Bib & Tucker Small Batch Bourbon Whiskey Review

Welcome back to DadDimes on the Rocks! Today, we’re diving into a bourbon with a name as unique as its bottle—Bib & Tucker Small Batch Bourbon Whiskey. With its vintage-style presentation and claims of being a smooth, well-aged bourbon, it certainly catches the eye. But does it live up to expectations? Let’s find out, with our very special return guest, Paul Murray and his American Hero Son, John Murray!

The Story Behind Bib & Tucker

Bib & Tucker is sourced bourbon, meaning it’s not distilled by the company that bottles it. It’s produced by Tennessee-based Deutsch Family Wine & Spirits, which doesn’t disclose the distillery but is rumored to source from George Dickel. The brand markets itself as a premium small-batch bourbon, focusing on a refined, smooth profile with a touch of Southern charm.

The name "Bib & Tucker" comes from 19th-century slang, referring to one's finest attire—essentially, "dressed to impress"—which is reflected in the brand’s elegant, old-school bottle design.

Key Details

• Type: Small Batch Tennessee Bourbon
• Proof: 92 (46% ABV)
• Mash Bill: Undisclosed, but believed to be corn-heavy with some rye and malted barley
• Age: Minimum 6 years, with some bottles rumored to contain older juice
• Distillery: Sourced (likely George Dickel, Tennessee)

Bottle Presentation

Bib & Tucker stands out with its antique-style glass bottle, featuring an embossed script logo and deep amber color. The wax-style top and overall design give it a premium, Prohibition-era feel, making it a great-looking addition to any shelf.

Tasting Notes

Nose

A sweet and slightly floral aroma with caramel, vanilla, and light oak. Subtle notes of toasted nuts, cinnamon, and dried fruit emerge as it opens up.

Palate

The first sip is smooth and soft, featuring flavors of honey, toffee, and charred oak. A mild spice from the rye component kicks in mid-palate, with hints of nutmeg, dark fruit, and a touch of leather.

Finish

Medium-length, with lingering sweet vanilla, oak, and a gentle peppery spice. It’s not overly bold, but it’s well-balanced and pleasant.

How Does It Compare?

Bib & Tucker is often compared to other Tennessee-style bourbons, like George Dickel 8-Year or Nelson’s Green Brier. It’s softer and smoother than some high-rye bourbons but lacks the bold punch of something like Wild Turkey 101 or Elijah Craig Barrel Proof.

If you enjoy a gentler, well-rounded bourbon, this one fits the bill.

Best Ways to Enjoy

👔 Neat – The smooth profile makes this an easy sipper.
🧊 On the Rocks – A little ice opens up the caramel and fruit notes.
🥃 Classic Old Fashioned – The sweet, vanilla-forward notes work great in a cocktail.

Final Thoughts

Bib & Tucker Small Batch Bourbon delivers on its promise of a smooth, refined pour, making it a great choice for those