The Chase for 28 - A Yankees Podcast

The 2025 Yankees season is officially over. In this emotional instant reaction episode, Chris and the Podcast Paisan (AJ) host what feels like the Bronx Bombers’ postseason wake. The Yankees’ offense went silent once again, managing only three hits through eight innings before falling 5–2 to the Blue Jays in Game 4. Despite Cam Schlittler’s strong start, sloppy defense from Jazz Chisholm and a quiet lineup sealed their fate.

Chris a...

The Yankees aren’t dead yet! In Game 3 of the ALDS, Aaron Judge put the team on his back as the Bronx Bombers stormed back from a 6–1 deficit to defeat the Blue Jays and keep their season alive. Chris and the Podcast Paisan (AJ) break down every emotional moment—from Rodón’s early collapse to the bullpen’s lockdown effort and Judge’s MVP-caliber leadership that sparked the comeback.

Despite leaving eight runners on base, the Yankees...

The Bronx Bombers are on the ropes. In this Game 2 postgame reaction episode, Chris and the Podcast Paisan (AJ) try to make sense of a disastrous weekend in Toronto as the Yankees fall behind 0–2 in the ALDS after a 13–7 loss. Despite scoring late against Toronto’s bullpen, the early innings were defined by rookie Trey Yesavage, who threw 5.1 no-hit innings and racked up 11 strikeouts in just his fourth career start.

The guys vent t...

The Yankees’ postseason run hit its first bump north of the border as Toronto dominated Game 1 of the ALDS with a 10–1 victory at Rogers Centre. Despite the lopsided score, host Chris Nesi reminds fans that the effort on the field wasn’t nearly as bad as the final line suggested. Vladimir Guerrero Jr. put on a two-way clinic, flashing leather and launching a homer, while Alejandro Kirk surprised everyone with two of his own.

Luis Gi...

Episode 115 of Chase for 28 sets the stage for the American League Division Series between the Yankees and the Blue Jays. Chris and the Podcast Padre rewind the Wild Card win, revisit last episode’s trivia answer, and look ahead to a best-of-five series that promises pressure-packed baseball.

The conversation dives into pitching matchups (Luis Gil, Max Fried, Carlos Rodón, and Cam Schlittler vs. Gausman, Bieber, and a rookie arm), p...

The Yankees survive and advance! In this Wild Card Game 3 recap, Chris, AJ, and the Podcast Padre celebrate a 4–0 shutout over the Boston Red Sox, powered by rookie sensation Cam Schlittler’s historic postseason performance. Schlittler became the only pitcher in MLB history to throw 8+ innings with 12 strikeouts, no walks, and no runs allowed in a playoff start.

From Rosario’s clutch RBI to McMahon’s jaw-dropping defensive play, the...

In this bonus episode of the "Chase for 28" podcast, we dive deep into the Yankees' exhilarating victory in Game Two of the Wild Card series. Host Chris is joined by the Podcast Padre and the Podcast Paisano, providing a lively discussion filled with instant reactions and analysis of the game. Listeners can expect to hear insights on key player performances, strategic decisions by Aaron Boone, and what the Yankees need to do to pus...

Game 1 of the Wild Card series had everything October baseball promises—tension, drama, and heartbreak in the Bronx. In front of 47,000-plus fans at Yankee Stadium, Max Fried delivered a gem and Anthony Volpe provided an early spark with a solo shot. But the night unraveled in the seventh inning when the Yankees’ bullpen faltered, giving the Red Sox the opening they needed.

Garrett Crochet turned in a historic performance for Boston...

The marathon is over, and the postseason is finally here. In Episode 114 of Chase for 28, Chris and the Podcast Padre wrap up the Yankees’ 94–68 regular season, reflect on the ups and downs that defined the summer, and preview the highly anticipated Wild Card series against the Red Sox. From déjà vu records to the dangers of Chapman in October, the guys dive into how the Yankees match up against Boston and what it will take to surv...

