July 23, 2025 • 17 mins
Reid Carter exposes the killing spree that destroyed two families. July 11th: Alex Cox executes Charles Vallow in "self-defense" while Lori hosts a pool party hours later. September: Sixteen-year-old Tylee vanishes after Yellowstone, dismembered and buried on Chad's property. Two weeks later, autistic seven-year-old JJ disappears, found wrapped in plastic and duct tape. October 19th: Tammy Daybell dies mysteriously in her sleep as Chad rushes cremation. Seventeen days later, Chad and Lori celebrate with a Hawaiian wedding while families desperately search for missing children. Between murders, the couple maintains perfect facades - posting on social media, attending conferences, collecting victim benefits. Cold-blooded efficiency disguised as divine mission.
To become a premium subscriber (no ads and no feed drops) visit caloroga.com/plus. For Apple users, hit the banner on your Apple podcasts app which seays UNINTERRUPTED LISTENING. For Spotify or other players, visit caloroga.com/plus. You also get 25+ other shows on the network ad-free! Go to Caloroga.com for all our shows!
Thanks to our sponsor https://www.booksamillion.com/p/Happiness-Experiment/Carl-B-Barney/9798886452891
To become a premium subscriber (no ads and no feed drops) visit caloroga.com/plus. For Apple users, hit the banner on your Apple podcasts app which seays UNINTERRUPTED LISTENING. For Spotify or other players, visit caloroga.com/plus. You also get 25+ other shows on the network ad-free! Go to Caloroga.com for all our shows!
Thanks to our sponsor https://www.booksamillion.com/p/Happiness-Experiment/Carl-B-Barney/9798886452891
Mark as Played
Transcript
Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:03):
Caalarogu Shark Media. Good morning, I'm read Carter, and welcome
back to Celebrity Trials. We've spent two episodes exploring how
Chad Dabell and Laurie Valo transformed from ordinary people into
self proclaimed gods with a divine mission to eliminate family members.
Today we're entering the killing phase, the summer of twenty nineteen,
(00:26):
when their twisted planning became bloody reality. What happened over
the next four months wasn't just murder. It was the
systematic destruction of a family, carried out with such callous
precision that it still shocks investigators today. By the time
Chad and Laurie were done, three people were dead, two
(00:47):
children had vanished, and the survivors were left to piece
together how people they trusted could become such efficient killers.
But here's what makes this case particularly chilling. Between each murder,
Chad and Laurie went about their normal lives. They posted
on social media, they went to conferences, they celebrated, They
(01:08):
acted like nothing had happened, because, in their twisted minds,
they weren't committing crimes. They were doing God's work. Let
me take you through the summer that changed everything, starting
with a phone call that would set everything in motion.
On July eleventh, twenty nineteen, Charles Valow drove to Laurie's
house in Chandler, Arizona, to pick up JJ for a visit.
(01:29):
It should have been a routine custody exchange. Instead, it
became the opening act of a killing spree that would
span four months and claim five lives. Charles had no
idea that he was walking into a trap that had
been months in the planning. Laurie had made sure her
brother Alex Cox would be there. She had positioned Hilely
(01:49):
as a witness. She had prepared the story they would
tell police about self defense. According to the official police report,
Alex Cox claimed that Charles became violent during an argument
with Tyley. Cox said Charles threatened the sixteen year old
with a baseball bat and that he shot Charles to
protect his niece and sister, But prosecutors would later prove
(02:11):
this was an elaborate lie. The evidence at the scene
told a different story. Charles Valow was shot twice, once
in the chest and once in the head. The second
shot was fired while Charles was already on the ground dying.
That's not self defense, that's execution. Phone records show that
in the minutes after Charles was killed, Laurie and Alex
(02:34):
were frantically calling Chad dabll not nine one one, not
for medical help. They called their spiritual leader to report
that the first obstacle had been eliminated. But here's the
detail that shows you exactly who Laurie Valo really was.
