April 21, 2025 • 17 mins
In this compelling narrative, veteran international correspondent Alexandra Reeves delivers an insightful exploration of Pope Francis's transformative papacy. The article examines his efforts to modernize the Catholic Church through environmental advocacy (particularly in his encyclical Laudato Si'), his push for greater inclusivity, financial reforms, and his distinctive approach to leadership characterized by humility and accessibility. Through firsthand observations and interviews, Reeves illustrates how Francis has challenged traditional papal conventions while navigating complex issues from LGBTQ+ rights to interfaith dialogue, the refugee crisis, and the Church's response to sexual abuse. The piece portrays a pontiff who has permanently altered perceptions of the papacy by prioritizing direct human connection over institutional concerns and bringing attention to those on society's peripheries. For more engaging podcasts like "The Pope" series, visit https://www.quietperiodplease.com/ where you'll discover thought-provoking content that brings global stories to life with the depth and nuance they deserve.
Click here to browse handpicked Amazon finds inspired by this podcast series! https://amzn.to/424pzou
Click here to browse handpicked Amazon finds inspired by this podcast series! https://amzn.to/424pzou
Mark as Played
Transcript
Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:00):
Hello, I'm Alexandra Reeves and welcome to another episode of
The Pope from Quiet Please Podcast Networks. Today we're exploring
the revolutionary papacy of Francis, a tenure that has reshaped
the Catholic Church's relationship with the modern world and redefined
what papal leadership means in the twenty first century. On
a crisp March evening in twenty thirteen, white smoke billowed
(00:21):
from the Sistine Chapel chimney, and the world waited with
bated breath to meet the successor of the recently resigned
Pope Benedict. Sixteen, When Cardinal Jorge Mario Bergoglio of Argentina
stepped onto the balcony of Saint Peter's Basilica, few predicted
how profoundly this humble Jesuit would transform the papacy. As
the first pope from the Americas, the first Jesuit Pope,
(00:42):
and the first to take the name Francis, honoring Saint
Francis of Assisi, Francis of Assisi, the patron Saint of
the Poor. His selection immediately signaled a departure from tradition.
I remember standing in Saint Peter's Square that night, surrounded
by thousands of rain soaked pilgrims. The collective gasp when
this unknown cardinal was announced was palpable, who whispered. An
Italian woman beside me frantically searching her program. Within minutes,
(01:06):
as the new Pope asked the crowd to pray for
him before he blessed them, inverting the traditional order, I
sense we were witnessing something unprecedented. This was not the
ceremonial pomp we'd come to expect, but something far more
personal and direct. That night marked the beginning of what
many now call the Francis Revolution. From his first decisions,
Pope Francis established a pattern of breaking with convention. He
(01:28):
declined the papal apartments in the Apostolic Palace, choosing instead
to live in the modest Vatican guesthouse Santa Marta. He
abandoned the traditional red papal shoes for simple orthopedic black ones.
He carried his own briefcase, paid his own hotel bills,
and rode in ordinary cars rather than the custom built
papal limousine. These weren't mere symbolic gestures. They reflected a
(01:49):
profound belief that the Church needed to shed its imperial
trappings and reconnect with ordinary believers. The legacy of Francis
must be understood within the context he inherited a church
reeling from sexual abuse scandal's financial improprieties at the Vatican Bank,
and the unprecedented resignation of his predecessor. The institution appeared
increasingly disconnected from modern believers and mired in self referential bureaucracy.
(02:13):
What Francis proposed wasn't just administrative reform, but a comprehensive
reimagining of how the church engages with the contemporary world.
I prefer a church which has bruised, hurting, and dirty
because it has been out on the streets, rather than
a church which is unhealthy from being confined and from
clinging to its own security, he declared in his twenty
thirteen apostolic exhortation Evangeli Guardium the Joy of the Gospel.
(02:37):
This manifesto articulated his vision of a church that prioritizes
pastoral care over doctrinal rigidity, mercy over judgment, and outreach
to the margins over institutional self preservation. Environmental stewardship emerged
as a defining priority of Francis's papacy. His twenty fifteen
encyclical Laudato Ci Praise Be to You represented the most
(02:58):
comprehensive Vaticans statement on environmental issues in history. Subtitled on
Care for Our Common Home, the document framed environmental degradation
as both a scientific crisis and a profound moral failure.
