June 15, 2024 • 22 mins
In this gripping episode of "True Crime Case Files," we delve into the shocking murder of Callie Carter, a beloved Assistant District Attorney from Galveston, Texas. Uncover the chilling details of her brutal stabbing, the intense investigation that followed, and the twisted motives behind the heinous act. Featuring interviews, forensic evidence, and courtroom drama, this true crime story unravels the complex web of betrayal, infidelity, and blackmail that led to Callie's tragic death.
FOLLOW now to stay on the edge of your seat and become a part of our growing community of crime-solving aficionados!
Have a true crime case you'd like to share with us?
Contact us here: eddo.lehi@gmail.com
We're waiting...
FOLLOW now to stay on the edge of your seat and become a part of our growing community of crime-solving aficionados!
Have a true crime case you'd like to share with us?
Contact us here: eddo.lehi@gmail.com
We're waiting...
Mark as Played
Transcript
Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
(00:00):
Callie Carter was thirty four years oldand worked as an assistant district attorney in
Galveston County, Texas. She waswell known in her town for being very
good at her job, especially whenit came to fighting crime involving the many
cults that operated in the area.Many people in Galveston admired her hard work
and dedication. Calli was not justabout her job. She was also a
(00:20):
big part of the community. Sheoften organized charity events to help people in
need and love participating in the town'sfestivals like the annual Galveston Island Food and
Wine Festival. Calli lived in acozy house on a quiet street in Galveston.
She was married to James Carter,though their relationship had become strained.
Despite this, she remained hopeful andfocused on her future. She had big
(00:43):
dreams for her career and wanted tomake Galveston a safer place for everyone.
Cally attended the University of Texas atAustin for her law degree, where she
graduated with honors. Her passion forlaw and justice was evident from a young
age, often talking about her dreamsof some day becoming a judge. When
she was just three years old.Her life was full of promise and potential,
and she had a bright future aheadof her. Calli's family was very
(01:06):
important to her. She had aclose relationship with her parents, Linda and
Robert Jenkins, who lived nearby inHouston. She also had an old brother,
Tim, a successful judge in Montana, who often visited with his wife
and kids. Callie's friends described heras optimistic and full of energy. She
was always smiling and had a positiveoutlook on life, even when things were
(01:26):
tough. In the days before herdeath, Calli was busy preparing for a
big case against a new cult thathad begun attracting members around Galveston Beach.
She spent long hours at the office, but still made time to help organize
a local charity event to support homelessshelters. She was excited about the future
and had plans to take a shortvacation with her family after the trial.
(01:49):
Callie's untimely death left a void inthe community and among those who loved her.
Her dedication to her work and hercaring nature made her a beloved figure
in Galveston. On the morning ofJune twelve, two thousand and four,
Galvezton was waking up to a warm, sunny day. The town was quiet,
with people going about their usual routines. Emily Ruis, a close friend
(02:09):
and neighbor of Callie Carter, wasworried Callie had missed their morning jogs,
something she never did. Emily decidedto check on her, Hoping everything was
okay, Emily walked to Calli's house, which was just a few houses down
the street. She knocked on thedoor but got no answer. Growing more
concerned, Emily tried the door andfound it unlocked. She stepped inside,
(02:31):
calling out for Calli. As shewalked into the living room, she was
met with a horrifying sight. Calliwas lying on the floor in a pool
of blood. She had been stabbedmultiple times, and there were strange marks
all over her body. Emily's heartrased as she pulled out her cell phone
and dialed nine one one. Hervoice trembled as she spoke to the operator
(02:52):
nine one one, what's your emergency. It's my friend Callie Carter. She's
on the floor, there's blood everywhere. I think she's dead. Please send
help. The nine one one operatortried to calm Emily down while dispatching emergency
services to the scene. Emily,still in shock, could hardly believe what
she was seeing. She stayed onthe phone with the operator, who asked
(03:14):
her a way outside until the policearrived. Police and emergency medical services arrived
quickly at the scene. They foundEmily outside, still in tears and clearly
traumatized. The police immediately began toassess the scene and secure the perimeter.
They called in forensics experts to helpgather evidence. As news of the murder
(03:34):
spread through Galveston, the community wasin shock. Cali Carter was a well
known and respected figure, and herviolent death left every one reeling. The
small town, known for its beachin Pier, was suddenly the center of
a major crime investigation. The policearrived at Calli Carter's house quickly after Emily
Rouse's nine one one call on themorning of June twelve, two thousand and
(03:55):
four. It was a sunny dayin Galveston, Texas, but the scene
inside the house was grim. DetectiveSarah Jenkins and Officer Mark Davis led the
investigation. Known for their attention todetail, they knew this was going to
be a tough case. Detective Jenkins, a cousin of Kality and a seasoned
investigator with a calm demeanor took chargeimmediately. She directed the officers to secure
(04:18):
the area and keep onlookers away.Officer Davis, who was younger and eager,
followed her lead, making sure everythingwas handled by the book. The
crime scene in Calli's living room waschaok. Blood was splattered on the walls
in furniture, showing signs of aviolent struggle. Calli's body lay in the
middle of the room with multiple stabwounds and strange marks on her skin.
(04:40):
The letter Z had been branded inseveral places on her body, adding a
disturbing element to the scene. Forensicsexperts arrived and began their work. They
used luminal to check for hidden bloodtraces, revealing more about the brutal attack.
