January 19, 2025 • 16 mins
In this chilling tale of love, betrayal, and justice, we explore the haunting story of the Greenbrier Ghost—the only known case in U.S. history where the testimony of a ghost helped convict a murderer. Set in 1897 Greenbrier County, West Virginia, this true-crime legend blends supernatural intrigue with a mother’s relentless pursuit of justice for her daughter, Elva Zona Heaster Shue.
Was it a mother’s intuition, divine intervention, or a ghostly visitation from beyond the grave? Follow the story from Zona’s tragic death to the trial that captivated a nation and continues to mystify us today. If you enjoy mysteries, true crime, and the unexplained, this is a story you won’t want to miss!
Was it a mother’s intuition, divine intervention, or a ghostly visitation from beyond the grave? Follow the story from Zona’s tragic death to the trial that captivated a nation and continues to mystify us today. If you enjoy mysteries, true crime, and the unexplained, this is a story you won’t want to miss!
Mark as Played
Transcript
Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:00):
In eighteen ninety seven, a ghost took the stand in
a murder trial, and the jury believed her. What she
revealed was so shocking it led to a conviction. Stay
with me because by the end of this video you'll
uncover the spine chilling story of the Greenbriar Ghost and
how she solved her own murder from Beyond the Grave.
(00:31):
Greenbrier County, West Virginia in eighteen ninety seven was a quiet,
close knit community where life was governed by the rhythms
of nature and the traditions of the time. The Appalachian region,
with its rolling hills and dense forests, was steeped in
folklore and superstition. Stories of spirits and omens were as
much a part of daily life as church gatherings and
(00:51):
harvest festivals. In this rural landscape, a belief in the
supernatural often intersected with the deeply religious values of its people,
creating a unique cultural tapestry. Elva Zona Heaster, known to
everyone as Zona, was a young woman who embodied the
spirit of the area. She had a striking presence with
(01:12):
her molasses brown eyes and long, silk like hair. Zona
was known for her free spirited nature, a trait that
set her apart in a community where conformity was often expected.
Her life had not been without its challenges. At the
age of eighteen, she had a child out of wedlock,
a scandalous event in a deeply conservative society. Despite the
(01:33):
whispers and judgment from her neighbors, Zona carried herself with resilience,
determined to find happiness. In the fall of eighteen ninety six,
Zona's life took an unexpected turn. A new face appeared
in Greenbrier County, Erasmus Edward Schu, a tall and handsome
blacksmith with ocean blue eyes and an enigmatic charm. Edward,
(01:54):
who went by the nickname Trout, had recently arrived in
the area seeking work in a fresh start. He quickly
made an impression with his skill at the forge and
his striking appearance. Zona was captivated by him, and their
whirlwind romance became the talk of the town. By November
of that year, they were married in a small ceremony
at the old Methodist Church in Livesaze Mill. For Zona,
(02:19):
it seemed like a new beginning. She and Edward moved
into a modest two story home near Sewell Mountain. Edward
worked hard at his trade, and Zona took care of
their household. Yet not every one was convinced of the
marriage's blissful appearance. Mary Jane Heaster, Zona's mother, had misgivings
about Edward from the start. She had an unshakable feeling
(02:40):
that something about him wasn't right. Edward's past was a mystery,
and Mary Jane's instincts told her that her daughter might
not be as safe as she appeared. On the morning
of January twenty third, eighteen ninety seven, Edward schu arrived
at the home of his neighbor, Martha Jones, and asked
if her son, eleven year old Anderson Jones, could run
(03:01):
an errand for him. Edward claimed that Zona wasn't feeling
well and needed help with chores. Anderson, who often did
odd jobs for the Shoes, had other commitments that morning,
but Edward returned multiple times, growing more insistent with each visit. Finally,
around one PM, Anderson agreed to go to the shoe residence.
(03:25):
He reported that he felt something was wrong, as all
the doors were closed and there was an unsettling air
about the place. Upon reaching the steps, Anderson noticed a
trail of blood, which scared him. He knocked on the
door but received no response. Finding it unlocked, he entered
the kitchen, where he saw the blood trail, continuing to
(03:46):
the dining room door, which was also closed. After knocking
again and getting no answer, Anderson opened the dining room
door and stumbled over Zona's body. He described her as
stretched out on the floor, looking up at him with
wide open eyes, her face seemingly frozen in a laughing expression.