Within hours of her husband's murder, she was hosting a
pool party. Picture this for a moment. Charles Valow's body
(02:56):
has just been removed from Laurie's house by the coroner.
The police have finished processing the crime scene, and that
same evening, neighbors report hearing loud music and seeing lots
of people swimming at Laurie's house. The woman whose husband
had just been killed was celebrating. She was literally partying
on the day of his murder. When investigators later asked
her about this, Laurie claims she was just trying to
(03:18):
keep things normal for the children. But JJ wasn't even there.
He was in the custody of Charles's sister Kay after
the shooting. This wasn't grief management, this was celebration. Laurie
was marking the successful completion of phase one of their plan.
Alex Cox was questioned by police, but never charged. He
(03:38):
claimed self defense, highly backed up his story, and without
contradictory evidence, prosecutors couldn't prove otherwise. It was exactly what
Laurie had planned, a perfect murder disguised as justified protection.
But Charles Valow's death had an unexpected consequence because he
(03:59):
had changed his life insurance beneficiary from Laurie to his
sister Kay just months before his death, Laurie didn't get
the million dollar payout she was expecting. Charles had outsmarted
her from beyond the grave. Laurie was furious. Text messages
recovered from her phone show her raging about the insurance
money going to Kay instead of her. In one message
(04:20):
to Chad, she complained that Charles must have changed the
beneficiary before we got rid of him. Those five words
before we got rid of him proved that Charles's murder
was premeditated. Laurie wasn't talking about a sudden act of
self defense. She was talking about a planned execution that
didn't go exactly as intended. With Charles dead, but the
(04:44):
insurance money gone, Chad and Laurie needed to accelerate their timeline.
They still had obstacles to eliminate, and now they had
less money to fund their new life together. The children
were next on their list. In late August twenty nineteen,
Laurie moved JJ and time Hi from Arizona to Rexburg, Idaho,
to be closer to Chad. She told friends and family
(05:05):
that she wanted a fresh start after Charles's death, but
investigators would later prove she was actually preparing for the
next phase of the murders. Chad helped Laurie find a
townhouse in Rexburg, just minutes from his family home. Laurie
enrolled Jaj in school and seemed to be settling into
normal life, but behind the scenes, she and Chad were
(05:26):
finalizing their plans to eliminate the children. September eighth, twenty nineteen,
Tylee Ryan was last seen alive on a family trip
to Yellowstone National Park. Laurie had taken JJ and Tyley
to the park along with Alex Cox for what she
told them was a fun family outing. Photos from that
day show Tily smiling at the camera, unaware that her
(05:49):
mother and uncle were planning her death. But here's what
makes that Yellowstone trip so sinister Chad Dabell's phone pinged
in the same area at the same time. He wasn't
officially part of the family trip, but cell tower records
prove he was there. Prosecutors believe this was the day
Chad and Laurie finalized their plan for Tyley's murder. The
(06:12):
next day, September ninth, Tylee Ryan disappeared. Her own mother
would later claim that Tiley had gone to Byu, Idaho,
but school records show she never enrolled. Laurie told other
family members that Tylee was staying with friends, but she
could never provide names or contact information. What actually happened
to Tylee Ryan on September ninth is too horrific to
(06:35):
fully comprehend. Investigators would later find her dismembered remains buried
on Chad day Bell's property. The level of violence used
against this sixteen year old girl suggests a rage that
goes beyond simple elimination. Someone wanted to erase Tyley Ryan
from existence. But even as her daughter lay dead and buried,
(06:56):
Laurie Valo continued with her normal routine hosted on social media.
She attended religious conferences, she went on dates with Chad
day Bell, She acted like a woman whose teenage daughter
was safely away at college, not buried in pieces on
her boyfriend's property. Two weeks later, it was JJ's turn.
