9: The Cry That No One Answered: The Tonie Wells Story

🖤 A 22-year-old mother. A history of abuse. A cry in the cold that should have saved her life—but didn’t. In this episode of Sleuthy Stories, we travel to Brooklyn, New York, to uncover the tragic case of Tonie Wells, a young woman who was trying to break free from a dangerous relationship. When her toddler's cries led neighbors to call 911, the horrifying discovery that followed exposed a string of systemic failures—from police negligence to a justice system that gave her killer only seven years.

This is a story of missed warning signs, heartbreaking loss, and a family still fighting for justice.

🔔 Don’t forget to follow, rate, and share if you believe stories like Tonie’s deserve to be heard.

Follow so you never miss a story. 

🎙 Available on YouTube and podcast platforms
 🔍 Want more true crime? Watch the full Sleuthy Stories videos on my channel!  (44) Sleuthy Lucy - YouTube
📢 Join the community – Become a Sleuthy Insider for exclusive content! 

SPONSOR
Stop data brokers from exposing your personal information. Go to my sponsor https://aura.com/sleuthylucy to get a 14-day free trial and see how much of yours is being sold.

 
📚 Source List:

1. New York Daily News – Coverage of Tonie Wells’ death and initial investigation
2. ABC7 New York – Reporting on the 911 call, NYPD response, and arrest of Barry Wells
3. The New York Times – Contextual information on domestic violence and law enforcement response
4. PIX11 News – Updates on the trial, sentencing, and public reaction
5. NBC News – Reports on internal NYPD investigation of the officers involved
6. Family statements and interviews – Insights shared publicly by Tonie’s family, especially her cousin Cat
7. New York Penal Law § 125.10 – Definition and implications of criminally negligent homicide
8. The “I Am Tonie Project” – Initiative started by Tonie’s family to raise awareness and advocate for legislative change
9. Cousin Kat’s Youtube Channel
10.  All royalty free music & sound effects sourced from Motion Array