They dusted for fingerprints, collected hairand fiber samples, and carefully photographed
the entire area. The forensic steamworked methodically, knowing that every piece of
(05:03):
evidence could be crucial. Detective Jenkinsnoticed a broken vase and some scattered papers
which suggested a fight had taken place. She pointed these out to Officer Davis,
who made detailed notes. They alsofound a bloody knife in the kitchen
sink, which was quickly bagged asevidence. While Jenkins and Davis were busy
inside, officers canvassed the neighborhood,talking to any one who might have seen
(05:26):
or heard something unusual. A fewneighbors reported hearing loud noises the night before,
but no one had called the police. As the investigation continued, Jenkins
and Davis discussed possible motives. Theyknew Calli was working on prosecuting a strange
cult that had been attracting hundreds ofcomforts in the Galveston area. The branding
with the lettered Z seemed like apossible link to the cult. Detective Jenkins
(05:49):
also remembered that Calli's husband, JamesCarter, had a trouble passed and a
rocky relationship with Calli. They decidedto question him as soon as possible.
The detective knew they had to considerall possibilities and leave no stone unturned.
James Carter, thirty six, wasthe first suspect in the investigation. He
was Calli's husband and their relationship hadbeen increasingly rocky. James was known around
(06:14):
Galveston as a lazy, unemployed man, very different from his successful wife.
People often saw him arguing with Calliyin public. James had a history of
cheating and had been acting strangely inthe weeks before Callie's murder. The police
brought James in for questioning on theafternoon of June twelve, two thousand and
four. Detective Sarah Jenkins and OfficerMark Davis conducted the interrogation. James appeared
(06:38):
nervous and restless, shifting in hisseat and avoiding eye contact. Where were
you last night? I was homewatching Jay Leno and the Reagan funeral.
Can anyone confirm that? No,not really? CALLI went to bed early,
I was alone. Detective Jenkins tooknote of his inconsistent alibi. She
knew they needed more to go on, so she continued to We found a
(07:00):
bloody knife in your kitchen sink.How do you explain that? I don't
know, I didn't touch no knife. As the questioning continued, James's story
seemed to fall apart. He couldn'tprovide a clear timeline of his actions the
night Calli was murdered. His behaviorbecame more erratic, and he started to
sweat. James, we know you'vebeen having an affair with a woman named
(07:20):
Maureen. Did CALLI find out abouther. She she knew, but that
ain't mean I killed her. Throughoutthe interrogation, James's responses were inconsistent and
unconvincing. Detective Jenkins decided to takea break in regroup. They needed to
verify his alibi and gather more evidencebefore they could move forward. The police
(07:41):
also searched James's personal belongings and foundtroubling evidence. There were sexually explicit letters
from several women. They also founda hidden stash of three thousand dollars,
raising more questions about james activities.As the day went on, it became
clear that James Carter was hiding something. The detectives knew they had to keep
digging to uncover the truth. Theydecided to question Maureen next, hoping to
(08:03):
find more links between her and James. Galveston was buzzing with rumors about the
case. Everyone was eager for answers, and the police were determined to provide
them. They worked tirelessly, knowingthat every detail could bring them closer to
solving the murder of Cali Carter.The second suspect in the investigation was Maureen's
Afterpines fifty six, the secretive leaderof Xeno Philosophy, a new cult that
(08:28):
had been quickly gaining popularity around Galveston. The teachings of the group were based
on nineteen ninety nine Disney Channel originalmovie Xenan Girl of the twenty first Century.
The group believed that the futuristic visionpresented in the movie, known to
members as xene and Philosophy, wasa prophetic glimpse into humanity's destiny, and
that a character in the movie,Protozo, a rock star, was a
(08:48):
prophet whose lyrics contained hidden messages inspiritual truths. Members considered his songs to
be sacred texts, often reciting andanalyzing them for guidance. They believed ve
that through spiritual purity and adherence totheir teachings, members would travel to the
space station featured in the movie.More importantly, the group considered the letter
(09:09):
Z short for Zenom, to bea holy symbol representing the ultimate spiritual journey.
Members believed that the Z had protectiveand purifying powers, and often used
it in rituals. In branding,initiation involved a branding ceremony where new members
received as Z mark. This combinedwith the fact that Cali Carter had been
preparing to prosecute the cult for stockpilingweapons, made Maureen a key person of
(09:33):
interest. Detective Sarah Jenkins and OfficerMark Davis brought Maureen in for questioning on
June thirteen, two thousand four.Maureen arrived at the station dressed in five
to eleven tactical wear. Her usualcalm and composed demeanor was deeply unsettling.
When asked about her whereabouts the nightCalli was murdered, Maureen claimed she was
at the group's headquarters, leading theirevening meditation. She insisted that hundreds of
(09:58):
followers could confirm her alibi. Thedetectives knew they needed to verify this,
but continued to press her about herrelationship with Calli and the prosecution case.
