10 Episode 62: Peter Aguero of The Moth - The Design Of Authentic Storytelling

Peter Aguero isn’t just a performer, he’s a presence. Known for his emotionally charged, wildly entertaining, and deeply human stories, Peter has become one of the most beloved voices in the storytelling world. A longtime host and GrandSLAM champion with The Moth, Peter’s work explores grief, rage, love, redemption, and the quiet moments that define who we are. In this episode, we sit down with Peter to trace the creative arc of his life, from growing up in South Jersey and leaving football behind, to traveling the country with Chicago City Limits, and eventually becoming a core figure in The Moth’s rise to cultural prominence. Along the way, we explore why storytelling isn’t just communication, it’s how we make sense of being human. Peter’s story intersects with some of the greats, including his longtime friendship with creative musician and experimental educator Dave Gould, who introduced him at a transformative moment in Iowa City. Together, their work reminds us that story is not just scientific, it’s deeply experiential. It’s memory. It’s identity. It’s the way we heal, connect, and lead. We also revisit some of Peter’s most memorable performances, including: “You’re Not Alone” (The Moth Mainstage, Metropolitan Museum of Art), a heartbreaking and healing story about Christmas with his mother “The Italian Ice Fight” — a wild, true tale about a summer job that ended with a hammer, a fight, and a lesson in fear Daddy Issues (his one-man show) — a raw, theatrical journey through masculinity, shame, and survival Appearances on Conan and in venues like the Bitter End, Highline Ballroom, and under-the-radar NYC gems like Under St. Mark’s In this episode, you’ll learn: + How vulnerability builds creative credibility + Why your real voice is more powerful than your polished one + How to structure stories that resonate emotionally, without overproducing + What brands and leaders can learn from live storytelling and audience honesty + How to tell stories that invite recognition, not just applause Whether you’re leading a brand, creating a presentation, or trying to inspire others, this episode is a reminder that the most unforgettable stories are the ones that don’t try too hard. They just tell the truth.