Brock Purdy Got Paid... But Did He Deserve It?

Brock Purdy Got the Bag... But Was It Too Soon?

In this video, we dive into the San Francisco 49ers’ decision to pay Brock Purdy and ask the big question: did he actually earn that contract? We break down his performance, the context around his success, and whether the Niners jumped the gun or made a smart investment. Is Purdy the real deal or just a product of the system? Let’s break it all down.

Do you think Purdy deserved the payday? Sound off in the comments!

📺 LIVE Monday - Friday at 9 PM EST
🔔 Subscribe, hit the like button, and join the live interactive show at youtube.com/manhour
#FTTB #NFL #PigskinPundits

Episode Transcript

Speaker 1 (00:00):
Contract. Let's dive right into it, guys. Brock Purtty just
signed a five year, two hundred and sixty five million
dollar extension with the Sampsisco point nine Ers, making him
the highest played player in franchise history and tying him
with Jared Goff of the seventh high salary in the league.
But here's a thing he didn't earn it. Yes, I

(00:20):
said it, Brock Party should have not been paid that much, simple,
point blank. Now, before brock Purty apologies start flooding the comments,
let's get one thing clear. This isn't about hating the guy.
His story. It's inspirational. Last pick of the twenty twenty
two NFL Draft NC Championship appears even a Supersons Super

(00:40):
Bowl run. The guy has done more than anybody expected.
But that's also the part of the problem. Expectations have
inflated his value far beyond what his actual tape en
roll of the system justify, guys. Let's just be honest.
He is a system quarterback. Kyle Shanahan's offense made Jimmy
Jimmy g look elite. Nick Mullen. Nick Mullen's had stresses

(01:02):
where he looked like a franchise guy. So why is
this so hard to admit that Perty just another guy
excurting it finally tuned script. The numbers may look clean,
but watch the film. Perty is rarely creating off script,
rarely elevating weapons, and he has just shown that he
can put a team on his back when things break down.
In fact, in the Super Bowl lost too to the Kansa,

(01:24):
She's Purty's limitations were exposed once the running game stalled
and the pass rush kicked in, he shrank. And now
the forty nine ers have hamstrung themselves financially as two
hundred and sixty five million dollars, includes one hundred and
eighty one million dollars in guarantees and a full no
trade clause. While Purdy and his camp try to spend

(01:48):
this as a team friendly deal coming in under nineteen
percent of other sur of capted, reality is the Niners
just locked himselves into a quarterback New Yorkery at prime price.
This is a team that was on edge of greatness,
elite defense, elite weapons, smart coaching, but now now you
got major extensions going out to George Kittle, Red Fred

(02:10):
Fred Warner, and now Brock Perty good players know no
doubt about it. But this is how super Bowl would
get closed. Not in a fiery crash, but in a quiet,
careful budget overreaches. Let's not forget guys. At the sempisix
four Nineers finished six to eleven last season. Party was
banged up, yes, but even when healthy, he didn't move

(02:31):
the needle in the way. Fifty three million to our
year quarterback. Should you want that kind of money, you
better have carried a team when things get tough, you
better elevate, just not survive, guys, Purdy, he just played
his part. He played it well, but just apart and
for all that, the Niners are now paying the price. Literally,

(02:53):
my take, this moves ends the point nine or super
Bowl window. They commit a long term to a quarterback
whose ceiling may have already been reached. And while the
locker room loves him and the story sells and the
stories don't win championships, playmakers do, difference makers do, and
brock Thurty he's not that So, guys, do you think

(03:15):
brock Purty deserves that tutor sixty five million dollar contract?
Or did the point nine Ers sabotage or super Bowl window?
Let me know. In the commons down below. Next Up, guys,