November 20, 2025 • 37 mins
In Part 2 of this special Q&A roundtable, the Echando Raíces team dives deeper into the real concerns of real estate investors. From installing security cameras, optimizing taxes on property sales, and inheritance planning, to navigating pet policies, insurance coverage, and unit delivery conditions, no topic is off-limits. The hosts break down complex topics with clarity and humor, offering practical advice for anyone looking to protect and grow their real estate investment in Mexico. Whether you’re a first-time buyer or a seasoned investor, this episode offers actionable insights to help you invest with confidence.
Questions tackled in this episode:
- Can I install cameras outside my apartment?
- What taxes do I pay when I sell my property, and how can I optimize the appreciation?
- Are developments pet-friendly?
- Do the apartments come with insurance against natural disasters?
- Is the apartment delivered as I see it in the showroom?
- What happens if we buy a property as a family and the parents pass away?
Ideal for: First-time investors, curious buyers, and real estate agents looking for clear answers and advice from experienced professionals.
Síguenos en instagram en: @echando.raices_podcast
Proximamente en TikTok y YouTube
Bienvenidos a Echando Raíces!
Follow us on instagram: @echando.raices_podcast
Coming soon: TikTok & YouTube
Welcome to Echando Raices!
Mark as Played
Transcript
Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Alexa (00:00):
Welcome back to the Deep Dive.
(00:01):
If you are an investor who'slooking past that initial
property acquisition, past thebeautiful rendering and the
closing table, then this is youressential shortcut.
Today we are taking a stack ofreally specific investor
questions.
We're talking about theoperational realities in these
high growth condo markets, uh,specifically focusing on the
regulatory, legal, and financialside of things in the Riviera
(00:25):
Maya,
Bob (00:26):
and that's.
Really the crucial shift, isn'tit?
The sales process, it gets allthe attention, but your true
long-term success, I mean,minimizing risk, maximizing your
profit, that depends entirely onhow you.
Handle the day to day.
Alexa (00:40):
The logistics.
Bob (00:41):
The logistics, the community dynamics, and this is
the most important part, theplanned exit.
We've collected questions that,uh, that really cut straight to
the core of these complexities,
Alexa (00:50):
and that is our mission today, to give you the
actionable details on everythingthat happens.
After you get the keys, we areunpacking the, the nuances of
communal living.
Yeah.
Like how far can the condoassembly really.
Go in dictating how you use yourunit.
We're going to detail exactlywhy a standard utility bill is,
believe it or not, your mostpowerful tool for tax exemption.
Bob (01:11):
It's amazing how many people miss that one.
Alexa (01:13):
And critically, how to avoid the deadly asterisk trap
that's, you know, hidden deepwithin your technical spec
sheet.
Bob (01:21):
And we'll wrap up by dissecting risk mitigation.
Talk about mandatory insurance,the, the really fascinating
geographic advantage that CosmMill provides to the mainland.
Alexa (01:32):
Oh, that part is incredible.
Bob (01:33):
It really is.
And why?
The most critical piece of legalpaperwork you'll sign has
nothing to do with the purchase,but, uh, everything to do with
protecting your family'sinheritance down the line.
Alexa (01:43):
Okay, let's unpack this.
We should start where theconflict, you know, it often
begins right away Hmm.
At the boundary of your personalinvestment and the shared
community space.
The
Bob (01:51):
front door.
Alexa (01:51):
Exactly.
The front door.
The minute an investor acceptsdelivery of their unit, they
basically transition from beinga consumer to, uh, being a
member of a mini government.
Mm-hmm.
Bob (02:01):
The condominium associ.
Alexa (02:03):
Right, and this immediately creates a conflict
between your individual desirefor security and the community's
need for well harmony andprivacy.
Let's start with one of the mostcommon friction points we've
seen.
We're calling it the cameraconundrum.
Bob (02:18):
It's absolutely everywhere.
It's especially with investorswho are planning on doing short
term rentals.
Alexa (02:22):
Yeah,
Bob (02:23):
the investor's logic is.
You know, it's flawless.
Alexa (02:26):
Of course, I need to track who's coming and going.
Bob (02:28):
Exactly.
I need to track who accesses myunit, especially for insurance,
for liability.
Why wouldn't I put a camera inthe hallway?
It seems so obvious.
Alexa (02:36):
So what's the hard and fast rule here?
Where does my private securityend?
And where does you know thatcommunal privacy begin?
Bob (02:43):
Right.
So the, the defining line is,uh, literally the interior of
your apartment,
Alexa (02:48):
just the door.
Bob (02:48):
Exactly.
Alexa (02:49):
Yeah.
Bob (02:49):
Inside your four walls, you have complete liberty.
You can, you know, install asmany cameras as you need.
Do whatever you want.
Alexa (02:55):
Okay.
Bob (02:55):
But the moment that lens crosses the threshold and points
into a common area, the hallway,the elevator lobby, you are
violating privacy.
And just as importantly,community aesthetics.
Alexa (03:06):
I get the privacy concern.
I mean, you're recording yourneighbors, their kids, their
guests, all without theirconsent.
But let's dig into the legalseverity of this.
The source material warns about.
Pretty severe penalties.
What does that actually mean?
Bob (03:22):
Yeah, it means this is not just a, you know, a, a minor
slap on the wrist from the condoadministration.
Alexa (03:28):
So it's not a$50 fine,
Bob (03:29):
not at all.
Mexico has strong federal lawsthat protect personal data and
privacy.
So if you're recording a commonhallway, you are in the eyes of
the law collecting the personaldata and images of everyone who
passes by.
Wow,
Alexa (03:43):
I never thought of it that way.
Personal data,
Bob (03:45):
that's what it is.
Without explicit consent andwithout a legitimate security
purpose that's been sanctionedby the entire community, you
could be facing significantfinancial fines.
We're talking thousands ofdollars,
Alexa (03:56):
okay,
Bob (03:56):
and mandated removal of the equipment and even legal action
from an offended neighbor whowants to press the issue, it
instantly elevates a simpleproperty rule violation into a a
serious legal matter.
Alexa (04:08):
That completely reframes the risk.
So it's not about having a fightwith your neighbor over their
welcome mat.
It's about breaking federalprivacy mandates
Bob (04:17):
precisely.
And then there's the other sideof it, the visual harmony
argument, which I find just ascompelling.
Alexa (04:23):
Explain that.
Why does one little camera posesuch a threat to the whole
building?
Bob (04:29):
Because it sets a physical precedent.
The bylaws are there to protectthe collective investment.
Right,
Alexa (04:34):
right.
The value of everyone's unit.
Bob (04:36):
Exactly.
And a huge part of thatprotection is maintaining a
unified high quality aesthetic.
So if the assembly lets oneowner bolt a visible camera
bracket and, you know, run wiresin the common hallway,
Alexa (04:50):
they have to let the next person do something else.
Bob (04:52):
They logically must permit the next owner to install a,
say, a large potted plant, orthe one after that to hang some
personalized signage.
As the analogy from the sourcesuggests, the visual space very
quickly devolves into a totalmess,
Alexa (05:05):
and that lowers the collective perception of quality
Bob (05:07):
and therefore the collective property value.
It makes the building feel cheapand disorganized.
Alexa (05:12):
So if an investor still feels they absolutely need that
entry and exit tracking fortheir rental, what is the
compliant workaround?
Bob (05:20):
The universally recommended solution is the digital
electronic people camera.
Alexa (05:25):
Ah, I've seen those.
Yeah,
Bob (05:26):
they're great.
These devices are self-containedwithin the doorframe.
They're very minimal in size,and they face outward just
enough to capture whoever'sdirectly at the door
Alexa (05:37):
so they're not panning down the entire hallway
recording Mrs.
Smith from three B
Bob (05:41):
Exactly.
They maintain the visual harmonyof the door and they
significantly mitigate thatbroader privacy intrusion.
Because their scope is solimited, they track access
without dominating the commonspace.
Alexa (05:53):
But let's say an investor is just insistent, they believe
a fixed external camera isabsolutely essential for their
business.
How do they navigate the legalrequirement?
Bob (06:02):
They have to go through the proper democratic process of the
community.
It's the only way.
Alexa (06:05):
The owner's assembly?
Bob (06:07):
Yes.
This means consulting andgaining explicit permission from
the condo owner's assembly.
And this is not a casualmeeting, you know, over coffee?
No.
It often requires a formalnotice of meeting.
Yeah.
You have to achieve quorum,which is a minimum number of
owners present or represented,and then you have to secure a
majority vote.
Sometimes, depending on thebylaws, it's even a super
(06:28):
majority to approve amodification like that.
Alexa (06:30):
And if they skip that step,
Bob (06:32):
if they skip it, they are entirely exposed to all those
legal penalties we justdiscussed.
It's a collective decisionbecause the space belongs to the
collective.
Simple as that.
Alexa (06:41):
This idea of community consensus and modification,
that's a perfect bridge to thenext topic.
Let's talk about the bylaws andthe role of the community more
broadly, especially when itcomes to pets.
Mm.
I thought the source material'sobservation on this was
fascinating.
The global trend of fewerchildren and more little dogs,
this has to be impactingproperty design everywhere.
Bob (07:03):
Oh, absolutely.
Alexa (07:03):
So our most new developments in the Riviera may
are, are they pet friendly now?
Bob (07:07):
Yes.
Generally speaking, they are,modern developments are
responding to this huge culturalshift and are typically designed
from the ground up to be.
Pet friendly.
Mm-hmm.
But this is where the nuancereally begins.
See, the developer provides afoundational set of bylaws.
It's like the basic constitutionfor the building, if you will.
The
Alexa (07:27):
skeleton.
Bob (07:27):
The skeleton, exactly.
It covers the fundamental thingslike how maintenance fees are
calculated, general operatinghours for the pool liability
stuff,
Alexa (07:36):
but those basic rules are never comprehensive enough for
day-to-day life.
Are they
Bob (07:40):
never.
They're skeletal.
They don't cover the specificsthat lead to friction between
neighbors, noise levels,specific pool hours, whether you
can hang your laundry on thebalcony or crucially, the
detailed rules for animals.
