Stop Pushing, Start Connecting - How to Write Outreach Messages That Get a Response

Have you ever sent an outreach message and wondered why it didn’t get a response? In this episode of the Sales Maven Show, Nikki Rausch breaks down exactly what makes outreach messages work and what causes them to fall flat. She shares practical strategies for crafting messages that truly engage readers, build connection, and inspire action, instead of getting ignored or deleted.

Nikki starts by analyzing a real outreach message that, at first glance, seems polished and professional. But on closer inspection, it fails to spark engagement because it is written entirely from the sender’s perspective. With more than 70 percent of its sentences beginning with “I” or “we,” the message focuses on the writer’s wants, vision, and goals, rather than on the recipient. Nikki explains why this self centered approach is a common trap and why effective outreach messages must flip the focus back onto the reader.

One of the most powerful ways to do this is through questions. Nikki draws on neuroscience and psychology to show that questions literally hijack the brain, triggering instinctive elaboration and forcing the reader to engage. She highlights how well placed questions tap into cognitive engagement, encourage reflection, and even create new neural pathways that make a message more memorable. Whether it is as simple as “Are you being called to uplevel?” or “Would you agree the world needs positive voices?,” the shift from statements to questions transforms outreach messages into genuine conversations.

Clarity is another key ingredient. Nikki emphasizes that vague, generic phrases like “uplevel, expand, redirect” or “your voice has power” don’t connect because they could apply to anyone. Instead, she encourages giving specific, sincere compliments that show real understanding of the recipient’s work. She also stresses the importance of having a single, clear call to action. Multiple asks like “check out our website” and “schedule a call” only dilute the message and overwhelm the reader.

Throughout the episode, Nikki shares practical tips like following the 80/20 rule (at least 80 percent of sentences should be about the reader, only 20 percent about the sender) and framing calendar links around the recipient’s convenience rather than the writer’s. She even offers a simple pattern interrupt question, “Did I catch you at a bad time?,” that can shift conversations instantly.

By the end, you will not only understand the psychology behind effective outreach messages but also have clear, actionable ways to rewrite your own. Nikki’s advice will help you stop wasting time on generic messages and start creating authentic connections that get real responses.

Nikki invites you to join the Sales Maven Society. Take advantage of this opportunity to work together with you and Nikki. Bring your questions, concerns, and sales situations; she provides answers and guidance. Join the Sales Maven Society here, click Join Today, and then checkout and use coupon code 47trial to get your first month for $47.00!

For more actionable sales tips, download the FREE Closing The Sale Ebook.

Find Nikki:

Nikki Rausch

[e-mail]

Facebook | Twitter | LinkedIn | Instagram

Sales Maven Society

https://calendly.com/salesmaven/work-with-nikki-discussion