The earth our home, is beginning to look more and
more like an immense pile of filth, he wrote, with
characteristic directness, challenging the throwaway culture of consumption that treats
(03:20):
both the planet and vulnerable people as disposable. The encyclical
explicitly accepted the scientific consensus on climate change and called
for radical transformation of politics, economics, and individual behavior. What
made Laudato c revolutionary wasn't just its environmental focus, but
how it connected ecological concerns with issues of poverty, inequality,
(03:40):
and ethics. Francis rejected the notion that technological progress alone
would solve environmental problems, arguing instead that addressing the ecological
crisis requires confronting the underlying cultural and spiritual crisis of
modern consumerism. I've covered three different papal visits to regions
devastated by environmental catastrophes, the Philippines after Typhoon Hyan, the
(04:01):
amazon As, deforestation accelerated, and Pacific island nations threatened by
rising seas. In each place, Francis eschewed abstract theological pronouncements
in favour of direct encounters with affected communities. In the
Peruvian Amazon, I watched him listen intently as indigenous leaders
described the contamination of their ancestral waters by illegal mining.
Rather than offering platitudes, he amplified their concerns on the
(04:24):
global stage, challenging political and business leaders to recognize that
you cannot improve the environment by destroying indigenous communities. This approach,
elevating marginalized voices rather than speaking for them, characterizes France's
broader approach to leadership. He has consistently sought to decentralized
papal authority, empowering local bishop's conferences to make decisions appropriate
(04:46):
to their cultural contexts. His twenty fifteen Synod on the
Family and subsequent exhortation are Morris Letitia The Joy of
Love encouraged pastoral discernment in complex family situations, rather than
imposing universal rules from Rome. This shift toward what theologians
call Sinnidality. Collaborative consultative governance represents perhaps his most significant
(05:07):
structural reform. Francis has revitalized the Synard process itself, transforming
what was once a perfunctory meeting into genuine dialogue. The
Synod on Sinnoidality, launched in twenty twenty one, expanded participation
beyond bishops to include lay people, women, and even non
Catholics in unprecedented ways. During synodal discussions on the Amazon region,
(05:27):
I observed remarkable scenes of indigenous people in traditional dress
speaking directly to cardinals about ecological devastation, conversations that would
have been unimaginable under previous pontificates. The financial reforms instituted
by Francis deserve particular attention. Upon his election, the Vatican's
finances remain notoriously opaque, with the Vatican Bank long suspected
(05:48):
of money laundering and other improprieties. Francis appointed Cardinal George
pell to lead a newly created Secretariat for the Economy,
granting him unprecedented authority to bring Vatican finances into compliance
with international standards. When these reforms met resistance from entrenched
interests within the Curia, the Vatican's Central administration, Francis persisted
(06:09):
despite significant internal opposition. These efforts culminated in a comprehensive
revision of the Vatican's financial structures, including new procurement procedures,
external audits, and greater transparency in budgeting. While progress has
been uneven and sometimes marked by setbacks, including corruption scandals
within the Secretariat of State, Francis has maintained his commitment
(06:29):
to financial accountability. As one Vatican insider told me, previous
reform efforts died when they threatened powerful interests. Francis's reforms
have been messy and incomplete, but they've survived because he's
willing to make enemies to get results. Perhaps no aspect
of Francis's papacy has generated more controversy than his approach
to LGBTQ plus issues. While maintaining the Church's traditional teaching
(06:52):
on marriage, he has dramatically shifted its pastoral tone. His
famous twenty thirteen remarks if someone is gay and seeks
the law or with goodwill, who am I to judge
signaled a profound departure from the more condemnatory language that
had often characterized Vatican statements. Over the years. He has
met with LGBTQ plus Catholics and their advocates, urged compassionate
(07:13):
pastoral care and spoken against discrimination. In December twenty twenty three,
the Vatican's Diecastri for the Doctrine of the Faith, with
Francis's approval, published a declaration permitting priests to bless same
sex couples in certain contexts, while maintaining the distinction between
these blessings and sacramental marriage. This nuanced position, maintaining doctrinal
(07:34):
boundaries while creating space for pastoral accompaniment, exemplifies Francis's approach
of maximum pastoral mercy within doctrinal parameters. I've interviewed dozens
of LGBTQ plus Catholics about Francis's impact. Their responses reveal
the complexity of incremental change in a global institution. It
feels like opening a window in a house that's been
(07:54):
sealed for centuries. A gay Catholic activist in the Philippines
told me, it's not everything we hope for, but for
the first time, there's fresh air coming in. Others expressed
frustration at what they see as half measures that still
leave fundamental teachings unchanged. This tension between those who see
Francis as moving too quickly and those who find him
too cautious, characterizes many aspects of his reform agenda. Women's
(08:17):
roles in the Church present a similar dynamic. Francis has
appointed women to unprecedented positions in Vatican leadership, including sister
Natalie Becker as the first female Under Secretary of the
Synod of Bishops with voting rights, and economist Alessandras Merili
as Secretary of the Decastory for Promoting Integral Human Development.
