Homeschool vs. Catholic Schools: Restoring Faith and Community in Education

Restoring Christian Culture Podcast – Episode 20: Homeschool vs. Catholic Schools: Restoring Faith and Community in Education

We’ve hit a milestone! Join Marco, Dan, and returning guest Mathias as we celebrate Episode 20 of the Restoring Christian Culture Podcast. In this thought-provoking episode, the team dives deep into Mathias’s recent Substack article, "The Hollowing of Tradition: Why Catholic Schools Must Rise Again." The conversation explores the decline of authentic Catholic education in America, the loss of institutional tradition, and what it will take to rebuild a true Catholic educational culture.

From witty banter about studio upgrades and the challenges of homeschooling to sobering reflections on the responsibility parents (and the Church) bear in forming the next generation, this is an honest conversation about why tradition matters, what’s been lost, and how Catholic communities can restore a vibrant culture of faith and learning.

Key Topics Discussed

• Catholic School Crisis: Why so many diocesan Catholic schools today have become “hollowed out” and why parents are left questioning if their children are truly receiving a formation in the faith.
• Public vs. Diocesan vs. Independent Catholic Schools: What’s at stake for families choosing between these options?
• The Homeschool Movement: Mathias shares insights from his own experience with homeschooling, its strengths, and its limitations—especially concerning vocations and fostering a sense of Catholic community.
• Returning to Institution-Building: The historical role that parochial schools played in community life, the sacrifices made by saints like Elizabeth Ann Seton, and why building strong Catholic institutions is vital—not just for families, but for the wider Church and society.
• Parental Responsibility: The duty to seek a truly Catholic education, even if it means leaving comfortable or “approved” diocesan options that have lost their soul.
• Community Over Individualism: Why reclaiming Christian culture requires us to think communally, supporting Catholic schools that serve all—especially the most vulnerable.
• Practical Guidance: What questions parents should ask about their children’s school, when to push for change, and when to move on.
• Exciting Updates! The hosts tease big upcoming projects and collaborations—stay tuned for more details in future episodes.

Resources & Mentions

• Mathias Sevigny’s Substack:
  Ever Ancient, Ever New — Articles on liturgy, Catholic education, and culture.
• Lumen Christi Academy:
  Learn more about this model of restored Catholic education.
• Further Reading:
  • Pope Pius XI, Divini Illius Magistri (On Christian Education)
  • Classic works on Catholic parochial schools, the desert Fathers, and the history of seminary education

Connect & Continue the Conversation

• Support Catholic Schools: If you’re in a parish with an authentic Catholic school, become an advocate! If you’re elsewhere, get involved—support, build, or join a movement that’s truly restoring Christian culture.
• Contact: Reach out, share your feedback, or suggest topics for future episodes!
• Subscribe: Get updates on future episodes and exclusive content by subscribing on your favorite podcast platform.

Restoring Christian Culture Podcast — Where tradition meets real life, and families, parishes, and communities are called to build a brighter Catholic future together.

Listen Now & Share!

www.RestoringChristianCulture.org