August 17, 2025 • 21 mins
Once the symbol of fraud and false promises, “snake oil” wasn’t always a scam. In fact, it started as a genuine medicinal remedy brought to America by Chinese laborers in the 1800s. So how did a legitimate treatment become shorthand for quackery? In this episode of The History Of, we uncover the real story behind snake oil, from railroad workers and traveling salesmen to patent medicine empires and modern-day miracle cures.
New Episodes: Mon/Wed/Fri
(If people enjoy, and feedback via reviews and ratings is good, will release daily)
The History Of is your daily dose of weird, wonderful, and occasionally ridiculous history. Each episode takes one topic an object, a place, a job, a trend and unpacks the surprising story behind it. No homework, no boring lectures, just history you’ll actually want to share.
A podcast for all ages, if you enjoy please share it and leave a review because that tells me you want more.
Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/the-history-of--6664775/support.
New Episodes: Mon/Wed/Fri
(If people enjoy, and feedback via reviews and ratings is good, will release daily)
The History Of is your daily dose of weird, wonderful, and occasionally ridiculous history. Each episode takes one topic an object, a place, a job, a trend and unpacks the surprising story behind it. No homework, no boring lectures, just history you’ll actually want to share.
A podcast for all ages, if you enjoy please share it and leave a review because that tells me you want more.
Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/the-history-of--6664775/support.
Mark as Played
Transcript
Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:10):
Hello, and welcome to the History of the Show for
anyone who flunked history but still wants to impress at
Trivia Night. Each day we take one topic, an object,
a place, a job, a trend and uncover the weird, messy,
and sometimes ridiculous truth behind it. No homework, just history
you'll actually want to tell people about. Ready, let's get
(00:30):
into it. The history of snake oil real origins. If
you were to step into a Chinese apothecary centuries ago,
the shelves would be lined with jars of herbs, powders,
dried roots, and animal parts, each with a specific purpose
in the complex framework of traditional Chinese medicine. Somewhere among
(00:50):
them would be small containers of a golden, slightly viscous
liquid snake oil. To a modern ear, that name might
sound suspicious, almost like the beginning of a scam, but
for the people who used it, snake oil was an
entirely legitimate medicine valued for real and measurable benefits. The
Chinese water snake and Hydros chenensis was the source of
(01:12):
the original product. These snakes are semi aquatic and thrive
in rice paddies, ponds and slow moving rivers. Their bodies
store a high concentration of Omega three fatty acids in
their fat, particularly icosapentanoic acid EPA. Today we understand that
EPA has potent anti inflammatory properties, but traditional healers didn't
(01:34):
need a biochemistry textbook to know it worked. Centuries of trial,
observation and refinement had already shown them that oil extracted
from these snakes could ease pain and swelling in joints
and muscles. The preparation was straightforward. Snakes were killed and
their fat carefully removed, often through boiling or slow rendering.
The oil was then strained and stored in sealed jars
(01:57):
Applied topically. It was used to treat arthritis, versitis, and
other inflammatory conditions in rural China, where hard physical labor
was the norm. This was not an exotic luxury, but
a practical remedy for everyday aches. Traditional Chinese medicine worked
on the principle of balancing the body's energy or chi
and addressing the root cause of illness rather than just
(02:19):
the symptoms. Snake oil fit into this system as a
treatment that restored harmony by reducing excess heat in the body.
A metaphorical way of describing inflammation. Healers might prescribe it
alongside acupuncture, herbal teas, or dietary changes, creating a holistic
approach to recovery. This was the snake oil that actually
(02:40):
did what it claimed to do, and it was this
same product that would eventually make its way to America,
though the journey would twist its meaning beyond recognition. By
the mid nineteenth century, the United States was in the
throes of rapid expansion. The discovery of gold in California
in eighteen forty eight had set off a wave of migration,
(03:00):
and with it came the need for infrastructure. The dream
of a transcontinental railroad connecting the East Coast to the
Pacific became a national priority. It was a massive undertaking,
requiring thousands of laborers to work in some of the
most difficult and dangerous conditions imaginable. Chinese laborers began arriving
in large numbers in the eighteen fifties and eighteen sixties,
(03:23):
recruited primarily to work on the western portion of the railroad.
They were prized by railroad companies for their endurance, discipline,
and skill, though they were often paid less and given
the most hazardous jobs. These men lived in makeshift camps
along the route, enduring harsh weather, long hours, and physically
punishing labor. A typical day might start before sunrise and
(03:47):
end at dusk, with men lifting heavy rails, swinging sledge hammers,
drilling through rock, or clearing land. Injuries were common, and
medical care was rudimentary at best. In such an environment,
remedy that could relieve pain and speed recovery were invaluable.
