Highly Unlikely with Josh & Jenaye

Highly Unlikely with Josh & Jenaye

Welcome to Highly Unlikely with Josh and Jenaye. We're so glad you're joining us, and we're excited to take you into conversations about highly unlikely people, many from highly unlikely places, and now doing some highly unlikely things. We will also dig into topics we're passionate about that lead us to live highly unlikely lives.

Episodes

September 15, 2025 51 mins

How do we help the next generation build lasting faith in a world that keeps changing? Pastors Josh and Jenaye are joined by Pastor Kyle, who shares insights from years of NextGen ministry—shaped by his parents’ influence and a life soaked in Scripture. He talks about helping kids discover their identity in Christ and writing music with his friend QB that the whole family can enjoy (without the cringe). This conversation will inspi...

Mark as Played

What if your calling isn’t just about what you do on Sundays, but also how you live and serve every day of the week? Pastors Josh and Jenaye are joined by Pastor Raymond who shares about his journey from military service to vocational children’s ministry. His experience highlights the importance of patience and trusting God's timing. We are reminded how God uses both our careers and our willingness to serve in the local church...

Mark as Played

Pastors Josh and Jenaye sit down with longtime staff member Jen to talk about keeping our hearts healthy in the midst of change. Having spent over a decade navigating the evolving landscape of a growing church, Jen shares her journey of embracing change and growth, reminding us that longevity in any community requires trust and humility. Together, they encourage us to remain open-handed with our callings and to trust the Lord in ea...

Mark as Played
August 4, 2025 59 mins

In this special milestone episode of Highly Unlikely, Pastors Josh and Jenaye reflect on how the podcast has become a way to connect with the church body. Like conversations over coffee, it’s become a space to share stories, better understand others (and themselves), and introduce listeners to the voices that have shaped them and the church—friends, mentors, church members, and staff alike. They share what’s made the journey so mea...

Mark as Played

As Evangel prepares for 21 Days of Prayer and Fasting, Pastors Josh and Jenaye are joined by Pastor Dylan to unpack the heart behind this powerful spiritual discipline. The conversation explores how fasting—often misunderstood or overlooked—can become a meaningful way to draw closer to God. They share personal stories, challenge common misconceptions, and reflect on the deeper purpose of fasting, which extends beyond just giving up...

Mark as Played

Relationships are a mirror, often revealing unresolved pain and past experiences that shape how we show up with the people closest to us. They explore how God can use those moments for healing, growth, and deeper connection. Whether you’re navigating conflict, working on communication, or simply needing a fresh dose of encouragement, this conversation is filled with wisdom and hope!

The first counseling episode (episode 87): https:/...

Mark as Played

Pastor Josh led a powerful conversation with NFL players Carson Wentz and Drue Tranquill, highlighting the importance of authentic friendship and intentional community. The two athletes shared their personal faith journeys, reflecting on how deep relationships—with each other and their teammates—have shaped them, especially as husbands and fathers.

https://arenamen.org

Mark as Played
June 9, 2025 56 mins

What does it really look like to grieve—and keep going? Diane Haan, Ruby Paul and Pastor Diane Freitag join Pastors Josh and Jenaye to share personal stories of loss and healing. They talk openly about what it means to grieve well and move forward. You’ll hear how healing often begins in unexpected ways—through Grief Share, Connect Groups, and simply showing up for one another. This episode offers hope, insight, and a powerful remi...

Mark as Played

Pastors Josh and Jenaye sit down with Bryce and Eden Meyer for a real, meaningful conversation about parenting. Together, they explore what it looks like to go beyond behavior management and truly connect with our kids' hearts. They share practical insights on building strong relationships through open communication, intentional time, and discipline that helps kids grow from the inside out.  Tune in for honest encouragement an...

Mark as Played

In this episode, Pastor Jenaye is joined by Jasmine, co-director of Bismarck Global Neighbors, for a heartfelt conversation about how we can support immigrants and refugees in meaningful, lasting ways. Grounded in the biblical call to love our neighbor, this conversation serves as both an invitation to welcome others into what you’re already doing and a challenge to consider: Do we truly see and love our neighbor? 

Mark as Played
April 28, 2025 55 mins

What does it really mean to grow into the man you’re meant to be? In this episode of Highly Unlikely, Pastor Josh unpacks the stages of identity, purpose, and legacy—from childhood roots to midlife revelations. With real talk and biblical wisdom, it’s a call to grow deeper, love better, and leave a lasting impact.


https://www.arenamen.org/

Mark as Played

In this episode, Pastors Josh and Jenaye sit down once again with Steve Pavek, who shares powerful updates about the Hub 1 Initiative in Alaska. Through the Alaska Student Partnership, teachers are being equipped to serve in remote villages—communities facing deep challenges like domestic violence, substance abuse, and isolation. They explore how building trust and forming relationships through education is opening doors for church...

