August 20, 2025 • 8 mins
#horrorstories #reddithorrorstories #ScaryStories #creepypasta #horrortales #familyhorror #darksecrets #traumarevealed #deadlyreunion #emotionalhorror What was meant to be a warm family reunion quickly spirals into horror when buried secrets resurface. As old wounds reopen and hidden traumas are brought to light, the gathering turns deadly. A tangled web of betrayal, abuse, and generational darkness is slowly unraveled, revealing that sometimes the scariest things are the ones closest to home. A gripping and emotional horror story of blood ties, truth, and the monsters we hide behind closed doors. horrorstories, reddithorrorstories, scarystories, horrorstory, creepypasta, horrortales, familysecrets, reuniongonewrong, darkpast, psychologicalhorror, emotionaltrauma, buriedtruths, generationaltrauma, familydrama, horrorfiction, betrayal, chillingreveal, hauntedbythepast, deadlytruths, innerdemons
Mark as Played
Transcript
Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:00):
Okay, before I get into this, let me just say something.
Don't start bombarding me with questions about where it happened
or who these people are. Don't ask me for names, dates,
or locations. Please. I'm still crawling my way out of
this mess, and I'm not exactly eager to rip the
scab off again. Therapy's been rough enough already, so just
(00:24):
listen and let me get it out. It all started
with one of those classic family reunions, you know, the type.
Half of us hadn't seen each other in years, and
some hadn't spoken in decades. There were old grudges under
the surface, polite smiles hiding years of bitterness, and wine,
way too much wine. The excuse for this chaos Grandma's
(00:47):
eighty fifth birthday. Apparently that was a big enough deal
for everyone to swallow their pride and show up. The
reunion was set at the family estate, and when I
say estate, I mean one of those old, ivy covered
manners straight out of a Gothic novel. It was nestled
deep in the main woods, and during the day it
(01:08):
was kind of charming, peaceful even, but at night that
place took on a whole different vibe. Long hallways that
seemed to stretch forever, cold drafts coming from nowhere, creaky floorboards,
the kind of place that makes you glance over your
shoulder more than once. We all rolled in on Friday,
hauling suit cases and pretending like we were happy to
(01:29):
be there. There were hugs, awkward small talk, and too
many oh my gosh, look how much you've grown moments.
It felt like we were actors on stage, playing a
happy family for an audience that didn't exist. But by
Sunday morning, the show was over because some one was dead.
It was Uncle Peter. Peter was how do I describe him?
(01:54):
He was loud, the kind of guy who'd walk into
a room and immediately take over. He had this way
of telling stories that made every one laugh, even if
the stories were wildly inappropriate or exaggerated beyond belief. He
always had a glass of whiskey in one hand and
a smirk on his face. Some people adored him, others,
(02:16):
like me, tolerated him. That morning, Peter didn't come down
for breakfast. At first, no one thought much of it,
maybe he was sleeping off the previous night's drinking session.
But when hours passed and he still hadn't shown up.
Some one, I think it was aunt Lydia, decided to
check on him. What she found sent everything spiraling. Peter
(02:39):
was in his guest room, slumped in a chair by
the window. His eyes were glassy, staring at nothing. His
skin had this grayish tint, like the color had been
sucked out of him. At first, we all thought it
had to be a heart attack. He wasn't exactly the
picture of health. The man smoked like it was still
(03:00):
nineteen sixty two and had high blood pressure on top
of that. But then the cops showed up and the
coroner gave us news. None of us were ready for poison,
a rare plant based poison, to be exact. Some one
had slipped it into his drink the night before. The
bottle was missing, and whoever had done it knew exactly
(03:20):
what they were doing. That's when things got really bad.
The police locked the estate down. No one was allowed
to leave. We were trapped there together with the heavy
knowledge hanging in the air like a storm cloud. Someone
in our family had murdered Uncle Peter. At first there
was shock, tears, gasps of horror, but as the hours
(03:45):
turned into days, the grief twisted into something darker. Suspicion, paranoia,
whispered accusations in shadowy corners. Everyone was looking over their shoulder,
wondering if they'd be next, and the cops weren't helping.
They made it clear that we were all suspects, every
(04:06):
single one of us the suspects. Let's break this down,
because trust me, we all had reasons. Cousin Miranda was
the first name on every one's lips. She and Peter
had gone at it the night before, loud enough that
even the staff heard it, something about a piece of
family property Peter had sold off. Miranda was furious. She
(04:30):
believed the land was rightfully hers and saw Peter as
a greedy bastard for taking it away. She stormed out
of the dining room after dinner, red faced and swearing
she had motive. Jonah, my brother wasn't much better. Money
Trouble doesn't even begin to describe his situation. Jonah owed people,
(04:51):
dangerous people. I knew Peter had offered him a loan
a few months ago, but it wasn't a gift. It
came with humiliating strings at t hatched. Jonah had turned
it down, But who's to say he didn't finally snap.
Maybe he figured murder was easier than paying off his debts.
