August 16, 2024 • 56 mins
Send us a textChapter 6: Jennifer Meets Joey
Don't miss Jules' weekly true crime podcast, True Crime and Headlines with Jules & Jen
Help support our show by leaving us a 5 star review and rating wherever you get your podcasts!
10 % of all profits from this podcast will be donated back to the Wix family to fund their costs in this journey of justice.
For more information, visit our website www.missinginhushtown.com
You're wanted.
You're loved.
And you deserve to be found.
Thank you to our episode sponsor:
YouTube Channel @IamFromTennesseeHometown Connect
Your all-in-one app for Middle TN communities. SixOneFive Real Estate Advisors, LLC
People Over Profit.Relive Studio
Unlock the story your brand deserves. Andi B's Boutique
Creating faith, pet, and family-friendly designs for all. Hometown Connect
Your all-in-one app for Mid TN communities. SixOneFive Real Estate Advisors, LLC
People Over Profit.Andi B's Boutique
Creating faith, pet, and family-friendly designs for all. Relive Studio
Unlock the story your brand deserves. Hometown Connect
Your direct connection to local dining, shopping, events, jobs, and news in Middle Tennessee communiSixOneFive Real Estate Advisors, LLC
People Over Profit.Andi B's Boutique
Creating faith, pet, and family-friendly designs for all. Relive Studio
Unlock the story yourSupport the show
Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/missing-in-hush-town--6404892/support.
Don't miss Jules' weekly true crime podcast, True Crime and Headlines with Jules & Jen
Help support our show by leaving us a 5 star review and rating wherever you get your podcasts!
10 % of all profits from this podcast will be donated back to the Wix family to fund their costs in this journey of justice.
For more information, visit our website www.missinginhushtown.com
You're wanted.
You're loved.
And you deserve to be found.
Thank you to our episode sponsor:
YouTube Channel @IamFromTennesseeHometown Connect
Your all-in-one app for Middle TN communities. SixOneFive Real Estate Advisors, LLC
People Over Profit.Relive Studio
Unlock the story your brand deserves. Andi B's Boutique
Creating faith, pet, and family-friendly designs for all. Hometown Connect
Your all-in-one app for Mid TN communities. SixOneFive Real Estate Advisors, LLC
People Over Profit.Andi B's Boutique
Creating faith, pet, and family-friendly designs for all. Relive Studio
Unlock the story your brand deserves. Hometown Connect
Your direct connection to local dining, shopping, events, jobs, and news in Middle Tennessee communiSixOneFive Real Estate Advisors, LLC
People Over Profit.Andi B's Boutique
Creating faith, pet, and family-friendly designs for all. Relive Studio
Unlock the story yourSupport the show
Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/missing-in-hush-town--6404892/support.
Mark as Played
Transcript
Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:00):
Hey, it's Ryan Seacrest. Life comes at you fast, which
is why it's important to find some time to relax
a little U time enter Chumba Casino with no download required.
You can jump on any time, anywhere for the chance
to redeem some serious prizes. So treat yourself with Chumba
Casino and play over one hundred online casino style games,
all for free. Go to chumbucasino dot com to collect
(00:21):
your free welcome bonus sponsored by Chumpa Casino. No purchase
necessary VGW group void where prohibited by Law eighteen plus.
Terms and conditions apply.
Speaker 2 (00:32):
Black Friday is coming, and for the adults in your life.
Speaker 3 (00:34):
Who love the coolest toys, well there's something for them
this year too. Bartisian is the premiere craft cocktail maker
that automatically makes more than sixty seasonal.
Speaker 2 (00:44):
And classic cocktails each and.
Speaker 3 (00:45):
Out of thirty seconds at the push of a buzzon
and right now, Bartisian is having a huge sight wide sale.
You can get one hundred dollars off any cocktail maker
or cocktail maker bundle when you spend four hundred dollars
or more. So if the cocktail our lover in your
life has been good this year or the right kind
of bad. Get them Bartisian at the push of a button,
(01:07):
make Bark quality Cosmopolitans, Martini's, Manhattan's, and more, all in
just thirty seconds, all for one hundred off Amazing toys.
Speaker 2 (01:17):
Aren't just put kids.
Speaker 3 (01:19):
Get one hundred off a cocktail maker when you spend
four hundred through cyber Monday. Missus Bartisian dot com slash cocktail.
That's pa r t E sia n dot com slash cocktail.
Speaker 4 (01:32):
Missing in Hushtowns Season one is proudly sponsored by the
following relive studio, Andy B's Boutique six one five, real
Estate Advisors and Hometown Connect. Thank you to our sponsors.
This episode is sponsored by the YouTube channel at I
Am from Tennessee by professional local realtor Jennifer Davis. Missing
(01:54):
in Hushtowns Season one is proudly sponsored by the following
relive studio, Andy B's Boutique six one five, real Estate
Advisors and Hometown Connect. Thank you to our sponsors. Small
Town's Talk and We've been listening. I'm your host Jules Thorpe,
an independent investigated podcaster living in the same town. Jennifer
(02:15):
and Adriana Wicks went missing from in two thousand and four,
and this is missing in Hushtown Season one, chapter six,
Jennifer meets Joey.
Speaker 5 (03:06):
Note for me before we dive in.
Speaker 4 (03:09):
What I know now makes everything you are about to
hear even more heartbreaking. Myself, along with many people who
are close with the Wicks girls and the Benton family,
believe that if Jennifer and Adriana had never met Joey,
they would be alive today. This is me saying that
someone at that Benton residence knows what happened and who
(03:34):
did it, So if there was never any Joey and Jennifer,
there would never be any Bentons in their life. I
promised in the first episode I would share with you
more information, and I will. I'm not done yet, I promise.
In fact, I'll go ahead and share this. Joey called
Casey and they talked on the phone for the first
(03:56):
time in twenty years. Casey asked Joey some very direct
and tough questions and still he lied. And yes, now
we know he lied. We have confirmation that he lied,
but we'll get more into that in a few episodes.
Speaker 5 (04:15):
Stay with me.
Speaker 4 (04:16):
We need to roll the tape back to win Jennifer
meets Joey. It's the winner of two thousand and three
in Middle Tennessee. Jennifer is now a young mother at
twenty one to her daughter Adriana, who was just past
her first birthday. Most people will pronounce it as Adrianna,
but Jennifer will make sure to correct them and say
(04:38):
her baby's name the right way Adriana. In fact, she
named her after seeing Vince gild perform the Adriana song
at the Grand ol Opry when she went with her mom.
Speaker 6 (04:48):
Kathy.
Speaker 4 (04:49):
Robertson County tends to slow down a bit in the cold,
as if the community freezes in time. Along with the
layers of ice that can shut down roads for a
week at a time, a county ill equipped with snow
clearing devices finds it's easier to shut down school a
few days than invest the money on snowplows and storage
just to use maybe a few times a year. Maybe
(05:14):
the weather is unpredictable here in the winter, but it's
typically cold. The evenings tend to drop below freezing as
the sun sets and the night goes still. The trees
are bare and extend into the moonlight as old withered
arms stretching for the stars beyond their reach. Jennifer's mom, Kathy,
has accepted a job promotion which will find her moving
(05:36):
across the country to Las Vegas, Nevada. This job will
provide more opportunities for Kathy to grow in her field,
and she feels her youngest daughter, Casey will adapt well
with the change. After all, she'll be moving right before
she starts high school. Jennifer and her middle sister, Heather
choose to stay in Tennessee. This is their home and
they have places to live while mom Kathy moves away,
(05:59):
Heather choosing to stay mostly with Kathy's mother and Jennifer
choosing to stay mostly with Michael's mother. So both girls
are with grandparents from different sides of the family, and
Jennifer also goes in between Grannie Wicks and Aunt Lisa's home.
Heather is often visiting with her sister and her niece
(06:19):
at Aunt Lisa's house. Recall, Grannie Wicks is from Jennifer's
father's side, and although this is true, Grannie Wicks was
always so inviting and loving toward all of Jennifer's siblings,
blood or not. With temperatures in the triple digits with
humidity to match. Many people in Robertson County can be
(06:40):
found in waterwaves, creeks, rivers, pools, sprinklers, Sweet tea is
poured by the gallons, and the humming of air conditioning
units fill the air. Aunt Lisa has two children at
home at the time, her son Jeffrey and her daughter Samantha.
This is Samantha, Jennifer's cousin.
Speaker 7 (07:00):
I'm Samantha True. I'm first cousins with Jennifer Wigs. Yeah,
pretty typical cousin relationships. She's was quite a bit older
than me, so I was obviously closer to her younger
sisters than to her until we were older. I do
remember her being with us. That's when the two of
us got really close. Did you share a room but
(07:22):
did not share a room? Her room was right next
to mine because we had a spare bedroom. Her and
Adriana were in the room together, right next to me.
I spent a lot of time with Adriana, rocked her
to sleep many nights.
Speaker 6 (07:33):
I don't remember her being with any.
Speaker 7 (07:35):
Men before Joey long enough for it to be one
of those things where like he came to family functions
or was like involved in that kind of way. I
can tell you that I was exposed to him because
he was a friend of my brother and he would
come to the house to, you know, visit with my brother.
(07:57):
I was young, so obviously I didn't have any you know,
I didn't talk to him personally because I had no
reason to. But yeah, I first met him and was
around him because of his relationship with my brother his friendship.
I don't remember when they met. I know it was
through my brother, just because she was there. The only
(08:19):
time I recall being around them as a couple for
any expiritive time was they had one of Adriana's birthday
parties at the Benton home and I went. Most people
know that Joey and his sister or his siblings didn't
have a good childhood, especially so if you're going to
(08:41):
love someone else's child the way it seemed like he
loved Adriana, you have to you have to know that
he loved her at some point, or his version of
love or what he thought love was, or how he
felt love. It's also hard to understand how people that
have had traumatic childhoods feel love, you know, how did
they receive love? His children and what does it look
(09:03):
like to them? But it seemed to me like he
loved Adriana. It's so strange that one minute you're being
a loving father figure per se to this child, and
the next minute they're gone and you don't seem to care.
In all appearances from the outside looking in, he didn't
care about them. He didn't care about Jennifer, he didn't
care about Adriana. If if you're a spectator looking in
(09:25):
on this, he seems like, you know, a short time
boyfriend that you know didn't really care. But I think
he did. I think he did care. And I think
whatever is causing him to act like he doesn't care
and to not be around is severe. And to think
(09:48):
about I mean, he was young. Think about being that young,
and you know, whatever happens, his life's probably been a
living hell. And I'm not saying he didn't deserve it,
because he obviously could have given us some closure up
to this point. But something bad happened to him that
day too. He's not innocent. He was involved in some
(10:14):
kind of way. I'm still angry at him. The one
time I can recall an adult seeing him in public
broke me that day. I was living where I'm living
now in the house next to me is a duplex,
and I look up my window one morning and he's
in my driveway cause we have a shared driveway, and
he's helping the people next door move And so all
(10:36):
day I'm home having to look out the window and
see him. And what's really strange too, is to live
in the same town as someone and never see them.
Like when you live in the same town as someone,
you see people passing by in their vehicle, you see
them at the gas station, at the grocery store, at
the local restaurants. You do not ever see the Bitten
(10:58):
family and cross planes. Ever, I don't I don't recall
seeing them out like is. I don't know where they
go do their shopping.
Speaker 6 (11:09):
Or get gas.
Speaker 7 (11:10):
But anyways, I just the whole day looking out of
the window and having to see him there, and that
many years later, when you've gone about your life and
then for it to be like smacked in the face
by it, And really it just made me mad to
see him doing just like a normal everyday thing, just
(11:33):
live in his life, helping a friend move, and in
my mind, it's just kissed me off. So I do
sympathize for him, but I also understand that he could
(11:54):
have said dark family a lot of hurt these best
years if he hadn't been scared. I think I think
he's scared. But it's just not fair that he's continued
living his life however shitty it. Maybe I'm not saying
he's got a good life. He probably doesn't. But just
(12:19):
to see him on a random day helping someone move
when I hadn't seen him in years.
Speaker 8 (12:29):
Did he see you?
Speaker 6 (12:31):
I don't think so.
Speaker 7 (12:32):
I pretty much hit away in my house all day,
and I was so mad all day that I was
shaking and crying. And if i'd go one else, had
I practice said something to him, I'm not something to
do anybody any good. He probably wouldn't even know who
I was if he saw me.
Speaker 8 (12:44):
Honestly.
Speaker 7 (12:45):
We have a community wide yard cell every year called
Trash and Treasures, because I remember being summertime and I
think we had gotten together as a family at a
home locally, and I was walking into the Food Value
or the Piglo Wigley or whatever, And that probably would
have been three months after they went missing, And so
(13:09):
their signs, their posters are still all over town and
I remember just walking into the grocery store to get
something and people standing there looking at their sign and
making remarks like, you know, they just ran away because
this town sucks, or something to that effect, like you know,
she just hated it here and so she left, or
just making assumptions just because she was an adult that
(13:31):
she could just leave. I didn't say anything to them
because I was young, and but my memories are vague
of that time, but for some reason, that really sticks
out in my mind of that was probably the first
time that I heard or saw somebody like make that
assumption about them. In my mind, obviously I knew them,
(13:53):
I knew that wasn't the case, but it never occurred
to me that that's what other people might think. It
was so hurtful this someone in our town was making
those assumptions and voicing them to other people. My mom
loved Jennifer like she was her own and I think
she showed that, and Jennifer knew that she always had
a place in our home. And yeah, Jennifer knew that.
(14:17):
Jennifer knew she always had somewhere to go, and she
had people that cared for her. So that's that's another
aspect of the case that people don't understand is she
had somewhere to go if she wanted to leave Joey.
She had the opportunity. She had a place to go,
She had a room. The room was still empty that
she lived in. She could have came back, and my
mom told her she could come back whenever she wanted.
(14:39):
She knew where we hid the key. But yeah, my
mom loved her. My mom loved Adriana and was willing
to take care of her and do anything for her.
I've dreamed about her so many times. Her and Jennifer
(15:05):
have come to me in dreams many times over. Mainly
they've just been here, we are you found us, reunions,
the fill of joy and happiness and relief over just
(15:29):
we found them.
Speaker 8 (15:34):
Yeah.
Speaker 7 (15:36):
And I don't know if that's wishful thinking or Jennifer
is saying we'll see you later. You know, we'll see
you after this life. But it's a comfort, but it's
also a nightmare when you wake up.
Speaker 5 (16:03):
Yeah.
Speaker 4 (16:05):
I asked Heather, Jennifer's middle sister on her mom's side,
how she met Joey and what she had to say.
Speaker 9 (16:12):
Well, Samantha was just in here. That's our cousin. Her
older brother is Jeffrey. Jeffrey and I were super close
as cousins, so me and Jeffrey would hang out all
the time. And Jeffrey was best friends with Joey. So
I remember meeting joe one night. Meet Jeffrey and Joey.
(16:35):
We were in his Explore. We went to Rivergate at
a Toys Rs.
Speaker 6 (16:39):
One time.
Speaker 9 (16:41):
I remember that was the first night I met him.
Jeffrey was like, you want to take a ride, and
I was like, yeah, let's go. I didn't know what
we were doing, you know, I was young. I was
probably sixteen maybe, And then we drove to the Toys Rs.
Parking lot in Rivergate. Joey was the driver, in the
driver's seat. He was driving us at his Explorer, and
then my cousin Jeffrey was in the passenger seat.
Speaker 6 (17:03):
I was in the back.
Speaker 9 (17:04):
Then Joey takes a gun out and he sits in
on the console. He takes I remember him like lining
up some pills and some baggies and he did a
drug deal. And I would say that I was My
mom was so strict growing up.
Speaker 6 (17:19):
I was just a little bit sheltered.
Speaker 9 (17:21):
So then I started to hang out with Jeffrey and
his friends, and that was like the first of any
you know thing. I was like so scared and so shocked.
But anyways, I just find that ironic. That's my first
meeting ever with Joey before Joey ever started dating Jennifer, so.
Speaker 6 (17:38):
Basically knew he was no good for her.
Speaker 9 (17:39):
But but yeah, that's how I met Joey. That's the
first time. And I think I hung out with him
again when maybe in his barn one time and there
was a bunch of Jeffrey and Joey's friends and they
were all passing around, you know, a joint mayor or whatever,
(18:02):
and we were all just hanging out, like in the barn,
just partying as kids and teenagers. But then I don't
think too long after that, Jennifer started dating Joey.
Speaker 10 (18:15):
And.
Speaker 9 (18:17):
Their relationship was now that I'm a grown woman and
I look back, it was toxic as can be. It
was the breakup, go out, breakup, go out, you know, fighting, hostility,
you know, her crying.
Speaker 4 (18:34):
It wasn't long before Joey and Jennifer became an intense
and serious couple, with Jennifer bringing him around the people
she cared the most about. Jennifer's youngest sister, Megan Wicks
from her dad's side, recalls when Joey and Jennifer came
to visit them.
Speaker 11 (18:48):
One of the last times we saw her, and they
came to visit with Joey. Only met Joey. I guess
one time. It was one of the last times I
saw him, but I don't know. I feel like they
visited or she at least visited with Adriana twice before,
you know, before I ever saw him again, never saw
(19:09):
them again. But I do remember.
Speaker 6 (19:11):
Joey very vaguely.
Speaker 11 (19:14):
I remember, I think a lot of the time he.
Speaker 6 (19:18):
Was outside talking with my dad.
Speaker 11 (19:20):
You know, they are just outside hanging out, probably because
they were smoking a cigarette or whatever. They're just outside.
But I remember when they left. When people would come
visited our house, especially Jennifer, it wasn't just Okay, we're
getting in the car and leaving. It was We're gonna
stand around and talk for another hour, you know. So
you know, Jennifer and Joey are standing outside just talking
(19:41):
to my dad getting ready to leave, and you know,
I'm out there with my dad because I followed him everywhere,
and I remember Adriana was in the back seat, and
she just absolutely adored Joey. And this was the only
time I ever saw her cry or get upset, but
she wanted him in that car. She was tired, and
she just kept saying Joey, Doe, like that's.
Speaker 6 (20:03):
What she called him.
Speaker 11 (20:04):
And she was doing she was motioning her little hand
like come get in the car, like come on, Joey,
you know, like she loved.
Speaker 6 (20:11):
Joey, and it was very sweet.
Speaker 11 (20:15):
And I can't remember if they had brought her rocking
horse or if we already had one, but I remember
she her playing on the rocking horse.
Speaker 4 (20:25):
Wall don't go anywhere, We'll be right back. Six one
five real Estate Advisors People Overprofit. Sixty one five real
estate Advisors are committed to bringing people in our community
home every single day. This includes Jennifer and Adriana Wicks.
(20:50):
Located in Robertson County, Tennessee. Six one five real Estate
Advisors proudly serve.
Speaker 5 (20:55):
All of Middle Tennessee.
Speaker 4 (20:58):
Andy Bee's boutique custom for all your needs, creating faithpet
and family friendly designs for all. Visit shopandybees dot com
for an exclusive Jennifer and Adriana Wick shirt. Andy Be's
boutique will donate profits from each Wick shirt back to
the Wicks family to fight for justice. That website is
shop andybes a and d i bs dot com. Don't
(21:31):
go anywhere, We'll be right back. Six one five real
Estate Advisors People over Profit.
Speaker 5 (21:38):
Six one five real.
Speaker 4 (21:39):
Estate advisors are committed to bringing people in our community
home every single day. This includes Jennifer and Adriana Wicks.
Located in Robertson County, Tennessee. Sixty one five real Estate
Advisors proudly serve all of Middle Tennessee. Andy B's Boutique
custom tees for all your needs, creating faith, p and
(22:00):
family friendly designs for all.
Speaker 5 (22:02):
Visit shopandybees dot.
Speaker 4 (22:04):
Com for an exclusive Jennifer and Adriana wickshirt. Andyb's Boutique
will donate profits from each Wick shirt back to the
Wicks family to fight for justice. That website is shop
andybs A and d i bs dot com.
Speaker 12 (22:21):
In the Shadows of the City, a business missed a
crucial chance, neglecting the power of captivating content. While others
captured hearts. Their story remained hidden, but you can rewrite
your story. Relive Studio transforms your brand with striking photos
and video content. Visit www Dot relive dot studio, Mention
(22:46):
this ad and receive free photos with your video package.
Unlock the story your brand deserves.
Speaker 4 (22:55):
Hometown Connect your local list. Hometown Connect your ultimate list,
bringing communities together through small town business connections. They're your
go to app for all things Middle Tennessee. They empowered
local businesses and promote.
Speaker 5 (23:10):
The shop local revolution through.
Speaker 4 (23:12):
Advanced technology, while never sacrificing online privacy with innovative Bluetooth,
proximity marketing, direct customer messaging, and in app marketing tools.
Speaker 5 (23:23):
They're your ultimate local list.
Speaker 4 (23:26):
Hometown Connect.
Speaker 12 (23:31):
In the shadows of the city, a business missed a
crucial chance, neglecting the power of captivating content, while others
captured hearts. Their story remained hidden, but you can rewrite
your story. Relive Studio transforms your brand with striking photos
and video content. Visit www. Dot relive dot studio, Mention
(23:57):
this ad and receive free photos with your video package.
Unlock the story your brand deserves.
Speaker 4 (24:05):
Hometown Connect your local list. Hometown Connect your ultimate list,
bringing communities together through small town business connections. They're your
go to app for all things Middle Tennessee. They empowered
local businesses and promote.
Speaker 5 (24:21):
The shop local revolution through.
Speaker 4 (24:23):
Advanced technology, while never sacrificing online privacy. With innovative bluetooth,
proximity marketing, direct customer messaging, and in app marketing tools,
they're your ultimate local list hometown connect. Although Kathy wasn't
(24:43):
thrilled about Jennifer and Adriana living in a barn on
the bent And property, she was assured it was fine
as the months became cooler and the fall began bringing
cool breezes. And if you've never experienced a fall in
a small football town in the South, you're in for
a treat. The leaves go from it deep green to
a beautiful, rich orange, yellow and deep red. The weighted
(25:04):
blanket of the humidity from the summer burdens have been lifted.
And if you were to drive around this small town
on Friday night, you'll see teenagers piled up in trucks
headed to the high school football games, the bleachers filled
with alumni from generations, past the stadium, lights flooding far
past the field into the town square. Or maybe the
(25:27):
kids are headed to bonfires at someone's family farm, or
they plan to meet by the creek with music and beer.
Speaker 5 (25:34):
Whatever they choose.
Speaker 4 (25:35):
The air is filled with the smoke from the tobacco
burning barns, something that Robertson County is known for. So
in Springfield, Tennessee, just a few roads over from the
cross Plains city lines, deep in the heart of Robertson County, Jennifer, Joey,
and Adriana seek a life independent of others, a life
where they can act as a family, a trio, Joey
(25:58):
stepping in as a father and protect role for Adriana,
offering commitment, support, and loved Jennifer. The barn offered a
sense of independence, albeit it was veiled independence. Jennifer was
always dependent on her family, and not just financially. You know,
she was attached in a loving way to her family.
