Don't Pet The Pony

Send us a text

It looks like a toy.
It feels like comfort.
But what if your favorite plush was something else entirely?

In this haunting tale, Saydie meets a creature born from our own imagination—a Cradlemare.
It doesn’t bite. It doesn’t chase.
It watches.
And waits.
And if you touch it in a dream…
It might wake up in your place.

A Sleep Tight Frights original creature story.
This is:
Don’t Pet the Pony
Where dreams remember. And toys don’t forget.

Support the show

Connect with us!
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61576252241932
Instagram: instagram.com/Sleeptightfrights

OR by email: [e-mail]

Follow for behind-the-scenes peeks, creature features, and creepy content between episodes!

~~~~~~~~~~

Content Warning: Sleep Tight Frights

This podcast features spooky stories intended for brave listeners aged 8 and up.
While there’s no graphic content, these tales may include:
• eerie sounds
• supernatural themes
• unsettling creatures
• and haunting twists.

Listener discretion is advised—especially at bedtime.

© 2025 Sleep Tight Frights. All Rights Reserved.
This episode, including all stories, characters, and narration, is the original work of Sleep Tight Frights and may not be copied, reproduced, or distributed without express permission. Unauthorized use is strictly prohibited.