. My pleasure. Good talking to you.
(01:00:02):
Thank you for listening.
If you enjoy the podcast,please leave me five star rating on Spotify or Apple Podcasts.
This is great help for me and for the podcast.
And while you already there, don't forget to subscribe to my newsletter.The link is in the description of the show.
This is the Conservation and Science Podcast Replay series,a curated collection of best episodes from last year.
If you are new to the show, this is an excellent opportunityto catch up with the most popular episodes from the back catalog.
And if you are a regular listener,maybe you miss one of those or want to listen to one of them again.
(00:20):
Don't worry, the new episodes are being published on their regularfortnightly schedule, so keep tuning in for the new content
every other Tuesday.
Is bow hunting inhumane?
Is killing an animal with an arrow and inhumane thing to do?
Well, there is a lot of folks who insist the answer is yes,and that is somehow reflected in the regulations.
(00:44):
As hunting with archery tackle is illegal in most of Europe,and I am not surprised if those opinions are expressed
by, let's say, a veterinary professionalwith particular interest in animal welfare,
who on top of that had very little,if none, experience and exposure to bow hunting.
(01:04):
But when those opinions are expressed by hunters and almost bothered
especially that those hunters had also no exposure,no real world exposure to bow hunting.
And in a second part of this podcast,you will hear a story about a hardcore old European hunter
(01:27):
who changed his mind about bow hunting oncehe took part and participated in a hunt with archery tackle.
So that's in the second part of this podcast,
but I think it is my role here in this podcastto be bringing you different opinions, different points of view.
And this is, probably third or fourth episode.
(01:49):
Where are we going to talk about bow hunting?
So today we are joined by an expert bow hunter, Jim Clark.
Jim Hunts with archery tackle close to four decades.
He hunts with a compound bow with a recurve bow.He hunted with a crossbow.
And obviously he handled with a rifle.
So his opinions and his views, I think that are very well thought out.
(02:14):
And he has a wealth of experience, and he's sharing that with us today.
And as usual in those episodes, I'll post him a little bit,asking him questions
about hunting with archery, tackle and bow huntingthat might be uncomfortable.
And, yeah, you're gonna hear his answers.
(02:35):
In the episode, we also discuss the development and progressin, technology of archery, tackle
and how this might or might not impact the humaneness of an endeavor.
And also, Jim will share some of his hunting stories.
So overall, that was a very enjoyable episode to record,
(02:59):
and I hope you will learn a thing or two about bowhunting and hunting with archery tackle.
And just to be clear, if you are against bow huntingor you think it is an inhumane thing to do,
I'm not expecting you to change your mindafter listening to this episode.
But maybe, just maybe, on the surface of your strong opinion,a little crack appears and if that happens, my job is done.
(03:28):
This is what we do.
In this podcast, we discuss issues related to environmentsand human wildlife interactions that are sometimes controversial,
maybe not clear cut, and the role of the podcastis to present different angles and different opinions on those aspects.
So this is one of those episodes.And as always, before I let you enjoy this episode of the podcast.
(03:49):
Just a reminderthat if you're interested in the subjects we're discussing here
and you want to dive deeper in those subjects, you should subscribeto my newsletter, the so-called Conservation and Science Newsletter.
The link is obviously in the description of the show,and that newsletter comes together
(04:09):
with podcast episodes,and it usually contains some other reading and other materials
that will allow you to dive deeper into the subjectswe discuss on the podcast.
And also you'll get notifications thereabout live events, weather, events.
When I'm speaking live. Or maybe I'm just attending participating.
(04:32):
So if it's something that interests you, you can join the event,you can go to the event.
And if you see me there, come up and say hello.
So, that's it for that introduction.
And so now,ladies and gentlemen, Jim Clark and hunting with archery tackle.
(05:04):
And. Jim, welcome to the show.
It's a pleasure to have you in the pleasure. Talk with you.
Thank you. Tammy,I really appreciate it. Been looking forward to our conversation. Yes.
And as, listeners of this podcast know,and as you already know as well, I,
I'm really keen, to talk about bow hunting any time I can,because bow hunting is just not a thing in Europe, and I.
(05:32):
I hope that maybeif there's going to be like 1 or 2 people who starts, you know,
pushing right buttons to get that bow hunting going in Europein, in the to the greater extent, because there are
some places in France, I think that in Spain there are some provinceswhere you can bow hunt, but in general you cannot bow hunting.
Where I am in Ireland, it's a no no in the UK as well,where the probably majority of the listeners are.
(05:57):
So, you know, I'm very keen to talk about it and we,we have a lot of talk.
So before we start, Jim, could you give us, like,a, like a brief introduction to,
who you are, what you do, and how you got started, in bow hunting?
Yeah, absolutely. Tommy.
So my name is Jim Clark, and I grew up in Chicago, Illinois,so in a city, fairly good sized city. And,
(06:25):
since a young age, I always love the outdoors.
Just it was just one of those things where I was always taking myfishing rod and going out to the local pond and things of that nature.
And, and once a year,my dad would take us on a, on a pheasant hunting trip.
So I got exposed to hunting a little bitthrough my father and his business.
But he was not a passionate big game hunter, nor a bow hunter.
(06:46):
But I just fell in love with it.
With the with the whole lifestyle of of pursuing game
and the tremendous challenge and fulfillmentthat I got out of that, even even though I started small time.
And so as I got older,I started working in a sporting goods store and was introduced.
The sporting goods store sold bows and I was like, wow, that is cool.
(07:09):
And I'd shot the little bowswhen I was a kid, right? But never a real bow.
And so I started shooting at that store,and I fell in love with archery, and I got introduced
to the concept of bow hunting for deer,which was much easier to get a tag.
Right. So. So the reason I started bow hunting wasI had never gun hunted up to that point.
(07:31):
But there was a lot of areas that had public groundthat you could bow hunt.
Only where I grew up, outside of Chicago, Illinois,they didn't allow gun hunting, just buying.
So I'm like, well, this is perfect for me.
I can I can learn a new sport that's pursuing big game,which I thought was the sport of kings and still believe that.
And I started and I didn't really know what I was doing.
(07:51):
So I did a lot of readingand I didn't really have any mentors at the time.
