August 17, 2025 • 37 mins
In Simplicity Parenting, therapist and educator Kim John Payne argues that the root of many modern childhood challenges, anxiety, attention issues, behavioural struggles, is not psychological, but environmental.
The solution?
Less.
Less stuff. Less screen time. Fewer activities. Fewer choices.
By stripping away the noise of modern life, Payne shows how parents can create a calmer, more secure environment where children can thrive emotionally and neurologically. The book blends practical strategies with deep insights about rhythm, connection, and the power of predictability in a child’s life.
If your family feels rushed, overwhelmed, or constantly ‘on’, this episode is a gentle invitation to slow down, and rediscover what actually matters.
Mark as Played
Transcript
Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
(00:00):
Welcome to the Summary State podcast.
Today we're embarking on a deep dive into simplicity parenting
by Kim Jong Payne and Lisa M Ross.
Our mission is to really unpack the core idea that when it comes
to raising well adjusted, joyfulchildren, especially in a world
that just seems to demand more, faster, earlier, all the time,
(00:21):
well, maybe less is actually profoundly more.
It really is. It's a topic that I think
resonates deeply with so many parents, you know, just trying
to navigate that daily deluge ofchoices and commitments, just
sheer stuff. The book offers such a powerful
counter narrative. It suggests that some of the
very things we believe are like giving our children an advantage
might actually be contributing to their overwhelming stress.
(00:44):
So we'll explore how actively choosing simplicity can really
restore a sense of calm and well-being.
And not just for our kids, but for us as parents too.
OK, so to kick us off, they alsouses this really striking image.
It's the boiling frog analogy, and you're the one.
If you drop a frog into boiling water, boom, it jumps right out.
Right instant. But if you put it in cold water
and slowly heat it up, yeah, well, it just stays put, kind of
(01:07):
oblivious until it's too late. It's a It's a pretty unsettling
thought, isn't it, it? Really is that we could be so
immersed in our environment, we don't even perceive how
drastically it's changing aroundus.
And this is where the author makes such a compelling point.
Applying that that chilling analogy directly to our modern
families, he suggests we're living in an environment that's
(01:27):
become, well, increasingly inhospitable, especially for
children. But these shifts are so gradual,
you know, so incremental, that we might not even notice the
water heating up until our kids are already feeling overwhelmed.
Right. It's not like one big crisis.
Exactly. It's the accumulation of all
those small, seemingly harmless additions, the extra activities
(01:48):
and new gadgets, the endless information streams that just
slowly raise the temperature. So if we're the frogs here, what
exactly is heating up our water?What's driving this relentless
push for more? Well, the book points to two
major culprits. Too much stuff and too many
choices. Just think about it.
Advertising constantly bombards us with the message that more
(02:09):
equals happiness, right? But, the author smartly
observes, anyone who's ever tried to pick a cellular plan
knows too many choices can be overwhelming.
Oh. Tell me about it.
Yeah. It drains our time, it saps our
motivation, and it really diminishes our sense of
well-being. It's like that.
That colossal aisle of breakfastcereals at the grocery store.
(02:32):
Yes, what should be a simple decision becomes this like minor
existential crisis every morning.
Totally. And what's the underlying
emotional current behind all of this more faster mentality?
Yeah. Is it really about benefiting
our children or is there something else going on?
The author makes a strong case that it's often anxiety.
We find ourselves rushing from one enrichment opportunity to
(02:52):
the next, desperate to give our children every advantage now
known or soon to be invented. But much of this, the book
argues, stems from fear rather than a genuine reverence for
childhood. Reverence for childhood.
I like that. Phrase.
Yeah. That reverence, in his view,
would lead to a slower, more intentional approach.
You know, allowing things to unfold naturally instead of
(03:13):
trying to force them or like over engineer every single step.
So if we are indeed in this slowly boiling pot, what's the
ultimate goal of the book? How does it propose we turn down
the heat? The book's aim is really to help
us strip away these unnecessary,distracting elements, to realign
our daily lives with what he calls the pace and promise of
(03:33):
childhood. The ultimate prize here, he
suggests, is finding moments of calm, what the author describes
as a form of deep sustenance. Deep sustenance.
Yeah, it's about creating these little islands of being in the
torrent of constant doing, just carving out space where children
can simply be rather than constantly doing.
That makes so much sense. It really brings us to this
(03:55):
powerful concept. The book introduces cumulative
stress response, or CSR. Can you explain what that is,
why it's so sort of central to understanding childhood
overwhelm? Absolutely.
Cumulative stress response, or CSR.
It isn't about one single major traumatic event.
Instead, it's the consistent, frequent accumulation of small,
(04:15):
seemingly minor stresses that just build up overtime.
The author shares this really profound insight from his
clinical work. He initially treated children in
like, war-torn areas for PTSD, and years later, he found
himself applying the exact same treatment plans to, you know,
typical children in affluent Western countries.
(04:35):
No way the same plans. The same plans.
The symptoms were a strikingly similar jumpiness,
hypervigilance, difficulty with new situations, anger outbursts,
sleep and food control issues. He realized these children were
suffering from what he calls an undeclared war on childhood,
where the speed and the fears ofadult life are just flooding
into their world unchecked. Wow, that's that's a pretty
(04:58):
heavy parallel comparing everyday kids to those in war
zones. That really reframes things and
it leads to the author's powerful formula.
Quirk plus stress equals disorder.
What does that mean for how we see our children?
It's such a profound lens. Imagine that wonderfully dreamy
child. You know, the one who loves to
get lost in nature. Perhaps a bit of a daydreamer.
Add cumulative stress into theirdaily life and suddenly they
(05:21):
might slide towards ADHD, specifically the inattentive
type, where they're kind of checking out as an escape,
struggling to focus not because of some fundamental flaw, but
really as a response to overload.
The book argues this sliding along the spectrum is actually
quite normal and reversible. Reversible.
Yeah, it's like when we as adults are preparing for a big
(05:43):
exam or a long trip are latent tendencies, whether it's
procrastination or anxiety, theyget amplified under stress,
right? The simplification process can
truly pull them back from that edge.
So it's not about pathologizing every challenge, but really
looking at the environment. Yeah, and it reminds me of how
our own immune systems work. Exactly.
Think of our immune system. We need exposure to some bugs
(06:05):
and viruses to build resilience.Similarly, children need what
the author calls necessary resistance, those normal
manageable stresses like a scraped knee or an an argument
with a friend or even, you know,a few days flat out with the
flu. These are opportunities to learn
coping skills. But, and this is the key part,
the book cautions that overprotecting them or being
(06:28):
harmony addicted. Harmony addicted, Yeah.
Always striving for that rainbowexperience every single day that
can actually push them further along the behavioral spectrum.
It leaves them vulnerable and less equipped to navigate
difficult situations when they inevitably arise and.
What role does parental anxiety play in all this?
Because honestly, it feels like the underlying hum for so many
(06:48):
of us. Parents.
Oh, definitely. The author notes that little
ones graze on our emotions. Graze.
Yeah, yeah. If we're nervous, if we're hyper
vigilant, they pick up on it. It creates the self perpetuating
cycle of anxiety. It reminds me of that powerful
quote from Ellen Goodman that the author keeps a patterned
copy of in his wallet. The central struggle of
parenthood is to let our hopes for our children outweigh our
(07:10):
fears. That's powerful.
And the book points to fascinating research the author
and his colleague Bonnie River did.
They looked at simplification asa drug free approach to ADD.
They found that simplifying children's lives led to
significant behavioral improvements.
It brought children out of amygdala hijack.
(07:31):
Right, that fight or flight thing.
Exactly that instant primitive brain response to perceived
threat that just bypasses rational thought.
And surprisingly, they saw a 36.8% increase in academic and
cognitive ability. That's a benefit not typically
seen with psychotropic drugs alone.
Wow, 36.8% that's huge. It is.
(07:52):
The book even compares medication to like scaffolding
for a building. It can help temporarily, but
it's not a long range substitutefor the fundamental work of
simplifying a child's daily lifeand environment.
OK, so we've talked about the problem and its impact.
Now for the solution. How does the book suggest we
actually start on this journey of simplification?
Because honestly, it sounds likea pretty big task.
(08:13):
Yeah, it can feel daunting, but it's important to remember that
the author doesn't propose A1 size fits all approach or like a
specific right order to do things.
It's truly about finding what's workable and sustainable for
your family. His advice is to start with what
is most doable rather than what seems most important, he says.
(08:34):
If you do enough that is doable,you will get to the important
and your motivation will be fueled by your success.
That makes sense. Small wins build momentum.
Exactly. Success in those small steps
really builds momentum for bigger transformations.