Alexa (07:53):
So who decides those limits?
Bob (07:55):
The community itself is done through the owner's
assembly.
Alexa (07:58):
So the community assembly gets together and decides, for
instance, that while dogs areallowed, they have to be under
say, 20 pounds
Bob (08:04):
precisely.
The assembly establishes thespecific limits.
Any registration requirementsand a structured finding system
for violations, they define thetypes of animals allowed.
It's, uh, humorously noted inthe source that you can't bring
exotic animals like jaguars orgiraffes,
Alexa (08:21):
chuckles.
Good to know,
Bob (08:23):
but the regulation is serious.
It prevents pets that might posea danger or require some kind of
specialized disruptive upkeep.
They might mandate leash rulesor designated pet relief areas,
or even specific elevator usagefor owners with pets.
Alexa (08:39):
This really highlights the immense power of the
assembly.
So the rules that the developergives you when you buy, they're
really just a starting point.
Bob (08:45):
That is the single key takeaway for any investor buying
into a condo.
You are buying into a livinglegal document.
The rules can change.
The owners by majority consensuscan add, modify, or even revoke
rules.
Alexa (08:59):
So a building could start out as pet friendly,
Bob (09:01):
right?
If a community initiallywelcomes pets, but then a few
years later they find the noiseor the sanitation burden is just
too high, the owners can vote tointroduce much stricter rules or
Alexa (09:10):
even ban them,
Bob (09:11):
or even potentially revoke the pet friendly status
entirely.
Now, that's complex and it hasto follow the process and not
violate fundamental privateproperty rights.
But it's possible, especiallyfor new residents, the common
areas and noise levels areabsolutely regulated by the
assembly.
Alexa (09:27):
So the community might think X today, let's say they
allow large dogs, but if a fewincidents happen, they can
collectively vote y tomorrow andsuddenly restrict all new dogs
over say 20 kilograms.
Bob (09:40):
You've got it.
So your engagement isn't justadvisory.
It's essential to protecting theoperational viability of your
investment.
Alexa (09:48):
It means you can't be an absentee owner, at least not an
absentee decision maker.
Bob (09:52):
Right.
You cannot just buy theapartment and then ignore the
quarterly assembly meetings.
Yeah, because that is the roomwhere the rules governing your
rental income, your security,and your daily life are being
decided.
Alexa (10:03):
Okay.
That covers the daily logistics.
Let's pivot now from rules tothe reason we're all here.
The end game,
Bob (10:09):
the financial payoff.
Alexa (10:11):
Exactly.
When you sell a successfulinvestment after five or seven
years, the profit.
Appreciation can be substantial,but the tax bill can be just as
substantial if you haven'tplanned ahead.
Mm-hmm.
We need a detailed understandingof the income tax on sale or
what's known as ISR in Mexico.
Bob (10:27):
Right.
ISR is the seller's liabilityand it's paid upon the transfer
of the property title.
The taxes calculated against theappreciation or the gain that
you made during your ownershipperiod and the initial rates,
well, they can look prettydaunting.
Alexa (10:42):
What are we talking?
Bob (10:42):
You're levy to either 25% on the total sale price.
Which is rarely the preferredmethod, for obvious reasons, or
up to 35% on the calculated netprofit.
Alexa (10:53):
Let's break down that net profit calculation.
What gets deducted before that35% tax is applied.
I think this is where people getconfused.
Bob (11:00):
It is.
So when you're calculating thenet profit, the notary's office.
Which actually acts as the taxcollector in this process, takes
the final appraised sale value.
Okay?
And then they deduct several keyitems.
First, the original purchaseprice you paid, and that's
adjusted for inflation over theyears you owned it.
That's
Alexa (11:16):
important.
Bob (11:17):
It is.
Second, any documented capitalimprovements, we're talking
major renovations, not just, youknow, fixing a leaky faucet, and
you have to have the properfactors, which are official
government sanctioned digitalreceipts.
So keep your paperwork.
Always and third, certaintransfer and closing costs can
be deducted, including notaryfees and sales commissions.
(11:38):
The taxes then applied towhatever is left.
That is the appreciation afterall those documented deductions,
Alexa (11:44):
even after those deductions, I mean 35% of a
large appreciation number, whichis common in these high growth
areas, that is a massive hit toyour return on investment.
That's
Bob (11:53):
huge.
Alexa (11:53):
This leads us directly to what the source material calls
the golden strategy.
Tax exemption strategy, which isachieved by proving primary
residence status.
Bob (12:03):
This is truly where the strategic investor separates
themselves from the pack.
Yeah.
If the seller can demonstratetwo things, one, that they are a
tax resident in Mexico, and twothat the property served as
their primary residence, theycan claim a significant tax
exemption on that.
ISR.
Alexa (12:18):
Now, is this only available to Mexican nationals
or can foreign investors takeadvantage of this?
Bob (12:23):
Foreign investors who have established tax residency and
that often requires a specificvisa status and fiscal
registration with the governmentcan absolutely use this.
The key is establishing thatresidency status first and then
proving the properties use.
Alexa (12:37):
Let's talk about the value threshold.
'cause that's gotta matter.
Bob (12:40):
Yeah.
Alexa (12:40):
Does this exemption apply to, you know, super high-end
luxury condos?
Bob (12:45):
That's a great question.
The exemption limit is based onsomething called udi's unis
inversion or investment units.
Alexa (12:51):
Okay.
What are uds?
Bob (12:53):
Think of them as a, uh, a financial instrument.
The Mexican government uses.
To adjust values based oninflation.
It's a sort of inflation proofunit of account.
So because the limit is based onuds, the actual peso amount of
the exemption thresholdautomatically increases with
inflation every year.
Alexa (13:11):
Ah, so it protects the investor's gain over time.
The goalposts keep moving
Bob (13:15):
precisely, and the source material confirms that the vast
majority of mid to upper tierinvestment apartments in these
tourist zones, you know, thetypical three to 6 million peso
range, they fall comfortablywithin this exemp.
Alexa (13:27):
So for most investors listening, this isn't just a
partial discount,
Bob (13:30):
not at all.
It often wipes out the entireISR tax liability on the capital
gain.
It could be a hundred percentexemption.
Alexa (13:36):
Now for the critical question, this is the one I've
been waiting for.
If an investor is using the unitas a vacation rental, 90% of the
time generating income, how dothey legally prove it's their
primary residence?
Without.
Actually living there full time.
Bob (13:51):
This is the operational magic, the essential primary
document required by the notaryand the tax authority, which is
called SAT to prove habitualresidence, is the CFE bill, the
electric bill, the electricbill, the commission federal,
the electricity odd bill.
If that bill is registered inthe seller's name for that
specific address, it acts asirrefutable proof of primary
(14:13):
resident status in the eyes ofthe tax mechanism for this
specific exemption.
Alexa (14:18):
That single piece of paper is the key that unlocks
potentially hundreds ofthousands of pesos in tax
savings.
It is.
But let's get into the nittygritty.
If I'm a foreign investorsetting up a rental, how do I
ensure the CFE bill is in mypersonal name and not say the
name of the previous owner orthe developer?
Bob (14:33):
That process is administrative, but it is
absolutely vital during theclosing and delivery process,
the has to coordinate with thedeveloper.
Or a local administrator toformally transfer the CFE
contract into their name.
Alexa (14:47):
What does that involve?
Bob (14:48):
It requires your notarized deed and your official
identification.
And sometimes, you know, CFEoffices can be a little
bureaucratic, especially whenthey're dealing with foreign id.
But it must be done.
Failure to have that bill inyour name means you forfeit the
entire tax advantage period.
Alexa (15:05):
What about alternatives?
Let's say the CFE bill isdelayed for some reason.
Can you use the water bill oryour bank statements?
Bob (15:12):
The CFE bill is the gold standard.
It's the strongest, moststandardized proof for this
specific real estate taxexemption.
Now, while some notaries mightaccept an alternative utility
bill or local bank statementshowing the address, those are
often considered secondaryproof.
Alexa (15:26):
So you're introducing risk,
Bob (15:28):
you're introducing risk.
Relying solely on them is agamble.
The CFE bill is the standardbecause it directly proves
electricity consumption at theresidency address.
It's tied directly to theseller's name.
Alexa (15:39):
Mm-hmm.
Okay.
Here is where we have tointroduce the critical
challenge.
If an investor is clearlyoperating a very successful
rental property and thenclaiming primary resident status
once every three years, how doesSAT, the Mexican Tax Authority
Police this?
I mean, isn't this an easilyabused loophole?
Bob (15:58):
It is a critical risk to acknowledge, and you have to be
smart about it.
The SAT is getting more and moresophisticated while the CFE bill
acts as the necessary proof forthe notary to authorize the
exemption at the time of sale,right?
The SAT always retains the rightto audit that transaction later.
The main red flag for them isinconsistency.
Alexa (16:18):
For example,
Bob (16:19):
for example, if the owner claims primary residence, but
their income tax filings inMexico, if they're filing them,
show zero expenses related toliving there.
Yeah.
Or if their rental incomefilings clearly show 360 days of
tenant occupancy for that year,
Alexa (16:33):
that's gonna trigger an audit.
Bob (16:34):
It could absolutely trigger about it.
So
Alexa (16:35):
the savvy investor has to maintain a paper trail that
supports the claim of habitualuse, even if it's just
intermittent.
You have to genuinely use theproperty for some personal stay.
Bob (16:45):
Absolutely.
It's a risk mitigation game.
The legal structure allows forthe exemption, but it requires
the investor to make sure theirtotal fiscal profile doesn't
just scream abuse.
You're leveraging a legaldistinction that was intended
for homeowners, but you'reapplying it.
To an investment property in amixed use strategy.
Alexa (17:03):
Okay, so let's summarize the whole thing.
The mixed investment strategy,you generate strong monthly cash
flow from short term rentals,maximizing your operational
income.
Mm-hmm.
And then after maximizingappreciation, you cycle the
asset every three years usingthat CFE bill to exempt the
capital gains tax
Bob (17:21):
that is the engine.
That three year frequency limitis vital.
You cannot cycle assets everysingle year.