So I just started figuring it out with another friend of mine.
So that's how I got started in bow planning, and I've pursued itmy whole life from from that kind of from that starting point.
So you're you're neveryou never started, like, with a rifle and then graduated to the bow.
You just started straight up.
(08:12):
Bow was the first type of hunting you started.
I did, and that's a little unusual mill based on all the friendsthat I now know, that bow and a lot of them started,
in different ways, mainly started gun hunting,and then wanted more of a challenge and bonding.
But I started bonding because it was theit was the only opportunity that I had.
And, and, and it was very accessible, right.
(08:33):
In many state, in many areas in the United States,both seasons starts way earlier than rifle season.
It's three and some cases four months long,whereas rifle season or even, primitive weapon season is very short.
So it opened up a lot of opportunity over with longer seasons
and created a great challenge.
(08:55):
Right. Because bow hunting is certainly very challenging,particularly with the, the,
the equipment that we had 35 years ago when I started up.
But I, but I, but I fell in love with itand since then I've done more gun hunting and so on.
But I've shot and harvested many more animals with a bow than a gun.
What is for youthe main difference between bow hunting and hunting with a rifle?
(09:18):
If I was to boil it down to 2 or 2 a word, it was it's intimacy,
meaning the ability to be very intimate with the animalbecause they're very close.
The requirement to get very intimate about your knowledgeof their movements, where they bed, where they feed.
You know, you have to really study the movements of the animals to putyourself in position between where they are and where they're going.
(09:44):
Whereas with a rifle, you can sit on an opposite hillside and knowa general area that's good for for deer or elk or whatever it may be.
And see animals in a distance and today shoot them at 600 yards.
So that has its own challenge and own fulfillment.
I'm not knocking that, but I love the intimacy of bow on.
It is there is there going like a, a little bit of a rivalry betweenthe bow hunters and and rifle hunters?
(10:11):
It's a it's an interesting question. I would say,
there is a bit, but,
rifle hunters know they have a tremendous advantage, right?
But their seasons are typically late in the season.
After the rut in most states is when you can gun hunt.
So the rifle hunters are sometimes they're a little bit,
(10:32):
miffed that the archery guys get to hunt during the peak of of themating season of the rut, which is when the animals are most vulnerable.
So there's a little bit of that,but bow hunters have the added challenge. So.
So in my years of exercise,I've never run into, like, a real rift between gun and bow.
The at least in the circles I travel,I know it exists, but I haven't haven't really run into that.
(10:56):
I respect rifle hunters.
And I feel like they they respect what what I do as a bow hunter.
But I have heard stories of of of friction there, for sure,but I don't really see a need for it.
We're all there to enjoy the same thing. We just do it in our own way.
Yeah.
And I and I think that also kind of like, is, separation of seasons is,
(11:18):
you know, helping that deer because I presume it wouldn't workif the season like, is it, maybe that's a question.
Is there situations that you can hunt the animalsboth with the rifle or with the bow?
There is in most in most states in the US,
you can legally hut deer during gun season with the bow.
(11:42):
Okay. Provided you're following all the regulations of a gun hunter.
So if they require blaze orange, you have to be wearing blaze orange.
If they require an extra tag, you have to have that extra tag.
But you can legally Beaumont during gun season.
Now that has has its obvious disadvantages however.
But if you're on private ground that you have exclusive rights to huntand there's guys gun hunting all around
(12:06):
and you want to have it harvest an animal with a bow,
that's actually not a bad time, because there are a lot of timesmoving those animals onto your property.
Hahaha. Not that's true, that's true.
So yeah, I've done, I've done,I've done some of that and it can be effective.
Okay, okay. Yeah.
I was just thinking about, you know, the safety measuresbecause you need to get so much closer to the animal.
(12:28):
And, you know, I can I can almost imagine you're just, you know, trying,to take a shot at the animal and then someone 200 yards, boom.
Just happens.
It's it's sits the other. Well, it can happen. And you mentioned safety.
That's paramount. Like when you're bow hunting during gun season,you have to, be very aware.
(12:48):
And yet in most states, you're.
I would always wear blaze orange during gun season. Full stop,whether it's required or not. Absolutely.
Because of that safety reason. Yeah, yeah.
Before we, jump into ita little bit further into the details of bow hunting,
I got to askyou also about crossbow so that it that counts as a archery equipment.
(13:10):
Yes. And yeah, the probably you can elaboratenow whether there's a separate season for
for, crossbow probably depends on the state.
Or is it, like archery equipment is all encompassing?
You know, so if youif you could give us a little bit of the, insight on this,
(13:32):
keeping in mind that, you know, most of the listeners of this podcastnever hunted with a bow and never hunted with a crossbow
and might not even be fully aware ofwhat are the differences, in effectiveness and so on.
Okay, great. Well, it's a really interesting question.And that is a hot button in many, in many circles.
But just to boil it down, when you're shooting a bow,whether it's your traditional recurve or long bow
(13:56):
where you don't have a sight on it and a release, or you're shootinga compound bow, which often has a sight and a release.
So it's a little bit easier to be accurate at a distance.
You still have limitations relative to theyou still have to draw the bow back, hold it back,
keep it on target, and make a clean release,with an on magnified, sight pin.
(14:18):
If you're cutting with a compound bow.
So there are limits to, you know, the range and accuracy and so on.
With a crossbow, the primary distinction is it's more like a rifle,in that once you pocket and put the bolt in, it stays cocked.
And the arrow, which is called a bolt,the bolt in a crossbow is much smaller.
(14:39):
It's shorter and heavy,so it travels extremely fast and flies extremely, flat.
So you can you're much more accurate out to 70, 80 yards with a crossbowthan you would ever be with a compound.
And when you get the animal in close,you don't have to draw back the crossbow.
It's already cocked like a rifle. So you just point and shoot.
(15:01):
Then you can put a scope on a crossbow.
So it's a crossbow.
Is has, I think, more similarities to a rifle than it does a bow,
relative to the advantagesyou obtain by always having it cocked and ready to shoot.
It has a safety on it, and you can put a scope on it.
The similarities are they both use a a banded,you know, abandoned bow limb to propel the arrow.
(15:26):
That's about the only similarities.
So I'll just stop there from a just the different standpoint.Does that make sense.
Yeah. Yeah, absolutely.
And and obviously because of thatalso the range you can shoot an animal is way
longer or higher or you can, you can should an animalfor the greater distance or the crossbow I presume
you, you can I mean, obviously there's people out there that can shoota compound bow very accurately, particularly out west where you're.
(15:52):
We're hunting big country longer distances.
They'll shoot maybe even out to 40, 50, even 60 yards,which is really long with a bow, but with a crossbow.
But that takes a high degree of skill. Yeah. Someone.Someone who has never shot a crossbow.
I've ever shot a crossbow in your life. You know I did not.
If you've picked if you picked up a crossbow today.
(16:14):
If I handed you, handed you one that was sighted
and you went to shoot it, you could shoot itvery accurately out to 70, 80 yards and your very first try.
So imagine that it takes away more practice and expertiseto accurately shoot a bow out to say, 60 yards than with a crossbow.
Who you could just pick it up and shoot it,which gives a lot of people confidence to take a lot longer shots.
(16:35):
Maybe then they're capable, different, different story.
But that's the that's the difference primarily, is it?
Then causing the again, tension between the like a classical,let's call them bow hunters and and crossbow
because it's like okay, we have this season for bow huntingand it requires skill and all those things and all that.
(16:56):
Then, you know, someone shows up, like I said, with a crossbow,first time in their hands, and they have all that,
you know, advantages, let's say, of the early archery seasonand so on, that, that you're absolutely right.
There is there is tension and friction there. And it really gets down to
(17:17):
the, the advantages of the equipment that you, that you reference.
In other words,
people who bohot at least speaking for myself, I chose to bow becauseI love the challenge and the intimacy of getting closer to the deer.
And part of the challenge is the requirement to really practiceshooting your bow and really get good at.
And I shot traditional.
I shot recurve for the first 25, 30 years of of my hunting.
(17:41):
So so so I really,
actually I started with a compound bowshot, a few deer with it, and I'm like, I want something else.
And then I went to recurve and hunted with a recurve traditional bowfor about 30 years.
I think. And, it was by choice.
But it's because I enjoyed the challenge and the intimacyand the the requirement to practice and so on.
(18:02):
And so most folks that bow hunt feel like bow hunting with the longerseasons should be limited to, more, you know, Archer traditional archery
equipment, because you're giving a lot, you know, a longer opportunityto hunt because you have a more a bigger challenge with the equipment.
Once you enter crossbows into that equation, right?
(18:22):
There is some friction because it's like, look,
we're having someone who's hunting with a crossbow has the advantageof a rifle hunting in a, a traditional equipment season.
And that's really where the friction is.
What I can say is in the United States and I don't know the exactnumbers, I haven't studied the numbers, but there are a lot of states
(18:42):
where archery in in archery season, you can only hunt with a compound,
or a traditional bow, like a longbow or recurvecrossbows are not allowed.
The only time they would be allowed is if you had a disabilityand you applied for a permit, and you got granted a permit
based on some kind of a doctor's, you know, disability note,and it has to be approved by the state.
(19:05):
So, so they're, they're they're not allowed in Boces.
They are allowed in what's called I think it's called,there's a primitive weapon season in a lot of states,
which is primarily, muzzle loaders and oftentimescrossbows are allowed in muzzleloader season.
Oh, because they're actually more akin to that if you thinkabout the effective range of a muzzleloader being, let's say,
(19:27):
I should say a traditional muzzleloader, out to about 100 yards.
Well, the, you know, that's kind of with a crossbow. You're,you're good out to nearly there.
So in other states, for example, Ohio or Kansas,crossbows are allowed in bow season as a traditional weapon.
And there is some friction there because of what I mentioned earlier.
(19:49):
It's like, hey, you're you're coming in and you're not having it.
You're not being held at the same standard of scoutingand getting close to the animal and practicing and so on and so forth.
You can come in and shoot a deer at 50, 60 yardswith a crossbow, fairly easily.
And so that's the distinction. And there is some friction there.
And it's state by state.
It's been a battle between the traditional archersand the guys that oftentimes the manufacturers that want it
(20:16):
legalized in the state, because they're going to sella lot more crossbows if it's legal during bow season.
You know, the economics of that.
So of course, that's where the tensionthat's where the tension is. Yeah.
Oh okay. Thanks for for laying that out for us, Jim.
And you mentioned like an interesting thing that I, that I want one moreand that is kind of like a equipment, front.
And this is something we mentioned briefly before we started recordingthis podcast, is that there is a traditional equipment,
(20:42):
scale required, traditional bow, compound bow.
But then when you look at the compoundbow, well, it's nothing but traditional.
You have, you know, space age materials and you have a proceed precisionmachining and 3D printing and all that technology.
I would argue that even if I go and buy a new rifle, like a tick,or whatever, new rifle, decent rifle, it's actually technologically
(21:12):
very old and obsolete compared to when I go and buy a new compound bow,which is all the latest it is.
So I'm curious, like what's your what's your view? What's your comments?
Maybe on this because this is, this is one of the things that I oftenhear like, oh, this is like traditional, like, not traditional at all.
Yes. It's having shot both compounds and,
(21:37):
traditional recurve and shot animals with both.
I have mixed feelings on itwith respect to a, a traditional bow recurve longbow.
When you pull a 65 pound bow back, you're holding 65 pounds,so you can't hold it for long, right?
You got to pull back and shoot, and you're shooting instinctively,meaning no sights,
(21:58):
when you are with a compound. Of course.
We talked about the advantage of being youpull it back and there's a release.
So if you're pulling back 65,maybe you're only holding 3035 at full draw so you can hold for longer.
Let the animal get closeand then you have a oftentimes a trigger release so you can hold it.
And when you release you're not,you know, relying on your fingers doing the work.
You're just pulling a trigger.So you get a good clean release more frequently.
(22:21):
So those advances are normal and have, you know, evolved.
And yet on the one hand,
you know, I'm in favor of anything that helpspeople make a clean, humane kill shot.
Like, to me, that's the most important thing, respecting the animaland making a good, clean, humane shot.