September twenty second, twenty nineteen, seven year old Jjvallo was
(07:21):
last seen alive by his babysitter. Laurie had asked the
babysitter to watch JJ during the day, then picked him
up that evening for what she said would be a
normal night at home, but JJ Vallo never made it
to school the next day. When the school called to
report his absence, Laurie told them that JJ was visiting
his grandmother in Louisiana. It was a lie. JJ was
(07:42):
already dead. September twenty third, twenty nineteen, phone records show
that Alex Cox's phone was pinging at Chad day Bell's
property early that morning. Investigators believe this is when JJ's
body was buried, wrapped in plastic bags and duct tails,
in a shallow grave near where his sister had been
(08:02):
buried two weeks earlier. The level of planning required to
murder and dispose of two children while maintaining the appearance
of normal life is staggering. Chad and Laurie had to
coordinate alibis, burial sites and cover stories. They had to
make sure no witnesses saw them transporting bodies. They had
to create explanations for where the children had gone that
(08:25):
would satisfy schools, family members, and child services. Most chillingly,
they had to look JJ's autism therapists in the eye
and lie about why he was suddenly unavailable for appointments.
They had to tell his grandparents that he was thriving
in his new school while his body decomposed in Chad's backyard.
(08:47):
Back in a moment, welcome back to Celebrity Trials, I'm
read Carter, and we're in the middle of the summer
of twenty nineteen, when Chad Dabell and Laurie Valo systematically
(09:08):
murdered her family members to clear the path for their
new life. Together. With Charles Tyley and JJ dead, Chad
and Laurie began implementing the cover up that they believed
would allow them to get away with triple murder. But
their lives were about to catch up with them in
ways they never expected. October twenty nineteen, with both children
(09:30):
dead and buried, Laurie needed to maintain the illusion that
they were still alive. She continued collecting JJ's Social Security benefits.
She told his therapists that he was adjusting well to
his new school. She assured concerned family members that both
children were thriving in Idaho. But Laurie made a crucial mistake.
She kept the children's belongings. In early October, surveillance cameras
(09:54):
captured Laurie and Alex Cox loading multiple storage units in
Rexburg with items that belo belonged to JJ and Tyly bikes, clothes, toys,
personal items, everything that would have been evidence of the
children's existence and death. Why keep this evidence? Prosecutors believe
Laurie was planning to eventually sell or dispose of the items,
(10:16):
but she needed to wait until enough time had passed
that no one would connect them to the missing children.
It was a calculated decision that would ultimately help convict her.
More importantly, Laurie was already planning the next murder. With
the children eliminated, only one obstacle remained between Chad and
Laurie and their new life together, Tammy day Bell. Throughout
(10:39):
September and October, Chad continued telling Tammy about his prophetic
dreams of her death. But now these weren't just spiritual visions.
They were threats disguised as revelations. Chad was psychologically preparing
his wife for her own murder. While setting up the
narrative that would explain her death, Chad also began making
practical preparations. He researched bi options and cremation procedures. He
(11:02):
updated Tammy's life insurance policies. He started talking to friends
and family about how difficult it would be to live
without her, positioning himself as the grieving widower he was
about to become. But Chad and Laurie had a problem.
Unlike Charles Valow, Tammy Day Bell wasn't involved in any
confrontations that could justify a claim of self defense. She
(11:24):
was a beloved librarian and educator with no enemies and
no history of violence. Her murder would have to look
like natural causes or an accident. The solution they devised
was as simple as it was evil. They would make
Tammy's death look like a heart attack or natural illness,
then rush to cremate her body before anyone could order
(11:45):
an autopsy. October nineteenth, twenty nineteen, Tammy Day Bell went
to bed healthy and woke up dead. Chad called nine
one one early that morning, reporting that he had found
his wife of nearly thirty years unresponsive in them. He
told paramedics that Tammy had been feeling ill the night
before and that she had a history of health problems.
