Fundraising Fog? Messaging That Donors Actually Love

Fundraising can feel like walking through mist—messages blur, instincts wobble, and urgency crowds out intention. In this energizing conversation, we welcome returning favorite Micah James (team lead and coach at Bloomerang—and a bride-to-be!) to name the haze and show practical ways through it. Micah calls today’s moment “muddy and foggy” because donors face nonstop alerts, shifting giving channels, and rising skepticism about how funds are used. Organizations feel it too: higher costs, greater need, and inboxes stuffed with appeals that all sound the same.

So what cuts through? First, stop centering money and recenter mission. As Micah says, “We don’t want to give to budgets…we want to give to people, to mission, and to impact.” Translate dollars into outcomes. “There’s nothing wrong with saying we’re raising $3,000 because it will feed 300 families”—pair the cost with the change. Then make it personal. Tell one vivid story (Stacy, Jim, or Larry), not vague totals. Shift language so the donor becomes the hero; use “you” as often as “we.” That mental switch alone sharpens your message and steadies your strategy.

Micah urges radical transparency to build trust. Be clear about what it takes to serve and honest when you’re not top-of-mind in the community. Share the real work and the real budget picture without panic language. Invite support in many forms—gifts, volunteer hours, or simple acts of advocacy—and keep communicating the difference each supporter makes.

A big unlock is specificity. Use your database tools to reference the donor’s last gift and show what it accomplished. Celebrate recurring givers and ask for modest step-ups (from $10 to $15, from $47 to $60). Those small upgrades flatten chaotic cash-flow lines and reduce the pressure that pushes teams into constant alarm. Micah reminds us that the often-forgotten “middle” donors—already engaged, steady in capacity—can become the backbone of predictable revenue when you know them well and speak to what they care about.

Bottom line: name the fog, then choose clarity. Tell one true story. Make the donor the protagonist. Map dollars to outcomes. Share the journey openly. When you do, the sun breaks through—and sustainable generosity follows.

 00:00:00 Welcome and Micah’s joyful news
 00:03:06 Defining the fundraising fog today
 00:07:14 Why budget-gap appeals miss the mark
 00:10:04 Pairing dollars with outcomes that matter
 00:11:49 Personalization and showing specific impact
 00:13:50 Radical transparency to build trust
 00:17:44 One story and donor-as-hero language
 00:20:29 Using data and merge fields smartly
 00:24:07 Middle donors and recurring upgrades
 00:26:26 Escaping crisis mode with steady revenue 

Find us Live daily on YouTube!

Find us Live daily on LinkedIn!

Find us Live daily on X: @Nonprofit_Show

Our national co-hosts and amazing guests discuss management, money and missions of nonprofits!
12:30pm ET 11:30am CT 10:30am MT 9:30am PT

Send us your ideas for Show Guests or Topics: [e-mail]
Visit us on the web:The Nonprofit Show