June 18, 2025 • 57 mins
In this Rewired episode, Dani peels back the layers of one of the most haunting and highly publicized true crime cases of our time — the murder of Gabby Petito. The story was everywhere. Viral hashtags. 24-hour news cycles. Social media sleuths dissecting every second of footage. But behind the public obsession lies a deeply human story of control, power imbalance, emotional abuse, and the dangerous dynamics that often hide in plain sight. Dani takes us beyond the headlines and police reports, unpacking the psychological threads woven into Gabby and Brian’s relationship.
From the disturbing behaviors captured on bodycam footage to the toxic patterns of coercive control, Dani explores the unsettling psychology that often fuels intimate partner violence — and how society sometimes misses the red flags until it’s too late. We examine the role of parasocial relationships, the true crime media machine, and the uncomfortable reality of how some victims are elevated while others remain invisible. Why did this case capture the public imagination so powerfully? What does it reveal about our collective fascination with tragedy?
And how can we better recognize the early warning signs that may save lives? This is not just a retelling.
This is a rewiring — challenging you to see the Gabby Petito case through a different lens.
Listener discretion is advised.
From the disturbing behaviors captured on bodycam footage to the toxic patterns of coercive control, Dani explores the unsettling psychology that often fuels intimate partner violence — and how society sometimes misses the red flags until it’s too late. We examine the role of parasocial relationships, the true crime media machine, and the uncomfortable reality of how some victims are elevated while others remain invisible. Why did this case capture the public imagination so powerfully? What does it reveal about our collective fascination with tragedy?
And how can we better recognize the early warning signs that may save lives? This is not just a retelling.
This is a rewiring — challenging you to see the Gabby Petito case through a different lens.
Listener discretion is advised.
Mark as Played
Transcript
Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:08):
Hello, true crime lovers, Welcome back to The Guilty Files
True Crime Rewired, the podcast where we take one crime,
two perspectives, and create endless intrigue. I'm Danny, your guide
for the second act of this case, where we take
the hard facts from earlier this week and twist them
into something unexpected, daring, and just a little wicked. Think
(00:30):
of me as your pilot through the tangled web of
true crime, with the side of sass and a dash
of drama to keep you hooked. At The Guilty Files
True Crime Rewritten. We believe every crime has two sides
to the story, and every listener deserves the thrill of both.
So sit back, lean in, and let's rewrite the narrative.
(00:52):
Because true crime isn't just meant to be solved, It's
meant to be explored. Let's get started. Welcome back, Guilty
Files fam and if you're joining us for the first time,
(01:14):
buckle up because today we're rewiring one of the most heartbreaking, complicated,
and widely publicized cases of the last decade, the murder
of Gabby Petito. My co host Brian recently walked you
through the factual case file in meticulous detail. As always,
(01:34):
Brian delivered that clean, sharp, professional lens you've come to
expect from the guilty files uncovered. But here on Rewired, well,
we pull a little differently on the thread. We take
those same facts and we explore the psychological layers, the
sociological systems, the procedural cracks, and yes, we take some
(01:58):
bold liberties with speculatives scenarios that might have unfolded, because
real cases don't live in a vacuum. People are messy,
systems fail, and sometimes truth hides between the lines. What
if there were pieces we never saw? What if we
could shine light on the maybe's that still haunt this case?
(02:22):
And before we go any further, let me make something
abundantly clear. While everything you're about to hear is rooted
in the real timeline, much of today's episode is somewhat hypothetical,
speculative dramatizations inspired by the original case. The facts stay facts,
(02:44):
but today we explore what could have been hiding beneath them.
Today's episode is divided into ten acts, each one peeling
back a layer of possible darkness that may have gone unnoticed.
So if you're ready, let's dive headfirst into one of
the most most tragic cautionary tales of the modern social
media era. Gabby Petito the Rewired File. All right, my
(03:08):
fellow rewired junkies, before we dive into the deep end
of the what ifs today, let's hit pause for a
hot second and lay out our playing field. Because listen,
my brilliant co host Brian already walked you through the
full case file over on the Guilty Files Uncovered and
you know Brian facts, receipts, timelines. Man comes locked and
(03:33):
loaded like a defense attorney with a laser pointer. But
I want to make sure we're all properly grounded before
I start rewiring this thing into the darker, messier places
our mind's love to wander. So here's your high speed
Gabby Potito refresher. Gabby Petito twenty two years old, Bright, vibrant, artistic,
(03:56):
deeply loved. She grew up in New York, had a big,
blended family, a gift for photography, and big dreams of travel,
influencer stardom. Basically the kind of young woman every parent
hopes their daughter grows into, independent, creative, alive. And then
there was Brian Laundry, the high school sweetheart who slowly
(04:16):
transitioned into the boyfriend, the fiance, and ultimately the killer.
The two of them hit the road in July of
twenty twenty one in that infamous converted van, chasing the
hashtag van life dream uploading curated Instagram posts that painted
the perfect digital postcard of young love on the open road.
(04:40):
But behind those beautiful photos, yeah, something far darker was brewing.
There were red flags. Controlling behaviors, emotional manipulation, isolation from
family and friends, the classic slowburn setup for what domestic
violence experts call CoA control. You don't always see the
(05:03):
bruises early on, but the damage is there. Their trip
unraveled in moab Utah when police responded to a domestic dispute.
A witness called nine to one one saying Brian was
hitting Gabby, But when cops arrived, the narrative flipped. Gabby
was crying, blaming herself, classic DV victim behavior, and Brian
(05:27):
played the calm, rational, oh she's just stressed card, and
despite the physical marks on both of them, no arrest
was made. Instead, the cops separated them for the night
and sent them on their way. And folks, let's just
say we'll be revisiting that little moment of systemic failure. Later,
(05:50):
fast forward, Gabby disappears, Brian returns home alone to Florida,
no explanation, no help in the search, just radio silence
while her family desperately pleads for answers. The nation watches
in horror, The Internet turns into full blown amateur CSI,
(06:12):
and finally Gabby's remains are discovered in Wyoming on September nineteenth,
twenty twenty one. She was strangled to death a homicide. Meanwhile,
Brian Poof vanishes into the Florida Wilderness. Massive manhunt, FBI
swarms the Carlton Reserve. Weeks go by, and then his
(06:34):
skeletal remains are found on October twentieth, cause of death suicide.
A water logged notebook near his body contained his so
called confession. And we're going to have some thoughts about
that little manipulative manifesto later too. So yeah, that's the
rough sketch of it. Tragic, preventable and chilling in every way.
(06:56):
But here at Rewired, we don't stop at the headlines.
We peel back the messy layers hiding beneath, because for
every hard fact in this case, there are a dozen
ways this nightmare could have played out differently, and we're
about to explore them. You ready for this ride? Good,
(07:16):
because from here on out we're stepping off the factual
trail and marching straight into the speculative woods. All right,
now that we've refreshed your memory and knocked the dust
off the facts, let's start where this whole tragedy might
have been stopped dead in its tracks. Moab Utah. The
flashing lights, the police cams rolling, the domestic call that
(07:40):
could have changed everything if anyone had actually done their
damn job. Welcome to Act one, the moment that could
have changed everything. We begin in moab Utah, August twelfth,
twenty twenty one. Red Rock cliffs glow under that late
summer sun. The air smells dry, that kind of desert
(08:03):
heat that bakes your skin like you're inside some ancient
biblical oven. Tourists buzz around town, renting jeeps, snapping selfies,
living out their Southwest Adventure fantasies. It's peaceful quiet, except
it wasn't, because somewhere on the side of that dusty
main road near Moonflower co Op, inside a cramped little
(08:27):
white Ford transit van, hell was simmering, and it wasn't
the temperature causing the boil. Brian Laundry and Gabby Patito
trapped together in what had become both their dream and
their cage van life Instagram fame endless, wide open roads,
but inside that van, barely eighty square feet of space,
(08:52):
shrinking tighter every single mile, And on this particular day,
that tension finally cracked wide open, not behind closed doors,
but in full view of a bystander who had the
courage to do what many don't. They picked up the
phone and called nine to one. Pint one. We drove by,
(09:14):
and the gentleman was slapping the girl. That call would
trigger one of the most crucial moments in this entire story,
because from here on out, this could have gone a
thousand different ways, and maybe one of those ways might
have saved Gabby's life. Now here's where I want you
(09:34):
to stay with me, because, as someone who's worn the badge,
I've been on these calls more times than I can count.
Domestic disputes they are messy, they are complicated, and they
are very often the place where officers screw it up
without even realizing it. The responding MOAB officers arrive, they
(09:54):
pull over the van. They see Gabby crying, shaking, visibly distressed.
Brian calm, collected, articulate, spinning his narrative before they even
unclip their seat belts. Classic power dynamics of domestic violence
playing out in real time. And here's the truth. A
(10:17):
lot of the public doesn't want to admit. We as
officers are trained far better to handle violent strangers than
we are intimate partners. This is where law enforcement protocol
so often fails victims like Gabby, because we are conditioned
to believe the louder person is the problem, the one
(10:39):
who cries, who can't regulate, who's emotionally spiraling, That's who
gets labeled unstable. Meanwhile, Brian, he's playing a much more
dangerous game. The cool, collected abuser, the controlled narrative, the
guy who knows the officer's own biases will probably work
in his favor. Now, let me fictionalize this for you
(11:02):
just a second, because we're in rewired territory. Now, picture
Officer Miller, my hypothetical junior officer on the scene that day.
Let's give him some dimension, fresh out of domestic violence training,
eager to apply what he's learned. He's standing there, sweating
under that unforgiving desert sun, watching Gabby wipe tears from
(11:25):
her face over and over again. He's reading her body language,
the constant fidgeting, the way her voice trembles every time
she apologizes for being mean or having OCD, for getting frustrated.
Miller's alarm bells are going off because every victim advocate
(11:46):
class he just sat through told him this is textbook
trauma response, hyper accountability, deflection of blame, minimizing her own
victimhood to protect her abuser. But then there's his supervisor,
Officer Pratt. Let's call him that. Since we're leaning into
both fact and fiction. Pratt's old school been in Moab
(12:10):
a long time. He sees a stressed out couple having
a bad road trip. He's already made up his mind.
Miller wants to push boss. Should we maybe separate them longer,
call in a victim services unit, interview them fully apart.
