I Should Have Known

I Should Have Known

The trivia podcast that can't be trusted! Each week one of our quizmasters, Sups, Andi, or Tanner, presents you with four big facts on a topic, but one of those facts is a lie! Try to guess which one and you'll be saying, "I should have known!"


May 23, 2023 19 mins

Take the plunge with us again Under the Sea as we learn all about sharks! This week, Quizmaster Tanner netted four great white facts about the finned terrors of the deep. But one of his facts is a false alarm. Jump in with hosts Andi and Sups as they sink their teeth in and try to separate fact from fiction! 

Mark as Played

As we tread along on our voyage Under the Sea this month, Quizmaster Andi invoked four gods of the sea! She found four pantheons across the globe and a description of each of the rulers of the depths. However, one of them is an imposter! She completely made it up! See if you can fish out the real gods or goddesses from the fake one along with hosts Tanner and Sups! 

Mark as Played

This week, we're continuing our Under the Sea theme with Quizmaster Sups going to the deepest depths to find the four best facts about superlatives underwater! But one of the facts is truly the worst. Think you can guess which fact is a lie? Join hosts Andi and Tanner as they try to stay afloat and do their best to figure it out! 

Mark as Played
May 2, 2023 18 mins

Put on your masks and flippers for this episode! To begin our Under the Sea theme, Quizmaster Tanner went deep to come up with four facts about scuba diving! But one of them isn't certified true. Listen along with hosts Sups and Andi as they try to bring to the surface which fact is a lie! 

Mark as Played
April 25, 2023 19 mins

We hope everyone had a happy Earth Day! In this final episode of the month, Quizmaster Andi dug up four facts about dirt. But one of them is a dirty lie! Think you can excavate the truth? Then pick up a shovel and join our hosts Sups and Tanner as they sift through the four facts! 

Mark as Played

In this Earth Day-themed episode, Quizmaster Sups bombards us with four plots from disaster movies. But take cover, because one of the plots is so fake, it'll rock your world. So grab some popcorn and strap in to join hosts Andi and Tanner in guessing which disaster movie plot has been altered! 

Mark as Played
April 11, 2023 16 mins

In keeping with our Earth Day theme for the month, we're looking critically at endangered species in this episode. Quizmaster Tanner corralled four facts about four animal species that are in danger of going extinct. But one of his facts is not true! So put on your safari hat and join hosts Andi and Sups in tracking down which fact is a lie! 

Mark as Played
April 4, 2023 18 mins

April is Earth Month at the I Should Have Known podcast! All this month, we'll be featuring episodes dedicated to our Mother Earth. To get this big blue ball rolling, Quizmaster Sups has four facts about the Indian Ocean for us. But watch out, one of his facts is as true as a flat earth! Play along with hosts Andi and Tanner as they venture deep into uncharted territory to find the lie among the facts. 

  • Follow and subscribe...
Mark as Played
March 28, 2023 18 mins

To end our line of nerdy episodes this month, Quizmaster Queen Andi tells the histories of four kings. But the twist this time is that three of them are from works of fiction while one really lived! Join hosts Tanner and Sups to see if you can spot the real ruler among the fantasy kings from three nerd-doms! 

Mark as Played
March 21, 2023 17 mins

"Check" out our latest episode continuing our nerding out theme! Quizmaster Tanner opens with four facts about the game of chess, but watch out for his gambit: one of them is false! Play along with hosts Andi and Sups as they try to outmaneuver him and find the lie! 

Mark as Played
March 14, 2023 18 mins

Insert a quarter to continue our nerding out theme for this month! Quizmaster Andi describes four events in the history of retro video games, but one of them is out of order! Think you know your gaming history? Join Players 1 and 2, Tanner and Sups, as they try to guess which event is out of time! 

Mark as Played

For the month of March, we're nerding out! Quizmaster Sups is leading us off with a 'find the fake' episode about superheroes from the Marvel universe! He tells the tales of four characters, but one of them is not really a Marvel superhero. Put on your cape and try to spot his imposter with your hosts Andi and Tanner! 

Mark as Played

To finish off our Anti-Valentine theme, Quizmaster Tanner delivers a bouquet of four facts about heart-stopping flowers. All four flowers are poisonous but only three facts are true! Think you can sniff out the truth or will you get your heart broken? Guess which fact is a lie along with hosts Andi and Sups! 

Mark as Played
February 21, 2023 19 mins

In this week's episode, Quizmaster Andi channels her inner bard and continues our Anti-Valentine theme with four tales of ill-fated couples. But one pair of star-crossed lovers is an Andi-original! Join hosts Sups and Tanner in trying to find the fake story and avoid getting your heart broken! 

Mark as Played
February 14, 2023 22 mins

Celebrate a happy Anti-Valentine's with this PG-13 episode all about how animals get it on! Quizmaster Tanner documented four facts about animal mating habits, but one of his facts is faking it. See if you get lucky guessing which one it is along with hosts Andi and Sups! 

Mark as Played
February 7, 2023 19 mins

Forget flowers, chocolates, and over-wrought romance, this February the ISHK podcast is celebrating the opposite with an Anti-Valentine's theme. Starting us off is Quizmaster Sups with four facts about breakup songs. Prepare to have your heart strings shredded when one of his facts turns out to be a lie! Guess which one it is along with hosts Andi and Tanner! 

Mark as Played
January 31, 2023 21 mins

To finish up our NEW theme this month, Quizmaster Andi penned four facts about novels throughout history. But instead of a bestseller, one of the facts is a lie! So before you add these novels to your reading list, join hosts Sups and Tanner as they learn the hard way that you can't judge a book by its cover! 

Mark as Played
January 24, 2023 19 mins

This week, Quizmaster Sups sits in the director's chair and produces four facts about Hollywood movie remakes! But one of them is a flop because it's not 100% true. Grab some popcorn and find your seat along with hosts Andi and Tanner in this continuation of our NEW theme. See if you can find the lie! 

Mark as Played
January 17, 2023 16 mins

In this brand spanking new episode, Quizmaster Tanner continues our theme of NEW by delivering four facts about newborn babies! But one of his facts needs changing, because it's a total lie! Can you figure out which one it is? Join hosts Sups and Andi as they try to sniff out which fact isn't 100% true! 

Mark as Played
January 10, 2023 14 mins

Continuing our theme of NEW, Quizmaster Andi documented four words that were newly added to the 2022 Merriam-Webster Dictionary. But one of them does not fit that definition! Are you confident in your lexicographic prowess? If so, join hosts Tanner and Sups in sorting through these neologisms to find the lie! 

Mark as Played

Popular Podcasts

    Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations.

    Crime Junkie

    If you can never get enough true crime... Congratulations, you’ve found your people.


    In order to tell the story of a crime, you have to turn back time. Every season, Investigative journalist Delia D'Ambra digs deep into a mind-bending mystery with the hopes of reigniting interest in a decades old homicide case.


    It’s a lighthearted nightmare in here, weirdos! Morbid is a true crime, creepy history and all things spooky podcast hosted by an autopsy technician and a hairstylist. Join us for a heavy dose of research with a dash of comedy thrown in for flavor.


    Unforgettable true crime mysteries, exclusive newsmaker interviews, hard-hitting investigative reports and in-depth coverage of high profile stories.

Advertise With Us

For You

    Music, radio and podcasts, all free. Listen online or download the iHeart App.


    © 2023 iHeartMedia, Inc.