Using this exemption, you mustwait a minimum of three years
from the date of your lastexempt sale to qualify again.
Alexa (17:32):
So that dictates your whole strategy.
Bob (17:34):
It dictates your optimal holding period and your exit
timing for maximum efficiency.
It forces a medium to long terminvestment outlook rather than
short term flipping.
Alexa (17:43):
It really transforms the electric bill from just a
monthly expense into thisincredibly powerful strategic
financial tool.
Understanding that Onedocument's power is, I argue,
the most valuable takeaway foran investor focused on wealth
accumulation in Mexico,
Bob (18:00):
moving from proactive tax planning to more uh, reactive
asset protection riskmitigation.
This starts from day one ofconstruction, and it continues
right through the unit's entireoperational life, relying very
heavily on proper insurance.
Alexa (18:15):
Let's tackle insurance during construction.
Investors often focus on thedeveloper's reputation, but what
financial mechanism providesmandatory protection during the
build phase?
Bob (18:24):
It comes down to the financing.
If the project is financiallysecured by a bank, meaning the
developer is using a bankbridge, loan insurance is
mandatory.
Alexa (18:32):
The bank makes them do it.
Bob (18:33):
The bank requires the developer to be fully insured
from the moment they breakground until the final delivery.
It's non-negotiable because thebank needs to protect its
collateral.
This policy typically covers allrisks, fire, natural disasters,
theft to materials, even civilengineering failures that might
halter compromise the structure.
Alexa (18:50):
So if a major storm hits a site that's financed by a
bank, the bank's insurancecovers the damage and ensures
the project can be completed,which protects my presale money
Bob (19:00):
precisely.
And this provides a very strongrisk indicator for you as an
investor.
Developers who are buildingexclusively with presale cash
funding.
Alexa (19:09):
No bank loan.
Bob (19:09):
No bank loan, yep.
They are very likely, as asource, says not to carry
comprehensive insurance duringconstruction because there's no
mandatory lender requiring it.
Alexa (19:19):
And in that scenario,
Bob (19:20):
in that scenario, if a major structural incident
occurs, say a severe hurricaneor a construction accident, the
financial risk lands squarely onthe developer.
If they lack the capital to fixit, it ultimately impacts you.
The presale buyer.
It could lead to significantdelays or even in a worst case
scenario, abandonment of theproject
Alexa (19:39):
that makes bank financing, not just a vote of
confidence in the developer, butan essential risk barrier for
the investor.
Bob (19:45):
Okay, so once the unit is delivered, the insurance
framework changes completely.
What happens Post-delivery.
The developer's constructionpolicy expires.
The moment that bridge loan ispaid off and the property is
handed over, the policy is gone.
Responsibility then immediatelyshifts to the collective
ownership and the insurancesplits into two essential tiers.
Alexa (20:05):
Okay?
Tier one, protecting thestructure and the whole common
investment.
Bob (20:09):
That is the condo assembly insurance.
The owners through theiradministration decide on and
purchase a general insurancepolicy.
This policy covers the commonareas, the pool, the gardens,
the gym, the building,structural integrity, so the
foundation, walls, roof,
Alexa (20:25):
the big stuff,
Bob (20:26):
the big stuff, and the exterior facade.
It's generally defined aseverything from the exterior
face of your apartment dooroutward.
This policy is usually paid foroutta the monthly maintenance
fees, and it's critical fordisaster recovery and general
liability on common property.
Alexa (20:40):
And then tier two.
Protecting my personal propertyinside my four walls.
Bob (20:45):
That's the individual owner insurance.
The structure may be protectedby the assembly, but each owner
is individually responsible forensuring their specific private
square footage.
This includes all your contents,your furniture, your internal
equipment, and personalliability within the unit.
Alexa (21:01):
Okay?
Bob (21:01):
However, the source does note that administrations often
arrange group packages forinternal insurance with the same
carrier that covers the commonareas.
This can be significantlycheaper because the insurance
company is already familiar withthe risk profile of the
building.
Alexa (21:15):
That's a good tip.
Let's pivot to the Caribbeanclimate.
The threat of hurricanes isconstant, but the source
material highlights thiscritical geographic defense
mechanism that reduces the riskprofile for investors in Playa
Del Carmen.
Specifically,
Bob (21:29):
yes, this is a fascinating geographical detail.
Developers in Cantana Ru, theybuild to very high seismic and
wind standards, but the entiremainland benefits from what the
source calls a tremendous,tremendous advantage.
The island of Cozumel,
Alexa (21:44):
how exactly does Cozumel act as this tremendous barrier?
Bob (21:47):
So Cozumel is situated directly offshore and it runs
parallel to the coast.
Hurricanes typically approachthe mainland from the east
coming across the Caribbean Sea,
Alexa (21:56):
right into Cosm Mill's path.
Bob (21:58):
Cosmal is sitting right in the path.
The island acts as this massivenatural shield.
It absorbs so much of theinitial storm surge, the wind
speed, and the kinetic energy ofthe storm.
When a major hurricane hitsCosmal, takes the brunt of it,
effectively dampening the stormbefore it can reach the densely
populated, developed mean landareas like Playa del Carmen and
(22:19):
Tulum.
Alexa (22:20):
It's like the ultimate geographic bodyguard.
It's just sitting there reducingthe velocity and the flood risk
for the investment location.
Bob (22:26):
Exactly right.
This geographical protection isoften cited as a key reason why
development success in Playa delCarmen has been so sustained
compared to other parts of theCaribbean basin.
It inherently reduces theaverage risk profile of any
investment there.
Alexa (22:40):
Beyond the geography, there's the human element,
right?
Preparation and tracking.
Bob (22:44):
Yes.
And the region has excellentdisaster preparation systems,
unlike say an earthquake,hurricanes are not sudden
events.
They're tracked by verysophisticated weather systems
for 10 days, sometimes more inadvance.
Alexa (22:57):
That lead time is crucial.
Bob (22:59):
It's everything.
It allows developers tocompletely secure their
construction sites, taping downdebris, securing heavy equipment
and lumber.
And it gives condominiumadministrations ample time to
prepare the delivered units,secure furniture on terraces,
and implement residentevacuation plans if they're
necessary.
That advanced warningdramatically mitigates the
physical damage risk.
Alexa (23:20):
Finally, for the high volume rental investor, there is
an often overlooked safety netthat's built right into the
operational platformsthemselves.
Rental platform protection.
Bob (23:28):
Yes.
For investors who are using themajor platforms like Airbnb or
booking.com, there is animplicit layer of internal
protection.
These platforms offer reallystrong protection as the horse
puts it for tenant cause damageto your internal equipment and
furniture.
Alexa (23:44):
So if a guest breaks a sofa or damages an appliance,
Bob (23:47):
the platforms typically take a hundred percent
responsibility for the cost ofthat damage.
Often up to very significantlimits depending on the program
they offer.
Alexa (23:56):
That's a huge operational relief.
You don't have to chase thetenant down over a broken
television.
The platform handles the claimand the reimbursement.
Bob (24:04):
It acts as an effective, built-in protection against this
specific risk of tenantnegligence or carelessness,
which is really the highestoperational risk for any
short-term rental.
It allows the investor topotentially minimize the
internal contents coverage ontheir personal policy, knowing
that tenant damage is largelycovered by the platform.
Alexa (24:23):
Now we enter the moment of delivery.
The emotional high of buying thevision clashes with the cold
reality of the deliveredproduct.
We need to address the crucialdifference between the showroom
experience and the actualspecifications.
Bob (24:36):
The showroom is a masterpiece of psychological
marketing.
It is built to display theapartment's maximum potential.
Every single detail.
The scent in the air, thespecific art on the walls, the
high-end imported furniture, thedramatic lighting, it's all
selected to evoke an emotionalresponse
Alexa (24:51):
to make you feel like you're already living that
luxury lifestyle.
Bob (24:54):
Exactly.
It's selling the dream, notnecessarily the invoice.
Alexa (24:57):
Right.
Bob (24:58):
And the savvy investor must immediately separate that
emotional decor from thecontractual fixtures.
Developers often put up veryclear signs, clarifying that the
unit is not delivered as seen.
The furniture, the artwork,specific designer, light
fixtures, the electronics, thoseare usually just staging
elements.
They're not included in thepurchase price unless you've
(25:20):
explicitly added them.
Alexa (25:22):
To avoid confusion, we really need to clarify the
difference between the threecommon delivery types that
investors will encounter in themarket.
Let's start with the baselinefully equipped.
Bob (25:31):
A fully equipped unit includes the core fixed
operational elements.
The source defines thisperfectly as the items that
wouldn't fall out if you turnthe apartment upside down.
Alexa (25:41):
I like that.
Bob (25:41):
It's a good visual.
This means the structuralcomponents, your built-in
kitchen cabinetry.
Maybe a granite or quartzcountertop.
The sink, the AC units installedin the walls.
Ceiling fans, these are usuallynon-negotiable fixtures, but the
brands in quality is at apremium Samsung fridge versus an
economy local brand that must bescrutinized on the spec sheet.
Alexa (26:02):
Okay, next up is the widely used term turnkey.
Bob (26:05):
A turnkey unit goes a big step beyond equipped.
It means the property is readyto generate income or be lived
in immediately.
The second you get the key.
Alexa (26:14):
So that includes furniture.
Bob (26:15):
It implies furniture, bedding, linens, small kitchen
appliances, like a toaster andcoffee acre, all the necessary
utensils.
A true turnkey unit is instantlyoperational.
It's the easiest path forinternational investors who need
to start renting right awaywithout dealing with local
sourcing and installation.
Alexa (26:32):
And finally, the furniture package.
Bob (26:34):
This is an optional add-on that provides customization.
So instead of just accepting thedeveloper's, standardized,
turnkey set, the buyer workswith an interior designer to
select specific materials,colors, and furniture pieces to
create a more personalizedaesthetic.
Alexa (26:47):
Generally more expensive, I'd assume?
Bob (26:49):
Yes.
Generally more expensive, but itallows the unit to stand out in
what can be a very crowdedrental market.