In this special episode of Chase for 28, Chris and the Podcast Padre go beyond the Bronx with a family day to remember. Broadcasting live from Studio C, the duo shares their experience participating in the Guinness World Record-setting “Big Catch” event at Yogi Berra Stadium—joined by Yankee legends like Willie Randolph and Ron Guidry.

Meanwhile, the Yankees keep their playoff hopes alive in dramatic fashion as Ben Rice delivers a c...

In this episode of Chase for 28, Chris and the Podcast Padre cover a jam-packed week of Yankees baseball. From Aaron Judge passing Joe DiMaggio on the all-time Yankees home run list to the shocking news about Anthony Volpe’s torn labrum, no stone is left unturned. The conversation swings from historical overlap between Yankee greats like Gehrig, DiMaggio, and Mantle to current struggles with the bullpen and the impact of questionab...

In Episode 111 of Chase for 28, Chris and the Podcast Padre dive deep into the Yankees’ September journey as the playoff race heats up. From frustrations over September call-up rules to dissecting tough losses against Houston and Toronto, the duo breaks down everything you need to know about the Yankees’ current standing.

The conversation covers umpiring controversies, historic throwbacks like George Brett’s infamous pine tar incide...

This episode of Chase for 28 is all about family, Yankees baseball, and unforgettable moments at the ballpark! Chris is joined by the Podcast Padre—and for the first time—his sons, Miles and Colton. The crew takes you inside their recent trip to Yankee Stadium for Colton’s 10th birthday celebration, including behind-the-scenes fun at the Yankee Museum, Monument Park, and the game-day experience that had it all: home runs, dancing, ...

What a difference a week makes for the Yankees! In this episode of Chase for 28, Chris and the Podcast Padre break down an eventful week that saw the Yankees sweep the Cardinals and Rays before a tough loss to Boston. With a five-game win streak putting them in the first Wild Card spot, the conversation turns to whether this team can finally deliver against top competition—or if the fundamentals will continue to haunt them.

From def...

In Episode 108 of Chase for 28, Chris and the Podcast Padre break down another week of inconsistency and frustration in the Bronx. Despite hopes of a turnaround, the Yankees remain stuck in mediocrity—splitting series with Houston and Minnesota and now clinging to the third Wild Card spot. The guys examine the team’s lack of urgency, puzzling bullpen decisions, and the offensive struggles that continue to plague the lineup.

They als...

In Episode 107 of Chase for 28, Chris and the Podcast Padre dive deep into another frustrating week in Yankee Land. Despite trade deadline optimism, the Yankees have stumbled badly, getting swept by the Marlins for the first time in regular-season history and dropping another series to Texas. The duo examines where it all went wrong, from underperforming pitchers to slumping hitters, and whether Aaron Boone and Brian Cashman’s days...

In Episode 106 of Chase for 28, Chris and the Podcast Padre recap one of the busiest weeks of the Yankees' 2025 season. The team is in the midst of an uncertain stretch without Aaron Judge, now beginning to surge with renewed life—and an infusion of fresh talent—at the trade deadline. From bullpen reinforcements to defensive upgrades and spark plug additions, this episode breaks down every major move the front office made (and didn...

In Episode 105 of Chase for 28, Chris is joined once again by the Podcast Padre to break down the current state of the New York Yankees as they kick off the second half of the season. With the Yankees sitting at 54-44 and chasing Toronto in the AL East, the duo dives into trade deadline rumors, underwhelming pitching decisions, and the offensive inconsistencies that continue to plague the Bombers.

From blister issues and bullpen gam...

In Episode 104 of Chase for 28, Chris welcomes back longtime co-host AJ Bianco for a much-needed shot of optimism after a scorching 5–0 week from the Yankees. Together, they reflect on DJ LeMahieu’s surprising DFA, Clark Schmidt’s Tommy John surgery, Jazz Chisholm’s All-Star nod and Home Run Derby entry, and Cam Schlittler’s promising MLB debut.

The guys also preview potential trade deadline targets, debate the best third base fit (...