Maureen maintained that she and Kality hadno personal quarrel and that she was simply
doing her job as Callie was doinghers. Despite her calm exterior, the
detectives sensed Maureen was hiding something.They questioned her about her connection with James
(10:20):
Carter, noting how he admitted toa sexual relationship with e Maureen admitted to
having spoken with James a few times, but denied any romantic involvement. The
detectives presented Maureen with letters found inJames's belongings that suggested a deeper connection between
them. Maureen dismissed the letters,stating that she wrote to thousands of prospective
members and implying that the letters meantnothing. As the interrogation continued, Maureen's
(10:45):
responses remained measured and deliberate. Shenever lost her composure. Even when the
detectives brought up the brandings of theletters Z found on Calli's body, a
symbol associated with xen and philosophy,Maureen brushed off the connection, stated that
many things start with the letter Zand it did not implicate her or her
followers. The detectives ended the interrogation, planning to verify her alibi with her
(11:09):
followers and dig deeper into Mareene's backgroundand the group's activities. They returned to
the crime scene, re examining everythingfor any connections to Marine or her cult.
They interviewed members and looked into thegroup's finances and records, uncovering the
complex web of relationships and secrets.Meanwhile, the community was in a state
of unease. News of the murderand the involvement of the Strange cult had
(11:31):
everyone on edge. People were talkingabout it in caphus, at the Beach
and on the popular local radio stationKGL. Detective Jenkins and Officer Davis were
determined to uncover the truth. Theyknew that every detail mattered and that Maureene's
Afterpines was a critical piece of thepuzzle. As the investigation into Cali Carter's
(11:52):
murder unfolded, the focus shifted touncovering new evidence that could shed light on
the events leading up to her death. Maureen's after Pines, a leader of
Xenon Philosophy, initially emerged as asuspect due to her connection with James Carter
and the contentious relationship between the Carters. As detectives delved deeper, though,
they found that Maureen's alibi was solid, supported by corroborating evidence and witness testimonies.
(12:18):
However, while she was not directlyimplicated in Calli's murder, it became
clear that while she had been involvedin an affair with James. Nevertheless,
a significant revelation emerged during the investigation. Maureen had been blackmailing Cali, threatening
to expose their affair with James Maureenpressured Calli to abandon her prosecution of xen
(12:39):
On philosophy. This revelation added anew layer of complexity to the case,
suggesting a motive rooted in personal vendettaand coercion. The blackmailing scheme exerted immense
pressure on Cali, worsening tensions withinher marriage and contributing to James's already unstable
mental state. The realization that hisextramarital affair was at risk of exposure,
(13:01):
coupled with the prospect of financial ruinresulting from Calli's intention to leave him,
possibly pushed James to a breaking point. The police, harmed with this newfound
understanding of the circumstances surrounding Calli's murder, intensified their scrutiny of James Carter.
His erratic behavior, history of infidelity, and the mounting evidence linking him to
(13:22):
the crime scene made him a primesuspect in their eyes. Meanwhile, the
revelation of Maureene's blackmailing tactics sent shockwavesthrough the community, prompting widespread speculation and
scrutiny of this in On philosophy.Galveston's residence grappled with the unsettling realization that
their beloved assistant district attorney had beenensnared in a web of deceit and manipulation,
(13:43):
orchestrated by those closest to her.The third suspect in the investigation was
Michael Lawson, an eighty two yearold local police officer with a long history
in Galveston. Michael had a complicatedrelationship with Callie Carter. They had dated
briefly before she married James, andwhen rumor suggested that his patronage helped her
rise quickly to the position of assistantdistrict Attorney, Michael had never fully moved
(14:07):
on from their relationship and was knownto harbor lingering feelings for Calli. On
June fourteenth, two thousand and four, detectives decided to bring Michael in for
questioning. His advanced age and distinguishedcareer in law enforcement added a layer of
complexity to the investigation. Michael arrivedat the station in his uniform, carrying
himself with the dignity of a seasonedofficer, but there was a noticeable tension
(14:30):
in his demeanor. Detectives Sarah Jenkinsand Mark Davis led the interrogation, keen
to understand Michael's potential involvement in thecase. They began by asking about his
relationship with Calli and his whereabouts onthe night of her murder. Michael stated
that he had been at home alonereading a book about World War II,
his favorite historical period. The detectivesfound his alibi week and decided to dig
(14:54):
deeper. They asked about his feelingsfor Calli and if he had any contact
with her recently. Michael admitted thathe still cared for Cali, but denied
any recent interactions beyond professional encounters.He appeared calm but evasive when pressed for
details, raising suspicions about his trueinvolvement. In addition to questioning Michael,
the detectives examined his personal and professionalrecords. They discovered that Michael had a
(15:18):
history of becoming overly involved in caseswhere he had personal connections. This tendency
made his proximity to the investigation andhis personal history with Calli more troubling.
The police also reviewed surveillance footage fromthe area around Calli's home on the night
of the murder. While they didnot find clear evidence placing Michael at the
scene, his long standing infatuation withCalli and his erratic behavior in similar past
(15:41):
situations kept him on their radar throughoutthe investigation. Michael's colleagues and the community
were divided in their opinions. Someviewed him as a dedicated officer who would
never harm Calli, while others believehis unresolved feelings could have driven him to
a desperate act. As the detectivescontinued to scotonized Michael, they knew that
they needed solid evidence to either confirmor rule out his involvement. His age
(16:06):
and status made the case delicate,but the team remained committed to uncovering the
truth behind Calli Carter's tragic death.As the investigation into Cali Carter's murder progressed,
the police began to piece together crucialevidence pointing towards the true perpetrator.
On June fifteenth, two thousand andfour, a breakthrough came when they found
(16:26):
incriminating evidence against James Carter, Calli'shusband. James, a thirty six year
old jobless man, had a troubledpast marked by infidelity and iratic behavior.