We've got probable cause, but Pratt shuts him down with
the voice every rookie cop hears sooner or later. Relax, Miller,
(12:34):
they're just kid. Last thing we need is paperwork. If
they're both saying it was nothing, and just like that,
policy gets sidestepped. Not because anyone intended to harm Gabby,
but because domestic violence rarely screams its full name in
broad daylight. It whispers, it gaslights, it wears many masks.
(12:56):
You see, Folks, this is where my law enforcement frustration
hits its peak, because I've seen firsthand how easy it
is for bad decisions to hide behind good intentions. And
let's be blunt. Mandatory arrest laws exist for a reason.
Utah statute required an arrest if probable cause of assault existed.
(13:18):
The nine to one one caller literally said Brian was
slapping Gabby. There were visible injuries on both parties. That's enough,
but guess what they chose not to invoke it. Instead,
they did what cops sometimes do when leadership gets lazy.
They opted for conflict avoidance disguised as de escalation. Brian
(13:40):
got a motel room for the night. Gabby got the van.
No arrest, no report to victim services, no criminal charge
that might have legally separated them. One officer trusted his gut,
the other trusted his comfort zone. And Folks, that fork
in the road right there, that's where this entire story
(14:01):
might have twisted in an entirely different direction. Because here's
the sociological truth you don't hear enough. Most domestic homicides
occur after multiple misted intervention points, not one. Multiple. The
signs stack like bricks. This was one of Gabby's last one.
(14:21):
The missed opportunity in Moab wasn't simply a bad call.
It was a systemic failure, rooted in decades of law
enforcement training, gaps, cultural blind spots, and procedural cowardice, a
failure that played out exactly the way victim's fear at
will they won't believe me. And with that the van
(14:42):
rolled forward, so did the story. One decision, one non arrest,
and now we're barreling straight toward tragedy. But trust me, friends,
that was just the first missed exit ramp, because in
our next act we explore the call that almost broke through.
Now imagine this, what if Gabby tried one last desperate
(15:05):
lifeline before everything spiraled.
Speaker 2 (15:08):
Stay tuned for more of the guilty files. We'll be
right back after these messages.
Speaker 1 (15:17):
Because sometimes help is only one dropped call away. Literally,
welcome to act too. The call that almost broke through.
Now let's pull it another thread in the official case,
we know Gabby reached out to her parents regularly, but
what if there was one call no one knew about,
a fictionalized phone call that never got answered. In our
(15:41):
speculative rewired version, Gabby, isolated, emotionally shredded and running out
of options, picks up that phone in the middle of
some remote Wyoming motel parking lot. It's late, she's anxious.
Brian's out pacing somewhere, cooling off after one of his
signature blow up. The weight of weeks of conflict, control
(16:04):
and emotional exhaustion presses on her like a second skin.
She dials the National Domestic Violence hotline. It connects, but
the cell service out here is brutal, sparse towers, sketchy coverage.
She barely gets out her name, maybe stumbles over some
kind of whispered explanation, I need help my boyfriend the
(16:30):
van and then dead air signal drops. The call disconnects
before the operator can verify her location or even log
the full incident. And that's the thing about abuse victims
on the edge of crisis. Their windows to ask for
help aren't wide. They're slivers, split second moments of courage
(16:53):
that often slams shut as quickly as they open, even
though the hotline might have triggered an emergency welfare check,
even though they might have pinged the call and cross
referenced it with her existing missing person file. In this version,
the call simply evaporates into static and that tiny sliver
of opportunity gone. That's how fragile these escape attempts often are.
(17:18):
Now here's where I want to dig deeper with you
for a second, because this isn't just about one phone call.
This is about trauma bonding. And if you don't understand
trauma bonding, you'll never fully understand why Gabby couldn't simply
pack her bag and walk. So let me put my
sociology hat on for a moment. Trauma bonding is what
(17:41):
happens when cycles of abuse create deeply distorted attachments between
victim and abuser. It's not just psychological, it's chemical. The
brain literally wires itself around the abuse cycle fear relief,
fear relief, and the longer it goes on, the stronger
(18:04):
that bond feels. You get those bursts of kindness after
every blow up, the I'm sorry, baby, I didn't mean it,
honeymoon phase, that floods your brain with dopamine, temporarily easing
the fear. It creates a vicious dependency, not unlike addiction.
You're terrified of them, but you're more terrified of losing them.
(18:28):
That's why so many victims stay. That's why so many
calls for help get choked out by shame, guilt, or
loyalty right before the words leave their mouth. I saw
this exact dynamic play out more times than I care
to count when I was policing in Atlanta. Let me
tell you about one call that's never left me. I
(18:49):
got dispatched to a domestic over on the west side
of my beat, a rough little apartment complex just off Bankhead.
I'm the first unit on scene. The caller said it
sounded violent, multiple screaming, matches, glass breaking, not your garden
variety argument. As I knock, I can already hear the
muffled sobbing behind the door. Finally she opens up, and
(19:13):
immediately the scene hits me like a punch. Blood everywhere.
This man had shoved her into a cheap wooden wine rack.
Glass bottles shattered on impact, slicing her up like she'd
been dropped into barbed wire. Arms, face, legs, deep lacerations,
(19:34):
still bleeding, blood soaking her tank top. She's barefoot, shaking,
barely able to keep her footing, and yet she's got
one hand clutching his arm like he's the victim. Dispatch.
A signed backup arrives shortly after I do. As we
step inside, this guy, cool as ever, steps forward like
(19:57):
he's about to give me a customer service plant. Calm voice,
fake concern officer. It's not what it looks like. She slipped.
I was helping her up in her She starts parrotting it.
It's my fault. I shouldn't have been yelling I slipped.
I wasn't watching where I was going. That right there,
(20:18):
that is trauma bonding unfolding in front of your eyes.
My backup partner leans in, whispers she ain't gonna press charges.
Let's just document it and roll, and I'll be honest.
I was pissed because this is exactly how people die.
I looked that guy straight in the eye, looked back
(20:38):
at her, and I made the call charges custody. I
hooked him right there, read him his rights, and we
took him in. Bleeding, glass covered hands and all. She
was transported for medical but at least she was alive
and away from him, or at least one damn night.
That's the dark power of trauma bonding. You're trapped, not physically, psychologically,
(21:05):
you start believing you're the problem. You blame yourself for
your partner's violence, and by the time anyone realizes how
dangerous it's gotten, you're either missing or dead. And Gabby,
she was caught square in that web. Every tear filled
apology on that Moab body cam, every I was being
(21:28):
mean statement, classic signs. That hotline call she might have made.
That was her moment trying to fight against the trauma bond,
and like so many others, the opportunity slipped right through
her fingers. Now, if you're starting to feel your gut
twist a little good, that's the point of Rewired, because
(21:52):
this isn't just a Gabby story. This is a systemic
pattern that plays out across millions of relationships we never
hear about, and when it happens behind closed doors, the
outcome too often looks exactly like this case file. But
as fragile as that hotline moment was, it wasn't the
last chance because in Act three, we climb inside that van,
(22:18):
and we'll explore the secret recording. Gabby may have left
behind one missed hotline call, one lost signal, and just
like that, another invisible fork in the road will never
fully map. But trust me, the maybes only get darker
from here. All right, let's crawl inside that little van
for a second. And I'm not talking about Instagram's highlight reel.
(22:41):
I'm talking about what Gabby may have really captured behind
closed doors, if she had the foresight that so many
victims wish they had. Now, let's take things inside that tiny,
converted van. We know social media was a huge part
of Gabby's life. She documented everything, So what if she
she also recorded things we never saw. Imagine Gabby, desperate, isolated,
(23:05):
beginning to sense the true danger, secretly setting up a
phone or GoPro inside the van. Over days, perhaps weeks,
it captures footage of escalating fights, verbal abuse turning physical,
Brian screaming, threatening, controlling. This black box of domestic abuse
(23:28):
becomes Gabby's invisible cry for help, one she may have
intended to turn over to authorities once they got home.
The psychology here is gut wrenching. Many victims think, if
I can just get proof people will believe me that
hidden SD card. In our fictionalized version, it later becomes
(23:50):
a key piece of posthumous evidence discovered by digital forensics
after Brian's phone is confiscated, a haunting glimpse into the
months leading up to her murder. Proof she may never
have lived to use. But digital footprints. They don't die
so easy, and neither do secrets. Let's keep digging. You
know what sends my cop radar into full defcon mode
(24:13):
When a suspect is too calm, not frazzled, not unraveling, stone, cold, calculating.
That's not grief, my friends, that's orchestration. Welcome to act
for the false calm of brian laundry. We know Brian
returned home to Florida alone, silent, calm, calculated. But here's
(24:35):
where I want to introduce a critical psychological dynamic, the
organized offender profile. Organized offenders, often highly functional psychopaths, meticulously
plan both their crimes and their cover stories. They're not disheveled,
panicked rex They're composed. I want you to sit with
(24:55):
this for a second, because this is where most people,
even some of my fellow c get it dead wrong.
See when civilians think of a domestic homicide suspect, they
picture someone frantic, disheveled, falling apart, doing sloppy damage control.
That's true for a lot of impulsive offenders, crimes of passion, drunks,
(25:17):
meth heads, But Brian number Brian belonged to a much
scarier subset. The cool ones, the planners, the ones who've
rehearsed their behavior in their heads long before the violence
ever goes physical. In psychology, we'd categorize this as cognitive
(25:39):
rehearsal of dominance. Let me break that down for you.
He had mentally walked through this scenario over and over
and over. If it ever comes to it, here's how
I'll handle it. This is the difference between an escalation
and an execution. His outward calm wasn't grief, it wasn't shocked.
(26:00):
It was post event control. Let's get speculative. In this
rewired version, Brian didn't just snap. He prepped months before
they even left for Van Life. He was quietly assembling
what I would call a psychological exit strategy. He knows
(26:22):
the terrain, wilderness areas, isolated spaces, national parks with thousands
of acres of places to disappear. He's familiar with backcountry
trails and unregulated camping areas, the perfect staging ground for
accidents no one could witness. He likely plotted multiple routes
(26:43):
with low surveillance areas out of cell service, intentionally choosing
regions where law enforcement jurisdiction was sparse and fragmented, and
in our hypothetical rewired expansion, he had contingency plans, stashed
cash spread across several states, multiple supply packs buried near trailheads,
(27:07):
offline maps stored on encrypted drives, burner phones purchased in cash,
even lists of aliases or partial id kits ready for
worst case scenarios. Now, I know this sounds extreme, but
you'd be shocked how many offenders like this operate under
the radar. Because, let's call it like it is. They
(27:27):
look normal, they're clean cut, they say sir and ma'am.