So it's not necessarily about, you know, backing up a dumpster
to the house and throwing everything out immediately.
Although that might feel good for some, right?
(08:56):
But the physical environment is often the most straightforward
place to begin. The book outlines this road map
with four layers of simplification.
Let's dive into that first layer, the immediate
surroundings. Exactly.
The physical environment is indeed a great starting point
because it's so tangible. You can see the difference right
away all. Right, let's talk toys.
The author has a very specific, and I'd say bold, suggestion for
(09:21):
decluttering. What's his radical approach to
the toy tsunami? OK, brace yourself, He suggests
gathering all of a child's toys,every single one, into a
mountain in the room. Then the first step, have it,
then have it again, and maybe even again, until you're left
with just a small fraction of the original pile.
(09:41):
He even jokes that parents mightstart to see him as a Scrooge
for this advice. I can imagine.
He talks about parents sometimeseagerly hunting down the plastic
exploding disasters or the ones that were talk gyrate or
detonate. Often those well-intentioned
gifts from grandparents or, you know, bachelor uncles.
Yes, those sounds intense, but what's the deep reasoning behind
(10:04):
such a drastic reduction? Is it just about tidiness, or is
there something more profound going on?
Oh, it's far more profound than just tidiness.
The book argues that too many choices, especially when it
comes to toys, mean children only know one emotional gesture
more. It also shines a light on pester
power. Did you know children directly
influence over $286 billion in family purchases annually?
(10:27):
$286 billion. That's staggering.
It is, and advertisers spend billions targeting kids
directly. The author asserts that messages
like Happiness Can be bought andYou Are the Center of the
Universe are the constant siren song kids receive from what he
calls the industry of play. The industry of play that really
makes you wonder are we buying toys truly to develop our
(10:50):
child's imagination, or is this industry of play subtly
manipulating us into just consuming more?
It's such a critical question. The book talks about how
creativity is effectively shifting from the child to toy
company boardrooms. The author references architect
Simon Nicholson's theory of loose parts, which is such a
powerful idea. Basically, the less a toy does,
(11:11):
the more it can become in a child's play.
OK. Like a simple block versus a
detailed character. Exactly.
Think of a simple rock that can be a mountain, a spaceship, or
cooking pot versus a highly detailed action figure that can
really only ever be that one specific thing.
The book also cautions against those fixed toys, like detailed
movie characters that really limit imaginative play, and also
(11:34):
multiples, like having three identical race cars that can
dilute a child's affection for the original and just create a
sense of overwhelming sameness. That makes so much sense.
I'm thinking of the story of Elise and Mikey in the book.
Their parents saw this play out first hand, didn't they?
Yes, it's a great example. Elise, a 5 year old, and Mikey,
her three-year old brother, wereconstantly fighting over this
(11:55):
huge pile of toys. Elise almost compulsively tried
to control the clutter by organizing and lining things up.
The organizer. And Mikey in his own 3 year old
way would just destroy her arrangements.
Classic sibling stuff, but amplified by the sheer volume.
Yeah, once the parents radicallydecluttered, reducing the toys
to maybe a 10th of what they had, the kids became unstuck.
(12:18):
Unstuck. I like that.
They started playing cooperatively, moving through
different developmental play stages like parallel play,
cooperative play, sociodramatic play.
It's just a vivid illustration of how external clutter can
directly manifest as internal chaos and relational conflict.
So, OK, once you've done the bigpurge, which sounds terrifying
but necessary, how does the booksuggest maintaining this
(12:42):
simplified environment right without becoming a total toy
hoarder again or a permanent Scrooge?
Right, maintenance is key. The author suggests a toy
library system. A toy library.
Yeah, essentially, for every newtoy that comes in, one goes into
storage or maybe gets passed on.He sees this not as being overly
picky, but as putting a finger in the dike against the
(13:03):
culture's incessant flood of stuff.
OK, the goal is to limit visual clutter.
Keep a small number of truly beloved toys visible and easily
accessible, while the rest are accessible but out of sight,
maybe in baskets or bins, ideally at the child's level so
they can actually help with cleanup.
And empowers them too. Exactly.
It's about cultivating appreciation for what they have
(13:24):
rather than constantly craving what's new.
It's not just about about toys though, is it?
The book extends this idea of environmental simplification to
our other senses, which I found really intriguing.
It does, and this is where it gets incredibly insightful, I
think. For instance, with smell, the
author explains how chemical scents like from air fresheners
(13:44):
or strong cleaners can activate the amygdala and stress hormones
in children. Really.
Just from smells, yeah. He advises simplifying
HomeSense, preferring natural ones.
He even shares the sweet anecdote of a child taking
Daddy's pillow to feel soothed simply because of its familiar
natural scent. And for sound, he points out how
softening reflective surfaces, think hard floors, big windows
(14:08):
with things like rugs and drapes, can significantly help
children, especially kids up to about age 8, who can find too
much bouncing noise incredibly confusing and overwhelming for
their auditory processing. OK, that's practical Rugs and
drapes. And then there's light.
The simple act of lighting a candle, maybe before bedtime or
dinner, can create what he callsa magical world.
(14:28):
It concentrates attention and provides the soothing golden
circle that really helps transition children maybe
towards sleep or a calmer meal time.
He also stresses the importance of children sleeping in natural
darkness. You know, gradually weaning them
off. Multiple Night Lights if
possible. That's a really holistic
approach to the environment. OK, shifting gears a bit, the
(14:49):
second layer of the book focuseson his rhythm.
How does establishing daily rhythms impact children, and US
parents for that matter? Well, the book offers what it
calls good news, bad news Here, the good news.
Establishing rhythm is one of the most powerful ways to
simplify children's lives. The bad news, or maybe it's also
(15:09):
good news, is that it will also profoundly simplify yours.
OK, I like the sound of that. It's about creating
predictability and transparency in daily life.
This brings a sense of security and order that children
internalize. It frees them up emotionally to
grow and explore and engage withthe world, rather than
constantly bracing for the next unknown thing.
I think many parents here with them and immediately think
(15:32):
perfect schedule which it just feels like an impossible
standard sometimes. Does the author suggest we need
this like full blown Symphony ofperfection every day?
Not at all. That's a relief, right?
He reassures us that we don't need a full scale Symphony of
perfection. Even small, consistent rituals
like brushing teeth every night in the same way or a specific
(15:52):
way you say goodbye in the morning, can establish what he
calls beach heads of calm. Beach heads of calm.
Nice. His advice is super practical.
Start small, stay close, insist and follow through, especially
when children are young as they're strong body clocks make
them naturally process oriented.It's about consistent presence,
not rigid adherence to a minute by minute schedule.
(16:15):
And he shares a great story about a boy named Justin whose
life was so unpredictable that he would just stay in his
pajamas all day. How did Rhythm help him?
Right. Justin's parents had these
hectic travel schedules which made his life incredibly
unpredictable. As a response, he'd often just
stay in his pajamas. It was almost as if not getting
dressed for the day was his way to, like, opt out of the chaos.
(16:37):
So his parents started previewing the next day with
him. And this wasn't some hurried
rundown of tasks, right? It was more like hangout time
where they'd visually map out what was coming.
They created a picture for him to sort of live into.
This simple act conveyed there is no hidden agenda here.
It helped establish the parents as the captain of the ship,
(16:57):
which is immensely comforting for a child who feels adrift on
a large ocean. It provides the clarity kids
desperately need, even if they aren't technically in control of
their day. I love that captain of the Ship
analogy. It truly sounds like a way to
build trust and connection. And the book calls these
predictable moments relational credits.
What's the thinking behind that?It's a beautiful concept,
(17:19):
really. Think of music.
The pauses, the silence between the notes are absolutely
critical for the melody to make sense.
Right? Yeah.
Yeah. Similarly, the book argues that
relationships are often built inthe intervals, those quiet
moments of pause when nothing much is going on.
It's like the old shoe phenomenon.
By being consistently present and predictable, by just showing
(17:41):
up in these small, unassuming ways, you become a parent.
Kids can just be with. Comfortable.
Yeah, comfortable. That deep, comfortable presence
is what makes them feel safe enough to open up later on.
This builds a well worn groove of connection that truly pays
dividends, especially during those tumultuous adolescent
years like Lily confiding in herdad and his woodworking
(18:02):
workshop. Sawdust optional, of course.
Love it. The author emphasizes you don't
need some special sacred space to connect, just consistent time
and attention are enough. That makes so much sense.
It's about the underlying consistency, not grand gestures.
And Speaking of consistency, family dinners come up quite a
bit in the book. Why do they matter so much?
Oh, family dinners are indeed a cornerstone.
