The American West: The Bone Wars of the 1870s

When Othniel Charles Marsh secretly arranged to steal fossils from his friend Edward Drinker Cope's excavation site in 1868, he ignited one of the most infamous rivalries in American science. What followed was nearly three decades of sabotage, public humiliation, and ruthless competition across the American West—yet their bitter feud also resulted in the discovery of 136 new dinosaur species that captured the world's imagination.

The story begins with two brilliant but difficult men who briefly bonded as colleagues in 1863 Berlin, only to become lifelong enemies after a series of betrayals and a spectacularly embarrassing scientific error. Their rivalry escalated through the 1870s and 1880s as they competed for the same fossil sites in Wyoming, Colorado, and other western territories, each trying to outpace the other in discoveries and publications.

Both Marsh and Cope ultimately paid a devastating price—financial ruin, destroyed reputations, and personal misery. But their competitive drive pushed American paleontology forward by decades, introducing the world to Triceratops, Stegosaurus, Allosaurus, and countless other prehistoric giants. The Bone Wars proved that competition can fuel innovation, even when it destroys the competitors themselves.

Subscribe to Hometown History for forgotten American history stories every week. New episodes release Tuesdays. Every hometown has a story—what's yours?

In This Episode:

• How a stolen fossil site destroyed a friendship between two paleontologists
• The infamous dinosaur skull mistake that ignited public humiliation
• Competing expeditions across Wyoming and Colorado fossil beds in the 1870s
• The bitter newspaper war that scandalized the scientific community
• How 136 new dinosaur species emerged from personal destruction

Key Figures:

• Othniel Charles Marsh - Yale professor who became first North American paleontology professor; known for autocratic behavior
• Edward Drinker Cope - Self-taught naturalist with 1,400 publications; financially ruined by the rivalry
• John Wesley Powell - Head of US Geological Survey; caught in the crossfire
• Arthur Lakes - Mining teacher whose fossil discovery triggered major escalation

Timeline:

• 1863: Marsh and Cope meet as friends in Berlin, Germany
• 1868: Marsh secretly arranges to steal Cope's New Jersey fossil finds; Cope's skull placement error
• 1872: Open warfare begins when Cope searches Marsh's "territory" in Wyoming
• 1877: Fossil discoveries near Morrison, Colorado and Como Bluff, Wyoming intensify competition
• 1890: Public newspaper battle scandalizes scientific establishment
• 1892: Marsh forced to resign from Geological Survey
• 1897: Cope dies financially ruined; Marsh dies impoverished soon after

Historical Context: This episode covers a national scientific rivalry rather than a specific hometown story, representing an important chapter in American natural history. The fossil-rich territories of the American West—particularly Wyoming and Colorado—became the battleground for this infamous feud that transformed paleontology into a recognized scientific discipline.

Legacy: The Bone Wars period (1870s-1890s) remains one of the most productive eras in paleontology despite the personal destruction of its key figures. Museums around the world still display specimens collected during this rivalry.v

Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/hometownhistory/exclusive-content

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands