October 12, 2025 • 26 mins
The Power of Talismans: Mind Over Matter
In this episode of PsyberSpace, host Leslie Poston explores the fascinating world of talismans, lucky charms, and rituals. While these objects may seem irrational at first glance, psychological and anthropological insights reveal they significantly alter how our brains handle risk, uncertainty, and stress. From ancient warriors to modern surgeons and athletes, humans have always used symbolic objects to manage anxiety and enhance performance. This episode dives into the neuroscience of belief, the anthropology of ritual, and the line between helpful superstition and harmful compulsion. Discover how these practices, whether physical or digital, help us face uncertainty and regulate our emotions, anchoring us in chaotic situations.
00:00 Introduction to Talismans and Rituals
00:53 The Psychology Behind Talismans
01:27 Historical and Cultural Perspectives
02:39 Modern Examples and Psychological Mechanisms
05:24 Rituals in High-Stakes Professions
07:30 Sports and Performance Enhancement
10:30 The Placebo Effect and Physical Properties
13:25 Cultural Significance and Adaptation
16:20 When Rituals Become Unhealthy
19:40 Digital Age Talismans
22:14 Conclusion: The Power of Belief
References
Atkinson, P. (1981). The clinical experience: The construction and reconstruction of medical reality. Gower.
Bandura, A. (1997). Self-efficacy: The exercise of control. W. H. Freeman.
Berle, D., Starcevic, V., Wootton, B., Arnáez, S., & Baggio, S. (2023). A network approach to understanding obsessions and compulsions. Journal of Obsessive-Compulsive and Related Disorders, 36, 100786.
Damisch, L., Stoberock, B., & Mussweiler, T. (2010). Keep your fingers crossed! How superstition improves performance. Psychological Science, 21(7), 1014–1020.
Davoudi, M., Mohammadzadeh, A., Vafaei, A., Mirzaei, S. M., & Ghanbari Jolfaei, A. (2024). A cross-sectional study in two common OCD subtypes: Network structure of symptoms, personality, and obsessive beliefs. Frontiers in Psychiatry, 15, 1330901.
Einstein, D. A., & Menzies, R. G. (2004). The presence of magical thinking in obsessive–compulsive disorder. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 42, 539–549.
Einstein, D. A., & Menzies, R. G. (2004). Role of magical thinking in obsessive–compulsive symptoms in an undergraduate sample. Depression and Anxiety, 19, 174–179.
Edwards, C. D. (2023). Obsessive–compulsive disorder in sports—Beyond superstitions. Advances in Psychiatry and Behavioral Health. Advance online publication.
Fite, R. E., Adut, S. L., & Magee, J. C. (2020). Do you believe in magical thinking? Examining magical thinking as a mediator between obsessive–compulsive belief domains and symptoms. Behavioural and Cognitive Psychotherapy, 48(4), 454–462.
Frazer, J. G. (1996). The golden bough: A study in magic and religion. Oxford University Press. (Original work published 1890)
Langer, E. J. (1975). The illusion of control. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 32(2), 311–328.
Rabinovitch, H. (2025). Playoff beards and unwashed uniforms: A scoping review on athletes’ superstitions and rituals. International Review of Sport and Exercise Psychology. Advance online publication.
West, B., & Willner, P. (2011). Magical thinking in obsessive–compulsive disorder and generalized anxiety disorder. Behavioural and Cognitive Psychotherapy, 39(4), 399–411.
Vyse, S. A. (2014). Believing in magic: The psychology of superstition (Updated ed.). Oxford University Press.
★ Support this podcast ★
Mark as Played
Transcript
Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Leslie Poston (00:12):
Welcome back to PsyberSpace. I'm your host,
Leslie Poston. Today, we'retalking about something small,
sometimes silly, yetsurprisingly powerful:
talismans, lucky charms, andrituals. Whether it's a surgeon
who won't step into theOperating Theater without a
particular pin in their pocketor an athlete who insists on
(00:33):
wearing the same socks to everygame. Humans reach for symbolic
objects when the stakes arehigh.
On the surface, it might lookirrational. After all, a sock
can't make a shot go in, and anecklace can't keep a patient
alive. But dig into thepsychology and anthropology and
you find something fascinating.Charms and rituals change how
(00:55):
our brains handle risk,uncertainty, and stress. They
don't alter probability, butthey alter us.
Today, we'll unpack whytalismans work, how they calm
our bodies and sharpen ourfocus, when they start to become
unhealthy, and why they persistacross cultures and into our
digital lives. We'll look at theneuroscience of belief, the
(01:19):
anthropology of ritual, and thefine line between helpful
superstition and harmfulcompulsion. Humans hate
randomness. Our brains are wiredto see patterns, to link cause
and effect even when the two areunrelated. Way back in 1890,
anthropologist James Frasercalled this sympathetic magic.
(01:43):
The idea that objects connectedin time, space, or resemblance
could influence each other. It'swhy ancient warriors carried
battle charms, why sailorswouldn't set sail without
specific rituals, or why arabbit's foot symbolized both
fertility and luck. Fraseridentified two types of magical
(02:04):
thinking, imitative magic, wherelike produces like, and
contagious magic, where thingsonce in contact remain
connected. These aren't justhistorical curiosities. They're
cognitive patterns that stillshape how we think today.
When athletes wear the samesocks during a winning streak,
(02:24):
they're practicing contagiousmagic. When someone scratches a
lottery ticket faster or in acertain direction for higher
numbers, they're engaging inimitative magic, acting as if
their action transfers to theoutcome. Modern psychology picks
up where Fraser left off.Research from the '70s showed
(02:45):
that people act as if they cancontrol outcomes even when they
objectively can't. When rollingdice, for example, people throw
harder when aiming for highnumbers and they throw softer
when aiming for low numbers asif their physical action can
bend chance itself.
This is called the illusion ofcontrol and it's hardwired into
(03:07):
how we think. Talismans growdirectly out of that bias. When
you touch a charm before a testor a performance, you feel like
you've done something toinfluence the outcome, even when
you know intellectually it'ssymbolic. It's a way of pushing
back against chaos. Ittransforms passive waiting into
(03:29):
active participation, even ifthat participation is purely
psychological.
From an evolutionaryperspective, this pattern
seeking wasn't a flaw. It wasadaptive. Assuming connections
kept our ancestors alive.Hearing a rustle in the bushes
and treating it as a predator,even if it was just wind, was
(03:50):
much safer than ignoring it.That bias toward connection,
seeing meaning where there maybe none, underpins our belief in
charms now.
We'd rather impose order onrandomness than admit that we're
floating in uncertainty. Thecost of false positives was
minimal and the cost of missinga real threat was death.
(04:15):
Superstitions spike inenvironments of risk and
uncertainty. High stakes triggerour stress response, elevating
cortisol, narrowing focus, andheightening anxiety. In these
moments, rituals and charms stepin as regulators.
Studies on superstition showthat rituals reduce anxiety by
(04:35):
creating a sense ofpredictability. Even if we know
rationally that a pendant or aroutine can't change an outcome,
the act of believing soothes ournervous system. It provides
structure in the face of theunknown. When everything feels
out of control, controllingsomething, even a small ritual,
(04:56):
restores our sense of agency.The stress reduction mechanism
is real and measurable.
When you perform a ritual, yourheart rate stabilizes, your
breathing deepens. Therepetitive, familiar actions
trigger a calming responsesimilar to meditation or
mindfulness practices. You areessentially hacking your own
(05:17):
nervous system using symbolicbehavior to produce
physiological calm. Surgeons andpilots often admit to these
small rituals. One surgeon saidshe always scrubs in the same
sequence, not because it'smedically required but because
it centers her.
Another surgeon reportedcarrying the same watch into
(05:39):
every operation, checking it atspecific intervals as part of
his preparation routine. Pilotshave been known to carry small
tokens into the cockpit orfollow specific preflight
sequences beyond the officialchecklist. The common thread is
emotional regulation. Thesebehaviors don't guarantee
(06:00):
safety, but they helpprofessionals stay steady when
precision and focus matter most.Think about it.
In a high risk surgery where asingle slip could cost a life,
the formal rituals are alreadythere. The scrub, the gown, the
checklist. These institutionalrituals serve both practical and
(06:20):
psychological purposes. Theyreduce infection risk,
certainly, but they also createa liminal space, something we've
talked about before. This helpsthe surgeon transition from the
ordinary world into theheightened focus required for
surgery.
Many surgeons add their ownpersonal touches. Carrying the
(06:40):
same pen, adjusting instrumentsin a specific order, wearing the
same socks, repeating a calmingphrase before the first
incision. Some surgeons won'toperate without a specific piece
of music or playlist. Othersneed a moment of silence. These
aren't institutionalrequirements.
They're private anchors thathelp calm the mind and prepare
(07:02):
the body. Anthropologistsobserving medical practice
describe these behaviors aspersonal rituals layered onto
institutional ritual. They don'tsterilize instruments or mend
arteries, but they calm theperformer. Like athletes,
surgeons are managing not justtechnical skill but human
anxiety. They're creatingpsychological scaffolding for
(07:26):
high performance work.
Sports psychology gives us someof the clearest evidence.
Experiments have shown that whenathletes are told a ball is
lucky, they perform better. Notbecause the ball changes
physics, but because theirconfidence shifts. In one study,
golfers putting with what theybelieved was a lucky ball sank
(07:49):
significantly more putts thanthose using a regular ball. The
difference wasn't the equipment,it was the belief.
Their belief enhancedperformance. The mechanism is
straightforward. Belief reducesanxiety. Anxiety reduction
improves focus. And improvedfocus leads to better motor
(08:09):
control and decision making.
It's a cascade effect where asimple cognitive shift, thinking
this ball is lucky, triggersreal behavioral changes. Real
world athletes offer endlessstories. Michael Jordan famously
wore his UNC shorts under hisBulls uniform for years. Serena
Williams repeats small ritualsbefore every match, bouncing the
(08:33):
ball a specific number of times,arranging her towels in a
particular way. Baseball playersare notorious for elaborate pre
bat routines, adjusting theirgloves, tapping the plate,
stepping out and back in exactlythe same way every time.
Wade Boggs ate chicken beforeevery game for twenty years.
(08:54):
Turk Wendell, a pitcher, chewedlicorice and brushed his teeth
between innings. At the elitelevel where skill is already
maximized, the mental edgematters most. When everyone has
incredible talent, thedifferences between winning and
losing often come down to whocan manage their nerves better.
(09:15):
Charms and rituals act likeperformance enhancers for the
mind.
They reduce anxiety and focusattention, providing a script to
follow when pressure mounts. Andit's not just elite athletes. A
recent review of sports ritualsfound that players across all
levels use routines, charms,and, quote, don't change the
(09:36):
socks habits as ways to copewith anxiety and maintain
consistency. Youth athletes,college players, recreational
competitors, they all developsmall superstitions. It's a
shared language of control in aseries of unpredictable games.
When you can't control whetherthe ball goes in, you can at
(09:57):
least control what you wore orwhat you touched beforehand.
That review also noted somethinginteresting. Superstitions are
more common in sports withhigher variability in outcomes.
Baseball players are moresuperstitious than football
players. Golfers more thanswimmers.
The less direct the connectionbetween skill and outcome, the
(10:21):
more an athlete leans on ritual.When randomness plays a bigger
role, our need for symboliccontrol increases. So what's
actually happening in our brain?One explanation is that charms
operate like placebos. Beliefitself triggers real changes in
(10:41):
the body.
Placebo studies show thatexpectation can reduce pain,
improve endurance, and eveninfluence hormone levels and
immune responses. A talismanfits this same category. The
charm isn't chemically active,but belief makes it functionally
active. The placebo effect isn'tabout being gullible or fooled.
(11:04):
It's about how expectationshapes physiology.
When you believe something willhelp you, your brain releases
neurochemicals that actually dohelp you. Dopamine, endorphins,
oxytocin, these substanceschange how you feel and how you
perform. A lucky charm cantrigger this cascade just as
(11:25):
effectively as a sugar pilllabeled as medicine. There's
also something about touch andembodiment. Holding or wearing a
charm creates a physical cue.
The sensation reinforces belief,and belief reduces stress. That
loop improves focus, andimproved focus reinforces the
(11:46):
value of the charm. Over time, anecklace or token becomes a
conditioned anchor. Justtouching it signals calm, like
Pavlov's bell signaling food tohis dogs. In psychological
terms, it's about self efficacy,believing that you can succeed.
Research shows that selfefficacy is one of the strongest
(12:08):
predictors of actual performanceacross domains. And if a
talisman boosts that belief,performance follows. The charm
doesn't hold power in itself. Wegive it power. And in doing so,
we sometimes reshape our ownoutcomes.
And this is where the magicreally lies, not in the object,
(12:30):
but in the psychological shiftthe object creates. The lucky
pen doesn't make your handsteadier. The ritual of touching
it before you start calms yournervous system, sharpens your
attention, and primes your brainfor high performance. That's
real, measurable, and whytalismans seem to work. There's
(12:51):
even evidence that the physicalproperties of your charms
matter.
Weight, texture, temperature,these sensory qualities can
enhance the charm's effect onyour brain. A heavy charm might
feel more substantial, more realin its perceived power. A smooth
stone you can rub between yourfingers provides tactile
(13:13):
feedback that reinforces thecalming response. The multi
century nature of talismansmakes them more effective
anchors than purely mentalaffirmation. Across cultures,
talismans look different butserve the same function.
In Japan, small amulets calledomamori are purchased from
(13:36):
Shinto shrines and promiseprotection for travel, exams,
health, or safety. Each omamoriis specific. There's one for
traffic safety, another foracademic success, another for
safe childbirth. They'retypically small silk pouches
containing prayers or blessedobjects, and they're meant to be
(13:58):
carried or displayed but neveropened. Catholic traditions use
medals of saints.
Saint Christopher for travelers,Saint Jude for desperate causes,
Saint Anthony for lost things.These medals are blessed by
priests, imbuing them withspiritual authority. Wearing one
(14:18):
isn't just personalsuperstition. It's participation
in a religious traditioncenturies old. Indigenous
cultures around the worldintegrate protective items into
daily life and ceremony,carrying both spiritual and
communal power.
Medicine bags, sacred stones,carved totems these objects
(14:41):
connect individuals toancestors, to land, to
cosmological systems of meaning.They're never just lucky charms.
They're repositories of culturalknowledge and spiritual
practice. These aren't justpersonal quirks. They connect
individuals to collectivetraditions, turning private
(15:01):
anxiety into shared meaning.
Carrying an omamari isn't justabout luck on a test. It
connects you to a place, aritual, a priest blessing, a
community. That culturalscaffolding strengthens the
psychological effect. You're notjust relying on your own belief.
You're tapping into generationsof accumulated faith.
(15:25):
Western lucky socks or four leafclovers might seem more secular,
more individual, but they followthe same pattern. We attach
symbolic value to objects, andthese objects become vessels for
meaning. Whether blessed by apriest or simply worn during
past success, the mechanism isthe same. We invest the object
(15:47):
with power so it can reflectthat power back to us when we
need it the most. What'sinteresting is how these
cultural traditions adapt andpersist even as societies
modernize.
Japan, one of the mosttechnologically advanced nations
on earth, still has thrivingomamore sales at shrines.
(16:08):
Catholic metals remain populareven among less observant
believers. The form may beancient, but the psychological
function remains relevant. Notall rituals are healthy.
Sometimes superstition crossesinto dependence.
If an athlete refuses to playwithout their charm or a
(16:31):
professional can't perform if aritual is disrupted, the object
becomes a liability. Control hasshifted from the person to the
thing. This is where psychologydraws parallels to obsessive
compulsive disorder. OCDinvolves rituals as well.
Repeated behaviors aimed atreducing anxiety, often driven
(16:54):
by a fear that failing to dothem will cause harm.
Certainly, that's not the onlycriterion for OCD, but it is the
most reflective of what we'retalking about here. The
difference is severity andflexibility. For most people, a
charm is optional. If it's notavailable, you might feel a
(17:15):
little off, but you can stillfunction. For someone with OCD,
skipping a ritual can causedebilitating anxiety and genuine
distress.
The intrusive thoughts won'tstop. The fear won't subside.
Recent research underscores thiscontinuum. Network analysis of
obsessive compulsive symptomsplace superstitious obsession
(17:38):
right alongside compulsivecounting and repeating. Studies
comparing athletes with healthyrituals to those with clinical
OCD symptoms show where the lineblurs and where it holds.
Some athletes develop ritualdependencies that genuinely
interfere with their ability tocompete. That's when their
(17:59):
coping tool has become a cage.One study examined athletes who
met criteria for OCD and foundtheir superstitions were more
rigid, more time consuming, andmore distressing than those of
non OCD athletes. A healthyritual might take thirty seconds
and feel reassuring. Acompulsive ritual might take
(18:21):
thirty minutes and feelmandatory, with overwhelming
anxiety if it can't be completedperfectly.
There's also the question ofmagical thinking severity. Some
level of magical thinking isnormal and even adaptive. But
when it becomes pervasive, whenyou genuinely believe your
thoughts can cause harm toothers, or when you feel
(18:44):
responsible for preventingdisasters through ritual, it
crosses into pathology. It's areminder that while charms can
help, they can also trap. Thehealthiest relationship with a
talisman is when it supportsyour confidence without
controlling your ability to act.
If losing the charm means youcan't perform at all, the charm
(19:06):
has stopped serving you. You'vebecome dependent on an external
crutch rather than using it tobuild internal resilience. A key
question to ask yourself is doesthis ritual help me access my
own capabilities, or has itbecome a substitute for them? If
the ritual is a bridge toconfidence, that's adaptive. If
(19:29):
it's become the only source ofconfidence, that's problematic.
Our brains haven't changed, butour environment has. Today's
talismans are just as likely tobe digital as well as physical.
Gamers swear by luckycontrollers, specific hardware
they won't swap out even whennewer versions are available.
(19:51):
Some gamers have worn the sameshirt or hat to their
tournaments for years. Esportsplayers develop pre match
rituals just like traditionalathletes.
Coders keep the same playlist orwear the same headphones when
debugging. Some developers won'tstart a project without opening
specific applications in aspecific order or without a
(20:13):
particular beverage at hand.There are programmers who claim
they can only solve certaintypes of problems while wearing
certain clothes or sitting incertain chairs. Some people
choose laptop wallpapers orphone lock screens they refuse
to change because they feel itanchors their productivity or
their luck. Others have luckycoffee mugs they use only for
(20:35):
important work sessions.
Digital artists have specificbrushes or presets they consider
lucky. Writers might have luckyfonts or lucky writing
locations. These behaviorsmirror the ancient rabbit's foot
or saint's medal. The objectsdiffer, but the function is
identical, reducing uncertainty,reinforcing confidence, and
(20:57):
making the intangible world ofchance feel manageable. The tech
worker touching their luckymouse pad before a big
presentation is doing exactlywhat the medieval knight did
touching a saint's relic beforebattle.
It's fascinating thatsuperstition hasn't faded with
technological advancement. Ifanything, it's adapted and
(21:18):
proliferated. We've simplytransferred the same
psychological needs onto newobjects. The medium changes, the
mind doesn't. As our livesbecome more dominated by screens
and digital interactions, wefind new vessels for the same
ancient impulses.
In fact, I'm personally curiousfor how many people AI chatbots
(21:41):
and generative AI tools arebecoming a new kind of talisman.
Some researchers have noted thatdigital work, precisely because
it's less tangible, mightactually increase our need for
physical anchors. When your workexists only as pixels on a
screen, having a lucky keyboardor a specific desk setup creates
(22:03):
concrete, embodied ritual in anotherwise abstract environment.
The physical world grounds uswhen the work world is virtual.
When you strip it down,talismans endure because they
serve a deep psychological need.
They help us face uncertainty,regulate our emotions, and feel
(22:24):
anchored in chaotic situations.They work not because they
change the external world, butbecause they change our internal
state. And in high stakesmoments, that internal state
determines everything. That'swhy talismans and lucky charms
appear across cultures,professions, and centuries.
(22:45):
They're not outdated relics ofmagical thinking.
They're tools humans have alwaysused to study themselves. From
ancient warriors carryingprotective amulets into battle
to modern surgeons slipping afamiliar pin into a pocket, the
story is the same (22:59):
when we can't control outcomes, we control
rituals, and those rituals, inturn, help us perform. There's a
reason every major religionincorporates ritual objects.
Prayer beads, crucifixes, prayerwheels, sacred texts. These
aren't just symbols.
They're technologies formanaging the human nervous
(23:20):
system in the face ofexistential uncertainty. The
secular charm operates on thesame principle, just without the
theological framework. Talismansalso connect us to our own
histories. That lucky necklaceisn't just an object. It's
linked to a specific victory, acherished relationship, a moment
when you felt powerful or safe.
(23:42):
Wearing it brings that momentback into the present, like a
form of time travel, emotionallyspeaking. You're carrying a
piece of your best self into thecurrent challenge. But it's
worth noticing when your ritualsstart to hold too much power.
The healthiest relationship witha charm is when it supports you,
not when it controls you. Whenthe object becomes
(24:05):
nonnegotiable, when losing itderails you completely, it's
worth asking, am I using thistool or is it using me?
The goal isn't to abandonritual. For many people, they're
genuinely helpful. The goal isawareness. Recognize what the
charm does for you. Appreciateits role, but don't let it
become the only thing standingbetween you and your ability to
(24:28):
act.
Build multiple sources ofconfidence. Develop internal
anchors alongside your externalones. That way, if you ever lose
the charm, you don't loseyourself. So next time you see
an athlete kiss a necklacebefore stepping onto the field
or catch yourself slipping on apair of lucky shoes before your
(24:49):
big presentation, pause for asec. What you're seeing isn't
nonsense.
It's just a glimpse into the wayhumans cope with risk. Our
charms may not alterprobability, but they remind us
of something profound. Inuncertain moments, belief itself
can shift the outcome byshifting us. We imbue objects
with meaning so we can studyourselves when it matters most.
(25:13):
And in that small act, weconnect to a tradition thousands
of years old.
Humans facing the unknown withsomething solid in their hands.
Whether it's your surgeon'slucky socks, an athlete's hat,
or a gamer's horn controller,these objects serve the same
timeless function, transformingour anxiety into action, chaos
(25:34):
into control, and vulnerabilityinto strength, not through
magic, but through the very realpower of belief, shaping our
minds and bodies. If you enjoyedthis dive into the psychology of
talismans, check the show notesfor the full reference list and
visit the Psyber dot spacewebsite for past episodes on
related themes like thepsychology of gaslighting, the
(25:55):
cost of comfort, or how ourbrains wrestle with change.
Thanks again for listening toPsyberSpace. I'm your host,
Leslie Posten, signing off andreminding you to stay curious
and maybe take a moment to thinkabout your own rituals.
They might be more powerful thanyou realize. And don't forget to
subscribe so you never miss aweek, and send this to a friend
(26:16):
or a colleague if you think thatthey'll enjoy it.
Welcome back to PsyberSpace. I'm your host,
Leslie Poston. Today, we'retalking about something small,
sometimes silly, yetsurprisingly powerful:
talismans, lucky charms, andrituals. Whether it's a surgeon
who won't step into theOperating Theater without a
particular pin in their pocketor an athlete who insists on
(00:33):
wearing the same socks to everygame. Humans reach for symbolic
objects when the stakes arehigh.
On the surface, it might lookirrational. After all, a sock
can't make a shot go in, and anecklace can't keep a patient
alive. But dig into thepsychology and anthropology and
you find something fascinating.Charms and rituals change how
(00:55):
our brains handle risk,uncertainty, and stress. They
don't alter probability, butthey alter us.
Today, we'll unpack whytalismans work, how they calm
our bodies and sharpen ourfocus, when they start to become
unhealthy, and why they persistacross cultures and into our
digital lives. We'll look at theneuroscience of belief, the
(01:19):
anthropology of ritual, and thefine line between helpful
superstition and harmfulcompulsion. Humans hate
randomness. Our brains are wiredto see patterns, to link cause
and effect even when the two areunrelated. Way back in 1890,
anthropologist James Frasercalled this sympathetic magic.
(01:43):
The idea that objects connectedin time, space, or resemblance
could influence each other. It'swhy ancient warriors carried
battle charms, why sailorswouldn't set sail without
specific rituals, or why arabbit's foot symbolized both
fertility and luck. Fraseridentified two types of magical
(02:04):
thinking, imitative magic, wherelike produces like, and
contagious magic, where thingsonce in contact remain
connected. These aren't justhistorical curiosities. They're
cognitive patterns that stillshape how we think today.
When athletes wear the samesocks during a winning streak,
(02:24):
they're practicing contagiousmagic. When someone scratches a
lottery ticket faster or in acertain direction for higher
numbers, they're engaging inimitative magic, acting as if
their action transfers to theoutcome. Modern psychology picks
up where Fraser left off.Research from the '70s showed
(02:45):
that people act as if they cancontrol outcomes even when they
objectively can't. When rollingdice, for example, people throw
harder when aiming for highnumbers and they throw softer
when aiming for low numbers asif their physical action can
bend chance itself.
This is called the illusion ofcontrol and it's hardwired into
(03:07):
how we think. Talismans growdirectly out of that bias. When
you touch a charm before a testor a performance, you feel like
you've done something toinfluence the outcome, even when
you know intellectually it'ssymbolic. It's a way of pushing
back against chaos. Ittransforms passive waiting into
(03:29):
active participation, even ifthat participation is purely
psychological.
From an evolutionaryperspective, this pattern
seeking wasn't a flaw. It wasadaptive. Assuming connections
kept our ancestors alive.Hearing a rustle in the bushes
and treating it as a predator,even if it was just wind, was
(03:50):
much safer than ignoring it.That bias toward connection,
seeing meaning where there maybe none, underpins our belief in
charms now.
We'd rather impose order onrandomness than admit that we're
floating in uncertainty. Thecost of false positives was
minimal and the cost of missinga real threat was death.
(04:15):
Superstitions spike inenvironments of risk and
uncertainty. High stakes triggerour stress response, elevating
cortisol, narrowing focus, andheightening anxiety. In these
moments, rituals and charms stepin as regulators.
Studies on superstition showthat rituals reduce anxiety by
(04:35):
creating a sense ofpredictability. Even if we know
rationally that a pendant or aroutine can't change an outcome,
the act of believing soothes ournervous system. It provides
structure in the face of theunknown. When everything feels
out of control, controllingsomething, even a small ritual,
(04:56):
restores our sense of agency.The stress reduction mechanism
is real and measurable.
When you perform a ritual, yourheart rate stabilizes, your
breathing deepens. Therepetitive, familiar actions
trigger a calming responsesimilar to meditation or
mindfulness practices. You areessentially hacking your own
(05:17):
nervous system using symbolicbehavior to produce
physiological calm. Surgeons andpilots often admit to these
small rituals. One surgeon saidshe always scrubs in the same
sequence, not because it'smedically required but because
it centers her.
Another surgeon reportedcarrying the same watch into
(05:39):
every operation, checking it atspecific intervals as part of
his preparation routine. Pilotshave been known to carry small
tokens into the cockpit orfollow specific preflight
sequences beyond the officialchecklist. The common thread is
emotional regulation. Thesebehaviors don't guarantee
(06:00):
safety, but they helpprofessionals stay steady when
precision and focus matter most.Think about it.
In a high risk surgery where asingle slip could cost a life,
the formal rituals are alreadythere. The scrub, the gown, the
checklist. These institutionalrituals serve both practical and
(06:20):
psychological purposes. Theyreduce infection risk,
certainly, but they also createa liminal space, something we've
talked about before. This helpsthe surgeon transition from the
ordinary world into theheightened focus required for
surgery.
Many surgeons add their ownpersonal touches. Carrying the
(06:40):
same pen, adjusting instrumentsin a specific order, wearing the
same socks, repeating a calmingphrase before the first
incision. Some surgeons won'toperate without a specific piece
of music or playlist. Othersneed a moment of silence. These
aren't institutionalrequirements.
They're private anchors thathelp calm the mind and prepare
(07:02):
the body. Anthropologistsobserving medical practice
describe these behaviors aspersonal rituals layered onto
institutional ritual. They don'tsterilize instruments or mend
arteries, but they calm theperformer. Like athletes,
surgeons are managing not justtechnical skill but human
anxiety. They're creatingpsychological scaffolding for
(07:26):
high performance work.
Sports psychology gives us someof the clearest evidence.
Experiments have shown that whenathletes are told a ball is
lucky, they perform better. Notbecause the ball changes
physics, but because theirconfidence shifts. In one study,
golfers putting with what theybelieved was a lucky ball sank
(07:49):
significantly more putts thanthose using a regular ball. The
difference wasn't the equipment,it was the belief.
Their belief enhancedperformance. The mechanism is
straightforward. Belief reducesanxiety. Anxiety reduction
improves focus. And improvedfocus leads to better motor
(08:09):
control and decision making.
It's a cascade effect where asimple cognitive shift, thinking
this ball is lucky, triggersreal behavioral changes. Real
world athletes offer endlessstories. Michael Jordan famously
wore his UNC shorts under hisBulls uniform for years. Serena
Williams repeats small ritualsbefore every match, bouncing the
(08:33):
ball a specific number of times,arranging her towels in a
particular way. Baseball playersare notorious for elaborate pre
bat routines, adjusting theirgloves, tapping the plate,
stepping out and back in exactlythe same way every time.
Wade Boggs ate chicken beforeevery game for twenty years.
(08:54):
Turk Wendell, a pitcher, chewedlicorice and brushed his teeth
between innings. At the elitelevel where skill is already
maximized, the mental edgematters most. When everyone has
incredible talent, thedifferences between winning and
losing often come down to whocan manage their nerves better.
(09:15):
Charms and rituals act likeperformance enhancers for the
mind.
They reduce anxiety and focusattention, providing a script to
follow when pressure mounts. Andit's not just elite athletes. A
recent review of sports ritualsfound that players across all
levels use routines, charms,and, quote, don't change the
(09:36):
socks habits as ways to copewith anxiety and maintain
consistency. Youth athletes,college players, recreational
competitors, they all developsmall superstitions. It's a
shared language of control in aseries of unpredictable games.
When you can't control whetherthe ball goes in, you can at
(09:57):
least control what you wore orwhat you touched beforehand.
That review also noted somethinginteresting. Superstitions are
more common in sports withhigher variability in outcomes.
Baseball players are moresuperstitious than football
players. Golfers more thanswimmers.
The less direct the connectionbetween skill and outcome, the
(10:21):
more an athlete leans on ritual.When randomness plays a bigger
role, our need for symboliccontrol increases. So what's
actually happening in our brain?One explanation is that charms
operate like placebos. Beliefitself triggers real changes in
(10:41):
the body.
Placebo studies show thatexpectation can reduce pain,
improve endurance, and eveninfluence hormone levels and
immune responses. A talismanfits this same category. The
charm isn't chemically active,but belief makes it functionally
active. The placebo effect isn'tabout being gullible or fooled.
(11:04):
It's about how expectationshapes physiology.
When you believe something willhelp you, your brain releases
neurochemicals that actually dohelp you. Dopamine, endorphins,
oxytocin, these substanceschange how you feel and how you
perform. A lucky charm cantrigger this cascade just as
(11:25):
effectively as a sugar pilllabeled as medicine. There's
also something about touch andembodiment. Holding or wearing a
charm creates a physical cue.
The sensation reinforces belief,and belief reduces stress. That
loop improves focus, andimproved focus reinforces the
(11:46):
value of the charm. Over time, anecklace or token becomes a
conditioned anchor. Justtouching it signals calm, like
Pavlov's bell signaling food tohis dogs. In psychological
terms, it's about self efficacy,believing that you can succeed.
Research shows that selfefficacy is one of the strongest
(12:08):
predictors of actual performanceacross domains. And if a
talisman boosts that belief,performance follows. The charm
doesn't hold power in itself. Wegive it power. And in doing so,
we sometimes reshape our ownoutcomes.
And this is where the magicreally lies, not in the object,
(12:30):
but in the psychological shiftthe object creates. The lucky
pen doesn't make your handsteadier. The ritual of touching
it before you start calms yournervous system, sharpens your
attention, and primes your brainfor high performance. That's
real, measurable, and whytalismans seem to work. There's
(12:51):
even evidence that the physicalproperties of your charms
matter.
Weight, texture, temperature,these sensory qualities can
enhance the charm's effect onyour brain. A heavy charm might
feel more substantial, more realin its perceived power. A smooth
stone you can rub between yourfingers provides tactile
(13:13):
feedback that reinforces thecalming response. The multi
century nature of talismansmakes them more effective
anchors than purely mentalaffirmation. Across cultures,
talismans look different butserve the same function.
In Japan, small amulets calledomamori are purchased from
(13:36):
Shinto shrines and promiseprotection for travel, exams,
health, or safety. Each omamoriis specific. There's one for
traffic safety, another foracademic success, another for
safe childbirth. They'retypically small silk pouches
containing prayers or blessedobjects, and they're meant to be
(13:58):
carried or displayed but neveropened. Catholic traditions use
medals of saints.
Saint Christopher for travelers,Saint Jude for desperate causes,
Saint Anthony for lost things.These medals are blessed by
priests, imbuing them withspiritual authority. Wearing one
(14:18):
isn't just personalsuperstition. It's participation
in a religious traditioncenturies old. Indigenous
cultures around the worldintegrate protective items into
daily life and ceremony,carrying both spiritual and
communal power.
Medicine bags, sacred stones,carved totems these objects
(14:41):
connect individuals toancestors, to land, to
cosmological systems of meaning.They're never just lucky charms.
They're repositories of culturalknowledge and spiritual
practice. These aren't justpersonal quirks. They connect
individuals to collectivetraditions, turning private
(15:01):
anxiety into shared meaning.
Carrying an omamari isn't justabout luck on a test. It
connects you to a place, aritual, a priest blessing, a
community. That culturalscaffolding strengthens the
psychological effect. You're notjust relying on your own belief.
You're tapping into generationsof accumulated faith.
(15:25):
Western lucky socks or four leafclovers might seem more secular,
more individual, but they followthe same pattern. We attach
symbolic value to objects, andthese objects become vessels for
meaning. Whether blessed by apriest or simply worn during
past success, the mechanism isthe same. We invest the object
(15:47):
with power so it can reflectthat power back to us when we
need it the most. What'sinteresting is how these
cultural traditions adapt andpersist even as societies
modernize.
Japan, one of the mosttechnologically advanced nations
on earth, still has thrivingomamore sales at shrines.
(16:08):
Catholic metals remain populareven among less observant
believers. The form may beancient, but the psychological
function remains relevant. Notall rituals are healthy.
Sometimes superstition crossesinto dependence.
If an athlete refuses to playwithout their charm or a
(16:31):
professional can't perform if aritual is disrupted, the object
becomes a liability. Control hasshifted from the person to the
thing. This is where psychologydraws parallels to obsessive
compulsive disorder. OCDinvolves rituals as well.
Repeated behaviors aimed atreducing anxiety, often driven
(16:54):
by a fear that failing to dothem will cause harm.
Certainly, that's not the onlycriterion for OCD, but it is the
most reflective of what we'retalking about here. The
difference is severity andflexibility. For most people, a
charm is optional. If it's notavailable, you might feel a
(17:15):
little off, but you can stillfunction. For someone with OCD,
skipping a ritual can causedebilitating anxiety and genuine
distress.
The intrusive thoughts won'tstop. The fear won't subside.
Recent research underscores thiscontinuum. Network analysis of
obsessive compulsive symptomsplace superstitious obsession
(17:38):
right alongside compulsivecounting and repeating. Studies
comparing athletes with healthyrituals to those with clinical
OCD symptoms show where the lineblurs and where it holds.
Some athletes develop ritualdependencies that genuinely
interfere with their ability tocompete. That's when their
(17:59):
coping tool has become a cage.One study examined athletes who
met criteria for OCD and foundtheir superstitions were more
rigid, more time consuming, andmore distressing than those of
non OCD athletes. A healthyritual might take thirty seconds
and feel reassuring. Acompulsive ritual might take
(18:21):
thirty minutes and feelmandatory, with overwhelming
anxiety if it can't be completedperfectly.
There's also the question ofmagical thinking severity. Some
level of magical thinking isnormal and even adaptive. But
when it becomes pervasive, whenyou genuinely believe your
thoughts can cause harm toothers, or when you feel
(18:44):
responsible for preventingdisasters through ritual, it
crosses into pathology. It's areminder that while charms can
help, they can also trap. Thehealthiest relationship with a
talisman is when it supportsyour confidence without
controlling your ability to act.
If losing the charm means youcan't perform at all, the charm
(19:06):
has stopped serving you. You'vebecome dependent on an external
crutch rather than using it tobuild internal resilience. A key
question to ask yourself is doesthis ritual help me access my
own capabilities, or has itbecome a substitute for them? If
the ritual is a bridge toconfidence, that's adaptive. If
(19:29):
it's become the only source ofconfidence, that's problematic.
Our brains haven't changed, butour environment has. Today's
talismans are just as likely tobe digital as well as physical.
Gamers swear by luckycontrollers, specific hardware
they won't swap out even whennewer versions are available.
(19:51):
Some gamers have worn the sameshirt or hat to their
tournaments for years. Esportsplayers develop pre match
rituals just like traditionalathletes.
Coders keep the same playlist orwear the same headphones when
debugging. Some developers won'tstart a project without opening
specific applications in aspecific order or without a
(20:13):
particular beverage at hand.There are programmers who claim
they can only solve certaintypes of problems while wearing
certain clothes or sitting incertain chairs. Some people
choose laptop wallpapers orphone lock screens they refuse
to change because they feel itanchors their productivity or
their luck. Others have luckycoffee mugs they use only for
(20:35):
important work sessions.
Digital artists have specificbrushes or presets they consider
lucky. Writers might have luckyfonts or lucky writing
locations. These behaviorsmirror the ancient rabbit's foot
or saint's medal. The objectsdiffer, but the function is
identical, reducing uncertainty,reinforcing confidence, and
(20:57):
making the intangible world ofchance feel manageable. The tech
worker touching their luckymouse pad before a big
presentation is doing exactlywhat the medieval knight did
touching a saint's relic beforebattle.
It's fascinating thatsuperstition hasn't faded with
technological advancement. Ifanything, it's adapted and
(21:18):
proliferated. We've simplytransferred the same
psychological needs onto newobjects. The medium changes, the
mind doesn't. As our livesbecome more dominated by screens
and digital interactions, wefind new vessels for the same
ancient impulses.
In fact, I'm personally curiousfor how many people AI chatbots
(21:41):
and generative AI tools arebecoming a new kind of talisman.
Some researchers have noted thatdigital work, precisely because
it's less tangible, mightactually increase our need for
physical anchors. When your workexists only as pixels on a
screen, having a lucky keyboardor a specific desk setup creates
(22:03):
concrete, embodied ritual in anotherwise abstract environment.
The physical world grounds uswhen the work world is virtual.
When you strip it down,talismans endure because they
serve a deep psychological need.
They help us face uncertainty,regulate our emotions, and feel
(22:24):
anchored in chaotic situations.They work not because they
change the external world, butbecause they change our internal
state. And in high stakesmoments, that internal state
determines everything. That'swhy talismans and lucky charms
appear across cultures,professions, and centuries.
(22:45):
They're not outdated relics ofmagical thinking.
They're tools humans have alwaysused to study themselves. From
ancient warriors carryingprotective amulets into battle
to modern surgeons slipping afamiliar pin into a pocket, the
story is the same (22:59):
when we can't control outcomes, we control
rituals, and those rituals, inturn, help us perform. There's a
reason every major religionincorporates ritual objects.
Prayer beads, crucifixes, prayerwheels, sacred texts. These
aren't just symbols.
They're technologies formanaging the human nervous
(23:20):
system in the face ofexistential uncertainty. The
secular charm operates on thesame principle, just without the
theological framework. Talismansalso connect us to our own
histories. That lucky necklaceisn't just an object. It's
linked to a specific victory, acherished relationship, a moment
when you felt powerful or safe.
(23:42):
Wearing it brings that momentback into the present, like a
form of time travel, emotionallyspeaking. You're carrying a
piece of your best self into thecurrent challenge. But it's
worth noticing when your ritualsstart to hold too much power.
The healthiest relationship witha charm is when it supports you,
not when it controls you. Whenthe object becomes
(24:05):
nonnegotiable, when losing itderails you completely, it's
worth asking, am I using thistool or is it using me?
The goal isn't to abandonritual. For many people, they're
genuinely helpful. The goal isawareness. Recognize what the
charm does for you. Appreciateits role, but don't let it
become the only thing standingbetween you and your ability to
(24:28):
act.
Build multiple sources ofconfidence. Develop internal
anchors alongside your externalones. That way, if you ever lose
the charm, you don't loseyourself. So next time you see
an athlete kiss a necklacebefore stepping onto the field
or catch yourself slipping on apair of lucky shoes before your
(24:49):
big presentation, pause for asec. What you're seeing isn't
nonsense.
It's just a glimpse into the wayhumans cope with risk. Our
charms may not alterprobability, but they remind us
of something profound. Inuncertain moments, belief itself
can shift the outcome byshifting us. We imbue objects
with meaning so we can studyourselves when it matters most.
(25:13):
And in that small act, weconnect to a tradition thousands
of years old.
Humans facing the unknown withsomething solid in their hands.
Whether it's your surgeon'slucky socks, an athlete's hat,
or a gamer's horn controller,these objects serve the same
timeless function, transformingour anxiety into action, chaos
(25:34):
into control, and vulnerabilityinto strength, not through
magic, but through the very realpower of belief, shaping our
minds and bodies. If you enjoyedthis dive into the psychology of
talismans, check the show notesfor the full reference list and
visit the Psyber dot spacewebsite for past episodes on
related themes like thepsychology of gaslighting, the
(25:55):
cost of comfort, or how ourbrains wrestle with change.
Thanks again for listening toPsyberSpace. I'm your host,
Leslie Posten, signing off andreminding you to stay curious
and maybe take a moment to thinkabout your own rituals.
They might be more powerful thanyou realize. And don't forget to
subscribe so you never miss aweek, and send this to a friend
(26:16):
or a colleague if you think thatthey'll enjoy it.
Popular Podcasts
Dateline NBC
Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Follow now to get the latest episodes of Dateline NBC completely free, or subscribe to Dateline Premium for ad-free listening and exclusive bonus content: DatelinePremium.com
Are You A Charlotte?
In 1997, actress Kristin Davis’ life was forever changed when she took on the role of Charlotte York in Sex and the City. As we watched Carrie, Samantha, Miranda and Charlotte navigate relationships in NYC, the show helped push once unacceptable conversation topics out of the shadows and altered the narrative around women and sex. We all saw ourselves in them as they searched for fulfillment in life, sex and friendships. Now, Kristin Davis wants to connect with you, the fans, and share untold stories and all the behind the scenes. Together, with Kristin and special guests, what will begin with Sex and the City will evolve into talks about themes that are still so relevant today. "Are you a Charlotte?" is much more than just rewatching this beloved show, it brings the past and the present together as we talk with heart, humor and of course some optimism.
Stuff You Should Know
If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.