Calli had recently discovered his affair withMarines after Pines, which further strained their
already tumultuous marriage. Detectives uncovered thatCalli had planned to leave James and expose
his affair, threatening to cut offhis financial support. Faced with the potential
(16:51):
ruin of his leisurely lifestyle, James'sdesperation drove him to a breaking point.
Further forensic analysis revealed that James's fingerprintswere on the knife used to stab Calli
multiple times. Additionally, fibers fromhis clothing matched those found at the chaotic
crime scene. The branding of theletters Z on Calli's body, initially thought
to be linked to Maureene's cult,was identified as a desperate attempt by James
(17:15):
to divert suspicion towards Xenum philosophy.On the morning of June sixteenth, two
thousand and four, under a clearblue Texas sky, the police moved to
arrest James at his home, whichwas also the site of the murder.
Detective Sarah Jenkins and Officer Mark Davisapproached the house with a sense of urgency
and caution. James opened the door, visibly agitated and disheveled, has She
(17:37):
and Davis placed him in handcuffs.James's face turned pale, and he protested
loudly, but the overwhelming evidence lefthim with little room for denial. The
news of james arrests sent shockwaves throughGalveston. Calli's family, who had been
anxiously following the investigation, expressed amix of relief and sorrow. Calli's mother,
Margaret, tearfully than the police fortheir diligent work, but lamented the
(18:02):
tragic loss of her beloved daughter.The community, already shaken by the murder,
grappled with the revelation that the crimewas committed by someone so close to
Calli. Friends and colleagues of Caliwere stunned, finding it hard to reconcile
the image of James as the lovinghusband with the brutal facts of the case.
James's arrest marked a critical turning pointin the investigation, bringing some closure
to a grieving family and community.The focus now shifted to insuring justice for
(18:27):
Calli through the upcoming trial. JamesCarter's trial for the murder of Cali Carter
began on September one, two thousandand five, in the Galveston County Court
House. The prosecution led by DistrictAttorney Linda Ramers, forty five, known
for her no nonsense attitude and sharplegal acumen presented a compelling case against James.
(18:48):
They detailed how his desperate attempt tosilence Calli was driven by the fear
of exposure and financial ruin. Theprosecution's argument relied heavily on the forensic evidence,
james finger prints on the murder weapon, the matching fibers, and the
digital trail of messages and emails betweenJames and Marines after Pines, Ramirez painted
a vivid picture of a man corneredby his own lies and infidelity, driven
(19:11):
to commit an unthinkable act. Incontrast, the defense, headed by attorney
Ulcer Mitcham fifty, known for hissmooth talking style and high profile case history,
tried to cast doubt on the evidence. Mitchell argued that the investigation was
biased from the start, influenced bythe community's shock and grief. He suggested
that the evidence was circumstantial and thatthe branding of the letters Z pointed more
(19:34):
convincingly towards Xenum philosophy. The triallasted for three and tense weeks, with
testimonies from forensic experts, character witnesses, and members of Xenum Philosophy. The
courtroom was filled with residents, journalistsand TV crews from stations like local ABC
affiliate k t r K all eagerto witness the unfolding drama. On September
(19:56):
twenty one, two thousand and five, the jury delivered their verdict guilty of
first degree murder. The courtroom eruptedin a mix of relief in tears.
James Carter showed little emotion as theverdict was read, his face a mask
of resignation. The sentencing hearing followedswiftly. The judge handed down a sentence
of life in prison without the possibilityof parole, citing the brutality of the
(20:18):
crime and the betrayal of trust askey factors in her decision. The verdict
and sentencing resonated deeply within the Galvestoncommunity. Some felt the punishment was just
reflecting the heinous nature of the crime. Others debated the fairness given james apparent
lack of remorse and the complexities ofthe case. The trial's conclusion brought some
closure, but also highlighted the deepscars left by the tragedy. Friends and
(20:41):
colleagues of Calli continued to mourn herloss while trying to move forward Forever changed
by the events that had transpired.In the months following the trial, the
community of Galveston slowly began to healfrom the tragedy of Calli Carter's murder.
Life for many, however, wasirrevocably changed. James Carter, now serving
(21:02):
a life sentence without parole, facedthe grim reality of his actions. In
prison, He was known to bea solitary figure, rarely interacting with other
inmates. Reports indicated that he spentmost of his time in his cell reflecting
on the life he had destroyed.Maureen's after Pines, the leader of Xenum
Philosophy, faced intense scrutiny following thetrial. Though she was not directly involved
(21:25):
in the murder, the revelations abouther affair with James and the subsequent blackmailing
of Cali tarnished a reputation. Membershipdwindle this former followers questioned her teachings in
integrity. Maureen stepped down from herleadership position and retreated from public life,
leaving the future of the Xenum Philosophyuncertain. Michael Lawson, the elderly police
(21:45):
officer who had been a suspect,struggled to rebuild his reputation despite being cleared
of any involvement in the murder,the investigation had taken a toll on his
career and personal life. Michael retiredfrom the police force and moved to El
Paso, Texas, seeking peace indistance from the painful memories. The case
of Calli Carter remained a somber chapterin Galveston's history, but it also served
(22:08):
as a reminder of the importance ofjustice and the impact one person's life can
have on a community. Through collectiveeffort and remembrance, Galveston aimed to move
forward while honoring Calli's legacy.