The Chinese workers brought with them their own medical traditions,
including snake oil. Imagine a winter evening in a railroad
(04:10):
camp high in the Sierra Nevada. The wind is cutting,
snow is falling, and a small group of men huddle
inside a rough wooden shack. One of them, his hands
swollen from frostbite and his knees aching from days of
heavy lifting, reaches into his belongings and pulls out a
small jar. The lid comes off, and the faint, earthy
(04:30):
scent of rendered fat fills the air. He rubs the
oil into his joints, working it in with slow, practiced motions.
By morning, the stiffness has eased enough for him to
pick up his tools again. To the Chinese laborers. This
was nothing extraordinary. It was the same remedy their fathers
and grandfathers had used. But to the Americans who occasionally
(04:51):
worked alongside them, it was novel and intriguing. Here was
a substance with a foreign name and an exotic origin,
tied to a culture they knew little about, and in
the late nineteenth century, novelty could be as powerful a
selling point as any claimed benefit. It's important to understand
the medical landscape of America at that time. There were doctors,
(05:14):
of course, but the profession was still developing standardized practices.
Germ theory was relatively new, and antibiotics were decades away.
Many people, especially in rural areas, relied on home remedies,
folk cures, and over the counter concoctions sold by traveling
salesmen or local druggists. Into this environment, a product like
(05:36):
snake oil, with its strong endorsements from the men who
used it, could seem like a gift from nature. But
the qualities that made the genuine Chinese snake oil effective
also made it vulnerable to imitation. The average American buyer
in the eighteen hundreds didn't know the difference between a
Chinese water snake and a rattlesnake, and they certainly didn't
(05:57):
have a way to check whether the bottle they bought
contained one or the other. There were no ingredient lists,
no lab tests, and no legal standards to enforce honesty.
This gap between genuine product and public perception is the
crack through which the American version of snake oil slipped.
By the eighteen seventies and eighteen eighties, as more people
(06:18):
heard about the wonders of snake oil, entrepreneurs began producing
their own versions. Some were honest attempts to replicate the
original using local snakes. Others were purely opportunistic, bottling whatever
cheap ingredients were available and relying on persuasive sales pitches
to move the product. It was here, in the wide
open marketplace of late nineteenth century America that the seed
(06:41):
of the snake oil scam took root. But in this
first part of the story, before the con men took over,
snake oil was still what it had always been, a
remedy born of practical need, rooted in real science, and
valued by those who used it. The irony is that
the term we now use as a synonym for fraud
began with something that actually worked. The original Chinese water
(07:05):
snake oil was the product of centuries of observation and refinement,
and its journey to America was part of a much
larger story about migration, cultural exchange, and the blending and
sometimes the distortion of traditions. That distortion would come soon enough.
In the next chapter. Snake oil would leave the railroad
camps and enter the world of the Traveling Medicine Show,
(07:27):
where truth and fiction danced together on the back of
a brightly painted wagon, and where one man in particular
would become its most famous salesman, the Great American Reinvention.
By the eighteen eighties, snake oil had already made the
leap from a culturally specific remedy in Chinese railroad camps
to something whispered about in American towns and cities. People
(07:48):
had heard the stories the cure all that eased aching backs,
soothed swollen joints, and worked where other remedies failed. It
had an air of mystery about it, partly because few
Americans had ever seen the Chinese water snake and partly
because the product itself was exotic in name and origin.
But this was a country with a talent for reinvention,
(08:09):
and in an era when you could sell anything from
radium face cream to cocaine laced toothache drops without much oversight,
it was inevitable that someone would step forward to take
snake oil out of its quiet medicinal context and turn
it into a spectacle. That someone was Clark Stanley. Stanley's
early life is hazy, not least because he liked to
(08:30):
tell his own version of it. He was born in
Texas around eighteen fifty four and claimed to have worked
as a cowboy before spending time with Hope Healers in Arizona,
where he said he learned the secret of snake oil.
Whether that part of the story was true hardly mattered.
In the showman's world of nineteenth century America, a good
origin tale was worth its weight in gold. By the
(08:53):
late eighteen eighties, Stanley had reinvented himself as the Rattlesnake King,
and his act was ready for the big stage. At fairs, expositions,
and small town gatherings, he would make his entrance with
boxes or sacks of live rattlesnakes. Dressed in a vest
and wide brimmed hat, he would pull out a snake,
kill it with practiced ease, slit it open, and drop
(09:14):
the carcass into a pot of boiling water or oil.
As the crowd watched, he would skim fat from the surface,
mix it with other ingredients, and bottle it on the spot.
The entire performance was designed to convince onlookers that they
were witnessing the creation of a rare and powerful medicine.
It was theater. The snake wasn't necessarily the source of
(09:35):
what went into the bottle. The act itself was the product.