(18:25):
Studies dating back to the 1980shave consistently shown that
families who eat together more often have kids to, oh, do
better in school. They eat healthier, they build
stronger vocabularies, and they're less likely to smoke,
drink, do drugs or suffer from depression.
That's a lot of benefits. It really is, and the book says
it's the process, not the particulars.
(18:45):
Even if the meal isn't gourmet, even if there's some
good-natured bickering, the consistent coming together is
what truly matters. It's more than just a meal.
It's a shared experience, an exchange of conversation and
attention that offers like exponential nourishment.
That's a really compelling case for keeping meal time a priority
even when life gets crazy. So applying the less is more
(19:07):
principle to food itself. What does the author suggest for
simplifying food choices becausegrocery stores are overwhelming?
He suggests exactly that, extending the less is more
principle to food instead of facing that choice overload at
the grocery store, which he vividly compares to an airport
hangar of options. Simplifying means consciously
reducing those big hit processedfoods and embracing
(19:30):
predictability. OK, predictability how?
He proposes themed dinner nightswhere the question what's for
dinner is answered simply by That's easy, what day of the
week is it? Like Taco Tuesday?
Exactly. This not only simplifies
preparation for parents, but also deeply grounds and affirms
kids. They know what to expect.
And it's also important, he notes, to involve kids in food
(19:52):
preparation, even if it's just something simple like giving
peas a bath, which apparently just means washing them.
Giving peas a bath. It builds A ramp to the meal, he
says, and often avoids those classic meal time battles.
And for picky eaters, or for introducing new foods, are there
any practical tips the book offers?
Yeah, because that's a struggle for many.
Yes, he offers a very practical tip.
(20:13):
Offer a new food at least eight times. 8 times OK.
You can even gradually decrease salt or other strong flavorings
over those exposures if needed, he says.
This almost guarantees acceptance.
The idea is to start with a verysmall quantity and just offer it
repeatedly, maybe alongside A preferred food.
This gradual, consistent processhelps children expand their
(20:36):
palates and avoid getting stuck in that red and white food alley
of limited choices. The red and white food alley.
I know it well. OK, all these rhythms contribute
to overall well-being, and one of the most fundamental rhythms
is sleep. The book really hammers home its
importance. It calls sleep the ultimate
rhythm, and for good reason. It emphasizes that without
(20:56):
enough sleep, children's performance can drop
significantly. Get this 1/6 grader sleeping one
hour less can learn and behave at a fourth grade level.
Wow, one hour makes that much difference.
Apparently so. The book notes that most
children between 2:00 and 6:00 need about 11 hours of sleep
from 6:00 to 11:10 hours, and itoften increases again to 11 or
(21:18):
12 during adolescence. These are numbers most kids
sadly don't even get close to intoday's hurried world.
That's quite startling. So if sleep is that crucial, how
do we help kids actually wind down in a world that feels like
it's always rubbing up right? The book introduces the concept
of pressure valves throughout the day.
Pressure valves. Yeah, these are intentional
moments to release emotional steam.
(21:39):
Basically, for a boy named Henry, it was his mom's grit
sandwich ritual before bed. A grit sandwich?
What's that? She'd ask him about a courageous
thing he did that day and the hardest thing about his day.
Then they talk about the hardestthing and the best thing
anticipated for tomorrow. Oh, I like that.
The simple ritual helped Henry unpack his day, processing his
(22:00):
thoughts and feelings in the comforting, attentive light of
his mom's presence. That's a lovely, simple ritual.
What other kinds of pressure vowels does the book suggest we
can integrate into our children's days?
Well, other pressure valves could be just a quiet rest time,
even if they don't nap, or a period for working on an ongoing
creative project, or even that simple moment of lighting a
(22:22):
candle before dinner, which the author's family practices.
He says it creates a magical world for small children that
instantly concentrates their attention and brings a soothing
calm. The book also highlights the
profound importance of stories, especially fairy tales, for
helping children process their day, learn about the world and
build empathy. And he notes that repetition and
(22:44):
storytelling, like reading Curious George for the 100th
time or telling cherished familyanecdotes over and over,
actually deepens the experience and connection for a child.
It makes the story truly their own.
OK, so far we've covered simplifying the environment and
establishing rhythm. That brings us to the third
layer schedules and really seemslike our kids schedules are just
(23:06):
busier than ever these days. They absolutely are.
You know, the Roman poet Ovid once said, take rest.
A field that has rested gives a bountiful crop.
But in today's world, are we as parents kind of overcropping our
children's lives? The book delves into what it
calls the hurried child phenomenon.
It points out that since the 1980s, children have lost as
(23:26):
much as 12 hours of free time a week. 12 hours a week.
That's staggering. It is, and structured activities
and homework have basically doubled in that same time.
It's a truly significant shift in just one generation.
Wow, the author uses a great analogy for all this enrichment
we pile on, doesn't he? He does.
He compares enrichment to fertilizer being applied by the
(23:47):
ton to childhood. Fertilizer by the by the time.
Yeah, and while parents undeniably have good intentions,
the book argues that too many scheduled activities may limit a
child's ability to direct themselves to fill their own
time to find and follow their own path.
It's not about blaming parents really, but recognizing this
broader societal trend where childhood and parenting have
(24:09):
become like things to be constantly improved and made
productive, often at the expenseof that unstructured, unhurried
time needed for genuine play andself discovery.
That brings to mind the idea of balancing arousing and calming
activities. The author shares a wonderful
example with Emily and her mom, Sarah.
Can you remind us of that? Yes, Emily would often just
meltdown during busy family holidays or really intense
(24:31):
events. Her mom Sarah learned to
consciously build in C days. Calming days after A days,
arousing days. A and C days, OK.
So after a big party, maybe the next day would be a quiet bike
ride, or a walk in the park, or just an afternoon reading at
home. This conscious effort to
rebalance Emily's schedule completely restored her
equilibrium and her sense of control.
(24:52):
It's a very practical framework for looking at your family's
week. And Emery's dad takes that
concept to a slightly humorous extreme, doesn't he?
He does. It's quite funny.
After seeing how well the ANC day system worked for Emily, her
dad Frankie decided to go to a national monster truck rally by
himself. Seriously.
Yeah. He realized he couldn't possibly
(25:14):
schedule enough C days for Emilyto balance out the intensity of
a AAA day like a monster truck rally.
A AAA day. It humorously underscores just
how intense some of these arousing experiences can be for
children, and how much deep restand replenishment they truly
need to process and recover. The book also touches on how our
on demand culture, you know, wanting everything faster right
(25:35):
now, is robbing our children of something quite precious.
What is that? It argues that this constant
need for instant gratification steals the gift of anticipation
from our children. The gift of anticipation.
Yeah, that profound yearning forsummer or a birthday, literally
counting down the days that builds genuine will and
identity. The author calls it more bang
(25:57):
for the buck because the anticipation itself becomes part
of the richness of the experience.
When everything is instantly available, children lose that
developmental power that grows through waiting and the rich
layers of meaning that anticipation adds to an
experience. And this leads the author to
explore the seeds of addiction. That's a strong claim, isn't it,
(26:18):
That an over scheduled life can actually sow those seeds?
It is a strong claim, but one inthe book supports quite
thoughtfully. It defines addiction broadly as
an increasing and compulsive tendency to avoid pain or
boredom and replace inner development with outer
stimulation. An over scheduled life,
constantly seeking the next activity or external thrill can
absolutely sow these seeds. It creates a reliance on outer
(26:42):
stimulation and instant gratification.
It effectively mutes a child's internal feelings and makes them
lose the ability to regulate their own time or even just
entertain themselves. It creates this constant chase
for the next peak experience, making ordinary quiet moments
feel flat and unfulfilling. And what about youth sports?
Because for many families, that's a huge part of their
(27:04):
children's schedules. The book isn't completely
against them, but it has some important caveats, right?
Absolutely. The author isn't against sports
at all, but he cautions against too much and far too young.
That much too young? Exactly.
He argues that organized sports,particularly the really
competitive ones, can impose toomuch structure on young
children. This can hinder their progress
(27:24):
through vital developmental playstages.
Free play, where kids make the play up as they go along, where
they invent rules and rules thatfosters problem solving,
flexibility, and emotional intelligence in a way that fixed
rules and predetermined positions often don't.
So free play is crucial. He sees it as a developmental
necessity. It allows children to negotiate
(27:46):
rules, adapt to changing situations and create their own
roles based on their needs rather than being confined by an
adult driven agenda. OK, we've talked about the
physical environment, establishing rhythm, and
managing schedules. The final layer of
simplification, and arguably oneof the most challenging, is
filtering out the adult world. What exactly does the book mean
(28:06):
by that? This final layer is truly about
protecting the sanctity of childhood, creating a safe,
contained bubble, if you will, for children.