And so things like sight pins and releases on a compound bow
(22:45):
enable the average hunter to more accurately placea shot on an animal and have a humane kill.
So there.
So having said that, when you start getting to advancements like,
both sites that have, magnification or bow sitesthat have lighted pins and magnify,
(23:05):
and the ability to turn a dial to adjust to, you know, 27 yardsor 36 yards or both sites that have integrated rangefinders in them.
Yeah, I heard that.
That's the that's the latest, right,with the bow bow site with the range finder. Okay.
So there you go.
So so then then you say, well wow,those really make it much easier for someone
(23:27):
to effectively range an animal, dial in their sightand make a clean shot at further distances.
Jim, how do you feel about that?
Well, again, I just said anything that helps an archermake a clean, humane shot more consistently is a good thing.
But and those elementsI just discuss those advancements certainly do that.
(23:49):
Right? Yeah.
But at what point does the advancement in technologystart to reduce the level of challenge that's required to Beaumont,
and bring in a lot of folks into the sport that just want to have it.
They just want to hunt deer more frequently and make it easy. You bet.
And by the way,you can make the same argument about the crossbow, right?
It's absolutely it makes you, you know, more more proficient,and it makes you, you know, more likely to have a quick
(24:17):
and humane kill in the animal. So it's a it's interesting.
Let me just a quick story on thatbecause I have some experience with that.
I had never shot a crossbow until last year.
And last spring I was involved in a, in a hunting accident where I got,I got, shot during Turkey season in my right side of my face,
and it put my right I am. Yeah. Oh, geez.
(24:39):
Yeah. Yeah.
Happens.
It's a really unfortunate, but but the point is,
they were able to restore some vision to my right eye,but not to the point where I had any level of acuity.
You know, out of. It'smore like looking through a bottom of a Coke bottle.
So, I'm coming up to both season,and I don't have the time to learn how to shoot left handed.
Right. And I don't want to miss both seasons.One of my greatest passions in life.
(25:02):
And I'm really conflicted.
I'm like lawmakers. And we were going to Kansas. I'm like,am I just going to go to Kansas?
And help with my brother in law?Just hang out with him? Or am I going to hunt? But I can't both.
I can't shoot righty.
But I can't learn the left handedand be accurate enough in the next six weeks.
So I'm in that conundrum.
How do I get accurate and make a good, humane, clean kill?
(25:24):
And so I ended up borrowing a crossbow.
Now, borrowing a weapon goes against my grain,but generally for hunting, right?
Like you got to get a, you know, you got to get a weapon,you got to get proficient at it.
But I felt like if I could be proficient at it and limit my range,I could still enjoy the, you know, enjoy my Beaumont.
(25:46):
Right.
So I went to Kansas, had had a had a barrel bow.
I shot it a couple of days beforehand.
And when I shot at righty, it was iffy because of my vision.
So I had to shoot it lefty because my left eye is was is better.
And I got to where I could just naila target at 30 yards with a crossbow.
Like I'm talking like this in two days.
(26:09):
I maybe shot 30 arrows, 30 bolts, and I am just absolutely knocking the,you know, the center out of the target.
So I'm like, I'm comfortable.
You know, Archer and I shot it out to 50.
I'm like, I'm comfortable out to 50.
But I'm I've never shot a deer with my bowin all the years over 25 yards
in all the deer I shot, probably 45, 50 deernever shot one over 25 years because I like to get them in close.
(26:32):
So the moral of the story is I go out hunting and, we're three daysinto the hunt and I have an opportunity to shoot a really nice buck,
and I can't get many closer than 50 yards,
and he's out in the middle of a field and it's in the wide open.
He's with a doe. He's very. He's distracted. It's the perfect situation.I can't get him any closer.
(26:53):
I've tried. I've rattled.
He's not getting any closer. He's going to move off.
And I ranged him and he was 50
and I shot him left handed offand at no rest. Just left handed, 50 yards.
Shot him right in the heart. He went 50 yards and died.
And and I was shot.
But I felt so confident making that shotbecause when I put that that weapon on him
(27:17):
and it was a scoped crossbow for I think it was a two power scope,maybe, I put it right on his breadbasket.
I pulled the trigger. I just knew I was going to make a clean shot.
So I didn't violate any any of my, you know, ethos,if you will, that way.
But after that hunt, I was reflecting on the fact that.
How easy was that for me to have never shot a crossbowand then just picked it up a few days before, and I went out
(27:42):
during both season, and I shot a deer that I would not have shot with mywith my normal equipment, and I shot him at 50 yards.
Yes, I made a good clean kill,
but it it what it did was it it actually emphasized the primary beefI have with allowing crossbows during both season.
And I did it and I did it legally and it enabled me to hunt.And because I had this disability. Right.
(28:04):
And I and I enjoyed it for all that it was,but it really highlights the advantage of a crossbow.
That's a great story, Jim. That's athat's a great story. Congratulations on the book.
Yeah, it was interesting.
I never in my life thought I'd shoot a deer with a crossbow ever.
Yeah, and I did, and I, I took nothing away from the animal.
(28:26):
I love the experience. I enjoyed it,but it really gave me a lot to reflect on, honestly.
Yeah, yeah, yeah for sure, for sure. And that's a, that's athat's a great story.
And you know, like sometimes things are happening in lifethat made you try things that you would,
you will never try and then you enjoy it or at least have it like a,you know, some thoughts about it, like you did.
(28:51):
Jim. So I think you it's a great moment now to kind of like a transitionto another part of this conversation.
You mentioned the word humane there quite a few times.
Yes. And obviously, well, obvious to me, maybe to other people as well.
This is one of the biggest,
arguments of the opponents of bow hunting.
(29:14):
And, you know, even on this podcast,I spoke with, few bow hunters, but I also spoke with veterinarians and,
even accomplished hunters, rifle hunters who were expressing their,
you know, various level of disapproval for bow hunting based on the,
(29:36):
how humane that their shot is.
And it seems to me like the the most common argument is that the,
arrow is lacking the concussive power that they can concussive,affect on the, on the animal where you have the, the,
effect where the water in the eye,it says a name that is eluding me right now, which, which has a,
(30:01):
the basically is the all the water in the body ofthe animal is disturbed and creates like a wave.
