All Episodes

February 26, 2025 7 mins

Send us a text

She left for a run and never came back. Samantha Murphy, a devoted mother and beloved community member, vanished without a trace on what should have been an ordinary morning jog in Ballarat, Victoria. Despite extensive searches, weeks of unanswered questions, and national media coverage, no trace of her was ever found—until authorities arrested 23-year-old Patrick Orren Stephenson for her murder. But with no body recovered, can investigators prove their case beyond a reasonable doubt?

Join The Missing Pieces as we delve deep into the mystery surrounding Samantha’s disappearance. Was she a victim of a calculated crime, or is there more to the story than meets the eye? We explore the theories, the evidence, and the haunting questions left unanswered. What really happened to Samantha Murphy? And will her family ever find closure?

Tune in as we unravel the case, piece by piece.

Support the show

Mark as Played
Transcript

Episode Transcript

Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:00):
She left for a run and never came back.
A woman who had a routine, afamily and a community that
loved her gone without a trace.
How does someone disappear inbroad daylight with no apparent
clues?
Welcome back to the MissingPieces, the podcast where we
explore the most mysteriousdisappearances and unsolved

(00:22):
cases.
Today we're diving into thecase of Samantha Murphy, a
devoted mother, an active memberof her community and a woman
who seemingly vanished without atrace on what should have been
a routine morning run.
What happened to SamanthaMurphy and why has her case
gripped an entire nation?
Let's piece it together.

(00:42):
On the morning of February 4,2024, 51-year-old Samantha
Murphy laced up her runningshoes and stepped out into the
crisp morning air of Ballarat,victoria.
She was an experienced jogger,the kind of person who found
solace in the rhythmic poundingof her feet against the dirt
paths of Wubukarung RegionalPark.

(01:02):
The eucalyptus trees stood talland still that morning, casting
long shadows as the sun rose.
It was an ordinary day, exceptit would be the last time anyone
saw Samantha.
Her family expected her returnby mid-morning, but as the hours
stretched on, unease turned todread.
Calls to her phone wentunanswered.

(01:24):
Her usual running route wasfamiliar to her.
She wouldn't have gotten lost.
Something was wrong.
Authorities and volunteersswarmed the regional park,
combing every inch of thewinding trails, peering beneath
dense brush, sending search dogsto track her scent.
But it was as if the earth hadswallowed her whole.

(01:45):
Her phone's last ping placedher near the park, but no
further clues surfaced.
Days turned into weeks andstill nothing.
Was she lost, attacked?
Did she vanish voluntarily?
The possibilities wereconsidered, but there was no
concrete evidence to support anyof them.
Then, in March 2024, a shockingdevelopment A man named Patrick

(02:10):
Oren Stevenson, a 23-year-oldlocal, was arrested and charged
with Samantha's murder.
The news sent shockwavesthrough the community, but it
came with an unsettling caveatHer body had not been found.
How can someone be charged withmurder when the victim is still
missing?
Stevenson pleaded not guiltyand investigators have yet to

(02:31):
disclose what led them to hisarrest.
Was there forensic evidence?
Did he have a known connectionto Samantha?
And, if he was guilty, wherewas her body?
The details remain undisclosedas legal proceedings unfold,
leaving more questions thananswers.
Samantha's disappearance hasleft a scar on Ballarat.
The town known for its strongcommunity ties has been left

(02:55):
grappling with fear anduncertainty.
Candlelight vigils have beenheld in her honor, her face
plastered on posters shared inthousands of social media posts.
Women in the area nowsecond-guess their own safety,
questioning whether they toocould disappear without a trace.
Her family, especially hermother, has been relentless in

(03:16):
their search for justice.
We just want to give her afuneral, her mother pleaded, her
voice heavy with sorrow.
The search for Samantha has notjust been a local effort.
National media has picked upthe story, broadcasting it
across the country and beyond.
Internet sleuths have dissectedevery known detail, speculating
about possible scenarios.