They're polite to officers, they've never been arrested. The most
dangerous offenders often aren't the wild eyed monsters society imagines.
They're the ones you never suspect. And let's pull in
the sociological layer here, because it matters. We have a
(27:48):
cultural bias toward the nice guy narrative. Brian was marketed
as Gabby's high school sweetheart, outdoor enthusiast, survivalist artist. Even
after Gabby went missing, there were people online calling him
just a troubled young man. But that narrative protects men
like him because we still haven't evolved as a society
(28:10):
in how we understand manipulative, coercive personalities, especially in white,
middle class males who fit the safe profile. We are
wired to give them the benefit of the doubt. From
my police background, let me tell you how these personalities
read when you're interviewing them. Minimal facial affect, no excessive emotion,
(28:33):
calm speech patterns, highly regulated breathing. They give you just
enough detail to seem cooperative, but never more than you
asked for, Subtle linguistic distancing, things like she was upset
instead of we were arguing. That's not compliance, that's narrative control.
And let's not ignore who may have been assisting him,
(28:56):
because in this rewired version, the Laundry family weren't just
passive spectators. They were participants in his preparation. They had
generational enabling behavior. Don't worry, son, we'll handle it. If
something happens, you know where to go. In this version,
they helped him prep cash drops, taught him how to
(29:16):
stay off grid, provided financial cover, maybe even rehearsed how
to answer law enforcement if the worst happened. And if
you think that sounds too dramatic, let me remind you
they helped him lawyer up before Gabby was even reported missing.
That's not a panic response, that's an activation plan. The
(29:38):
hard truth Brian Laundry wasn't out of control. He was
very much in control. And that control that's what makes
these cases so haunting because, unlike the MOAB officers, unlike
the witnesses who saw the argument, unlike the friends who
thought it was just relationship drama, offenders like Brian are
(30:00):
playing a long game, and by the time most people
catch on, the victim is already gone. But his planning
didn't stop at logistics.
Speaker 2 (30:09):
Stay tuned for more of the guilty files. We'll be
right back after these messages.
Speaker 1 (30:18):
In Act five, we pull open the most disturbing piece
of all the burn after reading letter, and folks, if
you thought his parents were just grieving, buckle up. Survivalist skills,
control fantasies, tactical silence, Brian wasn't panicked. He was playing
chess while everyone else played checkers. But wait till you
(30:40):
see who might have been helping him set the board. Now,
let's get to the family business, because behind every manipulative killer,
sometimes there's a mama bear willing to burn more than bridges.
She's ready to burn the rule book too. Welcome to
Act five, the burn after reading letter. And now let's
(31:01):
talk about one of the most chilling and in my opinion,
most revealing artifacts recovered after Brian's death, the letter marked
burn after reading. And folks, let's just pause right here
for a second. You don't put burn after reading on
your grocery list. That's not love, you son, have a
(31:22):
great trip. Energy, that's contingency language. That's if everything goes
horribly wrong. Here's the playbook energy. And while the real
letter we know about was vague, cryptic, and heavily litigated,
in this rewired version we're peeling back the mask entirely.
But let's imagine what if that letter was far more
(31:42):
damning than the public ever saw in our rewired version.
It's not vague affection, it's an explicit playbook. This is
the kind of letter I believe could have existed behind
closed doors, Written in Roberta's shaky but obsessive handwriting late
at night as she rehearsed the darkest version of motherhood imaginable.
(32:08):
Here is the rewired version of the letter, My sweet Brian.
If you are reading this, then we are somewhere I
prayed we would never be. But I need you to remember,
no matter what happens, you are my son. You are
my blood. Nothing that has happened or will happen, can
(32:30):
ever change that. Life tests us in ways we cannot
always prepare for. But you have always been stronger than most.
You carry a burden others couldn't handle. Not everyone understands
what it's like to love someone so much that you
would do anything anything to protect them, even from themselves.
(32:55):
You always loved too deeply. You never could walk away,
could you? If what we feared has come to pass,
if Gabby forced your hand, if the situation spiraled, I
need you to stay calm. The world will never see
your heart the way I do. They'll paint you as
the villain, because that's easier than understanding. Remember what we discussed,
(33:19):
Disappear if you must. We've rehearsed this. Take only what
you need. Stay silent. The less they know, the less
they can twist. Do not trust anyone but family, strangers, friends,
even lawyers. They serve themselves. We serve you. The money
is where we agreed, use it. If you must survive first,
(33:42):
we will deal with the rest later. You do not
owe the world explanations. You only owe yourself peace. No
one understands the pressure you've carried all these years, how
much you sacrifice to keep everyone happy. People forget She
chose this life too, She knew how difficult things could be.
(34:04):
The road wore both of you down. Don't let them
pretend she was innocent in every fight. If the worst
happens and you are found, say nothing. Your father and
I have legal counsel ready. We will stand beside you,
no matter the headlines, no matter the lies they spin.
If you feel you cannot continue, if the world grows
(34:26):
too heavy, know that you are loved. You are never alone.
I will carry your pain as my own for the
rest of my life. Burn this love always. Mom that,
my friends, is not just a mother protecting her son.
That is intergenerational collusion, that is enabling taken to its
(34:48):
most extreme, twisted form. And make no mistake, if a
version of this letter existed, it would represent the clearest
evidence yet that Ryan's plan wasn't panic, it was preparation,
and it wasn't built alone. Think of what this says psychologically.
(35:09):
Roberta isn't just trying to help her son escape responsibility.
She's actively rewriting reality for him, gaslighting him into believing
that Gabby bore equal blame, that his violence was understandable,
that survival, not accountability, was the priority. This right here
(35:31):
is how family systems normalize dysfunction, shared narratives, collective denial,
external blame shifting, and let's be brutally honest. This type
of parental enmeshment. It doesn't create killers, but when a
child with narcissistic or antisocial tendencies grows up in it,
it creates someone who believes they'll be protected no matter
(35:55):
what they do. The burn after reading letter in this
rewired version, it wasn't an afterthought, It was part of
the plan all along. Let that sink in a burn
after reading letter. That's not Hallmark, folks, that's cover your ass.
One oh one, and you better believe we're only getting
started on how deep this family involvement might have run.
(36:19):
But as we'll see and Act six, even the most
carefully choreographed cover ups leave room for witnesses, and not
all of them came forward. Next up, the silent witness.
This is Act six because while millions of strangers became
Internet detectives, maybe someone out there heard everything firsthand and
(36:40):
chose to vanish into the trees. Now let's bring in
an entirely new player. A hiker alone quietly camping in
the remote areas of Grand Teton that night August twenty seventh,
they hear something screaming, a woman's voice pleading, then silence,
(37:05):
but fearing entanglement, fearing for their own safety, they pack
up and leave at sunrise. It's not until weeks later,
when national headlines explode that they connect the dots. This
speculative witness who stayed silent allows us to explore a
chilling sociological phenomenon called the bystander effect. Surely someone else
(37:32):
will call. Maybe it's not my place. I don't want
to get involved. That single unreported encounter may have delayed
Gabby's recovery and Brian's capture. And let me tell you,
I've seen it firsthand. The bystander effect isn't just some
fancy psych textbook concept. It's real and it costs lives.
(37:55):
You want an example, let me take you back to
a case from my time on the streets of Atlanta.
This one still haunts me. It was early spring, one
of those muggy Atlanta nights where the humidity sticks to
your skin before sunset. We got dispatched out to a
shooting call near an old apartment complex over in the
English Avenue neighborhood. Single gunshot, male victim, not much else
(38:18):
in the call notes. I arrive my unit back up,
already en route the scene. Nothing, no body, no shooter,
just a half empty parking lot and one busted, shattered
cell phone lying face down on the pavement near a
pool of blood that was already starting to darken under
the street light. We canvassed, knocked doors, ran license plates,
(38:43):
the usual dance. And here's where the frustration kicks in.
We had people, people standing in doorways, watching from windows,
hovering just outside the caution tape, whispering to one another.
They saw something. You could feel it, that weird nervous
energy you only get when people know more than they're saying.
(39:05):
But when we approached, shrugs silent. Did you see who
was involved? Now, Officer, I ain't seen nothing. You hear anything?
Gun went off? That's it. I didn't get involved. And
that's the thing, right, This wasn't out of malice. It
was fear, fear of retaliation, fear of getting pulled into
(39:26):
the system, fear that if they said something, they'd suddenly
be next. You know what that is. That's not apathy.
That's community trauma. Communities where calling nine to one one
isn't seen as safety, it's seen as danger. Communities where
police protection feels conditional but street justice feels permanent. Eventually,
(39:49):
after days of digging, we found our victim, shot once
in the chest, dumped in a drainage culvert about a
half mile away. No witnesses stepped forward, no usable footage
from the old broken surveillance cams, no suspect. Case unsolved.
And you know what sticks with me. There was someone
(40:11):
who saw it. There was someone who heard that shot,
saw the car, saw the shooter, saw the dump. There
always is. But nobody came forward. And the longer that
silence holds, the colder the case gets. And that, my friends,
is exactly what may have played out in Gabby's case,
even in our fictionalized, rewired version. Maybe someone saw Brian
(40:34):
dragging her body into the brush. Maybe they heard the
argument escalate before it all went quiet. Maybe a passing
hiker saw that white van parked where it didn't belong,
but kept moving, thinking someone else will call, because we
all like to believe we'd step up. But when the
moment hits, too many people default to self preservation. That's
(40:59):
the horror of the bystander effect. It doesn't take a
conspiracy to lose a life. Sometimes it just takes enough
people convincing themselves it's not my business. And in this
version of Gabby's story, that silence may have cost her
any remaining chance she had left. But Brian wasn't done
(41:21):
playing god with this narrative yet, because while people stayed silent,
one amateur detective wasn't. Next up. We meet the digital
sleuth who may have cracked it all open before anyone
even realized it. Let's be honest. Half of TikTok turned
into FBI agents during this case. But what if one
(41:43):
digital detective cracked the code before anyone else. Because sometimes
the best investigator isn't wearing a badge. They are rocking
ring lights. Welcome to Act seven, the digital sleuth. The
real investigation benefited from digital sleuths online, But what if
one TikTok influencer cracked far more than the van location
(42:07):
in our dramatization. This amateur cyber investigator, let's call her Lexi,
specializes in metadata extraction. She downloads Gabby's final Instagram post,
reverse engineers the photos, exif data notices, time stamp manipulations,
cross references satellite weather records showing cloud cover inconsistencies. Then
(42:31):
she scrapes archived cellular tower pings to triangulate the van's
true location that night. In this rewired version, Lexi beats
law enforcement to the scene by forty eight hours, a
chilling reminder that modern cases now play out on both
the ground and the cloud, often simultaneously.