It's, it's it's called hydro electric shock or something like that.
So it doesn't have a concussive barrier. Therefore it is less humane.
And I, you know, I think and thisthat was also confirmed by many people who said like, well, why?
(30:23):
Why, you know, why is
causing that concussion to the animal.
How can you come to the conclusion that this is somehow more humane?
If you can shoot an animal that and we know those stars.
You shoot an animal, an animal.
Just look what happenedand then comes back to grazing and then falls over.
(30:44):
They didn't even know what hit him.
But then the argument is like, yeah,but how many shots like that really happens?
It's one every now and thenand then again, fundamentally it's an issue, mate. So
once again, I would ask you to once again on this podcast,unpack this argument and how, how you feel about it.
(31:08):
How does that, said in your opinion, it's a great question.
It has some complexities and nuance to it,but it's a great question. And so
I'm no,
doctor or surgeon. Right.
But what I do know is that, having studied it is that,
(31:28):
an arrow kills through hemorrhage,
right?
Like blood loss or lungs, you know, for blood,
you know, it's just killed by hammered, whereas a bullet kills by shock,concussive power and damage to the material.
Whatever it hits, right.
And so I can only speak through that.
I'll only speak through experience here.
And that is to say, I've shot, you know, quite a few deer with my bow,
(31:50):
and I've shot a fair number of deerwith both a rifle and black powder and a shotgun slug.
And I will say that,
during all the years of bow hunting,I may have lost 2 or 3 deer that I hit, that I didn't recover
in all the years of bow hunting.
Right? 35 years.
(32:11):
So. Well, why?
Hey, wait a minute.
That seems like.
Well, it is low, but it's because,
of the commitment to practice and be proficient
and make sure the animal is close enough to make a clean shot.
And having the discipline to pass up anything that doesn't pass thatlitmus test of, I'm going to make a clean shot on this animal, right?
(32:34):
So I've had to pass upsome really nice animals at 35, 40 yards with my recurve.
I just not going to shoot them. Right.
Because I thought I probably would have voted themand I probably would have at that distance with a recurve.
So the animals that I've shot with my bow,I would say ballpark 80% of them after I hit them in some cases.
(32:56):
Well, they died within a hundred yardsthere. Went through them all the way, all the way through them.
And then they ran off. And I typically would see them fallor hear them fall within 100 yards, in some cases less,
because when you double lung
an animal with a arrow and it goes all the way through them like yousaid, they just they flinch,
especially if you don't hit a rib.
(33:18):
And I've had them go back to grazing and tip over in eight seconds.
If you hit a rib with your arrowand they feel that, you know, they'll they'll run for a while,
but they'll often stop after 30 or 40 yardsand then that blood flow to their brain ceases
because you let the air out of their lungsand they die in less than 10s, like literally 7 or 8 seconds.
(33:39):
And if you look at them on film, that's about how long it takes
with a rifle, unless you shoot them right in the head or in the,you know, or in the, you know, even in the spine.
Right?
The animals I've shot with a rifle have,some of them that have tipped over right where I shot them.
But oftentimes you hit them and they run even if they're hit.
Well, because what kills them is that shockand ultimately that blood loss. But,
(34:04):
I would say that
I don't have any evidence, personal evidencethat would suggest that that killing with a rifle
is more humane than taking an animal with a bow,because that just hasn't been my experience.
And when an animal is shot with a bow, oftentimesit's not that concussive bang,
you know, that hits themand that bullet expands and explodes inside them.
(34:28):
It just goes throughit must it feels like a, you know, fly prick sometimes, right?
Because they don't get spooked and all wild eyed and run off.
They'll run off 30, 40, 50 yards and stop and then fall over. So
any I know that it's a big topic out there,but in my experience that just hasn't been the case.
If you apply the discipline to make a clean shotand don't take those marginal shots.
(34:50):
And that's where the problem is, guys pushing that envelopeand they wound a lot more deer and that is a problem.
I'm just calling that out.
Yeah.
No. And and the and you're right because this is like athe next argument that follows closely by right.
And just to finish off on the on the concussive power versus versusjust, just, you know, sharp arrows cutting through the animal eye,
(35:14):
you know, like, I feel like if I, if I were a deer and I had to choose,I would, I would always choose to be shot by the bow
and by the arrow because they, I don't I justI don't see the argument of the concussive power making it more humane.
If the time it takes is roughlythe same, you're actually saving the animal
(35:35):
this extra concussive power and the, you know, sound of the gunshotand all these things.
So but that's that's just my my comment on it.
So let's talk about the difficulty because like you said,this is another argument that comes next that,
oh the guys are pushing the envelope.
They're they're taking the shots that they have no business taking.
(35:59):
My view on this is that, well, there are people who are taking shotswith the rifle that they have no business taking.
Yes. So,
that argument actually doesn't cut to me too much about,you know, who am I?
I live in a country that prohibits bow hunting. I never bow hunt.
So that's whatI have you on the podcast to talk about these, these things.
(36:20):
But the argument then is that because of such a high degree of skillrequired,
bow hunters are putting a lot of effort into training,into honing their skill, into shooting arrows.
Then, compared to the rifle hunterswho I know, people who are just, you know,
(36:41):
they they they never own the range, they just shooting on the animalsbecause it's so easy, you just putting in a crosshair and bang.
And then when they miss they go on the range, do zero of the skullbecause, oh, I'm just I just missed just missed this dog.
And so then the level of training, you know, there's so inmy head is like,
(37:03):
you are equally likely to take a shot that you shouldn't be able toyou shouldn't be taking if you're, you know, this kind of person.
But the bow hunter, by definition, at least,should be way more skilled and trained because of a difficulty of it.
Now, this is my, you know, borrowed opinions and what I think.
(37:26):
I want to hear your opinion is, is there any truth to that?
Is there are there any caveats to that?
What I said, I think it's a it's a fair
it's a fair observation from, from your perspective in that,
knowing, you know, over the years, hundreds of bowhunters and many, many gun hunters,
(37:48):
most of the bow hunters I know, Tommy,are, are very committed to the sport, right?
