H.E.R.B.I.E. From The Fantastic Four

Picture this: You're expecting a high-octane superhero adventure with the Fantastic Four. Instead, you get a robot. Not just any robot, but Herbie – a mechanical sidekick so bizarre, so utterly out of place, that he would become a legendary cautionary tale of superhero adaptation gone wrong. Standing barely waist-high, with all the combat effectiveness of a malfunctioning kitchen appliance, Herbie represents the absolute nadir of superhero television creativity.

Welcome to Monsters, Sharks, and Dinosaurs. Today we're exploring the most infamous robot in superhero history – Herbie., the Humanoid Experimental Robot, B-Type, Integrated Electronics, who infamously replaced the Human Torch in the 1978 Fantastic Four animated series.
The origin of Herbie is a perfect storm of licensing complications and questionable creative decisions. In the late 19 seventies, Marvel was in the habit of licensing its characters to various media companies with a seemingly random approach.

The Human Torch found himself caught in a legal limbo, with Universal exploring the possibility of a live-action series. This potential show never materialized, but it was enough to keep Johnny Storm completely absent from the 1978 Fantastic Four cartoon.

Unlock an ad-free podcast experience with Caloroga Shark Media! Get all our shows on any player you love, hassle free! For Apple users, hit the banner on your Apple podcasts app. For Spotify or other players, visit caloroga.com/plus. No plug-ins needed!

Subscribe now for exclusive shows like 'Palace Intrigue,' and get bonus content from Deep Crown (our exclusive Palace Insider!) Or get 'Daily Comedy News,' and '5 Good News Stories’ with no commercials! Plans start at $4.99 per month, or save 20% with a yearly plan at $49.99. Join today and help support the show!

We now have Merch!  FREE SHIPPING! Check out all the products like T-shirts, mugs, bags, jackets and more with logos and slogans from your favorite shows! Did we mention there’s free shipping? Get 10% off with code NewMerch10 Go to Caloroga.com

Get more info from Caloroga Shark Media and if you have any comments, suggestions, or just want to get in touch our email is [e-mail]

Episode Transcript

Speaker 1 (00:03):
Calarogu Shark Media. Picture this. You're expecting a high octane
superhero adventure with the Fantastic Four. Instead, you get a robot.
Not just any robot, but Herbie, a mechanical sidekick so bizarre,

(00:26):
so utterly out of place, that he would become a
legendary cautionary tale of superhero adaptation gone wrong. Standing barely
waist high with all the combat effectiveness of a malfunctioning
kitchen appliance, Herbie represents the absolute nedea of superhero television creativity.

(00:53):
Welcome to Monsters, sharks, and dinosaurs. Today we're exploring the
most infamous robot in superhero history, Herbie, the humanoid experimental
robot B type Integrated Electronics who infamously replaced the Human
Torch in the nineteen seventy eight Fantastic Four animated series.

(01:17):
The origin of Herbie is a perfect storm of licensing
complications and questionable creative decisions. In the late nineteen seventies,
Marvel was in the habit of licensing its characters to
various media companies with a seemingly random approach. The Human
Torch found himself caught in a legal limbo with Universal

(01:41):
exploring the possibility of a live action series. This potential
show never materialized, but it was enough to keep Johnny
Storm completely absent from the nineteen seventy eight Fantastic four cartoon.
Stan Lee himself was tasked with creating a replacement for

(02:03):
the Human Torch. His solution Herbie, a robot so underwhelming
that he would become a punchline in superhero animation history.
Lee commissioned legendary comics writer Dave Cockrum to design the character,
a task that would push even a seasoned professional to

(02:25):
his limits. The design process was reportedly so frustrating that
Cochrum allegedly walked away from the project in disgust. Jack
Kirby ultimately had to step in to complete Herbie's design,
adding insult to injury for a character that nobody wanted.
When the show aired, fans' worst fears were confirmed. Herbie

(02:49):
wasn't just a poor substitute for the Human Torch. He
was a complete narrative disaster. The robot's primary functions seemed
to be performing basic research tasks that read Richards could
easily do himself, stating the obvious after the fact, and
engaging in petty arguments with the thing. In one particularly

(03:10):
memorable moment, after read Richards loses a battle with Magneto,
Herbie provides the brilliant observation, my senses tell me that
something is not right. This level of insight epitomizes the
robot's complete narrative uselessness. The show's dynamic quickly became the

(03:33):
Fantastic Three and their pet robot. Herbie rarely participated in
actual combat, instead staying behind at headquarters to perform what
can generously be described as administrative tasks. His primary contribution
seemed to be cleaning the Fantastic Four's headquarters, essentially functioning

(03:55):
as a high tech janitor. While initially created solely for
the television show, Herbie would later be awkwardly incorporated into
Marvel Comics. His role shifted from team member to essentially
a servant, performing research, maintenance, and babysitting duties. The ultimate
indignity came when he was hacked by an evil cyborg,

(04:18):
tried to kill everyone, and ultimately self destructed. This narrative
arc perfectly encapsulates the fundamental problem with Herbie. He was
a solution to a problem that didn't exist, created through
a combination of licensing constraints and misguided creativity. The robot's