He was frightened, but touched her, Finding her stiff and cold,
(04:08):
Anderson ran from the house to tell Aunt Martha that
missus Schu is dead. Edward was at the blacksmith shop
when Anderson arrived with the grim news. Upon hearing it,
Edward let out a wail and immediately ran toward the house,
accompanied by his boss, Charles Tapscott. By the time doctor
(04:29):
George Knapp arrived to examine Zona, Edward had already moved
her body to the upstairs bedroom. He had dressed her
in a high neck dress, wrapped a scarf around her neck,
and arranged her on the bed as though she were
merely asleep. Edward cradled her head, rocking back and forth
in visible grief. His refusal to let anyone near her
head struck doctor Napp as odd, but the doctor performed
(04:52):
only a cursory examination. Given Edward's emotional state, doctor Napp
declared the cause of death to be an everlasting faint,
a term used to describe sudden heart failure. Later, he
amended the cause to complications from childbirth, though there was
no evidence that Zona was pregnant. The case was closed
without further investigation. Zona's body was prepared for burial the
(05:16):
following day, and Edward's behavior at the funeral only deepened
the unease felt by those around him. At the funeral,
held at the Soul Chapel Methodist Cemetery, Edward stayed by
Zona's casket, his demeanor alternating between inconsolable grief and an
unnerving vigilance. He insisted on arranging her body in the
coffin himself, using a folded sheet and clothing to prop
(05:40):
up her head and prevent anyone from getting too close.
Mary Jane Heaster, watching her son in law's peculiar behavior,
felt her suspicions grow. She had never trusted Edward, and
now her unease turned to outright alarm. After the funeral,
Mary Jane took home a sheet that had been used
to line Zona's coffin. When she had tempted to wash it,
(06:01):
the water turned a vivid red, as though soaked with blood.
No amount of scrubbing could remove the stain. To Mary Jane,
this was a sign a message from her daughter that
something was terribly wrong. She began to pray fervently for answers,
asking God to reveal the truth about Zona's death. One night,
(06:21):
as Mary Jane lay in bed, a light reportedly appeared
in her room. It grew brighter and brighter until it
coalesced into a human form. It was Zona. Over the
next four nights, Zona's ghost would visit her mother, each
time revealing more about the circumstances of her death. The
young woman's story was one of betrayal, violence, and a
(06:41):
desperate plea for justice. Mary Jane, now armed with this
otherworldly testimony, resolved to uncover the truth, no matter the cost.
Mary Jane Heaster, now convinced that her daughter had been murdered,
began sharing her experiences with Zona's ghost. At first, neighbors
dismissed her as a grieving mother, her mind clouded by sorrow,
(07:05):
but Mary Jane was resolute. She described in vivid detail
how Zona had appeared to her over four nights. The
ghost's form was unmistakable, her features clear, her voice calm
but filled with urgency. Zona's message was chilling. Edward had
killed her in a fit of rage, grabbing her by
the throat and snapping her neck. To prove it, the
(07:25):
ghost turned her head completely around, an image that left
Mary Jane shaken but determined. Zona's ghost also described the
events leading up to her death. Edward had flown into
a violent rage over something trivial, her failure to cook
meat for supper. As Mary Jane recounted this story, she
revealed details about the Shoes's home and Zona's final moments
(07:49):
that she could not have known without having been there herself.
This knowledge, combined with Edward's odd behavior and the blood
stained sheet, began to sway the community. So dispision turned
into whispers, and whispers grew louder. Mary Jane's persistence led
her to the office of John Alfred Preston, the local prosecutor.
(08:09):
At first, Preston was skeptical ghost stories were hardly a
foundation for legal action, but Mary Jane's unwavering conviction and
the specific details Zona's ghost had shared began to chip
away at his doubt, Preston agreed to investigate, starting with
a conversation with doctor Napp. The doctor admitted that his
initial examination of Zona's body had been rushed and incomplete
(08:31):
due to Edward's interference. This revelation, coupled with Mary Jane's insistence,
convinced Preston to order Zona's body exhumed for a proper autopsy.
