August 7, 2025 • 14 mins
Spring Valley, Pennsylvania, February 2019—the Williams family seemed perfect on the surface: David, the hardworking father; Sarah, the warm second wife; and Emily, the teenage daughter from his previous marriage. But behind the walls of their two-story home lies a forbidden secret: the illicit relationship between Sarah and Emily, which escalates from emotional comfort into a dangerous affair. When David discovers shocking photographic evidence, his family crumbles. Four days later, Emily lies bleeding on the floor, and Sarah stands over her holding a fireplace poker.
In this episode, you’ll learn how twisted love turned into dangerous obsession, leading to brutal violence and attempted murder. We discuss psychological manipulation, emotional control, and crucial evidence in the form of a secret journal revealing Sarah’s intent to kidnap Emily. Learn how forensic evidence and the victim’s testimony ultimately brought justice, and how fragile the line is between love and control in the dynamics between victim and perpetrator.
In this episode, you’ll learn how twisted love turned into dangerous obsession, leading to brutal violence and attempted murder. We discuss psychological manipulation, emotional control, and crucial evidence in the form of a secret journal revealing Sarah’s intent to kidnap Emily. Learn how forensic evidence and the victim’s testimony ultimately brought justice, and how fragile the line is between love and control in the dynamics between victim and perpetrator.
Mark as Played
Transcript
Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:05):
Today's case is one of shocking betrayal, twisted emotions, and
a tragic ending that no one saw coming. So let's begin.
It was a chilly evening on February third, twenty nineteen,
in the quiet suburban neighborhood of Spring Valley, PA. The
streets were calm, lined with bare trees that swayed gently
(00:26):
under the pale light a SD lamps. Inside the cozy
two story house on Oakwood Drive, the Williams family was
about to experience a nightmare that would forever change their lives.
David Williams, a successful real estate agent in his mid forties,
lived with his wife Sarah and his nineteen year old
daughter Emily from a previous marriage. From the outside, they
(00:48):
seemed like a perfectly normal family. David, hard working and dedicated,
had found love again after the death of his first wife. Sarah,
in her mid thirties, was warm, warm, charismatic, and seemingly
adored by everyone who knew her. She had taken on
the role of stepmother to Emily with ease, blending into
(01:08):
the family effortlessly. Emily, though initially resistant to her father's remarriage,
had grown close to Sarah over the years. The bond
they shared seemed genuine, at least on the surface, But
beneath this veneer of happiness there was a secret, one
so dark and twisted that its revelation would lead to
unimaginable tragedy. As time passed, subtle changes started to occur
(01:34):
in the William's household. Emily, who had always been a
bright and lively young woman, began to withdraw her father
noticed she was spending more time in her room, avoiding
conversations and seemed to be lost in her thoughts. She
wasn't dating anyone, hadn't had any major fallouts with friends,
and her grades at college were still good. David chalked
(01:57):
it up to the stresses of transitioning to adulthood. But
Sara's behavior was even more puzzling. She had grown increasingly distant,
spending hours away from home without explanation, often claiming she
was visiting friends or running errands. David, busy with his career,
didn't think much of it until he noticed the tension
between Sarah and Emily. On several occasions, David came home
(02:21):
to find the two women sitting in uncomfortable silence. Sometimes
he caught quick glances exchanged between them, almost like they
were hiding something. He asked Emily if anything was wrong,
but she brushed it off, assuring him that everything was fine. Sarah, too,
would dismiss his concerns, saying they just had the usual
(02:42):
mother daughter disagreements, but David couldn't shake the feeling that
there was more to it. Then, in March twenty nineteen,
things took a dramatic turn. One evening, David returned home
earlier than usual and overheard a heated argument between Sarah
and Emily. Their voices were muffled, but the tension was palpable.
(03:04):
As he walked up the stairs, he caught a glimpse
of Sara storming out of Emily's room, her face flushed
with anger. Emily, on the other hand, looked distressed, her
eyes red and puffy from crying. David, deeply concerned, confronted
them both, but neither was willing to talk. What he
didn't know at the time was that Emily was hiding
(03:25):
a secret, one that would soon tear the family apart.
