Why Your Political Affiliation Has No Place in the Classroom

Send us a text

"Hello, and welcome back to Teaching with Valor, the podcast where we tackle the essential questions that help us become the best teachers we can be. I’m your host, Don Fessenden, and today, we’re diving into a hot-button issue: Why teachers should keep their political affiliations out of the classroom.

Now, I know this topic can stir some strong feelings. As educators, we live in a world full of opinions, beliefs, and values, and it’s natural to want to connect with students on issues that are meaningful to us. But there’s a line—a line that, as teachers, we must be mindful not to cross. Today, we’ll be discussing why it’s crucial for teachers to create a neutral, inclusive space in the classroom, where students can explore ideas and learn to think for themselves, free from any bias that our personal political beliefs might introduce.

So, if you’re a teacher who’s ever wondered whether it’s appropriate to bring up your political views or if you’re a parent concerned about what students are exposed to in school, this episode is for you. Together, let’s dive into the impact that personal politics can have on students, on our classrooms, and on the foundation of trust we build as educators.

Show Notes

For more information on this topic checkout the following resources:

• Edutopia – Building a Culture of Open Dialogue in the Classroom: www.edutopia.org
• The Cult of Pedagogy – Maintaining Neutrality in the Classroom: A guide to fostering critical thinking while avoiding bias.
• Facing History and Ourselves: Resources for teaching students to think critically about historical and contemporary issues.
• Teaching Tolerance: Tools and resources for creating inclusive, unbiased classrooms.
• National Council for the Social Studies – Guidelines on Political Neutrality: Tips for maintaining an unbiased approach in social studies and civics education.

Stay tuned for more episodes, and remember, every student is unique, and every classroom can be a place where all students succeed. Keep teaching with valor!

Episode Transcript

Don (00:08):
"Welcome to Teaching with Valor, the podcast where we dive
into the heart of education,helping teachers, parents, and
students thrive.
I’m your host, Don Fessenden,and if you’re passionate about
making a difference ineducation, you’ve come to the
right place.
Before we jump into today’s deepdive episode, I’d like to ask

(00:29):
for your support.
If you find value in theseconversations, please take a
moment to like, subscribe, andshare this podcast with your
fellow educators and parents.
Your support helps us reach morelisteners, empowering more
teachers and families tonavigate the challenges of
education with confidence andcourage.

(00:49):
So hit that subscribe button,share this episode, and let’s
continue to grow this communitytogether." Today, we’re diving

into a hot-button issue (00:58):
Why teachers should keep their
political affiliations out ofthe classroom.
Now, I know this topic can stirsome strong feelings.
As educators, we live in a worldfull of opinions, beliefs, and
values, and it’s natural to wantto connect with students on
issues that are meaningful tous.

But there’s a line (01:19):
a line that, as teachers, we must be mindful
not to cross.
Today, we’ll be discussing whyit’s crucial for teachers to
create a neutral, inclusivespace in the classroom, where
students can explore ideas andlearn to think for themselves,
free from any bias that ourpersonal political beliefs might

(01:39):
introduce.
So, if you’re a teacher who’sever wondered whether it’s
appropriate to bring up yourpolitical views or if you’re a
parent concerned about whatstudents are exposed to in
school, this episode is for you.
Together, let’s dive into theimpact that personal politics
can have on students, on ourclassrooms, and on the

(02:00):
foundation of trust we build aseducators.
Stick around for a special bonussegment at the end, where we’ll
address a question we hear fromparents: How can I encourage my
child to form their own opinionswithout being influenced by
mine?
Let’s get started." In our firstsegment we look at The Role of

(02:20):
the Classroom as a NeutralSpace.
"Let’s start with an essentialquestion: What is the role of
the classroom?
At its core, a classroom is aplace for learning, exploration,
and growth.
It’s a space where students cometogether with diverse
backgrounds, perspectives, andexperiences.
When they enter that space, theyshould feel confident that it’s

(02:42):
an environment where they canask questions, express ideas,
and engage with the materialwithout feeling that one
particular viewpoint is beingfavored over others.
As educators, our job is not tocreate echo chambers but to
foster critical thinking.
We’re here to guide students inexploring ideas, questioning
assumptions, and developingtheir own informed perspectives.