Because, you know, they enjoy archery, they shoot 3D shoots,you know, that that they,
around the area that they live in, the three dimensional targetswhere they're set up at different ranges to test their skill,
you know, estimate ranges and shoot and score.
(38:09):
And they're out here out west where I live in Oregon.
Now, there's they they train physically cardiobecause there's big hills, right? Big mountains out here.
And so they know they're going to have to be physically fitand to be able to execute a shot.
So they're very committed, to the sport.
And therefore they really work on their proficiency with their weapon.
(38:31):
I know many gun hunters that are also very committed to shooting
accurately and go to the range and would never go hunting with a riflewithout shooting in before setting in beforehand.
But I know probably an equal or greater numberthat fall into the category you describe, which is like, oh, it's,
you know, you've been to the range this year.Oh no, my, my, my rifle was cited in last year.
(38:53):
I killed a nice bike with it. I'm good to go.
Well, really, you know what I mean. Yeah. You've pointed that out.
And so they go out in a mess and I've had guys go, oh go to the range.
And it's, you know, up, up a foot offand they miss or worse wound an animal
because they didn't feelthey needed to take the time because of the proficiency of a firearm.
So I think what you characterized is reasonably true.
(39:15):
But but with any sport, especially blood sportsthat we're talking about here, just to be, you know, candid,
there are folks that
that endeavor to do it correctlyand are really respectful about the animal and the sport and so on.
And there are some smaller proportion that want to take the easyroute, are willing to chance a long shot at an animal
(39:35):
even if they wounded in the event that they might take it,you know, doing things that they shouldn't do.
And I think that that exists in any sport.
But when you're talking about shooting animals,I think it's, it's really unfortunate that that can be the case.
And the easier you make it, the in my opinion,the more it invites casual, less committed folks.
(39:58):
And that gets right back to the conversation we had on crossbows.
And anything that makes it easy
invites more people not willing to necessarilyput the time in to say, oh, if it's that easy, I'll give it a try.
And that to me is is it?
That rubs me the wrong way.
Yeah. They're more focus on the outcomerather than on the process. Nailed it.
You just nailed it. That's right.What about the wounding rates? Wounding rates are higher with a bolt.
(40:22):
I think there is no no questions about it. Or are they.
Well, it's all about shot placement right. And so
the opportunity to wound an animal with a bow is definitely therebecause just the angle of the animal.
Right.
Like if it's dead broadside and you shoot it right in the,you know, right behind the front, like you'll take out both lungs.
(40:45):
But if that animal's quartering to you even slightly 15 degrees,same shot, you might hit one lung and miss the second one, right?
That animal or one lung hit animal can run hundreds of yards. Right.
And so you can run them
and but but most are fatally wounded, right.
(41:08):
Like most are fatally wounded.
So that's where skills of tracking, understanding animal behavior,where they where they typically go
and their behavior after they're mortally wounded is really important.
And, you know, I take tremendous pride on my ability to track animals.
And I don't give up. I've tracked them for days,
(41:28):
and hours on my hands and kneesand have a very, very high recovery rate.
As a consequence, I don't give up if I don't see specks of bloodlike I'm following tracks turned over leaves.
I'm following directionally where I believe they're going to go.I understand my property.
I know where they would likely to goif they were one London. They were hit and they're going to go downhill.
They're going to go toward waterand they're going to go and take cover. And I look there.
(41:50):
So if you really work at it, youyou can recover a high, high percentage of any wounded animals.
And when they're not fatally wounded with a bow.
Right. It's just like a clean slice. They often recover
like they often do.
I've killed many, not many.
I've killed a handful of of deer that had a broad head in their hip,and they were fine, right.
(42:14):
Or they had a scar, but they were fine. So,
there is a, an opportunity to own an animalno matter the weapon you use.
But as a bow hunter, I'mvery committed to because they die by hemorrhage.
You follow blood, right?
And, you can recover most animals if they're fatally hit, without doubt.
(42:38):
So I'll just. I'll just leave it there.
That's one of the reasons we talked about advancements in technologyearlier,
you know, where do they make sense and wherewhere do they maybe go against the rules of fair chase, lighted knocks,
you know that as it's lighted, knock on the back of an arrow,it lights up when you shoot it.
Yeah, I know, but you can explain to to the listeners.
But yeah, the knock is the is the end of the arrowthat attaches to your string, and it's made out of plastic.
(43:01):
And today they offer those that that light up when you shoot them.
They light up like with a little LED light,like light green or light pink.
So when you release the arrow you can see it fly and see it hit.
And and I
believe that's a good advancement in technologybecause the greater knowledge you have on where the arrow hit
hit the animal, the better odds are you're going to recover itbecause you're going to know where you hit.
(43:26):
That's a good thing.
When you have I for years shot broad headsthat were traditional broad heads, like the old bear broadhead
where you were, you actually,it was like a razor, but you had to sharpen it yourself.
So I'd sit there in front of the TV and sharpen it myself for hoursso I could cut air off.
My whole arm would be bald because I use that as a test.My left arm would be just completely bald.
(43:48):
Get it?
Going into Boston because I was testing it, right? And like, yeah,if I can shave hair off my arm, it's it's good.
It's it's it's right.
But what I found
is I tried one year the new mechanical broadhead,which fundamentally I was against.
Right. It's like, you know, it's another technological gimmick. Right.
(44:09):
But I tried and tested the mechanical broadhead,
with a 1.5in cutting radius.
And the very first year I shot with one,I shot him, you know, through both lungs.
And the blood trail was amazing.I mean it because of the cutting radius.
If you kill by hemorrhage, the more cutting, the better.
So my point is I'm in, I believe mechanical broadhead
(44:33):
are beneficial to the animal because of the larger cut radius.
Quicker kills, easier recovery because the blood trailis much more substantial for people who are listening to this.
The mechanical broadhead is the brow side.
Like thethe blades of the broadhead opens on the contact with the animal. Yes.
So that that improves the flight of the arrow,I guess because it's, it's it doesn't have the broadhead
(44:58):
with the, with the blades on it cracked open.
And then because of that it can open too much, like I said,larger extend larger blades basically, which makes a bigger cuts.
So so exactly.
You explain it perfectly.
So the arrow is much more likely to hit where you're aiming it,meaning a good clean kill.