Speaker 2 (42:53):
The tools have.
Speaker 1 (42:54):
Changed, the players have changed. The only thing that stays
the same obsession. But while the sleuths worked overtime, Brian
was busy playing with something even more dangerous. You want
modern horror picture. This Not only did Brian kill Gabby,
but he kept texting her family afterwards, using AI to
(43:18):
fake her voice. Welcome to the dystopia. Friends, this is
Act eight, the AI crafted alibi. Okay, folks, this is
where our rewired ride really swerves into the darker corners
of modern crime. Because in today's world, you don't need
to be a criminal mastermind to cover your tracks. All
(43:39):
you need is access to technology. See in this rewired version,
we imagine Brian as being far more digitally savvy than
the real life investigation ever uncovered. Remember, this was a
guy who lived in social media. He watched Gabby build
content studying game ag curate an image, and in that
(44:02):
process he learned exactly how easy it is to manipulate
digital footprints. Let's paint the scene after Gabby's death, and
yes we're assuming in this speculative version that it was
fully premeditated. Brian doesn't just run. He executes a carefully
rehearsed digital escape plan. First stop spoofed communications. Using widely
(44:29):
available AI text generators cheap subscription based tools you or
I could literally buy off the app store today, he
starts producing Gabby style messages, the language mimicked perfectly, the
emojis spot on, the tone, bright airy just like her
(44:51):
real texts AI trained on her previous social posts, is
now generating outgoing messages on her behalf.
Speaker 2 (45:00):
Stay tuned for more of the guilty files. We'll be
right back after these.
Speaker 1 (45:04):
Messages, Messages like hey mom, service still kind of spotty,
but loving grand Teton so far. Hoping to make it
to Yosemite next if the weather holds. Texts like these
begin buying him time, but he doesn't stop there next.
(45:25):
Synthetic voice cloning. Thanks to a few publicly available voice
replication programs, Brian uploads old Instagram live clips where Gabby's
voice can be isolated. The AI trains itself on her
speech patterns, her upward inflection, the breathy tone, the soft
(45:45):
pacing she used when recording vlogs. He generates short voicemail
drops or pre recorded snippets that could fool anyone listening
to her. Leave a check in on a loved one's phone,
Hey dad, we're having so much out here. Just wanted
to say I love you. Talk soon, and the Pista
Resistance GEO faked metadata with widely available XIF editors. He
(46:11):
alters the time stamps and GPS coordinates on newly staged photos,
creating the illusion that Gabby's phone has been active well
after her death, He posts a few delayed Instagram stories
filters carefully chosen exactly as Gabby would have done, using
scenic shots pulled from public domain stock libraries she herself
(46:35):
once referenced for inspiration. Now why is this so chilling?
Because for investigators like me this becomes a nightmare scenario.
The AI generated texts, they match her cadence, the voice files,
they pass a basic ear test the images. The metadata
says she's alive days or even weeks beyond her actual
(46:59):
time of death. From a law enforcement perspective, this gums
up your timeline entirely. Suddenly you're questioning your own initial theory.
Did Gabby vanish later than we thought? Did Brian leave earlier?
Are we even looking in the right jurisdiction? And here's
where Brian's understanding of procedural delay comes in. Every day
(47:23):
investigators spend reverifying data buys him time to disappear. The
goal isn't to fool everyone forever. The goal is to
slow us down long enough that by the time we
catch on, he's either vanished permanently or dead by his
own hand, leaving the case unfinished. In this rewired scenario,
(47:44):
he even attempts to reroute digital traffic, disabling phone pings,
masking IP addresses with cheap VPN services, logging in from
public Wi Fi hotspots to scramble jurisdictional authority, and folks,
I wish I was making that part up. But in
modern criminal investigations, we're already seeing this tech being weaponized
(48:07):
in active domestic violence and stalking cases today. Now let
me pause here and add a little law enforcement reality check.
Even if you have top tiered digital forensics teams, which
many smaller jurisdictions don't, parsing out manipulated AI content from
real data requires federal level resources, time, and a whole
(48:31):
lot of luck. And Brian was betting on one thing.
The system wouldn't move fast enough to outpace the fiction
he was building, the terrifying part in twenty twenty one,
this would have still been advanced. By twenty twenty five,
This kind of synthetic alibi construction almost mainstream. And that's
(48:51):
where I want to leave you for a moment, because
while we struggle to keep up offenders like this, they're
already rehearsing for crimes. Law enforcement hasn't even figured out
how to investigate yet. But no matter how advanced your
digital cover up may be, eventually you still have to
reconcile the why. And in Act nine, we finally open
(49:15):
Brian's infamous notebook, the last confession, or one last desperate
attempt to rewrite the story one final time in the
wrong hands. Technology isn't a tool, it's an accomplice, and
in this version, the deception was just getting started. Ah. Yes,
(49:36):
Brian's final mic drop the infamous water logged notebook. But
you know what smells worse than swamp water, A manipulator's
last ditch, self serving narrative. Welcome to Act nine, the
redacted confession. When Brian's skeletal remains are found, his water
logged notebook becomes headline news. But let's imagine the full
(50:00):
contents of that notebook were far darker than we ever
saw in our dramatization. Federal Labs recover heavily damaged entries
that suggest escalating obsession. She was pulling away. I couldn't
let her leave. If I couldn't have her, no one would.
I rehearsed this moment in my head for months. Even
(50:23):
if I confessed, no one would understand. They'd call it rage.
But it was control. These lines suggest not mercy but domination.
The psychology here, what Brian is doing here, and this
is textbook, is moral justification. He's reframing homicide into compassion.
(50:46):
He's not the aggressor, He's the tragic hero forced to
make an impossible decision. That Folks is called cognitive distortion,
and for narcissistic or antisocial personalities extremely common. But let's
be crystal clear, the evidence never supported his version of mercy.
(51:07):
Gabby was strangled, she suffered, There was no accident. What
Brian wrote wasn't a confession, it was a performance, And
even in death, he was still playing director of the story,
still trying to control how we and how her family
would remember him. The final gut punch his notebook wasn't
(51:28):
about Gabby. It was always about Brian. But here's the
brutal truth for anyone who tries to follow in his footsteps.
The evidence doesn't care about your script. And while Gabby's
voice was stolen, the forensics screamed louder. His final performance
(51:48):
a confession full of lies. The truth it rotted along
with him. But if you think that's where we stop,
not even close. And that my friend brings us to
our final act, the aftermath, where we confront not just
how this ended, but how we keep it from happening again.
(52:10):
And now the part that hits me in my gut,
because as much as this story is about Brian and Gabby,
it's really about us, about the systems that keep failing,
about the blind spots that kill. This is Act ten,
the systemic failure. And here's where I'll land the plane, folks.
(52:32):
In the real case, this was preventable. The Moab police
missed crucial intervention points. Gabby's isolation, geographical, financial, emotional followed
a textbook pattern seen in thousands of domestic violence homicides
every year. The sociology of it. Our systems still fail
(52:53):
to identify controlling non physical abuse early enough. The psychology
of it. Victims often remain loyal to their abusers, even
in extreme danger, because their self worth has been eroded
to nothing. The procedural reality. Law enforcement still lacks consistency
(53:14):
across jurisdictions when handling complex domestic violence calls, and as
technology evolves, the digital forensics landscape becomes increasingly sophisticated and
increasingly dangerous. The tragedy wasn't just the crime. It was
every missed exit ramp along the way. And that, my friends,
(53:36):
is why we rewire these cases, not to sensationalize them,
but to confront the uncomfortable what ifs hiding behind every headline.
Gabby Patito's death was real, it was senseless, it was tragic.
Today we walked a hypothetical path of what might have
been hidden beneath the headlines, not to rerid history, but
(54:01):
to expose where justice still struggles to reach. For every Gabby,
there are countless others, invisible, silenced, and often preventable. If
you're in danger, or you know someone who is, please
don't wait, call for help. We honor Gabby's real legacy
(54:21):
by confronting these hard truths. And that's another chapter closed
on The Guilty Files, True Crime Rewired. I hope Tonight's
fictionalized take on this week's case kept you intrigued, entertained,
and maybe even made you see things from a new perspective.
After all, true crime is never just black and white.
(54:42):
It's full of shades, possibilities, and what ifs. If you're
new here or missed it, be sure to listen to
Brian's episode The Guilty Files Uncovered where he broke down
the cold hard facts of this case with his signature
sharp analysis. It's the perfect compliment to tonight dramatization. Together,
these episodes show that at The Guilty Files we offer
(55:05):
true crime twice told, giving you the facts and the
fiction in a way that no other podcast does. And
be sure to stick around for Friday, when we come
tougher and co host The Guilty Files Revisited, typically where
all hell breaks loose. I want to take a moment
to thank you, yes, you for being the reason this
(55:29):
podcast exists. Your love of true crime fuels us to
dig deeper, explore further, and bring you stories that spark
your imagination. So if you're enjoying the show, don't keep
it to yourself, share it with a friend, leave a review,
or tag us on social media. Your engagement means the
(55:50):
world to us. We love hearing from you. Reach out
to me anytime via email Danny at Paranormalworldproductions dot com.
Of course, none of this would happen without Paranormal World
Productions Studio. They're the masterminds behind are polished sound and
seamless production, bringing the stories we tell to life. To
(56:13):
learn more about their work and what's coming next? Visit
www dot Paranormalworldproductions dot com. We'll be back next week
with another case, another chapter, and more true crime revisited
and reimagined. Thanks for listening to the Guilty Files. True
Crime rewired until next time, Stay suspicious, keep it guilty.