Alexa (26:55):
Whether it's fully equipped or turnkey, the moment
of truth rests entirely on onedocument, the spec sheet or the
technical sheet.
Why is this document the sourceof so much potential investor
disappointment?
Why does it get the title of theasterisk trap?
Bob (27:11):
Because it can be highly, highly misleading.
It blurs the line between yourexpectation and the material.
Reality developers arecapitalizing on new material
trends.
For example, the marketingbrochure might promise marble
walls or exotic wood floors, butyou have to look very closely at
the fine print.
Alexa (27:29):
So the expectation is this premium, durable material,
but the reality is often just animitation.
Bob (27:34):
Precisely.
We see the asterisk crapdeployed in three common areas.
First, flooring and walls.
The spec sheet might listpremium porcelain tile imitating
wood grain, or PVC panelsreplicating marble.
The truth is often revealed inthat tiny asterisk at the bottom
of the page stating, finishbased on imitation material,
Alexa (27:52):
and the durability and lifespan of PVC are vastly
different from marble.
Bob (27:56):
Oh, completely different.
You need to adjust yourexpectations and your
maintenance budget accordingly.
Alexa (28:02):
What's a second area?
Cabinetry and woodworking.
Bob (28:05):
The spec sheet might claim fine wood finishes, but the
asterisk often reveals that it'snot solid tropical hardwood,
which is expensive, but highlydurable.
It's actually MDF medium densityfiberboard, or a veneer with a
specific laminate on top,
Alexa (28:20):
and for a vacation rental unit in high humidity.
Bob (28:23):
Exactly.
A unit subjected to constanthigh humidity and frequent
cleaning.
Using a cheaper material likeMDF instead of solid wood
significantly increases thelong-term risk of it warping and
needing to be replaced muchsooner.
Alexa (28:36):
And the third area appliances and fixtures,
Bob (28:38):
you need to know the specific brand and model number
of the refrigerator, the ACunits, the faucets.
Hmm.
A vague claim of premiumfixtures can easily hide economy
level brands.
The spec sheet has to containspecific material names like
quartz countertop with specificbrand seal or inverter
technology, AC unit brand X.
If it's vague, that is a hugered flag that demands further
(29:00):
inquiry.
Alexa (29:00):
So what's the ultimate rule of thumb for an investor
walking through that beautifulshowroom?
Bob (29:05):
Do not let the beauty of the staging, the pretty sofa or
the stunning view, distract you.
You have to maintain a laserfocus on the technical sheet.
You need to know if you arepaying for real stone that
requires specific maintenance ora durable quartz or a cheaper
imitation that will need earlierreplacement.
Alexa (29:22):
The choice should match the use.
Bob (29:24):
Absolutely.
The material choice has to alignwith your intended usage.
A durable stain resistant quartzor porcelain is often a far, far
better choice for a high volumevacation rental than natural
marble.
Even though marble is moreluxurious, the focus must be on
durability and reducing yourlong-term maintenance costs.
(29:45):
We shift now to the final and,uh, perhaps most sensitive
aspect of investing, thelong-term legal and family
implications.
This is all about ensuring theasset you've worked so hard to
acquire continues to benefityour family seamlessly.
Alexa (29:58):
Let's start at the beginning, co-ownership.
If a family or maybe somebusiness partners want to pool
their resources, how does thatprocess work?
Bob (30:04):
It's entirely possible and actually very common to buy
property in co-ownership.
The deed itself can beregistered to multiple
individuals, say a marriedcouple and their two adult
children.
The percentages of ownership foreach person are recorded right
there on the deed.
Alexa (30:19):
And why would people do that?
Bob (30:21):
It's often done to simplify the asset, transfer down the
line, or simply to leverage theexpertise and capital of
multiple parties to afford theinvestment.
Alexa (30:30):
This leads us directly to the issue of asset transfer upon
death.
A major finding forinternational investors is the
situation regarding inheritancetax.
In Mexico.
Bob (30:40):
This is a tremendous advantage that Mexico offers
compared to the US or much ofEurope.
There is no federal inheritancetax in Mexico when property is
passed to an heir.
The government does not levy apercentage tax on the value of
the inherited assets themselves.
Alexa (30:55):
That's huge.
That simplifies wealth transfersignificantly.
However, if the planning isn'tdone correctly during the
parent's lifetime, the childrencould still face a tax liability
when they receive the assetsright.
The property acquisition tax
Bob (31:07):
absolutely corrected.
This is the crucial nuance thattrips up so many foreign
investors.
While there's no inheritancetax, there is still the property
acquisition tax known as ISA,which is levied anytime the
title changes hands.
Okay.
So if the property is solely inthe parents' names and then
transferred later upon theirdeath, the children will have to
pay the ISAI, which could bebetween 2% and 5% of the
(31:31):
appraised value, just toregister the new title in their
names
Alexa (31:35):
so the family avoids.
Say a 30% federal inheritancetax, but they could still face a
4% acquisition tax.
'cause the legal transferrequires a whole new valuation.
They've got it.
So how do sophisticatedinvestors mitigate this
acquisition tax liability whilestill controlling the asset
during their lifetime?
Bob (31:52):
They often use a, uh, complex but very effective legal
mechanism called the use offructose veal.
Alexa (31:58):
A life estate.
Bob (31:58):
A life estate, exactly.
Oh.
This essentially separates theownership rights into two
distinctive parts.
The parent returns the use offructo, which is the right to
use the property live in it, andmost importantly, collect all
the rental income it generatesfor the rest of their life.
Alexa (32:13):
And what happens to the bare title, the actual ownership
papers.
Bob (32:16):
The parents simultaneously transferred the nude to prop the
bear title to their children.
And because the transfer of thebear title happens during the
parent's lifetime, theacquisition tax, the ISAI is
calculated on the much lowervalue of the bear title at that
time.
Alexa (32:32):
I see.
Bob (32:33):
Then when the parents eventually pass away, the use of
fructose naturally extinguishesand it merges with the neuter
proppy dead.
The children automaticallyreceive full ownership without
triggering another round of highacquisition tax.
Alexa (32:45):
That's a powerful way to freeze the tax liability early,
while you still retain all theoperational control and the
income rights.
It sounds like a complexprocess, though.
Bob (32:55):
It is, and it requires very careful structuring with a good
notary to ensure all partiesunderstand the limitations.
For instance, the bear titleowners, the children, they can't
sell the property without theconsent of the use of fructo
owners, the parents.
It adds legal complexity, but itoften provides very significant
tax savings for the heirs.
Alexa (33:13):
This brings us to what might be the single most
important piece of legalpaperwork and investor must
execute regardless of their age,the paramount role of the will.
Bob (33:23):
This cannot be overstated.
Investors often assume thatbecause they have a contract or
maybe they have a will fromtheir home country, that the
asset transfer will be simple.
Alexa (33:32):
That's wrong,
Bob (33:34):
that is wrong.
At the national federal level inMexico, only a properly executed
legal Mexican will carries legalweight for the swift transfer of
property.
Alexa (33:44):
Why is this planning so crucial for someone who's, you
know, in their prime earningyears, maybe in their forties or
fifties.
Bob (33:50):
Because life is unpredictable and a failure to
plan turns an asset into aproblem.
If property owners pass awaywithout a will, the estate
enters a process calledsecession in testamentary in
test state succession.
Alexa (34:02):
And what does that mean?
Bob (34:04):
It means the process is entirely controlled by the
courts, and it instantly becomesas the source says.
Cumbersome, time consuming, andvery expensive.
Alexa (34:12):
How time consuming are we talking about here?
Are we talking months?
Yeah, years.
Bob (34:16):
Depending on the jurisdiction and the complexity
of the family structure, it cantake anywhere from one to three
years for the courts to legallysettle who the rightful heirs
are and authorize the sale ortransfer of the property, a
three year delay, and duringthat entire period.
The asset is typically frozen.
It cannot be rented, it can't besold, it can't be modified.
(34:37):
It just sits there costingmoney.
Alexa (34:39):
So the family not only incurs significant legal and
administrative cost, but theyalso lose years of potential
rental income from the veryinvestment you bought for them.
Bob (34:49):
Exactly.
You intended to leave yourchildren a valuable income
generating asset, and insteadyou've left them a debilitating
administrative nightmare andoften a source of family
conflict.
A clear legal will ensures theproperty passes immediately to
the intended beneficiaries.
It prevents disputes betweensiblings and it guarantees that
the heirs can access and enjoythe asset without unnecessary
(35:11):
delay or cost.
It is the ultimate act offinancial responsibility to
protect your investment for thenext generation.
Alexa (35:18):
That was an incredibly comprehensive deep dive.
We went from the nuances ofcommunity privacy all the way to
the complexities ofinternational wealth transfer.
We've covered essentialactionable knowledge that goes
so far beyond just the initialpurchase price.
Bob (35:33):
Let's quickly recap the three most powerful strategic
takeaways that every investorreally needs for a member.
First, the operational magic ofthe CFE electric bill.
Alexa (35:43):
The Humble Utility Bill.
Bob (35:44):
Yes, ensure that document is in your name and it's active
as it is the single mostimportant piece of evidence
you'll need to leverage theprimary residence exemption and
shield your capital appreciationfrom the ISR sellers tax.
Once every three years.
Alexa (35:58):
Second, takeaway the dynamic reality of condo
ownership.
You are buying into a livingdemocracy.
The collective power of thecondo assembly means the rules
regarding pets, aesthetics,common areas, they're constantly
subject to change.
Bob (36:11):
You have to stay engaged.
Investors must remain engaged orrisk seeing rules enacted that
could negatively affect theirrental operation.
Alexa (36:18):
And finally,
Bob (36:19):
and finally, the paramount legal necessity of the will.
Due to the lack of a federalinheritance tax, but the
presence of that propertyacquisition tax planning via a
Mexican will and potentiallyusing mechanisms like the use of
fructo vitalio is the only wayto ensure your investment
transfers efficiently, costeffectively, and without turning
(36:39):
the asset into a legal burdenfor your family.
Alexa (36:41):
So here is the final, provocative thought for you to
take away.
Investing in a condominium meansnavigating that delicate balance
between your private rights andthe community's collective will.