(03:07):
But the moment our politicalbeliefs enter the equation, we
risk compromising that essentialmission.
When students know a teacher’spolitical leanings, it can
inadvertently influence the waythey participate in discussions,
approach assignments, or evenfeel in the classroom.
This is particularly true foryounger students, who often see

(03:27):
their teachers as role modelsand authority figures.
When a teacher’s political viewsbecome known, even
unintentionally, it can color astudent’s perception of the
teacher and create an implicitbias in the way they interact
with that teacher.
Our students come from all walksof life, and our goal should be
to ensure they all feel equallyvalued and respected.""Let’s now

(03:52):
take a closer look at thedifferent challenges that arise
around political neutrality inelementary, middle, and high
school classrooms.""Inelementary school, students are
still in the early stages offorming their own beliefs and
values.
They’re deeply influenced by theadults around them, including
teachers, who they see astrusted sources of knowledge and

(04:15):
guidance.
For this reason, it’sparticularly important at the
elementary level that we avoidexpressing our political
opinions or discussingpolitically charged topics
without careful consideration.
Young children often interpretthings literally.
When they hear a teacher make apolitical comment, they may take

(04:35):
it as a universal truth.
A statement like,‘Our countrywould be better off if…’ can
easily become a seed that shapeshow they perceive the world.
At this stage, students need afoundation built on curiosity,
not conclusions.
They’re learning to askquestions like,‘Why do people
have different ideas?’ and‘Whatmakes something fair or unfair?’

(04:59):
Rather than introducing ourbeliefs, our role is to
encourage those questions andguide students to explore
answers in an unbiased way.
One of the best ways to maintainpolitical neutrality in the
elementary classroom is to stickto the curriculum and to avoid
assigning value-laden languagewhen discussing historical or

(05:19):
social events.
For instance, if you’re teachinga unit on presidents or
government, stick to the facts.
Explain the roles,responsibilities, and structures
without veering into commentaryon current politics or issues
that might be divisive.
And remember, elementarystudents are perceptive.

(05:39):
They pick up on tone, phrasing,and even facial expressions.
So, when talking about events orpolicies, it’s best to keep a
balanced and neutral stance toprevent any accidental
influence.
This approach helps build afoundation of respect and
inquiry that will benefitstudents as they grow.""As

(05:59):
students enter middle school,they begin to form more
independent thoughts and areexposed to a wider range of
ideas.
Let’s talk about how we cancontinue to support their
development without swaying themwith our own beliefs.""Middle
school is a time when studentsstart to develop a sense of
identity and are naturallycurious about the world around

(06:21):
them.
They’re aware of current eventsand may even start bringing up
political issues in classdiscussions.
This is a prime age for teachingstudents how to analyze
information, assess credibility,and consider multiple
perspectives.
And as their teacher, you’rethere to help them develop these
critical thinking skills—not todirect them toward any

(06:44):
particular viewpoint.
One of the most effectivestrategies in middle school is
to use open-ended questions tofacilitate discussion.
For instance, if a studentbrings up a political topic,
instead of providing an answeror expressing your opinion, try
asking,‘What do others thinkabout that?’ or‘Why do you think

(07:04):
people might feel differentlyabout this issue?’ This
encourages students to thinkmore deeply and listen to each
other, rather than seekingvalidation from you.
In middle school, students arealso starting to question the
beliefs and values they’veinherited from family,
community, and even you as ateacher.
By maintaining a neutral stance,you allow students the space to

(07:28):
explore and, importantly, to doso in a way that is free from
pressure.
If students feel that oneperspective is favored over
others, they may either conformto that perspective or shut
down, fearing that their ownviews aren’t welcome.
Another key point at this levelis to encourage media literacy.

