All Episodes

April 9, 2025 • 109 mins

Dan & Billy welcome back longtime friend & Nostalgia Test Podcast Allstar Jeremy Madson to put Metallica's 90s MTV EraĀ to the ultimate test—THE NOSTALGIA TEST!

ā€œWe’re on the reverse trajectory of Kiss. Right? Because KISS took the makeup off in the nineties and Metallic put it on.ā€ -Jeremy Madson

The boys continue the Metallica Eras journey Nostalgia Test Podcast Metalheads with the controversial 90s studio albums The Black Album, Load, & Reload, also known as the MTV era & the Jason Newstead. Dan, Billy, & Jeremy headbang down memory lane and talk about hearing these albums for the first time, the weird transition from the thrash era to whatever this mid-life metal crisis was, the shift in Metallica's musical style, the peculiar cover art for Load & Reload, and production choices. They go track-by-track and create a 10-track merged version of Load & Reload called Unload, which you can listen to here. In the end, the guys rank the 90s era albums. Ā 

If you’re a Metallica nerd, this episode is for you. If you’re not, listen anyway and give it 5-stars.

Listen toĀ Unload on Spotify!

Email us (thenostalgiatest@gmail.com) ranking so we can share them on the next MetallicaĀ episode!Ā 

Ā 

APPROXIMATE RUN OF SHOW:

00:00 Introduction to the Metallica Nostalgia Test

00:37 Recap of Previous Episodes and Albums

01:17 The Nineties Era: MTV and Jason Newstead

01:55 Metallica's Costume Era and Music Videos

03:23 High School Memories and Metallica's Influence

09:26 The Black Album: A Turning Point

19:24 Load and Reload: The Controversial Albums

40:51 Guitar Solos and Bob Rock's Influence

41:58 Debating the Merits of 'Bleeding Me'

42:34 Critiquing 'Cure' and Other Tracks

44:24 Discussing 'Wasting My Hate'

46:38 Country Influences in Metallica's Music

47:11 The Controversial 'Mama Said'

47:46 Evaluating 'Thorn Within' and 'Ronnie'

50:42 The Outlaw Torn and Album Reflection

51:10 Nostalgia Test: Does 'Load' Hold Up?

55:50 Comparing 'Load' to Other Albums of the Era

58:13 Introduction to 'Reload' and Its Reception

58:48 Lead Singles and Album Strategy

01:00:35 Track-by-Track Breakdown of 'Reload'

01:09:32 The Unforgiven II: A Sequel Song

01:13:29 Mixed Reviews on 'Better Than You' and 'Slither'

01:14:56 Debating the Middle Part of the Song

01:15:25 Critiquing the Lyrics and Vocals

01:15:49 Generic Hard Rock and Stoner Rock Comparisons

01:16:39 Discussing 'Where the Wild Things Are'

01:17:05 Lars' Dad's Brutal Honesty

01:17:44 Evaluating 'Prince Charming'

01:18:07 The Unmemorable Riffs

01:20:33 The Irish Bar Drinking Song Vibe

01:21:20 WWE and 'Attitude'

01:21:27 The Lengthy 'Fixer'

01:23:01 Reload Exhaustion and Nostalgia

01:29:50 Ranking and Sequencing the Best Tracks

01:43:45 Final Thoughts and Ranking the Era

Ā 

Ā 

Contact/Book The Nostalgia Test Podcast!

If you had a great time listening to The Nostalgia Test Podcast and want to book us on your next podcast or have perform at your themed party, or have us host a special event, fill out the form below and LET'S GET NOSTALGIC!

We can do so many fun

Mark as Played

Advertise With Us

Popular Podcasts

Stuff You Should Know
24/7 News: The Latest

24/7 News: The Latest

The latest news in 4 minutes updated every hour, every day.

Dateline NBC

Dateline NBC

Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Follow now to get the latest episodes of Dateline NBC completely free, or subscribe to Dateline Premium for ad-free listening and exclusive bonus content: DatelinePremium.com

Music, radio and podcasts, all free. Listen online or download the iHeart App.

Connect

Ā© 2025 iHeartMedia, Inc.