And when it hits and those blades open up, it makes a very largecutting radius, which then leads to a very, very good blood trail.
(45:26):
And that's what you want.You want to recover the animals you you hit, right. That's the key.
So those advancements in technology help recovery of animals,which I'm in favor of absolutely makes sense to me.
Makes sense.
And and look, we, we people who are more interested in their, you know,details of technical leaders of all the elements of the bow and arrow.
(45:49):
We have an episode,
on the podcast also, it's called,
I think, Sizzling Arrows, where we go into greatdepth on all the types of arrows and things like that.
So I'm just not one.
I don't want to go into technicals on it.
Because we have way more interesting things here to cover.
Oh, one other things that you mentioned that I also heard earlieris that the wounded animals, the animals wounded with a with a
(46:16):
as a result of the, of a inaccurate bow shot are more likely to recoverwhile the animals that are, that are, wounded by a gunshot
that's usually dead animal only it can take weeks or,you know, long time.
So that's that's you're you kind of confirmed that, as Mark.
(46:39):
Okay.
So I just want to switch gearshere, a little bit and talking about how long
in, on average, how long it
takes a person to practice with a bow before they get proficient.
In enough to be able to go and execute a shot at the animal,having in mind that
(47:07):
executing shot at the animal is quite a different dealthan executing, show that the range,
because of the emotions and the buck fever and all those things.
So I'm going with this thing here, you know, likeif anyone wants to try and, you know, maybe even the question is like,
if people like myself or other who live in Ireland, in the UK,they want to go hunting, they want to go bow hunting,
(47:36):
and they, they can go to Spain or to France or to Hungary,whatever that place in Europe, or maybe even fly to the US
to do this, you know, bow hunting experience.
But they need to prepare.
They cannot just, you know, how long it takes to become proficient.
(47:56):
And what would be your advice to person,
you know, like, again, who lives in Europeand wants to prepare themselves for that sort of experience?
It starts with what equipment we're using.
So I'm going to start with the most common, which is a compound bow.
And when I say a compound bow, I'm going to assume that there's aa sight,
(48:17):
a set of sight pins on the, on the bow bow side and a release,because that's the most common setup you see today.
Okay.
So my son is a good example because he just took up archery this year.
We got him a bow,
set up the way I just described.
And he became
(48:37):
pretty proficient at the range in a matter of, let's say four weeks,
five weeks. Now he's going three, four times a week.
You know, he goes to the range, he's shooting a 20 yardsand he's extending out to 30.
But he's really focused on just focus on your form.
You know meaning you release nice and smooth, no jerky.
(48:58):
You know, just nice and smooth. Focus on the fundamentals.
And, you know, in in 4 to 6 weeks.
And when he last he came up here,he was shooting a very tight group at 30 yards.
Meaning I take when I see a tiger,I'm talking about less than three inches. Okay. Like that bit.
So that's good. That's pretty impressive.
And now the question is becomes, well, is he proficient enough to hunt?
(49:19):
And at that point, no.
And however he's proficient enough to shoot accurately at a range then.
So that's let's call that six weeks. I think that's reasonable.
You know, a couple days a week, three days a week for six weeks.
You can be pretty proficient with it,should be expressive with the hours on the range. Right.
Because like six weeks ago.Yeah. About three times a week for six weeks.
(49:42):
Yeah.
I mean literally I mean if you shoot 2 or 3 times a week,but you're shooting about, you know, 75 arrows at a time, right.
And you do that over a period of six weeks. The equipment is so goodthese days.
You can get proficient at the range. Okay.
So in terms of elapsed time, I don't know how many hours that is,but it's not an inordinate amount of hours.
Right. It's reasonable.
(50:04):
The next step before you would ever go
hunting is you need to go out and shoot3D targets, different angles at unknown distances.
That's the next step.
So. Right.
Because when you know I'm shooting
20 yards, 30 yards, 40 yards, even if you're shooting deer targetsat an archery range, everything is controlled.
Everything.
You know, the distance,the next step is to go shoot a 3D range where you're shooting
(50:27):
at three dimensional targets of of deer or wild boar or elk or whateverthey have as the targets.
And you're shooting at different distances.
So you might be shooting at 18 yards, 27 yards, 36 yards,whatever it is. And,
you have to determine, do you want to use a rangefinderor do you want to estimate sight without a range fighter?
(50:48):
For all my years of hunting, I justI was able to estimate yardages without that.
But, but I would recommend having a range finder to knowif there's nothing wrong with that, because, again, good clean kill.
So if you spend another, let's say 4 to 6 weeks elapsed timeor whatever time you can spend,
shooting three
dimensional targets, unknown ranges at more realistic angleslike you would in the field.
(51:13):
That's the next step.
So let's call that another four weeks or so.
Transferhow much time you can at most of us work, so you can't do it every day.
And then the last step
would be to make sure that those last few practice sessions, shootingthree dimensional targets, either in your yard or at a range,
you're wearing the clothes you're going to hunt with, you'rewearing gloves, everything, face mask or whatever you're going to wear
(51:40):
hunting you're wearing on the range and you're shootingyour actual broadhead, and you do that for a couple of weeks.
Those are the phases.So if you think about that, you say, you know what?
In, you know, in 4 or 5 months over the period of a spring summer,could you be starting from zero?
Could you pre-prepared and equipped, if you put that time in
(52:02):
to go hunting confidently and make a humane kill on a big gameanimal with a bow, I would say that's reasonable.
Oh, and then might I might say that that was,
that was shorter period of time that I thought.
But again, it's very compressed effortbecause it's like a concert stunt going, going, going.
(52:22):
But so in other words, like if you're if someone would like to go,
for, you know, bow hunting experience trip, next yearif they start today,
then by that time next year, they should be more than able to goand execute humane shot at the animal.
That's correct.
(52:43):
And, and, you know, as a nonresident,I believe you can apply for, deer permits in the United States.
Yeah. I mean, like,you know, it's it's one of those things if you want, you can do it.
It's it's just, I think very unfortunate that that we can't do itwhere we live.
You know, like,I came into hunt and regular listeners of this podcast know this story.
(53:05):
I said it many times that, you know,I came to hunting very late in my life.
