Navigating Misjudgement: A Practical Framework for Better Board Performance | Nuala G Walsh, CEO & NED

Send us a text

This episode highlights decision-making errors affecting high-stakes boards. Using concepts like bias, ‘deaf spots,’ and ‘tone-deaf leadership,’ it outlines misjudgment traps as warning signs and solutions to mental misinformation. It explores human misjudgment in boards, from ego to identity and false narratives.

Dr. Sabine Dembkowski, Founder of Better Boards, discusses navigating misjudgment with Nuala Walsh, non-executive director, chair, and CEO of MindEquity. Nuala’s roles include Chair of Innocence Project London, iNED at British & Irish Lions, President of Harvard Club Ireland, Deputy Chair of The FA Inclusion Advisory Board, and Vice-Chair at UN Women (UK).

"Even the smartest boards risk tuning out what matters"

Nuala stresses context as a critical factor in board decisions. Experience, background, and environment shape perspectives, but today’s noisy world—data overload, disinformation, and constant distractions—creates a "toxic mix" for judgment. Even intelligent boards risk missing crucial data, ignoring key voices, and rushing into misjudgment.

"We hear less; we misjudge more"

Nuala highlights ‘deaf spots’—the failure to recognise how environments influence behaviour. While reputation depends on sound decisions, boardroom pressures increase risk. Boards may tune out critical signals, focusing instead on what is convenient or comfortable.

"To get it right, understand why people get it wrong"

Addressing echo chambers and tone-deaf decision-making begins with recognizing the problem. Overconfidence blinds boards to vulnerabilities, leading them to assume their judgments are sound, even against contradictory evidence.

"Groupthink is a warning sign of misjudgment"

Boardroom culture matters. While boards discuss company culture, they often overlook their own biases. Consensus without challenge signals a risk of misjudgment.

"The peacock cares about who's right, not what's right"

Ego-driven decisions are a major pitfall. Overconfidence fosters a false sense of certainty, pushing boards toward rushed decisions influenced by distractions, time pressures, and wishful thinking. Identity, emotion, and risk appetite compound these biases, making it vital to question both external narratives and internal assumptions.

"Check your intuition"

Nuala advises boards to test their intuition. While gut instincts are useful, validating assumptions improves decision accuracy by 10% to 40%. Boards should pause, fact-check, and challenge their reasoning rather than rely solely on intuition.

Key Takeaways for Effective Boards:

• Decisions matter more than you think.
• No one is immune to misjudgment—evaluate your board's mindset regularly.
• Not everything you hear is valuable, and not everything valuable is heard—listen differently and discern wisely.