Episode 38 - Inside Indiana’s Newest Classical School Option

In this episode, host Sarah Milligan sits down with Mollie Crummey, board president of the newly launched Chesterton Academy of St. Scholastica in Fort Wayne, Indiana. A homeschooling mom of seven with a background in financial risk analysis, Mollie shares the inspiring story behind launching one of Indiana’s most exciting new school choice options. Tune in as they explore what it takes to start a classical high school from the ground up—and why Fort Wayne families are responding with enthusiasm. From curriculum to community building to the surprising benefits of school vouchers, this conversation is packed with insight and inspiration for anyone passionate about educational freedom. Key Takeaways: Launching a Classical High School from Scratch: Mollie details the practical steps she took—from fundraising $275,000 to leasing space from a local airport—to open Chesterton Academy and bring a classical, values-driven curriculum to her community. Why Classical Education Matters: Discover how time-tested teaching methods like Socratic discussion and a curriculum rooted in the great books are helping students develop not just academically, but emotionally and spiritually. Parents as Partners in Education: Mollie explains how the academy was designed as a true extension of the home, giving families a trusted, mission-aligned option for high school. Making School Choice Accessible: Learn how the school joined Indiana’s voucher program without compromising its religious values or classical approach—opening the door for more families to access a high-quality private education. Looking Ahead: With growth already underway, hear Mollie’s vision for a flourishing future—and why she believes every community deserves an educational option that speaks to both the mind and the heart.Don’t miss this powerful episode about reimagining education, empowering families, and passing on the values that shape the next generation. Did you find this episode informative? Help us out! Leave a review Share it with your friends Give us a 5 Star rating on your podcatcher of choice For more information about school choice and the Indiana Choice Scholarship Program, visit our website at https://www.i4qed.org