We talked about how a communitythrough consensus can change
rules about cameras or pets.
If you were sitting at the nextowner's assembly meeting,
understanding that you have thepower to shape the future
(37:02):
operation of the building, whatpart of the existing condo
bylaws would you vote to changefirst to maximize your
investment success?
Bob (37:09):
Being this informed is the difference between simply owning
a property and successfullymanaging an asset.
Thank you for taking this deepdive with us and focusing on
those crucial details that leadto long-term profitability and
just as important peace of mind.
Welcome back to the Deep Dive.
(00:01):
If you are an investor who'slooking past that initial
property acquisition, past thebeautiful rendering and the
closing table, then this is youressential shortcut.
Today we are taking a stack ofreally specific investor
questions.
We're talking about theoperational realities in these
high growth condo markets, uh,specifically focusing on the
regulatory, legal, and financialside of things in the Riviera
(00:25):
Maya,
Bob (00:26):
and that's.
Really the crucial shift, isn'tit?
The sales process, it gets allthe attention, but your true
long-term success, I mean,minimizing risk, maximizing your
profit, that depends entirely onhow you.
Handle the day to day.
Alexa (00:40):
The logistics.
Bob (00:41):
The logistics, the community dynamics, and this is
the most important part, theplanned exit.
We've collected questions that,uh, that really cut straight to
the core of these complexities,
Alexa (00:50):
and that is our mission today, to give you the
actionable details on everythingthat happens.
After you get the keys, we areunpacking the, the nuances of
communal living.
Yeah.
Like how far can the condoassembly really.
Go in dictating how you use yourunit.
We're going to detail exactlywhy a standard utility bill is,
believe it or not, your mostpowerful tool for tax exemption.
Bob (01:11):
It's amazing how many people miss that one.
Alexa (01:13):
And critically, how to avoid the deadly asterisk trap
that's, you know, hidden deepwithin your technical spec
sheet.
Bob (01:21):
And we'll wrap up by dissecting risk mitigation.
Talk about mandatory insurance,the, the really fascinating
geographic advantage that CosmMill provides to the mainland.
Alexa (01:32):
Oh, that part is incredible.
Bob (01:33):
It really is.
And why?
The most critical piece of legalpaperwork you'll sign has
nothing to do with the purchase,but, uh, everything to do with
protecting your family'sinheritance down the line.
Alexa (01:43):
Okay, let's unpack this.
We should start where theconflict, you know, it often
begins right away Hmm.
At the boundary of your personalinvestment and the shared
community space.
The
Bob (01:51):
front door.
Alexa (01:51):
Exactly.
The front door.
The minute an investor acceptsdelivery of their unit, they
basically transition from beinga consumer to, uh, being a
member of a mini government.
Mm-hmm.
Bob (02:01):
The condominium associ.
Alexa (02:03):
Right, and this immediately creates a conflict
between your individual desirefor security and the community's
need for well harmony andprivacy.
Let's start with one of the mostcommon friction points we've
seen.
We're calling it the cameraconundrum.
Bob (02:18):
It's absolutely everywhere.
It's especially with investorswho are planning on doing short
term rentals.
Alexa (02:22):
Yeah,
Bob (02:23):
the investor's logic is.
You know, it's flawless.
Alexa (02:26):
Of course, I need to track who's coming and going.
Bob (02:28):
Exactly.
I need to track who accesses myunit, especially for insurance,
for liability.
Why wouldn't I put a camera inthe hallway?
It seems so obvious.
Alexa (02:36):
So what's the hard and fast rule here?
Where does my private securityend?
And where does you know thatcommunal privacy begin?
Bob (02:43):
Right.
So the, the defining line is,uh, literally the interior of
your apartment,
Alexa (02:48):
just the door.
Bob (02:48):
Exactly.
Alexa (02:49):
Yeah.
Bob (02:49):
Inside your four walls, you have complete liberty.
You can, you know, install asmany cameras as you need.
Do whatever you want.
Alexa (02:55):
Okay.
Bob (02:55):
But the moment that lens crosses the threshold and points
into a common area, the hallway,the elevator lobby, you are
violating privacy.
And just as importantly,community aesthetics.
Alexa (03:06):
I get the privacy concern.
I mean, you're recording yourneighbors, their kids, their
guests, all without theirconsent.
But let's dig into the legalseverity of this.
The source material warns about.
Pretty severe penalties.
What does that actually mean?
Bob (03:22):
Yeah, it means this is not just a, you know, a, a minor
slap on the wrist from the condoadministration.
Alexa (03:28):
So it's not a$50 fine,
Bob (03:29):
not at all.
Mexico has strong federal lawsthat protect personal data and
privacy.
So if you're recording a commonhallway, you are in the eyes of
the law collecting the personaldata and images of everyone who
passes by.
Wow,
Alexa (03:43):
I never thought of it that way.
Personal data,
Bob (03:45):
that's what it is.
Without explicit consent andwithout a legitimate security
purpose that's been sanctionedby the entire community, you
could be facing significantfinancial fines.
We're talking thousands ofdollars,
Alexa (03:56):
okay,
Bob (03:56):
and mandated removal of the equipment and even legal action
from an offended neighbor whowants to press the issue, it
instantly elevates a simpleproperty rule violation into a a
serious legal matter.
Alexa (04:08):
That completely reframes the risk.
So it's not about having a fightwith your neighbor over their
welcome mat.
It's about breaking federalprivacy mandates
Bob (04:17):
precisely.
And then there's the other sideof it, the visual harmony
argument, which I find just ascompelling.
Alexa (04:23):
Explain that.
Why does one little camera posesuch a threat to the whole
building?
Bob (04:29):
Because it sets a physical precedent.
The bylaws are there to protectthe collective investment.
Right,
Alexa (04:34):
right.
The value of everyone's unit.
Bob (04:36):
Exactly.
And a huge part of thatprotection is maintaining a
unified high quality aesthetic.
So if the assembly lets oneowner bolt a visible camera
bracket and, you know, run wiresin the common hallway,
Alexa (04:50):
they have to let the next person do something else.
Bob (04:52):
They logically must permit the next owner to install a,
say, a large potted plant, orthe one after that to hang some
personalized signage.
As the analogy from the sourcesuggests, the visual space very
quickly devolves into a totalmess,
Alexa (05:05):
and that lowers the collective perception of quality
Bob (05:07):
and therefore the collective property value.
It makes the building feel cheapand disorganized.
Alexa (05:12):
So if an investor still feels they absolutely need that
entry and exit tracking fortheir rental, what is the
compliant workaround?
Bob (05:20):
The universally recommended solution is the digital
electronic people camera.
Alexa (05:25):
Ah, I've seen those.
Yeah,
Bob (05:26):
they're great.
These devices are self-containedwithin the doorframe.
They're very minimal in size,and they face outward just
enough to capture whoever'sdirectly at the door
Alexa (05:37):
so they're not panning down the entire hallway
recording Mrs.
Smith from three B
Bob (05:41):
Exactly.
They maintain the visual harmonyof the door and they
significantly mitigate thatbroader privacy intrusion.
Because their scope is solimited, they track access
without dominating the commonspace.
Alexa (05:53):
But let's say an investor is just insistent, they believe
a fixed external camera isabsolutely essential for their
business.
How do they navigate the legalrequirement?
Bob (06:02):
They have to go through the proper democratic process of the
community.
It's the only way.
Alexa (06:05):
The owner's assembly?
Bob (06:07):
Yes.
This means consulting andgaining explicit permission from
the condo owner's assembly.
And this is not a casualmeeting, you know, over coffee?
No.
It often requires a formalnotice of meeting.
Yeah.
You have to achieve quorum,which is a minimum number of
owners present or represented,and then you have to secure a
majority vote.
Sometimes, depending on thebylaws, it's even a super
(06:28):
majority to approve amodification like that.
Alexa (06:30):
And if they skip that step,
Bob (06:32):
if they skip it, they are entirely exposed to all those
legal penalties we justdiscussed.
It's a collective decisionbecause the space belongs to the
collective.
Simple as that.
Alexa (06:41):
This idea of community consensus and modification,
that's a perfect bridge to thenext topic.
Let's talk about the bylaws andthe role of the community more
broadly, especially when itcomes to pets.
Mm.
I thought the source material'sobservation on this was
fascinating.
The global trend of fewerchildren and more little dogs,
this has to be impactingproperty design everywhere.
Bob (07:03):
Oh, absolutely.
Alexa (07:03):
So our most new developments in the Riviera may
are, are they pet friendly now?
Bob (07:07):
Yes.
Generally speaking, they are,modern developments are
responding to this huge culturalshift and are typically designed
from the ground up to be.
Pet friendly.
Mm-hmm.
But this is where the nuancereally begins.
See, the developer provides afoundational set of bylaws.
It's like the basic constitutionfor the building, if you will.
The
Alexa (07:27):
skeleton.
Bob (07:27):
The skeleton, exactly.
It covers the fundamental thingslike how maintenance fees are
calculated, general operatinghours for the pool liability
stuff,
Alexa (07:36):
but those basic rules are never comprehensive enough for
day-to-day life.
Are they
Bob (07:40):
never.
They're skeletal.
They don't cover the specificsthat lead to friction between
neighbors, noise levels,specific pool hours, whether you
can hang your laundry on thebalcony or crucially, the
detailed rules for animals.
Alexa (07:53):
So who decides those limits?
Bob (07:55):
The community itself is done through the owner's
assembly.
Alexa (07:58):
So the community assembly gets together and decides, for
instance, that while dogs areallowed, they have to be under
say, 20 pounds
Bob (08:04):
precisely.
The assembly establishes thespecific limits.
Any registration requirementsand a structured finding system
for violations, they define thetypes of animals allowed.
It's, uh, humorously noted inthe source that you can't bring
exotic animals like jaguars orgiraffes,
Alexa (08:21):
chuckles.
Good to know,
Bob (08:23):
but the regulation is serious.
It prevents pets that might posea danger or require some kind of
specialized disruptive upkeep.
They might mandate leash rulesor designated pet relief areas,
or even specific elevator usagefor owners with pets.
Alexa (08:39):
This really highlights the immense power of the
assembly.