It fed the idea that snake oil was an almost
magical substance made fresh by a man who clearly knew
what he was doing. In truth, rattlesnake fat contains nowhere
near the amount of Omega three, fatty acids found in
the Chinese water snake, and whatever medicinal benefits it might
(09:55):
offer are minimal. But in a crowd warmed up by
a good story, facts take a back seat to the
experience of the show. The late nineteenth century was the
golden age of the traveling medicine show. These were part vaudeville,
part sales pitch, and part carnival. A show might feature music, comedy, sketches, dancing,
and novelty acts, all designed to draw people in and
(10:18):
keep them entertained until it was time for the big pitch.
The medicine was the supposed reason for the gathering, but
the entertainment softened the crowd, made them receptive and turned
buying a bottle into part of the fun. Stanley's snake
oil liniment fit perfectly into this world. The labels promised
relief from an impressive list of ailments rheumatism, neuralgia sciatica, lumbago,
(10:42):
sore throat, frostbite, bites from animals or insects, and general
aches and pains in an age before modern painkillers. Those
claims hit the mark. People didn't just want the product,
they wanted the hope that came with it. Stanley's reputation grew,
and one of his biggest moments came at the eighteen
ninety three World's Columbian Exposition in Chicago. The fare was
(11:03):
a showcase of innovation and spectacle, drawing millions of visitors
from across the country. In that environment, Stanley's live snake
performance and bold claims drew large crowds. It was exactly
the kind of venue where a skilled showman could turn
regional fame into national recognition. Behind the scenes, the world
of patent medicines, of which Stanley's product was a part,
(11:26):
was a vast and chaotic marketplace. There were tonics, balms, syrups,
and pills claiming to cure everything from baldness to tuberculosis.
Ingredients were rarely listed, and when they were, they might
be misleading or incomplete. Alcohol, opium, and cocaine were common additives,
not for their medicinal value, but because they produced immediate
(11:48):
effects that convinced the buyer something was happening. The appeal
of these products wasn't limited to rural folk who lacked
access to doctors. Even in cities, many people preferred to
self medicaid, and there was a deep mistrust of the
medical establishment, which at the time was still uneven in
quality and riddled with quackery of its own. A bottle
(12:08):
of liniment from a charismatic salesman might seem as trustworthy
as anything a doctor could offer, and a lot cheaper.
Stanley understood this instinctively. His product was more than just
a liquid in a bottle. It was an experience. Buyers
weren't only purchasing medicine. They were buying into a story,
and once you believe in the story, you're more likely
(12:30):
to believe in the product. By the turn of the century,
Stanley was selling his snake oil lineament across the country,
often through mail order. His advertisements used confident language and
glowing testimonials. The imagery was consistent snakes, rugged landscapes, and
a strong, trustworthy figure promising relief if you'd seen him
(12:51):
in person. The ad was a reminder of that exciting
day when the rattlesnake King came to town. If you hadn't,
the image filled in the blanks for you. It's easy
to imagine someone in a small town, their hands stiff
with arthritis, looking at the ad in the newspaper and
remembering the neighbor who swore the liniment helped. With no
easy access to a doctor and few reliable alternatives, the
(13:14):
choice to spend a dollar on a bottle probably felt
like common sense. Stanley's success was part of a broader
phenomenon the rise of consumer marketing in America. This was
the era when brands began to matter. Packaging, slogans, and
logos became as important as the product itself. Stanley's snake
oil lineament was no exception. The name snake oil might
(13:37):
sound odd to us now, but at the time it
carried the allure of the exotic and the promise of
something rare. Of course, the truth about what was in
those bottles would eventually catch up with Stanley, but in
the years before that reckoning, he represented the pinnacle of
the medicine show era. His performances blended skill, showmanship, and
psychological insight. He knew how to read a crowd, when
(14:00):
to turn up the drama, and when to step back
and let the product seem to speak for itself. In
this period, snake oil was no longer the genuine article
brought by Chinese laborers. It was now an American invention,
a product built on spectacle advertising and the skill of
a man who understood that in sales, belief is more
important than truth. The world that allowed Stanley to thrive
(14:23):
was already starting to change. Journalists were beginning to investigate
the patent medicine industry, and public health advocates were calling
for stronger regulations. But for a while, the show went on,
the bottles kept selling, and the Rattlesnake King rolled his
wagon from one eager crowd to the next. The day
would come when science would take a closer look at
(14:45):
what was in those bottles, and the findings would strip
away the story Stanley had so carefully built. But that's
the next chapter for now. In the years before the Fall,
snake oil had become an icon of American ingenuity and
American gullibility, all at once, the Fall and the legacy.