(07:48):
Teach students how to identifybias in sources, how to evaluate
the credibility of information,and how to recognize opinion
versus fact.
This equips them with the toolsthey need to make informed
decisions as they engage withcurrent events outside the
classroom.
And, importantly, it models away of thinking that values

(08:09):
objectivity and fairness.""Highschool students are becoming
more independent thinkers, andthey’re likely to have strong
opinions on issues.
But this also creates newchallenges in maintaining a
neutral environment.
Let’s explore what politicalneutrality looks like in the
high school classroom.""In highschool, students are more

(08:31):
politically aware and ofteneager to discuss current events
and social issues.
They’re forming strong opinionsand learning to articulate them.
At this level, the stakes arehigher when it comes to
political neutrality becausestudents are actively watching
and evaluating the adults aroundthem, including teachers.

(08:51):
Any sign of bias—whetherintentional or accidental—can
quickly impact how studentsperceive the class, the teacher,
and even the school.
One way to maintain neutralityis to encourage debate and
discussion, but with groundrules that prioritize respect
and evidence-based reasoning.
If a politically charged topicarises, create a framework for

(09:14):
students to explore itthemselves.
For instance, rather thandiscussing a teacher’s
perspective on climate change,set up a debate where students
research and argue differentviewpoints.
By structuring discussions inthis way, you empower students
to form their own conclusionsbased on research and analysis,
rather than teacher influence.

(09:36):
It’s also crucial at this levelto avoid leading questions.
For example, instead of asking,‘Don’t you think this policy is
unfair?’ try something moreopen, like,‘What are some of the
arguments for and against thispolicy?’ Leading questions can
subtly sway students’ opinionsand make them feel that there’s
a‘right’ answer they need tofind.

(09:58):
When students directly ask aboutyour own political views,
consider responding withtransparency about the
importance of neutrality ineducation.
You might say,‘My job is to helpyou think critically about these
issues, not to tell you what tothink.’ High school students
respect honesty, and thisapproach reinforces your

(10:19):
commitment to their growth asindependent thinkers.
High school classrooms can bepowerful environments for
learning how to handledifferences respectfully, and
your role as a neutralfacilitator is key to that
process.""Now that we’ve coveredhow to maintain a politically

(10:40):
neutral stance at each gradelevel, let’s move into our bonus
segment, where we’ll answer aquestion from parents about how
they can encourage theirchildren to form independent
opinions.""Parents often ask,How can I support my child in
forming their own opinionswithout influencing them too
much?
It’s a fantastic questionbecause, as parents, it’s only

(11:03):
natural to want to share ourviews.
But it’s also important tofoster independence in their
thinking.
One approach is to ask questionsrather than give answers.
If your child brings up a topic,try responding with questions
like,‘What do you think aboutthat?’ or‘Why do you feel that
way?’ This encourages them toexplore their own thoughts

(11:26):
rather than simply adoptingyours.
Another strategy is to exposethem to diverse viewpoints.
If they’re interested in aparticular issue, encourage them
to read articles, watchdocumentaries, or listen to
podcasts from differentperspectives.
This helps them understand thatthere are multiple sides to
every story, and it gives themthe tools to form well-rounded

(11:49):
opinions.
And remember, children learn alot from watching how we handle
discussions.
Model respectful dialogue andshow them that it’s okay to
disagree with others.
When they see you listening,asking questions, and respecting
other viewpoints, they’re morelikely to adopt those behaviors
themselves." Now, todays episodetakeaways.

(12:13):
"Keeping politics out of theclassroom isn’t always easy,
especially in today’s dividedworld.
But as teachers, ourresponsibility is to create
spaces where students feel freeto think, question, and grow.
By maintaining neutrality, wefoster environments where
students can explore ideasindependently and develop into

(12:34):
thoughtful, engaged citizens.
Thank you for joining us ontoday’s episode of Teaching with
Valor.
For more resources onmaintaining a neutral classroom
and supporting students’critical thinking, check out the
links in our episodedescription.
Remember, as educators, our jobisn’t to shape our students’

(12:54):
opinions—it’s to give them thetools they need to shape their
own.
Keep teaching, keep inspiring,and as always, keep teaching
with valor."