Emily had been in a relationship, but it wasn't with
someone her father would ever have expected. It wasn't with
a classmate or a childhood friend. The person she had
been involved with was none other than her own stepmother, Sara.
The affair had started subtly, almost innocently, months earlier. Sara,
(03:49):
who had always been attentive and caring, had been there
for Emily during some difficult times. What began as the
emotional support evolved into something far more intimate. Emily, vulnerable
and confused, found herself drawn to Sara in ways she
couldn't understand. Sara, too was caught in a whirlwind of emotions,
(04:11):
torn between her role as a mother figure and her
growing attraction to Emily. They had managed to keep their
relationship hidden for a while, but the strain was beginning
to show. Emily, riddled with guilt, had tried to distance
herself from Sarah, but Sara's hold on her was too strong.
The intensity of their affair was building, and with each
(04:31):
passing day, the tension between them grew unbearable. On April fifteenth,
two thousand nineteen, the secret finally exploded into the open.
That evening, David received an anonymous e mail. It contained
no text, just a series of photos, photos of Sara
and Omily together in moments that were far from innocent.
(04:53):
His heart pounded in his chest as he scrolled through
the images, disbelief turning to rage. He stored out of
the house, not wanting to confront either of them in
the heat of the moment, but knowing that their lives
would never be the same again. Four days David stayed
in a hotel, refusing to answer calls from either Sarah
(05:13):
or Emily. The betrayal was too deep, too raw. But
on April twentieth, he returned home, ready to confront the
situation head on. What he didn't anticipate was just how
dangerous things had become. Sarah and Emily's relationship had grown
even more unstable in David's absence. Emily, racked with guilt
(05:35):
and fear of her father's reaction, had tried to break
things off with Sarah, but Sarah refused to let her go.
The once caring stepmother had become possessive, obsessed with keeping
Emily close. They argued constantly, their once secret affair now
an open wound that festered in the home. On the
night of April twenty, third, tragedy struck. It was around
(05:58):
nine PM when the neighbors first heard the screams. A
frantic nine one. One call was made by a passerby
who reported loud, arguing and crashing sounds coming from the
William's house. When the police arrived, they found the front
door ajar and the scene inside was nothing short of horrifying.
Emily lay on the living room floor, barely conscious, blood
(06:22):
pooling around her from a deep gash on her head.
Sarah stood over her, holding a fireplace poker, her face
pale and eyes wide with shock, it was clear that
something had gone terribly wrong. As the police restrained Sarah
and rushed Emily to the hospital, the truth of what
had happened began to unfold. Emily's injuries were severe, and
(06:44):
doctors worked through the night to save her. Meanwhile, Sarah
was taken into custody, charged with assault, but the full
story of that night was still shrouded in mystery, leaving
both the police and David with more questions than answers.
What had driven Sarah to such violence? Was it a
crime of passion or was there something more sinister at play.
(07:07):
As the investigation continued, shocking details emerged about the events
leading up to the attack, and what the detectives would
uncover next would leave everyone stunned. Setting the stage for
a tragic and final confrontation. As the police investigated the
events leading up to the assault, more disturbing truths came
to light. Emily remained in critical condition in the hospital,
(07:30):
fighting for her life, while Sarah sat behind bars awaiting
formal charges. But what had caused their already tumultuous relationship
to spiral into violence? What was it that Sarah was
hiding and could it have been prevented. In the days
following the attack, David Williams struggled to make sense of
what had happened. He spent hours by his daughter's bedside,
(07:53):
hoping she would wake up and give him the answers
he so desperately needed. The betrayal he felt from Sarah
was unbearable. How could the woman he loved, the woman
who had helped raise his daughter, be responsible for this
horrific act. The police, too, were determined to uncover the
full story. Detectives began piecing together the events that led
(08:15):
to the tragic night of April twenty third. What they
discovered was a chilling account of manipulation, emotional abuse, and
unrelenting control. It turned out that Sara had not simply
been a loving stepmother to Emily. Behind closed doors, she
had exerted a disturbing influence over her stepdaughter, carefully manipulating
(08:36):
Emily's emotions. Over the course of several months, what had
started as a closed bond had quickly turned into something
much darker. Sarah, unable to control her growing obsession, had
used her position of power within the family to manipulate
Emily into a relationship that crossed every line. Emily, emotionally
vulnerable and struggling with her own identity, had fallen deeper
(08:59):
into the affair, unsure of how to escape Sarah's grasp.
When she finally tried to pull away, it was too late.
Sarah's possessiveness had reached its breaking point. The night of
the attack, Tensions had been running high in the William's
household after receiving the anonymous e mail exposing their affair.
(09:19):
David's sudden departure left both Sarah and Emily on edge.
With David gone, the full weight of the situation began
to sink in for Emily. Overwhelmed with guilt and fear
of the inevitable fallout, she confronted Sarah, begging to end
their relationship for good, but Sarah wouldn't hear it. What
followed was a terrifying argument that escalated into violence. Sarah,
(09:44):
consumed by anger and desperation, had grabbed the fireplace poker
in a fit of rage and struck Emily, sending her
crashing to the floor. The physical wounds were severe, but
the emotional scars ran even deeper. It was clear that
Sara's abst session had driven her to the edge, and
now there was no turning back. But this wasn't the
(10:05):
end of the story. As the investigation continued, detectives uncovered
another shocking revelation that would turn the case on its head.
During a thorough search of Sarah's personal belongings, the police
found a hidden journal tucked away in the back of
her closet. Inside its pages were chilling entries that painted
a disturbing picture of Sarah's mindset leading up to the attack.
(10:28):
The journal revealed that Sarah had been planning to run
away with Emily. In the weeks before the assault. She
had written extensively about her feelings for her stepdaughter, describing
an unhealthy mix of love, jealousy, and control. Sarah's obsession
had grown to such a degree that she was willing
to destroy everything to keep Emily by her side, even
(10:49):
if it meant tearing apart the family and taking Emily
away from everyone she knew. One particular entry, dated April
twenty first, just two days before the attack, stood out,
I can't let her leave me. She's everything to me.
If David finds out, we'll lose it all. I need
to make her understand that we're meant to be together,
(11:11):
no matter what. If I have to, I'll take her
away where no one can find us. I won't let
any one stand in our way, not even her. The
discovery of the journal provided the police with the final
peace of the puzzle. This was not simply an act
of passion. It was a premeditated crime. Sarah had been
(11:32):
planning to isolate Emily, to remove her from the world
and keep her under her control. The confrontation that night
was not an isolated incident, but the culmination of months
of emotional manipulation and psychological abuse. With this new evidence,
the prosecution moved forward with charges of attempted murder along
with assault and unlawful restraint. The trial that followed captivated
(11:56):
the nation as the details of the sordid affair and
the shocking extent of Sarah's obsession were revealed to the public.
Throughout the trial, David Williams remained a silent but constant
presence in the courtroom. His once perfect family had been shattered,
and the woman he had loved now stood accused of
trying to kill his daughter. The pain of betrayal was
(12:16):
etched on his face as he listened to the harrowing
details of Sarah's manipulation and Emily's suffering. Emily, after several
surgeries and months of recovery, took the stand during the trial.
Her testimony was heartbreaking, recounting the months of emotional control
Sarah had exerted over her. She spoke of how confused
(12:37):
and trapped she felt, unable to see a way out
of the toxic relationship until it was too late. Emily's
words were powerful, and they painted a clear picture of
Sarah's disturbing influence over her. The jury deliberated for several days,
but in the end, the verdict was unanimous guilty on
all charges. Sarah was sentenced to twenty five years in
(12:59):
pre for her role in the crime, with the possibility
of parole after twenty years. For many the sentence seemed
too lenient given the extent of the damage she had caused,
but for David and Emily, it was a step toward healing,
a chance to move forward from the nightmare they had endured.
As the years passed, Emily worked hard to rebuild her life.
(13:22):
The scars of the past would always be there, but
with therapy and the support of her father, she was
able to find a sense of normalcy again. She returned
to college, determined to finish her degree and start a
new chapter, one free from the darkness that had consumed her.
For David, the road to recovery was long. The betrayal
(13:42):
from Sarah had left a deep wound, but his focus
remained on his daughter's well being. He sold the house
on Oakwood d r unable to bear the memories of
what had happened there. The quiet neighborhood of Spring Valley
eventually returned to its peaceful routine, but the tragic events
that unfolded inside that house would never be forgotten. This
(14:03):
case stands as a stark reminder of how easily loved
can turn into obsession, and how even the people we
trust the most can hide dangerous secrets.
Today's case is one of shocking betrayal, twisted emotions, and
a tragic ending that no one saw coming. So let's begin.
It was a chilly evening on February third, twenty nineteen,
in the quiet suburban neighborhood of Spring Valley, PA. The
streets were calm, lined with bare trees that swayed gently
(00:26):
under the pale light a SD lamps. Inside the cozy
two story house on Oakwood Drive, the Williams family was
about to experience a nightmare that would forever change their lives.
David Williams, a successful real estate agent in his mid forties,
lived with his wife Sarah and his nineteen year old
daughter Emily from a previous marriage. From the outside, they
(00:48):
seemed like a perfectly normal family. David, hard working and dedicated,
had found love again after the death of his first wife. Sarah,
in her mid thirties, was warm, warm, charismatic, and seemingly
adored by everyone who knew her. She had taken on
the role of stepmother to Emily with ease, blending into
(01:08):
the family effortlessly. Emily, though initially resistant to her father's remarriage,
had grown close to Sarah over the years. The bond
they shared seemed genuine, at least on the surface, But
beneath this veneer of happiness there was a secret, one
so dark and twisted that its revelation would lead to
unimaginable tragedy. As time passed, subtle changes started to occur
(01:34):
in the William's household. Emily, who had always been a
bright and lively young woman, began to withdraw her father
noticed she was spending more time in her room, avoiding
conversations and seemed to be lost in her thoughts. She
wasn't dating anyone, hadn't had any major fallouts with friends,
and her grades at college were still good. David chalked
(01:57):
it up to the stresses of transitioning to adulthood. But
Sara's behavior was even more puzzling. She had grown increasingly distant,
spending hours away from home without explanation, often claiming she
was visiting friends or running errands. David, busy with his career,
didn't think much of it until he noticed the tension
between Sarah and Emily. On several occasions, David came home
(02:21):
to find the two women sitting in uncomfortable silence. Sometimes
he caught quick glances exchanged between them, almost like they
were hiding something. He asked Emily if anything was wrong,
but she brushed it off, assuring him that everything was fine. Sarah, too,
would dismiss his concerns, saying they just had the usual
(02:42):
mother daughter disagreements, but David couldn't shake the feeling that
there was more to it. Then, in March twenty nineteen,
things took a dramatic turn. One evening, David returned home
earlier than usual and overheard a heated argument between Sarah
and Emily. Their voices were muffled, but the tension was palpable.
(03:04):
As he walked up the stairs, he caught a glimpse
of Sara storming out of Emily's room, her face flushed
with anger. Emily, on the other hand, looked distressed, her
eyes red and puffy from crying. David, deeply concerned, confronted
them both, but neither was willing to talk. What he
didn't know at the time was that Emily was hiding
(03:25):
a secret, one that would soon tear the family apart.
Emily had been in a relationship, but it wasn't with
someone her father would ever have expected. It wasn't with
a classmate or a childhood friend. The person she had
been involved with was none other than her own stepmother, Sara.
The affair had started subtly, almost innocently, months earlier. Sara,
(03:49):
who had always been attentive and caring, had been there
for Emily during some difficult times. What began as the
emotional support evolved into something far more intimate. Emily, vulnerable
and confused, found herself drawn to Sara in ways she
couldn't understand. Sara, too was caught in a whirlwind of emotions,
(04:11):
torn between her role as a mother figure and her
growing attraction to Emily. They had managed to keep their
relationship hidden for a while, but the strain was beginning
to show. Emily, riddled with guilt, had tried to distance
herself from Sarah, but Sara's hold on her was too strong.
The intensity of their affair was building, and with each
(04:31):
passing day, the tension between them grew unbearable. On April fifteenth,
two thousand nineteen, the secret finally exploded into the open.
That evening, David received an anonymous e mail. It contained
no text, just a series of photos, photos of Sara
and Omily together in moments that were far from innocent.
