All Episodes

October 11, 2025 18 mins
#redditstories #askreddit #aita #siblings #marriage #family #relationships #drama
Summary: A sibling labels the protagonist a solitary failure at her marriage ceremony, causing tension and drama within the family. 
Tags: redditstories, askreddit, reddit, aita, tifu, siblings, marriage, family, relationships, drama, wedding, conflict, siblingrivalry, communication, event, emotionalstress, support, advice, ceremony, socialdynamics
Mark as Played
Transcript

Episode Transcript

Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:00):
My sibling labeled me a solitary failure at her marriage ceremony,
prompting her partner to intervene and call off the wedding.
Our guardians then accused me of spoiling everything and ordered
me to leave. I chuckled in response, shocked them. My
sister Barbara invited me to her wedding will more like,
she pressured me to go, knowing i'd be the odd
one out. Of course you should come, she said, in

(00:21):
that fake, sweet way she does. But then she added,
you'll have to sit at the back table, though you
know with the singles, you wouldn't really belong anywhere else,
since everyone comes with they're partners. I didn't argue. I
just nodded and let it go. That's the way Barbara
and I have always been. She always tried to outshine me,
and I've learned that it's easier to just play along,

(00:41):
but to be honest, I was already bracing myself for
the usual passive, aggressive comments and comparisons she liked to
throw my way whenever she got the chance. This time, though,
I figured I'd just grin and bear it. After all,
it was her big day. What could possibly go wrong? Oh? Right,
a lot could go wrong. What Barbara didn't know, what
no one knew, was that her fiance, Oliver wasn't exactly

(01:03):
a stranger to me. We had a history, and not
just the casual kind. We were each other's first We've
been teenagers and separable for about two years until his
family moved across the country. We'd lost touch after that,
but it had been intense, one of those relationships that
never quite leaves you, even when life moves on. For
years after we broke up, he showed up out of nowhere.
Barbara had started seeing him without any idea of who

(01:24):
he was to me. I remember the day she brought
him home to introduce him to the family. I walked
into the living room saw him standing there. In my
heart just stopped. He saw me too. His face didn't
say much, but I saw it in his eyes he
remembered everything. We locked eyes for a moment, but neither
of us said a word. We both just smiled politely
and pretended not to know each other. Barbara, of course,
was too caught up in her fantasy to notice. For

(01:45):
the next few years, she bragged about how perfect Oliver was,
how deeply in love they were, how he was going
to give her the dream life she always wanted. And
I just sat there and listened and smiled, laughing inside
because she had no idea. She never even noticed the
way Oliver looked at me sometimes, the way he always
found a reason to talk to me whenever I was around.
But he was respectful. We never crossed any boundaries, but

(02:07):
I could sense that some part of him still remembered
how things used to be. Any Way, fast forward to
the wedding day. I showed up dressed decently, but not
too flashy. I didn't want to draw attention to myself.
The reception was in this huge ball room with fancy decorations, chandeliers,
the works, the kind of place Barbara would have drooled
over since she was a kid. When I got to
the reception hall, sure enough, they seated me at the
table farthest from the main stage, the extra's table, as

(02:31):
I called it in my head. I didn't mind too much.
I wasn't there to make a scene. I was just
there to do my duty as a good sister, clap
at the speeches, maybe have a drink or two, and
leave without causing any trouble. Everything was going fine until
Barbara decided she needed one last power move. It happened
right after the first dance. She stood up, microphone in hand,
and began making her rounds with a little speech. She

(02:52):
thanked the guests, gushed about Oliver, and bashed in the
spotlight like a queen. And then as she scanned the room,
her eyes landed on me. Her smile twisted into some
meaner and I knew what was coming before she even
opened her mouth. And finally, Barbara said, her voice echoing
through the hall, I want to give a shout out
to my sister Abigail. You all see her write. She's
over there at the single's table. The poor thing came alone.