He has commissioned studies on the historical role of women
(08:38):
deacons and repeatedly emphasized women's contributions to the Church. Yet
he has also reaffirmed the limitation of priestly ordination to men,
disappointing advocates for women's ordination. When I asked Francis directly
about this apparent contradiction during a press conference on the
papal plane returning from World Youth Day, he responded with
characteristic complexity. The Church is feminine. She is more than
(08:59):
an woman because she is mother and bride. The question
is not whether women will have more positions. This is
the functional problem. The deeper question is how to recognize
the feminine dimension of the Church herself. This answer, philosophical
rather than practical, illustrates both the depth of his theological
thinking and his tendency to reframe questions rather than provide
straightforward answers. Francis's approach to interfaith dialogue deserves particular attention.
(09:24):
His friendship with Rabbi Abraham Skorker and Argentina presaged a
papacy marked by genuine engagement with other religions. His twenty
nineteen Document on Human Fraternity, co signed with Grandi mum
ahmadal Tayeb, condemned religious extremism and affirmed universal human dignity.
His historic twenty twenty one visit to Iraq, the first
(09:45):
papal visit to the country, included powerful meetings with Iyatola
Eli al Sistani and prayers amid the ruins of churches
destroyed by ISIS. In each case, Francis has emphasized concrete
solidarity over theoretical dialogue. I witnessed this approach for first
hand in Bangui, Central African Republic, where Francis opened a
holy door at the cathedral despite security concerns amid religious
(10:08):
violence between Christians and Muslims. The following day, he visited
the Central Mosque in the Muslim PK five district, an
area considered so dangerous that UN peacekeepers initially opposed the visit.
Christians and Muslims are brothers and sisters, he declared, as
former fighters from both religious groups looked on. In that
moment of symbolic reconciliation, I saw how Francis's personal courage
(10:29):
and willingness to take risks serves his broader vision of
a church that builds bridges rather than walls. This courage
extends to Francis's political engagement. He has been unsparing in
his criticism of what he calls the globalization of indifference
toward migrants and refugees. During his first papal trip outside Rome,
he visited the Mediterranean island of Lampadusa, where thousands of
(10:51):
migrants have drowned attempting to reach Europe. Praying for the
dead and condemning the throwaway culture that devalues human life,
he established a pattern of concrete solidarity with displaced people
that has defined his papacy. His washing of migrants feet
during Holy Thursday liturgies, his bringing refugee families back to
the Vatican on his papal plane and his constant advocacy
(11:13):
for hospitable policies have made immigration as signature cause. Francis
has similarly challenged economic systems that prioritize profit over people.
His critiques of unrestrained capitalism have drawn praise from progressives
and criticism from free market advocates. This economy Kills, he
wrote in Evangelic Guardium, denouncing theories of trickle down economics
(11:33):
that express a crude and naive trust in the goodness
of those wielding economic power. During the COVID nineteen pandemic,
he repeatedly called for vaccine equity and debt relief for
developing nations, arguing that market forces alone cannot ensure just
outcomes in global crises. Such statements have prompted some critics
to label Francis and Marxist, a characterization he firmly rejects.
(11:55):
The Marxist ideology is wrong, he told an interviewer, but
I have met many Marxists in my life who are
good people, so I don't feel offended. This response captures
his ability to disagree with ideologies while respecting individual adherents,
a distinction often lost in polarized discourse. The most severe
opposition to Francis has come from within the Church itself,
particularly from traditionalists who view his reforms as diluting Catholic identity.
(12:20):
His twenty twenty one Motu proprio traditionist custaudes, which restricted
the celebration of the pre Vatican two Latin Mass, intensified
this conflict. Some cardinals have issued public jubia formal questions
challenging his teachings, while conservative Catholic media regularly criticize his pronouncements.