The author recounts the story ofa mother, Anne Marie, who's
defining emotion as a parent wasjust worry.
I think many parents can relate.Absolutely.
And while worry is integral to parenting, it shouldn't define
(28:27):
it because an emotional diet high in fear and sensationalism
can be transmitted to our children.
Parents often absorb this pervasive fear from media,
which, as the book points out, is incredibly end up at
exploiting our primal urge to protect our children.
And central to filtering out theadult world is the books analogy
of Uncle Andy, the television. It's a pretty blunt assessment,
(28:48):
isn't it, Uncle Andy? It is.
It's memorable. Though the author suggests that
simplifying screens, TV, computers, video games is one of
the most critical and rewarding steps parents can take, he
doesn't mince words. He calls television a direct
counterforce to simplifying an altar of commercialism and your
home's most efficient conduit ofclutter.
(29:10):
Most efficient conduit of clutter?
The Uncle Andy analogy vividly paints TV as this houseguest.
Who? Yeah, entertains, but also over
stimulates, brings in unwanted consumer messages, and
fundamentally disrupts family connection.
The book asserts that TV can easily just suck up any free
unstructured time you might gainfrom simplifying schedules
(29:31):
elsewhere. So beyond the commercialism and
the time suck, what's the actualimpact of screens on young
brains, according to the book and the research it cites?
The author cites studies that are quite stark, actually.
Television, for instance, provides none of the three
critical forms of interaction needed for optimal brain
development in babies. What are they?
Meaningful interaction with humans, direct manipulation of
(29:51):
their physical environment, and engaging in active problem
solving. TV offers none of that.
He notes that even seemingly educational programming like
Sesame Street very young children.
Even Sesame Street, Yeah. In fact, France has banned TV
shows specifically for children under 3, highlighting the severe
risks recognized by other nations.
(30:12):
And the effect on older kids is not just about language delays
is. It no, it goes deeper.
The book describes children becoming almost hypnotized by TV
with diminished mental activity.EEG studies show viewers are in
this relaxed and passive state while watching, and those
feelings can persist even after the TV is off, leaving them
feeling kind of depleted. It also warns about the
(30:34):
orienting reflex in programming.That's basically our brains
automatic pay attention, response to sudden changes, loud
noises, quick cuts. TV exploits this constantly.
It keeps you hooked. Exactly.
It conditions brains to expect constant hyperstimulation,
leading to boredom and inattentiveness in real life
when things aren't changing every few seconds, and violence
(30:55):
on screens that can desensitize children, particularly those
under six or seven who can't easily differentiate reality
from fantasy. It can even equate violence with
pleasure or excitement. The book also cautions against
early computer use, noting that kids who start later tend to
catch up very quickly anyway. And it raises the really
important question of whether exposing young children to
(31:17):
artificial minds without human values is truly beneficial for
their developing worldview. That's a powerful case against
excessive screen time. And this leads us to another
related idea, talking less. That seems almost
counterintuitive in an age wherewe're constantly told to
communicate more with our kids. It can feel that way, can it?
But the author shares this brilliant analogy from the
(31:37):
Little House on the Prairie books.
He asks why did Laura and Mary do what Pennsylvania said and
the short answer is this. Pennsylvania didn't say too
much. He argues that when we talk over
and around children constantly, when we over explain and
predigest every single experience for them, we
unintentionally stifle their innate curiosity and creativity.
(31:59):
We robbed them of the space to figure things out for
themselves. So how do we know when to speak
and when to just be silent? The book offers a practical
filter, doesn't. It it does, and it's 1, I think
many adults, myself included, could benefit from using more
often. Use three filters before
speaking. Is it true?
Is it kind? Is it?
Necessary kind necessary. OK.
(32:21):
The necessary filter is the key one here, the verbal clutter
filter. It really asks if what you're
about to say is truly more important than silence.
This gives children crucial space for their own thoughts and
feelings to develop, and for their own inner voice to
actually be heard. It's about letting children
process their own experiences rather than filling every moment
with adult commentary or instruction.
(32:41):
And part of that verbal clutter includes adult topics.
What does the book suggest? We filter there 'cause it's easy
to just chat about work stress or the news with kids around.
Right. This is about filtering out that
verbal and emotional clutter that kind of rushes them along
into premature adulthood. The book recalls that comforting
memory many of us have as children, being in the backseat
(33:02):
of the car, parents talking quietly in the front.
It conveys this profound sense of security and competence, even
if you don't understand the words.
Yeah, I remember that feeling. We project optimism and
capability to our children by talking less about things they
can't understand or affect, likecomplex financial worries or
political anxieties. The story of Sam, the little boy
(33:23):
who picked up his cynical dad's derision for the president,
illustrates so clearly how children absorb emotions and
actions much more deeply than words.
They often internalize adult anxieties without the context or
reasoning. So it's not just about what we
say, but also what we model and what emotional tone we set.
This also touches on parental involvement, where the book
notes an imbalance can often occur between parents.
(33:46):
Indeed, the book points out thatoften when one parent is over
involved, and frequently, thoughnot always, this is mother's,
especially regarding general social adjustment, the other
parent might be under involved. This creates an imbalance in the
parenting dynamic where worry can unfortunately over shadow
joy for the entire family. It's not meant as a criticism,
(34:06):
just an observation of a common pattern.
What are some practical steps the author advises to maybe
rebalance this involvement? He advises very practical steps,
like fathers for example, takingexclusive responsibility for
certain daily tasks, maybe be packing lunch every day or
always handling bath time. This moves them from merely
helping to truly doing. It establishes them as
(34:27):
consistent anchors for the children.
Right. Not just helper, but doer.
Exactly, and in turn, this allows the other parent, often
the mother in his examples, to loosen her grip a bit and
experience more ease and trust in the shared parenting.
Karla's story in the book reallydrives this point home.
Carla, this little girl who previously insisted on very
(34:48):
specific foods and routines, became noticeably less anxious
and controlling when her parentsprovided clear, consistent
direction and truly took charge.Together, it effectively allowed
her to hop back into the passenger seat of her own
childhood, trusting them to drive.
Back into the passenger seat. I like that.
And finally, the book cautions against less emotional
(35:08):
monitoring. That means constantly taking a
child's emotional temperature. Yeah, why is that potentially a
problem? It's another subtle way we can
inadvertently rush them. Young children's feelings are
often quite unconscious, constantly dissecting them,
asking how do you feel about that can feel invasive.
It can push them into what the author calls premature
adolescents. Instead, the book suggests
(35:30):
trusting your instincts as a parent, listening when they lead
the conversation about feelings,and understanding that young
children often put it right by doing.
Put it right by doing. Yeah, they need physical
engagement and activity to process emotions rather than
solely verbalizing them like adults might.
For instance, a child might express their fear or excitement
by singing about it loudly whileriding their bike back and forth
(35:52):
on the driveway, rather than sitting down and articulating
complex feelings and words. Giving them that space to
process physically without consonant verbal interrogation
is really key. So to bring it all together,
then, this deep dive into simplicity, parenting has truly
given us, I think, a powerful new lens through which to view
our often very busy family lives.
(36:15):
It's really about creating moments of stillness in a pretty
frantic world, about letting go of that constant pressure to
always do more, faster, earlier.It's such a profound shift in
perspective, isn't it? It's about remembering that deep
sustenance comes from those moments of calm, that
relationships are built in the pauses in the intervals, and
that a child's imagination trulythrives when it's not
(36:37):
overwhelmed by constant, manufactured stimulation.
It's about cultivating that reverence for childhood.
The author speaks of understanding that childhood is
this unique, unfolding ecology with its own pace and natural
systems that need to be protected and nurtured, not
constantly pushed or overstimulated.
What's so powerful here, I think, is that simplification
(36:58):
isn't just about taking things away.
It's ultimately about making room.
Room for your child's true self to emerge, room for your
family's authentic connections, and just room for a deeper, more
present kind of love. It's about creating an
environment where children can truly be themselves, rather than
constantly performing or consuming.
And that prompts an important question for you, our listener.
(37:18):
Given everything we've discussedtoday about the hidden stresses
of modern childhood and the power of simplicity, what's
maybe one small, doable step youmight take this week to simplify
your family's life just a littlebit and invite more of that calm
and connection? Perhaps it's clearing one small
space, creating one new dinner ritual, or consciously choosing
silence over just a few extra words.
(37:40):
The profound impact often beginswith the smallest, most
consistent choice.
Welcome to the Summary State podcast.
Today we're embarking on a deep dive into simplicity parenting
by Kim Jong Payne and Lisa M Ross.