Aunt Lydia, sweet, gentle, aunt Lydia, she always seemed so perfect,
(05:16):
so proper, but there was something off about her. Three
years ago, her husband died under mysterious circumstances. Officially, it
was ruled a suicide, but whispers floated around the family
that Lydia knew more than she let on. She and
Peter had been unusually close, too close, if you believe
(05:36):
the rumors. Maybe things turned sour between them. And then
there was Grandma herself. I know, I know, it sounds insane.
She was eighty five and frail, barely able to climb
stairs without help, but she wasn't stupid. Peter controlled the
family will, and there were rumors he planned to change
(05:57):
it soon if she'd been cut well, Desperation does strange
things to people. And let's not forget the wild card
in all this, Emily my sister. At that point, no
one even considered Emily. She was quiet, almost invisible at times.
She'd spent most of the reunion curled up in corners
(06:18):
with a book, nodding politely when spoken to, but never
really engaging. But I'm getting ahead of myself. The police
questioned all of us one by one. We sat in
that grand old library like school children waiting for the principal.
No one confessed, no one cracked, and for three long
(06:39):
days we were stuck there, sleeping in creaky beds, sharing
awkward meals, and wondering if the killer was sitting at
the same table, smiling like nothing had happened. Then they
found the bottle. It was hidden in the cellar, behind
rows of dusty wine racks, a bottle of single malt
scotch laced with poison. This dame brand Peter drank every
(07:01):
single night. The fingerprints on the bottle told the story Emily.
We were stunned. None of us had suspected her, not
even for a second. She'd always seemed so gentle, so passive.
She and Peter had seemed to get along fine, or
so we thought. But under police questioning, the truths billed out.
(07:25):
Peter had been abusing her. It started when she was twelve.
She'd kept it buried all these years, carrying the weight
in silence. Seeing him at the reunion, laughing, drinking, acting
like the adored uncle, something inside her snapped. She couldn't
take it anymore. That night, after dinner, she'd gone to
(07:46):
the liquor stash, slipped the poisoned bottle into his collection,
and left. She hadn't planned to get away with it.
She didn't even think that far ahead. She just wanted
him to stop. When the police let her out in handcuffs,
the house fell silent. No one spoke. We still talk
about it, sometimes not out loud and never using real names.
(08:11):
But every family holiday since there's this moment, a moment
when the laughter dies down and we all fall quiet.
We glance at each other, forced smiles plastered on our faces.
We pass the turkey, We tell old stories. We try
to pretend, but deep down we all remember. Because here's
(08:33):
the thing. Monsters don't always hide under the bed. Sometimes
they're sitting right across from you at dinner. The end
Okay, before I get into this, let me just say something.
Don't start bombarding me with questions about where it happened
or who these people are. Don't ask me for names, dates,
or locations. Please. I'm still crawling my way out of
this mess, and I'm not exactly eager to rip the
scab off again. Therapy's been rough enough already, so just
(00:24):
listen and let me get it out. It all started
with one of those classic family reunions, you know, the type.
Half of us hadn't seen each other in years, and
some hadn't spoken in decades. There were old grudges under
the surface, polite smiles hiding years of bitterness, and wine,
way too much wine. The excuse for this chaos Grandma's
(00:47):
eighty fifth birthday. Apparently that was a big enough deal
for everyone to swallow their pride and show up. The
reunion was set at the family estate, and when I
say estate, I mean one of those old, ivy covered
manners straight out of a Gothic novel. It was nestled
deep in the main woods, and during the day it
(01:08):
was kind of charming, peaceful even, but at night that
place took on a whole different vibe. Long hallways that
seemed to stretch forever, cold drafts coming from nowhere, creaky floorboards,
the kind of place that makes you glance over your
shoulder more than once. We all rolled in on Friday,
hauling suit cases and pretending like we were happy to
(01:29):
be there. There were hugs, awkward small talk, and too
many oh my gosh, look how much you've grown moments.
It felt like we were actors on stage, playing a
happy family for an audience that didn't exist. But by
Sunday morning, the show was over because some one was dead.
It was Uncle Peter. Peter was how do I describe him?
(01:54):
He was loud, the kind of guy who'd walk into
a room and immediately take over. He had this way
of telling stories that made every one laugh, even if
the stories were wildly inappropriate or exaggerated beyond belief. He
always had a glass of whiskey in one hand and
a smirk on his face. Some people adored him, others,
(02:16):
like me, tolerated him. That morning, Peter didn't come down
for breakfast. At first, no one thought much of it,
maybe he was sleeping off the previous night's drinking session.
But when hours passed and he still hadn't shown up.
Some one, I think it was aunt Lydia, decided to
check on him. What she found sent everything spiraling. Peter
(02:39):
was in his guest room, slumped in a chair by
the window. His eyes were glassy, staring at nothing. His
skin had this grayish tint, like the color had been
sucked out of him. At first, we all thought it
had to be a heart attack. He wasn't exactly the
picture of health. The man smoked like it was still
(03:00):
nineteen sixty two and had high blood pressure on top
of that. But then the cops showed up and the
coroner gave us news. None of us were ready for poison,
a rare plant based poison, to be exact. Some one
had slipped it into his drink the night before. The
bottle was missing, and whoever had done it knew exactly
(03:20):
what they were doing. That's when things got really bad.