During a revealing interview in the Vatican gardens, a senior
(12:42):
American cardinal who requested anonymity, told me what traditionalists don't
understand is that Francis isn't changing doctrine. He's changing how
we prioritize different aspects of doctrine. When previous popes emphasized
sexual ethics above all else, no one called that changing doctrine.
Now Francis emphasizes care for the poor and migrants with
the same emphasis, and suddenly he's accused of heresy. This
(13:03):
observation highlights how Francis's reforms often involve shifting emphasis rather
than changing fundamental teaching. Though the practical impact of such
shifts can be profound. The sexual abuse crisis has tested
Francis's reform agenda most severely. Early in his papacy, he
established the Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Miners and
met with abuse survivors, Yet his responses have sometimes appeared inconsistent.
(13:27):
His defense of Chilean Bishop Juan Barros, whom he initially
accused victims of calumny for implicating in a cover up,
represented a significant misstep. After sending investigators who confirmed the
victim's accounts, Francis issued an extraordinary apology, admitted his error,
and accepted the resignations of multiple Chilean bishops. This episode
reveals both Francis's limitations and his capacity for growth. Unlike
(13:51):
many leaders who become more entrenched when challenged, Francis has
demonstrated remarkable willingness to acknowledge mistakes and change course. The
twenty nineteen Vatican Summit on Abuse and subsequent procedural reforms
strengthened accountability, including the abolition of the Pontifical secret for
abuse cases and new requirements for reporting allegations. When I
interviewed Cardinal Shawn O'Malley, President of the Pontifical Commission for
(14:14):
the Protection of Miners. He emphasized this evolution. The journey
hasn't been perfect, but Francis has brought us further than
we've ever been in addressing this sin and crime. He
understands now in a way he didn't initially, that safeguarding
requires both pastoral compassion for survivors and rigorous accountability for
perpetrators and those who protected them. Francis health has become
(14:34):
an increasing concern in recent years. At eighty seven, he
continues maintaining a grueling schedule, despite having part of one
lung removed in his youth and undergoing colon surgery in
twenty twenty one. He often appears in pain when walking
due to knee problems, sometimes using a wheelchair, Yet he
has dismissed speculation about resignation, telling an interviewer one governs
with the head, not the knee. When I observed him
(14:56):
during recent public events, I noted both his physical limitations
and his evident determination to continue his mission despite them.
As Francis approaches his eleventh year as pope, what emerges
is a portrait of a leader focused on restoring the
church's moral authority through humility rather than power, dialogue rather
than proclamation, and pastoral accompaniment rather than rigid enforcement of rules.
(15:18):
His project remains unfinished and contested, with significant portions of
the Catholic world resistant to his vision of reform. Yet
he is undeniably altered the church's relationship with the modern
world and expanded the imagination of what papal leadership can
look like. Reform takes time, Francis told journalists during his
return flight from a twenty twenty three apostolic journey, I
(15:39):
may not see the fruits of everything we've planted, but
that's not the point. Our job is to plant seeds
faithfully and trust that God will bring the harvest in
his time. This agricultural metaphor, characteristic of Francis's earthy spirituality,
suggests he views his papacy as beginning a process rather
than completing one. Whether future popes will continue Francis's reforms
(15:59):
or will pursue different priorities remains an open question. The
college of cardinals that will elect his successor has been
significantly reshaped by his appointments, with a more geographically diverse
membership and many cardinals who share his pastoral priorities. Yet
history shows that papal transitions often bring unexpected shifts, and
the Francis effect may prove either transformative or transitory for
(16:21):
the church's long term development. What seems certain is that
Francis has permanently altered public perceptions of the papacy. By
prioritizing direct human encounter over institutional concerns, embracing complexity rather
than offering simplistic answers, and consistently directing attention to those
on society's peripheries. He has provided a distinctive model of
spiritual leadership for our fractured age. This, perhaps more than
(16:44):
any specific policy or teaching document, may prove his most
enduring legacy. From the slums of Buenos Aires to the
global stage of the papacy hod home, Mario Bergoglio has
remained fundamentally the same person, pastoral direct and focused on
bringing the Gospel to the margins. As one Vatican official
told me, with Francis, what you see is what you get.
(17:04):
There's no difference between the public figure and the private man.