I was in that early 40s, late, late 30s, for sure, less than a decade.
And I was an angler.
And I wanted bow hunting,you know, obviously American church shows and the TV's like, oh, I gonna
I feel like I'm ready to graduate to hunting from fishing.
(53:25):
And I want to go bow hunting because it was like,so natural and like, more like a fishing rod.
You know, you have a good bendy and, element and then you have a lineand all these things and they're like, no illegal.
And I didn't even want to go into the whole effort of getting, like,a firearm permit and all those things.
(53:46):
And it turns out like, no, I have no choice. I had to do this.
But this bow hunting thing other than, you know, talking about itand educating people through the podcast,
it is in the back of my head.
I would definitely like to, like to try it,
to wrap this up, Jim,what would be like a foolproof advice for you, arguments
(54:10):
for people who are looking favorably at bow huntingand they find themselves,
any in the, companion of other hunters, rifle hunterswho are, you know, usually don't have any experience with bow hunting.
And discussion starts about like, oh, you know, this is inhumane.
(54:33):
And should they what would be your like, a foolproof advice
how to conduct that conversation and,and give the give the fair representation of bow hunting.
It's an interesting question. I've never been asked that question.
And I would say that
Isabel Hunter, if I was in the company of, ofof of a lot of gun hunters and they were, they were,
(54:55):
you know, challenging the humaneness of my sport.
Right. Is that what you're suggesting? Right. Yeah.
My response would be that no matter the weapon you choose to use,there are certain standards
that that you have to and certain level of of skills and commitmentyou have to put forth to ensure a humane kill,
(55:17):
whether it's a rifle or a bow or a crossbow or a muzzleloader,there is a certain level of of of commitment
you have to make to become proficient and then discipline,you have to apply on what shot you will and will take.
And what I can say for myself and other bow hunters that I knowthat are as committed as I am, is that we make quick, humane kills
(55:42):
at a high, high rate 95 plus percent of the time.
Right?
And another state I would say isI've only missed 2 or 3 deer in my entire life.
Missed it completely because I just don't take long shots.
It's only 25 yards. I'm not going to miss a deer at 25 yards.
The ones that I did miss went down a hill and went shot over the back.
(56:05):
So I don't miss many.I know a lot of rifle hunters that have missed a lot of deer. Why?
Because they're taking shots that they shouldn'ttake, running animals, distances that they shouldn't.
They're just taking a pot shot. Right.
So my sport is any not any more, more or less humane than your method.
If we apply the same level of commitment to knowing our weapon andunderstanding its limits and being disciplined about what shot we take.
(56:31):
So let's let's go grab a beer.
That would be my response.
It's a great response.
And, you know, like this is like so many things that for example,some hunters in Europe, like in Germany and France,
they they think like, oh, bow hunting is inhumane.But then they, they should go running animals.
It's like a how that is humane.
Like if bow running is inhumaneand you're just shooting like a running deer and they're running right.
(56:54):
But that's, that's a, completely separate, conversation.
And I just want to, end up with, with a story this yearin, in, in May was
it was in an AprilI was on the, on the symposium and the like a CIC event
and I was talking with the, with the old hunter from Liechtensteinand we started and there was also people from the US and the and the,
(57:20):
not a hunter, but the guy who
is, really involved in conservation from the US was sitting at the tablewith us and the topic, got into the bow hunting.
And, you know, we started talk about hunting, and I look at the guyfrom the Liechtenstein and I said, oh, there we go.
Right. And then finally I goes like,so tell me what you think about bow hunting.
(57:41):
You're you're against this. You don't like it.
And this is like a hardcore old school European hunter.
And he goes like, you know what? I was somewhereI don't remember a square.
And there was a bow hunter, and he shook the deer,and I was shocked, in shock how quickly that animal went down.
(58:01):
So I am not against bow hunting. I'm I'm fine with bow hunting.
And I was like, yes, this probably the first time I hear likean old school European rifle hunter who actually says like it's great.
Like the animal.
Like because he saw that, you know, animals hit by an arrow,it'll be running with you. Whatever happens.
And he was he was shocked.
He couldn't believe how quickly that animal just just expired.And that was it.
(58:25):
So that's, kind of like a confirmation.
And maybe that is that once you see something and once you try it, onceyou experience that firsthand, then you are in a much better position
to, you know, offer opinions rather than just borrow an opinionand just repeat it without even, you know, experiencing,
(58:46):
editing yourself.
Jim, it's been great pleasure talking with you.
Just wondering, do you have any any words of wisdom to all the huntersand otherwise who are listening to this podcast?
I do, I do as I was thinking about where you started in your listeners,most of them don't have an opportunity
to hunt because of where they live in the restrictions.
And, I was thinking that what I wish and hope for all of your listeners
(59:12):
who truly love the sport of hunting, I wish and hope that they allhave an opportunity to bow out in their in their hunting lifetimes.
And and they make the commitment to do sobecause the level of intimacy and adrenaline
and the feeling that you getwhen you get that close to an animal and harvest it on its terms,
and you had to fool it and make a good, cleanshot, is a level of adrenaline and intimacy that I've never got in
(59:39):
all the years that I've gone, had, and I've certainly had, you know,I've certainly taken many animals with my rifle, which I enjoy as well.
It's just a completely different feel.
And I hope you and your listeners who are have the interest,have that make that opportunity for themselves happen.
Absolutely.Thanks very much, Jim. Okay. My pleasure. Good talking to you.
(01:00:02):
Thank you for listening.
If you enjoy the podcast,please leave me five star rating on Spotify or Apple Podcasts.
This is great help for me and for the podcast.
And while you already there, don't forget to subscribe to my newsletter.The link is in the description of the show.
Popular Podcasts
24/7 News: The Latest
The latest news in 4 minutes updated every hour, every day.
Therapy Gecko
An unlicensed lizard psychologist travels the universe talking to strangers about absolutely nothing. TO CALL THE GECKO: follow me on https://www.twitch.tv/lyleforever to get a notification for when I am taking calls. I am usually live Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays but lately a lot of other times too. I am a gecko.
The Joe Rogan Experience
The official podcast of comedian Joe Rogan.