Callie Carter was thirty four years oldand worked as an assistant district attorney in
Galveston County, Texas. She waswell known in her town for being very
good at her job, especially whenit came to fighting crime involving the many
cults that operated in the area.Many people in Galveston admired her hard work
and dedication. Calli was not justabout her job. She was also a
(00:20):
big part of the community. Sheoften organized charity events to help people in
need and love participating in the town'sfestivals like the annual Galveston Island Food and
Wine Festival. Calli lived in acozy house on a quiet street in Galveston.
She was married to James Carter,though their relationship had become strained.
Despite this, she remained hopeful andfocused on her future. She had big
(00:43):
dreams for her career and wanted tomake Galveston a safer place for everyone.
Cally attended the University of Texas atAustin for her law degree, where she
graduated with honors. Her passion forlaw and justice was evident from a young
age, often talking about her dreamsof some day becoming a judge. When
she was just three years old.Her life was full of promise and potential,
and she had a bright future aheadof her. Calli's family was very
(01:06):
important to her. She had aclose relationship with her parents, Linda and
Robert Jenkins, who lived nearby inHouston. She also had an old brother,
Tim, a successful judge in Montana, who often visited with his wife
and kids. Callie's friends described heras optimistic and full of energy. She
was always smiling and had a positiveoutlook on life, even when things were
(01:26):
tough. In the days before herdeath, Calli was busy preparing for a
big case against a new cult thathad begun attracting members around Galveston Beach.
She spent long hours at the office, but still made time to help organize
a local charity event to support homelessshelters. She was excited about the future
and had plans to take a shortvacation with her family after the trial.
(01:49):
Callie's untimely death left a void inthe community and among those who loved her.
Her dedication to her work and hercaring nature made her a beloved figure
in Galveston. On the morning ofJune twelve, two thousand and four,
Galvezton was waking up to a warm, sunny day. The town was quiet,
with people going about their usual routines. Emily Ruis, a close friend
(02:09):
and neighbor of Callie Carter, wasworried Callie had missed their morning jogs,
something she never did. Emily decidedto check on her, Hoping everything was
okay, Emily walked to Calli's house, which was just a few houses down
the street. She knocked on thedoor but got no answer. Growing more
concerned, Emily tried the door andfound it unlocked. She stepped inside,
(02:31):
calling out for Calli. As shewalked into the living room, she was
met with a horrifying sight. Calliwas lying on the floor in a pool
of blood. She had been stabbedmultiple times, and there were strange marks
all over her body. Emily's heartrased as she pulled out her cell phone
and dialed nine one one. Hervoice trembled as she spoke to the operator
(02:52):
nine one one, what's your emergency. It's my friend Callie Carter. She's
on the floor, there's blood everywhere. I think she's dead. Please send
help. The nine one one operatortried to calm Emily down while dispatching emergency
services to the scene. Emily,still in shock, could hardly believe what
she was seeing. She stayed onthe phone with the operator, who asked
(03:14):
her a way outside until the policearrived. Police and emergency medical services arrived
quickly at the scene. They foundEmily outside, still in tears and clearly
traumatized. The police immediately began toassess the scene and secure the perimeter.
They called in forensics experts to helpgather evidence. As news of the murder
(03:34):
spread through Galveston, the community wasin shock. Cali Carter was a well
known and respected figure, and herviolent death left every one reeling. The
small town, known for its beachin Pier, was suddenly the center of
a major crime investigation. The policearrived at Calli Carter's house quickly after Emily
Rouse's nine one one call on themorning of June twelve, two thousand and
(03:55):
four. It was a sunny dayin Galveston, Texas, but the scene
inside the house was grim. DetectiveSarah Jenkins and Officer Mark Davis led the
investigation. Known for their attention todetail, they knew this was going to
be a tough case. Detective Jenkins, a cousin of Kality and a seasoned
investigator with a calm demeanor took chargeimmediately. She directed the officers to secure
(04:18):
the area and keep onlookers away.Officer Davis, who was younger and eager,
followed her lead, making sure everythingwas handled by the book. The
crime scene in Calli's living room waschaok. Blood was splattered on the walls
in furniture, showing signs of aviolent struggle. Calli's body lay in the
middle of the room with multiple stabwounds and strange marks on her skin.
(04:40):
The letter Z had been branded inseveral places on her body, adding a
disturbing element to the scene. Forensicsexperts arrived and began their work. They
used luminal to check for hidden bloodtraces, revealing more about the brutal attack.
They dusted for fingerprints, collected hairand fiber samples, and carefully photographed
the entire area. The forensic steamworked methodically, knowing that every piece of
(05:03):
evidence could be crucial. Detective Jenkinsnoticed a broken vase and some scattered papers
which suggested a fight had taken place. She pointed these out to Officer Davis,
who made detailed notes. They alsofound a bloody knife in the kitchen
sink, which was quickly bagged asevidence. While Jenkins and Davis were busy
inside, officers canvassed the neighborhood,talking to any one who might have seen
(05:26):
or heard something unusual. A fewneighbors reported hearing loud noises the night before,
but no one had called the police. As the investigation continued, Jenkins
and Davis discussed possible motives. Theyknew Calli was working on prosecuting a strange
cult that had been attracting hundreds ofcomforts in the Galveston area. The branding
with the lettered Z seemed like apossible link to the cult. Detective Jenkins
(05:49):
also remembered that Calli's husband, JamesCarter, had a trouble passed and a
rocky relationship with Calli. They decidedto question him as soon as possible.
The detective knew they had to considerall possibilities and leave no stone unturned.
James Carter, thirty six, wasthe first suspect in the investigation. He
was Calli's husband and their relationship hadbeen increasingly rocky. James was known around
(06:14):
Galveston as a lazy, unemployed man, very different from his successful wife.
People often saw him arguing with Calliyin public. James had a history of
cheating and had been acting strangely inthe weeks before Callie's murder. The police
brought James in for questioning on theafternoon of June twelve, two thousand and
four. Detective Sarah Jenkins and OfficerMark Davis conducted the interrogation. James appeared
(06:38):
nervous and restless, shifting in hisseat and avoiding eye contact. Where were
you last night? I was homewatching Jay Leno and the Reagan funeral.
Can anyone confirm that? No,not really? CALLI went to bed early,
I was alone. Detective Jenkins tooknote of his inconsistent alibi. She
knew they needed more to go on, so she continued to We found a
(07:00):
bloody knife in your kitchen sink.How do you explain that? I don't
know, I didn't touch no knife. As the questioning continued, James's story
seemed to fall apart. He couldn'tprovide a clear timeline of his actions the
night Calli was murdered. His behaviorbecame more erratic, and he started to
sweat. James, we know you'vebeen having an affair with a woman named
(07:20):
Maureen. Did CALLI find out abouther. She she knew, but that
ain't mean I killed her. Throughoutthe interrogation, James's responses were inconsistent and
unconvincing. Detective Jenkins decided to takea break in regroup. They needed to
verify his alibi and gather more evidencebefore they could move forward. The police
(07:41):
also searched James's personal belongings and foundtroubling evidence. There were sexually explicit letters
from several women. They also founda hidden stash of three thousand dollars,
raising more questions about james activities.As the day went on, it became
clear that James Carter was hiding something. The detectives knew they had to keep
digging to uncover the truth. Theydecided to question Maureen next, hoping to
(08:03):
find more links between her and James. Galveston was buzzing with rumors about the
case. Everyone was eager for answers, and the police were determined to provide
them. They worked tirelessly, knowingthat every detail could bring them closer to
solving the murder of Cali Carter.The second suspect in the investigation was Maureen's
Afterpines fifty six, the secretive leaderof Xeno Philosophy, a new cult that
(08:28):
had been quickly gaining popularity around Galveston. The teachings of the group were based
on nineteen ninety nine Disney Channel originalmovie Xenan Girl of the twenty first Century.
The group believed that the futuristic visionpresented in the movie, known to
members as xene and Philosophy, wasa prophetic glimpse into humanity's destiny, and
that a character in the movie,Protozo, a rock star, was a
(08:48):
prophet whose lyrics contained hidden messages inspiritual truths. Members considered his songs to
be sacred texts, often reciting andanalyzing them for guidance. They believed ve
that through spiritual purity and adherence totheir teachings, members would travel to the
space station featured in the movie.More importantly, the group considered the letter
(09:09):
Z short for Zenom, to bea holy symbol representing the ultimate spiritual journey.
Members believed that the Z had protectiveand purifying powers, and often used
it in rituals. In branding,initiation involved a branding ceremony where new members
received as Z mark. This combinedwith the fact that Cali Carter had been
preparing to prosecute the cult for stockpilingweapons, made Maureen a key person of
(09:33):
interest. Detective Sarah Jenkins and OfficerMark Davis brought Maureen in for questioning on
June thirteen, two thousand four.Maureen arrived at the station dressed in five
to eleven tactical wear. Her usualcalm and composed demeanor was deeply unsettling.
When asked about her whereabouts the nightCalli was murdered, Maureen claimed she was
at the group's headquarters, leading theirevening meditation. She insisted that hundreds of
(09:58):
followers could confirm her alibi. Thedetectives knew they needed to verify this,
but continued to press her about herrelationship with Calli and the prosecution case.
Maureen maintained that she and Kality hadno personal quarrel and that she was simply
doing her job as Callie was doinghers. Despite her calm exterior, the
detectives sensed Maureen was hiding something.They questioned her about her connection with James
(10:20):
Carter, noting how he admitted toa sexual relationship with e Maureen admitted to
having spoken with James a few times, but denied any romantic involvement. The
detectives presented Maureen with letters found inJames's belongings that suggested a deeper connection between
them. Maureen dismissed the letters,stating that she wrote to thousands of prospective
members and implying that the letters meantnothing. As the interrogation continued, Maureen's
(10:45):
responses remained measured and deliberate. Shenever lost her composure. Even when the
detectives brought up the brandings of theletters Z found on Calli's body, a
symbol associated with xen and philosophy,Maureen brushed off the connection, stated that
many things start with the letter Zand it did not implicate her or her
followers. The detectives ended the interrogation, planning to verify her alibi with her
(11:09):
followers and dig deeper into Mareene's backgroundand the group's activities. They returned to
the crime scene, re examining everythingfor any connections to Marine or her cult.
They interviewed members and looked into thegroup's finances and records, uncovering the
complex web of relationships and secrets.Meanwhile, the community was in a state
of unease. News of the murderand the involvement of the Strange cult had
(11:31):
everyone on edge. People were talkingabout it in caphus, at the Beach
and on the popular local radio stationKGL. Detective Jenkins and Officer Davis were
determined to uncover the truth. Theyknew that every detail mattered and that Maureene's
Afterpines was a critical piece of thepuzzle. As the investigation into Cali Carter's
(11:52):
murder unfolded, the focus shifted touncovering new evidence that could shed light on
the events leading up to her death. Maureen's after Pines, a leader of
Xenon Philosophy, initially emerged as asuspect due to her connection with James Carter
and the contentious relationship between the Carters. As detectives delved deeper, though,
they found that Maureen's alibi was solid, supported by corroborating evidence and witness testimonies.