They offered her emotional support, consistency in a time when
(26:21):
you know, there was so much change and friendship. After all,
the family was together in support of Jennifer throughout Jennifer's
pregnancy at nineteen, her delivery at twenty, and throughout her
learning how to navigate life as a young mother. So
when Jennifer calls her mom Kathy one evening in Las
Vegas and shares that Joe's mother Cindy Benton drove her
(26:42):
and Adriana away from Joey's house and dropped her off
at a Granny Wicks's house.
Speaker 5 (26:47):
Kathy was alarmed what.
Speaker 4 (26:49):
Jennifer told her, Well, folks, it was enough to make
Kathy quit her job and immediately relocate back to Tennessee.
She knew she had to get back to her daughter
and granddaughter immediately. According to police reports, Cathy said, quote,
Joey had in the recent past pulled a gun on
(27:10):
Jennifer and threatened to hurt them all. He called his
mother to come and get them before he hurt them all.
She did and took Jennifer and Adriana to her grandparents
end quote. It's important to pause here and inform all
of our listeners that every person I've talked about by
name in this podcast was reached out to by either
(27:32):
myself or Casey, Jennifer's sister. I texted Joey multiple times,
Jennifer's cousin multiple times, and had an interview set up
for Aunt Lisa, which she ultimately declined to participate in.
I don't share this information to discredit these individuals, because,
in the end, I truthfully support their right to not
talk and after all investigated, podcasting is not a really
(27:55):
widely known medium for storytelling. People don't know me, and
of course I understand that lack of trust. I do
bring up my attempts to communicate with all involved individuals
because I wanted it known that my intent was to
give all sides, all parties in equal space to share
their opinions.
Speaker 5 (28:11):
Clear up, any rumors are set record straight.
Speaker 4 (28:13):
I want transparency here, but transparency doesn't mean I won't
interpret the information I believe. I did not attempt to
reach out to a few individuals in this case, and
that was at the request of law enforcement through the family.
I did not attempt to contact Joe Benton. Also note
he is currently in jail in Robertson County. Again, we
(28:37):
never want to hurt a case, just help. I am
here to poke some bears because this is the game
we have to play to get noticed, and we're going
to suit up and step in the ring and play
as fair as we can to win. But we are
not holding back our punches. All right, back to the report,
we have now played Cindy Benton in the car with
Jennifer and Adriana driving her to Granny Wicks's home. Recall,
(29:01):
Jennifer was living at that home and her aunt Lisa's
home while her mother had moved to Las Vegas for
a job promotion. So this is a house she feels
safe in. Obviously, the place we flee from is our
place of fear, but the place we flee too, says
everything about trust and understanding. Jennifer knew that her Granny
(29:21):
Wicks's home was a safe haven, and she knew she
was always welcome there at any time of the day.
What is interesting is that throughout the years, defenders of
Joey Benton have denied that Joey would ever harm Jennifer.
In fact, in an online forum that was popular in
local communities at the time called Topics, community members could
(29:41):
post anonymously, and when the girls went missing in two
thousand and four, Topics appeared to be the place where
the Wicks and the Benton families would communicate. And I
use that term loosely. The Benton family has always veheminently
denied Joey could ever hurt Jennifer until recently. Important to
not forget that these police reports quote what the family
(30:05):
says to the police officers. Now it's just that it's
quotes from other people. It's not corroborated information. It's not
a corroborative report about whether Joey did or did not
pull a gun on Jennifer. There is no police report
on that actual incident. As far as we civilians understand,
(30:25):
with the extent of our access to the files in
this case, we do not have a statement from Cindy
Benton or any written statement from anyone other than Kathy
in the report taken when the girls disappeared. Jennifer and
Adriana remained living between Aunt Lisa and Granny Wicks's home
until Kathy and Casey moved back to Tennessee. It wasn't
(30:46):
a long time waiting. Kathy mobilized very quickly. She didn't
think twice about coming back. Call it a mother's intuition.
This incident is what the Wick's family refers to as
the first red flag us, knowing what we know About's
first experience with Joey and the drug exchange at the mall,
it would likely be our second red flag. But up
until this point, Joey had never shown this dangerous behavior
(31:09):
toward Jennifer and Adriana. It's interesting to say the least,
we almost have two versions of joe when people recall him.
There was a Joey who appeared to have truly loved Jennifer,
and then there was the Joey that seemed to display rage, aggression,
and violence seeing on alternating side, Jennifer did break up
with Joey.
Speaker 5 (31:29):
She was done now.
Speaker 4 (31:31):
It recall they hadn't been dating that long. They met
in July and the first incident where Jennifer tells her
mother about Joey threatening the girls as in the fall.
So within twelve weeks give or take, they have moved
in together, not broken up, and now we find ourselves
living back with Kathy and Casey and Heather once Kathy
was able to get back to Tennessee. Meanwhile, Kathy's strong
(31:52):
and fierce mother, as those who knew her would describe her,
had a home that she was able to rent out
to the girls. Casey, Kathy, and Heather lived in the
upstairs park and Jennifer stayed in the finish basement below,
which had two bedrooms. Heather's bedroom was just above Jennifer's
and she could often hear Jennifer's phone conversation seep up
(32:13):
into her room and of course, a nosy little sister
would make sure she could hear even better by opening
her windows and crouching near the air fence. The family
rallied around Jennifer. They wanted her to succeed. They wanted
to help her and support her and raise her up.
They loved her so deeply that they decided to form
(32:33):
a type of intervention for Jennifer once they caught wind
that she may be considering going back to Joey. Heather
and Kathy both recall the intervention here.
Speaker 9 (32:44):
We all had a family intervention at one point, and
I can't remember. I feel like this may have been
before the fight where the door gets busted in, but
we it was her grandmother, it was me, my mom,
my grand mother. I can't remember who else was there,
but they all met at our house because we knew
(33:06):
that Jennifer was starting to think about going back to
Joey and she had no idea. We're about to have
an intervention on her, and this is where we all
knew this was not a good idea, and we were
going to set her down and let her know that
she shouldn't do this.
Speaker 6 (33:23):
Think about the baby.
Speaker 9 (33:25):
We also know Jennifer's an amazing mother and she loved
her baby. And then my mom just didn't want to
push Jennifer further away. But my mom just didn't want
Jennifer to hate her and push her away, which you
can only imagine how much that would cause, you know,
between a mom and a daughter if a mom did that.
Speaker 6 (33:45):
But Mom, we all.
Speaker 9 (33:47):
Were really just knew it was bad and that they
like we just knew something was gonna happen.
Speaker 8 (33:54):
When her and Joey were split up and I had
came back from Las Vegas and they were living with me,
and I was I worked during the day, and so
I babysat the baby at night for her to take
my vehicle and go to work. And I had found
out that she wasn't going to work. Every time she
(34:16):
told me that she was, she was actually going to
see Joey and maybe possibly trying to work things out
with him. And so she wasn't she wasn't holding up
to her into the bargain as far as getting her
(34:38):
life together and getting breaking away from the abuse and
stuff from Joey and you know, the verbal kind of
abuse from Joey, and you know, keeping her job. She
was in the threat of losing her job. It was
very important that she kept her job and and show
(35:02):
up in the morning in time for me to have
my car to go to work and take care of
her baby. There was just several little things that she
just wasn't doing that she had agreed that she would do.
So our family, all of us grandparents, aunts, everyone thought
(35:26):
that we needed to talk to her and let her
know how important it was that she basically get her
act together and put her priorities in line. And her
priorities shouldn't be Joey, it should be her job and
her baby and that sort of thing. And so we
(35:51):
all got together one night, if I remember correctly, it
was around November the tenth run in there, and when
Jennifer come in, we just said, hey, we want to
talk to you, and we kind of laid down the
law to her and said, look, you've got to do this,
and you do not need to have the baby at Joey's.
(36:13):
That's not a good environment. There's guns, there's drugs. You've
told us about all this, and that's not a place
you want to have your baby. It's not safe for you,
it's not safe for her. And so we told her that.
Then we said if you if you're not careful, someone
(36:34):
may try to intervene and take your child from you,
and you don't want that to happen. If someone was
to call child services and say that you were, you know,
shacked up in a party barn with guns and drugs,
they would they would take your child. And so this
is where it is very important that you'd listen to
us older folks who who have experience and can tell
(36:57):
you that that's you know that you're you're down the
wrong path here and you need to you need to
steer back into work, you know, onto the right path.
So that was our intervention that we had with her
in November.
Speaker 2 (37:12):
I guess it.
Speaker 8 (37:13):
Didn't do a lot of good, unfortunately, because you know,
she ended up giving Joey another chance and moving back
in with Joey in December.
Speaker 9 (37:23):
The night of the fight, I heard Jennifer talking to
Joey on the phone downstairs through the vent because I
was eavesdropping, and I ran and told my mom and Adriana.
I believe Adriana was upstairs. She may have been playing
with Casey or something, but I was in my room
eavesdropping I could hear that she was getting back together
(37:46):
with Joey despite denying, and she was basically inviting him
to come over and to help her get everything out
of the house and help her because she knew we
weren't gonna let her just walk out the door. So
I ran and told Mom, and I think, if I
can remember correctly, Mom and Jennifer just started arguing. Mom's
(38:08):
trying to talk her out of it. Next thing we know,
Joey is there. I think Joey gets in. He goes
downstairs to grab some of Jennifer's things and belongings. He
walks outside to put them in the car. Mom and
Jennifer are fighting. I locked the door behind Joey as
(38:31):
he takes the stuff out, and I'm like standing up
against the door with the door locked, and I remember
Jennifer like physically pushing my mom.
Speaker 6 (38:46):
Over onto the coffee table.
Speaker 9 (38:48):
I don't know if she hit her or pushed her
or what, but she pushed her and my mom literally
just went tumbling over the coffee table. Well, this is
the first fight I've ever gotten into in my life.
Speaker 6 (39:07):
I think this is actually.
Speaker 9 (39:10):
The hardest thing for me personally to talk about because
when I saw my when I saw Mom weighing on
the floor like I'm protective over my mother. I didn't
want Jennifer to go or Adriana, But as soon as
I saw her, you know, hit my mom and push
her over the coffee table. I jumped on Jennifer and
(39:30):
we started physically fighting, and I think her earring ripped out.
Speaker 6 (39:36):
I don't know, but I mean, you're sitting here looking
at me.
Speaker 9 (39:44):
I'm five to two and a half and Jennifer was
probably I don't know, five six.
Speaker 6 (39:50):
Five seven, I don't even know. I know a younger.
Speaker 9 (39:52):
I remember my mom put her in this modeling thing
and she was like one of the tall models. But anyway,
the reason why I say that is because we started fighting.
The next thing, I know, she's screaming for Joey. Joey
kicks in our front door and the whole door comes
(40:13):
tumbling down and he grabs her and they literally like
I'm screaming and my mom's screaming, like Casey, get Adriana
and take her to the back bedroom and call nine
one one, like we are screaming, and Casey runs locks
the door, has the baby and is calling nine one one.
So and Jennifer and Adriana just start running. I guess
(40:34):
because we had just gotten in a fight. You know,
she had hit me a couple of times. I probably
hit her a couple of times. She had hit my mom,
who was just chaos.
Speaker 6 (40:42):
And so.
Speaker 9 (40:46):
I don't know why they didn't stay to try to
get Adriana, maybe just to get out of the situation,
but they took off running and they left. Well the
next thing I know, they're a police there. So on
their end, Joe Jennifer called the police, and on our end,
Casey called the police. So they were a police on
both ends who knew, and unfortunately we fought. We fought,
(41:13):
We pressed charges and filed a report.
Speaker 6 (41:15):
You did, yes, and then for vandalism.
Speaker 9 (41:20):
And then I'm pretty I'm not exactly sure if they
filed a report. I'm not exactly sure, but I remember
we had to hand Adriana back over.
Speaker 6 (41:38):
And that was hard. And then.