That authenticity is his greatest strength in an era of
carefully crafted public personas such, genuineness feels both countercultural and
deeply refreshing. I'm Alexandra Reeves and thank you for joining
me for this exploration of Pope Francis's transformative papacy. Thanks
for listening, and please subscribe to hear more episodes like
(17:26):
this one. This has been brought to you by Quiet
Please Podcast networks. For more content like this, please go
to Quiet. Please dot ai Quiet, Please dot ai hear
what Matters
Hello, I'm Alexandra Reeves and welcome to another episode of
The Pope from Quiet Please Podcast Networks. Today we're exploring
the revolutionary papacy of Francis, a tenure that has reshaped
the Catholic Church's relationship with the modern world and redefined
what papal leadership means in the twenty first century. On
a crisp March evening in twenty thirteen, white smoke billowed
(00:21):
from the Sistine Chapel chimney, and the world waited with
bated breath to meet the successor of the recently resigned
Pope Benedict. Sixteen, When Cardinal Jorge Mario Bergoglio of Argentina
stepped onto the balcony of Saint Peter's Basilica, few predicted
how profoundly this humble Jesuit would transform the papacy. As
the first pope from the Americas, the first Jesuit Pope,
(00:42):
and the first to take the name Francis, honoring Saint
Francis of Assisi, Francis of Assisi, the patron Saint of
the Poor. His selection immediately signaled a departure from tradition.
I remember standing in Saint Peter's Square that night, surrounded
by thousands of rain soaked pilgrims. The collective gasp when
this unknown cardinal was announced was palpable, who whispered. An
Italian woman beside me frantically searching her program. Within minutes,
(01:06):
as the new Pope asked the crowd to pray for
him before he blessed them, inverting the traditional order, I
sense we were witnessing something unprecedented. This was not the
ceremonial pomp we'd come to expect, but something far more
personal and direct. That night marked the beginning of what
many now call the Francis Revolution. From his first decisions,
Pope Francis established a pattern of breaking with convention. He
(01:28):
declined the papal apartments in the Apostolic Palace, choosing instead
to live in the modest Vatican guesthouse Santa Marta. He
abandoned the traditional red papal shoes for simple orthopedic black ones.
He carried his own briefcase, paid his own hotel bills,
and rode in ordinary cars rather than the custom built
papal limousine. These weren't mere symbolic gestures. They reflected a
(01:49):
profound belief that the Church needed to shed its imperial
trappings and reconnect with ordinary believers. The legacy of Francis
must be understood within the context he inherited a church
reeling from sexual abuse scandal's financial improprieties at the Vatican Bank,
and the unprecedented resignation of his predecessor. The institution appeared
increasingly disconnected from modern believers and mired in self referential bureaucracy.
(02:13):
What Francis proposed wasn't just administrative reform, but a comprehensive
reimagining of how the church engages with the contemporary world.
I prefer a church which has bruised, hurting, and dirty
because it has been out on the streets, rather than
a church which is unhealthy from being confined and from
clinging to its own security, he declared in his twenty
thirteen apostolic exhortation Evangeli Guardium the Joy of the Gospel.
(02:37):
This manifesto articulated his vision of a church that prioritizes
pastoral care over doctrinal rigidity, mercy over judgment, and outreach
to the margins over institutional self preservation. Environmental stewardship emerged
as a defining priority of Francis's papacy. His twenty fifteen
encyclical Laudato Ci Praise Be to You represented the most
(02:58):
comprehensive Vaticans statement on environmental issues in history. Subtitled on
Care for Our Common Home, the document framed environmental degradation
as both a scientific crisis and a profound moral failure.
The earth our home, is beginning to look more and
more like an immense pile of filth, he wrote, with
characteristic directness, challenging the throwaway culture of consumption that treats
(03:20):
both the planet and vulnerable people as disposable. The encyclical
explicitly accepted the scientific consensus on climate change and called
for radical transformation of politics, economics, and individual behavior. What
made Laudato c revolutionary wasn't just its environmental focus, but
how it connected ecological concerns with issues of poverty, inequality,
(03:40):
and ethics. Francis rejected the notion that technological progress alone
would solve environmental problems, arguing instead that addressing the ecological
crisis requires confronting the underlying cultural and spiritual crisis of
modern consumerism. I've covered three different papal visits to regions
devastated by environmental catastrophes, the Philippines after Typhoon Hyan, the
(04:01):
amazon As, deforestation accelerated, and Pacific island nations threatened by
rising seas. In each place, Francis eschewed abstract theological pronouncements
in favour of direct encounters with affected communities. In the
Peruvian Amazon, I watched him listen intently as indigenous leaders
described the contamination of their ancestral waters by illegal mining.