Our mission is to really unpack the core idea that when it comes
to raising well adjusted, joyfulchildren, especially in a world
that just seems to demand more, faster, earlier, all the time,
(00:21):
well, maybe less is actually profoundly more.
It really is. It's a topic that I think
resonates deeply with so many parents, you know, just trying
to navigate that daily deluge ofchoices and commitments, just
sheer stuff. The book offers such a powerful
counter narrative. It suggests that some of the
very things we believe are like giving our children an advantage
might actually be contributing to their overwhelming stress.
(00:44):
So we'll explore how actively choosing simplicity can really
restore a sense of calm and well-being.
And not just for our kids, but for us as parents too.
OK, so to kick us off, they alsouses this really striking image.
It's the boiling frog analogy, and you're the one.
If you drop a frog into boiling water, boom, it jumps right out.
Right instant. But if you put it in cold water
and slowly heat it up, yeah, well, it just stays put, kind of
(01:07):
oblivious until it's too late. It's a It's a pretty unsettling
thought, isn't it, it? Really is that we could be so
immersed in our environment, we don't even perceive how
drastically it's changing aroundus.
And this is where the author makes such a compelling point.
Applying that that chilling analogy directly to our modern
families, he suggests we're living in an environment that's
(01:27):
become, well, increasingly inhospitable, especially for
children. But these shifts are so gradual,
you know, so incremental, that we might not even notice the
water heating up until our kids are already feeling overwhelmed.
Right. It's not like one big crisis.
Exactly. It's the accumulation of all
those small, seemingly harmless additions, the extra activities
(01:48):
and new gadgets, the endless information streams that just
slowly raise the temperature. So if we're the frogs here, what
exactly is heating up our water?What's driving this relentless
push for more? Well, the book points to two
major culprits. Too much stuff and too many
choices. Just think about it.
Advertising constantly bombards us with the message that more
(02:09):
equals happiness, right? But, the author smartly
observes, anyone who's ever tried to pick a cellular plan
knows too many choices can be overwhelming.
Oh. Tell me about it.
Yeah. It drains our time, it saps our
motivation, and it really diminishes our sense of
well-being. It's like that.
That colossal aisle of breakfastcereals at the grocery store.
(02:32):
Yes, what should be a simple decision becomes this like minor
existential crisis every morning.
Totally. And what's the underlying
emotional current behind all of this more faster mentality?
Yeah. Is it really about benefiting
our children or is there something else going on?
The author makes a strong case that it's often anxiety.
We find ourselves rushing from one enrichment opportunity to
(02:52):
the next, desperate to give our children every advantage now
known or soon to be invented. But much of this, the book
argues, stems from fear rather than a genuine reverence for
childhood. Reverence for childhood.
I like that. Phrase.
Yeah. That reverence, in his view,
would lead to a slower, more intentional approach.
You know, allowing things to unfold naturally instead of
(03:13):
trying to force them or like over engineer every single step.
So if we are indeed in this slowly boiling pot, what's the
ultimate goal of the book? How does it propose we turn down
the heat? The book's aim is really to help
us strip away these unnecessary,distracting elements, to realign
our daily lives with what he calls the pace and promise of
(03:33):
childhood. The ultimate prize here, he
suggests, is finding moments of calm, what the author describes
as a form of deep sustenance. Deep sustenance.
Yeah, it's about creating these little islands of being in the
torrent of constant doing, just carving out space where children
can simply be rather than constantly doing.
That makes so much sense. It really brings us to this
(03:55):
powerful concept. The book introduces cumulative
stress response, or CSR. Can you explain what that is,
why it's so sort of central to understanding childhood
overwhelm? Absolutely.
Cumulative stress response, or CSR.
It isn't about one single major traumatic event.
Instead, it's the consistent, frequent accumulation of small,
(04:15):
seemingly minor stresses that just build up overtime.
The author shares this really profound insight from his
clinical work. He initially treated children in
like, war-torn areas for PTSD, and years later, he found
himself applying the exact same treatment plans to, you know,
typical children in affluent Western countries.
(04:35):
No way the same plans. The same plans.
The symptoms were a strikingly similar jumpiness,
hypervigilance, difficulty with new situations, anger outbursts,
sleep and food control issues. He realized these children were
suffering from what he calls an undeclared war on childhood,
where the speed and the fears ofadult life are just flooding
into their world unchecked. Wow, that's that's a pretty
(04:58):
heavy parallel comparing everyday kids to those in war
zones. That really reframes things and
it leads to the author's powerful formula.
Quirk plus stress equals disorder.
What does that mean for how we see our children?
It's such a profound lens. Imagine that wonderfully dreamy
child. You know, the one who loves to
get lost in nature. Perhaps a bit of a daydreamer.
Add cumulative stress into theirdaily life and suddenly they
(05:21):
might slide towards ADHD, specifically the inattentive
type, where they're kind of checking out as an escape,
struggling to focus not because of some fundamental flaw, but
really as a response to overload.
The book argues this sliding along the spectrum is actually
quite normal and reversible. Reversible.
Yeah, it's like when we as adults are preparing for a big
(05:43):
exam or a long trip are latent tendencies, whether it's
procrastination or anxiety, theyget amplified under stress,
right? The simplification process can
truly pull them back from that edge.
So it's not about pathologizing every challenge, but really
looking at the environment. Yeah, and it reminds me of how
our own immune systems work. Exactly.
Think of our immune system. We need exposure to some bugs
(06:05):
and viruses to build resilience.Similarly, children need what
the author calls necessary resistance, those normal
manageable stresses like a scraped knee or an an argument
with a friend or even, you know,a few days flat out with the
flu. These are opportunities to learn
coping skills. But, and this is the key part,
the book cautions that overprotecting them or being
(06:28):
harmony addicted. Harmony addicted, Yeah.
Always striving for that rainbowexperience every single day that
can actually push them further along the behavioral spectrum.
It leaves them vulnerable and less equipped to navigate
difficult situations when they inevitably arise and.
What role does parental anxiety play in all this?
Because honestly, it feels like the underlying hum for so many
(06:48):
of us. Parents.
Oh, definitely. The author notes that little
ones graze on our emotions. Graze.
Yeah, yeah. If we're nervous, if we're hyper
vigilant, they pick up on it. It creates the self perpetuating
cycle of anxiety. It reminds me of that powerful
quote from Ellen Goodman that the author keeps a patterned
copy of in his wallet. The central struggle of
parenthood is to let our hopes for our children outweigh our
(07:10):
fears. That's powerful.
And the book points to fascinating research the author
and his colleague Bonnie River did.
They looked at simplification asa drug free approach to ADD.
They found that simplifying children's lives led to
significant behavioral improvements.
It brought children out of amygdala hijack.
(07:31):
Right, that fight or flight thing.
Exactly that instant primitive brain response to perceived
threat that just bypasses rational thought.
And surprisingly, they saw a 36.8% increase in academic and
cognitive ability. That's a benefit not typically
seen with psychotropic drugs alone.
Wow, 36.8% that's huge. It is.
(07:52):
The book even compares medication to like scaffolding
for a building. It can help temporarily, but
it's not a long range substitutefor the fundamental work of
simplifying a child's daily lifeand environment.
OK, so we've talked about the problem and its impact.
Now for the solution. How does the book suggest we
actually start on this journey of simplification?
Because honestly, it sounds likea pretty big task.
(08:13):
Yeah, it can feel daunting, but it's important to remember that
the author doesn't propose A1 size fits all approach or like a
specific right order to do things.
It's truly about finding what's workable and sustainable for
your family. His advice is to start with what
is most doable rather than what seems most important, he says.
(08:34):
If you do enough that is doable,you will get to the important
and your motivation will be fueled by your success.
That makes sense. Small wins build momentum.
Exactly. Success in those small steps
really builds momentum for bigger transformations.
So it's not necessarily about, you know, backing up a dumpster
to the house and throwing everything out immediately.
Although that might feel good for some, right?
(08:56):
But the physical environment is often the most straightforward
place to begin. The book outlines this road map
with four layers of simplification.
Let's dive into that first layer, the immediate
surroundings. Exactly.
The physical environment is indeed a great starting point
because it's so tangible. You can see the difference right
away all. Right, let's talk toys.
The author has a very specific, and I'd say bold, suggestion for
(09:21):
decluttering. What's his radical approach to
the toy tsunami? OK, brace yourself, He suggests
gathering all of a child's toys,every single one, into a
mountain in the room. Then the first step, have it,
then have it again, and maybe even again, until you're left
with just a small fraction of the original pile.
(09:41):
He even jokes that parents mightstart to see him as a Scrooge
for this advice. I can imagine.