(56:35):
Just be sure to keep your alibis airtight and maybe
delete your browser history. The story's done, but the intrigue
never ends. See you next week for more guilt and glory.
I'm Danny signing off in it
Hello, true crime lovers, Welcome back to The Guilty Files
True Crime Rewired, the podcast where we take one crime,
two perspectives, and create endless intrigue. I'm Danny, your guide
for the second act of this case, where we take
the hard facts from earlier this week and twist them
into something unexpected, daring, and just a little wicked. Think
(00:30):
of me as your pilot through the tangled web of
true crime, with the side of sass and a dash
of drama to keep you hooked. At The Guilty Files
True Crime Rewritten. We believe every crime has two sides
to the story, and every listener deserves the thrill of both.
So sit back, lean in, and let's rewrite the narrative.
(00:52):
Because true crime isn't just meant to be solved, It's
meant to be explored. Let's get started. Welcome back, Guilty
Files fam and if you're joining us for the first time,
(01:14):
buckle up because today we're rewiring one of the most heartbreaking, complicated,
and widely publicized cases of the last decade, the murder
of Gabby Petito. My co host Brian recently walked you
through the factual case file in meticulous detail. As always,
(01:34):
Brian delivered that clean, sharp, professional lens you've come to
expect from the guilty files uncovered. But here on Rewired, well,
we pull a little differently on the thread. We take
those same facts and we explore the psychological layers, the
sociological systems, the procedural cracks, and yes, we take some
(01:58):
bold liberties with speculatives scenarios that might have unfolded, because
real cases don't live in a vacuum. People are messy,
systems fail, and sometimes truth hides between the lines. What
if there were pieces we never saw? What if we
could shine light on the maybe's that still haunt this case?
(02:22):
And before we go any further, let me make something
abundantly clear. While everything you're about to hear is rooted
in the real timeline, much of today's episode is somewhat hypothetical,
speculative dramatizations inspired by the original case. The facts stay facts,
(02:44):
but today we explore what could have been hiding beneath them.
Today's episode is divided into ten acts, each one peeling
back a layer of possible darkness that may have gone unnoticed.
So if you're ready, let's dive headfirst into one of
the most most tragic cautionary tales of the modern social
media era. Gabby Petito the Rewired File. All right, my
(03:08):
fellow rewired junkies, before we dive into the deep end
of the what ifs today, let's hit pause for a
hot second and lay out our playing field. Because listen,
my brilliant co host Brian already walked you through the
full case file over on the Guilty Files Uncovered and
you know Brian facts, receipts, timelines. Man comes locked and
(03:33):
loaded like a defense attorney with a laser pointer. But
I want to make sure we're all properly grounded before
I start rewiring this thing into the darker, messier places
our mind's love to wander. So here's your high speed
Gabby Potito refresher. Gabby Petito twenty two years old, Bright, vibrant, artistic,
(03:56):
deeply loved. She grew up in New York, had a big,
blended family, a gift for photography, and big dreams of travel,
influencer stardom. Basically the kind of young woman every parent
hopes their daughter grows into, independent, creative, alive. And then
there was Brian Laundry, the high school sweetheart who slowly
(04:16):
transitioned into the boyfriend, the fiance, and ultimately the killer.
The two of them hit the road in July of
twenty twenty one in that infamous converted van, chasing the
hashtag van life dream uploading curated Instagram posts that painted
the perfect digital postcard of young love on the open road.
(04:40):
But behind those beautiful photos, yeah, something far darker was brewing.
There were red flags. Controlling behaviors, emotional manipulation, isolation from
family and friends, the classic slowburn setup for what domestic
violence experts call CoA control. You don't always see the
(05:03):
bruises early on, but the damage is there. Their trip
unraveled in moab Utah when police responded to a domestic dispute.
A witness called nine to one one saying Brian was
hitting Gabby, But when cops arrived, the narrative flipped. Gabby
was crying, blaming herself, classic DV victim behavior, and Brian
(05:27):
played the calm, rational, oh she's just stressed card, and
despite the physical marks on both of them, no arrest
was made. Instead, the cops separated them for the night
and sent them on their way. And folks, let's just
say we'll be revisiting that little moment of systemic failure. Later,
(05:50):
fast forward, Gabby disappears, Brian returns home alone to Florida,
no explanation, no help in the search, just radio silence
while her family desperately pleads for answers. The nation watches
in horror, The Internet turns into full blown amateur CSI,
(06:12):
and finally Gabby's remains are discovered in Wyoming on September nineteenth,
twenty twenty one. She was strangled to death a homicide. Meanwhile,
Brian Poof vanishes into the Florida Wilderness. Massive manhunt, FBI
swarms the Carlton Reserve. Weeks go by, and then his
(06:34):
skeletal remains are found on October twentieth, cause of death suicide.
A water logged notebook near his body contained his so
called confession. And we're going to have some thoughts about
that little manipulative manifesto later too. So yeah, that's the
rough sketch of it. Tragic, preventable and chilling in every way.
(06:56):
But here at Rewired, we don't stop at the headlines.
We peel back the messy layers hiding beneath, because for
every hard fact in this case, there are a dozen
ways this nightmare could have played out differently, and we're
about to explore them. You ready for this ride? Good,
(07:16):
because from here on out we're stepping off the factual
trail and marching straight into the speculative woods. All right,
now that we've refreshed your memory and knocked the dust
off the facts, let's start where this whole tragedy might
have been stopped dead in its tracks. Moab Utah. The
flashing lights, the police cams rolling, the domestic call that
(07:40):
could have changed everything if anyone had actually done their
damn job. Welcome to Act one, the moment that could
have changed everything. We begin in moab Utah, August twelfth,
twenty twenty one. Red Rock cliffs glow under that late
summer sun. The air smells dry, that kind of desert
(08:03):
heat that bakes your skin like you're inside some ancient
biblical oven. Tourists buzz around town, renting jeeps, snapping selfies,
living out their Southwest Adventure fantasies. It's peaceful quiet, except
it wasn't, because somewhere on the side of that dusty
main road near Moonflower co Op, inside a cramped little
(08:27):
white Ford transit van, hell was simmering, and it wasn't
the temperature causing the boil. Brian Laundry and Gabby Patito
trapped together in what had become both their dream and
their cage van life Instagram fame endless, wide open roads,
but inside that van, barely eighty square feet of space,
(08:52):
shrinking tighter every single mile, And on this particular day,
that tension finally cracked wide open, not behind closed doors,
but in full view of a bystander who had the
courage to do what many don't. They picked up the
phone and called nine to one. Pint one. We drove by,
(09:14):
and the gentleman was slapping the girl. That call would
trigger one of the most crucial moments in this entire story,
because from here on out, this could have gone a
thousand different ways, and maybe one of those ways might
have saved Gabby's life. Now here's where I want you
(09:34):
to stay with me, because, as someone who's worn the badge,
I've been on these calls more times than I can count.
Domestic disputes they are messy, they are complicated, and they
are very often the place where officers screw it up
without even realizing it. The responding MOAB officers arrive, they
(09:54):
pull over the van. They see Gabby crying, shaking, visibly distressed.
Brian calm, collected, articulate, spinning his narrative before they even
unclip their seat belts. Classic power dynamics of domestic violence
playing out in real time. And here's the truth. A
(10:17):
lot of the public doesn't want to admit. We as
officers are trained far better to handle violent strangers than
we are intimate partners. This is where law enforcement protocol
so often fails victims like Gabby, because we are conditioned
to believe the louder person is the problem, the one
(10:39):
who cries, who can't regulate, who's emotionally spiraling, That's who
gets labeled unstable. Meanwhile, Brian, he's playing a much more
dangerous game. The cool, collected abuser, the controlled narrative, the
guy who knows the officer's own biases will probably work
in his favor. Now, let me fictionalize this for you
(11:02):
just a second, because we're in rewired territory. Now, picture
Officer Miller, my hypothetical junior officer on the scene that day.
Let's give him some dimension, fresh out of domestic violence training,
eager to apply what he's learned. He's standing there, sweating
under that unforgiving desert sun, watching Gabby wipe tears from
(11:25):
her face over and over again. He's reading her body language,
the constant fidgeting, the way her voice trembles every time
she apologizes for being mean or having OCD, for getting frustrated.
Miller's alarm bells are going off because every victim advocate
(11:46):
class he just sat through told him this is textbook
trauma response, hyper accountability, deflection of blame, minimizing her own
victimhood to protect her abuser. But then there's his supervisor,
Officer Pratt. Let's call him that. Since we're leaning into
both fact and fiction. Pratt's old school been in Moab
(12:10):
a long time. He sees a stressed out couple having
a bad road trip. He's already made up his mind.
Miller wants to push boss. Should we maybe separate them longer,
call in a victim services unit, interview them fully apart.
We've got probable cause, but Pratt shuts him down with
the voice every rookie cop hears sooner or later. Relax, Miller,
(12:34):
they're just kid. Last thing we need is paperwork. If
they're both saying it was nothing, and just like that,
policy gets sidestepped. Not because anyone intended to harm Gabby,
but because domestic violence rarely screams its full name in
broad daylight. It whispers, it gaslights, it wears many masks.
(12:56):
You see, Folks, this is where my law enforcement frustration
hits its peak, because I've seen firsthand how easy it
is for bad decisions to hide behind good intentions. And
let's be blunt. Mandatory arrest laws exist for a reason.
Utah statute required an arrest if probable cause of assault existed.
(13:18):
The nine to one one caller literally said Brian was
slapping Gabby. There were visible injuries on both parties. That's enough,
but guess what they chose not to invoke it. Instead,
they did what cops sometimes do when leadership gets lazy.
They opted for conflict avoidance disguised as de escalation. Brian
(13:40):
got a motel room for the night. Gabby got the van.
No arrest, no report to victim services, no criminal charge
that might have legally separated them. One officer trusted his gut,
the other trusted his comfort zone. And Folks, that fork
in the road right there, that's where this entire story
(14:01):
might have twisted in an entirely different direction. Because here's
the sociological truth you don't hear enough. Most domestic homicides
occur after multiple misted intervention points, not one. Multiple. The
signs stack like bricks. This was one of Gabby's last one.