Rather than offering platitudes, he amplified their concerns on the
(04:24):
global stage, challenging political and business leaders to recognize that
you cannot improve the environment by destroying indigenous communities. This approach,
elevating marginalized voices rather than speaking for them, characterizes France's
broader approach to leadership. He has consistently sought to decentralized
papal authority, empowering local bishop's conferences to make decisions appropriate
(04:46):
to their cultural contexts. His twenty fifteen Synod on the
Family and subsequent exhortation are Morris Letitia The Joy of
Love encouraged pastoral discernment in complex family situations, rather than
imposing universal rules from Rome. This shift toward what theologians
call Sinnidality. Collaborative consultative governance represents perhaps his most significant
(05:07):
structural reform. Francis has revitalized the Synard process itself, transforming
what was once a perfunctory meeting into genuine dialogue. The
Synod on Sinnoidality, launched in twenty twenty one, expanded participation
beyond bishops to include lay people, women, and even non
Catholics in unprecedented ways. During synodal discussions on the Amazon region,
(05:27):
I observed remarkable scenes of indigenous people in traditional dress
speaking directly to cardinals about ecological devastation, conversations that would
have been unimaginable under previous pontificates. The financial reforms instituted
by Francis deserve particular attention. Upon his election, the Vatican's
finances remain notoriously opaque, with the Vatican Bank long suspected
(05:48):
of money laundering and other improprieties. Francis appointed Cardinal George
pell to lead a newly created Secretariat for the Economy,
granting him unprecedented authority to bring Vatican finances into compliance
with international standards. When these reforms met resistance from entrenched
interests within the Curia, the Vatican's Central administration, Francis persisted
(06:09):
despite significant internal opposition. These efforts culminated in a comprehensive
revision of the Vatican's financial structures, including new procurement procedures,
external audits, and greater transparency in budgeting. While progress has
been uneven and sometimes marked by setbacks, including corruption scandals
within the Secretariat of State, Francis has maintained his commitment
(06:29):
to financial accountability. As one Vatican insider told me, previous
reform efforts died when they threatened powerful interests. Francis's reforms
have been messy and incomplete, but they've survived because he's
willing to make enemies to get results. Perhaps no aspect
of Francis's papacy has generated more controversy than his approach
to LGBTQ plus issues. While maintaining the Church's traditional teaching
(06:52):
on marriage, he has dramatically shifted its pastoral tone. His
famous twenty thirteen remarks if someone is gay and seeks
the law or with goodwill, who am I to judge
signaled a profound departure from the more condemnatory language that
had often characterized Vatican statements. Over the years. He has
met with LGBTQ plus Catholics and their advocates, urged compassionate
(07:13):
pastoral care and spoken against discrimination. In December twenty twenty three,
the Vatican's Diecastri for the Doctrine of the Faith, with
Francis's approval, published a declaration permitting priests to bless same
sex couples in certain contexts, while maintaining the distinction between
these blessings and sacramental marriage. This nuanced position, maintaining doctrinal
(07:34):
boundaries while creating space for pastoral accompaniment, exemplifies Francis's approach
of maximum pastoral mercy within doctrinal parameters. I've interviewed dozens
of LGBTQ plus Catholics about Francis's impact. Their responses reveal
the complexity of incremental change in a global institution. It
feels like opening a window in a house that's been
(07:54):
sealed for centuries. A gay Catholic activist in the Philippines
told me, it's not everything we hope for, but for
the first time, there's fresh air coming in. Others expressed
frustration at what they see as half measures that still
leave fundamental teachings unchanged. This tension between those who see
Francis as moving too quickly and those who find him
too cautious, characterizes many aspects of his reform agenda. Women's
(08:17):
roles in the Church present a similar dynamic. Francis has
appointed women to unprecedented positions in Vatican leadership, including sister
Natalie Becker as the first female Under Secretary of the
Synod of Bishops with voting rights, and economist Alessandras Merili
as Secretary of the Decastory for Promoting Integral Human Development.
