Welcome to Derry: Can HBO's IT Prequel Avoid Feeling Like a Reboot?

We started off with a quick update: Meaghan and Arthur are trying out a new recording setup for the Fully-Booked Podcast and, like any of us facing tech upgrades, are crossing their fingers that it behaves itself. From there, they leaned into their end-of-May tradition of a more casual, "free-for-all" episode format. It’s their chance to have fun, try different things, and bring up topics they might not usually squeeze into a themed episode.

IT Welcome to Derry and Stephen King's Expanding Universe

Then came the meat of the conversation: the new HBO series IT Welcome to Derry. The trailer just dropped, and while it didn’t give us a release date (other than the vague “Fall 2025”), it did get Meaghan and Arthur talking about the direction this prequel might take.

They noted the show's pedigree, with Andy and Barbara Muschietti (the sibling team behind the modern IT films) involved, and speculated on how the series might expand the IT universe. Both hosts agreed that the original IT story has a very clear endpoint, Pennywise is defeated, so a prequel has to find clever ways to build tension and keep things fresh. They tossed around ideas about time jumps, exploring different eras of Derry, or focusing on the evil that lives in the town itself.

Arthur was quick to point out that IT works so well because it's not about superheroes; it's about ordinary people facing unimaginable horrors. That relatability makes the fear hit harder. They both agreed that Stephen King is a master at spotlighting how the real villains are often the adults, indifferent, abusive, or just willfully blind to what's happening around them.

Trailer Takeaways and Concerns About Repetition

When they turned to the actual IT Welcome to Derry trailer, they both had mixed feelings. Visually, it's spot on, creepy, unsettling, and full of that “Derry atmosphere.” You know, the kind of unsettling small-town vibe where everything looks normal on the surface but clearly isn’t. But here's the catch: a lot of the trailer felt familiar.

Like, maybe a little too familiar.

Shots of kids peering into sinks, mysterious voices in the pipes, and a new version of the “Losers Club” forming, it all mirrors scenes we've seen before. Arthur joked (half-seriously) that if this new group has a nickname, it’s going to feel painfully forced. They understand that the 27-year cycle within the IT lore sets the stage for repeated patterns, but they hope the show brings something new to the table.

One aspect that did catch their attention was the possibility of new characters, particularly a young family that moves into Derry and starts to question what's going on. That could add some interesting outside perspective to a town where the residents usually ignore or forget the horror around them.

Symbolism, Theories, and King’s Giant Connected Universe

From there, things got a little nerdy in the best way. Arthur and Meaghan dove into numerology, specifically the significance of the number 27. It shows up in the IT mythos a lot, and not by accident. They discussed how 27 is 3 cubed and how Stephen King often uses the number three in symbolic ways, particularly in his Dark Tower series.

Then came the deeper cuts: the theory that Pennywise is a creature from the Todash Darkness, a space between worlds in The Dark Tower universe. They talked about how IT could be one of the Crimson King’s agents, and how this ties into King’s sprawling mult