He talks about parents sometimeseagerly hunting down the plastic
exploding disasters or the ones that were talk gyrate or
detonate. Often those well-intentioned
gifts from grandparents or, you know, bachelor uncles.
Yes, those sounds intense, but what's the deep reasoning behind
(10:04):
such a drastic reduction? Is it just about tidiness, or is
there something more profound going on?
Oh, it's far more profound than just tidiness.
The book argues that too many choices, especially when it
comes to toys, mean children only know one emotional gesture
more. It also shines a light on pester
power. Did you know children directly
influence over $286 billion in family purchases annually?
(10:27):
$286 billion. That's staggering.
It is, and advertisers spend billions targeting kids
directly. The author asserts that messages
like Happiness Can be bought andYou Are the Center of the
Universe are the constant siren song kids receive from what he
calls the industry of play. The industry of play that really
makes you wonder are we buying toys truly to develop our
(10:50):
child's imagination, or is this industry of play subtly
manipulating us into just consuming more?
It's such a critical question. The book talks about how
creativity is effectively shifting from the child to toy
company boardrooms. The author references architect
Simon Nicholson's theory of loose parts, which is such a
powerful idea. Basically, the less a toy does,
(11:11):
the more it can become in a child's play.
OK. Like a simple block versus a
detailed character. Exactly.
Think of a simple rock that can be a mountain, a spaceship, or
cooking pot versus a highly detailed action figure that can
really only ever be that one specific thing.
The book also cautions against those fixed toys, like detailed
movie characters that really limit imaginative play, and also
(11:34):
multiples, like having three identical race cars that can
dilute a child's affection for the original and just create a
sense of overwhelming sameness. That makes so much sense.
I'm thinking of the story of Elise and Mikey in the book.
Their parents saw this play out first hand, didn't they?
Yes, it's a great example. Elise, a 5 year old, and Mikey,
her three-year old brother, wereconstantly fighting over this
(11:55):
huge pile of toys. Elise almost compulsively tried
to control the clutter by organizing and lining things up.
The organizer. And Mikey in his own 3 year old
way would just destroy her arrangements.
Classic sibling stuff, but amplified by the sheer volume.
Yeah, once the parents radicallydecluttered, reducing the toys
to maybe a 10th of what they had, the kids became unstuck.
(12:18):
Unstuck. I like that.
They started playing cooperatively, moving through
different developmental play stages like parallel play,
cooperative play, sociodramatic play.
It's just a vivid illustration of how external clutter can
directly manifest as internal chaos and relational conflict.
So, OK, once you've done the bigpurge, which sounds terrifying
but necessary, how does the booksuggest maintaining this
(12:42):
simplified environment right without becoming a total toy
hoarder again or a permanent Scrooge?
Right, maintenance is key. The author suggests a toy
library system. A toy library.
Yeah, essentially, for every newtoy that comes in, one goes into
storage or maybe gets passed on.He sees this not as being overly
picky, but as putting a finger in the dike against the
(13:03):
culture's incessant flood of stuff.
OK, the goal is to limit visual clutter.
Keep a small number of truly beloved toys visible and easily
accessible, while the rest are accessible but out of sight,
maybe in baskets or bins, ideally at the child's level so
they can actually help with cleanup.
And empowers them too. Exactly.
It's about cultivating appreciation for what they have
(13:24):
rather than constantly craving what's new.
It's not just about about toys though, is it?
The book extends this idea of environmental simplification to
our other senses, which I found really intriguing.
It does, and this is where it gets incredibly insightful, I
think. For instance, with smell, the
author explains how chemical scents like from air fresheners
(13:44):
or strong cleaners can activate the amygdala and stress hormones
in children. Really.
Just from smells, yeah. He advises simplifying
HomeSense, preferring natural ones.
He even shares the sweet anecdote of a child taking
Daddy's pillow to feel soothed simply because of its familiar
natural scent. And for sound, he points out how
softening reflective surfaces, think hard floors, big windows
(14:08):
with things like rugs and drapes, can significantly help
children, especially kids up to about age 8, who can find too
much bouncing noise incredibly confusing and overwhelming for
their auditory processing. OK, that's practical Rugs and
drapes. And then there's light.
The simple act of lighting a candle, maybe before bedtime or
dinner, can create what he callsa magical world.
(14:28):
It concentrates attention and provides the soothing golden
circle that really helps transition children maybe
towards sleep or a calmer meal time.
He also stresses the importance of children sleeping in natural
darkness. You know, gradually weaning them
off. Multiple Night Lights if
possible. That's a really holistic
approach to the environment. OK, shifting gears a bit, the
(14:49):
second layer of the book focuseson his rhythm.
How does establishing daily rhythms impact children, and US
parents for that matter? Well, the book offers what it
calls good news, bad news Here, the good news.
Establishing rhythm is one of the most powerful ways to
simplify children's lives. The bad news, or maybe it's also
(15:09):
good news, is that it will also profoundly simplify yours.
OK, I like the sound of that. It's about creating
predictability and transparency in daily life.
This brings a sense of security and order that children
internalize. It frees them up emotionally to
grow and explore and engage withthe world, rather than
constantly bracing for the next unknown thing.
I think many parents here with them and immediately think
(15:32):
perfect schedule which it just feels like an impossible
standard sometimes. Does the author suggest we need
this like full blown Symphony ofperfection every day?
Not at all. That's a relief, right?
He reassures us that we don't need a full scale Symphony of
perfection. Even small, consistent rituals
like brushing teeth every night in the same way or a specific
(15:52):
way you say goodbye in the morning, can establish what he
calls beach heads of calm. Beach heads of calm.
Nice. His advice is super practical.
Start small, stay close, insist and follow through, especially
when children are young as they're strong body clocks make
them naturally process oriented.It's about consistent presence,
not rigid adherence to a minute by minute schedule.
(16:15):
And he shares a great story about a boy named Justin whose
life was so unpredictable that he would just stay in his
pajamas all day. How did Rhythm help him?
Right. Justin's parents had these
hectic travel schedules which made his life incredibly
unpredictable. As a response, he'd often just
stay in his pajamas. It was almost as if not getting
dressed for the day was his way to, like, opt out of the chaos.
(16:37):
So his parents started previewing the next day with
him. And this wasn't some hurried
rundown of tasks, right? It was more like hangout time
where they'd visually map out what was coming.
They created a picture for him to sort of live into.
This simple act conveyed there is no hidden agenda here.
It helped establish the parents as the captain of the ship,
(16:57):
which is immensely comforting for a child who feels adrift on
a large ocean. It provides the clarity kids
desperately need, even if they aren't technically in control of
their day. I love that captain of the Ship
analogy. It truly sounds like a way to
build trust and connection. And the book calls these
predictable moments relational credits.
What's the thinking behind that?It's a beautiful concept,
(17:19):
really. Think of music.
The pauses, the silence between the notes are absolutely
critical for the melody to make sense.
Right? Yeah.
Yeah. Similarly, the book argues that
relationships are often built inthe intervals, those quiet
moments of pause when nothing much is going on.
It's like the old shoe phenomenon.
By being consistently present and predictable, by just showing
(17:41):
up in these small, unassuming ways, you become a parent.
Kids can just be with. Comfortable.
Yeah, comfortable. That deep, comfortable presence
is what makes them feel safe enough to open up later on.
This builds a well worn groove of connection that truly pays
dividends, especially during those tumultuous adolescent
years like Lily confiding in herdad and his woodworking
(18:02):
workshop. Sawdust optional, of course.
Love it. The author emphasizes you don't
need some special sacred space to connect, just consistent time
and attention are enough. That makes so much sense.
It's about the underlying consistency, not grand gestures.
And Speaking of consistency, family dinners come up quite a
bit in the book. Why do they matter so much?
Oh, family dinners are indeed a cornerstone.
(18:25):
Studies dating back to the 1980shave consistently shown that
families who eat together more often have kids to, oh, do
better in school. They eat healthier, they build
stronger vocabularies, and they're less likely to smoke,
drink, do drugs or suffer from depression.
That's a lot of benefits. It really is, and the book says
it's the process, not the particulars.
(18:45):
Even if the meal isn't gourmet, even if there's some
good-natured bickering, the consistent coming together is
what truly matters. It's more than just a meal.
It's a shared experience, an exchange of conversation and
attention that offers like exponential nourishment.
That's a really compelling case for keeping meal time a priority
even when life gets crazy. So applying the less is more
(19:07):
principle to food itself. What does the author suggest for
simplifying food choices becausegrocery stores are overwhelming?
He suggests exactly that, extending the less is more
principle to food instead of facing that choice overload at
the grocery store, which he vividly compares to an airport
hangar of options. Simplifying means consciously
reducing those big hit processedfoods and embracing
(19:30):
predictability. OK, predictability how?