By the early nineteen hundreds, the patent medicine market was
(15:06):
still thriving, but cracks were starting to appear. People had
begun to question whether these miracle cures actually worked. Newspapers
were running exposes, public health advocates were speaking out, and
the idea that companies should at least tell people what
was in their medicine was gaining traction. For Clark Stanley
and his snake oil lineament, the timing was bad. In
(15:29):
nineteen oh six, the Pure Food and Drug Act became law.
It was the first significant federal legislation aimed at regulating
food and medicine in the United States. Among other things,
it required manufacturers to list certain ingredients on their labels
and prohibited the sale of misbranded or adulterated drugs, While
the law was far from perfect, enforcement was patchy, and
(15:52):
the penalties were small. It represented a turning point. The
days when a salesman could make any claim he liked
without fear of legal consequences were coming to an end.
For a while, Stanley kept selling his product was well known,
and there were still plenty of customers who swore by it.
But in nineteen seventeen, the Bureau of Chemistry, the forerunner
(16:14):
of the Food and Drug Administration, seized a shipment of
his snake oil liniment. They tested it to see what
was actually inside. The results were devastating to Stanley's reputation.
The analysis showed there was no snake oil in the
liniment at all. Instead, the main ingredient was mineral oil,
a substance derived from petroleum. It also contained befat, turpentine,
(16:38):
capsaisin from chili peppers, and camphor. None of these were
especially harmful in the quantities used, but none could deliver
the kind of results promised on the label. Whatever healing
power the original Chinese water snake oil might have had
was absent. The Bureau declared the product misbranded under the law.
Stanley was fined twenty dollars that might sound laughably small
(17:01):
by today's standards, and even then it wasn't enough to
bankrupt him. But the real damage was in the public
revelation that his product was a fraud. The words snake
oil were now tainted. From that moment, the term began
its shift from a literal product to a figure of speech.
It became shorthand for any fraudulent product or scheme, whether
(17:22):
in medicine or not. By the mid twentieth century, you
could hear it used to describe shady investment opportunities, dubious
political promises, and half baked technological ideas. The transformation was complete.
Snake oil had moved from a genuine remedy to a
theatrical scam, to a permanent fixture in the English language.
(17:42):
In the decades that followed, the story of snake oil
became part of the cultural imagination. It showed up in cartoons,
western films, and comedy routines. The image of the fast
talking salesman pitching a miracle cure became a stock character,
a symbol of gullibility and greed. And yet as much
as the phrase carried a warning, it also carried a
strange nostalgia. The medicine show, with its mix of entertainment
(18:06):
and salesmanship, belonged to a vanished world. But if you
think the snake oil era is over, you might want
to look again. The packaging has changed, but the pitch
is much the same. The wellness industry, now worth trillions globally,
has more than its share of products making grand claims
with little evidence, from detox t's to miracle weight loss supplements.
(18:29):
The line between genuine benefit and marketing hype can still
be blurry. In politics, too, Snake oil accusations fly. Opponents
accuse one another of selling impossible dreams or quick fixes
that won't work. In the tech world, startups sometimes promise
revolutionary changes without showing how they'll deliver. Even in finance,
(18:50):
investment schemes with unrealistic returns often get labeled as snake oil.
The metaphor has proved endlessly adaptable because at its heart,
it's about the gap between promise and reality. The lesson
of the snake oil saga is not simply don't fall
for scams. It's also about understanding why people are drawn
to them in the first place. In the nineteenth century,
(19:12):
many of Stanley's customers lived with chronic pain and limited
access to medical care. They wanted relief, and they wanted it. Now,
in the twenty first century, people still want solutions to
health problems, financial worries, or political frustrations, and they're still
willing to believe in something that offers hope, even if
it sounds too good to be true. There's another irony here.
(19:35):
The original Chinese snake oil actually did have medicinal value.
If American producers like Stanley had used Chinese water snake fat,
they might have been selling a product that genuinely worked,
but sourcing it would have been difficult and expensive, and
rattlesnakes were much easier to come by. The shift from
real remedy to fake product wasn't inevitable, but it was profitable,
(19:59):
and so the name that began in good faith became
a byword for deception. That transformation is why the story
of snake oil still resonates. It's a reminder that even
useful ideas can be corrupted, and that the distance between
a helpful treatment and a worthless one can be measured
not just in ingredients, but in the honesty of the
(20:19):
person selling it. Next time you hear someone call something
snake oil. You'll know they're invoking a history that stretches
from Chinese rice paddies to American railroad camps to the
back of a traveling wagon. You'll also know that the
term says as much about the buyer as it does
about the seller. After all, a con needs two ingredients,
(20:40):
a person willing to lie and a person willing to believe.
Without the second, the first goes out of business. The
bottle of liniment in Clark Stanley's hand is long gone,
but the pitch, in one form or another, is still
with us. And as long as there are people looking
for an easy answer, there will be someone ready to
sell it to them a confident smile and a story
(21:01):
that's just convincing enough to make you reach for your wallet.