(12:18):
However, while she was not directlyimplicated in Calli's murder, it became
clear that while she had been involvedin an affair with James. Nevertheless,
a significant revelation emerged during the investigation. Maureen had been blackmailing Cali, threatening
to expose their affair with James Maureenpressured Calli to abandon her prosecution of xen
(12:39):
On philosophy. This revelation added anew layer of complexity to the case,
suggesting a motive rooted in personal vendettaand coercion. The blackmailing scheme exerted immense
pressure on Cali, worsening tensions withinher marriage and contributing to James's already unstable
mental state. The realization that hisextramarital affair was at risk of exposure,
(13:01):
coupled with the prospect of financial ruinresulting from Calli's intention to leave him,
possibly pushed James to a breaking point. The police, harmed with this newfound
understanding of the circumstances surrounding Calli's murder, intensified their scrutiny of James Carter.
His erratic behavior, history of infidelity, and the mounting evidence linking him to
(13:22):
the crime scene made him a primesuspect in their eyes. Meanwhile, the
revelation of Maureene's blackmailing tactics sent shockwavesthrough the community, prompting widespread speculation and
scrutiny of this in On philosophy.Galveston's residence grappled with the unsettling realization that
their beloved assistant district attorney had beenensnared in a web of deceit and manipulation,
(13:43):
orchestrated by those closest to her.The third suspect in the investigation was
Michael Lawson, an eighty two yearold local police officer with a long history
in Galveston. Michael had a complicatedrelationship with Callie Carter. They had dated
briefly before she married James, andwhen rumor suggested that his patronage helped her
rise quickly to the position of assistantdistrict Attorney, Michael had never fully moved
(14:07):
on from their relationship and was knownto harbor lingering feelings for Calli. On
June fourteenth, two thousand and four, detectives decided to bring Michael in for
questioning. His advanced age and distinguishedcareer in law enforcement added a layer of
complexity to the investigation. Michael arrivedat the station in his uniform, carrying
himself with the dignity of a seasonedofficer, but there was a noticeable tension
(14:30):
in his demeanor. Detectives Sarah Jenkinsand Mark Davis led the interrogation, keen
to understand Michael's potential involvement in thecase. They began by asking about his
relationship with Calli and his whereabouts onthe night of her murder. Michael stated
that he had been at home alonereading a book about World War II,
his favorite historical period. The detectivesfound his alibi week and decided to dig
(14:54):
deeper. They asked about his feelingsfor Calli and if he had any contact
with her recently. Michael admitted thathe still cared for Cali, but denied
any recent interactions beyond professional encounters.He appeared calm but evasive when pressed for
details, raising suspicions about his trueinvolvement. In addition to questioning Michael,
the detectives examined his personal and professionalrecords. They discovered that Michael had a
(15:18):
history of becoming overly involved in caseswhere he had personal connections. This tendency
made his proximity to the investigation andhis personal history with Calli more troubling.
The police also reviewed surveillance footage fromthe area around Calli's home on the night
of the murder. While they didnot find clear evidence placing Michael at the
scene, his long standing infatuation withCalli and his erratic behavior in similar past
(15:41):
situations kept him on their radar throughoutthe investigation. Michael's colleagues and the community
were divided in their opinions. Someviewed him as a dedicated officer who would
never harm Calli, while others believehis unresolved feelings could have driven him to
a desperate act. As the detectivescontinued to scotonized Michael, they knew that
they needed solid evidence to either confirmor rule out his involvement. His age
(16:06):
and status made the case delicate,but the team remained committed to uncovering the
truth behind Calli Carter's tragic death.As the investigation into Cali Carter's murder progressed,
the police began to piece together crucialevidence pointing towards the true perpetrator.
On June fifteenth, two thousand andfour, a breakthrough came when they found
(16:26):
incriminating evidence against James Carter, Calli'shusband. James, a thirty six year
old jobless man, had a troubledpast marked by infidelity and iratic behavior.
Calli had recently discovered his affair withMarines after Pines, which further strained their
already tumultuous marriage. Detectives uncovered thatCalli had planned to leave James and expose
his affair, threatening to cut offhis financial support. Faced with the potential
(16:51):
ruin of his leisurely lifestyle, James'sdesperation drove him to a breaking point.
Further forensic analysis revealed that James's fingerprintswere on the knife used to stab Calli
multiple times. Additionally, fibers fromhis clothing matched those found at the chaotic
crime scene. The branding of theletters Z on Calli's body, initially thought
to be linked to Maureene's cult,was identified as a desperate attempt by James
(17:15):
to divert suspicion towards Xenum philosophy.On the morning of June sixteenth, two
thousand and four, under a clearblue Texas sky, the police moved to
arrest James at his home, whichwas also the site of the murder.
