S2 E5 The 1826 Trial of Joseph Smith

Send us a text!

Episode 5 of Beginnings  explores Joseph Smith's 1826 legal case in Bainbridge, New York, where he faced charges of being a "disorderly person" for treasure-hunting with a seer stone. We examine conflicting testimonies from witnesses who either believed in Smith's abilities or dismissed him as a fraud. The trial's outcome remains ambiguous, with contradictory accounts from different sources. We'll dive into the historical context of folk practices in the 1820s and various interpretations by historians. Rather than making definitive judgments, we invite you to consider how this incident might reshape your understanding of Smith's later religious leadership. 

Sources

• Video: Joseph Smith 1826 Trial part 1_Vogel
• Video: Joseph Smith 1826 Trial part 2_Vogel
• Essay: Joseph Smith 1826 Trial_LDS.org
• Essay: 1826 Trial_FAIR LDS
• Essay: 1826 Trial_Analyzing Mormonism
• Essay: Cunning and Disorderly_Dialogue
• Essay: Joseph Smith 1826 Conviction_Mormon Think

AI Prompt
Create a balanced analysis of Joseph Smith's 1826 trial, examining: 1) The legal charges regarding his "money-digging" activities, 2) Conflicting testimony from witnesses like Stowell who believed in Smith's abilities versus skeptics, 3) The ambiguous verdict with contradictory historical accounts, and 4) How scholars interpret this episode—either as evidence of fraudulent beginnings or as a misunderstood spiritual gift being refined toward prophetic calling.

Support the show

Study with our Free AI Notebooks

1. Truth | 2. Beginnings | 3. First Vision | 4. Priesthood | 5. The Gold Plates | 6. The BoM | 7. The BoA | 8. Polygamy | 9. Changes | 10. Challenges | ...