Stop Slapping Band-Aids on Broken Arms: The Gratitude Trap

Send us a text

Ever been told to "just be grateful" when you're genuinely struggling? That well-meaning advice might actually be harming your mental health. Welcome to the darker side of gratitude—where positive thinking transforms from helpful practice into emotional manipulation.

The science behind this is fascinating. When someone dismisses your pain with toxic positivity, your brain's rational thinking center temporarily shuts down while your amygdala—your brain's panic button—lights up like a smoke detector. University of Michigan researchers found that people pressured into gratitude actually experience more stress, resentment, and emotional exhaustion. It's like being forced to smile for a photo while mid-cry, creating a disconnect between your external expression and internal reality.

Sometimes it's perfectly okay to be ungrateful. You don't need to feel thankful for toxic relationships, unfair treatment, or soul-crushing jobs just because "it could be worse." In fact, studies from the American Psychological Association reveal that people who allow themselves to fully experience negative emotions without immediately reframing them positively recover faster from trauma and stress. Real gratitude isn't about ignoring the bad—it's about balancing light and dark in an authentic way.

Ready to practice healthier gratitude? Start by acknowledging difficult emotions before reaching for thankfulness. Name your pain first. Stop comparing struggles (gratitude isn't a competition), and firmly reject gratitude when it's used as a silencing tool. Remember, you can be grateful while still expecting better. Try writing down what you're genuinely thankful for without pressure, and consider one small gratitude practice that feels real rather than performative.

Share this episode with someone who needs permission to feel all their emotions, not just the grateful ones. And remember—gratitude is powerful, but it's a practice and a choice, not a weapon or guilt trip.

www.in8code.com

Episode Transcript

Speaker 1 (00:18):
Welcome to another edition of GW Unspoken, where we
discuss stuff we don'ttypically talk about but
probably should.
And we're here with episode 5,season 9, talking about
gratitude.
And well, we're talking aboutgratitude and how it gets
weaponized today, and that'sright.
We're talking about the darkerside of gratitude, that side
that's been slapped on t-shirts,motivational posters and those
cringe-inducing bumper stickerslike good vibes only because

(00:41):
sometimes gratitude actually canbe harmful.
So you ready for this one?
This one's a little bit leftfield, so I'd love to have your
opinion on this one.
But this is a problem.
We've all heard it.
Just be grateful.
It could be worse.
At least you have a job.
Be thankful you even have afamily.
We've talked about this in oneof our first episodes.
But on the surface, thisstatement seems well or
well-meaning, but they're theemotional equivalent of slapping

(01:04):
a band-aid on a broken arm.
Here's the problem.
When we use gratitude todismiss someone's pain, shame
their struggle or silence theirvoice, it's no longer gratitude,
it's actually emotionalmanipulation.
There's a study from theUniversity of Michigan that
found people who felt pressuredto be grateful during difficult

(01:25):
times experienced actually morestress, more resentment and
actual emotional exhaustion.
And why?
Because this forced gratitudecreates a distance or a
disconnect between our externalexpression and our internal
reality.
And it's like being told, forexample, like hey smile for a
family photo when you're stillmid-crying.
And here's the brain science ofit.

(01:47):
This is why it's harmful.
When you're struggling andsomeone tells you to just be
grateful, that front part ofyour brain, the prefrontal
cortex, that part that actuallyis responsible for rational
thought and emotional regulation, it actually goes offline.
And what happens is youramygdala, that brain's panic
button.
It lights up like a foley smokedetector and you go into that

(02:07):
defensive mode.
Your body thinks it's underattack and you feel dismissed,
invalidated and even alone.
So gratitude, when real, canreduce cortisol and increase
dopamine, but fake gratitude itcan actually spike your stress
levels because it forces you toemotionally gaslight yourself.
And that's full on, isn't it?
When you think about it, ifsomeone tells you to be grateful

(02:28):
for something that's genuinelyhurting you, your brain is
forced to wrestle with that sortof cognitive distance.
So you're thinking am Ioverreacting?
Should I just shut up and justbe grateful?
Are they right?
And that internal conflict caneat away at your self-worth over
time.
And the problem is here's whereit gets controversial.
Sometimes it's okay to beungrateful.