Hello, and welcome to the History of the Show for
anyone who flunked history but still wants to impress at
Trivia Night. Each day we take one topic, an object,
a place, a job, a trend and uncover the weird, messy,
and sometimes ridiculous truth behind it. No homework, just history
you'll actually want to tell people about. Ready, let's get
(00:30):
into it. The history of snake oil real origins. If
you were to step into a Chinese apothecary centuries ago,
the shelves would be lined with jars of herbs, powders,
dried roots, and animal parts, each with a specific purpose
in the complex framework of traditional Chinese medicine. Somewhere among
(00:50):
them would be small containers of a golden, slightly viscous
liquid snake oil. To a modern ear, that name might
sound suspicious, almost like the beginning of a scam, but
for the people who used it, snake oil was an
entirely legitimate medicine valued for real and measurable benefits. The
Chinese water snake and Hydros chenensis was the source of
(01:12):
the original product. These snakes are semi aquatic and thrive
in rice paddies, ponds and slow moving rivers. Their bodies
store a high concentration of Omega three fatty acids in
their fat, particularly icosapentanoic acid EPA. Today we understand that
EPA has potent anti inflammatory properties, but traditional healers didn't
(01:34):
need a biochemistry textbook to know it worked. Centuries of trial,
observation and refinement had already shown them that oil extracted
from these snakes could ease pain and swelling in joints
and muscles. The preparation was straightforward. Snakes were killed and
their fat carefully removed, often through boiling or slow rendering.
The oil was then strained and stored in sealed jars
(01:57):
Applied topically. It was used to treat arthritis, versitis, and
other inflammatory conditions in rural China, where hard physical labor
was the norm. This was not an exotic luxury, but
a practical remedy for everyday aches. Traditional Chinese medicine worked
on the principle of balancing the body's energy or chi
and addressing the root cause of illness rather than just
(02:19):
the symptoms. Snake oil fit into this system as a
treatment that restored harmony by reducing excess heat in the body.
A metaphorical way of describing inflammation. Healers might prescribe it
alongside acupuncture, herbal teas, or dietary changes, creating a holistic
approach to recovery. This was the snake oil that actually
(02:40):
did what it claimed to do, and it was this
same product that would eventually make its way to America,
though the journey would twist its meaning beyond recognition. By
the mid nineteenth century, the United States was in the
throes of rapid expansion. The discovery of gold in California
in eighteen forty eight had set off a wave of migration,
(03:00):
and with it came the need for infrastructure. The dream
of a transcontinental railroad connecting the East Coast to the
Pacific became a national priority. It was a massive undertaking,
requiring thousands of laborers to work in some of the
most difficult and dangerous conditions imaginable. Chinese laborers began arriving
in large numbers in the eighteen fifties and eighteen sixties,
(03:23):
recruited primarily to work on the western portion of the railroad.
They were prized by railroad companies for their endurance, discipline,
and skill, though they were often paid less and given
the most hazardous jobs. These men lived in makeshift camps
along the route, enduring harsh weather, long hours, and physically
punishing labor. A typical day might start before sunrise and
(03:47):
end at dusk, with men lifting heavy rails, swinging sledge hammers,
drilling through rock, or clearing land. Injuries were common, and
medical care was rudimentary at best. In such an environment,
remedy that could relieve pain and speed recovery were invaluable.
The Chinese workers brought with them their own medical traditions,
including snake oil. Imagine a winter evening in a railroad
(04:10):
camp high in the Sierra Nevada. The wind is cutting,
snow is falling, and a small group of men huddle
inside a rough wooden shack. One of them, his hands
swollen from frostbite and his knees aching from days of
heavy lifting, reaches into his belongings and pulls out a
small jar. The lid comes off, and the faint, earthy
(04:30):
scent of rendered fat fills the air. He rubs the
oil into his joints, working it in with slow, practiced motions.
By morning, the stiffness has eased enough for him to
pick up his tools again. To the Chinese laborers. This
was nothing extraordinary. It was the same remedy their fathers
and grandfathers had used. But to the Americans who occasionally
(04:51):
worked alongside them, it was novel and intriguing. Here was
a substance with a foreign name and an exotic origin,
tied to a culture they knew little about, and in
the late nineteenth century, novelty could be as powerful a
selling point as any claimed benefit. It's important to understand
the medical landscape of America at that time. There were doctors,
(05:14):
of course, but the profession was still developing standardized practices.
Germ theory was relatively new, and antibiotics were decades away.