(14:21):
The missed opportunity in Moab wasn't simply a bad call.
It was a systemic failure, rooted in decades of law
enforcement training, gaps, cultural blind spots, and procedural cowardice, a
failure that played out exactly the way victim's fear at
will they won't believe me. And with that the van
(14:42):
rolled forward, so did the story. One decision, one non arrest,
and now we're barreling straight toward tragedy. But trust me, friends,
that was just the first missed exit ramp, because in
our next act we explore the call that almost broke through.
Now imagine this, what if Gabby tried one last desperate
(15:05):
lifeline before everything spiraled.
Speaker 2 (15:08):
Stay tuned for more of the guilty files. We'll be
right back after these messages.
Speaker 1 (15:17):
Because sometimes help is only one dropped call away. Literally,
welcome to act too. The call that almost broke through.
Now let's pull it another thread in the official case,
we know Gabby reached out to her parents regularly, but
what if there was one call no one knew about,
a fictionalized phone call that never got answered. In our
(15:41):
speculative rewired version, Gabby, isolated, emotionally shredded and running out
of options, picks up that phone in the middle of
some remote Wyoming motel parking lot. It's late, she's anxious.
Brian's out pacing somewhere, cooling off after one of his
signature blow up. The weight of weeks of conflict, control
(16:04):
and emotional exhaustion presses on her like a second skin.
She dials the National Domestic Violence hotline. It connects, but
the cell service out here is brutal, sparse towers, sketchy coverage.
She barely gets out her name, maybe stumbles over some
kind of whispered explanation, I need help my boyfriend the
(16:30):
van and then dead air signal drops. The call disconnects
before the operator can verify her location or even log
the full incident. And that's the thing about abuse victims
on the edge of crisis. Their windows to ask for
help aren't wide. They're slivers, split second moments of courage
(16:53):
that often slams shut as quickly as they open, even
though the hotline might have triggered an emergency welfare check,
even though they might have pinged the call and cross
referenced it with her existing missing person file. In this version,
the call simply evaporates into static and that tiny sliver
of opportunity gone. That's how fragile these escape attempts often are.
(17:18):
Now here's where I want to dig deeper with you
for a second, because this isn't just about one phone call.
This is about trauma bonding. And if you don't understand
trauma bonding, you'll never fully understand why Gabby couldn't simply
pack her bag and walk. So let me put my
sociology hat on for a moment. Trauma bonding is what
(17:41):
happens when cycles of abuse create deeply distorted attachments between
victim and abuser. It's not just psychological, it's chemical. The
brain literally wires itself around the abuse cycle fear relief,
fear relief, and the longer it goes on, the stronger
(18:04):
that bond feels. You get those bursts of kindness after
every blow up, the I'm sorry, baby, I didn't mean it,
honeymoon phase, that floods your brain with dopamine, temporarily easing
the fear. It creates a vicious dependency, not unlike addiction.
You're terrified of them, but you're more terrified of losing them.
(18:28):
That's why so many victims stay. That's why so many
calls for help get choked out by shame, guilt, or
loyalty right before the words leave their mouth. I saw
this exact dynamic play out more times than I care
to count when I was policing in Atlanta. Let me
tell you about one call that's never left me. I
(18:49):
got dispatched to a domestic over on the west side
of my beat, a rough little apartment complex just off Bankhead.
I'm the first unit on scene. The caller said it
sounded violent, multiple screaming, matches, glass breaking, not your garden
variety argument. As I knock, I can already hear the
muffled sobbing behind the door. Finally she opens up, and
(19:13):
immediately the scene hits me like a punch. Blood everywhere.
This man had shoved her into a cheap wooden wine rack.
Glass bottles shattered on impact, slicing her up like she'd
been dropped into barbed wire. Arms, face, legs, deep lacerations,
(19:34):
still bleeding, blood soaking her tank top. She's barefoot, shaking,
barely able to keep her footing, and yet she's got
one hand clutching his arm like he's the victim. Dispatch.
A signed backup arrives shortly after I do. As we
step inside, this guy, cool as ever, steps forward like
(19:57):
he's about to give me a customer service plant. Calm voice,
fake concern officer. It's not what it looks like. She slipped.
I was helping her up in her She starts parrotting it.
It's my fault. I shouldn't have been yelling I slipped.
I wasn't watching where I was going. That right there,
(20:18):
that is trauma bonding unfolding in front of your eyes.
My backup partner leans in, whispers she ain't gonna press charges.
Let's just document it and roll, and I'll be honest.
I was pissed because this is exactly how people die.
I looked that guy straight in the eye, looked back
(20:38):
at her, and I made the call charges custody. I
hooked him right there, read him his rights, and we
took him in. Bleeding, glass covered hands and all. She
was transported for medical but at least she was alive
and away from him, or at least one damn night.
That's the dark power of trauma bonding. You're trapped, not physically, psychologically,
(21:05):
you start believing you're the problem. You blame yourself for
your partner's violence, and by the time anyone realizes how
dangerous it's gotten, you're either missing or dead. And Gabby,
she was caught square in that web. Every tear filled
apology on that Moab body cam, every I was being
(21:28):
mean statement, classic signs. That hotline call she might have made.
That was her moment trying to fight against the trauma bond,
and like so many others, the opportunity slipped right through
her fingers. Now, if you're starting to feel your gut
twist a little good, that's the point of Rewired, because
(21:52):
this isn't just a Gabby story. This is a systemic
pattern that plays out across millions of relationships we never
hear about, and when it happens behind closed doors, the
outcome too often looks exactly like this case file. But
as fragile as that hotline moment was, it wasn't the
last chance because in Act three, we climb inside that van,
(22:18):
and we'll explore the secret recording. Gabby may have left
behind one missed hotline call, one lost signal, and just
like that, another invisible fork in the road will never
fully map. But trust me, the maybes only get darker
from here. All right, let's crawl inside that little van
for a second. And I'm not talking about Instagram's highlight reel.
(22:41):
I'm talking about what Gabby may have really captured behind
closed doors, if she had the foresight that so many
victims wish they had. Now, let's take things inside that tiny,
converted van. We know social media was a huge part
of Gabby's life. She documented everything, So what if she
she also recorded things we never saw. Imagine Gabby, desperate, isolated,
(23:05):
beginning to sense the true danger, secretly setting up a
phone or GoPro inside the van. Over days, perhaps weeks,
it captures footage of escalating fights, verbal abuse turning physical,
Brian screaming, threatening, controlling. This black box of domestic abuse
(23:28):
becomes Gabby's invisible cry for help, one she may have
intended to turn over to authorities once they got home.
The psychology here is gut wrenching. Many victims think, if
I can just get proof people will believe me that
hidden SD card. In our fictionalized version, it later becomes
(23:50):
a key piece of posthumous evidence discovered by digital forensics
after Brian's phone is confiscated, a haunting glimpse into the
months leading up to her murder. Proof she may never
have lived to use. But digital footprints. They don't die
so easy, and neither do secrets. Let's keep digging. You
know what sends my cop radar into full defcon mode
(24:13):
When a suspect is too calm, not frazzled, not unraveling, stone, cold, calculating.
That's not grief, my friends, that's orchestration. Welcome to act
for the false calm of brian laundry. We know Brian
returned home to Florida alone, silent, calm, calculated. But here's
(24:35):
where I want to introduce a critical psychological dynamic, the
organized offender profile. Organized offenders, often highly functional psychopaths, meticulously
plan both their crimes and their cover stories. They're not disheveled,
panicked rex They're composed. I want you to sit with
(24:55):
this for a second, because this is where most people,
even some of my fellow c get it dead wrong.
See when civilians think of a domestic homicide suspect, they
picture someone frantic, disheveled, falling apart, doing sloppy damage control.
That's true for a lot of impulsive offenders, crimes of passion, drunks,
(25:17):
meth heads, But Brian number Brian belonged to a much
scarier subset. The cool ones, the planners, the ones who've
rehearsed their behavior in their heads long before the violence
ever goes physical. In psychology, we'd categorize this as cognitive
(25:39):
rehearsal of dominance. Let me break that down for you.
He had mentally walked through this scenario over and over
and over. If it ever comes to it, here's how
I'll handle it. This is the difference between an escalation
and an execution. His outward calm wasn't grief, it wasn't shocked.
(26:00):
It was post event control. Let's get speculative. In this
rewired version, Brian didn't just snap. He prepped months before
they even left for Van Life. He was quietly assembling
what I would call a psychological exit strategy. He knows
(26:22):
the terrain, wilderness areas, isolated spaces, national parks with thousands
of acres of places to disappear. He's familiar with backcountry
trails and unregulated camping areas, the perfect staging ground for
accidents no one could witness. He likely plotted multiple routes
(26:43):
with low surveillance areas out of cell service, intentionally choosing
regions where law enforcement jurisdiction was sparse and fragmented, and
in our hypothetical rewired expansion, he had contingency plans, stashed
cash spread across several states, multiple supply packs buried near trailheads,
(27:07):
offline maps stored on encrypted drives, burner phones purchased in cash,
even lists of aliases or partial id kits ready for
worst case scenarios. Now, I know this sounds extreme, but
you'd be shocked how many offenders like this operate under
the radar. Because, let's call it like it is. They
(27:27):
look normal, they're clean cut, they say sir and ma'am.
They're polite to officers, they've never been arrested. The most
dangerous offenders often aren't the wild eyed monsters society imagines.
They're the ones you never suspect. And let's pull in
the sociological layer here, because it matters. We have a
(27:48):
cultural bias toward the nice guy narrative. Brian was marketed
as Gabby's high school sweetheart, outdoor enthusiast, survivalist artist. Even
after Gabby went missing, there were people online calling him
just a troubled young man. But that narrative protects men
like him because we still haven't evolved as a society
(28:10):
in how we understand manipulative, coercive personalities, especially in white,
middle class males who fit the safe profile. We are
wired to give them the benefit of the doubt. From
my police background, let me tell you how these personalities
read when you're interviewing them. Minimal facial affect, no excessive emotion,
(28:33):
calm speech patterns, highly regulated breathing. They give you just
enough detail to seem cooperative, but never more than you
asked for, Subtle linguistic distancing, things like she was upset
instead of we were arguing. That's not compliance, that's narrative control.
