E468 - Are Podcast Pre-Interview Chats A Stupid Waste of Time or Are They the Secret to A Better Interview

Episode 468 - Are Podcast Pre-Interview Chats A Stupid Waste of Time or Are They the Secret to A Better Interview

Dave tackles the often-debated topic of pre-interviews in podcasting. Here’s a high-level overview of the major themes and takeaways from this episode:

• Dave sets the scene: It’s late August 2025. Inspired by a recent critique from another podcaster who “let it fly” against the practice of pre-interviews, Dave explores both sides of the debate.

• The controversy: Dave shares how one podcaster harshly criticized anyone who conducts pre-interviews—almost to the point of “gatekeeping.” He expresses concern for this mindset, emphasizing that there is never just one way to podcast.

• Dave's perspective: As a longtime advocate for pre-interviews, Dave values them as a tool for building rapport and preparation. He explains that his process involves meeting guests twice—first for a 20-minute pre-interview, then again for the formal recording. He believes this makes for a more organized and engaging podcast, which his audience appreciates.

• The challenges: Dave agrees that pre-interviews are a substantial time commitment, both for the host and the guest. He acknowledges the criticisms—especially from those who don't edit or deeply prepare their shows. Still, he observes that shows without pre-interviews sometimes struggle with unstructured conversations and disengaged guests.

• Reevaluating the process: With experience from working with PR agencies on his author-focused podcast, Dave recognizes that not every guest needs a pre-interview—especially seasoned broadcasters. He’s considering relaxing his usual requirement, taking inspiration (but not the harsh tone) from those who skip pre-chats entirely.

• Listener engagement: Dave turns to his audience, inviting them to share how they handle guest preparation:

  • Do you do pre-interviews at all?

  • Are they scheduled on a different day, or just a quick chat before recording?

  • Is the meeting purely spontaneous with no pre-chat?

  • Why do you do it your way, and how has that worked for you?

• Openness and feedback: Dave encourages a spirit of learning and community. He makes it clear that podcasting is not one-size-fits-all: what works for one may not work for another, and respectful debate/feedback only makes the community stronger.

• Opportunities to connect: Listeners are encouraged to share their thoughts and show links via howtopodcast.ca or the show's SpeakPipe voice message system. Dave wants to feature listener feedback and podcast recommendations in future episodes.

• There is no universal right way to podcast.

• Pre-interviews can add value, structure, and relationship-building—but they're not always necessary.

• It's vital to respect diverse methods and avoid judging others’ choices.

• Open communication and willingness to adjust your process benefit both the host and guests.

• Dave values listener feedback as a way to learn and shape future episodes.

• Share how you handle guest prep on your podcast!

• Leave a voice message at howtopodcast.ca to join the conversation.

• Let Dave know your thoughts and get your podcast mentioned on the show.

Thank you for listening, for your support, and—most importantly—keep sharing your message!

https://www.speakpipe.com/HelloDave

___

https://howtopodcast.ca/