Many people, especially in rural areas, relied on home remedies,
folk cures, and over the counter concoctions sold by traveling
salesmen or local druggists. Into this environment, a product like
(05:36):
snake oil, with its strong endorsements from the men who
used it, could seem like a gift from nature. But
the qualities that made the genuine Chinese snake oil effective
also made it vulnerable to imitation. The average American buyer
in the eighteen hundreds didn't know the difference between a
Chinese water snake and a rattlesnake, and they certainly didn't
(05:57):
have a way to check whether the bottle they bought
contained one or the other. There were no ingredient lists,
no lab tests, and no legal standards to enforce honesty.
This gap between genuine product and public perception is the
crack through which the American version of snake oil slipped.
By the eighteen seventies and eighteen eighties, as more people
(06:18):
heard about the wonders of snake oil, entrepreneurs began producing
their own versions. Some were honest attempts to replicate the
original using local snakes. Others were purely opportunistic, bottling whatever
cheap ingredients were available and relying on persuasive sales pitches
to move the product. It was here, in the wide
open marketplace of late nineteenth century America that the seed
(06:41):
of the snake oil scam took root. But in this
first part of the story, before the con men took over,
snake oil was still what it had always been, a
remedy born of practical need, rooted in real science, and
valued by those who used it. The irony is that
the term we now use as a synonym for fraud
began with something that actually worked. The original Chinese water
(07:05):
snake oil was the product of centuries of observation and refinement,
and its journey to America was part of a much
larger story about migration, cultural exchange, and the blending and
sometimes the distortion of traditions. That distortion would come soon enough.
In the next chapter. Snake oil would leave the railroad
camps and enter the world of the Traveling Medicine Show,
(07:27):
where truth and fiction danced together on the back of
a brightly painted wagon, and where one man in particular
would become its most famous salesman, the Great American Reinvention.
By the eighteen eighties, snake oil had already made the
leap from a culturally specific remedy in Chinese railroad camps
to something whispered about in American towns and cities. People
(07:48):
had heard the stories the cure all that eased aching backs,
soothed swollen joints, and worked where other remedies failed. It
had an air of mystery about it, partly because few
Americans had ever seen the Chinese water snake and partly
because the product itself was exotic in name and origin.
But this was a country with a talent for reinvention,
(08:09):
and in an era when you could sell anything from
radium face cream to cocaine laced toothache drops without much oversight,
it was inevitable that someone would step forward to take
snake oil out of its quiet medicinal context and turn
it into a spectacle. That someone was Clark Stanley. Stanley's
early life is hazy, not least because he liked to
(08:30):
tell his own version of it. He was born in
Texas around eighteen fifty four and claimed to have worked
as a cowboy before spending time with Hope Healers in Arizona,
where he said he learned the secret of snake oil.
Whether that part of the story was true hardly mattered.
In the showman's world of nineteenth century America, a good
origin tale was worth its weight in gold. By the
(08:53):
late eighteen eighties, Stanley had reinvented himself as the Rattlesnake King,
and his act was ready for the big stage. At fairs, expositions,
and small town gatherings, he would make his entrance with
boxes or sacks of live rattlesnakes. Dressed in a vest
and wide brimmed hat, he would pull out a snake,
kill it with practiced ease, slit it open, and drop
(09:14):
the carcass into a pot of boiling water or oil.
As the crowd watched, he would skim fat from the surface,
mix it with other ingredients, and bottle it on the spot.
The entire performance was designed to convince onlookers that they
were witnessing the creation of a rare and powerful medicine.
It was theater. The snake wasn't necessarily the source of
(09:35):
what went into the bottle. The act itself was the product.
It fed the idea that snake oil was an almost
magical substance made fresh by a man who clearly knew
what he was doing. In truth, rattlesnake fat contains nowhere
near the amount of Omega three, fatty acids found in
the Chinese water snake, and whatever medicinal benefits it might
(09:55):
offer are minimal. But in a crowd warmed up by
a good story, facts take a back seat to the
experience of the show. The late nineteenth century was the
golden age of the traveling medicine show. These were part vaudeville,
part sales pitch, and part carnival. A show might feature music, comedy, sketches, dancing,
and novelty acts, all designed to draw people in and
(10:18):
keep them entertained until it was time for the big pitch.
The medicine was the supposed reason for the gathering, but
the entertainment softened the crowd, made them receptive and turned
buying a bottle into part of the fun. Stanley's snake
oil liniment fit perfectly into this world. The labels promised
relief from an impressive list of ailments rheumatism, neuralgia sciatica, lumbago,
(10:42):
sore throat, frostbite, bites from animals or insects, and general
aches and pains in an age before modern painkillers. Those
claims hit the mark. People didn't just want the product,
they wanted the hope that came with it. Stanley's reputation grew,
and one of his biggest moments came at the eighteen
ninety three World's Columbian Exposition in Chicago. The fare was
(11:03):
a showcase of innovation and spectacle, drawing millions of visitors
from across the country. In that environment, Stanley's live snake
performance and bold claims drew large crowds. It was exactly
the kind of venue where a skilled showman could turn
regional fame into national recognition. Behind the scenes, the world
of patent medicines, of which Stanley's product was a part,
(11:26):
was a vast and chaotic marketplace. There were tonics, balms, syrups,
and pills claiming to cure everything from baldness to tuberculosis.
