#15 The Missing Pieces: Vanished While Expecting: The Kylee Monteiro Mystery

Send us a text

"I don't feel safe. Something's not right." These were the last words anyone received from Kylee Monteiro before she vanished without a trace on August 7, 2025. At just 18 years old and 11 weeks pregnant, Kylie had everything to live for - a high school diploma fresh in hand and a future full of possibilities.

The disappearance of this young woman from Rehoboth, Massachusetts has left a community searching for answers and a family desperate for her return. Described by loved ones as timid and not particularly street-savvy, Kylee’s sudden silence speaks volumes. Her sister Faith puts it plainly: if she's not calling or posting on social media, something is wrong. This isn't a teen who would simply walk away from her life, especially not while expecting a child.

We delve into the troubling timeline surrounding Kylee’s disappearance, including reports of an argument with her boyfriend shortly before she went missing. We examine the massive search effort that has mobilized in response - from police deploying canine units, helicopters and dive teams, to volunteers combing miles of terrain on foot. The small town of Rehoboth, about 50 miles south of Boston, now finds itself at the center of a mystery that has residents locking their doors and keeping closer watch on their loved ones.

Kylee stands six feet tall with light brown hair and blue-brown eyes. When last seen, she wore a red t-shirt with "Get over it" printed on the front, ripped blue jeans, and tan boots. If you have information that could help bring her home, please contact authorities immediately. Every missing person has a story, every family deserves answers, and your tip could be the missing piece that solves this case. Share Kylee’s story - her life and her unborn child's life may depend on it.

If you live in Massachusetts—or know someone who does—please share Kylee’s story. Police are asking anyone with information to contact Trooper Sabrina Hinchey at [phone], or Detective Paul McGovern with the Rehoboth Police Department at [phone], extension 1135.

Support the show

Episode Transcript

Speaker 1 (00:00):
Welcome to the Missing Pieces podcast, where we
shine a light on the stories ofpeople who vanish and the
families and communities leftsearching for answers.
Today, we're going to talkabout the case of Kylie Monteiro
, an 18-year-old from Rehoboth,massachusetts.
Kylie is more than just anotherheadline.
She's a recent high schoolgraduate, a daughter, a sister,

(00:22):
a friend and, at just 11 weekspregnant, she was preparing for
a whole new chapter of life.
But on August 7, 2025, kyliedisappeared, and the
circumstances leading up to herdisappearance are chilling.
Kylie had just graduated fromAttleboro High School, two

(00:42):
months earlier.
Friends and family describe heras timid, the kind of person
who wasn't street savvy, whodidn't really know how to be on
her own.
She had big plans for herfuture, but her loved ones say
it was unlikely she would justleave without telling anyone.
Her sister, faith, said she'snot the type to cut off contact.
If she's not calling us, ifshe's not posting on social

(01:05):
media, something's wrong.
On the evening of August 6th,kylie was last heard from by
voice.
The next day, august 7th, shesent a final text message to a
friend.
The message was short, but itsaid everything.
I don't feel safe.
Something's not right.
That was the last anyone heardfrom her Family.

(01:28):
Members say Kylie had gotteninto an argument with her
boyfriend shortly before herdisappearance.
Police have not confirmed thedetails of that dispute, but
it's central to the timeline.
Kylie was last seen on CountyStreet in Rehoboth.
She was wearing a red t-shirtwith the words Get over it
printed on the front, rippedblue jeans, tan boots, and she

(01:48):
may have had a white bagcarrying some of her belongings.
She is about six feet tall,with light brown hair and
blue-brown eyes.
These details are crucialbecause they help investigators
and the public know exactly whatto look for.
Since her disappearance, searchefforts have been extensive.
Local and state police haveteamed up.
They've deployed canine units,helicopters, drones, atvs and

(02:12):
even dive teams in nearby watersand wooded areas.
Neighbors have been urged tocheck home security footage.
Volunteers have walked miles ofterrain.
Family and friends have put upflyers and flooded social media,
but so far no trace of Kylie.
Rehoboth police are calling thisan open, fluid incident.
They're being careful not tocall it a criminal investigation

(02:36):
at this stage, though many inthe community fear the worst.
Kylie's disappearance hasdevastated her family.
Her sisters, faith and Kitty,have been outspoken in pleading
for her safe return.
Kitty said we just want her tocome home.
We're not going to stop tryingto find her.
Kylie's pregnancy only makesthis case more urgent.

(02:56):
Not only is an 18-year-old girlmissing, but so is the child
she was carrying.
In Rehoboth, a small town about50 miles south of Boston, the
story has shaken the community.
People are locking doors,keeping closer tabs on their
teens and following every updatein the news.
Some describe it as a nightmarethat feels too close to home.

(03:19):
Others say they're volunteeringin searches because they
imagine what it would feel likeif it were their daughter or
sister missing.
Right now there are no arrests,no confirmed suspects and no
evidence has been publiclyshared that explains what
happened to Kylie.
After that final text, butpolice and family are still
asking for the public's help.

(03:39):
Even the smallest clue footagefrom a doorbell camera, a car
seen at the wrong time, a detailthat didn't feel right could be
the missing piece.
Unfortunately, kylie's case isnot isolated.
Across the United States,thousands of people go missing
every year, many of them youngwomen, some pregnant, some
vulnerable, and all deeply lovedby their families.

(04:01):
These cases remind us howfragile safety can feel and how
important it is to stay aware,connected and ready to speak up
if we notice something unusual.
If you live in Massachusetts orknow someone who does, please
share Kylie's story.
Police are asking anyone withinformation to contact Trooper

(04:22):
Sabrina Hinchey at 508-972-1041or Detective Paul McGovern with
the Rehoboth Police Departmentat 508-252-3722, extension 1135.
Kylie Montero is 18 years old,about 6 feet tall, with light
brown hair and blue-brown eyes.

(04:42):
She was last seen in Rehobothon August 7th.
If you saw something, if youheard something or if you know
something, say something.
Every missing person has astory, every family deserves
answers and every voice matters.
Thank you for listening to theMissing Pieces podcast and
please share Kylie's story.