(03:15):
Maybe one day she'll find a husband too, so she
won't have to sit there like a lonely loser. The
whole room fell silent. The music playing in the background
was the only sound. I felt as if someone had
slapped me in the face. All the eyes on me
made my skin crawl, and I wanted to disappear, but
I didn't move. I didn't give her the satisfaction of reacting.
The tension hung in the air until Oliver's voice cut

(03:35):
through it like a knife. Barbara, he said loud enough
for everyone to hear shut up. It was as if
the world froze. Everyone turned to him, eyes why. Even
Barbara looked stunned. She started to stammer something, but Oliver
wasn't having it. He stepped forward and glared at her.
You've humiliated them enough, you've humiliated yourself. He said, I'm done.
This is not the person I want to marry, and
with that, he took off his wedding ring, walk to

(03:56):
the nearest window, and threw it out. The crowd collectively gasped.
Barbara ran after him, but he didn't stop. He walked
straight out of the lobby and disappeared into the night.
Barbara screamed after him, her wedding dress dragging on the
floor as she tried to catch up. Meanwhile, I just
sat there, stunned. The guests were whispering to each other,
and some were still frozen. I didn't know whether to
laugh or cry, but I knew one thing for sure,

(04:19):
this wasn't going to end quietly. Soon after, I slipped out,
got in my car and drove home. I didn't know
what was going to happen next, but I could already
feel the storm brewing. I got home and braced myself
for the fallout. I knew my parents weren't going to
take this well. Barbara was their golden child, the one
who always did everything right. Me I was the afterthought,
the good enough daughter who rarely made waves. I kicked

(04:39):
off my shoes, changed into some comfortable clothes, and tried
to relax. I knew the storm was coming, but I
didn't expect it to last three hours. When my parents
finally arrived with Barbara in the car, I could hear
the screaming before they even made it to the front door.
They burst into the house like a sweat team. My
dad slammed the door, and Barbara burst into tears on
cue You've ruined everything? She screwed, I mean, you always

(05:00):
have to ruin everything. My mother folded her arms and
glared at me like I was some kind of criminal. Abigail,
what have you done? How could you embarrass your sister
on her wedding day? I just blinked at her. What
did I do? I didn't even say a word. Oh
don't you dare play innocent? Barbara snapped. Her face was
red and blotchy, her mascara smeared from crying. Why did

(05:21):
Oliver defend you like that? Huh why did he look
at you like that? What did you say to him?
I laughed. I couldn't help at the absurdity of it
all hit me all at once. The room fell silent
for a moment, and my parents stared at me as
if I'd lost my mind. Are you seriously blaming me
for this? I said, still laughing, Barbara, you humiliated me
in front of everyone. I didn't do anything. Oliver told

(05:45):
you to shut up because you were being cruel. Maybe
you should ask yourself why he couldn't handle it any more.
You're lying. You were always jealous of me. You must
have said something to him, jealous I repeated, of what that?
You were always putting me down to make yourself feel better.
Barbara froze for a moment, as if she hadn't expected
me to actually defend myself. But my parents weren't done.
My mother stepped forward, her voice sharp. We know you

(06:06):
had something to do with this. You've been trying to
undermine your sister for years. I rolled my eyes. Oh,
give me a break. I didn't say a word to Oliver.
He made his decision on his own. Barbara started pacing
in her wedding dress, tugging at her hair in frustration.
Then why did he defend you? Why? I crossed my
arms and leaned against the wall. Maybe because deep down

(06:28):
he knows who you really are. You treat people like crap, Barbara,
you always have. He finally saw through at her, jaw clenched.
You shut up, You don't know anything. He loved me,
He's supposed to be with me, as he I shot back,
because from where I'm standing, it doesn't look like he
loves you enough to put up with your crap. That
was at Barbara completely lost as she started screaming incoherent

(06:50):
insults at me, and my parents quickly joined in backing
her up. As usual, the three of them yelled at
each other so much it sounded like a chaotic rap battle.
Then my dad pointed to the or you've done enough
damage for one night. Get out. We don't want you here.
Barbara folded her arms and sneered ya, get out. I
raised an eyebrow, then grinned, you want me to leave, fine,
but before I go, let me say one last thing.

(07:12):
I walked closer to her and locked eyes with her.
Do you want to know why Oliver defended me? Why
he left you because I'm like you. I don't act
like a cheap, insecure brat. He respects me, and that's
something you'll never have because you're too busy tearing everyone
else down to make yourself feel better. The look on
her face was priceless. She stood there gaping at me
as if her brain had shorted out. My parents were
also stunned into silence. I guess they didn't expect me

(07:36):
to finally stand up for myself. I turned and walked
to my room, gathering a few essentials into a bag.
Barbara was still frozen in shock as I passed her
on my way to the door. I didn't even bother
to say goodbye. I just grabbed my keys, left the house,
and drove to a hotel for the night. When I
finally got to the hotel and settled, and I noticed
that my phone had dozens of myst calls and texts,
all from Barbara. She was blowing up my phone with

(07:56):
everything from screaming voicemails to frantic rambling texts. I did
even bother to listen to them. I knew it would
just be more of the same recrimination's, insults, accusations. I
turned my phone to silent and went to sleep. The
next morning, I woke up to something different. Among the
unread messages, one caught my eye. It was from Oliver. Hey.

(08:17):
It read can we talk? Oliver and I agreed to
meet at my hotel that evening. I wasn't sure what
to expect. I didn't want to read too much into it,
but my mind kept racing Why did he want to
talk to me now? After all this, What could he
possibly have to say that hadn't already been said through
his actions last night. By the time he arrived, my
nerves were shot. I heard the knock at the door

(08:39):
around eight p m. And took a deep breath before
opening it. There he stood, looking tired but calm. Hey,
he said softly. Hey, I replied, stepping aside to let him,
and we sat down on the small couch in the room,
and for a few moments either of us spoke. There
was this heavy, unspoken tension between us, like all the
years and memories we buried were suddenly rising to the surface.

(09:01):
Finally he broke the silence. Barbara has been calling me NonStop,
he said, shaking his head. She's been waiting for me
at the apartment with my parents and sister. I guess
she thought i'd come back after cooling off, but I couldn't.
I needed to talk to you first. Yet. She's been
calling me too, I said, showing him the long list
of missed calls on my phone. I haven't answered. He
smiled slightly, then leaned back, rubbing his face. This whole

(09:23):
thing's a mess. Huh, I nodded, yea, it's a disaster.
For the next few hours, we talked about everything that
passed the wedding and what had happened between us all
those years ago. He told me how he'd never really
forgotten about me after his family moved away, how he'd
always wondered what could have been if things had turned
out differently. We were good together, he said, quietly, looking
at me with that same warmth I remembered from when

(09:45):
we were teenagers. Yeah, I agreed, we really were. He
told me about how things with Barbara had started out
fine but had gradually turned into something else. I don't
even know how it got this far, he admitted. At first,
I thought maybe I was just settling into the idea
of a stable life. Barbara, she was in tense but
seemed driven. I thought it was passion, but over time
I started to see how manipulative she could be. I stayed, though,

(10:06):
probably out of pity more than anything. I didn't want
to hurt her, and I thought I could make it work.
I shook my head. You shouldn't stay with some one
out of pity. That's not fair to either of you.
I know that now, he said, But last night, when
she humiliated you like that, I couldn't take it any more.
That was the moment I realized I was done pretending.
We kept talking, sharing old memories, laughing about silly things

(10:29):
we'd done as kids. There was a spark between us,
something I hadn't felt in years. It was like we
picked up right where we left off. For a moment,
I wondered if things were about to take a more
intimate turn. His eyes lingered on mine, and I could
feel the tension building, but we both hesitated. Maybe we
should take things slow, he finally said, almost reading my thoughts. Yeah,
I agreed, there's a lot to process right now. We

(10:50):
talked until the early hours of the morning, five a m.
To be exact. Eventually, the exhaustion caught up with us
and we both fell into a comfortable silence, I could
tell that Oliver felt lighter, as if a weight had
been lifted off his shoulders. He had finally made peace
with the decision to leave Barbara. I think I'm going
to pack up my things today, he said, after a
long pause. I'll tell her it's over and leave the apartment.

(11:12):
I can't keep living a lie. Are you sure, I asked, yeah,
He nodded, I'm done. I should have done this a
long time ago. With that, he stood up and stretched,
I'll get going. Thanks for listening. I really needed this
any time, I said, walking him to the door. As
he left, I couldn't help but feel a strange mix
of relief and anticipation. This was far from over, but

(11:34):
for the first time in a long time, I felt
like I had control over my own life again. The
next chapter was just beginning. Later that morning, I managed
to catch a couple of hours of sleep, but around noon,
I was woken up by loud banging on my hotel
room door. For a moment, I thought it might be
Oliver coming back, but the aggressive, frantic knocking didn't match
his style. Abigail opened the door. Barbara, I groaned, pulling

(11:55):
myself out of bed. She didn't stop banging. I considered
ignoring her, but I didn't want her waking up half
the hotel. I opened the door slightly, just enough to
glare at her. What do you want, I asked coldly.
Barbara shoved the door open and barged, and still wearing
a cocktail, dress or hair a mess, makeup smudged. Where
is he, she hissed, looking around the room, like Oliver

(12:16):
might be hiding in the closet. I crossed my arms.
He's not here. Don't lie to me, she snapped. You
think I don't know what's going on. He didn't come
home last night. He's not answering his phone. I know
he's been with you. Calm down, Barbara, I said, trying
to keep my composure. Oliver came here last night to talk.