Ingredients were rarely listed, and when they were, they might
be misleading or incomplete. Alcohol, opium, and cocaine were common additives,
not for their medicinal value, but because they produced immediate
(11:48):
effects that convinced the buyer something was happening. The appeal
of these products wasn't limited to rural folk who lacked
access to doctors. Even in cities, many people preferred to
self medicaid, and there was a deep mistrust of the
medical establishment, which at the time was still uneven in
quality and riddled with quackery of its own. A bottle
(12:08):
of liniment from a charismatic salesman might seem as trustworthy
as anything a doctor could offer, and a lot cheaper.
Stanley understood this instinctively. His product was more than just
a liquid in a bottle. It was an experience. Buyers
weren't only purchasing medicine. They were buying into a story,
and once you believe in the story, you're more likely
(12:30):
to believe in the product. By the turn of the century,
Stanley was selling his snake oil lineament across the country,
often through mail order. His advertisements used confident language and
glowing testimonials. The imagery was consistent snakes, rugged landscapes, and
a strong, trustworthy figure promising relief if you'd seen him
(12:51):
in person. The ad was a reminder of that exciting
day when the rattlesnake King came to town. If you hadn't,
the image filled in the blanks for you. It's easy
to imagine someone in a small town, their hands stiff
with arthritis, looking at the ad in the newspaper and
remembering the neighbor who swore the liniment helped. With no
easy access to a doctor and few reliable alternatives, the
(13:14):
choice to spend a dollar on a bottle probably felt
like common sense. Stanley's success was part of a broader
phenomenon the rise of consumer marketing in America. This was
the era when brands began to matter. Packaging, slogans, and
logos became as important as the product itself. Stanley's snake
oil lineament was no exception. The name snake oil might
(13:37):
sound odd to us now, but at the time it
carried the allure of the exotic and the promise of
something rare. Of course, the truth about what was in
those bottles would eventually catch up with Stanley, but in
the years before that reckoning, he represented the pinnacle of
the medicine show era. His performances blended skill, showmanship, and
psychological insight. He knew how to read a crowd, when
(14:00):
to turn up the drama, and when to step back
and let the product seem to speak for itself. In
this period, snake oil was no longer the genuine article
brought by Chinese laborers. It was now an American invention,
a product built on spectacle advertising and the skill of
a man who understood that in sales, belief is more
important than truth. The world that allowed Stanley to thrive
(14:23):
was already starting to change. Journalists were beginning to investigate
the patent medicine industry, and public health advocates were calling
for stronger regulations. But for a while, the show went on,
the bottles kept selling, and the Rattlesnake King rolled his
wagon from one eager crowd to the next. The day
would come when science would take a closer look at
(14:45):
what was in those bottles, and the findings would strip
away the story Stanley had so carefully built. But that's
the next chapter for now. In the years before the Fall,
snake oil had become an icon of American ingenuity and
American gullibility, all at once, the Fall and the legacy.
By the early nineteen hundreds, the patent medicine market was
(15:06):
still thriving, but cracks were starting to appear. People had
begun to question whether these miracle cures actually worked. Newspapers
were running exposes, public health advocates were speaking out, and
the idea that companies should at least tell people what
was in their medicine was gaining traction. For Clark Stanley
and his snake oil lineament, the timing was bad. In
(15:29):
nineteen oh six, the Pure Food and Drug Act became law.
It was the first significant federal legislation aimed at regulating
food and medicine in the United States. Among other things,
it required manufacturers to list certain ingredients on their labels
and prohibited the sale of misbranded or adulterated drugs, While
the law was far from perfect, enforcement was patchy, and
(15:52):
the penalties were small. It represented a turning point. The
days when a salesman could make any claim he liked
without fear of legal consequences were coming to an end.
For a while, Stanley kept selling his product was well known,
and there were still plenty of customers who swore by it.
But in nineteen seventeen, the Bureau of Chemistry, the forerunner
(16:14):
of the Food and Drug Administration, seized a shipment of
his snake oil liniment. They tested it to see what
was actually inside. The results were devastating to Stanley's reputation.
The analysis showed there was no snake oil in the
liniment at all. Instead, the main ingredient was mineral oil,
a substance derived from petroleum. It also contained befat, turpentine,
(16:38):
capsaisin from chili peppers, and camphor. None of these were
especially harmful in the quantities used, but none could deliver
the kind of results promised on the label. Whatever healing
power the original Chinese water snake oil might have had
was absent. The Bureau declared the product misbranded under the law.