Mark as Played

Jake and Megan Thomas join Pastor Jenaye in today’s episode to share their journey through infertility, foster care, and adoption. They discuss how they learned to surrender their plans to God’s timing and encourage believers to step into uncomfortable, vulnerable spaces while trusting His plan. The couple also shares how The Lily Initiative has been instrumental in supporting them through the challenges of foster care.

th...

Mark as Played

Join Pastors Josh and Jenaye as they talk with Mark Testroet, the Chaplain at both the North Dakota State Penitentiary and Missouri River Correctional Center. Hear about the transformative work happening in the lives of residents as they encounter hope and purpose through faith in Jesus. Mark emphasizes how they are seeking something real and authentic and that the most requested item is a Bible!

Mark as Played

Join Pastors Josh and Jenaye as they sit down with Noah VanVoorhis to discuss his journey of stepping out of his comfort zone to serve on Dream Teams at Evangel. Noah shares how serving in Production has provided community for him, given him opportunity to serve with his son, and opened doors to helping in Middle School Services and NextGen Summer Camps. He also talks about his role as a public school ESL teacher and how it allows ...

Mark as Played

In this episode, we talk about a Highly Unlikely way to take the gospel to all nations. Tune in for a powerful conversation with Pastors Josh and Jenaye as Travis Gatzke shares his journey—from his time at Midwest Leadership College to his current role as Prison Outreach Coordinator. Hear stories about Alpha groups, water baptisms, and Evangel’s upcoming in-person services in 2025 at the North Dakota State Penitentiary!

Mark as Played

In this episode, Pastors Josh and Jenaye are joined by three licensed counselors to discuss the role biblical counseling can play in supporting mental, emotional and spiritual health. They explore counseling not just as a reaction to crises, but as a proactive step for everyone—similar to regular car maintenance. The conversation highlights how faith can be integrated into the healing process, showing how the tools from counseling ...

Mark as Played
January 20, 2025 45 mins

Pastor Josh hosts a discussion with Bill and Karen Schneider, retirees who challenge the conventional view of retirement as only a time of enjoyment and leisure. They emphasize that while they may have stepped away from their jobs, they continue to serve God by establishing a clear purpose in retirement and redefining the retired lives around service and legacy.  Ultimately, they encourage people to see their later years as an enco...

Mark as Played

Pastor Josh welcomes Pastor Noah, who leads Way Church in Nashville.  Noah discusses his book "Holy Habits," emphasizing that while encounters with Jesus can lead to freedom, developing spiritual habits is essential for maintaining that freedom.  Noah also highlights the importance of creating safe spaces for vulnerability, particularly among the younger generation. This conversation serves as a heartfelt reminder of the ...

Mark as Played
December 23, 2024 58 mins

In this final episode of 2024, Pastors Josh and Jenaye share practical plans and rhythms to start your new year strong! They encourage listeners to reflect on the past year, not just focusing on successes, but also acknowledging and processing the challenges faced. And to ultimately ask for God’s wisdom and guidance as we step into 2025 to fulfill what He has called us to do.

Mark as Played

Popular Podcasts

    Ding dong! Join your culture consultants, Matt Rogers and Bowen Yang, on an unforgettable journey into the beating heart of CULTURE. Alongside sizzling special guests, they GET INTO the hottest pop-culture moments of the day and the formative cultural experiences that turned them into Culturistas. Produced by the Big Money Players Network and iHeartRadio.

    Dateline NBC

    Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Follow now to get the latest episodes of Dateline NBC completely free, or subscribe to Dateline Premium for ad-free listening and exclusive bonus content: DatelinePremium.com

    The Charlie Kirk Show

    Charlie is America's hardest working grassroots activist who has your inside scoop on the biggest news of the day and what's really going on behind the headlines. The founder of Turning Point USA and one of social media's most engaged personalities, Charlie is on the front lines of America’s culture war, mobilizing hundreds of thousands of students on over 3,500 college and high school campuses across the country, bringing you your daily dose of clarity in a sea of chaos all from his signature no-holds-barred, unapologetically conservative, freedom-loving point of view. You can also watch Charlie Kirk on Salem News Channel

    The Breakfast Club

    The World's Most Dangerous Morning Show, The Breakfast Club, With DJ Envy, Jess Hilarious, And Charlamagne Tha God!

    Stuff You Should Know

    If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.

Advertise With Us
Music, radio and podcasts, all free. Listen online or download the iHeart App.

Connect

© 2025 iHeartMedia, Inc.