On February twenty second, eighteen ninety seven, a small group
gathered at the cemetery to witness the exhumation. Edward, chu
visibly nervous, protested the decision, but could do nothing to
(08:53):
stop it. Zona's body was transported to a one room
schoolhouse where doctor Napp, along with two other physicians, conducted
the autopsy. For three days. They examined her remains, and
their findings shocked the community. Zona's neck had been broken
between the first and second vertebrae, her windpipe was crushed,
and there were distinct finger shaped bruises around her throat.
(09:16):
The injuries were consistent with strangulation, aligning perfectly with the
ghost's account. When the results of the autopsy were made public,
Edward's behavior became the focus of scrutiny. His insistence on
dressing Zona's body, his refusal to let anyone near her neck,
and his overprotective demeanor at the funeral now seemed less
(09:37):
like grief and more like a calculated effort to hide evidence.
Edward was arrested and charged with murder. The case was
set to go to trial, and the story of Zona's
ghosts spread like wildfire. In June eighteen ninety seven, the
trial of Edward's Shoe began in the Greenbrier County court House.
The prosecution, led by John Preston, relied heavily on the
(10:01):
physical evidence from the autopsy and Edward's suspicious behavior. They
avoided directly mentioning the ghost, knowing it would be dismissed
as hearsay. Instead, they focused on Edward's history. Witnesses testified
about his violent tendencies, including accounts from his first wife,
who had divorced him for abuse, and rumors surrounding the
(10:21):
mysterious death of his second wife. Edward's past painted a
picture of a man capable of extreme violence. The defense,
in an attempt to discredit Mary Jane Heaster, brought up
the ghost's story during cross examination. They hoped to portray
her as superstitious and unreliable, but Mary Jane held her ground,
(10:42):
recounting her visions with unwavering certainty. She described Zona's visits
in detail, from the light that preceded her appearance to
the exact words her daughter had spoken. Her testimony captivated
the court room, and though the judge instructed the jury
to disregard the supernatural elements, the story left an indelible
impression As the trial unfolded. Edward's own testimony only added
(11:05):
to the drama. He claimed innocence, insisting he loved Zona
and would never harm her, but his demeanor and evasive
answers worked against him. He came across as arrogant and unrepentant,
even making the bizarre statement that he hoped to marry
seven women in his lifetime. The jury, already swayed by
the autopsy findings and Mary Jane's testimony, found his performance unconvincing.
(11:30):
The court room was a battleground of skepticism and belief,
science and the supernatural. While the ghost's testimony was not
officially admissible, it had undeniably influenced the proceedings. The physical
evidence corroborated the ghost's claims, creating a narrative that was
difficult to ignore. As the trial drew to a close,
(11:50):
the community waited anxiously for the verdict, knowing the stakes
were not just about justice for Zona, but also about
the clash between reason and the unexplolable. On July eleventh,
eighteen ninety seven, after deliberating for little more than an hour,
the jury returned with their verdict. Edward Schu was guilty
(12:11):
of first degree murder. The decision was clear, though not unanimous,
on the question of his punishment. While most jurors favored
the death penalty, a few hesitated, leading to a sentence
of life imprisonment instead. The courtroom buzzed with the weight
of the decision. Justice had been served not just by
the evidence presented, but many believed by the intervention of
(12:35):
a restless spirit. Edward remained defiant, proclaiming his innocence even
as he was led away in shackles. Yet his demeanor
throughout the trial, arrogant, evasive, and at times chillingly indifferent,
had sealed his fate in the eyes of the community.
The autopsy findings in Mary Jane Heaster's unshakable testimony had
exposed him as a violent man with a dark past.
(12:58):
The courtroom drama became a national sinneration. Newspapers reported the
story of the Greenbriar Ghost, marveling at how the testimony
of a spirit had contributed to the conviction of a murderer.
Though the judge had instructed the jury to disregard the
supernatural elements, the ghost's story lingered in the public imagination,
(13:18):
adding a layer of mystique to an already extraordinary case.