(12:07):
But here's what makes Tammy's death immediately suspicious. Chad seemed
remarkably calm for someone who had just lost his wife.
Paramedics noted that he showed no emotion, no distress, no
signs of genuine grief. He seemed more concerned with controlling
the narrative than mourning his loss. Even more suspicious was
(12:28):
Chad's immediate insistence that Tammy be cremated as quickly as possible.
He told the coroner that Tammy had expressed wishes to
be cremated and that he wanted to honor her desires immediately.
There was no viewing, no extended funeral service, no time
for family and friends to say goodbye. The coroner initially
ruled Tammy's death as natural causes, citing her age and
(12:51):
apparent health issues, but Tammy's family was suspicious. They couldn't
understand how a healthy, forty nine year old woman could
die suddenly in her sleep, with no warning signs. What
they didn't know was that Chad had been poisoning their
minds for months with talk of prophetic dreams about Tammy's death.
He had convinced them that her death was spiritually inevitable,
(13:12):
even as he was actively planning to murder her. But
Chad day Bell couldn't wait to claim his prize. Within
seventeen days of Tammy's death, he married Laurie Valo in
a ceremony in Hawaii, seventeen days. Most people take longer
to plan a week end vacation than Chad took between
burying his wife and marrying her replacement. The quick remarriage
(13:36):
raised immediate red flags with both families. Tammy's relatives couldn't
understand how Chad could move on so quickly from a
woman he claimed to love deeply. Charles Valo's family was
horrified that Laurie was remarrying so soon after her husband's
violent death. But for Chad and Laurie, the Hawaii wedding
wasn't just a celebration of their love. It was a
(13:57):
victory lap They had eliminated four opst to their relationship.
They had access to insurance money and social security benefits.
They believed they had committed the perfect crimes and gotten
away with everything. The photos from their Hawaiian honeymoon show
two people who look absolutely care free. There's no guilt,
no remorse, no signs that they had just murdered three people,
(14:20):
including two children. They looked like any other couple celebrating
their new marriage. But back in Idaho and Arizona, people
were starting to ask questions, where were JJ and Tylee?
Why hadn't anyone seen them? Why were their school enrollment
records incomplete? Why couldn't Louri provide current photos or allow
family members to talk to them. Kay and Larry Woodcock,
(14:42):
JJ's grandparents through Charles, were particularly persistent. They had been
trying to contact JJ since Charles's death, but Laurie kept
giving them excuses. The boy was sick, he was adjusting
to his new school, he was too busy to talk.
By November twenty nineteen, the woods Cocks were convinced something
was wrong. They contacted Rexburg Police and asked them to
(15:04):
do a welfare check on JJ. They explained that no
one had seen or heard from the seven year old
boy in months, and they were afraid for his safety.
November twenty sixth, twenty nineteen, Rexburg police arrived at Laurie's
townhouse to check on JJ's welfare. Laurie told them that
JJ was staying with a family friend named Melanie Gibb
(15:26):
in Arizona. She seemed calm and cooperative, giving police Melanie's
contact information and assuring them that JJ was safe and happy.
But when police contacted Melanie Gibb, she told them a
very different story. JJ wasn't with her, She hadn't seen
him in months. She had no idea where he was
or why Laurie would tell police he was in her care.
(15:48):
Police returned to Laurie's house the next day with a
search warrant, but the townhouse was empty. Laurie, Chad, and
any evidence of the children's whereabouts had vanished overnight. The
hunt for the missing children had begun, but Chad and
Laurie believed they were untouchable. They had fled to Hawaii,
where they planned to wait out the investigation and start
(16:09):
their new life as spiritual leaders preparing for the apocalypse.
What they didn't realize was that their perfect crimes were
about to unravel, one lie at a time. Tomorrow, we'll
explore how Chad and Laurie's final murder led to their downfall,
and how a community's desperate search for two missing children
exposed the horrific truth about what had happened in Chad
(16:31):
Daybell's backyard. This is read Carter with celebrity trials. The
most dangerous killers aren't always the ones who look like monsters.
Sometimes they're the ones who look like your neighbors, your
family members, the people you trust most. And sometimes evil
doesn't announce itself with fanfare. It hides behind smiles, spiritual language,
(16:55):
and the promise of divine purpose.
Caalarogu Shark Media. Good morning, I'm read Carter, and welcome
back to Celebrity Trials. We've spent two episodes exploring how
Chad Dabell and Laurie Valo transformed from ordinary people into
self proclaimed gods with a divine mission to eliminate family members.
Today we're entering the killing phase, the summer of twenty nineteen,
(00:26):
when their twisted planning became bloody reality. What happened over
the next four months wasn't just murder. It was the
systematic destruction of a family, carried out with such callous
precision that it still shocks investigators today. By the time
Chad and Laurie were done, three people were dead, two
(00:47):
children had vanished, and the survivors were left to piece
together how people they trusted could become such efficient killers.
But here's what makes this case particularly chilling. Between each murder,
Chad and Laurie went about their normal lives. They posted
on social media, they went to conferences, they celebrated, They
(01:08):
acted like nothing had happened, because, in their twisted minds,
they weren't committing crimes. They were doing God's work. Let
me take you through the summer that changed everything, starting
with a phone call that would set everything in motion.
On July eleventh, twenty nineteen, Charles Valow drove to Laurie's
house in Chandler, Arizona, to pick up JJ for a visit.
(01:29):
It should have been a routine custody exchange. Instead, it
became the opening act of a killing spree that would
span four months and claim five lives. Charles had no
idea that he was walking into a trap that had
been months in the planning. Laurie had made sure her
brother Alex Cox would be there. She had positioned Hilely
(01:49):
as a witness. She had prepared the story they would
tell police about self defense. According to the official police report,
Alex Cox claimed that Charles became violent during an argument
with Tyley. Cox said Charles threatened the sixteen year old
with a baseball bat and that he shot Charles to
protect his niece and sister, But prosecutors would later prove
(02:11):
this was an elaborate lie. The evidence at the scene
told a different story. Charles Valow was shot twice, once
in the chest and once in the head. The second
shot was fired while Charles was already on the ground dying.
That's not self defense, that's execution. Phone records show that
in the minutes after Charles was killed, Laurie and Alex
(02:34):
were frantically calling Chad dabll not nine one one, not
for medical help. They called their spiritual leader to report
that the first obstacle had been eliminated. But here's the
detail that shows you exactly who Laurie Valo really was.
Within hours of her husband's murder, she was hosting a
pool party. Picture this for a moment. Charles Valow's body
(02:56):
has just been removed from Laurie's house by the coroner.
The police have finished processing the crime scene, and that
same evening, neighbors report hearing loud music and seeing lots
of people swimming at Laurie's house. The woman whose husband
had just been killed was celebrating. She was literally partying
on the day of his murder. When investigators later asked
her about this, Laurie claims she was just trying to
(03:18):
keep things normal for the children. But JJ wasn't even there.
He was in the custody of Charles's sister Kay after
the shooting. This wasn't grief management, this was celebration. Laurie
was marking the successful completion of phase one of their plan.
Alex Cox was questioned by police, but never charged. He
(03:38):
claimed self defense, highly backed up his story, and without
contradictory evidence, prosecutors couldn't prove otherwise. It was exactly what
Laurie had planned, a perfect murder disguised as justified protection.
But Charles Valow's death had an unexpected consequence because he
(03:59):
had changed his life insurance beneficiary from Laurie to his
sister Kay just months before his death, Laurie didn't get
the million dollar payout she was expecting. Charles had outsmarted
her from beyond the grave. Laurie was furious. Text messages
recovered from her phone show her raging about the insurance
money going to Kay instead of her. In one message
(04:20):
to Chad, she complained that Charles must have changed the
beneficiary before we got rid of him. Those five words
before we got rid of him proved that Charles's murder
was premeditated. Laurie wasn't talking about a sudden act of
self defense. She was talking about a planned execution that
didn't go exactly as intended. With Charles dead, but the
(04:44):
insurance money gone, Chad and Laurie needed to accelerate their timeline.