And let's not ignore who may have been assisting him,
(28:56):
because in this rewired version, the Laundry family weren't just
passive spectators. They were participants in his preparation. They had
generational enabling behavior. Don't worry, son, we'll handle it. If
something happens, you know where to go. In this version,
they helped him prep cash drops, taught him how to
(29:16):
stay off grid, provided financial cover, maybe even rehearsed how
to answer law enforcement if the worst happened. And if
you think that sounds too dramatic, let me remind you
they helped him lawyer up before Gabby was even reported missing.
That's not a panic response, that's an activation plan. The
(29:38):
hard truth Brian Laundry wasn't out of control. He was
very much in control. And that control that's what makes
these cases so haunting because, unlike the MOAB officers, unlike
the witnesses who saw the argument, unlike the friends who
thought it was just relationship drama, offenders like Brian are
(30:00):
playing a long game, and by the time most people
catch on, the victim is already gone. But his planning
didn't stop at logistics.
Speaker 2 (30:09):
Stay tuned for more of the guilty files. We'll be
right back after these messages.
Speaker 1 (30:18):
In Act five, we pull open the most disturbing piece
of all the burn after reading letter, and folks, if
you thought his parents were just grieving, buckle up. Survivalist skills,
control fantasies, tactical silence, Brian wasn't panicked. He was playing
chess while everyone else played checkers. But wait till you
(30:40):
see who might have been helping him set the board. Now,
let's get to the family business, because behind every manipulative killer,
sometimes there's a mama bear willing to burn more than bridges.
She's ready to burn the rule book too. Welcome to
Act five, the burn after reading letter. And now let's
(31:01):
talk about one of the most chilling and in my opinion,
most revealing artifacts recovered after Brian's death, the letter marked
burn after reading. And folks, let's just pause right here
for a second. You don't put burn after reading on
your grocery list. That's not love, you son, have a
(31:22):
great trip. Energy, that's contingency language. That's if everything goes
horribly wrong. Here's the playbook energy. And while the real
letter we know about was vague, cryptic, and heavily litigated,
in this rewired version we're peeling back the mask entirely.
But let's imagine what if that letter was far more
(31:42):
damning than the public ever saw in our rewired version.
It's not vague affection, it's an explicit playbook. This is
the kind of letter I believe could have existed behind
closed doors, Written in Roberta's shaky but obsessive handwriting late
at night as she rehearsed the darkest version of motherhood imaginable.
(32:08):
Here is the rewired version of the letter, My sweet Brian.
If you are reading this, then we are somewhere I
prayed we would never be. But I need you to remember,
no matter what happens, you are my son. You are
my blood. Nothing that has happened or will happen, can
(32:30):
ever change that. Life tests us in ways we cannot
always prepare for. But you have always been stronger than most.
You carry a burden others couldn't handle. Not everyone understands
what it's like to love someone so much that you
would do anything anything to protect them, even from themselves.
(32:55):
You always loved too deeply. You never could walk away,
could you? If what we feared has come to pass,
if Gabby forced your hand, if the situation spiraled, I
need you to stay calm. The world will never see
your heart the way I do. They'll paint you as
the villain, because that's easier than understanding. Remember what we discussed,
(33:19):
Disappear if you must. We've rehearsed this. Take only what
you need. Stay silent. The less they know, the less
they can twist. Do not trust anyone but family, strangers, friends,
even lawyers. They serve themselves. We serve you. The money
is where we agreed, use it. If you must survive first,
(33:42):
we will deal with the rest later. You do not
owe the world explanations. You only owe yourself peace. No
one understands the pressure you've carried all these years, how
much you sacrifice to keep everyone happy. People forget She
chose this life too, She knew how difficult things could be.
(34:04):
The road wore both of you down. Don't let them
pretend she was innocent in every fight. If the worst
happens and you are found, say nothing. Your father and
I have legal counsel ready. We will stand beside you,
no matter the headlines, no matter the lies they spin.
If you feel you cannot continue, if the world grows
(34:26):
too heavy, know that you are loved. You are never alone.
I will carry your pain as my own for the
rest of my life. Burn this love always. Mom that,
my friends, is not just a mother protecting her son.
That is intergenerational collusion, that is enabling taken to its
(34:48):
most extreme, twisted form. And make no mistake, if a
version of this letter existed, it would represent the clearest
evidence yet that Ryan's plan wasn't panic, it was preparation,
and it wasn't built alone. Think of what this says psychologically.
(35:09):
Roberta isn't just trying to help her son escape responsibility.
She's actively rewriting reality for him, gaslighting him into believing
that Gabby bore equal blame, that his violence was understandable,
that survival, not accountability, was the priority. This right here
(35:31):
is how family systems normalize dysfunction, shared narratives, collective denial,
external blame shifting, and let's be brutally honest. This type
of parental enmeshment. It doesn't create killers, but when a
child with narcissistic or antisocial tendencies grows up in it,
it creates someone who believes they'll be protected no matter
(35:55):
what they do. The burn after reading letter in this
rewired version, it wasn't an afterthought, It was part of
the plan all along. Let that sink in a burn
after reading letter. That's not Hallmark, folks, that's cover your ass.
One oh one, and you better believe we're only getting
started on how deep this family involvement might have run.
(36:19):
But as we'll see and Act six, even the most
carefully choreographed cover ups leave room for witnesses, and not
all of them came forward. Next up, the silent witness.
This is Act six because while millions of strangers became
Internet detectives, maybe someone out there heard everything firsthand and
(36:40):
chose to vanish into the trees. Now let's bring in
an entirely new player. A hiker alone quietly camping in
the remote areas of Grand Teton that night August twenty seventh,
they hear something screaming, a woman's voice pleading, then silence,
(37:05):
but fearing entanglement, fearing for their own safety, they pack
up and leave at sunrise. It's not until weeks later,
when national headlines explode that they connect the dots. This
speculative witness who stayed silent allows us to explore a
chilling sociological phenomenon called the bystander effect. Surely someone else
(37:32):
will call. Maybe it's not my place. I don't want
to get involved. That single unreported encounter may have delayed
Gabby's recovery and Brian's capture. And let me tell you,
I've seen it firsthand. The bystander effect isn't just some
fancy psych textbook concept. It's real and it costs lives.
(37:55):
You want an example, let me take you back to
a case from my time on the streets of Atlanta.
This one still haunts me. It was early spring, one
of those muggy Atlanta nights where the humidity sticks to
your skin before sunset. We got dispatched out to a
shooting call near an old apartment complex over in the
English Avenue neighborhood. Single gunshot, male victim, not much else
(38:18):
in the call notes. I arrive my unit back up,
already en route the scene. Nothing, no body, no shooter,
just a half empty parking lot and one busted, shattered
cell phone lying face down on the pavement near a
pool of blood that was already starting to darken under
the street light. We canvassed, knocked doors, ran license plates,
(38:43):
the usual dance. And here's where the frustration kicks in.
We had people, people standing in doorways, watching from windows,
hovering just outside the caution tape, whispering to one another.
They saw something. You could feel it, that weird nervous
energy you only get when people know more than they're saying.
(39:05):
But when we approached, shrugs silent. Did you see who
was involved? Now, Officer, I ain't seen nothing. You hear anything?
Gun went off? That's it. I didn't get involved. And
that's the thing, right, This wasn't out of malice. It
was fear, fear of retaliation, fear of getting pulled into
(39:26):
the system, fear that if they said something, they'd suddenly
be next. You know what that is. That's not apathy.
That's community trauma. Communities where calling nine to one one
isn't seen as safety, it's seen as danger. Communities where
police protection feels conditional but street justice feels permanent. Eventually,
(39:49):
after days of digging, we found our victim, shot once
in the chest, dumped in a drainage culvert about a
half mile away. No witnesses stepped forward, no usable footage
from the old broken surveillance cams, no suspect. Case unsolved.
And you know what sticks with me. There was someone
(40:11):
who saw it. There was someone who heard that shot,
saw the car, saw the shooter, saw the dump. There
always is. But nobody came forward. And the longer that
silence holds, the colder the case gets. And that, my friends,
is exactly what may have played out in Gabby's case,
even in our fictionalized, rewired version. Maybe someone saw Brian
(40:34):
dragging her body into the brush. Maybe they heard the
argument escalate before it all went quiet. Maybe a passing
hiker saw that white van parked where it didn't belong,
but kept moving, thinking someone else will call, because we
all like to believe we'd step up. But when the
moment hits, too many people default to self preservation. That's
(40:59):
the horror of the bystander effect. It doesn't take a
conspiracy to lose a life. Sometimes it just takes enough
people convincing themselves it's not my business. And in this
version of Gabby's story, that silence may have cost her
any remaining chance she had left. But Brian wasn't done
(41:21):
playing god with this narrative yet, because while people stayed silent,
one amateur detective wasn't. Next up. We meet the digital
sleuth who may have cracked it all open before anyone
even realized it. Let's be honest. Half of TikTok turned
into FBI agents during this case. But what if one
(41:43):
digital detective cracked the code before anyone else. Because sometimes
the best investigator isn't wearing a badge. They are rocking
ring lights. Welcome to Act seven, the digital sleuth. The
real investigation benefited from digital sleuths online, But what if
one TikTok influencer cracked far more than the van location
(42:07):
in our dramatization. This amateur cyber investigator, let's call her Lexi,
specializes in metadata extraction. She downloads Gabby's final Instagram post,
reverse engineers the photos, exif data notices, time stamp manipulations,
cross references satellite weather records showing cloud cover inconsistencies. Then
(42:31):
she scrapes archived cellular tower pings to triangulate the van's
true location that night. In this rewired version, Lexi beats
law enforcement to the scene by forty eight hours, a
chilling reminder that modern cases now play out on both
the ground and the cloud, often simultaneously.
Speaker 2 (42:53):
The tools have.