Edward Chu was sent to the West Virginia State Penitentiary
in Moundsville, where he lived out his remaining years. In
nineteen hundred, he succumbed to an epidemic, sweeping through the prison,
dying alone and unremarked in an unmarked grave. For many
in Greenbrier County, his death marked the final chapter in
(13:41):
a tragic and eerie tale. Mary Jane Heaster, however, found
solace in the outcome. She believed wholeheartedly that her daughter's
spirit had intervened to ensure justice was served. Zona's ghost
never visited her again, a sign mary Jane felt that
her daughter's soul was finally at peace. Mary Jane lived
(14:01):
out her days quietly in Greenbrier County, passing away in
nineteen sixteen. She was buried near Zona in the family plot,
a testament to their unbreakable bond. The community, too, grappled
with the implications of the case. It was a story
that blended science and superstition, logic and faith, and it
left an indelible mark on the region's folklore. For some,
(14:22):
it was a cautionary tale about the dangers of unchecked
anger and violence. For others, it was proof of the
enduring power of a mother's love and the mysterious forces
that connect the living and the dead. The story of
the Greenbriar Ghost became a legend, one that transcended its
time and place. It is remembered as the only known
(14:44):
case in American history where the testimony of a ghost
helped to convict a murderer. Historical markers in Greenbrier County
commemorate the event, and the tale has been retold in books, plays,
and documentaries. It continues to captivate audiences, blending elements of
true crime and the paranormal. The case raises questions that
(15:04):
remain unanswered. Was it truly Zona's ghosts that appeared to
marry Jane. Or was it a mother's intuition manifesting in
an extraordinary way. Could Mary Jane have pieced together the
truth from subtle clues she had observed, subconsciously weaving them
into a vivid story of a ghostly visitation, or was
it something beyond explanation, a bridge between worlds forged by
(15:27):
love and a desire for justice. As the years passed,
the legend of the Greenbriar Ghost became a cornerstone of
Appalachian folklore. It spark debates about the nature of truth
and justice, the power of belief, and the limits of
the legal system. Could other spirits like Zona be waiting
to tell their stories? Might there be other cases where
(15:47):
the supernatural intersects with the pursuit of justice. The story
of the Greenbriar Ghost leaves the door open for further exploration,
a reminder that some mysteries linger defying time and reason.
And that's the haunting tale of the Greenbrier Ghost, a
story where justice transcended the boundaries of life and death.
(16:09):
Whether you believe in the supernatural or not, the events
in Greenbrier County remind us of the lengths love and
determination can go to uncover the truth
In eighteen ninety seven, a ghost took the stand in
a murder trial, and the jury believed her. What she
revealed was so shocking it led to a conviction. Stay
with me because by the end of this video you'll
uncover the spine chilling story of the Greenbriar Ghost and
how she solved her own murder from Beyond the Grave.
(00:31):
Greenbrier County, West Virginia in eighteen ninety seven was a quiet,
close knit community where life was governed by the rhythms
of nature and the traditions of the time. The Appalachian region,
with its rolling hills and dense forests, was steeped in
folklore and superstition. Stories of spirits and omens were as
much a part of daily life as church gatherings and
(00:51):
harvest festivals. In this rural landscape, a belief in the
supernatural often intersected with the deeply religious values of its people,
creating a unique cultural tapestry. Elva Zona Heaster, known to
everyone as Zona, was a young woman who embodied the
spirit of the area. She had a striking presence with
(01:12):
her molasses brown eyes and long, silk like hair. Zona
was known for her free spirited nature, a trait that
set her apart in a community where conformity was often expected.
Her life had not been without its challenges. At the
age of eighteen, she had a child out of wedlock,
a scandalous event in a deeply conservative society. Despite the
(01:33):
whispers and judgment from her neighbors, Zona carried herself with resilience,
determined to find happiness. In the fall of eighteen ninety six,
Zona's life took an unexpected turn. A new face appeared
in Greenbrier County, Erasmus Edward Schu, a tall and handsome
blacksmith with ocean blue eyes and an enigmatic charm. Edward,
(01:54):
who went by the nickname Trout, had recently arrived in
the area seeking work in a fresh start. He quickly
made an impression with his skill at the forge and
his striking appearance. Zona was captivated by him, and their
whirlwind romance became the talk of the town. By November
of that year, they were married in a small ceremony
at the old Methodist Church in Livesaze Mill. For Zona,
(02:19):
it seemed like a new beginning. She and Edward moved
into a modest two story home near Sewell Mountain. Edward
worked hard at his trade, and Zona took care of
their household. Yet not every one was convinced of the
marriage's blissful appearance. Mary Jane Heaster, Zona's mother, had misgivings
about Edward from the start. She had an unshakable feeling
(02:40):
that something about him wasn't right. Edward's past was a mystery,
and Mary Jane's instincts told her that her daughter might
not be as safe as she appeared. On the morning
of January twenty third, eighteen ninety seven, Edward schu arrived
at the home of his neighbor, Martha Jones, and asked
if her son, eleven year old Anderson Jones, could run
(03:01):
an errand for him. Edward claimed that Zona wasn't feeling
well and needed help with chores. Anderson, who often did
odd jobs for the Shoes, had other commitments that morning,
but Edward returned multiple times, growing more insistent with each visit. Finally,
around one PM, Anderson agreed to go to the shoe residence.