So the rules that the developergives you when you buy, they're
really just a starting point.
Bob (08:45):
That is the single key takeaway for any investor buying
into a condo.
You are buying into a livinglegal document.
The rules can change.
The owners by majority consensuscan add, modify, or even revoke
rules.
Alexa (08:59):
So a building could start out as pet friendly,
Bob (09:01):
right?
If a community initiallywelcomes pets, but then a few
years later they find the noiseor the sanitation burden is just
too high, the owners can vote tointroduce much stricter rules or
Alexa (09:10):
even ban them,
Bob (09:11):
or even potentially revoke the pet friendly status
entirely.
Now, that's complex and it hasto follow the process and not
violate fundamental privateproperty rights.
But it's possible, especiallyfor new residents, the common
areas and noise levels areabsolutely regulated by the
assembly.
Alexa (09:27):
So the community might think X today, let's say they
allow large dogs, but if a fewincidents happen, they can
collectively vote y tomorrow andsuddenly restrict all new dogs
over say 20 kilograms.
Bob (09:40):
You've got it.
So your engagement isn't justadvisory.
It's essential to protecting theoperational viability of your
investment.
Alexa (09:48):
It means you can't be an absentee owner, at least not an
absentee decision maker.
Bob (09:52):
Right.
You cannot just buy theapartment and then ignore the
quarterly assembly meetings.
Yeah, because that is the roomwhere the rules governing your
rental income, your security,and your daily life are being
decided.
Alexa (10:03):
Okay.
That covers the daily logistics.
Let's pivot now from rules tothe reason we're all here.
The end game,
Bob (10:09):
the financial payoff.
Alexa (10:11):
Exactly.
When you sell a successfulinvestment after five or seven
years, the profit.
Appreciation can be substantial,but the tax bill can be just as
substantial if you haven'tplanned ahead.
Mm-hmm.
We need a detailed understandingof the income tax on sale or
what's known as ISR in Mexico.
Bob (10:27):
Right.
ISR is the seller's liabilityand it's paid upon the transfer
of the property title.
The taxes calculated against theappreciation or the gain that
you made during your ownershipperiod and the initial rates,
well, they can look prettydaunting.
Alexa (10:42):
What are we talking?
Bob (10:42):
You're levy to either 25% on the total sale price.
Which is rarely the preferredmethod, for obvious reasons, or
up to 35% on the calculated netprofit.
Alexa (10:53):
Let's break down that net profit calculation.
What gets deducted before that35% tax is applied.
I think this is where people getconfused.
Bob (11:00):
It is.
So when you're calculating thenet profit, the notary's office.
Which actually acts as the taxcollector in this process, takes
the final appraised sale value.
Okay?
And then they deduct several keyitems.
First, the original purchaseprice you paid, and that's
adjusted for inflation over theyears you owned it.
That's
Alexa (11:16):
important.
Bob (11:17):
It is.
Second, any documented capitalimprovements, we're talking
major renovations, not just, youknow, fixing a leaky faucet, and
you have to have the properfactors, which are official
government sanctioned digitalreceipts.
So keep your paperwork.
Always and third, certaintransfer and closing costs can
be deducted, including notaryfees and sales commissions.
(11:38):
The taxes then applied towhatever is left.
That is the appreciation afterall those documented deductions,
Alexa (11:44):
even after those deductions, I mean 35% of a
large appreciation number, whichis common in these high growth
areas, that is a massive hit toyour return on investment.
That's
Bob (11:53):
huge.
Alexa (11:53):
This leads us directly to what the source material calls
the golden strategy.
Tax exemption strategy, which isachieved by proving primary
residence status.
Bob (12:03):
This is truly where the strategic investor separates
themselves from the pack.
Yeah.
If the seller can demonstratetwo things, one, that they are a
tax resident in Mexico, and twothat the property served as
their primary residence, theycan claim a significant tax
exemption on that.
ISR.
Alexa (12:18):
Now, is this only available to Mexican nationals
or can foreign investors takeadvantage of this?
Bob (12:23):
Foreign investors who have established tax residency and
that often requires a specificvisa status and fiscal
registration with the governmentcan absolutely use this.
The key is establishing thatresidency status first and then
proving the properties use.
Alexa (12:37):
Let's talk about the value threshold.
'cause that's gotta matter.
Bob (12:40):
Yeah.
Alexa (12:40):
Does this exemption apply to, you know, super high-end
luxury condos?
Bob (12:45):
That's a great question.
The exemption limit is based onsomething called udi's unis
inversion or investment units.
Alexa (12:51):
Okay.
What are uds?
Bob (12:53):
Think of them as a, uh, a financial instrument.
The Mexican government uses.
To adjust values based oninflation.
It's a sort of inflation proofunit of account.
So because the limit is based onuds, the actual peso amount of
the exemption thresholdautomatically increases with
inflation every year.
Alexa (13:11):
Ah, so it protects the investor's gain over time.
The goalposts keep moving
Bob (13:15):
precisely, and the source material confirms that the vast
majority of mid to upper tierinvestment apartments in these
tourist zones, you know, thetypical three to 6 million peso
range, they fall comfortablywithin this exemp.
Alexa (13:27):
So for most investors listening, this isn't just a
partial discount,
Bob (13:30):
not at all.
It often wipes out the entireISR tax liability on the capital
gain.
It could be a hundred percentexemption.
Alexa (13:36):
Now for the critical question, this is the one I've
been waiting for.
If an investor is using the unitas a vacation rental, 90% of the
time generating income, how dothey legally prove it's their
primary residence?
Without.
Actually living there full time.
Bob (13:51):
This is the operational magic, the essential primary
document required by the notaryand the tax authority, which is
called SAT to prove habitualresidence, is the CFE bill, the
electric bill, the electricbill, the commission federal,
the electricity odd bill.
If that bill is registered inthe seller's name for that
specific address, it acts asirrefutable proof of primary
(14:13):
resident status in the eyes ofthe tax mechanism for this
specific exemption.
Alexa (14:18):
That single piece of paper is the key that unlocks
potentially hundreds ofthousands of pesos in tax
savings.
It is.
But let's get into the nittygritty.
If I'm a foreign investorsetting up a rental, how do I
ensure the CFE bill is in mypersonal name and not say the
name of the previous owner orthe developer?
Bob (14:33):
That process is administrative, but it is
absolutely vital during theclosing and delivery process,
the has to coordinate with thedeveloper.
Or a local administrator toformally transfer the CFE
contract into their name.
Alexa (14:47):
What does that involve?
Bob (14:48):
It requires your notarized deed and your official
identification.
And sometimes, you know, CFEoffices can be a little
bureaucratic, especially whenthey're dealing with foreign id.
But it must be done.
Failure to have that bill inyour name means you forfeit the
entire tax advantage period.
Alexa (15:05):
What about alternatives?
Let's say the CFE bill isdelayed for some reason.
Can you use the water bill oryour bank statements?
Bob (15:12):
The CFE bill is the gold standard.
It's the strongest, moststandardized proof for this
specific real estate taxexemption.
Now, while some notaries mightaccept an alternative utility
bill or local bank statementshowing the address, those are
often considered secondaryproof.
Alexa (15:26):
So you're introducing risk,
Bob (15:28):
you're introducing risk.
Relying solely on them is agamble.
The CFE bill is the standardbecause it directly proves
electricity consumption at theresidency address.
It's tied directly to theseller's name.
Alexa (15:39):
Mm-hmm.
Okay.
Here is where we have tointroduce the critical
challenge.
If an investor is clearlyoperating a very successful
rental property and thenclaiming primary resident status
once every three years, how doesSAT, the Mexican Tax Authority
Police this?
I mean, isn't this an easilyabused loophole?
Bob (15:58):
It is a critical risk to acknowledge, and you have to be
smart about it.
The SAT is getting more and moresophisticated while the CFE bill
acts as the necessary proof forthe notary to authorize the
exemption at the time of sale,right?
The SAT always retains the rightto audit that transaction later.
The main red flag for them isinconsistency.
Alexa (16:18):
For example,
Bob (16:19):
for example, if the owner claims primary residence, but
their income tax filings inMexico, if they're filing them,
show zero expenses related toliving there.
Yeah.
Or if their rental incomefilings clearly show 360 days of
tenant occupancy for that year,
Alexa (16:33):
that's gonna trigger an audit.
Bob (16:34):
It could absolutely trigger about it.
So
Alexa (16:35):
the savvy investor has to maintain a paper trail that
supports the claim of habitualuse, even if it's just
intermittent.
You have to genuinely use theproperty for some personal stay.
Bob (16:45):
Absolutely.
It's a risk mitigation game.
The legal structure allows forthe exemption, but it requires
the investor to make sure theirtotal fiscal profile doesn't
just scream abuse.
You're leveraging a legaldistinction that was intended
for homeowners, but you'reapplying it.
To an investment property in amixed use strategy.
Alexa (17:03):
Okay, so let's summarize the whole thing.
The mixed investment strategy,you generate strong monthly cash
flow from short term rentals,maximizing your operational
income.
Mm-hmm.
And then after maximizingappreciation, you cycle the
asset every three years usingthat CFE bill to exempt the
capital gains tax
Bob (17:21):
that is the engine.
That three year frequency limitis vital.
You cannot cycle assets everysingle year.
Using this exemption, you mustwait a minimum of three years
from the date of your lastexempt sale to qualify again.
Alexa (17:32):
So that dictates your whole strategy.
Bob (17:34):
It dictates your optimal holding period and your exit
timing for maximum efficiency.
It forces a medium to long terminvestment outlook rather than
short term flipping.
Alexa (17:43):
It really transforms the electric bill from just a
monthly expense into thisincredibly powerful strategic
financial tool.
Understanding that Onedocument's power is, I argue,
the most valuable takeaway foran investor focused on wealth
accumulation in Mexico,
Bob (18:00):
moving from proactive tax planning to more uh, reactive
asset protection riskmitigation.
This starts from day one ofconstruction, and it continues
right through the unit's entireoperational life, relying very
heavily on proper insurance.
Alexa (18:15):
Let's tackle insurance during construction.