(04:39):
design was equally uninspired. Unlike the dynamic, flame powered Human Torch,
Herbie was a static, unimpressive, mechanical creation. Where Johnny Storm
represented youthful energy and rebellion, Herbie embodied bureaucratic tedium. Fans
were predictably furious. The Fantastic Four had always been about dynamic,

(05:03):
powerful personalities. The Human Torch was a core part of
the team's chemistry, brash, cocky and full of youthful energy.
Replacing him with a robot that spent most of its
time doing research and cleaning was nothing short of narrative betrayal.
The nineteen seventy eight series lasted only thirteen episodes, a

(05:28):
testament to its complete failure to capture the essence of
the Fantastic Four. Herbie became a cautionary tale, a perfect
example of how not to adapt a beloved superhero property.
Yet there's something almost endearing about Herbie's spectacular failure. In

(05:48):
an era of carefully managed superhero franchises, he represents a
moment of pure, unfiltered creative chaos. He is a reminder
that even the most well intentioned adaptations can go spectacularly wrong.
Modern pop culture has embraced Herbie as a sort of
ironic mascot. He represents the ultimate so bad It's good

(06:13):
moment in superhero history. Comic conventions feature costs, players dressed
as the robot, fans create memes, and He's become a
beloved piece of superhero trivia. The broader lesson of Herbie
extends beyond just one terrible animated series. He represents the

(06:33):
challenges of adapting comic book characters to other media. How
do you capture the essence of a character? How do
you balance creative vision with fan expectations. In many ways,
Herbie is a perfect microcosm of nineteen seventies television production,

(06:54):
well intentioned but fundamentally misguided. He reflects an era of
television where creators seem to have a tenuous understanding of
what made their source material compelling. Subsequent Fantastic Four adaptations
would go to great lengths to avoid repeating the Herbie mistake.
The human Torch would be restored to his rightful place,

(07:17):
bringing back the team's dynamic energy and youthful spirit. The
Robot's legacy is ultimately one of unintentional comedy, A character
so bad that he becomes good, a testament to the
sometimes absurd world of superhero adaptation. The most fascinating aspect

(07:39):
of Herbie's legacy is how a seemingly forgettable character became
a cult phenomenon. Comic book fans and pop culture enthusiasts
have transformed the robot from a narrative disaster into an
ironic icon of nineteen seventy superhero absurdity. In the decades

(07:59):
since his disastrous debut, Herbie has undergone several unexpected transformations.
In comic book law writers have attempted to rehabilitate the character,
giving him surprising depth and even moments of genuine heroism.
Some comic storylines have reimagined Herbie as a more complex

(08:21):
artificial intelligence, exploring themes of sentience and purpose that were
completely absent in his original incarnation. More in a moment,

(08:49):
Urban legends surrounding Herbie's creation have become almost as legendary
as the character himself. The most persistent rumor that he
was created because network ex secutives feared children would set
themselves on fire trying to imitate the human torch, has
been debunked, but it remains a beloved piece of pop

(09:09):
culture mythology. It speaks to the perceived patronizing nature of
nineteen seventies children's programming, where creators seem to view their
audience with a mixture of condescension and fear. Technological historians
have found an unexpected value in Herbie. The Robot represents

(09:29):
a fascinating snapshot of how mid nineteen seventy's popular culture
imagined artificial intelligence. He embodies the era's somewhat naive conception
of robots helpful but limited, more administrative assistant than true intelligence.
In many ways, Herbie is a time capsule of technological imagination,

(09:54):
showing how far our understanding of AI has come. Comic
conventions and online fan communities have embraced Herbie with a
sense of ironic celebration. Cosplayers create elaborate Herbie costumes, Meme
creators have turned his most ridiculous moments into Internet gold,

(10:15):
and collectors seek out vintage Herbie merchandise as a kind
of kitchy trophy of superhero absurdity. Even Stanley himself seemed
to view Herbie with a mixture of amusement and affection.
In later years, in various interviews, he would reference the

(10:36):
character as an example of the sometimes bizarre compromises necessary
in adapting comic books to other media. What was once
a potential embarrassment became a point of nostalgic humor. The
character has inspired broader conversations about creative adaptation. Herbie represents

(10:57):
a cautionary tale about what happens when licensing issues, network interference,
and creative compromise collide. He's become a symbol of the
sometimes absurd world of superhero media adaptation. In recent years,
some comic writers have attempted to give Herbie a more

(11:18):
dignified narrative arc. Modern interpretations have explored the potential consciousness
of artificial beings, turning the once laughable robot into a
more complex character grappling with questions of identity and purpose.
Perhaps the most unexpected legacy of Herbie is how he

(11:39):
represents a specific moment in superhero media, an era of
low budget animation, limited creative vision, and bizarre corporate compromises.
He's a reminder that even the most ridiculous creative decisions
can become beloved parts of pop culture history. That wraps

(12:01):
up our exploration of Herbie, the robot nobody asked for
but everyone remembers a testament to the fact that, in
the world of superheroes, sometimes the most unlikely characters become
the most memorable. Join us next time on Monsters, Sharks,
and Dinosaurs as we examine another legendary figure that captures

(12:26):
our imagination. Until then, keep your senses calibrated and your
expectations delightfully low.