(12:37):
That's it. We talked, and then he left. I don't
know where he is now. Barbara's eyes narrowed. Talk. Really,
that's all you expect me to believe that. I don't
care what you believe. Her face contorted with rage. You've
always wanted to ruin my life, haven't you. You couldn't
stand that I had someone who loved me, so you
had to steal him. Away. You're a pathetic, jealous bitch.

(12:57):
I took a deep breath. Barbara, you brought this on
your saw who you really are last night? You humiliated
me in front of all those people. Oliver stood up
for me because you crossed the line, not because I
stole him. Before she could respond, her phone rang. She
snatched it out of her bag and froze when she
saw the caller. I d at him, She whispered her
eyes while she answered, immediately putting it on speaker. Oliver,
where the hell are you? His voice came through, calm

(13:19):
but firm, Barbara, I'm at the apartment packing my things.
I'm leaving where dun? Barbara gasped, No, you can't do this.
You can't just walk away like this. I'm your fiance,
not anymore. He said. I'm sorry, but I can't do this.
I've been lying to both of us for too long.
We were never meant to be. Is it because of Abigail?
She shrieked, Did you leave me for her? There was

(13:40):
a pause on his end. This isn't about Abigail, he
finally said, this is about us. Our relationship has been
toxic for a long time. Last night was the final straw.
Barbara screamed in frustration and hung up the call, throwing
her phone across the room. I stood there quietly, watching
her unravel. She looked at me with wild eyes, like
she was ready to tear me apart. You think thank

(14:00):
you one, don't you? She spat Barbara, This isn't a competition.
You need to let him go. She shook her head violently. No,
this isn't over. You'll see. Without another word, she stormed
out of the room, slamming the door behind her. I
sat on the bed, my mind racing. I didn't know
what Barbara was planning, but something told me she wasn't
going to give up easily. An hour later, I got

(14:20):
a call from an unknown number. When I answered, a
voice I didn't expect said, Abigail, this is Officer Daniels.
We've had a report of a disturbance at Oliver's apartment.
We need to speak with you. My heart dropped. What
kind of disturbance? There's been an incident involving your sister.
When I arrived at Oliver's apartment later that afternoon, the
scene was chaotic. Barbara was crying hysterically, surrounded by her
parents and his sister. While Oliver stood calmly off to

(14:43):
the side with a few bags packed. His face was
set in stone. You can't do this, Oliver. We're supposed
to be together. Barbara sobbed. I've already made my decision,
he said, I'm done, Barbara. His parents arrived soon after.
I expected them to side with her, to beg him
to reconsider. Instead, his dad walked over to him, placed
a hand on it shoulder, and said, son, choose with
your heart and mind. If you truly understand what you

(15:03):
want and who makes you happy, then take that path
and don't listen to anyone else. Lives too short to
live a lie. His mother nodded in agreement. We trust you, Oliver.
Barbara's jaw dropped your supporting this, he's abandoning me. Oliver's
mom gave her a pointed look. Maybe you should reflect
on why he's leaving instead of blaming everyone else. Barbara
wailed even louder as his family helped him load his

(15:24):
bags into his car. Watching all this unfold, I felt
a pang of jealousy. I wish I'd had parents like his, calm,
supportive and wise mind. Well, they were a nightmare, always
putting Barbara on a pedestal while treating me like I
was a constant disappointment. After Oliver finished packing, he walked
over to me and pulled me aside, Abigail. He said, quietly,
let's get out of here. Let's leave all this behind.