They still had obstacles to eliminate, and now they had
less money to fund their new life together. The children
were next on their list. In late August twenty nineteen,
Laurie moved JJ and time Hi from Arizona to Rexburg, Idaho,
to be closer to Chad. She told friends and family
(05:05):
that she wanted a fresh start after Charles's death, but
investigators would later prove she was actually preparing for the
next phase of the murders. Chad helped Laurie find a
townhouse in Rexburg, just minutes from his family home. Laurie
enrolled Jaj in school and seemed to be settling into
normal life, but behind the scenes, she and Chad were
(05:26):
finalizing their plans to eliminate the children. September eighth, twenty nineteen,
Tylee Ryan was last seen alive on a family trip
to Yellowstone National Park. Laurie had taken JJ and Tyley
to the park along with Alex Cox for what she
told them was a fun family outing. Photos from that
day show Tily smiling at the camera, unaware that her
(05:49):
mother and uncle were planning her death. But here's what
makes that Yellowstone trip so sinister Chad Dabell's phone pinged
in the same area at the same time. He wasn't
officially part of the family trip, but cell tower records
prove he was there. Prosecutors believe this was the day
Chad and Laurie finalized their plan for Tyley's murder. The
(06:12):
next day, September ninth, Tylee Ryan disappeared. Her own mother
would later claim that Tiley had gone to Byu, Idaho,
but school records show she never enrolled. Laurie told other
family members that Tylee was staying with friends, but she
could never provide names or contact information. What actually happened
to Tylee Ryan on September ninth is too horrific to
(06:35):
fully comprehend. Investigators would later find her dismembered remains buried
on Chad day Bell's property. The level of violence used
against this sixteen year old girl suggests a rage that
goes beyond simple elimination. Someone wanted to erase Tyley Ryan
from existence. But even as her daughter lay dead and buried,
(06:56):
Laurie Valo continued with her normal routine hosted on social media.
She attended religious conferences, she went on dates with Chad
day Bell, She acted like a woman whose teenage daughter
was safely away at college, not buried in pieces on
her boyfriend's property. Two weeks later, it was JJ's turn.
September twenty second, twenty nineteen, seven year old Jjvallo was
(07:21):
last seen alive by his babysitter. Laurie had asked the
babysitter to watch JJ during the day, then picked him
up that evening for what she said would be a
normal night at home, but JJ Vallo never made it
to school the next day. When the school called to
report his absence, Laurie told them that JJ was visiting
his grandmother in Louisiana. It was a lie. JJ was
(07:42):
already dead. September twenty third, twenty nineteen, phone records show
that Alex Cox's phone was pinging at Chad day Bell's
property early that morning. Investigators believe this is when JJ's
body was buried, wrapped in plastic bags and duct tails,
in a shallow grave near where his sister had been
(08:02):
buried two weeks earlier. The level of planning required to
murder and dispose of two children while maintaining the appearance
of normal life is staggering. Chad and Laurie had to
coordinate alibis, burial sites and cover stories. They had to
make sure no witnesses saw them transporting bodies. They had
to create explanations for where the children had gone that
(08:25):
would satisfy schools, family members, and child services. Most chillingly,
they had to look JJ's autism therapists in the eye
and lie about why he was suddenly unavailable for appointments.
They had to tell his grandparents that he was thriving
in his new school while his body decomposed in Chad's backyard.