(03:37):
Some believe Stevenson is ascapegoat, that the police may
have moved too quickly to makean arrest.
Others are convinced of hisguilt, speculating that law
enforcement has far moreevidence than they've disclosed.
The debate rages on, fueled byfrustration over unanswered
questions.
It's impossible to imagine theagony her loved ones are

(03:59):
experiencing A mother, a wife, afriend simply gone, and the
longer her body remains missing,the more unbearable the
uncertainty becomes.
Without a physical discovery,closure is elusive.
Can her family ever trulygrieve without the ability to
lay her to rest?
And what if, against all odds,she's still alive somewhere?

(04:21):
The possibility of an abductioncannot be ruled out.
Samantha was a strong,independent woman, but in an
isolated park with dense brushand little visibility, she would
have been vulnerable.
Could she have encounteredsomeone she knew, or was this a
random act of violence?
There have been cases beforewhere missing persons reappear

(04:42):
years later, held captive orforced into a situation beyond
their control.
Could Samantha still be outthere waiting to be found?
There's also the lingeringquestion of why Stevenson was
arrested so quickly.
The police must have hadsubstantial evidence or a strong
lead, yet they've remainedtight-lipped about what they
know.
If there was DNA evidence, wasit found at the park At his home

(05:06):
?
Did someone witness somethingthey haven't yet revealed?
The legal system demands proofbeyond a reasonable doubt and
without a body, securing aconviction will be difficult.
Meanwhile, the communitycontinues to search.
Every lead is followed, everynew theory dissected.
The Murphy family has kept hopealive, refusing to give up

(05:27):
until they know what happened toSamantha.
The support they've received isoverwhelming, with thousands of
people invested in the case,desperate for answers.
The streets of Ballarat arefilled with people who remember
her.
The streets of Ballarat arefilled with people who remember
her, who knew her kindness andwarmth.
She was more than a missingperson.

(05:48):
She was a mother, a friend, acommunity member whose absence
has left a gaping hole.
There are so many hauntingquestions left in this case.
If Stevenson is guilty, how didhe do it and why Did he act
alone?
If he's innocent, where doesthat leave the investigation?
The justice system must movecarefully.
A wrongful conviction couldmean the real perpetrator
remains free, while a lack ofsufficient evidence could allow

(06:11):
a guilty party to walk.
It's a case that demandspatience, diligence and, most
importantly, truth.
Investigators continue to workbehind the scenes searching for
that missing piece of evidencethat could turn the case on its
head.
If Samantha is still out theresomewhere, what would she want
her loved ones to know?
What would she tell them if shehad the chance?

(06:34):
Until answers come, the mysteryof her disappearance will
remain one of the mostheartbreaking cases in recent
history.
This case is still developingand we will continue to follow
the details closely.
If you have any thoughts,theories or insights, let us
know by reaching out on oursocial media platforms.
That's it for today's episodeof the Missing Pieces.

(06:57):
If you enjoyed this episode,please consider leaving a review
and sharing it with those whofollow true crime.
And remember, behind everymystery, there's a family
searching for answers.
Until next time, stay safe.
Advertise With Us

Popular Podcasts

Stuff You Should Know
Law & Order: Criminal Justice System - Season 1 & Season 2

Law & Order: Criminal Justice System - Season 1 & Season 2

Season Two Out Now! Law & Order: Criminal Justice System tells the real stories behind the landmark cases that have shaped how the most dangerous and influential criminals in America are prosecuted. In its second season, the series tackles the threat of terrorism in the United States. From the rise of extremist political groups in the 60s to domestic lone wolves in the modern day, we explore how organizations like the FBI and Joint Terrorism Take Force have evolved to fight back against a multitude of terrorist threats.

Dateline NBC

Dateline NBC

Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Follow now to get the latest episodes of Dateline NBC completely free, or subscribe to Dateline Premium for ad-free listening and exclusive bonus content: DatelinePremium.com

Music, radio and podcasts, all free. Listen online or download the iHeart App.

Connect

© 2025 iHeartMedia, Inc.