(15:45):
We can go to another state, start over together. No drama,
no manipulation, no pretending, just us as adults this time,
not two teenagers holding hands. My heart pounded in my chest.
Are you serious? Dead's serious? I've had enough of this.
I want a real life with you. The words hit
me harder than I expected. I didn't even hesitate. Okay,

(16:09):
I said, let's do it. We made a plan to
meet in a few hours and drive out to Oregon,
far enough from everything and everyone. I headed back home
to pack, knowing full well what kind of reaction I
was going to get. As I left Oliver's place, I
noticed Barbara wasn't there any more. It seems strange at first,
but I figured maybe she'd finally given up. I couldn't
have been more wrong. She hadn't gone back to their apartments.

(16:29):
She'd followed me A few minutes after I drove off.
Barbara must have jumped into a taxi because When I
arrived at my parents' house, there she was pacing outside
like a vulture. She probably figured I was heading home
to pack and wanted to confront me before anyone else could.
As soon as I got out of the car, she
ran up to me, screaming, you think you can just
run off with him? Your delusional, she shrieked. I brushed
past her and headed inside. That's when the real storm began.

(16:51):
My parents immediately pounced on me, with Barbara right behind them.
Are you happy now, my mom demanded, You've ruined your
sister's life. Oliver left her because of you. You're a
selfish little snake. Barbara added, you think you're better than me.
You'll never have what I have. I stared at them emotionless.
What you have? You mean a guy who walked out

(17:11):
on you because you couldn't stop tearing people down. Your disgusting,
she screamed. Get out of here. You're not part of
this family any more. Gladly, I said, calmly. I went
to my room and packed my things quickly. I grabbed
everything important, including personal documents and my savings account information.
My dad barged in at one point, demanding to know

(17:31):
what I was doing. I'm leaving, I said flatly, and
I'm taking my share of the family money. What you
can't do that, watch me. I transferred the money to
my own account, knowing it would send them into a frenzy.
As I walked out the door for the last time,
Barbara and my mom were screaming at the top of
their lungs. I didn't even flinch. I got into my car,
blasted some music to drown out the noise, and drove

(17:52):
off without looking back. Oliver was waiting for me near
a gas station off the highway. We both smiled as
we pulled up next to each other. Ready, he asked,
more than ready? I said. We hit the road and
didn't stop until we reached Oregon. Late that night. We
checked into a small, cozy hotel and talked about our plans.
Over the next few days, we found a temporary apartment
and started piecing together our new life. Everything had changed

(18:14):
so quickly, but in a strange way, it felt like
it was meant to be. Meanwhile, his parents stayed in touch,
fully supportive of his decision. They didn't care about the
drama or what anyone thought. They just wanted him to
be happy. I ended that I knew I'd never get
that kind of love and understanding from my own family,
and honestly, I didn't want to any more. I cut
off all contact with my parents and Barbara. I blocked

(18:35):
their numbers, changed my phone, and erased them from my life.
It felt like shedding a heavy, suffocating weight. Oliver and
I had a lot of healing to do, but we
were ready for it. We weren't kids any more, and
we weren't going to let the pass define us. This
was our fresh start. No more lies, no more pain,
just us building something real together. And that's how everything
changed in my life, faster than I could have imagined.
But maybe that's exactly what I needed.
Advertise With Us

Popular Podcasts

My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

My Favorite Murder is a true crime comedy podcast hosted by Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark. Each week, Karen and Georgia share compelling true crimes and hometown stories from friends and listeners. Since MFM launched in January of 2016, Karen and Georgia have shared their lifelong interest in true crime and have covered stories of infamous serial killers like the Night Stalker, mysterious cold cases, captivating cults, incredible survivor stories and important events from history like the Tulsa race massacre of 1921. My Favorite Murder is part of the Exactly Right podcast network that provides a platform for bold, creative voices to bring to life provocative, entertaining and relatable stories for audiences everywhere. The Exactly Right roster of podcasts covers a variety of topics including historic true crime, comedic interviews and news, science, pop culture and more. Podcasts on the network include Buried Bones with Kate Winkler Dawson and Paul Holes, That's Messed Up: An SVU Podcast, This Podcast Will Kill You, Bananas and more.

24/7 News: The Latest

24/7 News: The Latest

The latest news in 4 minutes updated every hour, every day.

Dateline NBC

Dateline NBC

Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Follow now to get the latest episodes of Dateline NBC completely free, or subscribe to Dateline Premium for ad-free listening and exclusive bonus content: DatelinePremium.com

Music, radio and podcasts, all free. Listen online or download the iHeart App.

Connect

© 2025 iHeartMedia, Inc.