The police locked the estate down. No one was allowed
to leave. We were trapped there together with the heavy
knowledge hanging in the air like a storm cloud. Someone
in our family had murdered Uncle Peter. At first there
was shock, tears, gasps of horror, but as the hours
(03:45):
turned into days, the grief twisted into something darker. Suspicion, paranoia,
whispered accusations in shadowy corners. Everyone was looking over their shoulder,
wondering if they'd be next, and the cops weren't helping.
They made it clear that we were all suspects, every
(04:06):
single one of us the suspects. Let's break this down,
because trust me, we all had reasons. Cousin Miranda was
the first name on every one's lips. She and Peter
had gone at it the night before, loud enough that
even the staff heard it, something about a piece of
family property Peter had sold off. Miranda was furious. She
(04:30):
believed the land was rightfully hers and saw Peter as
a greedy bastard for taking it away. She stormed out
of the dining room after dinner, red faced and swearing
she had motive. Jonah, my brother wasn't much better. Money
Trouble doesn't even begin to describe his situation. Jonah owed people,
(04:51):
dangerous people. I knew Peter had offered him a loan
a few months ago, but it wasn't a gift. It
came with humiliating strings at t hatched. Jonah had turned
it down, But who's to say he didn't finally snap.
Maybe he figured murder was easier than paying off his debts.
Aunt Lydia, sweet, gentle, aunt Lydia, she always seemed so perfect,
(05:16):
so proper, but there was something off about her. Three
years ago, her husband died under mysterious circumstances. Officially, it
was ruled a suicide, but whispers floated around the family
that Lydia knew more than she let on. She and
Peter had been unusually close, too close, if you believe
(05:36):
the rumors. Maybe things turned sour between them. And then
there was Grandma herself. I know, I know, it sounds insane.
She was eighty five and frail, barely able to climb
stairs without help, but she wasn't stupid. Peter controlled the
family will, and there were rumors he planned to change
(05:57):
it soon if she'd been cut well, Desperation does strange
things to people. And let's not forget the wild card
in all this, Emily my sister. At that point, no
one even considered Emily. She was quiet, almost invisible at times.
She'd spent most of the reunion curled up in corners
(06:18):
with a book, nodding politely when spoken to, but never
really engaging. But I'm getting ahead of myself. The police
questioned all of us one by one. We sat in
that grand old library like school children waiting for the principal.
No one confessed, no one cracked, and for three long
(06:39):
days we were stuck there, sleeping in creaky beds, sharing
awkward meals, and wondering if the killer was sitting at
the same table, smiling like nothing had happened. Then they
found the bottle. It was hidden in the cellar, behind
rows of dusty wine racks, a bottle of single malt
scotch laced with poison. This dame brand Peter drank every
(07:01):
single night. The fingerprints on the bottle told the story Emily.
We were stunned. None of us had suspected her, not
even for a second. She'd always seemed so gentle, so passive.
She and Peter had seemed to get along fine, or
so we thought. But under police questioning, the truths billed out.
(07:25):
Peter had been abusing her. It started when she was twelve.
She'd kept it buried all these years, carrying the weight
in silence. Seeing him at the reunion, laughing, drinking, acting
like the adored uncle, something inside her snapped. She couldn't
take it anymore. That night, after dinner, she'd gone to
(07:46):
the liquor stash, slipped the poisoned bottle into his collection,
and left. She hadn't planned to get away with it.
She didn't even think that far ahead. She just wanted
him to stop. When the police let her out in handcuffs,
the house fell silent. No one spoke. We still talk
about it, sometimes not out loud and never using real names.
(08:11):
But every family holiday since there's this moment, a moment
when the laughter dies down and we all fall quiet.
We glance at each other, forced smiles plastered on our faces.
We pass the turkey, We tell old stories. We try
to pretend, but deep down we all remember. Because here's
(08:33):
the thing. Monsters don't always hide under the bed. Sometimes
they're sitting right across from you at dinner. The end
Popular Podcasts
Stuff You Should Know
If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.
My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark
My Favorite Murder is a true crime comedy podcast hosted by Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark. Each week, Karen and Georgia share compelling true crimes and hometown stories from friends and listeners. Since MFM launched in January of 2016, Karen and Georgia have shared their lifelong interest in true crime and have covered stories of infamous serial killers like the Night Stalker, mysterious cold cases, captivating cults, incredible survivor stories and important events from history like the Tulsa race massacre of 1921. My Favorite Murder is part of the Exactly Right podcast network that provides a platform for bold, creative voices to bring to life provocative, entertaining and relatable stories for audiences everywhere. The Exactly Right roster of podcasts covers a variety of topics including historic true crime, comedic interviews and news, science, pop culture and more. Podcasts on the network include Buried Bones with Kate Winkler Dawson and Paul Holes, That's Messed Up: An SVU Podcast, This Podcast Will Kill You, Bananas and more.
The Joe Rogan Experience
The official podcast of comedian Joe Rogan.