(03:25):
He reported that he felt something was wrong, as all
the doors were closed and there was an unsettling air
about the place. Upon reaching the steps, Anderson noticed a
trail of blood, which scared him. He knocked on the
door but received no response. Finding it unlocked, he entered
the kitchen, where he saw the blood trail, continuing to
(03:46):
the dining room door, which was also closed. After knocking
again and getting no answer, Anderson opened the dining room
door and stumbled over Zona's body. He described her as
stretched out on the floor, looking up at him with
wide open eyes, her face seemingly frozen in a laughing expression.
He was frightened, but touched her, Finding her stiff and cold,
(04:08):
Anderson ran from the house to tell Aunt Martha that
missus Schu is dead. Edward was at the blacksmith shop
when Anderson arrived with the grim news. Upon hearing it,
Edward let out a wail and immediately ran toward the house,
accompanied by his boss, Charles Tapscott. By the time doctor
(04:29):
George Knapp arrived to examine Zona, Edward had already moved
her body to the upstairs bedroom. He had dressed her
in a high neck dress, wrapped a scarf around her neck,
and arranged her on the bed as though she were
merely asleep. Edward cradled her head, rocking back and forth
in visible grief. His refusal to let anyone near her
head struck doctor Napp as odd, but the doctor performed
(04:52):
only a cursory examination. Given Edward's emotional state, doctor Napp
declared the cause of death to be an everlasting faint,
a term used to describe sudden heart failure. Later, he
amended the cause to complications from childbirth, though there was
no evidence that Zona was pregnant. The case was closed
without further investigation. Zona's body was prepared for burial the
(05:16):
following day, and Edward's behavior at the funeral only deepened
the unease felt by those around him. At the funeral,
held at the Soul Chapel Methodist Cemetery, Edward stayed by
Zona's casket, his demeanor alternating between inconsolable grief and an
unnerving vigilance. He insisted on arranging her body in the
coffin himself, using a folded sheet and clothing to prop
(05:40):
up her head and prevent anyone from getting too close.
Mary Jane Heaster, watching her son in law's peculiar behavior,
felt her suspicions grow. She had never trusted Edward, and
now her unease turned to outright alarm. After the funeral,
Mary Jane took home a sheet that had been used
to line Zona's coffin. When she had tempted to wash it,
(06:01):
the water turned a vivid red, as though soaked with blood.
No amount of scrubbing could remove the stain. To Mary Jane,
this was a sign a message from her daughter that
something was terribly wrong. She began to pray fervently for answers,
asking God to reveal the truth about Zona's death. One night,
(06:21):
as Mary Jane lay in bed, a light reportedly appeared
in her room. It grew brighter and brighter until it
coalesced into a human form. It was Zona. Over the
next four nights, Zona's ghost would visit her mother, each
time revealing more about the circumstances of her death. The
young woman's story was one of betrayal, violence, and a
(06:41):
desperate plea for justice. Mary Jane, now armed with this
otherworldly testimony, resolved to uncover the truth, no matter the cost.
Mary Jane Heaster, now convinced that her daughter had been murdered,
began sharing her experiences with Zona's ghost. At first, neighbors
dismissed her as a grieving mother, her mind clouded by sorrow,
(07:05):
but Mary Jane was resolute. She described in vivid detail
how Zona had appeared to her over four nights. The
ghost's form was unmistakable, her features clear, her voice calm
but filled with urgency. Zona's message was chilling. Edward had
killed her in a fit of rage, grabbing her by
the throat and snapping her neck. To prove it, the
(07:25):
ghost turned her head completely around, an image that left
Mary Jane shaken but determined. Zona's ghost also described the
events leading up to her death. Edward had flown into
a violent rage over something trivial, her failure to cook
meat for supper. As Mary Jane recounted this story, she
revealed details about the Shoes's home and Zona's final moments
(07:49):
that she could not have known without having been there herself.