He proposes themed dinner nightswhere the question what's for
dinner is answered simply by That's easy, what day of the
week is it? Like Taco Tuesday?
Exactly. This not only simplifies
preparation for parents, but also deeply grounds and affirms
kids. They know what to expect.
And it's also important, he notes, to involve kids in food
(19:52):
preparation, even if it's just something simple like giving
peas a bath, which apparently just means washing them.
Giving peas a bath. It builds A ramp to the meal, he
says, and often avoids those classic meal time battles.
And for picky eaters, or for introducing new foods, are there
any practical tips the book offers?
Yeah, because that's a struggle for many.
Yes, he offers a very practical tip.
(20:13):
Offer a new food at least eight times. 8 times OK.
You can even gradually decrease salt or other strong flavorings
over those exposures if needed, he says.
This almost guarantees acceptance.
The idea is to start with a verysmall quantity and just offer it
repeatedly, maybe alongside A preferred food.
This gradual, consistent processhelps children expand their
(20:36):
palates and avoid getting stuck in that red and white food alley
of limited choices. The red and white food alley.
I know it well. OK, all these rhythms contribute
to overall well-being, and one of the most fundamental rhythms
is sleep. The book really hammers home its
importance. It calls sleep the ultimate
rhythm, and for good reason. It emphasizes that without
(20:56):
enough sleep, children's performance can drop
significantly. Get this 1/6 grader sleeping one
hour less can learn and behave at a fourth grade level.
Wow, one hour makes that much difference.
Apparently so. The book notes that most
children between 2:00 and 6:00 need about 11 hours of sleep
from 6:00 to 11:10 hours, and itoften increases again to 11 or
(21:18):
12 during adolescence. These are numbers most kids
sadly don't even get close to intoday's hurried world.
That's quite startling. So if sleep is that crucial, how
do we help kids actually wind down in a world that feels like
it's always rubbing up right? The book introduces the concept
of pressure valves throughout the day.
Pressure valves. Yeah, these are intentional
moments to release emotional steam.
(21:39):
Basically, for a boy named Henry, it was his mom's grit
sandwich ritual before bed. A grit sandwich?
What's that? She'd ask him about a courageous
thing he did that day and the hardest thing about his day.
Then they talk about the hardestthing and the best thing
anticipated for tomorrow. Oh, I like that.
The simple ritual helped Henry unpack his day, processing his
(22:00):
thoughts and feelings in the comforting, attentive light of
his mom's presence. That's a lovely, simple ritual.
What other kinds of pressure vowels does the book suggest we
can integrate into our children's days?
Well, other pressure valves could be just a quiet rest time,
even if they don't nap, or a period for working on an ongoing
creative project, or even that simple moment of lighting a
(22:22):
candle before dinner, which the author's family practices.
He says it creates a magical world for small children that
instantly concentrates their attention and brings a soothing
calm. The book also highlights the
profound importance of stories, especially fairy tales, for
helping children process their day, learn about the world and
build empathy. And he notes that repetition and
(22:44):
storytelling, like reading Curious George for the 100th
time or telling cherished familyanecdotes over and over,
actually deepens the experience and connection for a child.
It makes the story truly their own.
OK, so far we've covered simplifying the environment and
establishing rhythm. That brings us to the third
layer schedules and really seemslike our kids schedules are just
(23:06):
busier than ever these days. They absolutely are.
You know, the Roman poet Ovid once said, take rest.
A field that has rested gives a bountiful crop.
But in today's world, are we as parents kind of overcropping our
children's lives? The book delves into what it
calls the hurried child phenomenon.
It points out that since the 1980s, children have lost as
(23:26):
much as 12 hours of free time a week. 12 hours a week.
That's staggering. It is, and structured activities
and homework have basically doubled in that same time.
It's a truly significant shift in just one generation.
Wow, the author uses a great analogy for all this enrichment
we pile on, doesn't he? He does.
He compares enrichment to fertilizer being applied by the
(23:47):
ton to childhood. Fertilizer by the by the time.
Yeah, and while parents undeniably have good intentions,
the book argues that too many scheduled activities may limit a
child's ability to direct themselves to fill their own
time to find and follow their own path.
It's not about blaming parents really, but recognizing this
broader societal trend where childhood and parenting have
(24:09):
become like things to be constantly improved and made
productive, often at the expenseof that unstructured, unhurried
time needed for genuine play andself discovery.
That brings to mind the idea of balancing arousing and calming
activities. The author shares a wonderful
example with Emily and her mom, Sarah.
Can you remind us of that? Yes, Emily would often just
meltdown during busy family holidays or really intense
(24:31):
events. Her mom Sarah learned to
consciously build in C days. Calming days after A days,
arousing days. A and C days, OK.
So after a big party, maybe the next day would be a quiet bike
ride, or a walk in the park, or just an afternoon reading at
home. This conscious effort to
rebalance Emily's schedule completely restored her
equilibrium and her sense of control.
(24:52):
It's a very practical framework for looking at your family's
week. And Emery's dad takes that
concept to a slightly humorous extreme, doesn't he?
He does. It's quite funny.
After seeing how well the ANC day system worked for Emily, her
dad Frankie decided to go to a national monster truck rally by
himself. Seriously.
Yeah. He realized he couldn't possibly
(25:14):
schedule enough C days for Emilyto balance out the intensity of
a AAA day like a monster truck rally.
A AAA day. It humorously underscores just
how intense some of these arousing experiences can be for
children, and how much deep restand replenishment they truly
need to process and recover. The book also touches on how our
on demand culture, you know, wanting everything faster right
(25:35):
now, is robbing our children of something quite precious.
What is that? It argues that this constant
need for instant gratification steals the gift of anticipation
from our children. The gift of anticipation.
Yeah, that profound yearning forsummer or a birthday, literally
counting down the days that builds genuine will and
identity. The author calls it more bang
(25:57):
for the buck because the anticipation itself becomes part
of the richness of the experience.
When everything is instantly available, children lose that
developmental power that grows through waiting and the rich
layers of meaning that anticipation adds to an
experience. And this leads the author to
explore the seeds of addiction. That's a strong claim, isn't it,
(26:18):
That an over scheduled life can actually sow those seeds?
It is a strong claim, but one inthe book supports quite
thoughtfully. It defines addiction broadly as
an increasing and compulsive tendency to avoid pain or
boredom and replace inner development with outer
stimulation. An over scheduled life,
constantly seeking the next activity or external thrill can
absolutely sow these seeds. It creates a reliance on outer
(26:42):
stimulation and instant gratification.
It effectively mutes a child's internal feelings and makes them
lose the ability to regulate their own time or even just
entertain themselves. It creates this constant chase
for the next peak experience, making ordinary quiet moments
feel flat and unfulfilling. And what about youth sports?
Because for many families, that's a huge part of their
(27:04):
children's schedules. The book isn't completely
against them, but it has some important caveats, right?
Absolutely. The author isn't against sports
at all, but he cautions against too much and far too young.
That much too young? Exactly.
He argues that organized sports,particularly the really
competitive ones, can impose toomuch structure on young
children. This can hinder their progress
(27:24):
through vital developmental playstages.
Free play, where kids make the play up as they go along, where
they invent rules and rules thatfosters problem solving,
flexibility, and emotional intelligence in a way that fixed
rules and predetermined positions often don't.
So free play is crucial. He sees it as a developmental
necessity. It allows children to negotiate
(27:46):
rules, adapt to changing situations and create their own
roles based on their needs rather than being confined by an
adult driven agenda. OK, we've talked about the
physical environment, establishing rhythm, and
managing schedules. The final layer of
simplification, and arguably oneof the most challenging, is
filtering out the adult world. What exactly does the book mean
(28:06):
by that? This final layer is truly about
protecting the sanctity of childhood, creating a safe,
contained bubble, if you will, for children.
The author recounts the story ofa mother, Anne Marie, who's
defining emotion as a parent wasjust worry.
I think many parents can relate.Absolutely.
And while worry is integral to parenting, it shouldn't define
(28:27):
it because an emotional diet high in fear and sensationalism
can be transmitted to our children.
Parents often absorb this pervasive fear from media,
which, as the book points out, is incredibly end up at
exploiting our primal urge to protect our children.
And central to filtering out theadult world is the books analogy
of Uncle Andy, the television. It's a pretty blunt assessment,
(28:48):
isn't it, Uncle Andy? It is.
It's memorable. Though the author suggests that
simplifying screens, TV, computers, video games is one of
the most critical and rewarding steps parents can take, he
doesn't mince words. He calls television a direct
counterforce to simplifying an altar of commercialism and your
home's most efficient conduit ofclutter.
