Merkle's Mistake: The Blunder That Changed Baseball History

On September 23, 1908, one of the most iconic moments in baseball history occurred during a game between the New York Giants and the Chicago Cubs at the Polo Grounds in New York City. The game was part of a tight pennant race, with both teams vying for the National League championship.

In the bottom of the ninth inning, with the score tied 1-1, the Giants had runners on first and third with two outs. The batter, Al Bridwell, hit a single to center field, and the runner on third, Moose McCormick, scored the apparent winning run. However, the runner on first, Fred Merkle, who was just 19 years old at the time, failed to touch second base and instead ran directly to the clubhouse to avoid the crowd that had stormed the field, thinking the game was over.

The Cubs second baseman, Johnny Evers, noticed Merkle's mistake and called for the ball. He touched second base, claiming a force out on Merkle, which would nullify the winning run. Chaos ensued as the fans had already flooded the field, and the game could not continue. The umpires eventually ruled the game a tie, to be replayed later if necessary.
This event became known as "Merkle's Boner" and is one of the most famous blunders in baseball history. The incident had significant implications for the pennant race that year. The Giants and Cubs ended the season tied for first place, and the replayed game was won by the Cubs, who went on to win the National League championship.

Merkle, despite his young age and the infamous mistake, went on to have a solid 16-year career in the major leagues. However, he would always be remembered for this one moment, which overshadowed his other accomplishments on the field.

The incident also highlighted the importance of knowing and following the rules of the game, no matter the situation. It showed that even a seemingly small mistake can have significant consequences, especially in high-stakes situations like a pennant race.

"Merkle's Boner" remains a legendary moment in baseball history, often cited as an example of the unpredictable nature of the sport and the importance of attention to detail. It is a reminder that even in the heat of the moment, players must keep their focus and adhere to the fundamentals of the game.

This content was created in partnership and with the help of Artificial Intelligence AI

Episode Transcript

Speaker 1 (00:00):
Welcome to This Moment in Sports History podcast on September
twenty third, nineteen zero eight. One of the most iconic
moments in baseball history occurred during a game between the
New York Giants and the Chicago Cubs at the Polo
Grounds in New York City. The game was part of
a tight Pennon race, with both teams vying for the

(00:20):
National League championship. In the bottom of the ninth inning,
with the score tied one one, the Giants had runners
on first and third with two outs. The batter Al
Bridwell hit a single to center field, and the runner
on third, Moose McCormick, scored The apparent winning run. However,
failed as another the Cub's second basement, Johnny Evers, noticed

(00:43):
Merkel's mistake and called for the ball. He touched second base,
claiming a force out on Markle, which would nullify the
winning run. Chaos ensued as the fans had already flooded
the field and the game could not continue. The umpires
eventually ruled the game a tie, to be replayed later
if necessary. This event became known as Merkeles boner in

(01:05):
and is one of the most famous blunders and baseball history.
The incident had significant implications for the pennant race that year.
The Giants and Cubs ended the season tied for first place,
and the replayed game was won by the Cubs, who
went on to win the National League Championship. Merkel, despite
his young age and the infamous mistake, went on to

(01:26):
have a solid sixteen year career in the major leagues. However,
he would always be remembered for this one woman, which
overshadowed his other accomplishments on the field. The incident also
highlighted the importance of knowing and following the rules of
the game, no matter the situation. It showed that even
a seemingly small mistake can have significant consequences, especially in

(01:48):
high stake situations like a pennet race. But Merkeles boner
remains a legendary moment in baseball history, often cited as
an example of the unpredictable nature of the sport and
the importance of attention to detail. It is a reminder
that even in the heat of the moment, players must
keep their focus and adhere to the fundamentals of the game.

(02:09):
And that wraps it up. Join us tomorrow and be
sure to hit that subscribe button so you never miss
a daily slice of sports history. This has been a
quiet please Studios Production. For more check out Quiet Please
dot Ai, thank you for listening.