Investors often focus on thedeveloper's reputation, but what
financial mechanism providesmandatory protection during the
build phase?
Bob (18:24):
It comes down to the financing.
If the project is financiallysecured by a bank, meaning the
developer is using a bankbridge, loan insurance is
mandatory.
Alexa (18:32):
The bank makes them do it.
Bob (18:33):
The bank requires the developer to be fully insured
from the moment they breakground until the final delivery.
It's non-negotiable because thebank needs to protect its
collateral.
This policy typically covers allrisks, fire, natural disasters,
theft to materials, even civilengineering failures that might
halter compromise the structure.
Alexa (18:50):
So if a major storm hits a site that's financed by a
bank, the bank's insurancecovers the damage and ensures
the project can be completed,which protects my presale money
Bob (19:00):
precisely.
And this provides a very strongrisk indicator for you as an
investor.
Developers who are buildingexclusively with presale cash
funding.
Alexa (19:09):
No bank loan.
Bob (19:09):
No bank loan, yep.
They are very likely, as asource, says not to carry
comprehensive insurance duringconstruction because there's no
mandatory lender requiring it.
Alexa (19:19):
And in that scenario,
Bob (19:20):
in that scenario, if a major structural incident
occurs, say a severe hurricaneor a construction accident, the
financial risk lands squarely onthe developer.
If they lack the capital to fixit, it ultimately impacts you.
The presale buyer.
It could lead to significantdelays or even in a worst case
scenario, abandonment of theproject
Alexa (19:39):
that makes bank financing, not just a vote of
confidence in the developer, butan essential risk barrier for
the investor.
Bob (19:45):
Okay, so once the unit is delivered, the insurance
framework changes completely.
What happens Post-delivery.
The developer's constructionpolicy expires.
The moment that bridge loan ispaid off and the property is
handed over, the policy is gone.
Responsibility then immediatelyshifts to the collective
ownership and the insurancesplits into two essential tiers.
Alexa (20:05):
Okay?
Tier one, protecting thestructure and the whole common
investment.
Bob (20:09):
That is the condo assembly insurance.
The owners through theiradministration decide on and
purchase a general insurancepolicy.
This policy covers the commonareas, the pool, the gardens,
the gym, the building,structural integrity, so the
foundation, walls, roof,
Alexa (20:25):
the big stuff,
Bob (20:26):
the big stuff, and the exterior facade.
It's generally defined aseverything from the exterior
face of your apartment dooroutward.
This policy is usually paid foroutta the monthly maintenance
fees, and it's critical fordisaster recovery and general
liability on common property.
Alexa (20:40):
And then tier two.
Protecting my personal propertyinside my four walls.
Bob (20:45):
That's the individual owner insurance.
The structure may be protectedby the assembly, but each owner
is individually responsible forensuring their specific private
square footage.
This includes all your contents,your furniture, your internal
equipment, and personalliability within the unit.
Alexa (21:01):
Okay?
Bob (21:01):
However, the source does note that administrations often
arrange group packages forinternal insurance with the same
carrier that covers the commonareas.
This can be significantlycheaper because the insurance
company is already familiar withthe risk profile of the
building.
Alexa (21:15):
That's a good tip.
Let's pivot to the Caribbeanclimate.
The threat of hurricanes isconstant, but the source
material highlights thiscritical geographic defense
mechanism that reduces the riskprofile for investors in Playa
Del Carmen.
Specifically,
Bob (21:29):
yes, this is a fascinating geographical detail.
Developers in Cantana Ru, theybuild to very high seismic and
wind standards, but the entiremainland benefits from what the
source calls a tremendous,tremendous advantage.
The island of Cozumel,
Alexa (21:44):
how exactly does Cozumel act as this tremendous barrier?
Bob (21:47):
So Cozumel is situated directly offshore and it runs
parallel to the coast.
Hurricanes typically approachthe mainland from the east
coming across the Caribbean Sea,
Alexa (21:56):
right into Cosm Mill's path.
Bob (21:58):
Cosmal is sitting right in the path.
The island acts as this massivenatural shield.
It absorbs so much of theinitial storm surge, the wind
speed, and the kinetic energy ofthe storm.
When a major hurricane hitsCosmal, takes the brunt of it,
effectively dampening the stormbefore it can reach the densely
populated, developed mean landareas like Playa del Carmen and
(22:19):
Tulum.
Alexa (22:20):
It's like the ultimate geographic bodyguard.
It's just sitting there reducingthe velocity and the flood risk
for the investment location.
Bob (22:26):
Exactly right.
This geographical protection isoften cited as a key reason why
development success in Playa delCarmen has been so sustained
compared to other parts of theCaribbean basin.
It inherently reduces theaverage risk profile of any
investment there.
Alexa (22:40):
Beyond the geography, there's the human element,
right?
Preparation and tracking.
Bob (22:44):
Yes.
And the region has excellentdisaster preparation systems,
unlike say an earthquake,hurricanes are not sudden
events.
They're tracked by verysophisticated weather systems
for 10 days, sometimes more inadvance.
Alexa (22:57):
That lead time is crucial.
Bob (22:59):
It's everything.
It allows developers tocompletely secure their
construction sites, taping downdebris, securing heavy equipment
and lumber.
And it gives condominiumadministrations ample time to
prepare the delivered units,secure furniture on terraces,
and implement residentevacuation plans if they're
necessary.
That advanced warningdramatically mitigates the
physical damage risk.
Alexa (23:20):
Finally, for the high volume rental investor, there is
an often overlooked safety netthat's built right into the
operational platformsthemselves.
Rental platform protection.
Bob (23:28):
Yes.
For investors who are using themajor platforms like Airbnb or
booking.com, there is animplicit layer of internal
protection.
These platforms offer reallystrong protection as the horse
puts it for tenant cause damageto your internal equipment and
furniture.
Alexa (23:44):
So if a guest breaks a sofa or damages an appliance,
Bob (23:47):
the platforms typically take a hundred percent
responsibility for the cost ofthat damage.
Often up to very significantlimits depending on the program
they offer.
Alexa (23:56):
That's a huge operational relief.
You don't have to chase thetenant down over a broken
television.
The platform handles the claimand the reimbursement.
Bob (24:04):
It acts as an effective, built-in protection against this
specific risk of tenantnegligence or carelessness,
which is really the highestoperational risk for any
short-term rental.
It allows the investor topotentially minimize the
internal contents coverage ontheir personal policy, knowing
that tenant damage is largelycovered by the platform.
Alexa (24:23):
Now we enter the moment of delivery.
The emotional high of buying thevision clashes with the cold
reality of the deliveredproduct.
We need to address the crucialdifference between the showroom
experience and the actualspecifications.
Bob (24:36):
The showroom is a masterpiece of psychological
marketing.
It is built to display theapartment's maximum potential.
Every single detail.
The scent in the air, thespecific art on the walls, the
high-end imported furniture, thedramatic lighting, it's all
selected to evoke an emotionalresponse
Alexa (24:51):
to make you feel like you're already living that
luxury lifestyle.
Bob (24:54):
Exactly.
It's selling the dream, notnecessarily the invoice.
Alexa (24:57):
Right.
Bob (24:58):
And the savvy investor must immediately separate that
emotional decor from thecontractual fixtures.
Developers often put up veryclear signs, clarifying that the
unit is not delivered as seen.
The furniture, the artwork,specific designer, light
fixtures, the electronics, thoseare usually just staging
elements.
They're not included in thepurchase price unless you've
(25:20):
explicitly added them.
Alexa (25:22):
To avoid confusion, we really need to clarify the
difference between the threecommon delivery types that
investors will encounter in themarket.
Let's start with the baselinefully equipped.
Bob (25:31):
A fully equipped unit includes the core fixed
operational elements.
The source defines thisperfectly as the items that
wouldn't fall out if you turnthe apartment upside down.
Alexa (25:41):
I like that.
Bob (25:41):
It's a good visual.
This means the structuralcomponents, your built-in
kitchen cabinetry.
Maybe a granite or quartzcountertop.
The sink, the AC units installedin the walls.
Ceiling fans, these are usuallynon-negotiable fixtures, but the
brands in quality is at apremium Samsung fridge versus an
economy local brand that must bescrutinized on the spec sheet.
Alexa (26:02):
Okay, next up is the widely used term turnkey.
Bob (26:05):
A turnkey unit goes a big step beyond equipped.
It means the property is readyto generate income or be lived
in immediately.
The second you get the key.
Alexa (26:14):
So that includes furniture.
Bob (26:15):
It implies furniture, bedding, linens, small kitchen
appliances, like a toaster andcoffee acre, all the necessary
utensils.
A true turnkey unit is instantlyoperational.
It's the easiest path forinternational investors who need
to start renting right awaywithout dealing with local
sourcing and installation.
Alexa (26:32):
And finally, the furniture package.
Bob (26:34):
This is an optional add-on that provides customization.
So instead of just accepting thedeveloper's, standardized,
turnkey set, the buyer workswith an interior designer to
select specific materials,colors, and furniture pieces to
create a more personalizedaesthetic.
Alexa (26:47):
Generally more expensive, I'd assume?
Bob (26:49):
Yes.
Generally more expensive, but itallows the unit to stand out in
what can be a very crowdedrental market.
Alexa (26:55):
Whether it's fully equipped or turnkey, the moment
of truth rests entirely on onedocument, the spec sheet or the
technical sheet.
Why is this document the sourceof so much potential investor
disappointment?
Why does it get the title of theasterisk trap?
Bob (27:11):
Because it can be highly, highly misleading.
It blurs the line between yourexpectation and the material.
Reality developers arecapitalizing on new material
trends.
For example, the marketingbrochure might promise marble
walls or exotic wood floors, butyou have to look very closely at
the fine print.
Alexa (27:29):
So the expectation is this premium, durable material,
but the reality is often just animitation.
Bob (27:34):
Precisely.
We see the asterisk crapdeployed in three common areas.
First, flooring and walls.
The spec sheet might listpremium porcelain tile imitating
wood grain, or PVC panelsreplicating marble.