(04:53):
His heart pounded in his chest as he scrolled through
the images, disbelief turning to rage. He stored out of
the house, not wanting to confront either of them in
the heat of the moment, but knowing that their lives
would never be the same again. Four days David stayed
in a hotel, refusing to answer calls from either Sarah
(05:13):
or Emily. The betrayal was too deep, too raw. But
on April twentieth, he returned home, ready to confront the
situation head on. What he didn't anticipate was just how
dangerous things had become. Sarah and Emily's relationship had grown
even more unstable in David's absence. Emily, racked with guilt
(05:35):
and fear of her father's reaction, had tried to break
things off with Sarah, but Sarah refused to let her go.
The once caring stepmother had become possessive, obsessed with keeping
Emily close. They argued constantly, their once secret affair now
an open wound that festered in the home. On the
night of April twenty, third, tragedy struck. It was around
(05:58):
nine PM when the neighbors first heard the screams. A
frantic nine one. One call was made by a passerby
who reported loud, arguing and crashing sounds coming from the
William's house. When the police arrived, they found the front
door ajar and the scene inside was nothing short of horrifying.
Emily lay on the living room floor, barely conscious, blood
(06:22):
pooling around her from a deep gash on her head.
Sarah stood over her, holding a fireplace poker, her face
pale and eyes wide with shock, it was clear that
something had gone terribly wrong. As the police restrained Sarah
and rushed Emily to the hospital, the truth of what
had happened began to unfold. Emily's injuries were severe, and
(06:44):
doctors worked through the night to save her. Meanwhile, Sarah
was taken into custody, charged with assault, but the full
story of that night was still shrouded in mystery, leaving
both the police and David with more questions than answers.
What had driven Sarah to such violence? Was it a
crime of passion or was there something more sinister at play.
(07:07):
As the investigation continued, shocking details emerged about the events
leading up to the attack, and what the detectives would
uncover next would leave everyone stunned. Setting the stage for
a tragic and final confrontation. As the police investigated the
events leading up to the assault, more disturbing truths came
to light. Emily remained in critical condition in the hospital,
(07:30):
fighting for her life, while Sarah sat behind bars awaiting
formal charges. But what had caused their already tumultuous relationship
to spiral into violence? What was it that Sarah was
hiding and could it have been prevented. In the days
following the attack, David Williams struggled to make sense of
what had happened. He spent hours by his daughter's bedside,
(07:53):
hoping she would wake up and give him the answers
he so desperately needed. The betrayal he felt from Sarah
was unbearable. How could the woman he loved, the woman
who had helped raise his daughter, be responsible for this
horrific act. The police, too, were determined to uncover the
full story. Detectives began piecing together the events that led
(08:15):
to the tragic night of April twenty third. What they
discovered was a chilling account of manipulation, emotional abuse, and
unrelenting control. It turned out that Sara had not simply
been a loving stepmother to Emily. Behind closed doors, she
had exerted a disturbing influence over her stepdaughter, carefully manipulating
(08:36):
Emily's emotions. Over the course of several months, what had
started as a closed bond had quickly turned into something
much darker. Sarah, unable to control her growing obsession, had
used her position of power within the family to manipulate
Emily into a relationship that crossed every line. Emily, emotionally
vulnerable and struggling with her own identity, had fallen deeper
(08:59):
into the affair, unsure of how to escape Sarah's grasp.
When she finally tried to pull away, it was too late.
Sarah's possessiveness had reached its breaking point. The night of
the attack, Tensions had been running high in the William's
household after receiving the anonymous e mail exposing their affair.
(09:19):
David's sudden departure left both Sarah and Emily on edge.
With David gone, the full weight of the situation began
to sink in for Emily. Overwhelmed with guilt and fear
of the inevitable fallout, she confronted Sarah, begging to end
their relationship for good, but Sarah wouldn't hear it. What
followed was a terrifying argument that escalated into violence. Sarah,
(09:44):
consumed by anger and desperation, had grabbed the fireplace poker
in a fit of rage and struck Emily, sending her
crashing to the floor. The physical wounds were severe, but
the emotional scars ran even deeper. It was clear that
Sara's abst session had driven her to the edge, and
now there was no turning back. But this wasn't the
(10:05):
end of the story. As the investigation continued, detectives uncovered
another shocking revelation that would turn the case on its head.