Speaker 10 (41:45):
This is the shitty thing because not long after that
they disappeared, and I just.
Speaker 6 (42:08):
I don't feel like that I really got to make
up with my big sister.
Speaker 9 (42:16):
He was also my best friend. I don't think I
saw her much after that. And then there was a chord.
Speaker 6 (42:29):
Date set.
Speaker 9 (42:31):
And I had to go testifying court and be portrayed
as a monster on the stand, and my sister was
supposed to be at court and she was missing already,
So my sister couldn't even stand up for me in
court and be like she was just trying to protect
her mom. Like my sister is not a monster, you know.
(42:56):
But I remember joey'stting sitting in court, and I just
remember his attorney, I don't know it was like a
public defender or whatever, but they were just like hammering me.
They made it out to sound like I'm so much
bigger than Jennifer, and like I hurt her.
Speaker 6 (43:18):
She was not hurt.
Speaker 9 (43:20):
Is this because he was trying to get off on
charges like and they were trying to say like he
had to protect my sister and bust in our door.
And they just made me out to be some monster
whenever my family and myself send so much pain. And
here I am seventeen years old, eighteen Can you remember
how old I was at this point?
Speaker 6 (43:38):
But it was seventeen or eighteen, But.
Speaker 9 (43:44):
And my whole entire family's just in pain because my
sister's gone and we know it he had We know
that the Ben family had something to do with it.
Speaker 6 (43:54):
We just knew.
Speaker 9 (43:55):
Look at what just happened, look at why we were
sitting in court in the first place, you know, and
she wasn't even there to be able to speak up
and use her voice.
Speaker 8 (44:06):
My memory is a little foggy after all these years,
but I do know that I came in and he
was there, and one of the girls, you know, told
me he was downstairs and they were getting Jennifer's things
together and the baby's things together, and so of course
I went down there to see what was going on,
and I confronted both of them, and I asked Jennifer
(44:31):
to you know, please, you don't go there, don't leave
with him, please. And I confronted Joey, and I said
to Joey, because Jennifer told me they wanted to get
married and stuff, you know, we're gonna get married. You're
gonna have to accept him. And I said to Joey,
(44:55):
how are you gonna support them? And are you going
to get the drugs and the guns of your house
so the baby will be safe? You know how? You know,
how are you going to support my daughter and granddaughter
and take care of them properly? And he turned around
and looked me square in the eye and he said,
you don't have a daughter anymore, bitch, and.
Speaker 9 (45:21):
He went on.
Speaker 8 (45:23):
Out with Jennifer's bag to put it in the truck.
And I shut the front door and locked it, and
I turned to Jennifer and I begged her, please don't go,
and she reached for the He was on the other
(45:45):
side of the door, knocking on the door. She reached
for the door to unlock the door, and I grabbed
her wrist and I was right in her face, eye
to eye, crying and begging her, please don't go with him,
Please don't go with him. And she shoved me. She
(46:11):
shoved me and pushed me, and I fell over the
coffee table in the living room, and Heather hears all
that's happening. Heather comes in. Casey has already I think
at this point, Casey, I believe has already grabbed the
baby and taken off to my bedroom in the back
(46:31):
of the house. And I didn't know it but at
that second, but she called. She was calling nine one one,
and Heather sees all this going on between me and Jennifer,
and that Jennifer had put her hands on me, and
that we were actually in a physical struggle, and so
Heather kind of took it up and was like, I'll
(46:54):
put your hands on mom. You know what's wrong with you?
You know, And just so it turned into this kind
of hair pulling, screaming, clawing match between the two sisters,
you know, not really any fist blows or anything like that.
Just no, not really.
Speaker 9 (47:14):
Uh uh.
Speaker 8 (47:15):
I had not ever seen them really fight like that.
But I mean I'd seen them maybe shove one another
and you know, say ugly things to each other or
something like that, but never to that extent.
Speaker 7 (47:27):
Uh.
Speaker 8 (47:28):
It was just that Heather went into protective mode for
her mom. And so while they're fussn't and hollering and
arguing and hair pulling, Jennifer's hollering Joey help me, Joey
help me, and Joey kicked down the door, I mean,
completely totally off the hinges the front door, and him
(47:53):
and Jennifer left and that's the baby there. Thus, and
they left quickly, and the police come take pictures of me.
I had a couple of little marks on me and stuff,
you know, and explain to us, you know that, I mean,
(48:17):
they understood that why everything had happened. They understood why
we didn't want the baby to go, but also we knew,
as they explained, and we really already knew in our
logical sense that you know, the baby has to go
with her with her mommy. So then, uh, Joey and
(48:46):
Cindy the police officer stayed there. Believe that was a
Cross Plains police officer that was there. It was, And
Julie comes back with his mom and they got Adriana
and took Adriana. And then I found out later that
(49:08):
joe Joey's bother, took Jennifer to the Cross Plains Police
department to foul a complaint against me trying to keep
her child from her and attacking her and all this
(49:30):
kind of thing. And you know, I believe that was
just to counteract what he knew was coming for his son,
which was vandalism charges for kicking in my door.
Speaker 4 (49:41):
And yes, you may have caught that in Heather's interview.
The family had to go to court for this event,
and it's because a family filed a report against Joey
for kicking down their door. But in order to fully
analyze each side of this event dutifully, so each participating
member was called to the stand. It means, folks, that
Heather was called to the stand and if you needn't
(50:03):
catch what she said, it was this. Her family was
in the throes of searching for Jennifer and Adriana. By
this time, when the court date is here, the girls
are missing and behind the scenes, the Wicks family is
fighting Robertson County to find their girls. Without confirmation of
(50:24):
when Jennifer and Joey were actually engaged, we do know
from Kathy's recollection that Jennifer was planning on being with
Joey now for a long time. However long Joey and
Jennifer had been talking again and seeing each other again
in secret is unknown, but it was likely emotion to
move back in together for some time. So that Christmas,
(50:45):
just three days after this incident, Kathy's home is in
distress and concerned over her daughter and granddaughter's safety. The
days turn into weeks without contact with Jennifer and Adriana's
second birthday comes and goes in January. At birthday spent
celebrating at the Benton home, not the Wicks home, tensions
(51:06):
begin to reach an all time high between the two families.
The Bentons may it very known that the Wicks family
is not welcome at their home, and the Wicks family
makes it very known that the Bentons are not welcome
at their home. But slowly Jennifer begins to come back around.
She starts by calling her mom regularly again and then
(51:27):
agrees to meet her mother at the local McDonald's where
little sisters Heather and Casey worked at the time.
Speaker 8 (51:34):
Jennifer did tell me that she and Jodi were engaged.
Think I think she even had a ring on, just
a simple gold wedding band that she was wearing, and ah, Homesley.
(52:00):
I just thought that at that moment, at that time,
I can remember just thinking, you're just trying to force
this guy on us, you know, like you know, getting
married to him, you know, because I thought Jennifer would
come to her senses and leave him. You know, I
really thought that I had come around right before they disappeared.
(52:23):
I had finally came around because I had met them
a couple of times, like at McDonald's, at the at
the play area, and just you know, you know, just
to talk with Jennifer and play with Adriana and get
her some unhappiness or whatever, you know, And Joey seemed okay,
(52:45):
like not, Yeah, Joey would come with him. She never
got to go anywhere without him. They wouldn't let her
drive any of their vehicles or anything like that. Uh,
so he had to bring her. He took her every
where she went. But when I would see him, you know,
placing the baby in her car seat, or playing with
her in the play area, or just carrying her out,
(53:07):
you know, I've seen a gentleness, and I thought, you know,
I need to just back off and let this play out.
I think I think that Jennifer will will see this
for herself. And in the meantime, he seems to be
(53:30):
taken care of. So you just need to accept her,
so to accept him so that you don't alienate Jennifer.
I was so afraid of alienating her that I had
just come to the conclusion to just accept this, just
accept this so that you know, because that's one thing,
you know that I've thought about over and over and
(53:50):
over and over and over again. What I've known more
even more about what she was going through on a
daily basis. If if maybe I hadn't, you know, like
if she'd felt and so I you know, I was
to this day, I'm I'm kind of real careful with
that with my other girls because or even just to
(54:11):
other young women in my life. You know, I'm kind
of an opinionated person, and with my girls, I like
for them to know how I feel about certain situations
and like to try to give them guidance that sometimes
they don't want. And but after what happened to Jennifer,
I've kind of I guess little I listen the hard
(54:34):
way like that I need to. I have to step
back sometime and let things play out and not alienate them.
Because if if I had been you know, if we
hadn't had that thing happen when he kicked the door
in or whatever, if you know, if all that had
to happen, would she had been calling me up every
(54:55):
day and saying, Mom, guess what he said, Mom, guess
what he donem guess where we went?
Speaker 9 (54:59):
You know?
Speaker 8 (55:00):
Would I have been a little bit more involved in
the day to day activities in hers and the baby's life.
And so it scares me to death to think of
making one wrong move or one wrong step that would
alienate someone I love.
Speaker 4 (55:16):
For me, Jennifer was reliant on them for everything, car
phone money. When Joey went to work. She was left
at that Benton home all day to wait on him.
As the winter got colder, Joey and Jennifer had to
move into the Benton home in the front.
Speaker 5 (55:33):
Of the property.
Speaker 4 (55:34):
The shed aka the party barn was just too cold
for a toddler to live in. Joey and Jennifer shared
one bedroom and Adriana had the bedroom next to them.
As the visits were amping up again between her family,
Jennifer and Kathy began talking daily. Jennifer attended Casey's sixteenth
birthday in February two thousand and four, with Joey dropping
(55:57):
her off down the street and waiting for her to
be done. But the good news Jennifer's reaching out. She's
seeking comfort and supporting her family. Nobody could predict that
the days of rebuilding their trust in family ties were
now numbered. Thank you to our episode sponsor YouTube channel
(56:55):
at I Am from Tennessee by realtor Jennifer Davis, Tennessee
Have Something for Everyone. Missing in Hushtown was executive produced
and written by Me Your Host Jewles with Anlee Audio
House LLC. Casey Robinson was co producer. Special thanks to
John Thorpe Patrick Robinson, My parents and Jen Rivera and
to our children. To follow our continued efforts on Justice
(57:18):
for Jennifer and Adriana Wicks. You can find us on
Facebook at Justice for Jennifer and Adriana Wicks. This page
is personally managed by Casey herself and you can find
me jewles Hi on Instagram at your host jewles Notes
and updates can be found on our website www dot
Missing in Hushtown dot com. Please help us continue to
(57:38):
grow by considering leaving a five star review and rating
wherever you're listening. If you have a tip for this case,
please please call one eight hundred TBI find help us
bring the Wicks girls home. To donate to this family's
continued fight for justice, please visit GoFundMe dot com slash
Jennifer and Adriana Wicks and To support the podcasts and
(58:00):
to help us continue this production, you may click support
the show in the show notes and donate a wis Kiss.
Speaker 5 (58:07):
Ten percent of all profits.
Speaker 4 (58:08):
From season one I'm Missing in Hushtown will be given
to the Wicks family indefinitely. As always, You're wanted, you
are loved, and you deserve to be found. Don't you
forget it? I'll see you next time.
Speaker 2 (58:24):
Hey, guysid is Ryan.
Speaker 1 (58:26):
I'm not sure if you know this about me, but
I'm a bit of a fun fanatic when I can.
I like to work, but I like fun too, And
now I can tell you about my favorite place to
have fun, Chumba Casino. They have hundreds of social casino
style games to choose from, with new games released each week.
You can play for free, and each day brings a
new chance to collect daily bonuses. So join me and
the fun. Sign up now at chumbacasino dot com.
Speaker 8 (58:49):
Sponsored by Chumba Casino. No purchase necessary VGW Group Ford.
We're prohibited by Law eighteen plus.