The truth is often revealed inthat tiny asterisk at the bottom
of the page stating, finishbased on imitation material,
Alexa (27:52):
and the durability and lifespan of PVC are vastly
different from marble.
Bob (27:56):
Oh, completely different.
You need to adjust yourexpectations and your
maintenance budget accordingly.
Alexa (28:02):
What's a second area?
Cabinetry and woodworking.
Bob (28:05):
The spec sheet might claim fine wood finishes, but the
asterisk often reveals that it'snot solid tropical hardwood,
which is expensive, but highlydurable.
It's actually MDF medium densityfiberboard, or a veneer with a
specific laminate on top,
Alexa (28:20):
and for a vacation rental unit in high humidity.
Bob (28:23):
Exactly.
A unit subjected to constanthigh humidity and frequent
cleaning.
Using a cheaper material likeMDF instead of solid wood
significantly increases thelong-term risk of it warping and
needing to be replaced muchsooner.
Alexa (28:36):
And the third area appliances and fixtures,
Bob (28:38):
you need to know the specific brand and model number
of the refrigerator, the ACunits, the faucets.
Hmm.
A vague claim of premiumfixtures can easily hide economy
level brands.
The spec sheet has to containspecific material names like
quartz countertop with specificbrand seal or inverter
technology, AC unit brand X.
If it's vague, that is a hugered flag that demands further
(29:00):
inquiry.
Alexa (29:00):
So what's the ultimate rule of thumb for an investor
walking through that beautifulshowroom?
Bob (29:05):
Do not let the beauty of the staging, the pretty sofa or
the stunning view, distract you.
You have to maintain a laserfocus on the technical sheet.
You need to know if you arepaying for real stone that
requires specific maintenance ora durable quartz or a cheaper
imitation that will need earlierreplacement.
Alexa (29:22):
The choice should match the use.
Bob (29:24):
Absolutely.
The material choice has to alignwith your intended usage.
A durable stain resistant quartzor porcelain is often a far, far
better choice for a high volumevacation rental than natural
marble.
Even though marble is moreluxurious, the focus must be on
durability and reducing yourlong-term maintenance costs.
(29:45):
We shift now to the final and,uh, perhaps most sensitive
aspect of investing, thelong-term legal and family
implications.
This is all about ensuring theasset you've worked so hard to
acquire continues to benefityour family seamlessly.
Alexa (29:58):
Let's start at the beginning, co-ownership.
If a family or maybe somebusiness partners want to pool
their resources, how does thatprocess work?
Bob (30:04):
It's entirely possible and actually very common to buy
property in co-ownership.
The deed itself can beregistered to multiple
individuals, say a marriedcouple and their two adult
children.
The percentages of ownership foreach person are recorded right
there on the deed.
Alexa (30:19):
And why would people do that?
Bob (30:21):
It's often done to simplify the asset, transfer down the
line, or simply to leverage theexpertise and capital of
multiple parties to afford theinvestment.
Alexa (30:30):
This leads us directly to the issue of asset transfer upon
death.
A major finding forinternational investors is the
situation regarding inheritancetax.
In Mexico.
Bob (30:40):
This is a tremendous advantage that Mexico offers
compared to the US or much ofEurope.
There is no federal inheritancetax in Mexico when property is
passed to an heir.
The government does not levy apercentage tax on the value of
the inherited assets themselves.
Alexa (30:55):
That's huge.
That simplifies wealth transfersignificantly.
However, if the planning isn'tdone correctly during the
parent's lifetime, the childrencould still face a tax liability
when they receive the assetsright.
The property acquisition tax
Bob (31:07):
absolutely corrected.
This is the crucial nuance thattrips up so many foreign
investors.
While there's no inheritancetax, there is still the property
acquisition tax known as ISA,which is levied anytime the
title changes hands.
Okay.
So if the property is solely inthe parents' names and then
transferred later upon theirdeath, the children will have to
pay the ISAI, which could bebetween 2% and 5% of the
(31:31):
appraised value, just toregister the new title in their
names
Alexa (31:35):
so the family avoids.
Say a 30% federal inheritancetax, but they could still face a
4% acquisition tax.
'cause the legal transferrequires a whole new valuation.
They've got it.
So how do sophisticatedinvestors mitigate this
acquisition tax liability whilestill controlling the asset
during their lifetime?
Bob (31:52):
They often use a, uh, complex but very effective legal
mechanism called the use offructose veal.
Alexa (31:58):
A life estate.
Bob (31:58):
A life estate, exactly.
Oh.
This essentially separates theownership rights into two
distinctive parts.
The parent returns the use offructo, which is the right to
use the property live in it, andmost importantly, collect all
the rental income it generatesfor the rest of their life.
Alexa (32:13):
And what happens to the bare title, the actual ownership
papers.
Bob (32:16):
The parents simultaneously transferred the nude to prop the
bear title to their children.
And because the transfer of thebear title happens during the
parent's lifetime, theacquisition tax, the ISAI is
calculated on the much lowervalue of the bear title at that
time.
Alexa (32:32):
I see.
Bob (32:33):
Then when the parents eventually pass away, the use of
fructose naturally extinguishesand it merges with the neuter
proppy dead.
The children automaticallyreceive full ownership without
triggering another round of highacquisition tax.
Alexa (32:45):
That's a powerful way to freeze the tax liability early,
while you still retain all theoperational control and the
income rights.
It sounds like a complexprocess, though.
Bob (32:55):
It is, and it requires very careful structuring with a good
notary to ensure all partiesunderstand the limitations.
For instance, the bear titleowners, the children, they can't
sell the property without theconsent of the use of fructo
owners, the parents.
It adds legal complexity, but itoften provides very significant
tax savings for the heirs.
Alexa (33:13):
This brings us to what might be the single most
important piece of legalpaperwork and investor must
execute regardless of their age,the paramount role of the will.
Bob (33:23):
This cannot be overstated.
Investors often assume thatbecause they have a contract or
maybe they have a will fromtheir home country, that the
asset transfer will be simple.
Alexa (33:32):
That's wrong,
Bob (33:34):
that is wrong.
At the national federal level inMexico, only a properly executed
legal Mexican will carries legalweight for the swift transfer of
property.
Alexa (33:44):
Why is this planning so crucial for someone who's, you
know, in their prime earningyears, maybe in their forties or
fifties.
Bob (33:50):
Because life is unpredictable and a failure to
plan turns an asset into aproblem.
If property owners pass awaywithout a will, the estate
enters a process calledsecession in testamentary in
test state succession.
Alexa (34:02):
And what does that mean?
Bob (34:04):
It means the process is entirely controlled by the
courts, and it instantly becomesas the source says.
Cumbersome, time consuming, andvery expensive.
Alexa (34:12):
How time consuming are we talking about here?
Are we talking months?
Yeah, years.
Bob (34:16):
Depending on the jurisdiction and the complexity
of the family structure, it cantake anywhere from one to three
years for the courts to legallysettle who the rightful heirs
are and authorize the sale ortransfer of the property, a
three year delay, and duringthat entire period.
The asset is typically frozen.
It cannot be rented, it can't besold, it can't be modified.
(34:37):
It just sits there costingmoney.
Alexa (34:39):
So the family not only incurs significant legal and
administrative cost, but theyalso lose years of potential
rental income from the veryinvestment you bought for them.
Bob (34:49):
Exactly.
You intended to leave yourchildren a valuable income
generating asset, and insteadyou've left them a debilitating
administrative nightmare andoften a source of family
conflict.
A clear legal will ensures theproperty passes immediately to
the intended beneficiaries.
It prevents disputes betweensiblings and it guarantees that
the heirs can access and enjoythe asset without unnecessary
(35:11):
delay or cost.
It is the ultimate act offinancial responsibility to
protect your investment for thenext generation.
Alexa (35:18):
That was an incredibly comprehensive deep dive.
We went from the nuances ofcommunity privacy all the way to
the complexities ofinternational wealth transfer.
We've covered essentialactionable knowledge that goes
so far beyond just the initialpurchase price.
Bob (35:33):
Let's quickly recap the three most powerful strategic
takeaways that every investorreally needs for a member.
First, the operational magic ofthe CFE electric bill.
Alexa (35:43):
The Humble Utility Bill.
Bob (35:44):
Yes, ensure that document is in your name and it's active
as it is the single mostimportant piece of evidence
you'll need to leverage theprimary residence exemption and
shield your capital appreciationfrom the ISR sellers tax.
Once every three years.
Alexa (35:58):
Second, takeaway the dynamic reality of condo
ownership.
You are buying into a livingdemocracy.
The collective power of thecondo assembly means the rules
regarding pets, aesthetics,common areas, they're constantly
subject to change.
Bob (36:11):
You have to stay engaged.
Investors must remain engaged orrisk seeing rules enacted that
could negatively affect theirrental operation.
Alexa (36:18):
And finally,
Bob (36:19):
and finally, the paramount legal necessity of the will.
Due to the lack of a federalinheritance tax, but the
presence of that propertyacquisition tax planning via a
Mexican will and potentiallyusing mechanisms like the use of
fructo vitalio is the only wayto ensure your investment
transfers efficiently, costeffectively, and without turning
(36:39):
the asset into a legal burdenfor your family.
Alexa (36:41):
So here is the final, provocative thought for you to
take away.
Investing in a condominium meansnavigating that delicate balance
between your private rights andthe community's collective will.
We talked about how a communitythrough consensus can change
rules about cameras or pets.
If you were sitting at the nextowner's assembly meeting,
understanding that you have thepower to shape the future
(37:02):
operation of the building, whatpart of the existing condo
bylaws would you vote to changefirst to maximize your
investment success?
Bob (37:09):
Being this informed is the difference between simply owning
a property and successfullymanaging an asset.
Thank you for taking this deepdive with us and focusing on
those crucial details that leadto long-term profitability and
just as important peace of mind.
Popular Podcasts
Dateline NBC
Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Follow now to get the latest episodes of Dateline NBC completely free, or subscribe to Dateline Premium for ad-free listening and exclusive bonus content: DatelinePremium.com
Stuff You Should Know
If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.
The Bobby Bones Show
Listen to 'The Bobby Bones Show' by downloading the daily full replay.