When Jonathan’s a Legend and Everyone Buys It | Buffy S04E17 Rewatch

Jonathan is a genius.

Jonathan is a model.

Jonathan is the Slayer’s right-hand man.

…Wait, what?

In “Superstar,” the Buffyverse turns upside down as Jonathan becomes the center of the universe—literally. With one spell, he rewrites reality so that he’s the smartest, strongest, coolest, most beloved person in Sunnydale. Buffy knows something’s off. But can she figure it out before everyone’s too starstruck to notice? A hilarious and bizarre detour with a dark twist underneath the glitter.

🎙 Hosted by your not-magically-famous Watchers:

• Rob “Snark” Clark → https://www.twitter.com/snarkyeti

• Special Guest: Brennen Marr → https://bsky.app/profile/brenmarr.bsky.social 

💬 Favorite fake Jonathan moment? How did you feel about this one on rewatch? And did you catch all the altered credits details?

👥 Join the Discord (no body swaps allowed… probably):

https://discord.gg/RFbkZek4Fm 

🪞 Feelings may vary depending on which Slayer you are today.

📣 Don’t Miss a Moment on the Hellmouth!

🧛‍♀️ Hit that Subscribe button on our YouTube channel so you never miss a Slayer showdown, Angel angst spiral, or Giles-approved breakdown:

🔗 https://youtube.com/@lgrn_postcredits?sub_confirmation=1 

📧 Business inquiries → [e-mail]

💸 SUPPORT THE COUNCIL (real or imaginary):

💵  Want to send a quick tip? CashApp ➤ $LGRN20 | Venmo ➤ @LGRN20

💓 One-time or monthly donations (with perks!) → https://ko-fi.com/lgr_network   

🅿 Monthly/Annual perks for superfans → https://patreon.com/lgr_network  

☕Treat us to caffeine: https://buymeacoffee.com/lgr_network 

👕Rep the brand: https://letsgetreadynetworkshop.com 

🌐 Follow Before You Forget What’s Real:

🌍 https://lgrn.online 

🐦 https://twitter.com/lgrnpostcredits 

🟦 https://bsky.app/profile/postcredits.lgrn.online 

📸 https://instagram.com/lgrnpostcredits 

🎵 https://tiktok.com/@lgrnpostcredits 

📖 https://facebook.com/lgrn.official 

📺 https://twitch.tv/lgrn_official 

🎬 https://letterboxd.com/lgrn_official 

🗓️🩸 This Week on the LGRN Hellmouth (Pacific Time)

(Schedule subject to prophetic dreams, vampire ambushes, or rogue witches.)

🔮 WEDNESDAYS

📼 Nostalgia Crackdown @ 5pm – We’re still talking Schmoedown… but only on the last Wednesday of the month.

🗡️ THURSDAYS

🧛 Buffy the Vampire Slayer (RWC) LIVE @ 3pm – Come for the monsters, stay for the metaphors.

🕯️ FRIDAYS

😇 Angel (RWC) @ 5pm – L.A. has a vampire problem—and he's got a soul.

🎭 SATURDAYS

🦸 MCU (RWC) @ 5pm – One universe. So many origin stories.

🕶️ LGRN After Snark – Time varies, like Giles’s accent. But Snark? Ever-present.

📓 SUNDAYS

🍷 The Open Table @ 6pm – Come decompress between prophecies.

🌌 When the Hellmouth flares…

💞 Couples Therapy – Film & feelings with Justin & his fiancée Brandi.

🎥 Hambone to the Movies – Cinematic chaos, with commentary.

📼 The Post Credits – Because there's always something to review.

🧥 What On Earth Are They Wearing? – Fashion talk worthy of Cordelia Chase.

🔖 Tags:

#BuffyTheVampireSlayer, #BuffyS04E17, #Superstar, #JonathanLevinson, #BuffyPodcast, #Buffyverse, #ReWatchersCouncil, #BuffyRewatch, #LetsGetReadyNetwork, #LGRNPostCredits, #BuffyAlternateReality, #BuffySpellEpisode, #JonathanTheHero