Speaker 2 (58:53):
Terms and conditions apply. Black Friday is coming, And for
the adults in your life.
Speaker 3 (58:58):
Who love the coolest toys, well there's something for them
this year too. Bartisian is the premiere craft cocktail maker
that automatically makes more than sixty seasonal and classic cocktails
each and under thirty seconds at the push of a button.
And right now, Bartisian is having a huge sight wide sale.
You can get one hundred dollars off any cocktail maker
or cocktail maker bundle when you spend four hundred dollars,
(59:21):
or more so, if the cocktail lover in your life
has been good this year or the right kind of bad,
get them Bartesian at the push of a button, make
bar quality Cosmopolitans, Martini's, Manhattan's, and more, all in just
thirty seconds, all for a hundred off. Amazing toys aren't
(59:41):
just for kids. Get one hundred off a cocktail maker
when you spend four hundred through Cyber Monday. Visit Bartsian
dot com slash cocktail.
Speaker 2 (59:49):
That's b A r t E. Sia n dot com
slash cocktail
Hey, it's Ryan Seacrest. Life comes at you fast, which
is why it's important to find some time to relax
a little U time enter Chumba Casino with no download required.
You can jump on any time, anywhere for the chance
to redeem some serious prizes. So treat yourself with Chumba
Casino and play over one hundred online casino style games,
all for free. Go to chumbucasino dot com to collect
(00:21):
your free welcome bonus sponsored by Chumpa Casino. No purchase
necessary VGW group void where prohibited by Law eighteen plus.
Terms and conditions apply.
Speaker 2 (00:32):
Black Friday is coming, and for the adults in your life.
Speaker 3 (00:34):
Who love the coolest toys, well there's something for them
this year too. Bartisian is the premiere craft cocktail maker
that automatically makes more than sixty seasonal.
Speaker 2 (00:44):
And classic cocktails each and.
Speaker 3 (00:45):
Out of thirty seconds at the push of a buzzon
and right now, Bartisian is having a huge sight wide sale.
You can get one hundred dollars off any cocktail maker
or cocktail maker bundle when you spend four hundred dollars
or more. So if the cocktail our lover in your
life has been good this year or the right kind
of bad. Get them Bartisian at the push of a button,
(01:07):
make Bark quality Cosmopolitans, Martini's, Manhattan's, and more, all in
just thirty seconds, all for one hundred off Amazing toys.
Speaker 2 (01:17):
Aren't just put kids.
Speaker 3 (01:19):
Get one hundred off a cocktail maker when you spend
four hundred through cyber Monday. Missus Bartisian dot com slash cocktail.
That's pa r t E sia n dot com slash cocktail.
Speaker 4 (01:32):
Missing in Hushtowns Season one is proudly sponsored by the
following relive studio, Andy B's Boutique six one five, real
Estate Advisors and Hometown Connect. Thank you to our sponsors.
This episode is sponsored by the YouTube channel at I
Am from Tennessee by professional local realtor Jennifer Davis. Missing
(01:54):
in Hushtowns Season one is proudly sponsored by the following
relive studio, Andy B's Boutique six one five, real Estate
Advisors and Hometown Connect. Thank you to our sponsors. Small
Town's Talk and We've been listening. I'm your host Jules Thorpe,
an independent investigated podcaster living in the same town. Jennifer
(02:15):
and Adriana Wicks went missing from in two thousand and four,
and this is missing in Hushtown Season one, chapter six,
Jennifer meets Joey.
Speaker 5 (03:06):
Note for me before we dive in.
Speaker 4 (03:09):
What I know now makes everything you are about to
hear even more heartbreaking. Myself, along with many people who
are close with the Wicks girls and the Benton family,
believe that if Jennifer and Adriana had never met Joey,
they would be alive today. This is me saying that
someone at that Benton residence knows what happened and who
(03:34):
did it, So if there was never any Joey and Jennifer,
there would never be any Bentons in their life. I
promised in the first episode I would share with you
more information, and I will. I'm not done yet, I promise.
In fact, I'll go ahead and share this. Joey called
Casey and they talked on the phone for the first
(03:56):
time in twenty years. Casey asked Joey some very direct
and tough questions and still he lied. And yes, now
we know he lied. We have confirmation that he lied,
but we'll get more into that in a few episodes.
Speaker 5 (04:15):
Stay with me.
Speaker 4 (04:16):
We need to roll the tape back to win Jennifer
meets Joey. It's the winner of two thousand and three
in Middle Tennessee. Jennifer is now a young mother at
twenty one to her daughter Adriana, who was just past
her first birthday. Most people will pronounce it as Adrianna,
but Jennifer will make sure to correct them and say
(04:38):
her baby's name the right way Adriana. In fact, she
named her after seeing Vince gild perform the Adriana song
at the Grand ol Opry when she went with her mom.
Speaker 6 (04:48):
Kathy.
Speaker 4 (04:49):
Robertson County tends to slow down a bit in the cold,
as if the community freezes in time. Along with the
layers of ice that can shut down roads for a
week at a time, a county ill equipped with snow
clearing devices finds it's easier to shut down school a
few days than invest the money on snowplows and storage
just to use maybe a few times a year. Maybe
(05:14):
the weather is unpredictable here in the winter, but it's
typically cold. The evenings tend to drop below freezing as
the sun sets and the night goes still. The trees
are bare and extend into the moonlight as old withered
arms stretching for the stars beyond their reach. Jennifer's mom, Kathy,
has accepted a job promotion which will find her moving
(05:36):
across the country to Las Vegas, Nevada. This job will
provide more opportunities for Kathy to grow in her field,
and she feels her youngest daughter, Casey will adapt well
with the change. After all, she'll be moving right before
she starts high school. Jennifer and her middle sister, Heather
choose to stay in Tennessee. This is their home and
they have places to live while mom Kathy moves away,
(05:59):
Heather choosing to stay mostly with Kathy's mother and Jennifer
choosing to stay mostly with Michael's mother. So both girls
are with grandparents from different sides of the family, and
Jennifer also goes in between Grannie Wicks and Aunt Lisa's home.
Heather is often visiting with her sister and her niece
(06:19):
at Aunt Lisa's house. Recall, Grannie Wicks is from Jennifer's
father's side, and although this is true, Grannie Wicks was
always so inviting and loving toward all of Jennifer's siblings,
blood or not. With temperatures in the triple digits with
humidity to match. Many people in Robertson County can be
(06:40):
found in waterwaves, creeks, rivers, pools, sprinklers, Sweet tea is
poured by the gallons, and the humming of air conditioning
units fill the air. Aunt Lisa has two children at
home at the time, her son Jeffrey and her daughter Samantha.
This is Samantha, Jennifer's cousin.
Speaker 7 (07:00):
I'm Samantha True. I'm first cousins with Jennifer Wigs. Yeah,
pretty typical cousin relationships. She's was quite a bit older
than me, so I was obviously closer to her younger
sisters than to her until we were older. I do
remember her being with us. That's when the two of
us got really close. Did you share a room but
(07:22):
did not share a room? Her room was right next
to mine because we had a spare bedroom. Her and
Adriana were in the room together, right next to me.
I spent a lot of time with Adriana, rocked her
to sleep many nights.
Speaker 6 (07:33):
I don't remember her being with any.
Speaker 7 (07:35):
Men before Joey long enough for it to be one
of those things where like he came to family functions
or was like involved in that kind of way. I
can tell you that I was exposed to him because
he was a friend of my brother and he would
come to the house to, you know, visit with my brother.
(07:57):
I was young, so obviously I didn't have any you know,
I didn't talk to him personally because I had no
reason to. But yeah, I first met him and was
around him because of his relationship with my brother his friendship.
I don't remember when they met. I know it was
through my brother, just because she was there. The only
(08:19):
time I recall being around them as a couple for
any expiritive time was they had one of Adriana's birthday
parties at the Benton home and I went. Most people
know that Joey and his sister or his siblings didn't
have a good childhood, especially so if you're going to
(08:41):
love someone else's child the way it seemed like he
loved Adriana, you have to you have to know that
he loved her at some point, or his version of
love or what he thought love was, or how he
felt love. It's also hard to understand how people that
have had traumatic childhoods feel love, you know, how did
they receive love? His children and what does it look
(09:03):
like to them? But it seemed to me like he
loved Adriana. It's so strange that one minute you're being
a loving father figure per se to this child, and
the next minute they're gone and you don't seem to care.
In all appearances from the outside looking in, he didn't
care about them. He didn't care about Jennifer, he didn't
care about Adriana. If if you're a spectator looking in
(09:25):
on this, he seems like, you know, a short time
boyfriend that you know didn't really care. But I think
he did. I think he did care. And I think
whatever is causing him to act like he doesn't care
and to not be around is severe. And to think
(09:48):
about I mean, he was young. Think about being that young,
and you know, whatever happens, his life's probably been a
living hell. And I'm not saying he didn't deserve it,
because he obviously could have given us some closure up
to this point. But something bad happened to him that
day too. He's not innocent. He was involved in some
(10:14):
kind of way. I'm still angry at him. The one
time I can recall an adult seeing him in public
broke me that day. I was living where I'm living
now in the house next to me is a duplex,
and I look up my window one morning and he's
in my driveway cause we have a shared driveway, and
he's helping the people next door move And so all
(10:36):
day I'm home having to look out the window and
see him. And what's really strange too, is to live
in the same town as someone and never see them.
Like when you live in the same town as someone,
you see people passing by in their vehicle, you see
them at the gas station, at the grocery store, at
the local restaurants. You do not ever see the Bitten
(10:58):
family and cross planes. Ever, I don't I don't recall
seeing them out like is. I don't know where they
go do their shopping.
Speaker 6 (11:09):
Or get gas.
Speaker 7 (11:10):
But anyways, I just the whole day looking out of
the window and having to see him there, and that
many years later, when you've gone about your life and
then for it to be like smacked in the face
by it, And really it just made me mad to
see him doing just like a normal everyday thing, just
(11:33):
live in his life, helping a friend move, and in
my mind, it's just kissed me off. So I do
sympathize for him, but I also understand that he could
(11:54):
have said dark family a lot of hurt these best
years if he hadn't been scared. I think I think
he's scared. But it's just not fair that he's continued
living his life however shitty it. Maybe I'm not saying
he's got a good life. He probably doesn't. But just
(12:19):
to see him on a random day helping someone move
when I hadn't seen him in years.
Speaker 8 (12:29):
Did he see you?
Speaker 6 (12:31):
I don't think so.
Speaker 7 (12:32):
I pretty much hit away in my house all day,
and I was so mad all day that I was
shaking and crying. And if i'd go one else, had
I practice said something to him, I'm not something to
do anybody any good. He probably wouldn't even know who
I was if he saw me.
Speaker 8 (12:44):
Honestly.
Speaker 7 (12:45):
We have a community wide yard cell every year called
Trash and Treasures, because I remember being summertime and I
think we had gotten together as a family at a
home locally, and I was walking into the Food Value
or the Piglo Wigley or whatever, And that probably would
have been three months after they went missing, And so
(13:09):
their signs, their posters are still all over town and
I remember just walking into the grocery store to get
something and people standing there looking at their sign and
making remarks like, you know, they just ran away because
this town sucks, or something to that effect, like you know,
she just hated it here and so she left, or
just making assumptions just because she was an adult that
(13:31):
she could just leave. I didn't say anything to them
because I was young, and but my memories are vague
of that time, but for some reason, that really sticks
out in my mind of that was probably the first
time that I heard or saw somebody like make that
assumption about them. In my mind, obviously I knew them,
(13:53):
I knew that wasn't the case, but it never occurred
to me that that's what other people might think. It
was so hurtful this someone in our town was making
those assumptions and voicing them to other people. My mom
loved Jennifer like she was her own and I think
she showed that, and Jennifer knew that she always had
a place in our home. And yeah, Jennifer knew that.