During a thorough search of Sarah's personal belongings, the police
found a hidden journal tucked away in the back of
her closet. Inside its pages were chilling entries that painted
a disturbing picture of Sarah's mindset leading up to the attack.
(10:28):
The journal revealed that Sarah had been planning to run
away with Emily. In the weeks before the assault. She
had written extensively about her feelings for her stepdaughter, describing
an unhealthy mix of love, jealousy, and control. Sarah's obsession
had grown to such a degree that she was willing
to destroy everything to keep Emily by her side, even
(10:49):
if it meant tearing apart the family and taking Emily
away from everyone she knew. One particular entry, dated April
twenty first, just two days before the attack, stood out,
I can't let her leave me. She's everything to me.
If David finds out, we'll lose it all. I need
to make her understand that we're meant to be together,
(11:11):
no matter what. If I have to, I'll take her
away where no one can find us. I won't let
any one stand in our way, not even her. The
discovery of the journal provided the police with the final
peace of the puzzle. This was not simply an act
of passion. It was a premeditated crime. Sarah had been
(11:32):
planning to isolate Emily, to remove her from the world
and keep her under her control. The confrontation that night
was not an isolated incident, but the culmination of months
of emotional manipulation and psychological abuse. With this new evidence,
the prosecution moved forward with charges of attempted murder along
with assault and unlawful restraint. The trial that followed captivated
(11:56):
the nation as the details of the sordid affair and
the shocking extent of Sarah's obsession were revealed to the public.
Throughout the trial, David Williams remained a silent but constant
presence in the courtroom. His once perfect family had been shattered,
and the woman he had loved now stood accused of
trying to kill his daughter. The pain of betrayal was
(12:16):
etched on his face as he listened to the harrowing
details of Sarah's manipulation and Emily's suffering. Emily, after several
surgeries and months of recovery, took the stand during the trial.
Her testimony was heartbreaking, recounting the months of emotional control
Sarah had exerted over her. She spoke of how confused
(12:37):
and trapped she felt, unable to see a way out
of the toxic relationship until it was too late. Emily's
words were powerful, and they painted a clear picture of
Sarah's disturbing influence over her. The jury deliberated for several days,
but in the end, the verdict was unanimous guilty on
all charges. Sarah was sentenced to twenty five years in
(12:59):
pre for her role in the crime, with the possibility
of parole after twenty years. For many the sentence seemed
too lenient given the extent of the damage she had caused,
but for David and Emily, it was a step toward healing,
a chance to move forward from the nightmare they had endured.
As the years passed, Emily worked hard to rebuild her life.
(13:22):
The scars of the past would always be there, but
with therapy and the support of her father, she was
able to find a sense of normalcy again. She returned
to college, determined to finish her degree and start a
new chapter, one free from the darkness that had consumed her.
For David, the road to recovery was long. The betrayal
(13:42):
from Sarah had left a deep wound, but his focus
remained on his daughter's well being. He sold the house
on Oakwood d r unable to bear the memories of
what had happened there. The quiet neighborhood of Spring Valley
eventually returned to its peaceful routine, but the tragic events
that unfolded inside that house would never be forgotten. This
(14:03):
case stands as a stark reminder of how easily loved
can turn into obsession, and how even the people we
trust the most can hide dangerous secrets.
Popular Podcasts
Stuff You Should Know
If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.
Dateline NBC
Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Follow now to get the latest episodes of Dateline NBC completely free, or subscribe to Dateline Premium for ad-free listening and exclusive bonus content: DatelinePremium.com
On Purpose with Jay Shetty
I’m Jay Shetty host of On Purpose the worlds #1 Mental Health podcast and I’m so grateful you found us. I started this podcast 5 years ago to invite you into conversations and workshops that are designed to help make you happier, healthier and more healed. I believe that when you (yes you) feel seen, heard and understood you’re able to deal with relationship struggles, work challenges and life’s ups and downs with more ease and grace. I interview experts, celebrities, thought leaders and athletes so that we can grow our mindset, build better habits and uncover a side of them we’ve never seen before. New episodes every Monday and Friday. Your support means the world to me and I don’t take it for granted — click the follow button and leave a review to help us spread the love with On Purpose. I can’t wait for you to listen to your first or 500th episode!