He has commissioned studies on the historical role of women
(08:38):
deacons and repeatedly emphasized women's contributions to the Church. Yet
he has also reaffirmed the limitation of priestly ordination to men,
disappointing advocates for women's ordination. When I asked Francis directly
about this apparent contradiction during a press conference on the
papal plane returning from World Youth Day, he responded with
characteristic complexity. The Church is feminine. She is more than
(08:59):
an woman because she is mother and bride. The question
is not whether women will have more positions. This is
the functional problem. The deeper question is how to recognize
the feminine dimension of the Church herself. This answer, philosophical
rather than practical, illustrates both the depth of his theological
thinking and his tendency to reframe questions rather than provide
straightforward answers. Francis's approach to interfaith dialogue deserves particular attention.
(09:24):
His friendship with Rabbi Abraham Skorker and Argentina presaged a
papacy marked by genuine engagement with other religions. His twenty
nineteen Document on Human Fraternity, co signed with Grandi mum
ahmadal Tayeb, condemned religious extremism and affirmed universal human dignity.
His historic twenty twenty one visit to Iraq, the first
(09:45):
papal visit to the country, included powerful meetings with Iyatola
Eli al Sistani and prayers amid the ruins of churches
destroyed by ISIS. In each case, Francis has emphasized concrete
solidarity over theoretical dialogue. I witnessed this approach for first
hand in Bangui, Central African Republic, where Francis opened a
holy door at the cathedral despite security concerns amid religious
(10:08):
violence between Christians and Muslims. The following day, he visited
the Central Mosque in the Muslim PK five district, an
area considered so dangerous that UN peacekeepers initially opposed the visit.
Christians and Muslims are brothers and sisters, he declared, as
former fighters from both religious groups looked on. In that
moment of symbolic reconciliation, I saw how Francis's personal courage
(10:29):
and willingness to take risks serves his broader vision of
a church that builds bridges rather than walls. This courage
extends to Francis's political engagement. He has been unsparing in
his criticism of what he calls the globalization of indifference
toward migrants and refugees. During his first papal trip outside Rome,
he visited the Mediterranean island of Lampadusa, where thousands of
(10:51):
migrants have drowned attempting to reach Europe. Praying for the
dead and condemning the throwaway culture that devalues human life,
he established a pattern of concrete solidarity with displaced people
that has defined his papacy. His washing of migrants feet
during Holy Thursday liturgies, his bringing refugee families back to
the Vatican on his papal plane and his constant advocacy
(11:13):
for hospitable policies have made immigration as signature cause. Francis
has similarly challenged economic systems that prioritize profit over people.
His critiques of unrestrained capitalism have drawn praise from progressives
and criticism from free market advocates. This economy Kills, he
wrote in Evangelic Guardium, denouncing theories of trickle down economics
(11:33):
that express a crude and naive trust in the goodness
of those wielding economic power. During the COVID nineteen pandemic,
he repeatedly called for vaccine equity and debt relief for
developing nations, arguing that market forces alone cannot ensure just
outcomes in global crises. Such statements have prompted some critics
to label Francis and Marxist, a characterization he firmly rejects.
(11:55):
The Marxist ideology is wrong, he told an interviewer, but
I have met many Marxists in my life who are
good people, so I don't feel offended. This response captures
his ability to disagree with ideologies while respecting individual adherents,
a distinction often lost in polarized discourse. The most severe
opposition to Francis has come from within the Church itself,
particularly from traditionalists who view his reforms as diluting Catholic identity.
(12:20):
His twenty twenty one Motu proprio traditionist custaudes, which restricted
the celebration of the pre Vatican two Latin Mass, intensified
this conflict. Some cardinals have issued public jubia formal questions
challenging his teachings, while conservative Catholic media regularly criticize his pronouncements.
During a revealing interview in the Vatican gardens, a senior
(12:42):
American cardinal who requested anonymity, told me what traditionalists don't
understand is that Francis isn't changing doctrine. He's changing how
we prioritize different aspects of doctrine. When previous popes emphasized
sexual ethics above all else, no one called that changing doctrine.
Now Francis emphasizes care for the poor and migrants with
the same emphasis, and suddenly he's accused of heresy. This
(13:03):
observation highlights how Francis's reforms often involve shifting emphasis rather
than changing fundamental teaching. Though the practical impact of such
shifts can be profound. The sexual abuse crisis has tested
Francis's reform agenda most severely. Early in his papacy, he
established the Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Miners and
met with abuse survivors, Yet his responses have sometimes appeared inconsistent.