(02:49):
Sometimes it's okay to say no,I'm not actually thankful for
this.
You don't have to be gratefulfor toxic relationships, unfair
treatment or jobs that juststrain your soul.
You don't have to be thankfulfor every challenge just because
it made you stronger.
You know what?
Sometimes life's just a bitcrap and it's actually okay to
admit it, and it's probably goodto do that.
There's another study in 2018from an American Psychology

(03:12):
Association that found thatpeople who allow themselves to
fully experience negativeemotions without trying to
immediately reframe them intosomething positive, they
actually recovered faster fromthat trauma and stress.
So here's a thought if you'rein a tough spot, so think about
your own personal life now.
And if you're in a tough spotand someone tells you to hey,
just be grateful, feel free tomentally hit them with a thanks,

(03:34):
but no thanks, all right.
But here's a lighter one foryou.
If someone's instagram bio says, hey, positive vibes only or
good vibes tribe, I think it's agood idea to approach that
maybe with caution.
These are the people who willcut you off in traffic.
Then to hey, just be grateful,you didn't crash and you've got
a car.

(03:55):
Gratitude isn't just aboutignoring the bad.
It's about balancing a lightand a dark.
It's not a personality contestor a forced smile.
It's a choice, a practice, anongoing messy real-life process,
and you know what it's actuallytough to do In a life skills
class.
At the moment we're doing thatwith our year eights, teaching
them how gratitude can actuallyhelp the emotional part of your
brain and also then help switchon that actually smart part or

(04:19):
the thinking part of your brain.
It's very hard.
It's very hard for people tosit still.
There's a lot of boys,particularly full of
testosterone, who just wants torun around and move.
So try some different practices.
Try it.
But going back to you, how canwe actually participate in
gratitude without becoming humandoormats or emotional
gaslighters?
Here's a plan for you, numberone and this is really important

(04:46):
because I don't think a lot ofus do.
Number one just acknowledgethat hard stuff Before you reach
your gratitude.
Actually name the pain.
Just say this is hard, I amstruggling, I'm not right now,
I'm not okay today.
Acknowledge it, have it at thefront of your brain.
Don't try and dismiss it or putit at the back of your brain
and deal with it later on.
It'll just build up over time.
That's where you'll see peopleexplode with outbursts.

(05:07):
Number two don't comparestruggles.
Just because someone else hasit worse doesn't mean your pain
isn't valid.
Gratefulness isn't acompetition, it's a conversation
.
Everyone has different feelingsabout their emotional pain.
And number three rejectgratitude as a silencing tool.
If someone tries to shut youdown with hey, just be grateful

(05:29):
again.
Hit them with a gentle but firmoy, I can be grateful, but
still expect better.
So here's three general promptsfor the week.
Again, I ask you to participatein this Write down.
I know it's easy, like goalsetting, just to think about it
and go no, no.
I ask you to participate inthis Write down.
I know it's easy, like goalsetting, just to think about it
and go no, no, I don't need towrite down and get it.
Most things that we write downand measure it actually gets
improved.
So, number one here's the firstone when in my life, ask

(05:50):
yourself where in my life have Ifelt pressured to just be
grateful when I actually needsupport or validation?
Instead, just name it, it mightfree up.
Just write it down.
There might be a few of them.
Number two ask yourself what amI genuinely grateful for in my
life right now, without anypressure or obligation to say it
.
What comes up naturally,without force?

(06:10):
What is it?
And number three, how can Ipractice gratitude this week in
a way that's real, balanced, andnot just for show?
Maybe it's a silent thank you,maybe it's a journal entry,
maybe it's just not complainingabout the Wi-Fi for a day.
What's one practice ofgratitude you can do?
It's real, balanced and notjust for show.
So that's another episode forus in episode five here, and I

(06:34):
really appreciate you joining inand remember gratefulness and
gratitude is powerful, but it'snot a weapon, it's not a shut or
a shush button, it's not a toolfor guilt.
It's a practice, it's a choice,and sometimes a quiet whisper
of thanks in a storm works forus.
And if this episode hit homefor you, please share it with
someone who you know needs it.
By God, a lot of people need itright now.

(06:55):
It's a reminder that it's okayto feel all things, not just a
grateful one.
So thank you for joining us foranother episode of GWN Spoken
and I look forward to yourcompany in our next episode.