Weeknight Mysteries Podcast

Athalia Ponsell Lindsley, born on July 25, 1917, was a former model and active community member in St. Augustine, Florida. On January 23, 1974, she was brutally murdered outside her home at 124 Marine Street. The attack, carried out by an unidentified assailant with a machete, resulted in her death at the age of 56. Her murder remains unsolved despite suspicions and investigations involving her husband, James Lindsley, and neighbor...

Terry McSpadden, 24, was a well-known local in Wisbech, known for his easy-going personality and hard work at Economy Windows. Despite minor convictions limiting his presence in Wisbech on weekends, he was a dedicated father to his young children. Terry's relationship with his girlfriend, Becky, was tumultuous, and he occasionally stayed with his friend Jonathan Porter. Terry 's mother Helen has raised concerns about Jona...

Six-year-old Lilly and her four-year-old brother Jack went missing from their rural Nova Scotia home on May 2nd, 2025. The mother and stepfather of the two children claim that the kids were last seen at home on Friday, May 2nd, playing near the kitchen area. Stepfather Daniel Martell believes the children may have quietly slipped out through the sliding door in the kitchen, which wouldn't have made much noise, allowing them to...

Bill and Edith Moffatt were discovered deceased in their home in Maryborough, Queensland, Australia, on September 22, 1977. The couple had been seen the previous day attending community events in the evening. They returned home by 11 pm, and a neighbor reported hearing two muffled shots around 3 am during the night. The Moffatts were found with their hands tied and mouths gagged. The perpetrator did not steal any valuables; however...

Erin Gilbert was 24 years old in 1995 when she went missing on July 1st.
For the past year, Erin had been living in Anchorage, Alaska, with her sister’s family. She had found work as a nanny and was beginning to settle in.

A few days before her disappearance, she met a man named David Combs at a bar in Anchorage. Several days later, David invited her to accompany him to the Girdwood Forest Fair. It was the July 4th wee...

Leigh Occhi was 13 years old when she disappeared on August 21, 1992. According to her mother, Vickie Felton, Leigh was left alone at home while Vickie went to work that Thursday. Upon arriving at work, Vickie learned about Hurricane Andrew heading towards their hometown of Tupelo, Mississippi. Vickie attempted to call her daughter to inform her of the approaching storm, but Leigh did not answer the phone, causing Vickie to worry. ...

On Monday, November 21, 2016, arson claimed the lives of four young girls in Flora, Indiana: Keyana Davis, 11; Keyara Phillips, 9; Kerriele McDonald, 7; and Kionnie Welch, 5. Their mother Gaylin Rose survived. The family of five had recently moved into the home at the intersection of East Columbia Street and South Division Street, paying $500 per month in rent. In the years following that tragic night, the investigation has been ma...

15-year-old Canadian teenager Mélanie Ethier disappeared on the night of Saturday, September 28, 1996. She was last seen around 2 a.m., walking home after spending the evening at a friend’s house, where they had watched a movie. Several suspects were later identified by investigators, including two half-brothers involved in drug activity, the occupants of a suspicious white van who had made several locals uncomfortable, and the boy...

In this episode, we delve into the mystery of Trude Espås, a 20-year-old Norwegian woman who had just begun her job as a maid in the tourist town of Geiranger in western Norway. Only a week into her new job, Trude vanished without a trace. Ten days after her disappearance, her body was discovered just outside the town, in an area adjacent to the highway. The investigation uncovered several clues—including sightings of a strange Ger...

Lauren Spierer was a 20-year-old student at Indiana University who went missing on Friday, June 3rd, 2011. On the night of her disappearance, Lauren had been out with friends, visiting several locations around Bloomington, Indiana. She was last seen leaving a friend’s apartment and heading south toward her home, which was only about 10 minutes away. However, Lauren never made it back that night. In this podcast, we discuss several ...

Lisa Stebic, a 37 year old mother of two from America, has been missing since April 30, 2007. At the time of her disappearance she was still married to her husband of 14 years Craig Stebic, however the 2 of them were going trough a divorce process as they were living together in the same house. On the day of her disappearance, Lisa was seen at work and later picking up a sandwich. She was home when her children returned from school...

On the evening of January 20, 2008, 37-year-old Liu Huijun took her 4-year-old daughter to the Yuanlin Finance Building in Yuanlin, Taiwan. They entered the elevator together, heading for the top floor. During the ascent, Liu removed both her and her daughter's coats and shoes, leaving them behind in the elevator. They stepped out onto the top floor and vanished without a trace.

Contact us at:
weeknightmysteries@gmail...

17 year old Brianna Maitland disappeared after leaving her work on March 19th, 2004 in a small town of Montgomery, Vermont. Her car was found the next day, the car had rear-ended an abandoned house around a mile away from her work. Brianna has not been seen since.

When you look at the car accident, it seems unnatural, the FBI had theorized that the car was stage in an odd position, however there doesn't seem any logic...

21 year old Maura Murray went missing on February 9, 2004 shortly after crashing her Saturn sedan on a rural road in the small town of Haverhill in New Hampshire. Maura left the crash seen before the police arrived and she has not been seen since. On the podcast we analyze several theories that could explain what happened to Maura, such as her getting lost in the surrounding wilderness or getting picked up by a hitchhiker or even a...

The Bennington Triangle is a region in southwestern Vermont where a series of unexplained disappearances occurred between 1945 and 1950. On the podcast we discuss 5 missing person cases that took places within this alleged triangle and give our take weather there is connection between these incidents or were the pure coincidences.

Contact us at:
weeknightmysteries@gmail.com
Instagram - https://www.instag...

Molly Bish a 16 year old girl from Massachusetts went missing on June 27, 2000. She was last seen at her work - a life guard post at Comins Pond in Warren. Molly went missing just minutes after her mother Magi dropped her off on the Tuesday morning. A couple years later a hunter had seen her blue bathing suit in the woods on Whiskey Hill in Palmer and on June 9, 2003, her body was found 5 miles from her family home.

The ma...

Kurt Sova, a 17 year old teenager from a small Cleveland suburb went missing after not returning home from a Halloween party on Friday, October 23rd 1981. 5 days later, Kurt's body was found in a ravine just 2 miles away from his home, he didn't have any visible signs of trauma and his cause of death was never determined. The coroner determined that Kurt Sova had been dead for around 24 hours before his body was discovere...

Jennifer Fairgate is an unidentified woman who was found dead in the Oslo Plaza Hotel on Saturday, June 3, 1995. This woman had used the name "Jennifer Fairgate" in order to check into the hotel just a few days before her death. At some point the woman had left her room for around 20 hours for which she was unaccounted for, the hotel staff found her dead after she had failed to pay her hotel fee's. She had a bullet w...

The disappearance of Flannan Isles Lighthouse keepers took place in the year 1900. Flannan Isles Lighthouse has only been recently built and in December of 1900, 3 men were stationed to keep the light going - James Ducat, Thomas Marshall and Donald McArthur. All 3 men vanished, likely shortly after diner on the 15th of December. We try to figure what happened to them, could it have been an accident of is there an alternative explan...