(08:47):
Back in a moment, welcome back to Celebrity Trials, I'm
read Carter, and we're in the middle of the summer
of twenty nineteen, when Chad Dabell and Laurie Valo systematically
(09:08):
murdered her family members to clear the path for their
new life. Together. With Charles Tyley and JJ dead, Chad
and Laurie began implementing the cover up that they believed
would allow them to get away with triple murder. But
their lives were about to catch up with them in
ways they never expected. October twenty nineteen, with both children
(09:30):
dead and buried, Laurie needed to maintain the illusion that
they were still alive. She continued collecting JJ's Social Security benefits.
She told his therapists that he was adjusting well to
his new school. She assured concerned family members that both
children were thriving in Idaho. But Laurie made a crucial mistake.
She kept the children's belongings. In early October, surveillance cameras
(09:54):
captured Laurie and Alex Cox loading multiple storage units in
Rexburg with items that belo belonged to JJ and Tyly bikes, clothes, toys,
personal items, everything that would have been evidence of the
children's existence and death. Why keep this evidence? Prosecutors believe
Laurie was planning to eventually sell or dispose of the items,
(10:16):
but she needed to wait until enough time had passed
that no one would connect them to the missing children.
It was a calculated decision that would ultimately help convict her.
More importantly, Laurie was already planning the next murder. With
the children eliminated, only one obstacle remained between Chad and
Laurie and their new life together, Tammy day Bell. Throughout
(10:39):
September and October, Chad continued telling Tammy about his prophetic
dreams of her death. But now these weren't just spiritual visions.
They were threats disguised as revelations. Chad was psychologically preparing
his wife for her own murder. While setting up the
narrative that would explain her death, Chad also began making
practical preparations. He researched bi options and cremation procedures. He
(11:02):
updated Tammy's life insurance policies. He started talking to friends
and family about how difficult it would be to live
without her, positioning himself as the grieving widower he was
about to become. But Chad and Laurie had a problem.
Unlike Charles Valow, Tammy Day Bell wasn't involved in any
confrontations that could justify a claim of self defense. She
(11:24):
was a beloved librarian and educator with no enemies and
no history of violence. Her murder would have to look
like natural causes or an accident. The solution they devised
was as simple as it was evil. They would make
Tammy's death look like a heart attack or natural illness,
then rush to cremate her body before anyone could order
(11:45):
an autopsy. October nineteenth, twenty nineteen, Tammy Day Bell went
to bed healthy and woke up dead. Chad called nine
one one early that morning, reporting that he had found
his wife of nearly thirty years unresponsive in them. He
told paramedics that Tammy had been feeling ill the night
before and that she had a history of health problems.
(12:07):
But here's what makes Tammy's death immediately suspicious. Chad seemed
remarkably calm for someone who had just lost his wife.
Paramedics noted that he showed no emotion, no distress, no
signs of genuine grief. He seemed more concerned with controlling
the narrative than mourning his loss. Even more suspicious was
(12:28):
Chad's immediate insistence that Tammy be cremated as quickly as possible.
He told the coroner that Tammy had expressed wishes to
be cremated and that he wanted to honor her desires immediately.
There was no viewing, no extended funeral service, no time
for family and friends to say goodbye. The coroner initially
ruled Tammy's death as natural causes, citing her age and
(12:51):
apparent health issues, but Tammy's family was suspicious. They couldn't
understand how a healthy, forty nine year old woman could
die suddenly in her sleep, with no warning signs. What
they didn't know was that Chad had been poisoning their
minds for months with talk of prophetic dreams about Tammy's death.
He had convinced them that her death was spiritually inevitable,
(13:12):
even as he was actively planning to murder her. But
Chad day Bell couldn't wait to claim his prize. Within
seventeen days of Tammy's death, he married Laurie Valo in
a ceremony in Hawaii, seventeen days. Most people take longer
to plan a week end vacation than Chad took between
burying his wife and marrying her replacement. The quick remarriage
(13:36):
raised immediate red flags with both families. Tammy's relatives couldn't
understand how Chad could move on so quickly from a
woman he claimed to love deeply. Charles Valo's family was
horrified that Laurie was remarrying so soon after her husband's
violent death. But for Chad and Laurie, the Hawaii wedding
wasn't just a celebration of their love. It was a
(13:57):
victory lap They had eliminated four opst to their relationship.