Speaker 1 (42:54):
Changed, the players have changed. The only thing that stays
the same obsession. But while the sleuths worked overtime, Brian
was busy playing with something even more dangerous. You want
modern horror picture. This Not only did Brian kill Gabby,
but he kept texting her family afterwards, using AI to
(43:18):
fake her voice. Welcome to the dystopia. Friends, this is
Act eight, the AI crafted alibi. Okay, folks, this is
where our rewired ride really swerves into the darker corners
of modern crime. Because in today's world, you don't need
to be a criminal mastermind to cover your tracks. All
(43:39):
you need is access to technology. See in this rewired version,
we imagine Brian as being far more digitally savvy than
the real life investigation ever uncovered. Remember, this was a
guy who lived in social media. He watched Gabby build
content studying game ag curate an image, and in that
(44:02):
process he learned exactly how easy it is to manipulate
digital footprints. Let's paint the scene after Gabby's death, and
yes we're assuming in this speculative version that it was
fully premeditated. Brian doesn't just run. He executes a carefully
rehearsed digital escape plan. First stop spoofed communications. Using widely
(44:29):
available AI text generators cheap subscription based tools you or
I could literally buy off the app store today, he
starts producing Gabby style messages, the language mimicked perfectly, the
emojis spot on, the tone, bright airy just like her
(44:51):
real texts AI trained on her previous social posts, is
now generating outgoing messages on her behalf.
Speaker 2 (45:00):
Stay tuned for more of the guilty files. We'll be
right back after these.
Speaker 1 (45:04):
Messages, Messages like hey mom, service still kind of spotty,
but loving grand Teton so far. Hoping to make it
to Yosemite next if the weather holds. Texts like these
begin buying him time, but he doesn't stop there next.
(45:25):
Synthetic voice cloning. Thanks to a few publicly available voice
replication programs, Brian uploads old Instagram live clips where Gabby's
voice can be isolated. The AI trains itself on her
speech patterns, her upward inflection, the breathy tone, the soft
(45:45):
pacing she used when recording vlogs. He generates short voicemail
drops or pre recorded snippets that could fool anyone listening
to her. Leave a check in on a loved one's phone,
Hey dad, we're having so much out here. Just wanted
to say I love you. Talk soon, and the Pista
Resistance GEO faked metadata with widely available XIF editors. He
(46:11):
alters the time stamps and GPS coordinates on newly staged photos,
creating the illusion that Gabby's phone has been active well
after her death, He posts a few delayed Instagram stories
filters carefully chosen exactly as Gabby would have done, using
scenic shots pulled from public domain stock libraries she herself
(46:35):
once referenced for inspiration. Now why is this so chilling?
Because for investigators like me this becomes a nightmare scenario.
The AI generated texts, they match her cadence, the voice files,
they pass a basic ear test the images. The metadata
says she's alive days or even weeks beyond her actual
(46:59):
time of death. From a law enforcement perspective, this gums
up your timeline entirely. Suddenly you're questioning your own initial theory.
Did Gabby vanish later than we thought? Did Brian leave earlier?
Are we even looking in the right jurisdiction? And here's
where Brian's understanding of procedural delay comes in. Every day
(47:23):
investigators spend reverifying data buys him time to disappear. The
goal isn't to fool everyone forever. The goal is to
slow us down long enough that by the time we
catch on, he's either vanished permanently or dead by his
own hand, leaving the case unfinished. In this rewired scenario,
(47:44):
he even attempts to reroute digital traffic, disabling phone pings,
masking IP addresses with cheap VPN services, logging in from
public Wi Fi hotspots to scramble jurisdictional authority, and folks,
I wish I was making that part up. But in
modern criminal investigations, we're already seeing this tech being weaponized
(48:07):
in active domestic violence and stalking cases today. Now let
me pause here and add a little law enforcement reality check.
Even if you have top tiered digital forensics teams, which
many smaller jurisdictions don't, parsing out manipulated AI content from
real data requires federal level resources, time, and a whole
(48:31):
lot of luck. And Brian was betting on one thing.
The system wouldn't move fast enough to outpace the fiction
he was building, the terrifying part in twenty twenty one,
this would have still been advanced. By twenty twenty five,
This kind of synthetic alibi construction almost mainstream. And that's
(48:51):
where I want to leave you for a moment, because
while we struggle to keep up offenders like this, they're
already rehearsing for crimes. Law enforcement hasn't even figured out
how to investigate yet. But no matter how advanced your
digital cover up may be, eventually you still have to
reconcile the why. And in Act nine, we finally open
(49:15):
Brian's infamous notebook, the last confession, or one last desperate
attempt to rewrite the story one final time in the
wrong hands. Technology isn't a tool, it's an accomplice, and
in this version, the deception was just getting started. Ah. Yes,
(49:36):
Brian's final mic drop the infamous water logged notebook. But
you know what smells worse than swamp water, A manipulator's
last ditch, self serving narrative. Welcome to Act nine, the
redacted confession. When Brian's skeletal remains are found, his water
logged notebook becomes headline news. But let's imagine the full
(50:00):
contents of that notebook were far darker than we ever
saw in our dramatization. Federal Labs recover heavily damaged entries
that suggest escalating obsession. She was pulling away. I couldn't
let her leave. If I couldn't have her, no one would.
I rehearsed this moment in my head for months. Even
(50:23):
if I confessed, no one would understand. They'd call it rage.
But it was control. These lines suggest not mercy but domination.
The psychology here, what Brian is doing here, and this
is textbook, is moral justification. He's reframing homicide into compassion.
(50:46):
He's not the aggressor, He's the tragic hero forced to
make an impossible decision. That Folks is called cognitive distortion,
and for narcissistic or antisocial personalities extremely common. But let's
be crystal clear, the evidence never supported his version of mercy.
(51:07):
Gabby was strangled, she suffered, There was no accident. What
Brian wrote wasn't a confession, it was a performance, And
even in death, he was still playing director of the story,
still trying to control how we and how her family
would remember him. The final gut punch his notebook wasn't
(51:28):
about Gabby. It was always about Brian. But here's the
brutal truth for anyone who tries to follow in his footsteps.
The evidence doesn't care about your script. And while Gabby's
voice was stolen, the forensics screamed louder. His final performance
(51:48):
a confession full of lies. The truth it rotted along
with him. But if you think that's where we stop,
not even close. And that my friend brings us to
our final act, the aftermath, where we confront not just
how this ended, but how we keep it from happening again.
(52:10):
And now the part that hits me in my gut,
because as much as this story is about Brian and Gabby,
it's really about us, about the systems that keep failing,
about the blind spots that kill. This is Act ten,
the systemic failure. And here's where I'll land the plane, folks.
(52:32):
In the real case, this was preventable. The Moab police
missed crucial intervention points. Gabby's isolation, geographical, financial, emotional followed
a textbook pattern seen in thousands of domestic violence homicides
every year. The sociology of it. Our systems still fail
(52:53):
to identify controlling non physical abuse early enough. The psychology
of it. Victims often remain loyal to their abusers, even
in extreme danger, because their self worth has been eroded
to nothing. The procedural reality. Law enforcement still lacks consistency
(53:14):
across jurisdictions when handling complex domestic violence calls, and as
technology evolves, the digital forensics landscape becomes increasingly sophisticated and
increasingly dangerous. The tragedy wasn't just the crime. It was
every missed exit ramp along the way. And that, my friends,
(53:36):
is why we rewire these cases, not to sensationalize them,
but to confront the uncomfortable what ifs hiding behind every headline.
Gabby Patito's death was real, it was senseless, it was tragic.
Today we walked a hypothetical path of what might have
been hidden beneath the headlines, not to rerid history, but
(54:01):
to expose where justice still struggles to reach. For every Gabby,
there are countless others, invisible, silenced, and often preventable. If
you're in danger, or you know someone who is, please
don't wait, call for help. We honor Gabby's real legacy
(54:21):
by confronting these hard truths. And that's another chapter closed
on The Guilty Files, True Crime Rewired. I hope Tonight's
fictionalized take on this week's case kept you intrigued, entertained,
and maybe even made you see things from a new perspective.
After all, true crime is never just black and white.
(54:42):
It's full of shades, possibilities, and what ifs. If you're
new here or missed it, be sure to listen to
Brian's episode The Guilty Files Uncovered where he broke down
the cold hard facts of this case with his signature
sharp analysis. It's the perfect compliment to tonight dramatization. Together,
these episodes show that at The Guilty Files we offer
(55:05):
true crime twice told, giving you the facts and the
fiction in a way that no other podcast does. And
be sure to stick around for Friday, when we come
tougher and co host The Guilty Files Revisited, typically where
all hell breaks loose. I want to take a moment
to thank you, yes, you for being the reason this
(55:29):
podcast exists. Your love of true crime fuels us to
dig deeper, explore further, and bring you stories that spark
your imagination. So if you're enjoying the show, don't keep
it to yourself, share it with a friend, leave a review,
or tag us on social media. Your engagement means the
(55:50):
world to us. We love hearing from you. Reach out
to me anytime via email Danny at Paranormalworldproductions dot com.
Of course, none of this would happen without Paranormal World
Productions Studio. They're the masterminds behind are polished sound and
seamless production, bringing the stories we tell to life. To
(56:13):
learn more about their work and what's coming next? Visit
www dot Paranormalworldproductions dot com. We'll be back next week
with another case, another chapter, and more true crime revisited
and reimagined. Thanks for listening to the Guilty Files. True
Crime rewired until next time, Stay suspicious, keep it guilty.
(56:35):
Just be sure to keep your alibis airtight and maybe
delete your browser history. The story's done, but the intrigue
never ends. See you next week for more guilt and glory.
I'm Danny signing off in it
Popular Podcasts
Stuff You Should Know
If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.
Dateline NBC
Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Follow now to get the latest episodes of Dateline NBC completely free, or subscribe to Dateline Premium for ad-free listening and exclusive bonus content: DatelinePremium.com
New Heights with Jason & Travis Kelce
Football’s funniest family duo — Jason Kelce of the Philadelphia Eagles and Travis Kelce of the Kansas City Chiefs — team up to provide next-level access to life in the league as it unfolds. The two brothers and Super Bowl champions drop weekly insights about the weekly slate of games and share their INSIDE perspectives on trending NFL news and sports headlines. They also endlessly rag on each other as brothers do, chat the latest in pop culture and welcome some very popular and well-known friends to chat with them. Check out new episodes every Wednesday. Follow New Heights on the Wondery App, YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts. You can listen to new episodes early and ad-free, and get exclusive content on Wondery+. Join Wondery+ in the Wondery App, Apple Podcasts or Spotify. And join our new membership for a unique fan experience by going to the New Heights YouTube channel now!