Detective Sarah Jenkins and Officer Mark Davisapproached the house with a sense of urgency
and caution. James opened the door, visibly agitated and disheveled, has She
(17:37):
and Davis placed him in handcuffs.James's face turned pale, and he protested
loudly, but the overwhelming evidence lefthim with little room for denial. The
news of james arrests sent shockwaves throughGalveston. Calli's family, who had been
anxiously following the investigation, expressed amix of relief and sorrow. Calli's mother,
Margaret, tearfully than the police fortheir diligent work, but lamented the
(18:02):
tragic loss of her beloved daughter.The community, already shaken by the murder,
grappled with the revelation that the crimewas committed by someone so close to
Calli. Friends and colleagues of Caliwere stunned, finding it hard to reconcile
the image of James as the lovinghusband with the brutal facts of the case.
James's arrest marked a critical turning pointin the investigation, bringing some closure
to a grieving family and community.The focus now shifted to insuring justice for
(18:27):
Calli through the upcoming trial. JamesCarter's trial for the murder of Cali Carter
began on September one, two thousandand five, in the Galveston County Court
House. The prosecution led by DistrictAttorney Linda Ramers, forty five, known
for her no nonsense attitude and sharplegal acumen presented a compelling case against James.
(18:48):
They detailed how his desperate attempt tosilence Calli was driven by the fear
of exposure and financial ruin. Theprosecution's argument relied heavily on the forensic evidence,
james finger prints on the murder weapon, the matching fibers, and the
digital trail of messages and emails betweenJames and Marines after Pines, Ramirez painted
a vivid picture of a man corneredby his own lies and infidelity, driven
(19:11):
to commit an unthinkable act. Incontrast, the defense, headed by attorney
Ulcer Mitcham fifty, known for hissmooth talking style and high profile case history,
tried to cast doubt on the evidence. Mitchell argued that the investigation was
biased from the start, influenced bythe community's shock and grief. He suggested
that the evidence was circumstantial and thatthe branding of the letters Z pointed more
(19:34):
convincingly towards Xenum philosophy. The triallasted for three and tense weeks, with
testimonies from forensic experts, character witnesses, and members of Xenum Philosophy. The
courtroom was filled with residents, journalistsand TV crews from stations like local ABC
affiliate k t r K all eagerto witness the unfolding drama. On September
(19:56):
twenty one, two thousand and five, the jury delivered their verdict guilty of
first degree murder. The courtroom eruptedin a mix of relief in tears.
James Carter showed little emotion as theverdict was read, his face a mask
of resignation. The sentencing hearing followedswiftly. The judge handed down a sentence
of life in prison without the possibilityof parole, citing the brutality of the
(20:18):
crime and the betrayal of trust askey factors in her decision. The verdict
and sentencing resonated deeply within the Galvestoncommunity. Some felt the punishment was just
reflecting the heinous nature of the crime. Others debated the fairness given james apparent
lack of remorse and the complexities ofthe case. The trial's conclusion brought some
closure, but also highlighted the deepscars left by the tragedy. Friends and
(20:41):
colleagues of Calli continued to mourn herloss while trying to move forward Forever changed
by the events that had transpired.In the months following the trial, the
community of Galveston slowly began to healfrom the tragedy of Calli Carter's murder.
Life for many, however, wasirrevocably changed. James Carter, now serving
(21:02):
a life sentence without parole, facedthe grim reality of his actions. In
prison, He was known to bea solitary figure, rarely interacting with other
inmates. Reports indicated that he spentmost of his time in his cell reflecting
on the life he had destroyed.Maureen's after Pines, the leader of Xenum
Philosophy, faced intense scrutiny following thetrial. Though she was not directly involved
(21:25):
in the murder, the revelations abouther affair with James and the subsequent blackmailing
of Cali tarnished a reputation. Membershipdwindle this former followers questioned her teachings in
integrity. Maureen stepped down from herleadership position and retreated from public life,
leaving the future of the Xenum Philosophyuncertain. Michael Lawson, the elderly police
(21:45):
officer who had been a suspect,struggled to rebuild his reputation despite being cleared
of any involvement in the murder,the investigation had taken a toll on his
career and personal life. Michael retiredfrom the police force and moved to El
Paso, Texas, seeking peace indistance from the painful memories. The case
of Calli Carter remained a somber chapterin Galveston's history, but it also served
(22:08):
as a reminder of the importance ofjustice and the impact one person's life can
have on a community. Through collectiveeffort and remembrance, Galveston aimed to move
forward while honoring Calli's legacy.
Popular Podcasts
My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark
My Favorite Murder is a true crime comedy podcast hosted by Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark. Each week, Karen and Georgia share compelling true crimes and hometown stories from friends and listeners. Since MFM launched in January of 2016, Karen and Georgia have shared their lifelong interest in true crime and have covered stories of infamous serial killers like the Night Stalker, mysterious cold cases, captivating cults, incredible survivor stories and important events from history like the Tulsa race massacre of 1921. My Favorite Murder is part of the Exactly Right podcast network that provides a platform for bold, creative voices to bring to life provocative, entertaining and relatable stories for audiences everywhere. The Exactly Right roster of podcasts covers a variety of topics including historic true crime, comedic interviews and news, science, pop culture and more. Podcasts on the network include Buried Bones with Kate Winkler Dawson and Paul Holes, That's Messed Up: An SVU Podcast, This Podcast Will Kill You, Bananas and more.
24/7 News: The Latest
The latest news in 4 minutes updated every hour, every day.
Dateline NBC
Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Follow now to get the latest episodes of Dateline NBC completely free, or subscribe to Dateline Premium for ad-free listening and exclusive bonus content: DatelinePremium.com