(14:17):
Jennifer knew she always had somewhere to go, and she
had people that cared for her. So that's that's another
aspect of the case that people don't understand is she
had somewhere to go if she wanted to leave Joey.
She had the opportunity. She had a place to go,
She had a room. The room was still empty that
she lived in. She could have came back, and my
mom told her she could come back whenever she wanted.
(14:39):
She knew where we hid the key. But yeah, my
mom loved her. My mom loved Adriana and was willing
to take care of her and do anything for her.
I've dreamed about her so many times. Her and Jennifer
(15:05):
have come to me in dreams many times over. Mainly
they've just been here, we are you found us, reunions,
the fill of joy and happiness and relief over just
(15:29):
we found them.
Speaker 8 (15:34):
Yeah.
Speaker 7 (15:36):
And I don't know if that's wishful thinking or Jennifer
is saying we'll see you later. You know, we'll see
you after this life. But it's a comfort, but it's
also a nightmare when you wake up.
Speaker 5 (16:03):
Yeah.
Speaker 4 (16:05):
I asked Heather, Jennifer's middle sister on her mom's side,
how she met Joey and what she had to say.
Speaker 9 (16:12):
Well, Samantha was just in here. That's our cousin. Her
older brother is Jeffrey. Jeffrey and I were super close
as cousins, so me and Jeffrey would hang out all
the time. And Jeffrey was best friends with Joey. So
I remember meeting joe one night. Meet Jeffrey and Joey.
(16:35):
We were in his Explore. We went to Rivergate at
a Toys Rs.
Speaker 6 (16:39):
One time.
Speaker 9 (16:41):
I remember that was the first night I met him.
Jeffrey was like, you want to take a ride, and
I was like, yeah, let's go. I didn't know what
we were doing, you know, I was young. I was
probably sixteen maybe, And then we drove to the Toys Rs.
Parking lot in Rivergate. Joey was the driver, in the
driver's seat. He was driving us at his Explorer, and
then my cousin Jeffrey was in the passenger seat.
Speaker 6 (17:03):
I was in the back.
Speaker 9 (17:04):
Then Joey takes a gun out and he sits in
on the console. He takes I remember him like lining
up some pills and some baggies and he did a
drug deal. And I would say that I was My
mom was so strict growing up.
Speaker 6 (17:19):
I was just a little bit sheltered.
Speaker 9 (17:21):
So then I started to hang out with Jeffrey and
his friends, and that was like the first of any
you know thing. I was like so scared and so shocked.
But anyways, I just find that ironic. That's my first
meeting ever with Joey before Joey ever started dating Jennifer, so.
Speaker 6 (17:38):
Basically knew he was no good for her.
Speaker 9 (17:39):
But but yeah, that's how I met Joey. That's the
first time. And I think I hung out with him
again when maybe in his barn one time and there
was a bunch of Jeffrey and Joey's friends and they
were all passing around, you know, a joint mayor or whatever,
(18:02):
and we were all just hanging out, like in the barn,
just partying as kids and teenagers. But then I don't
think too long after that, Jennifer started dating Joey.
Speaker 10 (18:15):
And.
Speaker 9 (18:17):
Their relationship was now that I'm a grown woman and
I look back, it was toxic as can be. It
was the breakup, go out, breakup, go out, you know, fighting, hostility,
you know, her crying.
Speaker 4 (18:34):
It wasn't long before Joey and Jennifer became an intense
and serious couple, with Jennifer bringing him around the people
she cared the most about. Jennifer's youngest sister, Megan Wicks
from her dad's side, recalls when Joey and Jennifer came
to visit them.
Speaker 11 (18:48):
One of the last times we saw her, and they
came to visit with Joey. Only met Joey. I guess
one time. It was one of the last times I
saw him, but I don't know. I feel like they
visited or she at least visited with Adriana twice before,
you know, before I ever saw him again, never saw
(19:09):
them again. But I do remember.
Speaker 6 (19:11):
Joey very vaguely.
Speaker 11 (19:14):
I remember, I think a lot of the time he.
Speaker 6 (19:18):
Was outside talking with my dad.
Speaker 11 (19:20):
You know, they are just outside hanging out, probably because
they were smoking a cigarette or whatever. They're just outside.
But I remember when they left. When people would come
visited our house, especially Jennifer, it wasn't just Okay, we're
getting in the car and leaving. It was We're gonna
stand around and talk for another hour, you know. So
you know, Jennifer and Joey are standing outside just talking
(19:41):
to my dad getting ready to leave, and you know,
I'm out there with my dad because I followed him everywhere,
and I remember Adriana was in the back seat, and
she just absolutely adored Joey. And this was the only
time I ever saw her cry or get upset, but
she wanted him in that car. She was tired, and
she just kept saying Joey, Doe, like that's.
Speaker 6 (20:03):
What she called him.
Speaker 11 (20:04):
And she was doing she was motioning her little hand
like come get in the car, like come on, Joey,
you know, like she loved.
Speaker 6 (20:11):
Joey, and it was very sweet.
Speaker 11 (20:15):
And I can't remember if they had brought her rocking
horse or if we already had one, but I remember
she her playing on the rocking horse.
Speaker 4 (20:25):
Wall don't go anywhere, We'll be right back. Six one
five real Estate Advisors People Overprofit. Sixty one five real
estate Advisors are committed to bringing people in our community
home every single day. This includes Jennifer and Adriana Wicks.
(20:50):
Located in Robertson County, Tennessee. Six one five real Estate
Advisors proudly serve.
Speaker 5 (20:55):
All of Middle Tennessee.
Speaker 4 (20:58):
Andy Bee's boutique custom for all your needs, creating faithpet
and family friendly designs for all. Visit shopandybees dot com
for an exclusive Jennifer and Adriana Wick shirt. Andy Be's
boutique will donate profits from each Wick shirt back to
the Wicks family to fight for justice. That website is
shop andybes a and d i bs dot com. Don't
(21:31):
go anywhere, We'll be right back. Six one five real
Estate Advisors People over Profit.
Speaker 5 (21:38):
Six one five real.
Speaker 4 (21:39):
Estate advisors are committed to bringing people in our community
home every single day. This includes Jennifer and Adriana Wicks.
Located in Robertson County, Tennessee. Sixty one five real Estate
Advisors proudly serve all of Middle Tennessee. Andy B's Boutique
custom tees for all your needs, creating faith, p and
(22:00):
family friendly designs for all.
Speaker 5 (22:02):
Visit shopandybees dot.
Speaker 4 (22:04):
Com for an exclusive Jennifer and Adriana wickshirt. Andyb's Boutique
will donate profits from each Wick shirt back to the
Wicks family to fight for justice. That website is shop
andybs A and d i bs dot com.
Speaker 12 (22:21):
In the Shadows of the City, a business missed a
crucial chance, neglecting the power of captivating content. While others
captured hearts. Their story remained hidden, but you can rewrite
your story. Relive Studio transforms your brand with striking photos
and video content. Visit www Dot relive dot studio, Mention
(22:46):
this ad and receive free photos with your video package.
Unlock the story your brand deserves.
Speaker 4 (22:55):
Hometown Connect your local list. Hometown Connect your ultimate list,
bringing communities together through small town business connections. They're your
go to app for all things Middle Tennessee. They empowered
local businesses and promote.
Speaker 5 (23:10):
The shop local revolution through.
Speaker 4 (23:12):
Advanced technology, while never sacrificing online privacy with innovative Bluetooth,
proximity marketing, direct customer messaging, and in app marketing tools.
Speaker 5 (23:23):
They're your ultimate local list.
Speaker 4 (23:26):
Hometown Connect.
Speaker 12 (23:31):
In the shadows of the city, a business missed a
crucial chance, neglecting the power of captivating content, while others
captured hearts. Their story remained hidden, but you can rewrite
your story. Relive Studio transforms your brand with striking photos
and video content. Visit www. Dot relive dot studio, Mention
(23:57):
this ad and receive free photos with your video package.
Unlock the story your brand deserves.
Speaker 4 (24:05):
Hometown Connect your local list. Hometown Connect your ultimate list,
bringing communities together through small town business connections. They're your
go to app for all things Middle Tennessee. They empowered
local businesses and promote.
Speaker 5 (24:21):
The shop local revolution through.
Speaker 4 (24:23):
Advanced technology, while never sacrificing online privacy. With innovative bluetooth,
proximity marketing, direct customer messaging, and in app marketing tools,
they're your ultimate local list hometown connect. Although Kathy wasn't
(24:43):
thrilled about Jennifer and Adriana living in a barn on
the bent And property, she was assured it was fine
as the months became cooler and the fall began bringing
cool breezes. And if you've never experienced a fall in
a small football town in the South, you're in for
a treat. The leaves go from it deep green to
a beautiful, rich orange, yellow and deep red. The weighted
(25:04):
blanket of the humidity from the summer burdens have been lifted.
And if you were to drive around this small town
on Friday night, you'll see teenagers piled up in trucks
headed to the high school football games, the bleachers filled
with alumni from generations, past the stadium, lights flooding far
past the field into the town square. Or maybe the
(25:27):
kids are headed to bonfires at someone's family farm, or
they plan to meet by the creek with music and beer.
Speaker 5 (25:34):
Whatever they choose.
Speaker 4 (25:35):
The air is filled with the smoke from the tobacco
burning barns, something that Robertson County is known for. So
in Springfield, Tennessee, just a few roads over from the
cross Plains city lines, deep in the heart of Robertson County, Jennifer, Joey,
and Adriana seek a life independent of others, a life
where they can act as a family, a trio, Joey
(25:58):
stepping in as a father and protect role for Adriana,
offering commitment, support, and loved Jennifer. The barn offered a
sense of independence, albeit it was veiled independence. Jennifer was
always dependent on her family, and not just financially. You know,
she was attached in a loving way to her family.
They offered her emotional support, consistency in a time when
(26:21):
you know, there was so much change and friendship. After all,
the family was together in support of Jennifer throughout Jennifer's
pregnancy at nineteen, her delivery at twenty, and throughout her
learning how to navigate life as a young mother. So
when Jennifer calls her mom Kathy one evening in Las
Vegas and shares that Joe's mother Cindy Benton drove her
(26:42):
and Adriana away from Joey's house and dropped her off
at a Granny Wicks's house.
Speaker 5 (26:47):
Kathy was alarmed what.
Speaker 4 (26:49):
Jennifer told her, Well, folks, it was enough to make
Kathy quit her job and immediately relocate back to Tennessee.
She knew she had to get back to her daughter
and granddaughter immediately. According to police reports, Cathy said, quote,
Joey had in the recent past pulled a gun on
(27:10):
Jennifer and threatened to hurt them all. He called his
mother to come and get them before he hurt them all.
She did and took Jennifer and Adriana to her grandparents
end quote. It's important to pause here and inform all
of our listeners that every person I've talked about by
name in this podcast was reached out to by either
(27:32):
myself or Casey, Jennifer's sister. I texted Joey multiple times,
Jennifer's cousin multiple times, and had an interview set up
for Aunt Lisa, which she ultimately declined to participate in.
I don't share this information to discredit these individuals, because,
in the end, I truthfully support their right to not
talk and after all investigated, podcasting is not a really
(27:55):
widely known medium for storytelling. People don't know me, and
of course I understand that lack of trust. I do
bring up my attempts to communicate with all involved individuals
because I wanted it known that my intent was to
give all sides, all parties in equal space to share
their opinions.
Speaker 5 (28:11):
Clear up, any rumors are set record straight.
Speaker 4 (28:13):
I want transparency here, but transparency doesn't mean I won't
interpret the information I believe. I did not attempt to
reach out to a few individuals in this case, and
that was at the request of law enforcement through the family.