(29:10):
Most efficient conduit of clutter?
The Uncle Andy analogy vividly paints TV as this houseguest.
Who? Yeah, entertains, but also over
stimulates, brings in unwanted consumer messages, and
fundamentally disrupts family connection.
The book asserts that TV can easily just suck up any free
unstructured time you might gainfrom simplifying schedules
(29:31):
elsewhere. So beyond the commercialism and
the time suck, what's the actualimpact of screens on young
brains, according to the book and the research it cites?
The author cites studies that are quite stark, actually.
Television, for instance, provides none of the three
critical forms of interaction needed for optimal brain
development in babies. What are they?
Meaningful interaction with humans, direct manipulation of
(29:51):
their physical environment, and engaging in active problem
solving. TV offers none of that.
He notes that even seemingly educational programming like
Sesame Street very young children.
Even Sesame Street, Yeah. In fact, France has banned TV
shows specifically for children under 3, highlighting the severe
risks recognized by other nations.
(30:12):
And the effect on older kids is not just about language delays
is. It no, it goes deeper.
The book describes children becoming almost hypnotized by TV
with diminished mental activity.EEG studies show viewers are in
this relaxed and passive state while watching, and those
feelings can persist even after the TV is off, leaving them
feeling kind of depleted. It also warns about the
(30:34):
orienting reflex in programming.That's basically our brains
automatic pay attention, response to sudden changes, loud
noises, quick cuts. TV exploits this constantly.
It keeps you hooked. Exactly.
It conditions brains to expect constant hyperstimulation,
leading to boredom and inattentiveness in real life
when things aren't changing every few seconds, and violence
(30:55):
on screens that can desensitize children, particularly those
under six or seven who can't easily differentiate reality
from fantasy. It can even equate violence with
pleasure or excitement. The book also cautions against
early computer use, noting that kids who start later tend to
catch up very quickly anyway. And it raises the really
important question of whether exposing young children to
(31:17):
artificial minds without human values is truly beneficial for
their developing worldview. That's a powerful case against
excessive screen time. And this leads us to another
related idea, talking less. That seems almost
counterintuitive in an age wherewe're constantly told to
communicate more with our kids. It can feel that way, can it?
But the author shares this brilliant analogy from the
(31:37):
Little House on the Prairie books.
He asks why did Laura and Mary do what Pennsylvania said and
the short answer is this. Pennsylvania didn't say too
much. He argues that when we talk over
and around children constantly, when we over explain and
predigest every single experience for them, we
unintentionally stifle their innate curiosity and creativity.
(31:59):
We robbed them of the space to figure things out for
themselves. So how do we know when to speak
and when to just be silent? The book offers a practical
filter, doesn't. It it does, and it's 1, I think
many adults, myself included, could benefit from using more
often. Use three filters before
speaking. Is it true?
Is it kind? Is it?
Necessary kind necessary. OK.
(32:21):
The necessary filter is the key one here, the verbal clutter
filter. It really asks if what you're
about to say is truly more important than silence.
This gives children crucial space for their own thoughts and
feelings to develop, and for their own inner voice to
actually be heard. It's about letting children
process their own experiences rather than filling every moment
with adult commentary or instruction.
(32:41):
And part of that verbal clutter includes adult topics.
What does the book suggest? We filter there 'cause it's easy
to just chat about work stress or the news with kids around.
Right. This is about filtering out that
verbal and emotional clutter that kind of rushes them along
into premature adulthood. The book recalls that comforting
memory many of us have as children, being in the backseat
(33:02):
of the car, parents talking quietly in the front.
It conveys this profound sense of security and competence, even
if you don't understand the words.
Yeah, I remember that feeling. We project optimism and
capability to our children by talking less about things they
can't understand or affect, likecomplex financial worries or
political anxieties. The story of Sam, the little boy
(33:23):
who picked up his cynical dad's derision for the president,
illustrates so clearly how children absorb emotions and
actions much more deeply than words.
They often internalize adult anxieties without the context or
reasoning. So it's not just about what we
say, but also what we model and what emotional tone we set.
This also touches on parental involvement, where the book
notes an imbalance can often occur between parents.
(33:46):
Indeed, the book points out thatoften when one parent is over
involved, and frequently, thoughnot always, this is mother's,
especially regarding general social adjustment, the other
parent might be under involved. This creates an imbalance in the
parenting dynamic where worry can unfortunately over shadow
joy for the entire family. It's not meant as a criticism,
(34:06):
just an observation of a common pattern.
What are some practical steps the author advises to maybe
rebalance this involvement? He advises very practical steps,
like fathers for example, takingexclusive responsibility for
certain daily tasks, maybe be packing lunch every day or
always handling bath time. This moves them from merely
helping to truly doing. It establishes them as
(34:27):
consistent anchors for the children.
Right. Not just helper, but doer.
Exactly, and in turn, this allows the other parent, often
the mother in his examples, to loosen her grip a bit and
experience more ease and trust in the shared parenting.
Karla's story in the book reallydrives this point home.
Carla, this little girl who previously insisted on very
(34:48):
specific foods and routines, became noticeably less anxious
and controlling when her parentsprovided clear, consistent
direction and truly took charge.Together, it effectively allowed
her to hop back into the passenger seat of her own
childhood, trusting them to drive.
Back into the passenger seat. I like that.
And finally, the book cautions against less emotional
(35:08):
monitoring. That means constantly taking a
child's emotional temperature. Yeah, why is that potentially a
problem? It's another subtle way we can
inadvertently rush them. Young children's feelings are
often quite unconscious, constantly dissecting them,
asking how do you feel about that can feel invasive.
It can push them into what the author calls premature
adolescents. Instead, the book suggests
(35:30):
trusting your instincts as a parent, listening when they lead
the conversation about feelings,and understanding that young
children often put it right by doing.
Put it right by doing. Yeah, they need physical
engagement and activity to process emotions rather than
solely verbalizing them like adults might.
For instance, a child might express their fear or excitement
by singing about it loudly whileriding their bike back and forth
(35:52):
on the driveway, rather than sitting down and articulating
complex feelings and words. Giving them that space to
process physically without consonant verbal interrogation
is really key. So to bring it all together,
then, this deep dive into simplicity, parenting has truly
given us, I think, a powerful new lens through which to view
our often very busy family lives.
(36:15):
It's really about creating moments of stillness in a pretty
frantic world, about letting go of that constant pressure to
always do more, faster, earlier.It's such a profound shift in
perspective, isn't it? It's about remembering that deep
sustenance comes from those moments of calm, that
relationships are built in the pauses in the intervals, and
that a child's imagination trulythrives when it's not
(36:37):
overwhelmed by constant, manufactured stimulation.
It's about cultivating that reverence for childhood.
The author speaks of understanding that childhood is
this unique, unfolding ecology with its own pace and natural
systems that need to be protected and nurtured, not
constantly pushed or overstimulated.
What's so powerful here, I think, is that simplification
(36:58):
isn't just about taking things away.
It's ultimately about making room.
Room for your child's true self to emerge, room for your
family's authentic connections, and just room for a deeper, more
present kind of love. It's about creating an
environment where children can truly be themselves, rather than
constantly performing or consuming.
And that prompts an important question for you, our listener.
(37:18):
Given everything we've discussedtoday about the hidden stresses
of modern childhood and the power of simplicity, what's
maybe one small, doable step youmight take this week to simplify
your family's life just a littlebit and invite more of that calm
and connection? Perhaps it's clearing one small
space, creating one new dinner ritual, or consciously choosing
silence over just a few extra words.
(37:40):
The profound impact often beginswith the smallest, most
consistent choice.
Popular Podcasts
Stuff You Should Know
If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.
Dateline NBC
Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Follow now to get the latest episodes of Dateline NBC completely free, or subscribe to Dateline Premium for ad-free listening and exclusive bonus content: DatelinePremium.com
New Heights with Jason & Travis Kelce
Football’s funniest family duo — Jason Kelce of the Philadelphia Eagles and Travis Kelce of the Kansas City Chiefs — team up to provide next-level access to life in the league as it unfolds. The two brothers and Super Bowl champions drop weekly insights about the weekly slate of games and share their INSIDE perspectives on trending NFL news and sports headlines. They also endlessly rag on each other as brothers do, chat the latest in pop culture and welcome some very popular and well-known friends to chat with them. Check out new episodes every Wednesday. Follow New Heights on the Wondery App, YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts. You can listen to new episodes early and ad-free, and get exclusive content on Wondery+. Join Wondery+ in the Wondery App, Apple Podcasts or Spotify. And join our new membership for a unique fan experience by going to the New Heights YouTube channel now!