Stanley was fined twenty dollars that might sound laughably small
(17:01):
by today's standards, and even then it wasn't enough to
bankrupt him. But the real damage was in the public
revelation that his product was a fraud. The words snake
oil were now tainted. From that moment, the term began
its shift from a literal product to a figure of speech.
It became shorthand for any fraudulent product or scheme, whether
(17:22):
in medicine or not. By the mid twentieth century, you
could hear it used to describe shady investment opportunities, dubious
political promises, and half baked technological ideas. The transformation was complete.
Snake oil had moved from a genuine remedy to a
theatrical scam, to a permanent fixture in the English language.
(17:42):
In the decades that followed, the story of snake oil
became part of the cultural imagination. It showed up in cartoons,
western films, and comedy routines. The image of the fast
talking salesman pitching a miracle cure became a stock character,
a symbol of gullibility and greed. And yet as much
as the phrase carried a warning, it also carried a
strange nostalgia. The medicine show, with its mix of entertainment
(18:06):
and salesmanship, belonged to a vanished world. But if you
think the snake oil era is over, you might want
to look again. The packaging has changed, but the pitch
is much the same. The wellness industry, now worth trillions globally,
has more than its share of products making grand claims
with little evidence, from detox t's to miracle weight loss supplements.
(18:29):
The line between genuine benefit and marketing hype can still
be blurry. In politics, too, Snake oil accusations fly. Opponents
accuse one another of selling impossible dreams or quick fixes
that won't work. In the tech world, startups sometimes promise
revolutionary changes without showing how they'll deliver. Even in finance,
(18:50):
investment schemes with unrealistic returns often get labeled as snake oil.
The metaphor has proved endlessly adaptable because at its heart,
it's about the gap between promise and reality. The lesson
of the snake oil saga is not simply don't fall
for scams. It's also about understanding why people are drawn
to them in the first place. In the nineteenth century,
(19:12):
many of Stanley's customers lived with chronic pain and limited
access to medical care. They wanted relief, and they wanted it. Now,
in the twenty first century, people still want solutions to
health problems, financial worries, or political frustrations, and they're still
willing to believe in something that offers hope, even if
it sounds too good to be true. There's another irony here.
(19:35):
The original Chinese snake oil actually did have medicinal value.
If American producers like Stanley had used Chinese water snake fat,
they might have been selling a product that genuinely worked,
but sourcing it would have been difficult and expensive, and
rattlesnakes were much easier to come by. The shift from
real remedy to fake product wasn't inevitable, but it was profitable,
(19:59):
and so the name that began in good faith became
a byword for deception. That transformation is why the story
of snake oil still resonates. It's a reminder that even
useful ideas can be corrupted, and that the distance between
a helpful treatment and a worthless one can be measured
not just in ingredients, but in the honesty of the
(20:19):
person selling it. Next time you hear someone call something
snake oil. You'll know they're invoking a history that stretches
from Chinese rice paddies to American railroad camps to the
back of a traveling wagon. You'll also know that the
term says as much about the buyer as it does
about the seller. After all, a con needs two ingredients,
(20:40):
a person willing to lie and a person willing to believe.
Without the second, the first goes out of business. The
bottle of liniment in Clark Stanley's hand is long gone,
but the pitch, in one form or another, is still
with us. And as long as there are people looking
for an easy answer, there will be someone ready to
sell it to them a confident smile and a story
(21:01):
that's just convincing enough to make you reach for your wallet.
Popular Podcasts
On Purpose with Jay Shetty
I’m Jay Shetty host of On Purpose the worlds #1 Mental Health podcast and I’m so grateful you found us. I started this podcast 5 years ago to invite you into conversations and workshops that are designed to help make you happier, healthier and more healed. I believe that when you (yes you) feel seen, heard and understood you’re able to deal with relationship struggles, work challenges and life’s ups and downs with more ease and grace. I interview experts, celebrities, thought leaders and athletes so that we can grow our mindset, build better habits and uncover a side of them we’ve never seen before. New episodes every Monday and Friday. Your support means the world to me and I don’t take it for granted — click the follow button and leave a review to help us spread the love with On Purpose. I can’t wait for you to listen to your first or 500th episode!
NFL Daily with Gregg Rosenthal
Gregg Rosenthal and a rotating crew of elite NFL Media co-hosts, including Patrick Claybon, Colleen Wolfe, Steve Wyche, Nick Shook and Jourdan Rodrigue of The Athletic get you caught up daily on all the NFL news and analysis you need to be smarter and funnier than your friends.
The Joe Rogan Experience
The official podcast of comedian Joe Rogan.