This knowledge, combined with Edward's odd behavior and the blood
stained sheet, began to sway the community. So dispision turned
into whispers, and whispers grew louder. Mary Jane's persistence led
her to the office of John Alfred Preston, the local prosecutor.
(08:09):
At first, Preston was skeptical ghost stories were hardly a
foundation for legal action, but Mary Jane's unwavering conviction and
the specific details Zona's ghost had shared began to chip
away at his doubt, Preston agreed to investigate, starting with
a conversation with doctor Napp. The doctor admitted that his
initial examination of Zona's body had been rushed and incomplete
(08:31):
due to Edward's interference. This revelation, coupled with Mary Jane's insistence,
convinced Preston to order Zona's body exhumed for a proper autopsy.
On February twenty second, eighteen ninety seven, a small group
gathered at the cemetery to witness the exhumation. Edward, chu
visibly nervous, protested the decision, but could do nothing to
(08:53):
stop it. Zona's body was transported to a one room
schoolhouse where doctor Napp, along with two other physicians, conducted
the autopsy. For three days. They examined her remains, and
their findings shocked the community. Zona's neck had been broken
between the first and second vertebrae, her windpipe was crushed,
and there were distinct finger shaped bruises around her throat.
(09:16):
The injuries were consistent with strangulation, aligning perfectly with the
ghost's account. When the results of the autopsy were made public,
Edward's behavior became the focus of scrutiny. His insistence on
dressing Zona's body, his refusal to let anyone near her neck,
and his overprotective demeanor at the funeral now seemed less
(09:37):
like grief and more like a calculated effort to hide evidence.
Edward was arrested and charged with murder. The case was
set to go to trial, and the story of Zona's
ghosts spread like wildfire. In June eighteen ninety seven, the
trial of Edward's Shoe began in the Greenbrier County court House.
The prosecution, led by John Preston, relied heavily on the
(10:01):
physical evidence from the autopsy and Edward's suspicious behavior. They
avoided directly mentioning the ghost, knowing it would be dismissed
as hearsay. Instead, they focused on Edward's history. Witnesses testified
about his violent tendencies, including accounts from his first wife,
who had divorced him for abuse, and rumors surrounding the
(10:21):
mysterious death of his second wife. Edward's past painted a
picture of a man capable of extreme violence. The defense,
in an attempt to discredit Mary Jane Heaster, brought up
the ghost's story during cross examination. They hoped to portray
her as superstitious and unreliable, but Mary Jane held her ground,
(10:42):
recounting her visions with unwavering certainty. She described Zona's visits
in detail, from the light that preceded her appearance to
the exact words her daughter had spoken. Her testimony captivated
the court room, and though the judge instructed the jury
to disregard the supernatural elements, the story left an indelible
impression As the trial unfolded. Edward's own testimony only added
(11:05):
to the drama. He claimed innocence, insisting he loved Zona
and would never harm her, but his demeanor and evasive
answers worked against him. He came across as arrogant and unrepentant,
even making the bizarre statement that he hoped to marry
seven women in his lifetime. The jury, already swayed by
the autopsy findings and Mary Jane's testimony, found his performance unconvincing.
(11:30):
The court room was a battleground of skepticism and belief,
science and the supernatural. While the ghost's testimony was not
officially admissible, it had undeniably influenced the proceedings. The physical
evidence corroborated the ghost's claims, creating a narrative that was
difficult to ignore. As the trial drew to a close,
(11:50):
the community waited anxiously for the verdict, knowing the stakes
were not just about justice for Zona, but also about
the clash between reason and the unexplolable. On July eleventh,
eighteen ninety seven, after deliberating for little more than an hour,
the jury returned with their verdict. Edward Schu was guilty
(12:11):
of first degree murder. The decision was clear, though not unanimous,
on the question of his punishment. While most jurors favored
the death penalty, a few hesitated, leading to a sentence
of life imprisonment instead. The courtroom buzzed with the weight
of the decision. Justice had been served not just by
the evidence presented, but many believed by the intervention of
(12:35):
a restless spirit. Edward remained defiant, proclaiming his innocence even
as he was led away in shackles. Yet his demeanor
throughout the trial, arrogant, evasive, and at times chillingly indifferent,
had sealed his fate in the eyes of the community.