I did not attempt to contact Joe Benton. Also note
he is currently in jail in Robertson County. Again, we
(28:37):
never want to hurt a case, just help. I am
here to poke some bears because this is the game
we have to play to get noticed, and we're going
to suit up and step in the ring and play
as fair as we can to win. But we are
not holding back our punches. All right, back to the report,
we have now played Cindy Benton in the car with
Jennifer and Adriana driving her to Granny Wicks's home. Recall,
(29:01):
Jennifer was living at that home and her aunt Lisa's
home while her mother had moved to Las Vegas for
a job promotion. So this is a house she feels
safe in. Obviously, the place we flee from is our
place of fear, but the place we flee too, says
everything about trust and understanding. Jennifer knew that her Granny
(29:21):
Wicks's home was a safe haven, and she knew she
was always welcome there at any time of the day.
What is interesting is that throughout the years, defenders of
Joey Benton have denied that Joey would ever harm Jennifer.
In fact, in an online forum that was popular in
local communities at the time called Topics, community members could
(29:41):
post anonymously, and when the girls went missing in two
thousand and four, Topics appeared to be the place where
the Wicks and the Benton families would communicate. And I
use that term loosely. The Benton family has always veheminently
denied Joey could ever hurt Jennifer until recently. Important to
not forget that these police reports quote what the family
(30:05):
says to the police officers. Now it's just that it's
quotes from other people. It's not corroborated information. It's not
a corroborative report about whether Joey did or did not
pull a gun on Jennifer. There is no police report
on that actual incident. As far as we civilians understand,
(30:25):
with the extent of our access to the files in
this case, we do not have a statement from Cindy
Benton or any written statement from anyone other than Kathy
in the report taken when the girls disappeared. Jennifer and
Adriana remained living between Aunt Lisa and Granny Wicks's home
until Kathy and Casey moved back to Tennessee. It wasn't
(30:46):
a long time waiting. Kathy mobilized very quickly. She didn't
think twice about coming back. Call it a mother's intuition.
This incident is what the Wick's family refers to as
the first red flag us, knowing what we know About's
first experience with Joey and the drug exchange at the mall,
it would likely be our second red flag. But up
until this point, Joey had never shown this dangerous behavior
(31:09):
toward Jennifer and Adriana. It's interesting to say the least,
we almost have two versions of joe when people recall him.
There was a Joey who appeared to have truly loved Jennifer,
and then there was the Joey that seemed to display rage, aggression,
and violence seeing on alternating side, Jennifer did break up
with Joey.
Speaker 5 (31:29):
She was done now.
Speaker 4 (31:31):
It recall they hadn't been dating that long. They met
in July and the first incident where Jennifer tells her
mother about Joey threatening the girls as in the fall.
So within twelve weeks give or take, they have moved
in together, not broken up, and now we find ourselves
living back with Kathy and Casey and Heather once Kathy
was able to get back to Tennessee. Meanwhile, Kathy's strong
(31:52):
and fierce mother, as those who knew her would describe her,
had a home that she was able to rent out
to the girls. Casey, Kathy, and Heather lived in the
upstairs park and Jennifer stayed in the finish basement below,
which had two bedrooms. Heather's bedroom was just above Jennifer's
and she could often hear Jennifer's phone conversation seep up
(32:13):
into her room and of course, a nosy little sister
would make sure she could hear even better by opening
her windows and crouching near the air fence. The family
rallied around Jennifer. They wanted her to succeed. They wanted
to help her and support her and raise her up.
They loved her so deeply that they decided to form
(32:33):
a type of intervention for Jennifer once they caught wind
that she may be considering going back to Joey. Heather
and Kathy both recall the intervention here.
Speaker 9 (32:44):
We all had a family intervention at one point, and
I can't remember. I feel like this may have been
before the fight where the door gets busted in, but
we it was her grandmother, it was me, my mom,
my grand mother. I can't remember who else was there,
but they all met at our house because we knew
(33:06):
that Jennifer was starting to think about going back to
Joey and she had no idea. We're about to have
an intervention on her, and this is where we all
knew this was not a good idea, and we were
going to set her down and let her know that
she shouldn't do this.
Speaker 6 (33:23):
Think about the baby.
Speaker 9 (33:25):
We also know Jennifer's an amazing mother and she loved
her baby. And then my mom just didn't want to
push Jennifer further away. But my mom just didn't want
Jennifer to hate her and push her away, which you
can only imagine how much that would cause, you know,
between a mom and a daughter if a mom did that.
Speaker 6 (33:45):
But Mom, we all.
Speaker 9 (33:47):
Were really just knew it was bad and that they
like we just knew something was gonna happen.
Speaker 8 (33:54):
When her and Joey were split up and I had
came back from Las Vegas and they were living with me,
and I was I worked during the day, and so
I babysat the baby at night for her to take
my vehicle and go to work. And I had found
out that she wasn't going to work. Every time she
(34:16):
told me that she was, she was actually going to
see Joey and maybe possibly trying to work things out
with him. And so she wasn't she wasn't holding up
to her into the bargain as far as getting her
(34:38):
life together and getting breaking away from the abuse and
stuff from Joey and you know, the verbal kind of
abuse from Joey, and you know, keeping her job. She
was in the threat of losing her job. It was
very important that she kept her job and and show
(35:02):
up in the morning in time for me to have
my car to go to work and take care of
her baby. There was just several little things that she
just wasn't doing that she had agreed that she would do.
So our family, all of us grandparents, aunts, everyone thought
(35:26):
that we needed to talk to her and let her
know how important it was that she basically get her
act together and put her priorities in line. And her
priorities shouldn't be Joey, it should be her job and
her baby and that sort of thing. And so we
(35:51):
all got together one night, if I remember correctly, it
was around November the tenth run in there, and when
Jennifer come in, we just said, hey, we want to
talk to you, and we kind of laid down the
law to her and said, look, you've got to do this,
and you do not need to have the baby at Joey's.
(36:13):
That's not a good environment. There's guns, there's drugs. You've
told us about all this, and that's not a place
you want to have your baby. It's not safe for you,
it's not safe for her. And so we told her that.
Then we said if you if you're not careful, someone
(36:34):
may try to intervene and take your child from you,
and you don't want that to happen. If someone was
to call child services and say that you were, you know,
shacked up in a party barn with guns and drugs,
they would they would take your child. And so this
is where it is very important that you'd listen to
us older folks who who have experience and can tell
(36:57):
you that that's you know that you're you're down the
wrong path here and you need to you need to
steer back into work, you know, onto the right path.
So that was our intervention that we had with her
in November.
Speaker 2 (37:12):
I guess it.
Speaker 8 (37:13):
Didn't do a lot of good, unfortunately, because you know,
she ended up giving Joey another chance and moving back
in with Joey in December.
Speaker 9 (37:23):
The night of the fight, I heard Jennifer talking to
Joey on the phone downstairs through the vent because I
was eavesdropping, and I ran and told my mom and Adriana.
I believe Adriana was upstairs. She may have been playing
with Casey or something, but I was in my room
eavesdropping I could hear that she was getting back together
(37:46):
with Joey despite denying, and she was basically inviting him
to come over and to help her get everything out
of the house and help her because she knew we
weren't gonna let her just walk out the door. So
I ran and told Mom, and I think, if I
can remember correctly, Mom and Jennifer just started arguing. Mom's
(38:08):
trying to talk her out of it. Next thing we know,
Joey is there. I think Joey gets in. He goes
downstairs to grab some of Jennifer's things and belongings. He
walks outside to put them in the car. Mom and
Jennifer are fighting. I locked the door behind Joey as
(38:31):
he takes the stuff out, and I'm like standing up
against the door with the door locked, and I remember
Jennifer like physically pushing my mom.
Speaker 6 (38:46):
Over onto the coffee table.
Speaker 9 (38:48):
I don't know if she hit her or pushed her
or what, but she pushed her and my mom literally
just went tumbling over the coffee table. Well, this is
the first fight I've ever gotten into in my life.
Speaker 6 (39:07):
I think this is actually.
Speaker 9 (39:10):
The hardest thing for me personally to talk about because
when I saw my when I saw Mom weighing on
the floor like I'm protective over my mother. I didn't
want Jennifer to go or Adriana, But as soon as
I saw her, you know, hit my mom and push
her over the coffee table. I jumped on Jennifer and
(39:30):
we started physically fighting, and I think her earring ripped out.
Speaker 6 (39:36):
I don't know, but I mean, you're sitting here looking
at me.
Speaker 9 (39:44):
I'm five to two and a half and Jennifer was
probably I don't know, five six.
Speaker 6 (39:50):
Five seven, I don't even know. I know a younger.
Speaker 9 (39:52):
I remember my mom put her in this modeling thing
and she was like one of the tall models. But anyway,
the reason why I say that is because we started fighting.
The next thing, I know, she's screaming for Joey. Joey
kicks in our front door and the whole door comes
(40:13):
tumbling down and he grabs her and they literally like
I'm screaming and my mom's screaming, like Casey, get Adriana
and take her to the back bedroom and call nine
one one, like we are screaming, and Casey runs locks
the door, has the baby and is calling nine one one.
So and Jennifer and Adriana just start running. I guess
(40:34):
because we had just gotten in a fight. You know,
she had hit me a couple of times. I probably
hit her a couple of times. She had hit my mom,
who was just chaos.
Speaker 6 (40:42):
And so.
Speaker 9 (40:46):
I don't know why they didn't stay to try to
get Adriana, maybe just to get out of the situation,
but they took off running and they left. Well the
next thing I know, they're a police there. So on
their end, Joe Jennifer called the police, and on our end,
Casey called the police. So they were a police on
both ends who knew, and unfortunately we fought. We fought,
(41:13):
We pressed charges and filed a report.
Speaker 6 (41:15):
You did, yes, and then for vandalism.
Speaker 9 (41:20):
And then I'm pretty I'm not exactly sure if they
filed a report. I'm not exactly sure, but I remember
we had to hand Adriana back over.
Speaker 6 (41:38):
And that was hard. And then.
Speaker 10 (41:45):
This is the shitty thing because not long after that
they disappeared, and I just.
Speaker 6 (42:08):
I don't feel like that I really got to make
up with my big sister.
Speaker 9 (42:16):
He was also my best friend. I don't think I
saw her much after that. And then there was a chord.
Speaker 6 (42:29):
Date set.
Speaker 9 (42:31):
And I had to go testifying court and be portrayed
as a monster on the stand, and my sister was
supposed to be at court and she was missing already,
So my sister couldn't even stand up for me in
court and be like she was just trying to protect
her mom. Like my sister is not a monster, you know.
(42:56):
But I remember joey'stting sitting in court, and I just
remember his attorney, I don't know it was like a
public defender or whatever, but they were just like hammering me.
They made it out to sound like I'm so much
bigger than Jennifer, and like I hurt her.
Speaker 6 (43:18):
She was not hurt.
Speaker 9 (43:20):
Is this because he was trying to get off on
charges like and they were trying to say like he
had to protect my sister and bust in our door.
And they just made me out to be some monster
whenever my family and myself send so much pain. And
here I am seventeen years old, eighteen Can you remember
how old I was at this point?
Speaker 6 (43:38):
But it was seventeen or eighteen, But.
Speaker 9 (43:44):
And my whole entire family's just in pain because my
sister's gone and we know it he had We know
that the Ben family had something to do with it.
Speaker 6 (43:54):
We just knew.
Speaker 9 (43:55):
Look at what just happened, look at why we were
sitting in court in the first place, you know, and
she wasn't even there to be able to speak up
and use her voice.