They had access to insurance money and social security benefits.
They believed they had committed the perfect crimes and gotten
away with everything. The photos from their Hawaiian honeymoon show
two people who look absolutely care free. There's no guilt,
no remorse, no signs that they had just murdered three people,
(14:20):
including two children. They looked like any other couple celebrating
their new marriage. But back in Idaho and Arizona, people
were starting to ask questions, where were JJ and Tylee?
Why hadn't anyone seen them? Why were their school enrollment
records incomplete? Why couldn't Louri provide current photos or allow
family members to talk to them. Kay and Larry Woodcock,
(14:42):
JJ's grandparents through Charles, were particularly persistent. They had been
trying to contact JJ since Charles's death, but Laurie kept
giving them excuses. The boy was sick, he was adjusting
to his new school, he was too busy to talk.
By November twenty nineteen, the woods Cocks were convinced something
was wrong. They contacted Rexburg Police and asked them to
(15:04):
do a welfare check on JJ. They explained that no
one had seen or heard from the seven year old
boy in months, and they were afraid for his safety.
November twenty sixth, twenty nineteen, Rexburg police arrived at Laurie's
townhouse to check on JJ's welfare. Laurie told them that
JJ was staying with a family friend named Melanie Gibb
(15:26):
in Arizona. She seemed calm and cooperative, giving police Melanie's
contact information and assuring them that JJ was safe and happy.
But when police contacted Melanie Gibb, she told them a
very different story. JJ wasn't with her, She hadn't seen
him in months. She had no idea where he was
or why Laurie would tell police he was in her care.
(15:48):
Police returned to Laurie's house the next day with a
search warrant, but the townhouse was empty. Laurie, Chad, and
any evidence of the children's whereabouts had vanished overnight. The
hunt for the missing children had begun, but Chad and
Laurie believed they were untouchable. They had fled to Hawaii,
where they planned to wait out the investigation and start
(16:09):
their new life as spiritual leaders preparing for the apocalypse.
What they didn't realize was that their perfect crimes were
about to unravel, one lie at a time. Tomorrow, we'll
explore how Chad and Laurie's final murder led to their downfall,
and how a community's desperate search for two missing children
exposed the horrific truth about what had happened in Chad
(16:31):
Daybell's backyard. This is read Carter with celebrity trials. The
most dangerous killers aren't always the ones who look like monsters.
Sometimes they're the ones who look like your neighbors, your
family members, the people you trust most. And sometimes evil
doesn't announce itself with fanfare. It hides behind smiles, spiritual language,
(16:55):
and the promise of divine purpose.
Popular Podcasts
Stuff You Should Know
If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.
Dateline NBC
Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Special Summer Offer: Exclusively on Apple Podcasts, try our Dateline Premium subscription completely free for one month! With Dateline Premium, you get every episode ad-free plus exclusive bonus content.
On Purpose with Jay Shetty
I’m Jay Shetty host of On Purpose the worlds #1 Mental Health podcast and I’m so grateful you found us. I started this podcast 5 years ago to invite you into conversations and workshops that are designed to help make you happier, healthier and more healed. I believe that when you (yes you) feel seen, heard and understood you’re able to deal with relationship struggles, work challenges and life’s ups and downs with more ease and grace. I interview experts, celebrities, thought leaders and athletes so that we can grow our mindset, build better habits and uncover a side of them we’ve never seen before. New episodes every Monday and Friday. Your support means the world to me and I don’t take it for granted — click the follow button and leave a review to help us spread the love with On Purpose. I can’t wait for you to listen to your first or 500th episode!