The autopsy findings in Mary Jane Heaster's unshakable testimony had
exposed him as a violent man with a dark past.
(12:58):
The courtroom drama became a national sinneration. Newspapers reported the
story of the Greenbriar Ghost, marveling at how the testimony
of a spirit had contributed to the conviction of a murderer.
Though the judge had instructed the jury to disregard the
supernatural elements, the ghost's story lingered in the public imagination,
(13:18):
adding a layer of mystique to an already extraordinary case.
Edward Chu was sent to the West Virginia State Penitentiary
in Moundsville, where he lived out his remaining years. In
nineteen hundred, he succumbed to an epidemic, sweeping through the prison,
dying alone and unremarked in an unmarked grave. For many
in Greenbrier County, his death marked the final chapter in
(13:41):
a tragic and eerie tale. Mary Jane Heaster, however, found
solace in the outcome. She believed wholeheartedly that her daughter's
spirit had intervened to ensure justice was served. Zona's ghost
never visited her again, a sign mary Jane felt that
her daughter's soul was finally at peace. Mary Jane lived
(14:01):
out her days quietly in Greenbrier County, passing away in
nineteen sixteen. She was buried near Zona in the family plot,
a testament to their unbreakable bond. The community, too, grappled
with the implications of the case. It was a story
that blended science and superstition, logic and faith, and it
left an indelible mark on the region's folklore. For some,
(14:22):
it was a cautionary tale about the dangers of unchecked
anger and violence. For others, it was proof of the
enduring power of a mother's love and the mysterious forces
that connect the living and the dead. The story of
the Greenbriar Ghost became a legend, one that transcended its
time and place. It is remembered as the only known
(14:44):
case in American history where the testimony of a ghost
helped to convict a murderer. Historical markers in Greenbrier County
commemorate the event, and the tale has been retold in books, plays,
and documentaries. It continues to captivate audiences, blending elements of
true crime and the paranormal. The case raises questions that
(15:04):
remain unanswered. Was it truly Zona's ghosts that appeared to
marry Jane. Or was it a mother's intuition manifesting in
an extraordinary way. Could Mary Jane have pieced together the
truth from subtle clues she had observed, subconsciously weaving them
into a vivid story of a ghostly visitation, or was
it something beyond explanation, a bridge between worlds forged by
(15:27):
love and a desire for justice. As the years passed,
the legend of the Greenbriar Ghost became a cornerstone of
Appalachian folklore. It spark debates about the nature of truth
and justice, the power of belief, and the limits of
the legal system. Could other spirits like Zona be waiting
to tell their stories? Might there be other cases where
(15:47):
the supernatural intersects with the pursuit of justice. The story
of the Greenbriar Ghost leaves the door open for further exploration,
a reminder that some mysteries linger defying time and reason.
And that's the haunting tale of the Greenbrier Ghost, a
story where justice transcended the boundaries of life and death.
(16:09):
Whether you believe in the supernatural or not, the events
in Greenbrier County remind us of the lengths love and
determination can go to uncover the truth
Popular Podcasts
Stuff You Should Know
If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.
Dateline NBC
Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Special Summer Offer: Exclusively on Apple Podcasts, try our Dateline Premium subscription completely free for one month! With Dateline Premium, you get every episode ad-free plus exclusive bonus content.
On Purpose with Jay Shetty
I’m Jay Shetty host of On Purpose the worlds #1 Mental Health podcast and I’m so grateful you found us. I started this podcast 5 years ago to invite you into conversations and workshops that are designed to help make you happier, healthier and more healed. I believe that when you (yes you) feel seen, heard and understood you’re able to deal with relationship struggles, work challenges and life’s ups and downs with more ease and grace. I interview experts, celebrities, thought leaders and athletes so that we can grow our mindset, build better habits and uncover a side of them we’ve never seen before. New episodes every Monday and Friday. Your support means the world to me and I don’t take it for granted — click the follow button and leave a review to help us spread the love with On Purpose. I can’t wait for you to listen to your first or 500th episode!