Speaker 8 (44:06):
My memory is a little foggy after all these years,
but I do know that I came in and he
was there, and one of the girls, you know, told
me he was downstairs and they were getting Jennifer's things
together and the baby's things together, and so of course
I went down there to see what was going on,
and I confronted both of them, and I asked Jennifer
(44:31):
to you know, please, you don't go there, don't leave
with him, please. And I confronted Joey, and I said
to Joey, because Jennifer told me they wanted to get
married and stuff, you know, we're gonna get married. You're
gonna have to accept him. And I said to Joey,
(44:55):
how are you gonna support them? And are you going
to get the drugs and the guns of your house
so the baby will be safe? You know how? You know,
how are you going to support my daughter and granddaughter
and take care of them properly? And he turned around
and looked me square in the eye and he said,
you don't have a daughter anymore, bitch, and.
Speaker 9 (45:21):
He went on.
Speaker 8 (45:23):
Out with Jennifer's bag to put it in the truck.
And I shut the front door and locked it, and
I turned to Jennifer and I begged her, please don't go,
and she reached for the He was on the other
(45:45):
side of the door, knocking on the door. She reached
for the door to unlock the door, and I grabbed
her wrist and I was right in her face, eye
to eye, crying and begging her, please don't go with him,
Please don't go with him. And she shoved me. She
(46:11):
shoved me and pushed me, and I fell over the
coffee table in the living room, and Heather hears all
that's happening. Heather comes in. Casey has already I think
at this point, Casey, I believe has already grabbed the
baby and taken off to my bedroom in the back
(46:31):
of the house. And I didn't know it but at
that second, but she called. She was calling nine one one,
and Heather sees all this going on between me and Jennifer,
and that Jennifer had put her hands on me, and
that we were actually in a physical struggle, and so
Heather kind of took it up and was like, I'll
(46:54):
put your hands on mom. You know what's wrong with you?
You know, And just so it turned into this kind
of hair pulling, screaming, clawing match between the two sisters,
you know, not really any fist blows or anything like that.
Just no, not really.
Speaker 9 (47:14):
Uh uh.
Speaker 8 (47:15):
I had not ever seen them really fight like that.
But I mean I'd seen them maybe shove one another
and you know, say ugly things to each other or
something like that, but never to that extent.
Speaker 7 (47:27):
Uh.
Speaker 8 (47:28):
It was just that Heather went into protective mode for
her mom. And so while they're fussn't and hollering and
arguing and hair pulling, Jennifer's hollering Joey help me, Joey
help me, and Joey kicked down the door, I mean,
completely totally off the hinges the front door, and him
(47:53):
and Jennifer left and that's the baby there. Thus, and
they left quickly, and the police come take pictures of me.
I had a couple of little marks on me and stuff,
you know, and explain to us, you know that, I mean,
(48:17):
they understood that why everything had happened. They understood why
we didn't want the baby to go, but also we knew,
as they explained, and we really already knew in our
logical sense that you know, the baby has to go
with her with her mommy. So then, uh, Joey and
(48:46):
Cindy the police officer stayed there. Believe that was a
Cross Plains police officer that was there. It was, And
Julie comes back with his mom and they got Adriana
and took Adriana. And then I found out later that
(49:08):
joe Joey's bother, took Jennifer to the Cross Plains Police
department to foul a complaint against me trying to keep
her child from her and attacking her and all this
(49:30):
kind of thing. And you know, I believe that was
just to counteract what he knew was coming for his son,
which was vandalism charges for kicking in my door.
Speaker 4 (49:41):
And yes, you may have caught that in Heather's interview.
The family had to go to court for this event,
and it's because a family filed a report against Joey
for kicking down their door. But in order to fully
analyze each side of this event dutifully, so each participating
member was called to the stand. It means, folks, that
Heather was called to the stand and if you needn't
(50:03):
catch what she said, it was this. Her family was
in the throes of searching for Jennifer and Adriana. By
this time, when the court date is here, the girls
are missing and behind the scenes, the Wicks family is
fighting Robertson County to find their girls. Without confirmation of
(50:24):
when Jennifer and Joey were actually engaged, we do know
from Kathy's recollection that Jennifer was planning on being with
Joey now for a long time. However long Joey and
Jennifer had been talking again and seeing each other again
in secret is unknown, but it was likely emotion to
move back in together for some time. So that Christmas,
(50:45):
just three days after this incident, Kathy's home is in
distress and concerned over her daughter and granddaughter's safety. The
days turn into weeks without contact with Jennifer and Adriana's
second birthday comes and goes in January. At birthday spent
celebrating at the Benton home, not the Wicks home, tensions
(51:06):
begin to reach an all time high between the two families.
The Bentons may it very known that the Wicks family
is not welcome at their home, and the Wicks family
makes it very known that the Bentons are not welcome
at their home. But slowly Jennifer begins to come back around.
She starts by calling her mom regularly again and then
(51:27):
agrees to meet her mother at the local McDonald's where
little sisters Heather and Casey worked at the time.
Speaker 8 (51:34):
Jennifer did tell me that she and Jodi were engaged.
Think I think she even had a ring on, just
a simple gold wedding band that she was wearing, and ah, Homesley.
(52:00):
I just thought that at that moment, at that time,
I can remember just thinking, you're just trying to force
this guy on us, you know, like you know, getting
married to him, you know, because I thought Jennifer would
come to her senses and leave him. You know, I
really thought that I had come around right before they disappeared.
(52:23):
I had finally came around because I had met them
a couple of times, like at McDonald's, at the at
the play area, and just you know, you know, just
to talk with Jennifer and play with Adriana and get
her some unhappiness or whatever, you know, And Joey seemed okay,
(52:45):
like not, Yeah, Joey would come with him. She never
got to go anywhere without him. They wouldn't let her
drive any of their vehicles or anything like that. Uh,
so he had to bring her. He took her every
where she went. But when I would see him, you know,
placing the baby in her car seat, or playing with
her in the play area, or just carrying her out,
(53:07):
you know, I've seen a gentleness, and I thought, you know,
I need to just back off and let this play out.
I think I think that Jennifer will will see this
for herself. And in the meantime, he seems to be
(53:30):
taken care of. So you just need to accept her,
so to accept him so that you don't alienate Jennifer.
I was so afraid of alienating her that I had
just come to the conclusion to just accept this, just
accept this so that you know, because that's one thing,
you know that I've thought about over and over and
(53:50):
over and over and over again. What I've known more
even more about what she was going through on a
daily basis. If if maybe I hadn't, you know, like
if she'd felt and so I you know, I was
to this day, I'm I'm kind of real careful with
that with my other girls because or even just to
(54:11):
other young women in my life. You know, I'm kind
of an opinionated person, and with my girls, I like
for them to know how I feel about certain situations
and like to try to give them guidance that sometimes
they don't want. And but after what happened to Jennifer,
I've kind of I guess little I listen the hard
(54:34):
way like that I need to. I have to step
back sometime and let things play out and not alienate them.
Because if if I had been you know, if we
hadn't had that thing happen when he kicked the door
in or whatever, if you know, if all that had
to happen, would she had been calling me up every
(54:55):
day and saying, Mom, guess what he said, Mom, guess
what he donem guess where we went?
Speaker 9 (54:59):
You know?
Speaker 8 (55:00):
Would I have been a little bit more involved in
the day to day activities in hers and the baby's life.
And so it scares me to death to think of
making one wrong move or one wrong step that would
alienate someone I love.
Speaker 4 (55:16):
For me, Jennifer was reliant on them for everything, car
phone money. When Joey went to work. She was left
at that Benton home all day to wait on him.
As the winter got colder, Joey and Jennifer had to
move into the Benton home in the front.
Speaker 5 (55:33):
Of the property.
Speaker 4 (55:34):
The shed aka the party barn was just too cold
for a toddler to live in. Joey and Jennifer shared
one bedroom and Adriana had the bedroom next to them.
As the visits were amping up again between her family,
Jennifer and Kathy began talking daily. Jennifer attended Casey's sixteenth
birthday in February two thousand and four, with Joey dropping
(55:57):
her off down the street and waiting for her to
be done. But the good news Jennifer's reaching out. She's
seeking comfort and supporting her family. Nobody could predict that
the days of rebuilding their trust in family ties were
now numbered. Thank you to our episode sponsor YouTube channel
(56:55):
at I Am from Tennessee by realtor Jennifer Davis, Tennessee
Have Something for Everyone. Missing in Hushtown was executive produced
and written by Me Your Host Jewles with Anlee Audio
House LLC. Casey Robinson was co producer. Special thanks to
John Thorpe Patrick Robinson, My parents and Jen Rivera and
to our children. To follow our continued efforts on Justice
(57:18):
for Jennifer and Adriana Wicks. You can find us on
Facebook at Justice for Jennifer and Adriana Wicks. This page
is personally managed by Casey herself and you can find
me jewles Hi on Instagram at your host jewles Notes
and updates can be found on our website www dot
Missing in Hushtown dot com. Please help us continue to
(57:38):
grow by considering leaving a five star review and rating
wherever you're listening. If you have a tip for this case,
please please call one eight hundred TBI find help us
bring the Wicks girls home. To donate to this family's
continued fight for justice, please visit GoFundMe dot com slash
Jennifer and Adriana Wicks and To support the podcasts and
(58:00):
to help us continue this production, you may click support
the show in the show notes and donate a wis Kiss.
Speaker 5 (58:07):
Ten percent of all profits.
Speaker 4 (58:08):
From season one I'm Missing in Hushtown will be given
to the Wicks family indefinitely. As always, You're wanted, you
are loved, and you deserve to be found. Don't you
forget it? I'll see you next time.
Speaker 2 (58:24):
Hey, guysid is Ryan.
Speaker 1 (58:26):
I'm not sure if you know this about me, but
I'm a bit of a fun fanatic when I can.
I like to work, but I like fun too, And
now I can tell you about my favorite place to
have fun, Chumba Casino. They have hundreds of social casino
style games to choose from, with new games released each week.
You can play for free, and each day brings a
new chance to collect daily bonuses. So join me and
the fun. Sign up now at chumbacasino dot com.
Speaker 8 (58:49):
Sponsored by Chumba Casino. No purchase necessary VGW Group Ford.
We're prohibited by Law eighteen plus.
Speaker 2 (58:53):
Terms and conditions apply. Black Friday is coming, And for
the adults in your life.
Speaker 3 (58:58):
Who love the coolest toys, well there's something for them
this year too. Bartisian is the premiere craft cocktail maker
that automatically makes more than sixty seasonal and classic cocktails
each and under thirty seconds at the push of a button.
And right now, Bartisian is having a huge sight wide sale.
You can get one hundred dollars off any cocktail maker
or cocktail maker bundle when you spend four hundred dollars,
(59:21):
or more so, if the cocktail lover in your life
has been good this year or the right kind of bad,
get them Bartesian at the push of a button, make
bar quality Cosmopolitans, Martini's, Manhattan's, and more, all in just
thirty seconds, all for a hundred off. Amazing toys aren't
(59:41):
just for kids. Get one hundred off a cocktail maker
when you spend four hundred through Cyber Monday. Visit Bartsian
dot com slash cocktail.
Speaker 2 (59:49):
That's b A r t E. Sia n dot com
slash cocktail
Popular Podcasts
Dateline NBC
Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Follow now to get the latest episodes of Dateline NBC completely free, or subscribe to Dateline Premium for ad-free listening and exclusive bonus content: DatelinePremium.com
Stuff You Should Know
If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.
Law & Order: Criminal Justice System - Season 1 & Season 2
Season Two Out Now! Law & Order: Criminal Justice System tells the real stories behind the landmark cases that have shaped how the most dangerous and influential criminals in America are prosecuted. In its second season, the series tackles the threat of terrorism in the United States. From the rise of extremist political groups in the 60s to domestic lone wolves in the modern day, we explore how organizations like the FBI and Joint Terrorism Take Force have evolved to fight back against a multitude of terrorist threats.