(13:27):
His defense of Chilean Bishop Juan Barros, whom he initially
accused victims of calumny for implicating in a cover up,
represented a significant misstep. After sending investigators who confirmed the
victim's accounts, Francis issued an extraordinary apology, admitted his error,
and accepted the resignations of multiple Chilean bishops. This episode
reveals both Francis's limitations and his capacity for growth. Unlike
(13:51):
many leaders who become more entrenched when challenged, Francis has
demonstrated remarkable willingness to acknowledge mistakes and change course. The
twenty nineteen Vatican Summit on Abuse and subsequent procedural reforms
strengthened accountability, including the abolition of the Pontifical secret for
abuse cases and new requirements for reporting allegations. When I
interviewed Cardinal Shawn O'Malley, President of the Pontifical Commission for
(14:14):
the Protection of Miners. He emphasized this evolution. The journey
hasn't been perfect, but Francis has brought us further than
we've ever been in addressing this sin and crime. He
understands now in a way he didn't initially, that safeguarding
requires both pastoral compassion for survivors and rigorous accountability for
perpetrators and those who protected them. Francis health has become
(14:34):
an increasing concern in recent years. At eighty seven, he
continues maintaining a grueling schedule, despite having part of one
lung removed in his youth and undergoing colon surgery in
twenty twenty one. He often appears in pain when walking
due to knee problems, sometimes using a wheelchair, Yet he
has dismissed speculation about resignation, telling an interviewer one governs
with the head, not the knee. When I observed him
(14:56):
during recent public events, I noted both his physical limitations
and his evident determination to continue his mission despite them.
As Francis approaches his eleventh year as pope, what emerges
is a portrait of a leader focused on restoring the
church's moral authority through humility rather than power, dialogue rather
than proclamation, and pastoral accompaniment rather than rigid enforcement of rules.
(15:18):
His project remains unfinished and contested, with significant portions of
the Catholic world resistant to his vision of reform. Yet
he is undeniably altered the church's relationship with the modern
world and expanded the imagination of what papal leadership can
look like. Reform takes time, Francis told journalists during his
return flight from a twenty twenty three apostolic journey, I
(15:39):
may not see the fruits of everything we've planted, but
that's not the point. Our job is to plant seeds
faithfully and trust that God will bring the harvest in
his time. This agricultural metaphor, characteristic of Francis's earthy spirituality,
suggests he views his papacy as beginning a process rather
than completing one. Whether future popes will continue Francis's reforms
(15:59):
or will pursue different priorities remains an open question. The
college of cardinals that will elect his successor has been
significantly reshaped by his appointments, with a more geographically diverse
membership and many cardinals who share his pastoral priorities. Yet
history shows that papal transitions often bring unexpected shifts, and
the Francis effect may prove either transformative or transitory for
(16:21):
the church's long term development. What seems certain is that
Francis has permanently altered public perceptions of the papacy. By
prioritizing direct human encounter over institutional concerns, embracing complexity rather
than offering simplistic answers, and consistently directing attention to those
on society's peripheries. He has provided a distinctive model of
spiritual leadership for our fractured age. This, perhaps more than
(16:44):
any specific policy or teaching document, may prove his most
enduring legacy. From the slums of Buenos Aires to the
global stage of the papacy hod home, Mario Bergoglio has
remained fundamentally the same person, pastoral direct and focused on
bringing the Gospel to the margins. As one Vatican official
told me, with Francis, what you see is what you get.
(17:04):
There's no difference between the public figure and the private man.
That authenticity is his greatest strength in an era of
carefully crafted public personas such, genuineness feels both countercultural and
deeply refreshing. I'm Alexandra Reeves and thank you for joining
me for this exploration of Pope Francis's transformative papacy. Thanks
for listening, and please subscribe to hear more episodes like
(17:26):
this one. This has been brought to you by Quiet
Please Podcast networks. For more content like this, please go
to Quiet. Please dot ai Quiet, Please dot ai hear
what Matters
Popular Podcasts
Dateline NBC
Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Follow now to get the latest episodes of Dateline NBC completely free, or subscribe to Dateline Premium for ad-free listening and exclusive bonus content: DatelinePremium.com
Stuff You Should Know
If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.
NFL Daily with Gregg Rosenthal
Gregg Rosenthal and a rotating crew of elite NFL Media co-hosts, including Patrick Claybon, Colleen Wolfe, Steve Wyche, Nick Shook and Jourdan Rodrigue of The Athletic get you caught up daily on all the NFL news and analysis you need to be smarter and funnier than your friends.